MECHANISTIC FEATURES OF THE MO-CONTAINING NITROGENASE

Elucidating the Coordination Chemistry and Mechanism of Biological Nitrogen Fixation

How does the enzyme nitrogenase reduce the inert molecule N2 to NH3 under ambient conditions that are so different from the energy-expensive conditions of the best industrial practices? This review focuses on recent theoretical investigations of the catalytic site, the iron-molybdenum cofactor FeMo-co, and the way in which it is hydrogenated by protons and electrons and then binds N2. Density functional calculations provide reaction profiles and activation energies for possible mechanistic steps. This establishes a conceptual framework and the principles for the coordination chemistry of FeMo-co that are essential to the chemical mechanism of catalysis. The model advanced herein explains relevant experimental data.

The correlation of redox potential, HOMO energy, and oxidation state in metal sulfide clusters and its application to determine the redox level of the FeMo-co active-site cluster of nitrogenase

This paper describes a procedure that permits the total charge state (i.e., oxidation state) of a complex molecule to be obtained from its redox potential data by comparison with good data (both charge state and redox potential) for reference compounds that are chemically similar. The link between the reference data and the unknown compound is made by the calculated energies of the Fermi level or highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO). The HOMO energies are calculated by unrestricted density functional methods (DMol) for the reference compounds in their known charge states, and a graphical correlation of HOMO energy and redox potential for oxidation (corresponding to loss of an electron from the HOMO) is constructed. The measured redox potential of the unknown is then applied to the correlation to yield the HOMO energy of the unknown, against which the calculated HOMO energies for various charge states of the unknown are assessed. This method is generally applicable. Using 26 reference data, the method is used here to determine the resting redox state, [NFe6MoS9]0, of the core of the FeMo cofactor (FeMo-co, bound to the MoFe protein) which is the active site of nitrogen-fixing enzymes. The analysis also shows that if the atom at the center of FeMo-co is C rather than N, then FeMo-co must be protonated in its resting state, but if FeMo-co is N-centered, it would not be protonated in the resting state.

Ammonia Production at the FeMo Cofactor of Nitrogenase: Results from Density Functional Theory

Biological nitrogen fixation has been investigated beginning with the monoprotonated dinitrogen bound to the FeMo cofactor of nitrogenase up to the formation of the two ammonia molecules. The energy differences of the relevant intermediates, the reaction barriers, and potentially relevant side branches are presented. During the catalytic conversion, nitrogen bridges two Fe atoms of the central cage, replacing a sulfur bridge present before dinitrogen binds to the cofactor. A transformation from cis- to trans-diazene has been found. The strongly exothermic cleavage of the dinitrogen bond takes place, while the Fe atoms are bridged by a single nitrogen atom. The dissociation of the second ammonia from the cofactor is facilitated by the closing of the sulfur bridge following an intramolecular proton transfer. This closes the catalytic cycle.

Quantitative geometric descriptions of the belt iron atoms of the iron-molybdenum cofactor of nitrogenase and synthetic iron(II) model complexes

Six of the seven iron atoms in the iron-molybdenum cofactor of nitrogenase display an unusual geometry, which is distorted from the tetrahedral geometry that is most common in iron-sulfur clusters. This distortion pulls the iron along one C3 axis of the tetrahedron toward a trigonal pyramid. The trigonal pyramidal coordination geometry is rare in four-coordinate transition metal complexes. In order to document this geometry in a systematic fashion in iron(II) chemistry, we have synthesized a range of four-coordinate iron(II) complexes that vary from tetrahedral to trigonal pyramidal. Continuous shape measures are used for a quantitative comparison of the stereochemistry of the Fe atoms in the iron-molybdenum cofactor with those of the presently and previously reported model complexes, as well as with those in polynuclear iron-sulfur compounds. This understanding of the iron coordination geometry is expected to assist in the design of synthetic analogues for intermediates in the nitrogenase catalytic cycle.

Molecular insights into nitrogenase FeMo cofactor insertion: the role of His 362 of the MoFe protein alpha subunit in FeMo cofactor incorporation

The assembly of the complex iron-molybdenum cofactor (FeMoco) of nitrogenase molybdenum-iron (MoFe) protein has served as one of the central topics in the field of bioinorganic chemistry for decades. Here we examine the role of a MoFe protein residue (His alpha362) in FeMoco insertion, the final step of FeMoco biosynthesis where FeMoco is incorporated into its binding site in the MoFe protein. Our data from combined metal, activity and electron paramagnetic resonance analyses show that mutations of His alpha362 to small uncharged Ala or negatively charged Asp result in significantly reduced FeMoco accumulation in MoFe protein, indicating that His alpha362 plays a key role in the process of FeMoco insertion. Given the strategic location of His alpha362 at the entry point of the FeMoco insertion funnel, this residue may serve as one of the initial docking points for FeMoco insertion through transient ligand coordination and/or electrostatic interaction.

Metal and cofactor insertion

Cells require metal ions as cofactors for the assembly of metalloproteins. Principally one has to distinguish between metal ions that are directly incorporated into their cognate sites on proteins and those metal ions that have to become part of prosthetic groups, cofactors or complexes prior to insertion of theses moieties into target proteins. Molybdenum is only active as part of the molybdenum cofactor, iron can be part of diverse Fe-S clusters or of the heme group, while copper ions are directly delivered to their targets. We will focus in greater detail on molybdenum metabolism because molybdenum metabolism is a good example for demonstrating the role and the network of metals in metabolism: each of the three steps in the pathway of molybdenum cofactor formation depends on a different metal (iron, copper, molybdenum) and also the enzymes finally harbouring the molybdenum cofactor need additional metal-containing groups to function (iron sulfur-clusters, heme-iron).

Macrocyclic Binucleating β-Diketiminate Ligands and their Lithium, Aluminum, and Zinc Complexes

The incorporation of rigid aromatic linkers into β-diketiminate ligands creates a binucleating scaffold that holds two metals near each other. This paper discloses the synthesis, characterization, and reactivity of mBin(2-), which has a meta-substituted xylylene spacer, and pBin(2-), which has a para-substituted xylylene spacer. Lithium, aluminum, and zinc complexes of each ligand are isolated, and in some cases are characterized by X-ray crystallography. The lithium complexes are coordinated to solvent-derived THF ligands, while the zinc and aluminum complexes have alkyl ligands. Complexes of the mBin(2-) ligand have an anti conformation in which the metals are on opposite sides of the macrocycle, while pBin(2-) complexes prefer a syn conformation. The (1)H NMR spectra of the complexes demonstrate that the conformations rapidly interconvert in the lithium complexes, and less rapidly in the zinc and aluminum complexes.

Functional ecology of ecotypic differentiation in the Californian serpentine sunflower (Helianthus exilis)

* Here, we examined phenotypic differences between locally adapted serpentine and riparian populations of the serpentine sunflower Helianthus exilis from northern California, USA. * Within a common environment, plants from serpentine and riparian sites were grown in regular potting soil or serpentine soil. Physiology, morphology, phenology and fitness-related traits were measured. * Overall, riparian plants grew more rapidly, attained a larger final size, produced larger leaves, and smaller flowering heads. Riparian plants also invested less in root biomass and were more water-use-efficient than the serpentine plants. Serpentine and riparian plants also differed in leaf concentrations of boron, magnesium, sodium and molybdenum. * These ecotypic differences suggest contrasting adaptive strategies to cope with either edaphic stress in serpentine sites or intense above-ground competition at riparian sites. There was a significant population origin x soil type crossing interaction in one fitness trait (average dry weight) that mirrored local adaptation previously documented for these riparian and serpentine ecotypes. However, because all other fitness traits did not exhibit this crossing interaction in our common garden study, it is possible that phenotypic differences underlying local adaptation may be amplified in the field as a result of biotic and abiotic interactions.

FeMo cofactor maturation on NifEN

FeMo cofactor (FeMoco) biosynthesis is one of the most complicated processes in metalloprotein biochemistry. Here we show that Mo and homocitrate are incorporated into the Fe/S core of the FeMoco precursor while it is bound to NifEN and that the resulting fully complemented, FeMoco-like cluster is transformed into a mature FeMoco upon transfer from NifEN to MoFe protein through direct protein-protein interaction. Our findings not only clarify the process of FeMoco maturation, but also provide useful insights into the other facets of nitrogenase chemistry.

Nitrogenase Fe protein: A molybdate/homocitrate insertase

The Fe protein is indispensable for nitrogenase catalysis and biosynthesis. However, its function in iron-molybdenum cofactor (FeMoco) biosynthesis has not been clearly defined. Here we show that the Fe protein can act as a Mo/homocitrate insertase that mobilizes Mo/homocitrate for the maturation of FeMoco precursor on NifEN. Further, we establish that Mo/homocitrate mobilization by the Fe protein likely involves hydrolysis of MgATP and protein-protein interaction between the Fe protein and NifEN. Our findings not only clarify the role of the Fe protein in FeMoco assembly and assign another function to this multitask enzyme but also provide useful insights into a mechanism of metal trafficking required for the assembly of complex metalloproteins such as nitrogenase.

Molecular insights into nitrogenase FeMoco insertion: TRP-444 of MoFe protein alpha-subunit locks FeMoco in its binding site

Biosynthesis of the FeMo cofactor (FeMoco) of nitrogenase MoFe protein is arguably one of the most complex processes in metalloprotein biochemistry. Here we investigate the role of a MoFe protein residue (Trp-alpha444) in the final step of FeMoco assembly, which involves the insertion of FeMoco into its binding site. Mutations of this aromatic residue to small uncharged ones result in significantly decreased levels of FeMoco insertion/retention and drastically reduced activities of MoFe proteins, suggesting that Trp-alpha444 may lock the FeMoco tightly in its binding site through the sterically restricting effect of its bulky, aromatic side chain. Additionally, these mutations cause partial conversion of the P-cluster to a more open conformation, indicating a potential connection between FeMoco insertion and P-cluster assembly. Our results provide some of the initial molecular insights into the FeMoco insertion process and, moreover, have useful implications for the overall scheme of nitrogenase assembly.

Mechanistic Significance of the Preparatory Migration of Hydrogen Atoms around the FeMo-co Active Site of Nitrogenase

The migration of H atoms over S and Fe atoms in the reaction domain of FeMo-co, the active site of nitrogenase, is described and used to explain mechanistic data on the catalyzed reductions of N(2) and C(2)H(2). After electron transfer to FeMo-co, H atoms are generated by fast proton supply to S3B (atom labels from structure 1M1N) and migrate vectorially via several pathways from S3B to locations on the FeMo-co face, specifically Fe6, S2B, Fe2, and S2A (calculated reaction profiles are reported). The E(n)H(n) reduction levels (n = 1-4) in the Thorneley-Lowe kinetic-mechanistic schemes are each potential sequences of substructures with different distributions of H atoms. The positions of H atoms influence the binding of substrates N(2) and C(2)H(2), and the bound substrate subsequently blocks further migration of H atoms past the binding site. This model provides a consistent structural interpretation of (a) the two-site reactivity of C(2)H(2) and the differentiation of the high- and low-affinity sites as due to different preparatory H migration; (b) the differing mutual inhibitions of N(2) and C(2)H(2) in wild-type protein; (c) the modified reactivity of the Azotobacter vinelandii alpha-(Gly)69(Ser) mutant with N(2) and C(2)H(2); and (d) the basis for the stereoselectivity of hydrogenation of C(2)D(2) and its loss in some mutant proteins. Some structures for initially bound N(2) and C(2)H(2), and their hydrogenated intermediates, are presented. The key new concept is that binding sites and binding states for substrates and intermediates are characterized not only by their locations on the FeMo-co face but also by the structural and temporal status of the distribution of H atoms over the FeMo-co reaction domain.

Studies of low-coordinate iron dinitrogen complexes

Understanding the interaction of N2 with iron is relevant to the iron catalyst used in the Haber process and to possible roles of the FeMoco active site of nitrogenase. The work reported here uses synthetic compounds to evaluate the extent of NN weakening in low-coordinate iron complexes with an FeNNFe core. The steric effects, oxidation level, presence of alkali metals, and coordination number of the iron atoms are varied, to gain insight into the factors that weaken the NN bond. Diiron complexes with a bridging N2 ligand, L(R)FeNNFeL(R) (L(R) = beta-diketiminate; R = Me, tBu), result from reduction of [L(R)FeCl]n under a dinitrogen atmosphere, and an iron(I) precursor of an N2 complex can be observed. X-ray crystallographic and resonance Raman data for L(R)FeNNFeL(R) show a reduction in the N-N bond order, and calculations (density functional and multireference) indicate that the bond weakening arises from cooperative back-bonding into the N2 pi orbitals. Increasing the coordination number of iron from three to four through binding of pyridines gives compounds with comparable N-N weakening, and both are substantially weakened relative to five-coordinate iron-N2 complexes, even those with a lower oxidation state. Treatment of L(R)FeNNFeL(R) with KC8 gives K2L(R)FeNNFeL(R), and calculations indicate that reduction of the iron and alkali metal coordination cooperatively weaken the N-N bond. The complexes L(R)FeNNFeL(R) react as iron(I) fragments, losing N2 to yield iron(I) phosphine, CO, and benzene complexes. They also reduce ketones and aldehydes to give the products of pinacol coupling. The K2L(R)FeNNFeL(R) compounds can be alkylated at iron, with loss of N2.

Structure of Spinach Nitrite Reductase: Implications for Multi-electron Reactions by the Iron−Sulfur:Siroheme Cofactor†,‡

The structure of nitrite reductase, a key enzyme in the process of nitrogen assimilation, has been determined using X-ray diffraction to a resolution limit of 2.8 A. The protein has a globular fold consisting of 3 alpha/beta domains with the siroheme-iron sulfur cofactor at the interface of the three domains. The Fe(4)S(4) cluster is coordinated by cysteines 441, 447, 482, and 486. The siroheme is located at a distance of 4.2 A from the cluster, and the central iron atom is coordinated to Cys 486. The siroheme is surrounded by several ionizable amino acid residues that facilitate the binding and subsequent reduction of nitrite. A model for the ferredoxin:nitrite reductase complex is proposed in which the binding of ferredoxin to a positively charged region of nitrite reductase results in elimination of exposure of the cofactors to the solvent. The structure of nitrite reductase shows a broad similarity to the hemoprotein subunit of sulfite reductase but has many significant differences in the backbone positions that could reflect sequence differences or could arise from alterations of the sulfite reductase structure that arise from the isolation of this subunit from the native complex. The implications of the nitrite reductase structure for understanding multi-electron processes are discussed in terms of differences in the protein environments of the cofactors.

Functional NifD-K fusion protein in Azotobacter vinelandii is a homodimeric complex equivalent to the native heterotetrameric MoFe protein

The MoFe protein of the complex metalloenzyme nitrogenase folds as a heterotetramer containing two copies each of the homologous alpha and beta subunits, encoded by the nifD and the nifK genes respectively. Recently, the functional expression of a fusion NifD-K protein of nitrogenase was demonstrated in Azotobacter vinelandii, strongly implying that the MoFe protein is flexible as it could accommodate major structural changes, yet remain functional [M.H. Suh, L. Pulakat, N. Gavini, J. Biol. Chem. 278 (2003) 5353-5360]. This finding led us to further explore the type of interaction between the fused MoFe protein units. We aimed to determine whether an interaction exists between the two fusion MoFe proteins to form a homodimer that is equivalent to native heterotetrameric MoFe protein. Using the Bacteriomatch Two-Hybrid System, translationally fused constructs of NifD-K (fusion) with the full-length lambdaCI of the pBT bait vector and also NifD-K (fusion) with the N-terminal alpha-RNAP of the pTRG target vector were made. To compare the extent of interaction between the fused NifD-K proteins to that of the beta-beta interactions in the native MoFe protein, we proceeded to generate translationally fused constructs of NifK with the alpha-RNAP of the pTRG vector and lambdaCI protein of the pBT vector. The strength of the interaction between the proteins in study was determined by measuring the beta-galactosidase activity and extent of ampicillin resistance of the colonies expressing these proteins. This analysis demonstrated that direct protein-protein interaction exists between NifD-K fusion proteins, suggesting that they exist as homodimers. As the interaction takes place at the beta-interfaces of the NifD-K fusion proteins, we propose that these homodimers of NifD-K fusion protein may function in a similar manner as that of the heterotetrameric native MoFe protein. The observation that the extent of protein-protein interaction between the beta-subunits of the native MoFe protein in BacterioMatch Two-Hybrid System is comparable to the extent of protein-protein interaction observed between the NifD-K fusion proteins in the same system further supports this idea.

Nitrogenase reactivity with P-cluster variants

Nitrogenase is a multicomponent metalloenzyme that catalyzes the conversion of atmospheric dinitrogen to ammonia. For decades, it has been generally believed that the [8Fe-7S] P-cluster of nitrogenase component 1 is indispensable for nitrogenase activity. In this study, we identified two catalytically active P-cluster variants by activity assays, metal analysis, and EPR spectroscopic studies. Further, we showed that both P-cluster variants resemble [4Fe-4S]-like centers based on x-ray absorption spectroscopic experiments. We believe that our findings challenge the dogma that the standard P-cluster is the only cluster species capable of supporting substrate reduction at the FeMo cofactor and provide important insights into the general mechanism of nitrogenase catalysis and assembly.

Normal-mode analysis of FeCl4- and Fe2S2Cl42- via vibrational mössbauer, resonance Raman, and FT-IR spectroscopies

[NEt(4)][FeCl(4)], [P(C(6)H(5))(4)][FeCl(4)], and [NEt(4)](2)[Fe(2)S(2)Cl(4)] have been examined using (57)Fe nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy (NRVS). These complexes serve as simple models for Fe-S clusters in metalloproteins. The (57)Fe partial vibrational density of states (PVDOS) spectra were interpreted by computation of the normal modes assuming Urey-Bradley force fields, using additional information from infrared and Raman spectra. Previously published force constants were used as initial values; the new constraints from NRVS frequencies and amplitudes were then used to refine the force field parameters in a nonlinear least-squares analysis. The normal-mode calculations were able to quantitatively reproduce both the frequencies and the amplitudes of the intramolecular-mode (57)Fe PVDOS. The optimized force constants for bending, stretching, and nonbonded interactions agree well with previously reported values. In addition, the NRVS technique also allowed clear observation of anion-cation lattice modes below 100 cm(-1) that are nontrivial to observe by conventional spectroscopies. These features were successfully reproduced, either by assuming whole-body motions of point-mass anions and cations or by simulations using all of the atoms in the unit cell. The advantages of a combined NRVS, Raman, and IR approach to characterization of Fe-S complexes are discussed.

Activation and protonation of dinitrogen at the FeMo cofactor of nitrogenase

The protonation of N2 bound to the active center of nitrogenase has been investigated using state-of-the-art density-functional theory calculations. Dinitrogen in the bridging mode is activated by forming two bonds to Fe sites, which results in a reduction of the energy for the first hydrogen transfer by 123 kJ/mol. The axial binding mode with open sulfur bridge is less reactive by 30 kJ/mol and the energetic ordering of the axial and bridged binding modes is reversed in favor of the bridging dinitrogen during the first protonation. Protonation of the central ligand is thermodynamically favorable but kinetically hindered. If the central ligand is protonated, the proton is transferred to dinitrogen following the second protonation. Protonation of dinitrogen at the Mo site does not lead to low-energy intermediates.

The Hydrogen Chemistry of the FeMo-co Active Site of Nitrogenase

The chemical mechanism by which nitrogenase enzymes catalyze the hydrogenation of N(2) (and other multiply bonded substrates) at the N(c)Fe(7)MoS(9)(homocitrate) active site (FeMo-co) is unknown, despite the accumulation of much data on enzyme reactivity and the influences of key amino acids surrounding FeMo-co. The mutual influences of H(2), substrates, and the inhibitor CO on reactivity are key experimental tests for postulated mechanisms. Fundamental to all aspects of mechanism is the accumulation of H atoms (from e(-) + H(+)) on FeMo-co, and the generation and influences of coordinated H(2). Here, I argue that the first introduction of H is via a water chain terminating at water 679 (PDB structure , Azotobacter vinelandii) to one of the mu(3)-S atoms (S3B) of FeMo-co. Next, using validated density functional calculations of a full chemical representation of FeMo-co and its connected residues (alpha-275(Cys), alpha-442(His)), I have characterized more than 80 possibilities for the coordination of up to three H atoms, and H(2), and H + H(2), on the S2A, Fe2, S2B, Fe6, S3B domain of FeMo-co, which is favored by recent targeted mutagenesis results. Included are calculated reaction profiles for movements of H atoms (between S and Fe, and between Fe and Fe), for the generation of Fe-H(2), for association and dissociation of Fe-H(2) at various reduction levels, and for H/H(2) exchange. This is new hydrogen chemistry on an unprecedented coordination frame, with some similarities to established hydrogen coordination chemistry, and with unexpected and unprecedented structures such as Fe(S)(3)(H(2))(2)(H) octahedral coordination. General principles for the hydrogen chemistry of FeMo-co include (1) the stereochemical mobility of H bound to mu(3)-S, (2) the differentiated endo- and exo- positions at Fe for coordination of H and/or H(2), and (3) coordinative allosteric influences in which structural and dynamic aspects of coordination at one Fe atom are affected by coordination at another Fe atom, and by H on S atoms. Evidence of end-differentiation in FeMo-co is described, providing a rationale for the occurrence of Mo. The reactivity results are discussed in the context of the Thorneley-Lowe scheme for nitrogenase reactions, and especially the scheme for the HD reaction (2H(+) + 2e(-) + D(2) --> 2HD), using a model containing an H-entry site and at least two coordinative sites on FeMo-co. I propose that S3B is the H-entry site, suggest details for the H(+) shuttle to S3B and subsequent movement of H atoms around FeMo-co preparatory to the binding and hydrogenation of N(2) and other substrates, and suggest how H could be transferred to an alkyne substrate. I propose that S2B (normally hydrogen bonded to alpha-195(His)) has a modulatory function and is not an H-entry site. Finally, the recent first experimental trapping of a hydrogenated intermediate with EPR and ENDOR characterization is discussed, leading to a consensual model for the intermediate.

NifU and NifS are required for the maturation of nitrogenase and cannot replace the function of isc-gene products in Azotobacter vinelandii

In recent years, it has become evident that [Fe-S] proteins, such as hydrogenase, nitrogenase and aconitase, require a complex machinery to assemble and insert their associated [Fe-S] clusters. So far, three different types of [Fe-S] cluster biosynthetic systems have been identified and these have been designated nif, isc and suf. In the present work, we show that the nif-specific [Fe-S] cluster biosynthetic system from Azotobacter vinelandii, which is required for nitrogenase maturation, cannot functionally replace the isc [Fe-S] cluster system used for the maturation of other [Fe-S] proteins, such as aconitase. The results indicate that, in certain cases, [Fe-S] cluster biosynthetic machineries have evolved to perform only specialized functions.

Model for Acetylene Reduction by Nitrogenase Derived from Density Functional Theory

The catalytic cycle of acetylene reduction at the FeMo cofactor of nitrogenase has been investigated on the basis of density functional theory. C2H2 binds to the same site as N2, but it binds to a less reduced state of the cofactor. In a manner similar to that of N2 binding, one of the sulfur bridges opens during acetylene binding. The model explains the strong noncompetitive inhibition of N2 reduction by C2H2 and the weak competitive inhibition of C2H2 reduction by N2. Our proposed mechanism is consistent with experimentally observed stereoselectivity and the ability of C2H2 to suppress H2 production by nitrogenase.

Genes required for rapid expression of nitrogenase activity in Azotobacter vinelandii

Rnf proteins are proposed to form membrane-protein complexes involved in the reduction of target proteins such as the transcriptional regulator SoxR or the dinitrogenase reductase component of nitrogenase. In this work, we investigate the role of rnf genes in the nitrogen-fixing bacterium Azotobacter vinelandii. We show that A. vinelandii has two clusters of rnf-like genes: rnf1, whose expression is nif-regulated, and rnf2, which is expressed independently of the nitrogen source in the medium. Deletion of each of these gene clusters produces a time delay in nitrogen-fixing capacity and, consequently, in diazotrophic growth. Deltarnf mutations cause two distinguishable effects on the nitrogenase system: (i), slower nifHDK gene expression and (ii), impairment of nitrogenase function. In these mutants, dinitrogenase reductase activity is lowered, whereas dinitrogenase activity remains essentially unaltered. Further analysis indicates that deltarnf mutants accumulate an inactive and iron-deficient form of NifH because they have lower rates of incorporation of [4Fe-4S] into NifH. Deltarnf mutations also cause a noticeable decrease in aconitase activity; however, they do not produce general oxidative stress or modification of Fe metabolism in A. vinelandii. Our results suggest the existence of a redox regulatory mechanism in A. vinelandii that controls the rate of expression and maturation of nitrogenase by the activity of the Rnf protein complexes. rnf1 plays a major and more specific role in this scheme, but the additive effects of mutations in rnf1 and rnf2 indicate the existence of functional complementation between the two homologous systems.

Low-coordinate iron complexes as synthetic models of nitrogenase

Three-coordinate iron sites are potentially important intermediates in the reduction of dinitrogen by the enzyme nitrogenase, but synthetic work to outline the behavior of three-coordinate iron complexes is in its infancy. Recent work shows that bulky diketiminate ligands give a general route to three-coordinate iron complexes with a variety of third ligands. The low coordination number leads to exciting new reactions in which N—N bonds are weakened or broken. Such complexes show great promise for evaluating the ability of low-coordinate iron to perform bond cleavage reactions akin to the individual steps of the nitrogenase system.Key words: nitrogenase, three-coordinate iron, diketiminate, N–N cleavage.

Identification of a nitrogenase FeMo cofactor precursor on NifEN complex

The biosynthesis of the FeMo cofactor (FeMoco) of Azotobacter vinelandii nitrogenase presumably starts with the production of its Fe/S core by NifB (the nifB gene product). This core is subsequently processed on the alpha2beta2 tetrameric NifEN complex (formed by the nifE and nifN gene products). In this article, we identify a NifEN-bound FeMoco precursor form that can be converted to fully assembled FeMoco in a so-called FeMoco-maturation assay containing only purified components. We also establish that only molybdate, homocitrate, MgATP, and Fe protein are essential for FeMoco maturation. The FeMoco-maturation assay described here will further address the remaining questions related to the assembly mechanism of the ever-intriguing FeMoco.

Substrate interactions with the nitrogenase active site

The chemical mechanism for biological cleavage of the N(2) triple bond at ambient pressure and temperature has been the subject of intense study for many years. The site of substrate activation and reduction has been localized to a complex cofactor, called FeMo cofactor, yet until now the complexity of the system has denied information concerning exactly where and how substrates interact with the metal-sulfur framework of the active site. In this Account, we describe a combined genetic, biophysical, and biochemical approach that was used to provide direct and detailed information concerning where alternative alkyne substrates interact with FeMo cofactor during catalysis. The relevance and limitations of this work with respect to N(2) binding and reduction also are discussed.

Characterization of Azotobacter vinelandii nifZ deletion strains. Indication of stepwise MoFe protein assembly

The nifZ gene product (NifZ) of Azotobacter vinelandii has been implicated in MoFe protein maturation. However, its exact function in this process remains largely unknown. Here, we report a detailed biochemical/biophysical characterization of His-tagged MoFe proteins purified from A. vinelandii nifZ and nifZ/nifB deletion strains DJ1182 and YM6A (Delta nifZ and Delta nifZ Delta nifB MoFe proteins, respectively). Our data from EPR, metal, activity, and stability analyses indicate that one alpha beta subunit pair of the Delta nifZ MoFe protein contains a P cluster ([8Fe-7S]) and an iron-molybdenum cofactor (FeMoco) ([Mo-7Fe-9S-X-homocitrate]), whereas the other contains a presumed P cluster precursor, possibly comprising a pair of [4Fe-4S]-like clusters, and a vacant FeMoco site. Likewise, the Delta nifZ Delta nifB MoFe protein has the same composition as the Delta nifZ MoFe protein except for the absence of FeMoco, an effect caused by the deletion of the nifB gene. These results suggest that the MoFe protein is likely assembled stepwise, i.e. one alpha beta subunit pair of the tetrameric MoFe protein is assembled prior to the other, and that NifZ might act as a chaperone in the assembly of the second alpha beta subunit pair by facilitating a conformational rearrangement that is required for the formation of the P cluster through the condensation of two [4Fe-4S]-like clusters. The possibility of NifZ exercising its effect through the Fe protein was ruled out because the Fe proteins from nifZ and nifZ/nifB deletion strains are not defective in their normal functions. However, the detailed mechanism of how NifZ carries out its exact function in MoFe protein maturation awaits further investigation.

The Mechanism of Nitrogenase. Computed Details of the Site and Geometry of Binding of Alkyne and Alkene Substrates and Intermediates

The chemical mechanism by which the enzyme nitrogenase effects the remarkable reduction of N(2) to NH(3) under ambient conditions continues to be enigmatic, because no intermediate has been observed directly. Recent experimental investigation of the enzymatic consequences of the valine --> alanine modification of residue alpha-70 of the component MoFe protein on the reduction of alkynes, together with EPR and ENDOR spectroscopic characterization of a trappable intermediate in the reduction of propargyl alcohol or propargyl amine (HCC[triple bond]C-CH(2)OH/NH(2)), has localized the site of binding and reduction of these substrates on the FeMo-cofactor and led to proposed eta(2)-Fe coordination geometry. Here these experimental data are modeled using density functional calculations of the allyl alcohol/amine intermediates and the propargyl alcohol/amine reactants coordinated to the FeMo-cofactor, together with force-field calculations of the interactions of these models with the surrounding MoFe protein. The results support and elaborate the earlier proposals, with the most probable binding site and geometry being eta(2)-coordination at Fe6 of the FeMo-cofactor (crystal structure in the Protein Database), in a position that is intermediate between the exo and endo coordination extremes at Fe6. The models described account for (1) the steric influence of the alpha-70 residue, (2) the crucial hydrogen bonding with Nepsilon of alpha-195(His), (3) the spectroscopic symmetry of the allyl-alcohol intermediate, and (4) the preferential stabilization of the allyl alcohol/amine relative to propargyl alcohol/amine. Alternative binding sites and geometries for ethyne and ethene, relevant to the wild-type protein, are described. This model defines the location and scene for detailed investigation of the mechanism of nitrogenase.

Comparison of Iron-Molybdenum Cofactor-deficient Nitrogenase MoFe Proteins by X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy

Nitrogenase, the enzyme system responsible for biological nitrogen fixation, is believed to utilize two unique metalloclusters in catalysis. There is considerable interest in understanding how these metalloclusters are assembled in vivo. It has been presumed that immature iron-molybdenum cofactor-deficient nitrogenase MoFe proteins contain the P-cluster, although no biosynthetic pathway for the assembly of this complex cluster has been identified as yet. Through the comparison by iron K-edge x-ray absorption edge and extended fine structure analyses of cofactor-deficient MoFe proteins resulting from nifH and nifB deletion strains of Azotobacter vinelandii, a novel [Fe-S] cluster is identified in the DeltanifH MoFe protein. The iron-iron scattering displayed by the DeltanifH MoFe protein is more similar to that of a standard [Fe(4)S(4)]-containing protein than that of the DeltanifB MoFe protein, which is shown to contain a "normal" P-cluster. The iron-sulfur scattering of the DeltanifH MoFe protein, however, indicates differences in its cluster from an [Fe(4)S(4)](Cys)(4) site that may be consistent with the presence of either oxygenic or nitrogenic ligation. Based on these results, models for the [Fe-S] center in the DeltanifH MoFe protein are constructed, the most likely of which consist of two separate [Fe(4)S(4)] sites, each with some non-cysteinyl coordination. This type of model suggests that the P-cluster is formed by the condensation of two [Fe(4)S(4)] fragments, possibly concomitant with Fe protein (NifH)-induced conformational change.

A sulfido-bridged diiron(II) compound and its reactions with nitrogenase-relevant substrates

The active site iron-molybdenum cofactor of nitrogenase has sulfide-bridged pairs of redox-active, trigonal pyramidal iron atoms that are postulated to be the site of N2 transformation. A synthetic compound is described in which two three-coordinate iron(II) ions are bridged similarly by sulfide. The compound binds nitrogen donors to become trigonal pyramidal and cleaves the N-N bond of phenylhydrazine with oxidation of iron(II) to iron(III).

Localization of a substrate binding site on the FeMo-cofactor in nitrogenase: trapping propargyl alcohol with an alpha-70-substituted MoFe protein

Substitution of the MoFe protein alpha-70(Val) residue with Ala or Gly expands the substrate range of nitrogenase, allowing the reduction of larger alkynes, including propargyl alcohol (HC[triple bond]CCH(2)OH). Herein, we report characterization of the alpha-70(Val)(-->)(Ala) MoFe protein with propargyl alcohol trapped at the active site. The alpha-70(Ala) variant MoFe protein was rapidly frozen during reduction of propargyl alcohol, resulting in the conversion of the resting-state FeMo-cofactor EPR signal (S = 3/2 and g = [4.41, 3.60, 2.00]) to a new state (S = 1/2 and g = [2.123, 1.998, 1.986]). This EPR signal of the new state increased in intensity with increasing propargyl alcohol concentration, consistent with the binding of a single substrate. The EPR signal of the propargyl alcohol state showed temperature and microwave power dependencies markedly different from those of the classic FeMo-cofactor EPR signal, consistent with the difference in spin. The new state is analogous to that induced by the binding of the inhibitor CO ("lo CO" state) to FeMo-cofactor in the wild-type MoFe protein. The (13)C ENDOR spectrum of the alpha-70(Ala) MoFe protein with trapped (13)C-labeled propargyl alcohol exhibited three well-resolved (13)C doublets centered at the (13)C Larmor frequency with isotropic hyperfine couplings of approximately 3.2, approximately 1.4, and approximately 0.7 MHz, indicating that the alcohol (or a fragment) is coordinated to the cofactor. The results presented here localize the binding site of propargyl alcohol to one [4Fe-4S] face of FeMo-cofactor and indicate roles for the alpha-70(Val) residue in controlling FeMo-cofactor reactivity.

Elucidating thermodynamic parameters for electron transfer proteins using isothermal titration calorimetry: application to the nitrogenase Fe protein

Establishing thermodynamic parameters for electron transfer reactions involving redox proteins is essential for a complete description of these important reactions. While various methods have been developed for measuring the Gibbs free energy change (Delta G(HR) or E(m)) for the protein half-reactions, deconvolution of the respective contributions of enthalpy (Delta H(HR)) and entropy (Delta S(HR)) changes is much more challenging. In the present work, an approach is developed using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) that allows accurate determination of all of these thermodynamic parameters for protein electron transfer half-reactions. The approach was validated for essentially irreversible and reversible electron transfer reactions between well-characterized mediators and between mediators and the protein cytochrome c. In all cases, the measured thermodynamic parameters were in excellent agreement with parameters determined by electrochemical methods. Finally, the calorimetry approach was used to determine thermodynamic parameters for electron transfer reactions of the nitrogenase Fe protein [4Fe-4S](2+/+) couple in the absence or presence of MgADP or MgATP. The E(m) value was found to change from -290 mV in the absence of nucleotides to -381 mV with MgATP and -423 mV with MgADP, consistent with earlier values. For the first time, the enthalpy (Delta H(HR)) and entropy (Delta S(HR)) contributions for each case were established, revealing shifts in the contribution of each thermodynamic parameter induced by nucleotide binding. The results are discussed in the context of current models for electron transfer in nitrogenase.

Observation of Fe-H/D modes by nuclear resonant vibrational spectroscopy

Metal-hydrogen bonding is important in chemistry and catalysis, but H atoms are often difficult to observe, especially in metalloproteins. In this work we show that Fe-H interactions can be probed by nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy at the 14.4 keV 57Fe nuclear resonance. An important advantage of this method, compared to Raman and IR spectroscopy, is the selectivity for modes that involve 57Fe motion. We present data on the FeS4 site in rubredoxin and the [FeH(D)6]2- ion. Prospects for studying more complex systems are discussed.

Speculative synthetic chemistry and the nitrogenase problem

There exist a limited but growing number of biological metal centers whose properties lie conspicuously outside the realm of known inorganic chemistry. The synthetic analogue approach, broadly directed, offers a powerful exploratory tool that can define intrinsic chemical possibilities for these sites while simultaneously expanding the frontiers of fundamental inorganic chemistry. This speculative application of analogue study is exemplified here in the evolution of synthetic efforts inspired by the cluster chemistry of biological nitrogen fixation.

Iron-arylimide clusters [Fe(m)()(NAr)(n)Cl(4)](2)(-) (m, n = 2, 2; 3, 4; 4, 4) from a ferric amide precursor: synthesis, characterization, and comparison to Fe-S chemistry

Tetrahedral FeCl[N(SiMe(3))(2)](2)(THF) (2), prepared from FeCl(3) and 2 equiv of Na[N(SiMe(3))(2)] in THF, is a useful ferric starting material for the synthesis of weak-field iron-imide (Fe-NR) clusters. Protonolysis of 2 with aniline yields azobenzene and [Fe(2)(mu-Cl)(3)(THF)(6)](2)[Fe(3)(mu-NPh)(4)Cl(4)] (3), a salt composed of two diferrous monocations and a trinuclear dianion with a formal 2 Fe(III)/1 Fe(IV) oxidation state. Treatment of 2 with LiCl, which gives the adduct [FeCl(2)(N(SiMe(3))(2))(2)](-) (isolated as the [Li(TMEDA)(2)](+) salt), suppresses arylamine oxidation/iron reduction chemistry during protonolysis. Thus, under appropriate conditions, the reaction of 1:1 2/LiCl with arylamine provides a practical route to the following Fe-NR clusters: [Li(2)(THF)(7)][Fe(3)(mu-NPh)(4)Cl(4)] (5a), which contains the same Fe-NR cluster found in 3; [Li(THF)(4)](2)[Fe(3)(mu-N-p-Tol)(4)Cl(4)] (5b); [Li(DME)(3)](2)[Fe(2)(mu-NPh)(2)Cl(4)] (6a); [Li(2)(THF)(7)][Fe(2)(mu-NMes)(2)Cl(4)] (6c). [Li(DME)(3)](2)[Fe(4)(mu(3)-NPh)(4)Cl(4)] (7), a trace product in the synthesis of 5a and 6a, forms readily as the sole Fe-NR complex upon reduction of these lower nuclearity clusters. Products were characterized by X-ray crystallographic analysis, by electronic absorption, (1)H NMR, and Mössbauer spectroscopies, and by cyclic voltammetry. The structures of the Fe-NR complexes derive from tetrahedral iron centers, edge-fused by imide bridges into linear arrays (5a,b; 6a,c) or the condensed heterocubane geometry (7), and are homologous to fundamental iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster motifs. The analogy to Fe-S chemistry also encompasses parallels between Fe-mediated redox transformations of nitrogen and sulfur ligands and reductive core conversions of linear dinuclear and trinuclear clusters to heterocubane species and is reinforced by other recent examples of iron- and cobalt-imide cluster chemistry. The correspondence of nitrogen and sulfur chemistry at iron is intriguing in the context of speculative Fe-mediated mechanisms for biological nitrogen fixation.

Functional expression of a fusion-dimeric MoFe protein of nitrogenase in Azotobacter vinelandii

The MoFe protein component of the complex metalloenzyme nitrogenase is an alpha2beta2 tetramer encoded by the nifD and the nifK genes. In nitrogen fixing organisms, the alpha and beta subunits are translated as separate polypeptides and then assembled into tetrameric MoFe protein complex that includes two types of metal centers, the P cluster and the FeMo cofactor. In Azotobacter vinelandii, the NifEN complex, the site for biosynthesis of the FeMo cofactor, is an alpha2beta2 tetramer that is structurally similar to the MoFe protein and encoded as two separate polypeptides by the nifE and the nifN genes. In Anabaena variabilis it was shown that a NifE-N fusion protein encoded by translationally fused nifE and nifN genes can support biological nitrogen fixation. The structural similarity between the MoFe protein and the NifEN complex prompted us to test whether the MoFe protein could also be functional when synthesized as a single protein encoded by nifD-K translational fusion. Here we report that the NifD-K fusion protein encoded by nifD-K translational fusion in A. vinelandii is a large protein (as determined by Western blot analysis) and is capable of supporting biological nitrogen fixation. These results imply that the MoFe protein is flexible in that it can accommodate major structural changes and remain functional.

Functional expression of the FeMo-cofactor-specific biosynthetic genes nifEN as a NifE-N fusion protein synthesizing unit in Azotobacter vinelandii

The nifEN encodes an E2N2 tetrameric metalloprotein complex that serves as scaffold for assembly of the FeMo cofactor of nitrogenase. In most diazotrophs, the NifE and NifN are translated as separate polypeptides and then assembled into tetrameric E2N2 complex. However, in Anabaena variabilis which has two nif clusters that encode two different NifEN complexes, the NifEN2 is encoded by a single nifE-N like gene, which has high homology to the NifE at amino-terminus and to the NifN at the carboxy-terminus. These observations implied that a metalloprotein like NifEN can accommodate large variations in their amino acid composition and also in the way they are synthesized (as two separate proteins or as a single protein) and yet remain functional. In Azotobacter vinelandii NifE and NifN are synthesized separately. To test whether NifEN could retain its functionality when encoded by a single gene, we generated a translational fusion of the nifE and nifN genes of A. vinelandii that could encode a large NifE-N fusion protein. When expressed in the nifEN-minus strain of A. vinelandii, the nifE-N gene fusion could complement the NifEN function. Western blot analysis by using polyclonal NifEN antibodies revealed that the complementing nifEN product is a large NifE-N fusion protein unit. The fact that the gene fusion of nifE-N specifies a functional NifE-N fusion protein reflects that these metalloproteins can accommodate a wide range of flexibility in their gene organization, structure, and assembly.

Great metalloclusters in enzymology

Metallocluster-containing enzymes catalyze some of the most basic redox transformations in the biosphere. The reactions catalyzed by these enzymes typically involve small molecules such as N2, CO, and H2 that are used to generate both chemical building blocks and energy for metabolic purposes. During the past decade, structures have been established for the iron-sulfur-based metalloclusters present in the molybdenum nitrogenase, the iron-only hydrogenase, and the nickel-carbon monoxide dehydrogenase, and for the copper-sulfide-based cluster in nitrous oxide reductase. Although these clusters are built from interactions observed in simpler metalloproteins, they contain novel features that may be relevant for their catalytic function. The mechanisms of metallocluster-containing enzymes are still poorly defined, and represent substantial and continuing challenges to biochemists, biophysicists, and synthetic chemists. These proteins also provide a window into the union of the biological and inorganic worlds that may have been relevant to the early evolution of biochemical catalysis.

Nitrogenase MoFe-protein at 1.16 A resolution: a central ligand in the FeMo-cofactor

A high-resolution crystallographic analysis of the nitrogenase MoFe-protein reveals a previously unrecognized ligand coordinated to six iron atoms in the center of the catalytically essential FeMo-cofactor. The electron density for this ligand is masked in structures with resolutions lower than 1.55 angstroms, owing to Fourier series termination ripples from the surrounding iron and sulfur atoms in the cofactor. The central atom completes an approximate tetrahedral coordination for the six iron atoms, instead of the trigonal coordination proposed on the basis of lower resolution structures. The crystallographic refinement at 1.16 angstrom resolution is consistent with this newly detected component being a light element, most plausibly nitrogen. The presence of a nitrogen atom in the cofactor would have important implications for the mechanism of dinitrogen reduction by nitrogenase.

The FeMoco-deficient MoFe protein produced by a nifH deletion strain of Azotobacter vinelandii shows unusual P-cluster features

The His-tag MoFe protein expressed by the nifH deletion strain Azotobacter vinelandii DJ1165 (Delta(nifH) MoFe protein) was purified in large quantity. The alpha(2)beta(2) tetrameric Delta(nifH) MoFe protein is FeMoco-deficient based on metal analysis and the absence of the S = 3/2 EPR signal, which arises from the FeMo cofactor center in wild-type MoFe protein. The Delta(nifH) MoFe protein contains 18.6 mol Fe/mol and, upon reduction with dithionite, exhibits an unusually strong S = 1/2 EPR signal in the g approximately 2 region. The indigo disulfonate-oxidized Delta(nifH) MoFe protein does not show features of the P(2+) state of the P-cluster of the Delta(nifB) MoFe protein. The oxidized Delta(nifH) MoFe protein is able to form a specific complex with the Fe protein containing the [4Fe-4S](1+) cluster and facilitates the hydrolysis of MgATP within this complex. However, it is not able to accept electrons from the [4Fe-4S](1+) cluster of the Fe protein. Furthermore, the dithionite-reduced Delta(nifH) MoFe can be further reduced by Ti(III) citrate, which is quite unexpected. These unusual catalytic and spectroscopic properties might indicate the presence of a P-cluster precursor or a P-cluster trapped in an unusual conformation or oxidation state.