Autologous hapten-modified melanoma vaccine as postsurgical adjuvant treatment after resection of nodal metastases

Advances in the non-surgical treatment of melanoma

Immune responses appear to play a role in the natural history of melanoma and immunotherapy has therefore been the subject of a number of studies. The results of several large randomised studies using allogeneic melanoma vaccines have shown minimal benefit and Phase I/II studies with gene transfected melanoma cells do not appear particularly encouraging. The majority of current interest now centres on development of vaccines using defined melanoma antigens recognised by T-cells and given as dendritic vaccines or injected directly as melanoma peptides or DNA. It can be expected that the most effective antigens and method of administration will become apparent over the next few years. It is clear, however, that melanoma shows low response rates to immunotherapy, as for chemotherapy. Both forms of therapy appear to kill melanoma by induction of apoptosis, so it is possible that resistance to apoptosis may underlie the low responses to these forms of therapy. Much is already known about agents that may sensitise melanoma to apoptosis and combining these with chemotherapy and/or immunotherapy provides a promising new approach in treatment of melanoma.

Whole cell ELISA for detection of tumor antigen expression in tumor samples

We have developed a whole cell enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) that detects the melanoma antigens gp100 and S-100 in tumor samples from patients with metastatic melanoma and the antigen CA 125 in tumor samples from patients with ovarian carcinoma. The assay is relatively simple to perform and interpret without specialized expertise in pathology. It is both sensitive and selective and is amenable to being automated. The results correlate very well with those obtained by flow cytometry and are in good accord with published values obtained by immunohistochemistry. We believe that this assay should be very helpful for characterizing autologous cell cancer vaccines and may also represent a useful alternative to immunohistochemistry for cancer diagnosis. It should be adaptable to other types of cancer where tumor antigens have been identified and good antibodies are available.

Short-term autologous tumor cell lines for the active specific immunotherapy of patients with metastatic melanoma

We established short-term cell lines for 108/170 (64%) patients with metastatic melanoma. Tumor cell numbers were expanded to 10(8), then cells were irradiated, aliquoted, and cryopreserved for clinical use. Vaccines have been used to treat 69 patients with clinical follow up for 33 who had measurable metastatic disease at the time vaccine therapy was initiated (METS), and 33 who had no evidence of disease (NED) at the time of vaccine therapy following surgical resection of metastases. The protocol called for a baseline test of delayed tumor hypersensitivity (DTH), three weekly injections, a repeat of the DTH test, then monthly injections for an additional 5 months. Objective tumor responses were noted in 3/26 (12%) patients who received a minimum of three vaccinations, one complete, and two partial, with survivals of 36, 46+, and 78+ months. Only 6/64 (9.4%) had a positive DTH (>10 mm) at baseline, including three METS, all of whom progressed within 4 months and died within a year, and three who are still NED after more than 5 years. Conversion of DTH from negative to positive was documented in 18/44 (41%) patients who were tested at week 0 and 4. At a median follow up of greater than 5 years, the median overall survival (OS) was 40 months for "NED" with a 5-year survival rate of 39%, and 8.6 months with a 5-year survival rate of 10% for "METS" The 18 patients who had conversion of their DTH had a median event-free survival (EFS) of 15.8 months and 5-year EFS of 32% compared to 4.2 months and 9% for the 26 non-converters (P=0.012, two-tailed, log-rank test). Among patients who were NED when treatment started, the 12 patients whose DTH converted had a median overall survival of 61.4 months with 5-year survival of 63% compared to 9.7 months and 0% for the 13 non-converters (P=0.0026). This treatment approach is feasible, produces minimal toxicity, and is associated with long-term survival in a significant subset of patients.

Biological and clinical developments in melanoma vaccines

The identification of antigens recognised on human tumours by autologous T-lymphocytes has opened the way for vaccination strategies involving defined tumour antigens. These vaccinations are therapeutic, i.e. they involve patients with detectable disease. Tumour regressions have been observed in a minority of melanoma patients in Phase I/II trials. Some of these regressions have been complete and long lasting. Improving the efficacy of therapeutic vaccines will critically depend on their capacity to trigger a robust immune response, on the development of appropriate methods to monitor these antitumour immune responses to vaccination and on a better understanding of the mechanisms used by tumours to escape immune attack. Finally, the initiation of large randomised Phase III trials will determine the impact of these vaccines on melanoma treatment.

Autologous, hapten-modified vaccine as a treatment for human cancers

We have devised a novel approach to active immunotherapy based on modification of autologous cancer cells with the hapten, dinitrophenyl (DNP). The treatment program consists of multiple intradermal injections of DNP-modified autologous tumor cells mixed with BCG. Administration of DNP-vaccine to patients with metastatic melanoma induces a unique reaction - the development of inflammation in metastatic masses. Histologically, this consists of infiltration of T lymphocytes, most of which are CD8+. These T cells usually produce gamma interferon in situ. Moreover, they represent expansion of T cell clones with novel T cell receptor structures. Occasionally, administration of DNP-vaccine results in partial or complete regression of measurable metastases. The most common site of regression has been small lung metastases. Administration of DNP-vaccine to patients in the post-surgical adjuvant setting produces a more striking clinical effect. We have treated 214 patients with clinically evident stage III melanoma who had undergone lymphadenectomy. With a median follow-up time of 4.4 years (1.8-10.4 years) the 5-year overall survival (OS) rate is 47% (one nodal site = 51%, two nodal sites = 33%). These results appear to be comparable to those obtained with high dose interferon. More recent studies suggest that this therapeutic approach is also applicable to ovarian cancer. There appear to be no insurmountable impediments to applying this approach to much larger numbers of patients or to developing it as a standard cancer treatment.

Cancer vaccines

Cancer vaccines have been extensively tested in animal models, and in humans. Initial studies focused on first generation vaccines based on whole cell preparations or tumor lysates derived from autologous or allogeneic tumors. Clinical studies conducted with such candidate vaccines contributed to establish the feasibility of immunizing cancer patients against their own tumors. Significant clinical benefits were observed, both in terms of long term survival and recurrence rate, in some of these trials. More recently, however, cancer vaccines targeting well-characterized tumor-associated antigens, i.e. molecules selectively or preferentially expressed by cancer cells but not by normal cells, have been designed and tested in humans. Results obtained as of today with these second-generation vaccines suggest that they are safe and that they can elicit humoral and cellular responses against tumor-specific antigens, without inducing unacceptable clinical signs of autoimmunity. Advances in tumor biology and tumor immunity have helped to better understand the mechanisms displayed by a number of tumors to escape host immunity. This bulk of new knowledge will be used to design future cancer vaccines, which will likely target multiple TAAs, presented by different antigen presentation platforms, in association with synthetic adjuvants and/or immunostimulatory cytokines. Lastly, specific tools allowing to assess in a qualitative and quantitative manner immune responses are critically needed in order to establish correlates between clinical and immune responses in patients receiving experimental vaccines.

Characterization of tumor vaccines during product development

The term tumor vaccines encompasses a wide variety of diverse agents capable of interacting with the immune system to produce local inflammation, delayed type hypersensitivity reaction and/or tumor regression and, hopefully, a therapeutic effect. These vaccines may be grouped into the following general areas: (1) Cell-based vaccines such as manipulated tumor cells, activated peripheral blood or bone marrow-derived lymphocytes, dendritic cells or other antigen presenting cells (APC) and gene-modified tumor cells or other cells engineered to express cytokines, growth factors or tumor antigens. (2) Antigen preparations, such as synthetic peptides, purified antigens and tumor cell lysates. (3) Viral and plasmid vectors expressing therapeutic genes. (4) Liposome containing antigen, peptides, plasmids encoding tumor antigens. While no tumor vaccine has been licensed by the FDA, numerous clinical trials are ongoing and some products have advanced to Phase III pivotal stages of development. However, as with many novel products, major regulatory and scientific issues associated with clinical use of tumor vaccines remain to be addressed. In this paper, we address issues associated with different types of tumor vaccines and provide recommendations for the characterization of these vaccines at various stages of development.

Protracted survival after resection of metastatic uveal melanoma

BACKGROUND

The objective of this study was to evaluate the usefulness of resection of metastatic uveal melanoma and to analyze the characteristics of patients who may benefit from surgical intervention. PATIENTS AND METHODS Twelve patients underwent surgical removal of metastasis between 1976 and 1998. Data regarding primary uveal melanoma, systemic metastasis, surgical procedures, and outcomes were reviewed retrospectively.

RESULTS

There were seven patients with liver metastases, two with lung metastases, one with brain metastasis, and two patients with metastases in the liver and other organs. Median time to systemic metastasis was 8 years. Seven of 12 patients were asymptomatic when they were found to have metastasis. Ten patients underwent complete resection of metastasis. No significant surgical complications were experienced. Median recurrence free and overall survival periods after complete resection were 19 months (range, 6-78 months) and greater than 27 months (range, 11-86 months), respectively. Recurrence free and overall 5-year survival rates of those patients were 15.6% and 53.3%, respectively. Three of these patients had no further systemic recurrence. All patients whose time to systemic metastasis was within 5 years developed further systemic recurrence within 2 years after surgery. In contrast, in 8 patients whose time to systemic metastases was greater than 5 years, 4 patients either were recurrence free or developed second metastasis more than 4 years after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Complete surgical removal of metastatic uveal melanoma provided unexpectedly long survival without significant morbidity for the selected patients. These results are encouraging and justify a trial in which patients eligible for resection are randomized between standard treatment and surgery.

Autologous, allogeneic tumor cells or genetically engineered cells as cancer vaccine against melanoma

Melanoma is a prototype of immunogenic tumor to which various types of immunotherapy have been applied extensively over the past decades. Melanoma vaccines are designed for the purpose of immune modulation and subsequent anti-tumor effects in the process of an active specific immunotherapy. Previous attempts of these vaccines include immunization with whole tumor cells/cell lysates admixed with nonspecific adjuvants. While these vaccines generated enhanced anti-tumor immunity in a subset of patients, some of which showing prolonged survival compared to historical controls, no clinical benefit has so far been demonstrated in a properly controlled phase III study. New-generation melanoma vaccines, which are based on genetic modifications of tumor cells to express cytokines, generated long-lasting systemic anti-tumor immunity in animal models. Translation of these preclinical results primarily into melanoma patients with advanced diseases, shows the potential of these vaccines to induce systemic anti-tumor immune responses and in some instances tumor regression with acceptably low toxicity. Higher efficacy of this novel vaccine approach would be expected when used in a postsurgical adjuvant setting when the tumor load is small. Also other novel vaccine approaches such as dendritic cell-based therapy hold promise for the treatment of melanoma. But the clinical value of all these new approaches has to be analysed in prospectively randomized clinical studies.

Advances in specific immunotherapy of malignant melanoma

Management of malignant melanoma continues to present a challenge to dermatologists, particularly in advanced cases. In light of the steady increase in the worldwide incidence and mortality rates for melanoma, better understanding of the immune mechanisms regulating melanoma progression and interaction with the host's immune system seems eminently important. New studies on the role of immune mechanisms in the pathogenesis and clinical course of melanoma have recently been published. We review the immune mechanisms involved in tumor progression and ways in which these mechanisms may be applied toward immunotherapeutic management of malignant melanoma.

LEARNING OBJECTIVE

After the completion of this learning activity, participants should be familiar with (1) the immune mechanisms involved in host-tumor interaction and tumor rejection, (2) factors allowing the escape of melanoma cells from immune recognition, and (3) the current rationale for the different types of specific immunotherapy in melanoma. Better understanding of basic mechanisms in tumor immunology should raise awareness of future immunotherapeutic approaches in patients with melanoma, particularly in those who are at high risk of recurrence or who present with advanced disease.

An overview of cancer immunotherapy

The survival of patients with cancer has improved steadily but incrementally over the last century, with the advent of effective anticancer treatments such as chemotherapy and radiotherapy. However, the majority of patients with metastatic disease will not be cured by these measures and will eventually die of their disease. New and more effective methods of treating these patients are required urgently. The immune system is a potent force for rejecting transplanted organs or microbial pathogens, but effective spontaneous immunologically induced cancer remissions are very rare. In recent years, much has been discovered about the mechanisms by which the immune system recognizes and responds to cancers. The specific antigens involved have now been defined in many cases. Improved adjuvants are available. Means by which cancer cells overcome immunological attack can be exploited and overcome. Most importantly, the immunological control mechanisms responsible for initiating and maintaining an effective immune response are now much better understood. It is now possible to manipulate immunological effector cells or antigen-presenting cells ex vivo in order to induce an effective antitumour response. At the same time, it is possible to recruit other aspects of the immune system, both specific (e.g. antibody responses) and innate (natural killer cells and granulocytes).

Adjuvant therapy of stage III and IV malignant melanoma using granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor

PURPOSE

To evaluate granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) as surgical adjuvant therapy in patients with malignant melanoma who are at high risk of recurrence.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Forty-eight assessable patients with stage III or IV melanoma were treated in a phase II trial with long-term, chronic, intermittent GM-CSF after surgical resection of disease. Patients with stage III disease were required to have more than four positive nodes or a more than 3-cm mass. All patients were rendered clinically disease-free by surgery before enrollment. The GM-CSF was administered subcutaneously in 28-day cycles, such that a dose of 125 microg/m(2) was delivered daily for 14 days followed by 14 days of rest. Treatment cycles continued for 1 year or until disease recurrence. Patients were evaluated for toxicity and disease-free and overall survival.

RESULTS

Overall and disease-free survival were significantly prolonged in patients who received GM-CSF compared with matched historical controls. The median survival duration was 37.5 months in the study patients versus 12.2 months in the matched controls (P <.001). GM-CSF was well tolerated; only one subject discontinued drug due to an adverse event (grade 2 injection site reaction).

CONCLUSION

GM-CSF may provide an antitumor effect that prolongs survival and disease-free survival in patients with stage III and IV melanoma who are clinically disease-free. These results support institution of a prospective, randomized clinical trial to definitively determine the value of surgical adjuvant therapy with GM-CSF in such patients.

Immunology and immunotherapy of human cancer: present concepts and clinical developments

Immunotherapy of cancer is entering into a new phase of active investigation both at the pre-clinical and clinical level. This is due to the exciting developments in basic immunology and tumour biology that have allowed a tremendous increase in our understanding of mechanisms of interactions between the immune system and tumour cells. This review briefly summarizes the state of the art in basic tumour immunology before discussing the clinical applications of the new concepts in the clinical setting. Clinical approaches are diverse but can now be based on strong scientific rationales. The analysis of the available clinical results suggests that, despite some disappointments, there is room for optimism that both active immunotherapy (vaccination) and adoptive immunotherapy may soon become part of the therapeutic arsenal to combat cancer in a more efficient way.

Melanoma. A multidisciplinary approach for the general surgeon

Advances in the understanding of the biology and treatment of melanoma have moved the care of melanoma patients into an increasingly multidisciplinary environment. Surgeons must understand these advances because they will often be responsible for directing the overall care of these patients. Most patients with melanomas more than 1 mm in diameter and no evidence of metastatic disease should be offered SLNB to more accurately stage them and direct decisions about participation in postoperative adjuvant therapy trials. Until the results of the MSLT are known, the effect of SLNB and ELND on outcome remains unknown. SLNs should be analyzed with serial sectioning and immunohistochemistry to avoid missing micro-metastatic disease. Based on the results of the ECOG-1684 trial, the FDA approved IFN-alpha 2b for the adjuvant treatment of melanoma patients with thick primary tumors (> 4 mm) or resected nodal disease. IFN-alpha 2b treatment is expensive and potentially toxic. The data from ECOG-1684 do not support the use of IFN-alpha 2b in patients with node-negative disease. In light of the ECOG-1690 trial results, the role of high-dose IFN-alpha 2b in the management of patients with resected nodal disease is considerably less clear. Any recommendations for treatment with high-dose IFN-alpha 2b should be made only after weighing the costs, side effects, and potential benefits for individual patients. Numerous, less toxic, promising, adjuvant immunotherapeutic strategies have been developed and are being tested in multicenter, prospective, randomized trials. These strategies include GMK, PMCV, and Melacine. If the results of any of these trials show a survival advantage compared with placebo or equivalent survival compared with IFN-alpha 2b, these immunotherapeutic agents will become the adjuvant treatment of choice for patients with resected high-risk melanoma. RT-PCR detection of tyrosinase in SLNs can identify patients with submicroscopic nodal disease who may be at increased risk for recurrence or death from melanoma. An ongoing, prospective, randomized trial will determine whether patients with histologically negative but RT-PCR-positive SLNs will benefit from lymphadenectomy or adjuvant IFN-alpha 2b therapy. RT-PCR can also identify minimal residual disease in peripheral blood and bone marrow from patients with high-risk melanoma, but RT-PCR analysis of peripheral blood and bone marrow is still experimental, and procedural details need to be standardized and prospectively validated in large patient groups before its use can be considered the standard of care.

New approaches to the systemic treatment of melanoma

Metastatic melanoma is an incurable condition with a median survival of about 6 months. Chemotherapy can result in objective tumour responses but only in a minority of cases and remissions are short-lived, 3-6 months. DTJC is the most active single agent with response rates of 15-20% and although combination chemotherapy can result in higher response rates there is no response duration or survival advantage. Phase II studies have suggested that combining chemotherapy with biological response modifiers may result in higher response rates, in the order of 50% and the results of two large randomized trials investigating this approach are awaited. Adjuvant trials currently focus on interferon and/or vaccine strategies. Further data are required before any adjuvant treatment can be regarded as standard.

Idiotype Vaccination in Human Myeloma: Generation of Tumor-Specific Immune Responses After High-Dose Chemotherapy

Igs contain unique portions, collectively termed idiotypes (Id), that can be recognized by the immune system. Id expressed by tumor cells in B-cell malignancies can be regarded as tumor-specific antigens and a target for vaccine immunotherapy. We have started a vaccination trial in multiple myeloma (MM) using Id-specific proteins conjugated to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) as immunogens and low doses of subcutaneous granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) or interleukin-2 (IL-2) as immunoadjuvants. Twelve patients who had previously been treated with high-dose chemotherapy followed by peripheral blood progenitor cell (PBPC) transplantation entered this study from August 1995 to January 1998. All patients were in first remission at the time of vaccination. They received subcutaneous injections of Id vaccines and immunoadjuvants in an outpatient setting. The generation of Id-specific T-cell proliferative responses was documented in 2 patients, whereas a positive Id-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reaction was observed in 8 of the 10 patients studied. DTH specificity was confirmed in 1 patient by investigating the reactivity to synthetic peptides derived from the VDJ sequence of the tumor-specific Ig heavy chain. None of the patients generated soluble immune responses to Id, whereas the generation of soluble and cellular immune responses to KLH was observed in 100% and 80%, respectively. Eleven patients completed the treatment, whereas 1 patient failed to finish owing to progression of disease. Freedom from disease progression (FFDP), measured from the date of first Id/KLH injection to the date of first treatment after vaccination or last follow-up, ranged from 9 to 36 months. These data indicate that the immune competence status of MM patients is still susceptible to specific immunization after high-dose chemotherapy and PBPC transplantation. It remains to be determined whether generation of Id-specific immune responses can reduce the relapse rate of patients with minimal residual disease.

Idiotype Vaccination in Human Myeloma: Generation of Tumor-Specific Immune Responses After High-Dose Chemotherapy

Igs contain unique portions, collectively termed idiotypes (Id), that can be recognized by the immune system. Id expressed by tumor cells in B-cell malignancies can be regarded as tumor-specific antigens and a target for vaccine immunotherapy. We have started a vaccination trial in multiple myeloma (MM) using Id-specific proteins conjugated to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) as immunogens and low doses of subcutaneous granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) or interleukin-2 (IL-2) as immunoadjuvants. Twelve patients who had previously been treated with high-dose chemotherapy followed by peripheral blood progenitor cell (PBPC) transplantation entered this study from August 1995 to January 1998. All patients were in first remission at the time of vaccination. They received subcutaneous injections of Id vaccines and immunoadjuvants in an outpatient setting. The generation of Id-specific T-cell proliferative responses was documented in 2 patients, whereas a positive Id-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reaction was observed in 8 of the 10 patients studied. DTH specificity was confirmed in 1 patient by investigating the reactivity to synthetic peptides derived from the VDJ sequence of the tumor-specific Ig heavy chain. None of the patients generated soluble immune responses to Id, whereas the generation of soluble and cellular immune responses to KLH was observed in 100% and 80%, respectively. Eleven patients completed the treatment, whereas 1 patient failed to finish owing to progression of disease. Freedom from disease progression (FFDP), measured from the date of first Id/KLH injection to the date of first treatment after vaccination or last follow-up, ranged from 9 to 36 months. These data indicate that the immune competence status of MM patients is still susceptible to specific immunization after high-dose chemotherapy and PBPC transplantation. It remains to be determined whether generation of Id-specific immune responses can reduce the relapse rate of patients with minimal residual disease.

Gene therapy with autologous, interleukin 2-secreting tumor cells in patients with malignant melanoma

We vaccinated metastatic melanoma patients with irradiated, autologous melanoma cells genetically engineered to secrete interleukin 2 (IL-2) to investigate whether an anti-tumor immune response would be induced. Melanoma cell cultures were established from surgical specimens and were engineered to secrete IL-2 by infection with recombinant retrovirus. Twelve patients were vaccinated subcutaneously one, two, or three times with approximately 10(7) irradiated, autologous, IL-2-secreting tumor cells. Treatment was well tolerated, with local reactions at 11 of 24 injection sites and minor systemic symptoms of fever and headache after 6 injections. One patient developed anti-tumor DTH after the first vaccination and showed an increased response after the second vaccination. Anti-autologous tumor CTLs could be detected prevaccination in the peripheral blood of seven patients and their activity increased after vaccination in four patients. No UICC-defined clinical responses were seen, but three patients had stable disease for 7-15 months, one of whom has not yet progressed (15+ months). Thus, patient vaccination with autologous, genetically engineered tumor cells is feasible and safe. Anti-tumor DTH and CTLs can be induced in some patients with such a vaccine.

Cancer vaccines with emphasis on a viral oncolysate melanoma vaccine

Biotherapy of malignant diseases has become the fourth treatment modality besides surgery, chemo- and radiotherapy. Whole cell melanoma vaccines with or without BCG and other adjuvants, purified ganglioside and shed antigens, recombinant viruses carrying tumor antigens, dendritic cells pulsed with antigenic peptides etc. are in clinical trials. Efficacious viral oncolysate vaccines induce the host to mount tumor-specific cytotoxic T-cell response and prevention of relapses is supported by clinical trials. The use of "polyvalent" whole cell vaccines vs. purified or genetically engineered single antigen vaccines is justified as i. only very few single tumor antigens are present in all tumors of a given histological type; and ii. antigen modulation occurs in tumors rendering them resistant to immune attack generated by vaccine against a single antigen. Thus polyvalent vaccines immunize against several antigens vs. against a selected antigen.

Immunotherapy of metastatic malignant melanoma by a vaccine consisting of autologous interleukin 2-transfected cancer cells: outcome of a phase I study

We performed a phase I trial to evaluate the safety and tolerability of repeated skin injections of IL-2-transfected autologous melanoma cells into patients with advanced disease. Cell suspensions, propagated from excised metastases, were IL-2 gene transfected by adenovirus-enhanced transferrinfection and X-irradiated prior to injection. Vaccine production was successful in 54% of the patients. Fifteen patients (37%) received two to eight skin vaccinations of either 3 x 10(6) (intradermal) or 1 x 10(7) (half intradermal, half subcutaneous) transfected melanoma cells per vaccination (secreting 140-17,060 biological response modifier program units of IL-2/10(6) cells/24 hr). Analyses of safety and efficacy were carried out in 15 and 14 patients, respectively. Overall, the vaccine was well tolerated. All patients displayed modest local reactions (erythema, induration, and pruritus) and some experienced flu-like symptoms. Apart from newly appearing (4 of 14) and increasing (5 of 14) anti-adenovirus and newly detectable anti-nuclear antibody titers (1 of 15), recipients developed de novo or exhibited increased melanoma cell-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reactions (8 of 15) and vitiligo (3 of 15) and showed signs of tumor regression (3 of 15). This supports the idea of a vaccine-induced or -amplified anti-cancer immune response. None of the patients exhibited complete or partial regressions, but five of them experienced periods of disease stabilization. Three of these individuals received more than the four planned vaccinations and their mean survival time was 15.7 +/- 3.5 months as compared to 7.8 +/- 4.6 months for the entire patient cohort. These data indicate that IL-2-producing, autologous cancer cells can be safely administered to stage IV melanoma patients and could conceivably be of benefit to patients with less advanced disease.

Clinical implications of the new biology in the development of melanoma vaccines

There has been a resurgence in clinical research of vaccine therapies, particularly for the treatment of melanoma. The renewed interest in this field is attributable to an increased understanding regarding the immune response to tumors and the immunobiology of melanoma. Molecular biology techniques have enabled investigators to develop genetically engineered tumor vaccines that are intended to favor the type 1 immune response over the type 2 response. Melanoma-associated antigens have been characterized at the molecular level and are currently being investigated in clinical trials. Dendritic cell biology has also provided a potent method to present antigens to the host for immunization. Lastly, vaccines are being explored as a method to generate immune T-cells for adoptive immunotherapy. These new areas of clinical investigation will be reviewed in the context of the historical developments that have laid the foundations of this field.

Advances in cancer vaccine development

Traditionally, cancer vaccines have used whole tumour cells administered in adjuvant or infected with viruses to increase the immunogenicity of the cells. With the identification of tumour-associated and tumour-specific antigens (TAA, TSA), antigen and epitope-specific vaccines have been designed. Compared to tumour cell vaccines, antigen and epitope vaccines are more specific and easier to produce in large quantities but may display lower immunogenicity and lead to the in vivo selection of antigen or epitope-negative escape tumour variant cells. The optimal vaccine will elicit both humoral and cellular immunity in the patients as both parameters have been positively correlated with the induction of beneficial clinical responses. The choice of adjuvant, costimulation and delivery mode greatly determines the outcome of vaccinations and may favour the induction of T-cell responses of T helper (Th)1, Th2, or both Th1 and Th2 types. Animal models of TAA vaccines must take into account the normal tissue expression of TAA, which may induce immunological tolerance to TAA. With the identification of homologues of human TAA in animals, novel experimental models of cancer vaccines which mimic the condition in patients are now available. Several vaccines comprising tumour cells, TAA or anti-idiotypic antibodies mimicking TAA have recently entered phase III of clinical evaluation.

Vaccination with irradiated autologous melanoma cells engineered to secrete human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor generates potent antitumor immunity in patients with metastatic melanoma

We conducted a Phase I clinical trial investigating the biologic activity of vaccination with irradiated autologous melanoma cells engineered to secrete human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor in patients with metastatic melanoma. Immunization sites were intensely infiltrated with T lymphocytes, dendritic cells, macrophages, and eosinophils in all 21 evaluable patients. Although metastatic lesions resected before vaccination were minimally infiltrated with cells of the immune system in all patients, metastatic lesions resected after vaccination were densely infiltrated with T lymphocytes and plasma cells and showed extensive tumor destruction (at least 80%), fibrosis, and edema in 11 of 16 patients examined. Antimelanoma cytotoxic T cell and antibody responses were associated with tumor destruction. These results demonstrate that vaccination with irradiated autologous melanoma cells engineered to secrete granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor stimulates potent antitumor immunity in humans with metastatic melanoma.

Long-term disease-free survival following surgery and active specific immunotherapy with allogeneic vaccine in a patient with high-risk malignant melanoma of the vulva

Vulvar malignant melanoma with deep vertical penetration of the tumor and involvement of regional lymph nodes carries a very poor prognosis. The case of a 25-year-old woman with a history of a Breslow depth 6.0 mm and Clark Level IV primary vulvar malignant melanoma, involving the anterior part of the left labium major, 1 cm from the clitoris, is reported. The patient had undergone a left radical hemivulvectomy and bilateral groin dissection. There were two of thirteen superficial left groin nodes containing metastatic melanoma. The patient had been treated postoperatively with an allogeneic specific anti-melanoma vaccine in combination with high-dose cimetidine and has survived without disease for more than five years. To the best of our knowledge this is the first case report in the literature of active specific immunotherapy with allogeneic vaccine in vulvar malignant melanoma. This case illustrates that the behavior of malignant melanoma, including vulvar malignant melanoma, is unpredictable and active specific immunotherapy with allogeneic vaccine may have a role in the postoperative treatment of high risk vulvar malignant melanoma.

Dinitrophenyl-modified autologous melanoma vaccine induces a T cell response to hapten-modified, melanoma peptides

Active specific immunotherapy with dinitrophenyl (DNP)-modified autologous melanoma vaccine elicits inflammatory responses in metastatic tumor sites. Postsurgical adjuvant immunotherapy with this vaccine prolongs survival in stage III melanoma patients. We have reported that, after administration of DNP-modified melanoma vaccine, T cell responses to DNP-modified autologous tumor cells are demonstrable in vivo and in vitro. These responses are hapten specific and MHC restricted. To elucidate this phenomenon, we investigated the immune response to DNP-modified peptides eluted from autologous cells. Short peptides were extracted from DNP-modified and unmodified autologous melanoma cells by an acid elution technique and HPLC fractionation. Peptides were also extracted from DNP-modified and unmodified, EB virus-transformed, autologous B lymphoblasts. These various peptide fractions were loaded onto autologous B lymphoblasts and tested for ability to elicit a response by a DNP-specific T cell line as measured by IFN-gamma production. Unexpectedly, stimulatory activity of peptides from DNP-modified melanoma cells was confined to a single HPLC fraction. Spectrometric analysis of this fraction confirmed modification of peptides with DNP. A weaker T cell response was observed to a single HPLC fraction of DNP-modified peptides from the patient's B lymphoblasts. No T cell response was elicited by corresponding fractions of peptides eluted from unmodified melanoma cells or B lymphoblasts. These findings demonstrate the human T cell response to DNP-modified autologous melanoma cells is mediated by hapten-modified, MHC-associated peptides. Further investigation of these peptides could lead to a new strategy for peptide-based cancer immunotherapy.