Intervertebral disc disorganization is related to trabecular bone architecture in the lumbar spine

Prediction of vertebral strength under loading conditions occurring in activities of daily living using a computed tomography-based nonlinear finite element method

STUDY DESIGN

A clinical study on osteoporotic vertebral strength in daily living using a computed tomography (CT)-based nonlinear finite element (FE) model.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the differences in predicted fracture strength of osteoporotic vertebral bodies among the different loading conditions that are occurring in the activities of daily living.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

FE model has been reported to predict vertebral strength in uniaxial loading, but forward bending load plays an important role in osteoporotic vertebral fractures.

METHODS

Strengths of the second lumbar vertebra in 41 female patients with postmenopausal osteoporosis were analyzed using a nonlinear CT-based FE method. Three different loading conditions were adopted uniaxial compression, forward bending, and erect standing. The same boundary condition was used for all loading conditions. Predicted strengths under forward bending and erect standing were compared with that under uniaxial compression and differences in strength were statistically analyzed.

RESULTS

The regression equation relating strength under uniaxial compression to that under erect standing was expressed as y = 0.8912x + 19.332 (R = 0.9522), whereas the equation relating uniaxial compression to forward bending was y = 0.7033x + 55.071 (R = 0.8342). Both relationships were significant, but the correlation between forward bending and uniaxial compression was not strong, while strength was lower under forward bending than under uniaxial compression according to the Friedman multiple comparison test (P = 0.00017).

CONCLUSION

Strength under forward bending correlated significantly to that under uniaxial compression, but the correlation was not strong. Therefore, in osteoporotic patients, both uniaxial compression and forward bending should be assessed to evaluate fracture risk in daily living using a CT-based FE method.

Vertebral fractures usually affect the cranial endplate because it is thinner and supported by less-dense trabecular bone

INTRODUCTION

Cranial endplates of human vertebrae are injured more often than caudal, in both young and elderly spines. We hypothesise that cranial endplates are inherently vulnerable to compressive loading because of structural asymmetries in the vertebrae.

METHODS

Sixty-two "motion segments" (two vertebrae and the intervening disc and ligaments) were obtained post-mortem from thirty-five human spines (17F/18M, age 48-92 yrs, all spinal levels from T8-9 to L4-5). Specimens were compressed to failure while positioned in 2-6 degrees of flexion, and the resulting damage characterised from radiographs and at dissection. 2 mm-thick slices of 94 vertebral bodies (at least one from each motion segment) were cut in the mid-sagittal plane, and in a para-sagittal plane through the pedicles. Microradiographs of the slices were subjected to image analysis to determine the thickness of each endplate at 10 locations. Optical density of the endplates and adjacent trabecular bone was also measured. Measurements obtained in cranial and caudal regions, and in mid-sagittal and pedicle slices, were compared using repeated measures ANOVA with age, level and gender included as between-subject factors. Linear regression was used to determine significant predictors of compressive strength (failure stress).

RESULTS

Fracture affected the cranial endplate in 55/62 specimens. Cranial endplates were thinner than caudal (p=0.003) by 14% and 11% on average, in mid-sagittal and pedicle slices respectively. Caudal but not cranial endplates were thicker at lower spinal levels (p=0.01). Optical density of trabecular bone adjacent to the endplates was 6% lower cranially than caudally (p=0.004), and the average optical density of trabecular bone in mid-sagittal slices was 10% lower in women than in men (p=0.025). Vertebral yield stress (mean 2.22 MPa, SD 0.77 MPa) was best predicted by the density of trabecular bone underlying the cranial endplate of the mid-sagittal slice of the fractured vertebra (r(2)=0.67, p=0.0006).

CONCLUSIONS

When vertebrae are compressed naturally by adjacent intervertebral discs, cranial endplates usually fail before caudal endplates because they are thinner and supported by less dense trabecular bone.

Effect of osteoporosis on morphology and mobility of the lumbar spine

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to examine disc morphology and spinal mobility in subjects with varying degrees of osteoporosis.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

There was limited information on the effect of osteoporosis on lumbar morphology and spinal mobility. It was also unclear how osteoporosis affects the nonosseous tissues such as the intervertebral disc.

METHODS

Ninety elderly subjects with varying bone mineral densities (22 normal, 28 osteopenia, 40 osteoporosis) were recruited from an osteoporosis clinic. Lateral radiographs and magnetic resonance images of their lumbar spines were obtained. An electromagnetic tracking device was employed to measure the ranges of motion of the whole lumbar spine.

RESULTS

Although the thoracic spine had been shown to have decreased anterior vertebral body height in subjects with osteoporosis, this study revealed that the anterior height was increased in the lumbar region. Osteoporosis was associated with expansion of the middle of the disc with corresponding collapse of vertebral bodies, but osteoporosis was found not to be related to either disc preservation or degeneration. No significant change in spinal mobility was observed in patients with osteoporosis.

CONCLUSION

Osteoporosis does not only affect the bone but also the nonosseous tissues. It was found to be associated with expansion of the intervertebral disc, which was likely to be secondary to changes in the vertebral endplate.

Bone health and back pain: what do we know and where should we go?

Bone health is generally not considered in patients who present with chronic back pain. Nonetheless, bone health and back pain share common genetic and environmental correlates suggesting a co-dependence. Evidence exists for a relationship between back pain and impaired bone health. Here we present the evidence, theoretic framework and clinical relevance. Bone health and back pain are important determinants of musculoskeletal health. Back pain experienced in youth is a risk factor for future back pain, while suboptimal bone health during development increases the risk of skeletal fragility in later life. Generally, bone health is not considered in patients with chronic back pain who do not demonstrate other well-recognised bone health risk factors or associated conditions. Nonetheless, evidence suggests that back pain and impaired bone health share common environmental and genetic correlates, indicating that bone health ought to be considered in the context of back pain in otherwise healthy individuals. This review describes the likely mechanisms explaining the relationship between back pain and impaired bone health, evidence concerning the relationship and suggestions for future research. A narrative literature search was conducted using CINAHL, Medline, PubMed and Web of Science electronic databases. A history of back pain is associated with decreased bone mineral density in adults, yet this tends to be site-specific. No studies were identified examining this association in youth, yet the negative effects of childhood skeletal trauma and obesity on bone and spinal health provide indirect evidence for an association. Further research is required to clarify the impact of back pain on bone health at different lifespan stages using prospective cohort designs.

Stress distribution in the intervertebral disc correlates with strength distribution in subdiscal trabecular bone in the porcine lumbar spine

BACKGROUND

It is understood that an interdependence of properties exists between the intervertebral disc and the subdiscal trabecular bone. Determining the biomechanics of this relationship is important in the development of novel spinal implants and instruments. The aim of this study was to analyze this relationship for the porcine lumbar spine and to compare it with that of the human spine.

METHODS

The stress distribution within the intervertebral disc of 10 porcine lumbar (L4/L5) motion segments was recorded using a 1.5mm needle pressure transducer. For dynamic loading a specialized testing rig was developed to apply flexion/extension and medial/lateral bending while intervertebral disc stress was simultaneously recorded. The regional variation in mechanical properties of trabecular bone was also examined for an additional 10 porcine (L5) vertebral bodies. For compressive testing of the subdiscal bone, columns were prepared using a low speed cutting saw and subjected to axial compression.

FINDINGS

Under pure compressive loading, stress levels within the intervertebral disc were relatively uniform. However, during asymmetric loading large peak stresses were evident in the periphery of the intervertebral disc in areas underlying the annulus fibrosus. The mechanical properties of trabecular bone demonstrated regional variations within the vertebral body. The ratio of compressive yield strength of bone underlying the outer annulus fibrosus to that of bone underlying the nucleus pulposus averaged 1.36.

INTERPRETATION

Although the effects of stress distribution and bone mass adaptation cannot be directly related, it is probable that peak stresses arising in the annulus fibrosus during asymmetric loading provide greater stimuli for the underlying bone to undergo adaptive remodeling to withstand the greater forces experienced. Findings of intervertebral stress distribution and strength distribution of subdiscal trabecular bone for the porcine spine may aid in the development of strategies for preclinical animal testing of spinal implants.

The Effect of Regional Variations of the Trabecular Bone Properties on the Compressive Strength of Human Vertebral Bodies

Cancellous centrum is a major component of the vertebral body and significantly contributes to its structural strength and fracture risk. We hypothesized that the variability of cancellous bone properties in the centrum is associated with vertebral strength. Microcomputed tomography (micro-CT)-based gray level density (GLD), bone volume fraction (BV/TV), and finite element modulus (E) were examined for different regions of the trabecular centrum and correlated with vertebral body strength determined experimentally. Two sets of images in the cancellous centrum were digitally prepared from micro-CT images of eight human vertebral bodies (T10-L5). One set included a cubic volume (1 per vertebral centrum, n = 8) in which the largest amount of cancellous material from the centrum was included but all the shell materials were excluded. The other set included cylindrical volumes (6 per vertebral centrum, n = 48) from the anterior (4 regions: front, center, left, and right of the midline of vertebra) and the posterior (2 regions: left and right) regions of the centrum. Significant positive correlations of vertebral strength with GLD (r (2) = 0.57, p = 0.03) and E (r (2) = 0.63, p = 0.02) of the whole centrum and with GLD (r (2) = 0.65, p = 0.02), BV/TV (r (2) = 0.72, p = 0.01) and E (r (2) = 0.85, p = 0.001) of the central region of the vertebral centrum were found. Vertebral strength decreased with increasing coefficient of variation of GLD, BV/TV, and E calculated from subregions of the vertebral centrum. The values of GLD, BV/TV, and E in centrum were significantly smaller for the anterior region than for the posterior region. Overall, these findings supported the significant role of regional variability of centrum properties in determining the whole vertebral strength.

A comparison of fatigue failure responses of old versus middle-aged lumbar motion segments in simulated flexed lifting

STUDY DESIGN

Survival analysis techniques were used to compare the fatigue failure responses of elderly motion segments to a middle-aged sample.

OBJECTIVES

To compare fatigue life of a middle-aged sample of lumbosacral motion segments to a previously tested elderly cohort. An additional objective was to evaluate the influence of bone mineral content on cycles to failure.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

A previous investigation evaluated fatigue failure responses of 36 elderly lumbosacral motion segments (average age, 81 +/- 8 years) subjected to spinal loads estimated when lifting a 9-kg load in 3 torso flexion angles (0 degrees, 22.5 degrees, and 45 degrees). Results demonstrated rapid fatigue failure with increased torso flexion; however, a key limitation of this study was the old age of the specimens.

METHODS

Each lumbosacral spine was dissected into 3 motion segments (L1-L2, L3-L4, and L5-S1). Motion segments within each spine were randomly assigned to a spinal loading condition corresponding to lifting 9 kg in 3 torso flexion angles (0 degrees, 22.5 degrees, or 45 degrees). Motion segments were statically loaded and allowed to creep for 15 minutes, then cyclically loaded at 0.33 Hz. Fatigue life was taken as the number of cycles to failure (10 mm displacement after creep loading).

RESULTS

Compared with the older sample of spines, the middle-aged sample exhibited increased fatigue life (cycles to failure) in all the torso flexion conditions. Increased fatigue life of the middle-aged specimens was associated with the increased bone mineral content (BMC) in younger motion segments (mean +/- SD, 30.7 +/- 11.1 g per motion segment vs. 27.8 +/- 9.4 g). Increasing bone mineral content had a protective influence with each additional gram increasing survival times by approximately 12%.

CONCLUSION

Younger motion segments survive considerably longer when exposed to similar spine loading conditions that simulate repetitive lifting in neutral and flexed torso postures, primarily associated with the increased bone mineral content possessed by younger motion segments. Cycles to failure of young specimens at 22.5 degrees flexion were similar to that of older specimens at 0 degrees flexion, and survivorship of young specimens at 45 degrees flexion was similar to the older cohort at 22.5 degrees.

Vertebral body integrity: a review of various anatomical factors involved in the lumbar region

The body of the vertebra can be affected in the majority of the conditions involving the lumbar spine. Multiple references, both books and periodicals, have been reviewed, and the anatomical factors responsible for the vertebral body integrity in the lumbar spine have been included under the following important areas, namely, morphology, development, genetics, microscopic examination using histology, structural architecture, blood supply, neuromuscular control, and biomechanics.

INTRODUCTION

The anatomy provides a three-dimensional frame work to support the interaction between the physiological and pathological alterations. The body of the vertebra can be affected in a majority of acute or chronic conditions involving the lumbar spine. The etiology of these conditions is multifactorial, which has been dealt with in previous studies sporadically. This study aims to review and incorporate the important anatomical factors which can influence the integrity of vertebral bodies in the lumbar region and manifest as low back pain.

METHODS

Multiple references, both books and periodicals, have been reviewed for the literature. Electronic databases, including Medline and PubMed, were used to collect the latest information. They were finally arranged in an anatomical framework for the article. An attempt has been made to cover these relevant issues in an integrated way in the article and have been structured into introduction, morphology, development, genetics, microscopic examination using histology, structural architecture, blood supply, neuromuscular control, biomechanics, and conclusion. The aforementioned anatomical aspects, some of which have received less attention in the literature, may be helpful to clinicians for restoring the mobility, stability, and load bearing capacity of the lumbar spine as well as planning better management strategies, especially for the chronic low back pain.

RESULTS

In our article all the anatomical factors affecting the integrity of vertebral body, including the morphology, development, genetics, growth and ossification, blood supply, specifically in the lumbar region, have been described, which were not covered earlier. The limitations of this review is its wide dimensions; hence, there are fair scopes of missing many relevant facts, as all of them cannot be compiled in a single article. We have attempted to confine our views to different anatomical domains only, this is our second limitation. Additional studies are required to incorporate and discuss the uncovered relevant scientific details.

CONCLUSIONS

The integrity of the body of the lumbar vertebra is multifactorial (Fig. 8). The vast spectrum of the anatomical domain influencing it has been summarized. The evolution of erect posture is a landmark in the morphology of human beings and the lumbar lordosis, which has also contributed to the gross design of the vertebral body, is one of the most important adaptations for axial loading and bipedal movements. The role of metamerism in the evolution of vertebrate morphology is repeated in the development of spine. The body of the vertebra is intersegmental in origin, which results in dual vascular and nerve supply, both from superior and inferior aspects of the body of the lumbar vertebrae. The vertebral body ossifies from three primary centers, one for centrum, which will form the major portion of body, and the other two for neural arches. The cartilaginous growth plate is mainly responsible for the longitudinal vertebral growth. Regional differentiation of the vertebral column, and the definite pattern of the structure of the different vertebra, is regulated by a large number of genetic factors, including the Hox genes. The vertebral body design therefore provides the requirements for optimal load transfer by maximal strength with minimal weight. Bone mineral density (BMD), bone quality, microarchitecture, and material properties are the important factors that contribute to bone strength. BMD is highly heritable; bone mineral distribution and architecture are also shown to be under strong genetic influence. All the aforementioned factors finally integrate to ensure mainly the mobility, stability, and load bearing capacity of the lumbar spine.

Regional variations in the apparent and tissue-level mechanical parameters of vertebral trabecular bone with aging using micro-finite element analysis

The aim of this study was to obtain the apparent and tissue-level mechanical parameters of vertebral cancellous bones using micro-finite element analysis, and to identify the regional variations and their relative differences with respect to aging. Ninety trabecular specimens were obtained from six normal L4 vertebral bodies of six male cadavers in two age groups, three aged 62 years and three aged 69 years, and then were scanned using a high-resolution micro-Computed Tomography (micro-CT) system. The obtained micro-CT reconstruction models were then converted to micro-finite element models. Micro-finite element analyses were done to determine the apparent Young's moduli and tissue-level Von Mises stress distribution for each trabecular specimen on the longitudinal direction, and medial-lateral and anterior-posterior directions (transverse directions), respectively. Regional variations about the mechanical parameters at both apparent and tissue levels in different transverse layers and vertical columns within and between the two age groups were then analyzed. The results showed significant decreases in the apparent Young's moduli in each direction with aging, and those in the two transverse directions decreased more with aging compared with the longitudinal direction. Furthermore, there were no statistically significant differences between the mechanical parameters in the two transverse directions in both age groups. This study offered an insight into the distributions and variations of mechanical properties within a vertebral body. The mechanical parameters calculated from this study may help in a better understanding of regional fracture risks and the vertebral fracture mechanism in the prevention of osteoporotic fracture in elder individuals.

Thoracic kyphosis affects spinal loads and trunk muscle force

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Patients with increased thoracic curvature often come to physical therapists for management of spinal pain and disorders. Although treatment approaches are aimed at normalizing or minimizing progression of kyphosis, the biomechanical rationales remain unsubstantiated.

SUBJECTS

Forty-four subjects (mean age [+/-SD]=62.3+/-7.1 years) were dichotomized into high kyphosis and low kyphosis groups.

METHODS

Lateral standing radiographs and photographs were captured and then digitized. These data were input into biomechanical models to estimate net segmental loading from T2-L5 as well as trunk muscle forces.

RESULTS

The high kyphosis group demonstrated significantly greater normalized flexion moments and net compression and shear forces. Trunk muscle forces also were significantly greater in the high kyphosis group. A strong relationship existed between thoracic curvature and net segmental loads (r =.85-.93) and between thoracic curvature and muscle forces (r =.70-.82).

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

This study provides biomechanical evidence that increases in thoracic kyphosis are associated with significantly higher multisegmental spinal loads and trunk muscle forces in upright stance. These factors are likely to accelerate degenerative processes in spinal motion segments and contribute to the development of dysfunction and pain.

The vertebral fracture cascade in osteoporosis: a review of aetiopathogenesis

Once an initial vertebral fracture is sustained, the risk of subsequent vertebral fracture increases significantly. This phenomenon has been termed the "vertebral fracture cascade". Mechanisms underlying this fracture cascade are inadequately understood, creating uncertainty in the clinical environment regarding prevention of further fractures. The cascade cannot be explained by low bone mass alone, suggesting that factors independent of this parameter contribute to its aetiopathogenesis. This review explores physiologic properties that may help to explain the vertebral fracture cascade. Differences in bone properties, including bone mineral density and bone quality, between individuals with and those without osteoporotic vertebral fractures are discussed. Evidence suggests that non-bone parameters differ between individuals with and those without osteoporotic vertebral fractures. Spinal properties, including vertebral macroarchitecture, intervertebral disc integrity, spinal curvature and spinal loading are compared in these groups of individuals. Cross-sectional studies also indicate that neurophysiologic properties, particularly trunk control and balance, are affected by the presence of a vertebral fracture. This review provides a synthesis of the literature to highlight the multi-factorial aetiopathogenesis of the vertebral fracture cascade. With a more comprehensive understanding of the mechanisms underlying this clinical problem, more effective preventative strategies may be developed to offset the fracture cascade.

Pathophysiology of the intervertebral disc and the challenges for MRI

Through its ability to make relatively noninvasive and repeatable measurements, MRI has a great deal to offer, not only to clinical diagnosis of intervertebral disc disorders but also as a tool for basic research into disc physiology and the etiology of disc degeneration. In this brief review we outline the structure of the disc, the composition and organization of its macromolecules, and the changes that occur during disc degeneration, attempting to summarize features that have been or could become targets of MRI characterization. It is important to recognize, however, the fundamental limitation that most of the changes so far observed in MRI are consequences of alterations in cellular metabolism that occurred months to years previously and provide little insight into the current functional status of the tissue. There is therefore a need to develop MR techniques that directly characterize cellular activity and factors such as nutrient delivery on which it is critically dependent. We therefore briefly review cellular energy metabolism and nutrient transport into the avascular disc and consider the ability of MRI to reveal information about such processes. As a corollary of this discussion we also consider the constraints that the unusual transport properties of the disc impose on the delivery of contrast agents to the disc, since an understanding of these limitations is central to interpretation of the resulting images.

Vertebral osteoporosis and trabecular bone quality

Vertebral fractures due to osteoporosis commonly occur under non-traumatic loading conditions. This problem affects more than 1 in 3 women and 1 in 10 men over a lifetime. Measurement of bone mineral density (BMD) has traditionally been used as a method for diagnosis of vertebral osteoporosis. However, this method does not fully account for the influence of changes in the trabecular bone quality, such as micro-architecture, tissue properties and levels of microdamage, on the strength of the vertebra. Studies have shown that deterioration of the vertebral trabecular architecture results in a more anisotropic structure which has a greater susceptibility to fracture. Transverse trabeculae are preferentially thinned and perforated while the remaining vertical trabeculae maintain their thickness. Such a structure is likely to be more susceptible to buckling under normal compression loads and has a decreased ability to withstand unusual or off-axis loads. Changes in tissue material mechanical properties and levels of microdamage due to osteoporosis may also compromise the fracture resistance of vertebral trabecular bone. New diagnostic techniques are required which will account for the influence of these changes in bone quality. This paper reviews the influence of the trabecular architecture, tissue properties and microdamage on fracture risk for vertebral osteoporosis. The morphological characteristics of normal and osteoporotic architectures are compared and their potential influence on the strength of the vertebra is examined. The limitations of current diagnostic methods for osteoporosis are identified and areas for future research are outlined.

Intervertebral disc degeneration can predispose to anterior vertebral fractures in the thoracolumbar spine

Mechanical experiments on cadaveric thoracolumbar spine specimens showed that intervertebral disc degeneration was associated with reduced loading of the anterior vertebral body in upright postures. Reduced load bearing corresponded to locally reduced BMD and inferior trabecular architecture as measured by histomorphometry. Flexed postures concentrated loading on the weakened anterior vertebral body, leading to compressive failure at reduced load.

INTRODUCTION

Osteoporotic fractures are usually attributed to age-related hormonal changes and inactivity. However, why should the anterior vertebral body be affected so often? We hypothesized that degenerative changes in the adjacent intervertebral discs can alter load bearing by the anterior vertebral body in a manner that makes it vulnerable to fracture.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty-one thoracolumbar spine "motion segments" (two vertebrae and the intervertebral disc) were obtained from cadavers 62-94 years of age. Specimens were loaded to simulate upright standing and flexed postures. A pressure transducer was used to measure the distribution of compressive "stress" inside the disc, and stress data were used to calculate how compressive loading was distributed between the anterior and posterior halves of the vertebral body and the neural arch. The compressive strength of each specimen was measured in flexed posture. Regional volumetric BMD and histomorphometric parameters were measured.

RESULTS

In the upright posture, compressive load bearing by the neural arch increased with disc degeneration, averaging 63 +/- 22% (SD) of applied load in specimens with severely degenerated discs. In these specimens, the anterior half of the vertebral body resisted only 10 +/- 8%. The anterior third of the vertebral body had a 20% lower trabecular volume fraction, 16% fewer trabeculae, and 28% greater intertrabecular spacing compared with the posterior third (p < 0.001). In the flexed posture, flexion transferred 53-59% of compressive load bearing to the anterior half of the vertebral body, regardless of disc degeneration. Compressive strength measured in this posture was proportional to BMD in the anterior vertebral body (r2 = 0.51, p < 0.001) and inversely proportional to neural arch load bearing in the upright posture (r2 = 0.28, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Disc degeneration transfers compressive load bearing from the anterior vertebral body to the neural arch in upright postures, reducing BMD and trabecular architecture anteriorly. This predisposes to anterior fracture when the spine is flexed.

The effect of osteoporotic vertebral fracture on predicted spinal loads in vivo

The aetiology of osteoporotic vertebral fractures is multi-factorial, and cannot be explained solely by low bone mass. After sustaining an initial vertebral fracture, the risk of subsequent fracture increases greatly. Examination of physiologic loads imposed on vertebral bodies may help to explain a mechanism underlying this fracture cascade. This study tested the hypothesis that model-derived segmental vertebral loading is greater in individuals who have sustained an osteoporotic vertebral fracture compared to those with osteoporosis and no history of fracture. Flexion moments, and compression and shear loads were calculated from T2 to L5 in 12 participants with fractures (66.4 +/- 6.4 years, 162.2 +/- 5.1 cm, 69.1 +/- 11.2 kg) and 19 without fractures (62.9 +/- 7.9 years, 158.3 +/- 4.4 cm, 59.3 +/- 8.9 kg) while standing. Static analysis was used to solve gravitational loads while muscle-derived forces were calculated using a detailed trunk muscle model driven by optimization with a cost function set to minimise muscle fatigue. Least squares regression was used to derive polynomial functions to describe normalised load profiles. Regression co-efficients were compared between groups to examine differences in loading profiles. Loading at the fractured level, and at one level above and below, were also compared between groups. The fracture group had significantly greater normalised compression (p = 0.0008) and shear force (p < 0.0001) profiles and a trend for a greater flexion moment profile. At the level of fracture, a significantly greater flexion moment (p = 0.001) and shear force (p < 0.001) was observed in the fracture group. A greater flexion moment (p = 0.003) and compression force (p = 0.007) one level below the fracture, and a greater flexion moment (p = 0.002) and shear force (p = 0.002) one level above the fracture was observed in the fracture group. The differences observed in multi-level spinal loading between the groups may explain a mechanism for increased risk of subsequent vertebral fractures. Interventions aimed at restoring vertebral morphology or reduce thoracic curvature may assist in normalising spine load profiles.

Disc space narrowing as a new risk factor for vertebral fracture: the OFELY study

OBJECTIVE

In a previous cross-sectional analysis, we found a positive association between disc space narrowing (DSN) and vertebral fracture. The aim of the present study was to analyze prospectively the risk of vertebral and nonvertebral fractures in women with spine osteoarthritis (OA).

METHODS

Using radiographs, spine OA was evaluated in 634 postmenopausal women from the OFELY (Os des Femmes de Lyon) cohort (mean+/-SD age 61.2+/-9 years). Prevalence and severity of spine OA were assessed by scoring osteophytes and DSN. Incidental clinical fractures were prospectively registered during annual followup, and vertebral fractures were evaluated by radiography every 4 years.

RESULTS

During an 11-year followup, fractures occurred in 121 women, including 42 with vertebral fractures. No association was found between osteophytes and the risk of fracture. In contrast, DSN was associated with an increased risk of vertebral fractures but not of nonvertebral fractures. After adjusting for confounding variables, the presence of DSN was associated with a marked increased risk of vertebral fractures, with an odds ratio of 6.59 (95% confidence interval 1.36-31.9). In addition, 95% of incident vertebral fractures were located above the disc with the most severe narrowing.

CONCLUSION

This longitudinal study shows that, despite a higher bone mineral density (BMD), women with spine OA do not have a reduced risk of fracture and that DSN is significantly associated with vertebral fracture risk. The location of DSN and of incident vertebral fractures suggests that disc degeneration impairs the biomechanics of the above spine, which leads to the increased risk of vertebral fractures, independent of BMD. We suggest that DSN is a newly identified risk factor for vertebral fracture that should be taken into consideration when assessing vertebral fracture risk in postmenopausal women.

Antero–postero differences in cortical thickness and cortical porosity of T12 to L5 vertebral bodies

OBJECTIVE

This study will investigate interrelationships between the cortical shell and cancellous bone trabecular thickness, in vertebral bodies.

METHODS

One hundred and sixty vertebral bodies from T12 to L5 were obtained at autopsy. The average age of the cohort was 59.3+/-22.1 years (range = 20-94 years). Cortical thickness, cortical porosity and trabecular thickness from the adjacent cancellous bone were measured.

RESULTS

At the mid-vertebral body anterior cortical thickness was significantly greater than posterior cortical thickness (524 +/- 352 vs. 370 +/- 283 microm, respectively, P < 0.0001) and mid-anterior cortical porosity was significantly less than mid-posterior cortical porosity (24 +/- 14% vs. 32 +/- 16%, respectively, P < 0.0001). There were no anterior/posterior differences in trabecular thickness of the cancellous bone adjacent to the cortical walls.

CONCLUSION

This study provides a novel perspective of T12 to L5 vertebral body bone, where measurement of cortical thickness and cortical porosity in a cohort of skeletally normal individuals revealed structural differences between load bearing anterior and posterior cortical walls. The data suggest that modulators of change to vertebral body bone may affect the cortical and trabecular bone differently. The relationships between cortical and cancellous bone suggest that the middle sectors of the vertebral body play a critical role in load bearing.

The effect of exogenous melatonin administration on trabecular width, ligament thickness and TGF-β1 expression in degenerated intervertebral disk tissue in the rat

Intervertebral disk (IVD) degeneration, a complex pathological condition of varying origins, causes low back pain. Degenerative changes in IVD tissue affect the adjacent vertebral structure, resulting in a decreased vertebral trabecular width. It has been suggested that transforming growth factor-beta 1 (TGF-beta(1)) may have a role in the repair of connective tissue, as it occurs in the IVD degeneration process. In this study, we investigated the effects of exogenous melatonin (MEL) administration on vertebral trabecular width, ligament thickness and TGF-beta(1) expression in degenerated IVD tissue. Fifteen adult male Swiss Albino rats were divided randomly into three groups; nonoperated control, operated degeneration, and MEL treatment groups. In the operated degeneration and MEL treatment groups, cuts were made parallel to the end plates in the posterior annulus fibrosus at the fifth and tenth vertebral segments of the tail to induce IVD degeneration. In each group, TGF-beta(1) immunoreactivity and morphometry of vertebral trabecular width and anterior and posterior ligament thickness were evaluated. Histologically, disorganisation and irregularity of collagen fibres was seen in the degenerated (operated) IVD. Increased TGF-beta(1) expression in multinuclear chondrocytes was also observed as was decreased vertebral trabecular width. Importantly, the reduction of trabecular width observed in the operated degenerated group was reversed after MEL administration (p<0.0001). Similarly, TGF-beta(1) expression in multinuclear chondrocytes was dramatically increased after exogenous MEL application. Thus, there was a regression in histopathological changes after MEL treatment, with disk appearances similar to those of the control group. Based on our findings, we suggest that MEL activates the recovery process in the degenerated IVD tissue, possibly by stimulating TGF-beta(1) activity. This is the first report investigating the involvement of the pineal hormone MEL in the repair of rat IVD.

Regional variations in microstructural properties of vertebral trabeculae with structural groups

STUDY DESIGN

Micro-computed tomography (CT) scanning to investigate three-dimensional microstructural properties of L4 vertebral bodies.

OBJECTIVE

To identify the regional variations in the three-dimensional microstructural properties of vertebral cancellous bones with respect to structural types for the prediction of related regional fracture risks.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

The literature contains no reports on regional variations in morphologic properties of vertebral trabeculae with microstructural types, which may shed light on the patterns of osteoporotic fractures.

METHODS

Ninety cubic cancellous specimens were obtained from 6 normal L4 vertebral bodies of 6 male donors 62 to 70 years of age and were scanned using a high-resolution micro-CT system. These specimens were further divided into two groups according to the average structure model index (SMI) of the 15 trabecular specimens in each vertebral body. Adjustment for age differences was done for the microstructural parameters, i.e.-, bone volume fraction, trabecular number, trabecular thickness, structure model index, degree of architectural anisotropy, and connectivity density, to allow investigation on the regional variations in different transverse layers and vertical columns independent of age.

RESULTS

Trabecular specimens with lower mass were liable to form high-SMI group and the differences in all parameters reached significance level either between columns or between layers from two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The anterior column in the high-SMI group is more susceptible to vertebral body wedge fracture; and in the low-SMI group, off-axis bone damage is most harmful to the central column of vertebral trabeculae. The data obtained may help to identify the most critical locations of fracture risks at an early stage and provide a microstructural basis for the repair and clinical treatment of vertebral fractures.

The numerical simulation of osteophyte formation on the edge of the vertebral body using quantitative bone remodeling theory

OBJECTIVES

To extend the quantitative prediction of the external shape of bone structure to the simulation of osteophyte formation on the edge of vertebral body.

METHODS

The high-order nonlinear equation of bone remodeling was used to control osteophyte formation process. The idea of topology optimization in engineering was imported to allow the outgrowth of osteophyte. Osteophyte on the edge of a vertebral body in its mid-sagittal plane was simulated numerically.

RESULTS

Osteophyte formation is an adaptive bone remodeling process in response to the progressive changes of mechanical environment, which were mainly caused by intervertebral disc degeneration.

CONCLUSION

The numerical simulation in this paper extended the structural simulation based on the quantitative bone remodeling theory to bone morphological abnormity in orthopaedics, which can help to better understand the relationship between bone morphological abnormity and the mechanical environment.

Spine biomechanics

Current trends in spine research are reviewed in order to suggest future opportunities for biomechanics. Recent studies show that psychosocial factors influence back pain behaviour but are not important causes of pain itself. Severe back pain most often arises from intervertebral discs, apophyseal joints and sacroiliac joints, and physical disruption of these structures is strongly but variably linked to pain. Typical forms of structural disruption can be reproduced by severe mechanical loading in-vitro, with genetic and age-related weakening sometimes leading to injury under moderate loading. Biomechanics can be used to quantify spinal loading and movements, to analyse load distributions and injury mechanisms, and to develop therapeutic interventions. The authors suggest that techniques for quantifying spinal loading should be capable of measurement "in the field" so that they can be used in epidemiological surveys and ergonomic interventions. Great accuracy is not required for this task, because injury risk depends on tissue weakness as much as peak loading. Biomechanical tissue testing and finite-element modelling should complement each other, with experiments establishing proof of concept, and models supplying detail and optimising designs. Suggested priority areas for future research include: understanding interactions between intervertebral discs and adjacent vertebrae; developing prosthetic and tissue-engineered discs; and quantifying spinal function during rehabilitation. "Mechanobiology" has perhaps the greatest future potential, because spinal degeneration and healing are both mediated by the activity of cells which are acutely sensitive to their local mechanical environment. Precise characterisation and manipulation of this environment will be a major challenge for spine biomechanics.

Dynamic stabilization in the surgical management of painful lumbar spinal disorders

STUDY DESIGN

A literature review.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the mechanisms of action and effectiveness of posterior dynamic stabilization devices in the management of painful spinal disorders.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Dynamic stabilization may provide pain relief by altering the transmission of abnormal loads across the degenerated disc space.

METHODS

A Medline search was conducted.

RESULTS

Articles supporting abnormal load transmission across the disc space and clinical reviews of currently available posterior dynamic systems were included.

CONCLUSIONS

Posterior dynamic stabilization systems may provide benefit comparable to fusion techniques, but without the elimination of movement. Further study is required to determine optimal design and clinical indications.

In vivo intrarater and interrater precision of measuring apparent bone mineral density in vertebral subregions using supine lateral dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry

Analysis of apparent bone mineral density (BMD) in the lumbar spine is commonly based on anteroposterior (AP) scanning using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA). Although not widely used, clinically important information can also be derived from lateral scanning. Vertebral bone density, and therefore strength, can may vary in different subregions of the vertebral body. Therefore, subregional BMD measurements might be informative about fracture risk. However, the intrarater and interrater precision of in vivo subregional BMD assessments from lateral DXA remains unknown. Ten normal, young (mean: 24 yr) and 10 older (mean: 63 yr) individuals with low BMD were scanned on one occasion using an AP/lateral sequence. Each lateral scan was reanalyzed six times at L2 by three raters to determine the intrarater and interrater precision in selecting seven regions of interest (subregions). Precision was expressed using percentage coefficients of variation (% CV) and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). Intrarater precision ranged from ICC(1,1) 0.971 to 0.996 (% CV: 0.50-3.68) for the young cohort and ICC(1,1) 0.934 to 0.993 (% CV: 1.46-5.30) for the older cohort. Interrater precision ranged from ICC(2,1) 0.804 to 0.915 (% CV: 1.11-2.35) for the young cohort and ICC(2,1) 0.912 to 0.984 (% CV: 1.85-4.32) for the older cohort. Scanning a subgroup of participants twice with repositioning was used to assess short-term in vivo precision. At L2, short-term in vivo precision ranged from ICC(1,1) 0.867 to 0.962 (% CV: 3.38-9.61), at L3 from ICC(1,1) 0.961 to 0.988 (% CV: 2.02-5.57) and using an L2/L3 combination from ICC(1,1) 0.942 to 0.980 (% CV: 2.04-4.61). This study demonstrated moderate to high precision for subregional analysis of apparent BMD in the lumbar spine using lateral DXA in vivo.

Intervertebral disc degeneration can lead to "stress-shielding" of the anterior vertebral body: a cause of osteoporotic vertebral fracture?

STUDY DESIGN

Mechanical testing of cadaveric lumbar motion segments.

OBJECTIVES

To test the hypothesis that degenerative changes in the intervertebral discs can influence loading of the anterior vertebral body in a manner that makes it vulnerable to fracture.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Measurements of systemic bone loss do not fully explain the patterns of osteoporotic vertebral fractures.

METHODS

Thirty-three cadaveric lumbar motion segments (aged 19-82 years) were subjected to 2 kN of compressive loading while positioned to simulate habitual erect standing postures and forwards bending. Intradiscal stresses were measured in each posture by pulling a miniature pressure transducer along the midsagittal diameter of the disc. "Stress profiles" were then integrated over area to calculate the force acting on the anterior and posterior halves of the vertebral body. These forces were subtracted from the applied 2 kN to determine the compressive force on the neural arch.

RESULTS

In motion segments with nondegenerated discs, <5% of the compressive force was resisted by the neural arch, and forces on the vertebral body were always distributed evenly, irrespective of posture. However, with severely degenerated discs, neural arch load-bearing increased to 40% in the erect posture, and the compressive force on the vertebral body was concentrated anteriorly in forwards bending, and posteriorly in erect posture.

CONCLUSIONS

Severe disc degeneration causes the anterior vertebral body to be stress-shielded during the usual erect posture, and yet severely loaded whenever the spine is flexed. This could help to explain why this region is frequently the site of osteoporotic fracture, and why forward bending movements often precipitate the injury.

A review of anatomical and mechanical factors affecting vertebral body integrity

Background: The aetiology of osteoporotic vertebral fracture is multifactorial and may be conceptualised using a systems framework. Previous studies have established several correlates of vertebral fracture including reduced vertebral cross-sectional area, weakness in back extensor muscles, reduced bone mineral density, increasing age, worsening kyphosis and recent vertebral fracture. Alterations in these physical characteristics may influence biomechanical loads and neuromuscular control of the trunk and contribute to changes in subregional bone mineral density of the vertebral bodies. Methods: This review discusses factors that have received less attention in the literature, which may contribute to the development of vertebral fracture. A literature review was conducted using electronic databases including Medline, Cinahl and ISI Web of Science to examine the potential contribution of trabecular architecture, subregional bone mineral density, vertebral geometry, muscle force, muscle strength, neuromuscular control and intervertebral disc integrity to the aetiology of osteoporotic vertebral fracture. Interpretation: A better understanding of factors such as biomechanical loading and neuromuscular control of the trunk may help to explain the high incidence of subsequent vertebral fracture after sustaining an initial vertebral fracture. Consideration of these issues may be important in the development of prevention and management strategies.

Dynamic stabilization devices in the treatment of low back pain

Soft stabilization has an important role in the treatment of the degenerative lumbar spine. Fusion of one or two motion segments may not make a big difference in the total range of motion of the lumbar spine, but preserving flexibility of a motion segment may prevent adjacent segment disease and may permit disc replacement, even when facet joints need to be excised. If a favorable environment is created in the motion segment by unloading the disc and permitting near normal motion, the disc may be able to repair itself or may supplement the reparative potential of gene therapy. Although soft stabilization seems promising, one should take a cautious approach to any new implant system. An implant for fusion only has to serve a temporary stabilization until fusion has taken place; on the other hand, a soft stabilization system has to provide stability throughout its life. Implant loosening following fusion surgery is common in the presence of pseudarthrosis. After soft stabilization, the implant has to stay anchored to the bone despite allowing movement. This sounds like a daunting task. The flexibility of the implant system, however, should be able to protect it from loosening at the anchor point into the bone. Finally, the soft stabilization system is intended to load-share with the disc and the facet joint only partially and unloads the motion segment. Any mismatch between the kinematics of the implant system and the motion segment, in particular any discrepancy between their IAR, would result in the implant bearing unexpected load at certain ranges of motion. If that happens, it would guarantee an early implant failure or loosening. The need for strict bench testing in the laboratory, therefore, cannot be over-emphasized. The few soft stabilization systems that have had clinical applications so far have produced a clinical outcome comparable to that of fusion. No prospective randomized controlled trial has been reported yet, which is an essential requirement for practice of evidence-based medicine.

Bone architecture and disc degeneration in the lumbar spine of mice lacking GDF-8 (myostatin)

GDF-8, also known as myostatin, is a member of the transforming growth factor-beta superfamily of secreted growth and differentiation factors that is expressed in vertebrate skeletal muscle. Myostatin functions as a negative regulator of skeletal muscle growth and myostatin null mice show a doubling of muscle mass compared to normal mice. We describe here morphology of the lumbar spine in myostatin knockout (Mstn(-/-)) mice using histological and densitometric techniques. The Mstn(-/-) mice examined in this study weigh approximately 10% more than controls (p<0.001) but the iliopsoas muscle is over 50% larger in the knockout mice than in wild-type mice (p<0.001). Peripheral quantitative computed tomography (pQCT) data from the fifth lumbar vertebra show that mice lacking myostatin have approximately 50% greater trabecular bone mineral density (p=0.001) and significantly greater cortical bone mineral content than normal mice. Toluidine blue staining of the intervertebral disc between L4-L5 reveals loss of proteoglycan staining in the hyaline end plates and inner annulus fibrosus of the knockout mice. Loss of cartilage staining in the caudal end plate of L4 is due to ossification of the end plate in the myostatin-deficient animals. Results from this study suggest that increased muscle mass in mice lacking myostatin is associated with increased bone mass as well as degenerative changes in the intervertebral disc.

Micro-computed tomography evaluation of trabecular bone structure on loaded mice tail vertebrae

STUDY DESIGN

A micro-computed tomography (CT) study of the trabecular bone structure on loaded mice tail vertebral bodies was conducted.

OBJECTIVE

To depict and characterize changes in the trabecular bone structure of mice tail vertebral bodies after in vivo application of static compressive load.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Static compressive loading leads to significant structural changes in murine tail intervertebral discs, such as disorganization of the anulus fibrosus, increase in apoptosis, and associated loss of cellularity. Wolff's Law suggests that alterations in spinal loading will also influence the architecture of the adjacent vertebral bodies. Because of biomechanical and biologic interdependencies between the disc and vertebra, these tissues should be considered simultaneously when investigating the etiology of degenerative spinal conditions.

METHODS

Mice tail discs between the ninth and 10th caudal vertebrae were compressed in vivo for 7 days with static axial loads using external fixators. Micro-CT scans of the vertebral bodies were performed at an isotropic resolution of 18 microm, to obtain trabecular bone structural parameters. Random effects models were used to evaluate statistical significance of these parameters in different compressed conditions.

RESULTS

With loading, the connectivity density of the trabecular network increases significantly. After a period of in vivo recovery on load removal, the trabeculae become more rod-like; corresponding changes such as disorganization of the anulus fibrosus and loss of nuclear and inner-anular cellularity are also seen.

CONCLUSIONS

In vivo compressive loading leads to significant architectural changes within vertebral bodies. These observations may be helpful in understanding the pathologic processes and the chronology of degenerative spinal conditions.

Zone-dependent changes in human vertebral trabecular bone: clinical implications

We have previously shown that there are pronounced age-related changes in human vertebral cancellous bone density and microarchitecture. However, the magnitude of these changes seemed to be dependent on zone location in the vertebral body-the central third vs. the areas adjacent to the endplates. The aim of the present study was, therefore, to investigate whether such zone-specific differences could be identified by static histomorphometric measures. The material comprised 48 individuals (24 women aged 19-97 years, and 24 men aged 23-95 years). Three of the women had a known fracture of the L-2. From each L-2, thick frontal sections of half of the vertebra were embedded undecalcified in methylmethacrylate, cut into 10-microm-thick sections, and stained with aniline blue. The sections were scanned into a computer, and classic static histomorphometry was performed on the images. The histomorphometry was performed on both the whole section and on the separate zones (central and sub-endplate zone). The results showed that trabecular bone volume, trabecular number, and connectivity density decreased significantly faster with age, whereas marrow space star volume increased significantly faster with age in the zones adjacent to the endplates than in the central zone. The other histomorphometric measures showed no zone specificity in relation to aging. However, trabecular thickness and trabecular separation were both higher at all ages in the central zone than in the sub-endplate zone, although this was significant only for trabecular separation. The described differences might have significant clinical implications concerning quantitative computed tomography (QCT) scanning, X-ray analyses, and assessment of fracture liability in the human spine, but the underlying pathogenesis is still not known. This study shows that the human vertebral body can be described as two distinct zones with very specific age-related changes in density and microstructure. This zone-specificity is important for the correct interpretation of clinical data.

Mechanical and pathologic consequences of induced concentric anular tears in an ovine model

STUDY DESIGN

Relations between induced concentric tears in the sheep disc and the mechanics of the intervertebral joint and vertebral body bone were analyzed.

OBJECTIVE

To examine the effect of concentric disc tears on the mechanics of the spine.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Degeneration of the intervertebral disc results in changes to the mechanics and morphology of the spine, but the effect of concentric disc tears is unknown.

METHODS

In this study, 48 merino wethers were subjected to surgery, and discs were randomly selected for either a needlestick injury or induction of a concentric tear in the anterior and left anterolateral anulus. Sheep were randomly assigned to groups for killing at 0, 1, 3, 6, 12, and 18 months. From each sheep, two spine segments were mechanically tested: one with a needlestick injury and one with a concentric tear. Macroscopic disc morphology was assessed by three axial slices of the disc. Sagittal bone slices were taken from cranial and caudal vertebral bodies for histologic analysis.

RESULTS

Induced concentric tears decrease the stiffness of intact spine segments in left bending and the disc alone in flexion. In all other mechanical tests, the needlestick injury had the same effect as the induced concentric tear. In the isolated disc, the disc stiffness at 6 months was increased for right bending, as compared with the response at 1 month. This was associated with increased anterior lamellar thickening and increased vertebral body bone volume fraction.

CONCLUSIONS

Concentric tears and needlestick injury in the anterior anulus lead to mechanical changes in the disc and both anular lamellar thickness and vertebral body bone volume fraction. A needlestick injury through the anulus parallel to the lamellae produces progressive damage.

Structural development of the mineralized tissue in the human L4 vertebral body

Knowledge of the structural development of the human vertebrae from non-weight-bearing before birth to weight-bearing after birth is still poor. We studied the mineralized tissue of the developing lumbar L4 vertebral body at ages 15 weeks postconception to 97 years from the tissue level (trabecular architecture) to the material level (micro- and nanostructure). Trabecular architecture was investigated by 2D histomorphometry and the material level was examined by quantitative backscattered electron imaging (for typical calcium content, CaMaxFreq) and scanning small-angle X-ray scattering (for mean mineral particle thickness). During early development, the trabecular orientation changed from a radial to a vertical/horizontal pattern. For bone area per tissue area and trabecular width in postnatal cancellous bone, the maximum was reached at adolescence (20 years), while for trabecular number the maximum was reached at childhood (approximately 1 year). CaMaxFreq was lower in early bone (approximately 21 wt%) than in mineralized cartilage (approximately 29 wt%) and adolescent bone (approximately 23 wt%). In conclusion, the changes at the tissue level were observed to continue throughout life while the development of bone at the material level (CaMaxFreq, mineral particle thickness and orientation) is essentially complete after the first years of life. CaMaxFreq and mean particle thickness increase rapidly during the first years and reach saturation. Remarkably, when these parameters are plotted versus logarithm of age, they appear linear.