Cellular contacts required for neural induction in Xenopus embryos: evidence for two signals

Later embryogenesis: regulatory circuitry in morphogenetic fields

The subject of this review is the nature of regulatory processes underlying the spatial subdivision of morphogenetic regions in later embryogenesis. I have applied a non-classical definition of morphogenetic field, the progenitor field, which is a region of an embryo composed of cells whose progeny will constitute a given morphological structure. An important feature of such fields is that they have sharp spatial boundaries, across which lie cells whose progeny will express different fates. Two examples of the embryonic specification and development of such fields are considered. These are the formation of the archenteron in the sea urchin embryo and the formation of dorsal axial mesoderm in the Xenopus embryo. From these and a number of additional examples, from vertebrate, Drosophila, Caenorhabditis elegans and sea urchin embryos, it is concluded that the initial formation of the boundaries of morphogenetic progenitor fields depends on both positive and negative transcription control functions. Specification of morphogenetic progenitor fields, organization of the boundaries and their subsequent regionalization or subdivision are mediated by intercellular signaling. Genes encoding regionally expressed transcription factors that are activated in response to intercell signaling, and that in turn mediate signaling changes downstream, appear as fundamental regulatory circuit elements. Such [signal-->transcription factor gene-->signal] circuit elements appear to be utilized, often repetitively, in many different morphogenetic processes.

Zebrafish primary neurons initiate expression of the LIM homeodomain protein Isl-1 at the end of gastrulation

Isl-1 has previously been established as the earliest marker of developing chicken spinal motor neurons where it is regulated by inductive signals from the floorplate and notochord. We now report that, in zebrafish, the expression of Isl-1 is initiated in Rohon-Beard cells, primary motor neurons, interneurons and cranial ganglia, hours before the neural tube itself is formed. The expression is initiated simultaneously in the Rohon-Beard cells and the primary motor neurons, at the axial level of the presumptive first somite. The Isl-1-expressing motor neurons appear on either side of the ventral midline whereas the interneurons and Rohon-Beard cells initiate expression while located at the edge of the germinal shield. Isl-1 expression is initiated in these cells before the formation of a differentiated notochord. Isl-1 is expressed in the various functional classes of primary neurons at 24 hours postfertilization. This selective expression of a homeodomain protein in the primary neurons implies that these neurons share a common program of early development and that they have evolved and been selected for as a coordinated system. One of the functions of the primary neurons is to send long axons which pioneer the major axon tracts in the zebrafish embryo. An evolutionary conserved functional role for Isl-1 in the expression of the pioneering phenotype of the primary neurons is suggested.

Expression of an extracellular deletion of Xotch diverts cell fate in Xenopus embryos

Xotch is a Xenopus homolog of Notch, a receptor involved in cell fate decisions in Drosophila. Using an extracellular deletion construct, Xotch delta E, we show that Xotch has a similar role in Xenopus embryos. Broad expression causes the loss of dorsal structures and the expansion and disorganization of the brain. Single blastomere injections of Xotch delta E induce autonomous neural and mesodermal hypertrophy, even in the absence of cell division. Xotch delta E inhibits the early expression of epidermal and neural crest markers yet enhances and extends the response of animal caps to mesodermal and neural induction. Our data suggest a mechanism for the function of Notch homologs in which they delay differentiation and leave undetermined cells competent to respond to later inductive signals.

The mouse NCAM gene displays a biphasic expression pattern during neural tube development

The neural cell adhesion molecule (NCAM) is one of the most abundant cell adhesion molecules expressed in vertebrates and it is thought to play important roles as a regulator of morphogenetic processes, but little is known of its expression pattern in mammalian embryos. In this study, we have examined the developmental profile of NCAM gene expression in mouse embryos from gestational day 7.5 to 12.5, focusing on the developing neural tube. NCAM transcripts were first detected around day 8.5 in the somites and the forming neural tube. At this stage, NCAM transcripts were expressed in the neuroepithelium throughout the width of the neural groove and tube up to a rostral boundary within the hindbrain, whereas NCAM mRNA levels were very low or undetectable in the neuroepithelium of the head region. The positional restriction of NCAM expression was confirmed by immunohistochemistry at the protein, and by polymerase chain reaction analysis at the RNA level. Expression in the neuroepithelium was transient as the level of NCAM transcripts declined in the germinal layer beyond day 8.5. By day 9.5, strong NCAM expression had appeared on the earliest postmitotic neurones along the entire neuraxis, and this pattern of expression in all regions with differentiating neurones was maintained until day 12.5. We conclude that NCAM expression in the neural tube occurs in two spatiotemporal distinct waves: a first wave in the proliferating neuroepithelium showing positional dependence along the rostrocaudal axis, and a second wave on essentially all neurones that have become postmitotic.

Evidence that the border of the neural plate may be positioned by the interaction between signals that induce ventral and dorsal mesoderm

In the early Xenopus embryo, a quadrant of endodermal cells that have descended from the vegetal dorsal localization in the zygote produces signals that pass into the animal hemisphere and induce dorsal mesoderm from the marginal zone. From the remaining three quadrants of the bordering endoderm, signals pass into the animal hemisphere and induce ventral mesoderm in the marginal region. There is evidence that suggests that these same mesoderm-inducing signals continue through the plane of the tissue of the animal hemisphere where they may at least begin the processes of neural and epidermal induction by changing the competence of the prospective ectodermal cells, and possibly influencing the early regional biasing of later expression of at least some gene products, such as Epi-1 whose expression in the future epidermal domain seems specified before gastrulation. We hypothesized that the interaction of the ventral and dorsal signals within the plane of the tissue of the animal hemisphere may position the border of the neural plate. If this is so, then transplantation into the animal pole of cells that signal induction of ventral mesoderm should drive the neural plate boundary back toward the blastopore and shorten the anterior-posterior axis. Removal of cells that induce ventral mesoderm should result in an axis that is longer than normal. Results of our experiments support these predictions. Also, by late pregastrula stage 9, increasing the ventral signals has no effect. Thus the evidence suggests that the position of the anterior neural plate boundary is established before gastrulation begins by the interaction of the signals that induce the ventral and dorsal mesoderm.

Expression of Pax-3- and neuroectoderm-inducing activities during differentiation of P19 embryonal carcinoma cells

A P19 embryonal carcinoma stem cell line carrying an insertion of the E. coli LacZ gene in an endogenous copy of the Pax-3 gene was identified. Expression of the Pax-3/LacZ fusion gene in neuroectodermal and mesodermal lineages following induction of differentiation by chemical treatments (retinoic acid and dimethylsulfoxide) was characterized using this line and is consistent with the previous localization of Pax-3 expression in the embryo to mitotically active cells of the dorsal neuroectoderm and the adjacent segmented dermomyotome. Pax-3/LacZ marked stem cells were also utilized as target cells in mixing experiments with unmarked P19 cells that had been differentiated by pretreatment with chemical inducers. Induction of beta-galactosidase and neuroectodermal markers in the target cells demonstrates that: (1) some differentiated P19 cell derivatives transiently express endogenous Pax-3- and neuroectoderm-inducing activities, (2) undifferentiated target stem cells respond to these activities even in the presence of leukemia inhibitory factor and (3) the endogenous activities can be distinguished from, and are more potent than, retinoic acid treatment in inducing neuroectoderm. These observations demonstrate that P19 embryonal carcinoma cells provide a useful in vitro system for analysis of the cellular interactions responsible for neuroectoderm induction in mammals.

Molecular mechanisms of pattern formation in the vertebrate hindbrain

During early stages of neural development a series of repeated bulges, termed rhombomeres, form in the vertebrate hindbrain. Studies in the chick have shown that rhombomeres are segments that underlie the patterning of nerves in the hindbrain, and this raises the question of the molecular basis of segment development. Several genes have been found with expression patterns consistent with roles in the formation or differentiation of rhombomeres. The zinc finger gene Krox-20 is expressed in two alternating rhombomeres, r3 and r5, in the mouse hindbrain; these stripes of gene expression are established prior to the morphological appearance of segments. Krox-20 is also expressed in this pattern in the chick and Xenopus, suggesting that it has a conserved role, possibly in the formation of rhombomeres. Four members of the Hox-2 homeobox gene cluster have limits of expression at rhombomere boundaries. Three genes, Hox-2.6, -2.7 and -2.8 have progressively more anterior limits of expression at two-segment intervals, whereas expression of Hox-2.9 is restricted to one rhombomere, r4. The Hox-2 genes are expressed in spatially restricted patterns in early neural crest cells. These findings suggest that the Hox genes have roles in specifying the identity of rhombomeres and of neural crest.

Pintallavis, a gene expressed in the organizer and midline cells of frog embryos: involvement in the development of the neural axis

We have identified a novel frog gene, Pintallavis (the Catalan for lipstick), that is related to the fly fork head and rat HNF-3 genes. Pintallavis is expressed in the organizer region of gastrula embryos as a direct zygotic response to dorsal mesodermal induction. Subsequently, Pintallavis is expressed in axial midline cells of all three germ layers. In axial mesoderm expression is graded with highest levels posteriorly. Midline neural plate cells that give rise to the floor plate transiently express Pintallavis, apparently in response to induction by the notochord. Overexpression of Pintallavis perturbs the development of the neural axis, suppressing the differentiation of anterior and dorsal neural cell types but causing an expansion of the posterior neural tube. Our results suggest that Pintallavis functions in the induction and patterning of the neural axis.

Regional differences in retinoid release from embryonic neural tissue detected by an in vitro reporter assay

Retinoic acid and related retinoids have been suggested to contribute to the pattern of cell differentiation during vertebrate embryonic development. To identify cell groups that release morphogenetically active retinoids, we have developed a reporter assay that makes use of a retinoic acid inducible response element (RARE) to drive lacZ or luciferase reporter genes in stably transfected cell lines. This reporter gene assay allows detection of retinoids released from embryonic tissues over a range equivalent to that induced by femtomole amounts of retinoic acid. We have used this assay first to determine whether the floor plate, a cell group that has polarizing properties in neural tube and limb bud differentiation, is a local source of retinoids within the spinal cord. We have also examined whether the effects of exogenously administered retinoic acid on anteroposterior patterning of cells in the developing central nervous system correlate with differences in retinoid release from anterior and posterior neural tissue. We find that the release of morphogenetically active retinoids from the floor plate is only about 1.5-fold that of the dorsal spinal cord, which does not have neural tube or limb polarizing activity. These results suggest that the spatial distribution of retinoid release from spinal cord tissues differs from that of the neural and limb polarizing activity. This assay has also shown that retinoids are released from the embryonic spinal cord at much greater levels than from the forebrain. This result, together with previous observations that the development of forebrain structures is suppressed by low concentrations of retinoic acid, suggest that the normal development of forebrain structures is dependent on the maintenance of low concentrations of retinoids in anterior regions of the embryonic axis. This assay has also provided initial evidence that other embryonic tissues with polarizing properties in vivo release retinoids in vitro.

Planar and vertical signals in the induction and patterning of the Xenopus nervous system

The cellular mechanisms responsible for the formation of the Xenopus nervous system have been examined in total exogastrula embryos in which the axial mesoderm appears to remain segregated from prospective neural ectoderm and in recombinates of ectoderm and mesoderm. Posterior neural tissue displaying anteroposterior pattern develops in exogastrula ectoderm. This effect may be mediated by planar signals that occur in the absence of underlying mesoderm. The formation of a posterior neural tube may depend on the notoplate, a midline ectodermal cell group which extends along the anteroposterior axis. The induction of neural structures characteristic of the forebrain and of cell types normally found in the ventral region of the posterior neural tube requires additional vertical signals from underlying axial mesoderm. Thus, the formation of the embryonic Xenopus nervous system appears to involve the cooperation of distinct planar and vertical signals derived from midline cell groups.

Planar induction of anteroposterior pattern in the developing central nervous system of Xenopus laevis

It has long been thought that anteroposterior (A-P) pattern in the vertebrate central nervous system is induced in the embryo's dorsal ectoderm exclusively by signals passing vertically from underlying, patterned dorsal mesoderm. Explants from early gastrulae of the frog Xenopus laevis were prepared in which vertical contact between dorsal ectoderm and mesoderm was prevented but planar contact was maintained. In these, four position-specific neural markers (engrailed-2, Krox-20, XlHbox 1, and XlHbox 6) were expressed in the ectoderm in the same A-P order as in the embryo. Thus, planar signals alone, following a path available in the normal embryo, can induce A-P neural pattern.

Developmental expression of the Xenopus int-2 (FGF-3) gene: activation by mesodermal and neural induction

We have used a probe specific for the Xenopus homologue of the mammalian proto-oncogene int-2 (FGF-3) to examine the temporal and spatial expression pattern of the gene during Xenopus development. int-2 is expressed from just before the onset of gastrulation through to prelarval stages. In the early gastrula, it is expressed around the blastopore lip. This is maintained in the posterior third of the prospective mesoderm and neuroectoderm in the neurula. A second expression domain in the anterior third of the neuroectoderm alone appears in the late gastrula, which later resolves into the optic vesicles, hypothalamus and midbrain-hindbrain junction region. Further domains of expression arise in tailbud to prelarval embryos, including the stomodeal mesenchyme, the endoderm of the pharyngeal pouches and the cranial ganglia flanking the otocyst. It is shown, by treatment of blastula ectoderm with bFGF and activin, that int-2 can be expressed in response to mesoderm induction. By heterotypic grafting of gastrula ectoderm into axolotl neural plate, we have also demonstrated that int-2 can be expressed in response to neural induction. These results suggest that int-2 has multiple functions in development, including an early role in patterning of the anteroposterior body axis and a later role in the development of the tail, brain-derived structures and other epithelia.

The LIM domain-containing homeo box gene Xlim-1 is expressed specifically in the organizer region of Xenopus gastrula embryos

A novel cysteine-rich motif, named LIM, has been identified in the homeo box genes lin-11, Isl-1, and mec-3; the mec-3 and lin-11 genes determine cell lineages in Caenorhabditis elegans. We isolated LIM class homeo box genes from Xenopus laevis that are closely related to lin-11 and mec-3 in the LIM and homeo domains. This paper deals with one of these genes, Xlim-1. Xlim-1 mRNA is found at low abundance in the unfertilized egg, has a major expression phase at the gastrula stage, decreases, and rises again during the tadpole stage. In adult tissues the brain shows the highest abundance, by far, of Xlim-1 mRNA. The maternal and late expression phases of the Xlim-1 gene suggest that it has multiple functions at different stages of the Xenopus life cycle. In the gastrula embryo, Xlim-1 mRNA is localized in the dorsal lip and the dorsal mesoderm, that is, in the region of Spemann's organizer. Explant experiments showed that Xlim-1 mRNA is induced by the mesoderm-inducer activin A and by retinoic acid, which is not a mesoderm inducer but affects patterning during Xenopus embryogenesis; application of activin A and retinoic acid together results in synergistic induction. The structure, inducibility, and localized expression in the organizer of the Xlim-1 gene suggest that it has a role in establishing body pattern during gastrulation.

Changes in dorsoventral but not rostrocaudal regionalization of the chick neural tube in the absence of cranial notochord, as revealed by expression of engrailed-2

Notochord has been implicated in previous studies in both the dorsoventral and rostrocaudal patterning of the developing neural tube. This possibility has been further explored by analyzing the expression of Engrailed-2 in chick embryos developing with cranial notochord defects. Control embryos containing intact notochords expressed Engrailed-2 protein within the neural tube and in a subset of the neural crest and overlying surface ectoderm at the future mesencephalon and cranial metencephalon levels. Within the neural tube, expression was confined to cell nuclei in the roof plate and lateral walls; floor plate nuclei directly overlying the notochord typically failed to show expression. After surgical removal of Hensen's node, the source of notochord precursor cells, embryos were cultured through neurulation and assayed for expression of Engrailed-2 protein. All embryos that partially or completely lacked cranial notochord expressed Engrailed-2 in a pattern similar to that of control embryos containing intact notochords, except that when notochord and floor plate were absent, Engrailed-2 was also expressed in the most ventral part of the neural tube. These results indicate that 1) Engrailed-2 expression is suppressed in the most ventral neural tube owing to induction of the floor plate by the notochord, and 2) that the presence of an underlying notochord is not required for correct rostrocaudal expression, suggesting that multiple pathways act in the patterning of the rudiment of the central nervous system.

The cellular basis of the convergence and extension of the Xenopus neural plate

There is great interest in the patterning and morphogenesis of the vertebrate nervous system, but the morphogenetic movements involved in early neural development and their underlying cellular mechanisms are poorly understood. This paper describes the cellular basis of the early neural morphogenesis of Xenopus laevis. The results have important implications for neural induction. Mapping the fate map of the midneurula (Eagleson and Harris: J. Neurobiol. 21:427-440, 1990) back to the early gastrula with time-lapse video recording demonstrates that the prospective hindbrain and spinal cord are initially very wide and very short, and thus at the beginning of gastrulation all their precursor cells lie within a few cell diameters of the inducing mesoderm. In the midgastrula, the prospective hindbrain and spinal cord undergo very strong convergence and extension movements in two phases: In the first phase they primarily undergo thinning in the radial direction and lengthening (extension) in the animal-vegetal direction, and the second phase is characterized primarily by mediolateral narrowing (convergence) and anterior-posterior lengthening (extension). These movements also occur in sandwich explants of the gastrula, thus demonstrating the local autonomy of the forces producing them. Tracing cell movements with fluorescein dextran-labeled cells in embryos or explants shows that the initial thinning and extension occurs by radial intercalation of deep cells to form fewer layers of greater area, all of which is expressed as increased length. The subsequent convergence and extension occurs by mediolateral intercalation of deep cells to form a longer, narrower array. These results establish that a similar if not identical sequence of radial and mediolateral cell intercalations underlie convergence and extension of the neural and the mesoderm tissues (Wilson and Keller: Development, 112:289-300, 1991). Moreover, these results establish that radial and mediolateral intercalation are the principal neural cell behaviors induced by the planar signals emanating from the dorsal involuting marginal zone (the Spemann organizer) in the early gastrula (Keller et al: Develop. Dynamics, 193: 218-234, 1992). Radial and mediolateral intercalation are induced among the 5 to 7 rows of cells comprising the prospective hindbrain and spinal cord, thus producing the massive convergence and extension movements that narrow and elongate these regions of the nervous system in the late gastrula. A more general significance of these results is that neural induction is best analyzed and understood in terms of the dynamics of the morphogenetic processes involved.

Planar induction of convergence and extension of the neural plate by the organizer of Xenopus

This paper demonstrates that convergence and extension within the neural plate of Xenopus laevis are regulated by planar inductive interactions with the adjacent Spemann organizer. The companion article (Keller et al.: Developmental Dynamics 193:199-217, 1992) showed that the prospective hindbrain and spinal cord occupy a very short and very wide area just above the Spemann organizer in the early gastrula and that these regions converge and extend greatly during gastrulation and neurulation, using a sequence of radial and mediolateral cell intercalations. In this article, we show that "planar" contact of these regions with the organizer at their vegetal edge until stage 11 is sufficient to induce convergence and extension, after which their convergence and extension become autonomous. Grafts of the organizer in planar contact with uninduced ectodermal tissues induce these ectodermal tissues to converge and extend by a planar inductive signal from the organizer. Labeling of the inducing or responding tissues confirms that only planar interactions occur. Neural convergence and extension are actually hindered in explants deliberately constructed so that vertical interactions occur. These results show unambiguously that the Spemann organizer induces the extraordinary and precocious convergence and extension movements of the Xenopus neural plate by planar interactions acting over short distances.

Mesodermal control of neural cell identity in vertebrates

It has long been appreciated that the differentiation and patterning of neural cells is controlled in part by inductive signals from the mesoderm. Several recent experiments have revealed that distinct mesodermal signals act throughout early neural development and have begun to address the nature and sources of such signals.

Molecular nature of Spemann's organizer: the role of the Xenopus homeobox gene goosecoid

This study analyzes the function of the homeobox gene goosecoid in Xenopus development. First, we find that goosecoid mRNA distribution closely mimics the expected localization of organizer tissue in normal embryos as well as in those treated with LiCl and UV light. Second, goosecoid mRNA accumulation is induced by activin, even in the absence of protein synthesis. It is not affected by bFGF and is repressed by retinoic acid. Lastly, microinjection of goosecoid mRNA into the ventral side of Xenopus embryos, where goosecoid is normally absent, leads to the formation of an additional complete body axis, including head structures and abundant notochordal tissue. The results suggest that the goosecoid homeodomain protein plays a central role in executing Spemann's organizer phenomenon.

Role of the midline glia and neurons in the formation of the axon commissures in the central nervous system of the Drosophila embryo

A row of midline precursor cells separates the two lateral neurogenic regions that give rise to most of the Drosophila CNS. From these midline precursors arises a discrete set of special glia and neurons. The growth cones of many CNS neurons initially head straight towards the midline and change their behavior after traversing it, leading to the hypothesis that these midline cells play a key role in the formation of the axon commissures. We have used a variety of cellular and molecular genetic techniques to elucidate the cells and interactions, including specific cell migrations, that are important for the normal formation of the two major commissures in each segment. This cellular analysis has led to a model that proposes a series of sequential cell interactions controlling the three stages in commissure development: (1) formation of the posterior commissure, (2) formation of the anterior commissure, and (3) separation of the two commissures. An initial genetic test of this model has used a number of mutations that, by either eliminating or altering the differentiation of various midline cells, perturb the development of the axon commissures in a predictable manner.

Neuroectoderm in Drosophila embryos is dependent on the mesoderm for positioning but not for formation

By studying neuroectoderm formation in the absence of mesoderm and mesectoderm in mutants of the zygotic genes snail and twist, we have found that the number of neuroblasts is not reduced in these mutants, suggesting that mesoderm and mesectoderm are not essential for the initiation of neural development. The position of the neuroectoderm, however, is ventrally shifted: Neuroectoderm takes over the presumptive peripheral mesoderm domain in single mutants, whereas the entire presumptive mesoderm domain in double mutants takes on the neuroectodermal fate. The shifted neuroectoderm still requires the proneural genes and the neurogenic genes. This shift is unlikely to be due to any shift in the nuclear localization gradient of the maternally supplied dorsal protein. A model for cell fate determination of the neuroectoderm, mesectoderm, and mesoderm will be discussed.

Homeogenetic neural induction in Xenopus

Neural induction is known to involve an interaction of ectoderm with dorsal mesoderm during gastrulation, but several kinds of studies have argued that competent ectoderm can also be neutralized via an interaction with previously neuralized tissue, a process termed homeogenetic neural induction. Although homeogenetic neural induction has been proposed to play an important role in the normal induction of neural tissue, this process has not been subjected to detailed study using tissue recombinants and molecular markers. We have examined the question of homeogenetic neural induction in Xenopus embryos, both in transplant and recombinant experiments, using the expression of two neural antigens to assay the response. When ectoderm that is competent to be neuralized is transplanted to the region adjacent to the neural plate of early neurula embryos, it forms neural tissue, as assayed by staining with antibodies against the neural cell adhesion molecule, N-CAM. Transplants to the ventral region, far from the neural plate, do not express N-CAM, indicating that neuralization is not occurring as a result of the transplantation procedure itself. Because this response might be occurring as a result of interactions of ectoderm with either adjacent neural plate tissue, or with underlying dorsolateral mesoderm, recombinant experiments were performed to determine the source of the neuralizing signal. Ectoderm cultured in combination with neural plate tissue alone expresses neural markers, while ectoderm cultured in combination with dorsolateral mesoderm does not. We conclude that neural tissue can homeogenetically induce competent ectoderm to form neural tissue and argue that this induction occurs via planar signaling within the ectoderm, a mechanism that, in normal development, may be involved in interactions within presumptive neural ectoderm or in specifying structures that lie near the neural plate.

Inductive interactions in early embryonic development

This is an update of a previous review (Current Opinion in Cell Biology 2:969-974) in which we discussed recent work attempting to understand the sequence of inductive interactions responsible for establishing the body plan of the early embryo. As before, we concentrate on inductive interactions in amphibian embryos, where significant progress has been made in the past two years. In this update, however, we also consider recent embryological data obtained with amniote embryos such as the chick, together with complementary data provided by genetic analyses of mouse and Drosophila development.

Retinoic acid can mimic endogenous signals involved in transformation of the Xenopus nervous system

In the frog Xenopus laevis, signals from the mesoderm divert part of the ectoderm from an epidermal to a neural fate. In the course of neural induction, the neurectoderm also acquires anterior-posterior polarity. In this report, the early expression of two genes, XlHbox6 and the neurofilament gene XIF6, is examined. The pattern of expression of the two genes seen in the tailbud embryo develops progressively over a 4 hr period following gastrulation. Physiological concentrations of retinoic acid can mimic this effect in isolated embryonic explants, consistent with the involvement of retinoic acid, or a closely related molecule, in localizing gene expression along the anterior-posterior axis of the neural tube.

Pre-existent pattern in Xenopus animal pole cells revealed by induction with activin

Activin, a peptide growth factor related to tumour growth factor-beta, has been implicated in early inductive interactions in vertebrates and can induce Xenopus blastula ectodermal explants to develop a rudimentary axial pattern with anteroposterior and dorsoventral polarity. Here we demonstrate that prospective dorsal and ventral regions of the ectoderm respond differently to the same concentration of activin. Thus, activin does not seem to endow ectodermal cells with polarity but rather reveals a pre-existent pattern. Our results suggest that patterning of mesoderm is determined not only by a localized inducer, but also by the differential competence of cells in the responding tissue.

Pattern formation during animal development

At the beginning of this century, embryologists defined the central problems of developmental biology that remain today. These questions include how differentiated cells arise and form tissues and organs and how pattern is generated. In short, how does an egg give rise to an adult? In recent years, the application of molecular biology to embryological problems has led to significant advances and recast old problems in molecular and cellular terms. Although not necessarily comprehensive, this idiosyncratic review is intended to highlight selected findings and indicate where there are important gaps in our knowledge for those less than familiar with developmental biology.

Retinoic acid modifies mesodermal patterning in early Xenopus embryos

Treatment of early Xenopus embryos with retinoic acid (RA) produces a concentration-dependent series of defects in anterior axial structures that range from small deletions to embryos lacking heads. The graded series of axial defects obtained after RA administration to early embryos appears to result, in part, from actions of RA on embryonic mesoderm. RA modifies the differentiation of anterior dorsal mesoderm from animal cap ectoderm induced by mesoderm-inducing peptide growth factors (PGFs). Concentrations of RA that suppress anterior dorsal mesoderm result in the differentiation of mesoderm of more posterior or ventral character. The suppression of anterior dorsal mesoderm may account for the absence of anterior neural ectoderm after RA treatment. Although RA changes the character of mesoderm, it does not seem to affect mesodermal induction by PGFs or the levels of Xhox3 mRNA induced in the mesoderm by PGFs. RA therefore appears to affect steps downstream from those involved in the initial induction of mesoderm. In experiments to examine the possible physiological role of RA in early Xenopus development, dorsal and ventral ectoderm were found to respond differently to identical concentrations of PGFs. One potential basis for this heterogeneity is the existence of a localized inhibitor, possibly RA, in the early Xenopus embryo. RA could therefore contribute to axial patterning by inhibiting the development of mesoderm of different character induced by PGFs.

Regional neural induction in Xenopus laevis

During development of the Xenopus embryo, the formation of the nervous system depends on an inductive interaction between mesoderm and ectoderm. The result is a neural tube that is regionally differentiated along the anterior-posterior axis from forebrain to spinal cord. The discovery of genes whose transcripts can be used as molecular markers for different regions of the nervous system has permitted reassessment of the existing theories of neural tissue formation. Although the neural inducing molecules remain elusive, the mechanism by which cells interact to form a regionally differentiated nervous system is becoming clearer.

Mesodermal control of neural cell identity: floor plate induction by the notochord

The floor plate is a specialized group of midline neuroepithelial cells that appears to regulate cell differentiation and axonal growth in the developing vertebrate nervous system. A floor plate-specific chemoattractant was used as a marker to examine the role of the notochord in avian floor plate development. Expression of this chemoattractant in lateral cells of the neural plate and neural tube was induced by an ectopic notochord, and midline neural tube cells did not express the chemoattractant after removal of the notochord early in development. These results provide evidence that a local signal from the notochord induces the functional properties of the floor plate.

Region-specific neural induction of an engrailed protein by anterior notochord in Xenopus

Anterior-specific neural induction can be assayed by means of an antibody that recognizes the Xenopus homeobox-containing protein En-2. The En-2 antigen is an excellent early marker, since it is present as a discrete band in the anterior neural plate of neurula embryos. Regional induction was assayed by combining dorsal mesoderm with competent ectoderm. Anterior notochord from the early neurula induced En-2 frequently, while posterior notochord induced En-2 less frequently. Presumptive somitic mesoderm and presumptive head mesoderm, though they induced neural tissue, were not strong inducers of En-2. Thus, anterior notochord may be the primary mesodermal tissue responsible for the patterning of the anterior neural plate.

Graded changes in dose of a Xenopus activin A homologue elicit stepwise transitions in embryonic cell fate

The protein XTC-MIF, a Xenopus homologue of activin A and a potent mesoderm-inducing factor, can induce responding animal pole explants to form several different cell types in a dose-dependent manner, higher doses eliciting more dorso-anterior tissues. This graded response, characteristic of classically postulated morphogens, may underlie pattern formation, but the response of intact animal caps to XTC-MIF provides only a crude indication of trends. Here we report the effects of XTC-MIF on dispersed blastomeres rather than intact animal caps. Under these conditions, responding cells distinguish sharply between doses of pure XTC-MIF differing by less than 1.5-fold. Two different response thresholds have been found, defining three cell states. This suggests that XTC-MIF has an instructive effect. Notochord and muscle are both induced in the same narrow dose-range. Mixing treated with untreated cells does not seem to shift the dose thresholds, showing that at least some cells can stably record the received dose of inducing factor.

Xotch, the Xenopus homolog of Drosophila notch

During the development of a vertebrate embryo, cell fate is determined by inductive signals passing between neighboring tissues. Such determinative interactions have been difficult to characterize fully without knowledge of the molecular mechanisms involved. Mutations of Drosophila and the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans have been isolated that define a family of related gene products involved in similar types of cellular inductions. One of these genes, the Notch gene from Drosophila, is involved with cell fate choices in the neurogenic region of the blastoderm, in the developing nervous system, and in the eye-antennal imaginal disc. Complementary DNA clones were isolated from Xenopus embryos with Notch DNA in order to investigate whether cell-cell interactions in vertebrate embryos also depend on Notch-like molecules. This approach identified a Xenopus molecule, Xotch, which is remarkably similar to Drosophila Notch in both structure and developmental expression.

Early tissue interactions leading to embryonic lens formation in Xenopus laevis

Our previous research has demonstrated that lens induction in Xenopus laevis requires inductive interactions prior to contact with the optic vesicle, which classically had been thought to be the major lens inductor. The importance of these early interactions has been verified by demonstrating that lens ectoderm is specified by the time it comes into contact with the optic vesicle. It has been argued that the tissues which underlie the presumptive lens ectoderm during gastrulation and neurulation, dorsolateral endoderm and mesoderm, are the primary early inductors. We show here, however, that these tissues alone cannot elicit lens formation in Xenopus ectoderm. Evidence is presented that presumptive anterior neural plate tissue (which includes the early eye rudiment) is an essential early lens inductor in Xenopus. The presence of dorsolateral mesoderm appears to enhance this response. These findings support a model in which an essential inductive signal passes through the plane of ectoderm during gastrula and early neurula stages from presumptive anterior neural tissue to the presumptive lens ectoderm. Since there is evidence for such interactions within a tissue layer in mesodermal and neural induction as well, this may be a general feature of the initial stages of determination of many tissues.

Identification of a retinoic acid-sensitive period during primary axis formation in Xenopus laevis

Retinoic acid (RA) is able to profoundly alter patterning of the primary body axis in embryos of the frog Xenopus laevis. The response to RA is dose-dependent, and leads to progressive truncation of the anteroposterior axis, with anterior structures most sensitive. Both mesodermal and ectodermal tissues are affected, and in vitro assays demonstrate that induced dorsal ectoderm is one direct target of RA. RA represses expression of anterior-specific genes and concomitantly induces expression of at least one posterior-specific gene. Resistance to RA is acquired gradually, during gastrula and early neurula stages, with posterior structures becoming resistant before anterior structures. These data demarcate in the embryo an anterior "domain," which may define the head rudiment and which transcends germ layers. RA can alter the axial pattern after its initial induction; thus, RA sensitivity defines a labile intermediate that occurs during axial patterning. These data suggest a possible role for RA in normal axis formation.

The effects of N-cadherin misexpression on morphogenesis in Xenopus embryos

N-cadherin is a calcium-dependent, cell adhesion molecule that has been proposed to play a role in morphogenesis in vertebrate embryos. Throughout early neural development, N-cadherin is expressed during the morphogenetic changes that occur when ectoderm, in response to neural induction, forms a neural plate and tube. To study the role of N-cadherin in these processes, cDNA clones encoding Xenopus laevis N-cadherin were isolated and used to study the expression of N-cadherin in frog embryos. These studies showed that N-cadherin RNA is not expressed at detectable levels in early cleavage embryos or in isolated ectoderm in the absence of neural induction. However, N-cadherin RNA rapidly appeared in ectoderm exposed to a heterologous neural inducer, indicating that N-cadherin expression, as an early response to induction, precedes the morphogenetic events associated with early neural development. The role of N-cadherin in these morphogenetic events was studied by ectopically expressing N-cadherin in the ectoderm of embryos prior to induction. The ectopic expression of this protein in ectoderm led to the formation of cell boundaries and to severe morphological defects. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the morphogenetic changes associated with early neural development are controlled, in part, by the induced expression of N-cadherin in the neural plate.