Sequential Immune Escape and Shifting of T Cell Responses in a Long-Term Survivor of Melanoma

Use of tumour-responsive T cells as cancer treatment

The stimulation of a tumour-specific T-cell response has several theoretical advantages over other forms of cancer treatment. First, T cells can home in to antigen-expressing tumour deposits no matter where they are located in the body-even in deep tissue beds. Additionally, T cells can continue to proliferate in response to immunogenic proteins expressed in cancer until all the tumour cells are eradicated. Finally, immunological memory can be generated, allowing for eradication of antigen-bearing tumours if they reoccur. We will highlight two direct methods of stimulating tumour-specific T-cell immunity: active immunisation with cancer vaccines and infusion of competent T cells via adoptive T-cell treatment. Preclinical and clinical studies have shown that modulation of the tumour microenvironment to support the immune response is as important as stimulation of the most appropriate effector T cells. The future of T-cell immunity stimulation to treat cancer will need combination approaches focused on both the tumour and the T cell.

CD8 T-cell responses against cyclin B1 in breast cancer patients with tumors overexpressing p53

PURPOSE

This study aimed to examine CD8 T-cell reactivity in breast cancer patients against cyclin B1-derived peptides restricted by the human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-A2 molecule.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 36 breast cancer patients were analyzed by enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot (ELISPOT) for the presence of T cells recognizing the cyclin B1-derived peptides CB9 (AKYLMELTM) and CB-P4 (AKYLMELCC), in addition to modified versions of CB9, CB9L2 (ALYLMELTM) and CB9M2 (AMYLMELTM), both of which display higher affinity to HLA-A2.

RESULTS

Twelve patients harbored a memory CD8 T-cell response against at least one of the peptides; strongest reactivity was detected against the CB9L2 peptide. Because the level of cyclin B1 has been shown to be influenced by the level of p53, which in turn is elevated in cancer cells because of point mutation, we analyzed the level of p53 protein in biopsies from the patients by immune histochemistry. Combined data showed that anti-cyclin B1 reactivity was predominantly detected in patients with tumors characterized by elevated expression of p53. Interestingly, no reactivity was detected against six peptides derived from the p53 protein.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data support the notion of cyclin B1 as a prominent target for immunologic recognition in cancer patients harboring p53-mutated cancer cells. Because mutation of p53 is one of the most frequent genetic alterations in human cancers, this suggests that immunotherapy based on targeting of cyclin B1 is broadly applicable in a large proportion of cancer patients.

Tumor dormancy and immunoescape

The role of the immune system in tumor dormancy is now well established. In several experimental models it is possible to induce tumor dormancy in immunocompetent hosts by prior immunization against tumor cells. Equilibrium between immune response and tumor cells leads to long-term tumor dormancy. This equilibrium is also observed early in tumor development and adaptive immunity may help contain tumor outgrowth. However, after variable times, tumor dormancy ends and the disease progresses. As the immune response remains active the tumor cells presumably escape dormancy by becoming resistant. Due to the extreme difficulty of isolating dormant tumor cells from patients, such mechanisms are poorly understood. However, experimental models have shown that dormant tumor cells may overexpress B7-H1 and B7.1, and inhibit CTL-mediated lysis. These cells resist apoptosis by methylating SOCS1, and by paracrine production of cytokines. The presence of immunoescape mechanisms in tumor cells from relapsing patients also suggests that the immune equilibrium which maintained dormancy has broken down. Identification of such mechanisms would offer new leads to favor the immune balance, and thus to clear minimal residual disease from patients.

Regressing and progressing metastatic lesions: resistance to immunotherapy is predetermined by irreversible HLA class I antigen alterations

Despite the significant efforts to enhance immune reactivity against malignancies the clinical effect of anti-tumor vaccines and cancer immunotherapy is still below expectations. Understanding of the possible causes of such poor clinical outcome has become very important for improvement of the existing cancer treatment modalities. In particular, the critical role of HLA class I antigens in the success of T cell based immunotherapy has led to a growing interest in investigating the expression and function of these molecules in metastatic cancer progression and, especially in response to immunotherapy. In this report, we illustrate that two types of metastatic lesions are commonly generated in response to immunotherapy according to the pattern of HLA class I expression. We found that metastatic lesions, that progress after immunotherapy have low level of HLA class I antigens, while the regressing lesions demonstrate significant upregulation of these molecules. Presumably, immunotherapy changes tumor microenvironment and creates an additional immune selection pressure on tumor cells. As a result, two subtypes of metastatic lesions arise from pre-existing malignant cells: (a) regressors, with upregulated HLA class I expression after therapy, and (b) progressors with resistance to immunotherapy and with low level of HLA class I. Tumor cells with reversible defects (soft lesions) respond to therapy by upregulation of HLA class I expression and regress, while tumor cells with structural irreversible defects (hard lesions) demonstrate resistance to immunostimulation, fail to upregulate HLA class I antigens and eventually progress. These two types of metastases appear independently of type of the immunotherapy used, either non-specific immunomodulators (cytokines or BCG) or autologous tumor vaccination. Similarly, we also detected two types of metastatic colonies in a mouse fibrosarcoma model after in vitro treatment with IFN-gamma. One type of metastases characterized by upregulation of all MHC class I antigens and another type with partial IFN-gamma resistance, namely with lack of expression of L(d)-MHC class I molecule. Our observations may shed new light on the understanding of the mechanisms of tumor escape and might have implications for improvement of the efficacy of cancer immunotherapy.

Dynamic expression of protective CEACAM1 on melanoma cells during specific immune attack

An efficient immune response against tumours depends on a well-orchestrated function of integrated components, but is finally exerted by effector tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL). We have previously reported that homophilic CEACAM1 interactions inhibit the specific killing and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) release activities of natural killer cells and TIL. In this study a model for the investigation of melanoma cells surviving long coincubation with antigen-specific TIL is reported. It is demonstrated that the surviving melanoma cells increase their surface CEACAM1 expression, which in turn confers enhanced resistance against fresh TIL. Furthermore, it is shown that this is an active process, driven by specific immune recognition and is at least partially mediated by lymphocyte-derived IFN-gamma. Similar results were observed with antigen-restricted TIL, either autologous or allogeneic, as well as with natural killer cells. The enhanced CEACAM1 expression depends, however, on the presence of IFN-gamma and sharply drops within 48 hr. This may be a mechanism that allows tumour cells to transiently develop a more resistant phenotype upon recognition by specific lymphocytes. Therefore, this work substantiates the melanoma-promoting role of CEACAM1 and marks it as an attractive target for novel immunotherapeutic interventions.

Human melanoma cytolysis by combined inhibition of mammalian target of rapamycin and vascular endothelial growth factor/vascular endothelial growth factor receptor-2

Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) plays a vital role in tumor angiogenesis. VEGF is produced by human melanomas, and the VEGF receptor 2 (VEGFR-2) is expressed by most advanced stage melanomas, suggesting the possibility of an autocrine loop. Here, we show that bevacizumab, an anti-VEGF antibody, inhibits proliferation of VEGFR-2(+) melanoma cell lines by an average of 41%; however, it failed to inhibit proliferation of VEGFR-2(neg) melanoma cell lines. The growth inhibitory effect of bevacizumab was eliminated by VEGFR-2 knockdown with small interfering RNA, showing that VEGF autocrine growth in melanoma is mediated through VEGFR-2. However, bevacizumab inhibition of autocrine signals did not completely inhibit cell proliferation nor cause cell death. Cell survival is mediated partially through mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR), which is inhibited by rapamycin. Combination of bevacizumab with rapamycin caused loss of half of the VEGFR-2(+) melanoma cells, but no reduction in the number of VEGFR-2(neg) melanoma cells. The results show (a) an autocrine growth loop active in VEGFR-2(+) melanoma, (b) a nonangiogenic mechanism for inhibition of melanoma by blocking autocrine VEGFR-2 activation, and (c) a possible therapeutic role for combination of inhibitors of mTOR plus VEGF in selected melanomas.

Dormant tumor cells as a therapeutic target?

Tumor dormancy is characterised by the persistence of residual tumor cells for long periods. Recurrence from minimal residual disease is a major cause of cancer death. Thus, understanding how cancer cells become and remain dormant, may lead to new strategies to prevent relapse. Evidence has emerged that a balance exists between host and dormant tumor cells. Cross-talk between tumor cells and their micro-environment, angiogenesis, and anti-tumor immune response participate in the control of dormant tumor cells. Tumor cells have several mechanisms of maintaining equilibrium, and immune escape, including expression of immuno-regulatory molecules (e.g., increased expression of B7.1 and B7-H1); epigenetic modifications (e.g., silencing of the SOCS1 gene, de-regulating the JAK/STAT pathway); and autocrine loops. These new findings offer new opportunities to design specific treatments, to modify the balance in favor of the host immune response.

Spontaneous immune responses against glioma-associated antigens in a long term survivor with malignant glioma

Background

In patients with high grade glioma, little is known regarding existence of naturally occurring adaptive T cell reactivity against glioma-associated antigens (GAAs). In this report, we characterized GAA-specific CD8⁺ T cells and innate immune cells in a patient who has survived with anaplastic astrocytoma (AA) for over 12 years without recurrence.

Methods

Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) derived from the long term survivor with AA were evaluated for the frequency, cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity and differentiation status of CD8⁺ cells recognizing GAA-derived epitopes as well as relative numbers of other immune cell subsets. This patient's AA tissue was evaluated for expression of two GAAs EphA2 and interleukin-13 receptor α2 subunit (IL-13Rα2) by immunohistochemistry.

Results

The patient's tumor expressed both EphA2 and IL-13Rα2, and in vitro stimulated PBMC demonstrated superior EphA2_883–891 and IL-13Rα2_345–353-specific CTL reactivity compared to PBMC samples from two other patients with progressing malignant glioma. Unstimulated EphA2_883–891-reactive CD8⁺ T cells contained high numbers of CD45RA^-/CCR7^- late effector and CD45RA^-/CCR7⁺ central memory cells. Among other leukocyte subsets, elevated numbers of NK-T cells were found.

Conclusion

To our knowledge, the current study is one of the first demonstrating the presence of antigen-experienced, GAA-reactive CD8⁺ T cells in a patient who has survived with AA for over 12 years without recurrence. Further studies are warranted to determine whether the status of GAA-reactive CD8⁺ T cells dictates survival of patients and/or response to therapeutic vaccines.

The role of the CTLA4 blockade in the treatment of malignant melanoma

Metastatic melanoma remains a disease with few effective treatments. The anti-tumor immune response has long been felt to be important in the prognosis of melanoma, and much work has focused on harnessing the immune system to fight this disease. Tumor-specific vaccines, immunomodulatory cytokines and non-specific immunostimulants (such as Bacille Calmette Guerin/BCG) have all been investigated. A new strategy has been identified involving cytotoxic T-lymphocyte antigen-4 (CTLA4). This molecule is expressed on the surface of activated T-lymphocytes and exerts a suppressive effect on the induction of immune responses after interaction between T-cell receptor (TCR) and human lymphocyte antigen (HLA) molecules on the antigen-presenting cell (APC). Work in animal models demonstrated that antibody-mediated blockade of this target could lead to anti-tumor responses. Two fully human monoclonal antibodies, ipilimumab (MDX-010) and tremelimumab (CP-675, 206; formerly known as ticilimumab), are in clinical development. Both have demonstrated hints of clinical activity in metastatic melanoma. Both also have a toxicity profile consistent with their mechanism of action, involving inactivation of a normal immunosuppressive homeostatic mechanism: development of auto-immune breakthrough events (IBE). These include inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), uveitis, dermatitis, arthritis, and others. Generally, these events have been easily managed by cessation of therapy and intravenous or topical steroid therapy and supportive care in most patients, although colectomy had been required in several severe cases and there have been several deaths. Interestingly, patients who develop IBE seem to have the greatest likelihood of clinical benefit, but it is unclear whether clinical benefit and IBE are dissociable events. Other than IBE, no other pharmacodynamic measure has been able to predict response, although certain autoimmune antibody titers may have promise in this regard. Further research will confirm the clinical benefit of these agents alone and in combination with other agents, further define the safety profile and protocols for toxicity management, and identify pharmacodynamic parameters predicting clinical benefit and toxicity.

Design and development of synthetic peptide vaccines: past, present and future

Synthetic peptide vaccines aiming at the induction of a protective CD8(+) T-cell response against infectious or malignant diseases are widely used in the clinic but, despite their success in animal models, they do not yet live up to their promise in humans. This review assesses the development of synthetic peptide vaccines, weighs it against the immunological concepts that have emerged, and identifies the key issues that play a role in the failure or success of a synthetic peptide vaccine. The current state-of-the-art peptide vaccine is a complete synthetic inflammatory product that is ingested by professional antigen-presenting cells and stimulates both CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells.

Identification of T-cell epitopes for cancer immunotherapy

The effectiveness of T-cell-mediated immunotherapy of cancer depends on both an optimal immunostimulatory context of the therapy and the proper selection with respect to quality and quantity of the targeted tumor-associated antigens (TAA), and, more precisely, the T-cell epitopes contained in these tumor proteins. Our progressing insight in human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I and class II antigen processing and presentation mechanisms has improved the prediction by reverse immunology of novel cytotoxic T lymphocyte and T-helper cell epitopes within known antigens. Computer algorithms that in silico predict HLA class I and class II binding, proteasome cleavage patterns and transporter associated with antigen processing translocation are now available to expedite epitope identification. The advent of genomics allows a high-throughput screening for tumor-specific transcripts and mutations, with that identifying novel shared and unique TAA. The increasing power of mass spectrometry and proteomics will lead to the direct identification from the tumor cell surface of numerous novel tumor-specific HLA class I and class II presented ligands. Together, the expanded repertoire of tumor-specific T-cell epitopes will enable more precise immunomonitoring and the development of effective epitope-defined adoptive T-cell transfer and multi-epitope-based vaccination strategies targeting epitopes derived from a wider diversity of TAA presented in a broader array of HLA molecules.

Dormant Tumor Cells Develop Cross-Resistance to Apoptosis Induced by CTLs or Imatinib Mesylate via Methylation of Suppressor of Cytokine Signaling 1

In the BCR/ABL DA1-3b mouse model of acute myelogenous leukemia, dormant tumor cells may persist in the host in a state of equilibrium with the CD8(+) CTL-mediated immune response by actively inhibiting T cells. Dormant tumor cells also show a progressive decrease of suppressor of cytokine signaling 1 (SOCS1) gene expression and a deregulation of the Janus-activated kinase/signal transducers and activators of transcription (JAK/STAT) pathway due to methylation of the SOCS1 gene. Dormant tumor cells were more resistant to apoptosis induced by specific CTLs, but resistance decreased when SOCS1 expression was restored via demethylation or gene transfer. AG490 JAK2 inhibitor decreased the resistance of dormant tumor cells to CTLs, but MG132 proteasome inhibitor was effective only in SOCS1-transfected cells. Thus, SOCS1 regulation of the JAK/STAT pathways contributes to the resistance of tumor cells to CTL-mediated killing. Resistance of dormant tumor cells to apoptosis was also observed when induced by irradiation, cytarabine, or imatinib mesylate, but was reduced by SOCS1 gene transfer. This cross-resistance to apoptosis was induced by interleukin 3 (IL-3) overproduction by dormant tumor cells and was reversed with an anti-IL-3 antibody. Thus, tumor cells that remain dormant for long periods in the host in spite of a specific CTL immune response may deregulate their JAK/STAT pathways and develop cross-resistance to various treatments through an IL-3 autocrine loop. These data suggest possible new therapeutic targets to eradicate dormant tumor cells.

HER-2/neu antigen loss and relapse of mammary carcinoma are actively induced by T cell-mediated anti-tumor immune responses

Induction of tumor-specific immune responses results in the inhibition of tumor development. However, tumors recur because of the tumor immunoediting process that facilitates development of escape mechanisms in tumors. It is not known whether tumor escape is an active process whereby anti-tumor immune responses induce loss or downregulation of the target antigen in the antigen-positive clones. To address this question, we used rat neu-overexpressing mouse mammary carcinoma (MMC) and its relapsed neu antigen-negative variant (ANV). ANV emerged from MMC under pressure from neu-specific T cell responses in vivo. We then cloned residual neu antigen-negative cells from MMC and residual neu antigen-positive cells from ANV. We found marked differences between these neu-negative clones and ANV, demonstrating that the residual neu-negative clones are probably not the origin of ANV. Since initial rejection of MMC was associated with the presence of IFN-gamma-secreting T cells, we treated MMC with IFN-gamma and showed that IFN-gamma could induce downregulation of neu expression in MMC. This appears to be due to methylation of the neu promoter. Together, these data suggest that neu antigen loss is an active process that occurs in primary tumors due to the neu-targeted anti-tumor immune responses.

Cancer vaccines and tumor dormancy: a long-term struggle between host antitumor immunity and persistent cancer cells?

Tumor dormancy is a phenomenon characterized by the persistence of residual cancer cells for long periods in the host. Evidence has emerged that a balance exists between the immune response and dormant tumor cells. This review presents our current understanding of the immune relationship between host and dormant tumor cells and the mechanism developed by these cells to escape host antitumor immunity. Implications of this immune escape for cancer vaccine strategy are considered.

Immune selective pressure and HLA class I antigen defects in malignant lesions

The revived cancer immune surveillance theory has emphasized the active role the immune system plays in eliminating tumor cells and in facilitating the emergence of their immunoresistant variants. MHC class I molecule abnormalities represent, at least in part, the molecular phenotype of these escape variants, given the crucial role of MHC class I molecules in eliciting tumor antigen-specific T cell responses, the high frequency of HLA class I antigen abnormalities in malignant lesions and their association with a poor clinical course of the disease. Here, we present evidence for this possibility and review the potential mechanisms by which T cell selective pressure participates in the generation of tumor cells with MHC class I molecule defects. Furthermore, we discuss the strategies to counteract tumor cell immune evasion.

CD8-mediated type 1 antitumor responses selectively modulate endogenous differentiated and nondifferentiated T cell localization, activation, and function in progressive breast cancer

CD8 T cell-mediated immune responses fall into two distinct types based on effector cell-derived cytokine production. Type I CD8 T cells (Tc1) produce IFN-gamma, whereas type 2 cells (Tc2) secrete IL-4, IL-5, IL-10, and GM-CSF. Using a murine TCR transgenic T cell/breast tumor model, we show that adoptively transferred Ag-specific Tc1 cells are more effective in delaying mammary tumor growth and progression than that of functionally distinct Tc2 cells. Donor Tc1 cells administered 7 days posttumor challenge localized and persisted at sites of primary tumor growth with antitumor responses that were dependent, in part, on effector cell-derived IFN-gamma. Tc1-mediated responses markedly enhanced the appearance and local accumulation of highly differentiated (CD44(high)) CD4 and CD8 endogenous tumor-infiltrating T cells when compared with that of untreated tumor-bearing mice. Conversely, Tc1 cell transfer markedly delayed the appearance of corresponding nondifferentiated (CD44(low)) endogenous T cells. Such cells were acutely activated as defined by coexpression of surface markers associated with TCR engagement (CD69) and early T cell activation (CD25). Moreover, cellular response kinetics appeared to further correlate with the up-regulation of endogenous T cells producing the chemokine IFN-gamma-inducible protein-10 in vivo. This suggested that CD8-mediated type 1 antitumor responses cannot only promote accumulation of distinct endogenous CD4 and CD8 T cell subpopulations, but also facilitate and preferentially modulate their localization kinetics, persistence, states of activation/differentiation, and function within the primary tumor environment at various stages of tumor progression. These studies offer insight into potential mechanisms for enhancing T cell-based immunotherapy in breast cancer.

Induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes against pediatric solid tumors in vitro using autologous dendritic cells pulsed with necrotic primary tumor

PURPOSE

Effective and generally applicable methods for generating cancer vaccines in children have not been defined. Dendritic cells (DCs) are the most potent professional antigen-presenting cells capable of activating primary cytolytic T cells. We tested the ability of DCs generated from pediatric patients' peripheral blood monocytes and pulsed with a necrotic tumor to activate autologous tumor-specific cytolytic T cells.

METHODS

Tumor and peripheral blood cells were obtained from pediatric patients undergoing biopsy or resection for advanced solid tumors according to an institutional research board-approved protocol and after acquiring informed consent from them. To generate DCs, we treated peripheral blood monocytes with granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor and interleukin (IL)-4. Maturation was induced with a cytokine cocktail (CC) containing tumor necrosis factor-alpha, IL-6, IL-1beta, and prostaglandin E2. The DC phenotype was assayed using flow cytometry. Tumor necrosis was induced by exposure to UV-B irradiation (1000 mJ). Dendritic cells pulsed with a UV-B-treated primary tumor and matured with CC were used to stimulate autologous peripheral blood lymphocytes weekly. Tumor-specific cytolytic activity was assayed using 4-hour 51Cr release.

RESULTS

Peripheral blood monocytes isolated from pediatric patients differentiated into immature DCs (CD14-, MHCII+ [major histocompatibility complex], CD80(low), CD86(low)) in the presence of granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor and IL-4. Cytokine cocktail induced maturation of DCs, as characterized by increased expressions of MHCII, CD83, CD80, and CD86. Patients' peripheral blood lymphocytes stimulated in vitro with DCs loaded with a necrotic primary tumor and matured with CC specifically lysed autologous neuroblastoma in 7 of 9 patients.

CONCLUSION

Dendritic cells generated from the peripheral blood of children with advanced solid tumors and pulsed with a necrotic primary tumor undergo maturation and effectively stimulate autologous tumor-specific cytolytic T cells in vitro. We describe a simple method for generating a vaccine capable of activating cytotoxic T cells against pediatric solid tumors that does not require the genetic identification of tumor-associated antigens.

MHC Class I Antigens and Immune Surveillance in Transformed Cells

MHC class I antigens play a crucial role in the interaction of tumor cells with the host immune system, in particular, in the presentation of peptides as tumor-associated antigens to cytotoxic lymphocytes (CTLs) and in the regulation of cytolytic activity of natural killer (NK) cells. In this review we discuss the role of MHC class I antigens in the recognition and elimination of transformed cells and in the generation of tumor immune escape routes when MHC class I losses occur in tumors. The different altered MHC class I phenotypes and their distribution in different human tumors are the main topic of this review. In addition, molecular defects that underlie MHC alterations in transformed cells are also described in detail. Future research directions in this field are also discussed, including the laboratory analysis of tumor MHC class I-negative variants and the possible restoration of MHC class I expression.

Inhibition of human tumor-infiltrating lymphocyte effector functions by the homophilic carcinoembryonic cell adhesion molecule 1 interactions

Efficient antitumor immune response requires the coordinated function of integrated immune components, but is finally exerted by the differentiated effector tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL). TIL cells comprise, therefore, an exciting platform for adoptive cell transfer (ACT) in cancer. In this study, we show that the inhibitory carcinoembryonic Ag cell adhesion molecule 1 (CEACAM1) protein is found on virtually all human TIL cells following preparation protocols of ACT treatment for melanoma. We further demonstrate that the CEACAM1 homophilic interactions inhibit the TIL effector functions, such as specific killing and IFN-gamma release. These results suggest that CEACAM1 may impair in vivo the antitumor response of the differentiated TIL. Importantly, CEACAM1 is commonly expressed by melanoma and its presence is associated with poor prognosis. Remarkably, the prolonged coincubation of reactive TIL cells with their melanoma targets results in increased functional CEACAM1 expression by the surviving tumor cells. This mechanism might be used by melanoma cells in vivo to evade ongoing destruction by tumor-reactive lymphocytes. Finally, CEACAM1-mediated inhibition may hinder in many cases the efficacy of TIL ACT treatment of melanoma. We show that the intensity of CEACAM1 expression on TIL cells constantly increases during ex vivo expansion. The implications of CEACAM1-mediated inhibition of TIL cells on the optimization of current ACT protocols and on the development of future immunotherapeutic modalities are discussed.

Effects of the tumor microenvironment on the efficacy of tumor immunotherapy

Cancer immunotherapy utilizes vaccines targeting tumor antigens or tumor endothelium to prevent or regress tumors. Many cancer vaccines are designed to induce antigen-specific effector T cells that migrate to the tumor site. In an optimal situation, the effector T cells penetrate the tumor, release their effector molecules, induce tumor cell death and tumor regression. However, the tumor microenvironment is frequently immunosuppressive and contributes to a state of immune ignorance, impacting on the vaccine's ability to break tolerance to tumor antigen/s. This review discusses the factors in the tumor microenvironment that can affect the efficacy of cancer vaccines. In particular, the review focuses on pathways leading to effector T cell penetration of tumors or the inhibition of this process.

Lentiviral vector expression of tumour antigens in dendritic cells as an immunotherapeutic strategy

Therapeutic cancer vaccines need to stimulate a refractory immune system to make an effective anti-tumour response. We have explored the use of lentiviral vectors to deliver tumour antigen genes to dendritic cells (DC) as a possible mechanism of immune stimulation. Direct injection of a lentiviral vector encoding the melanoma antigen NY-ESO-1 in HLA-A2 transgenic mice primed NY-ESO-1-specific CD8+ cells that could be expanded by boosting with an NY-ESO-1 vaccinia virus. The expanded cells could kill NY-ESO-1(157-165) peptide-pulsed targets in vivo. In order to examine the priming step directly, we constructed another lentiviral vector expressing the melanoma antigen Melan-A (MART-1). Here we show that Melan-A protein is also efficiently expressed after transduction of human DC cultured from peripheral blood mononuclear cells. When these transduced DC are co-cultured with autologous naïve T cells, they cause the expansion of cells that recognise the HLA-A2 restricted Melan-A(27-35) epitope. The expanded cells are functional in that they release IFN-gamma upon antigen stimulation. Melan-A lentiviral vector transduced DC caused a similar level of naïve T-cell expansion to Melan-A(27-35) peptide-pulsed DC in four experiments using different HLA-A2 positive donors. These data suggest that a vaccine based either on DC transduced with a lentiviral vector ex vivo, or on direct lentiviral vector injection, should be assessed in a phase I clinical trial.

Immunomodulation of the melanoma sentinel lymph node: a novel adjuvant therapeutic option

Cutaneous melanoma is the most aggressive type of skin cancer. Paradoxically, melanoma is also the most immunogenic tumour identified to date: tumour-reactive T cells are detectable both in the blood and in tumour-draining lymph nodes (TDLN) of melanoma patients and their frequency can be increased by specific vaccination. However, early melanoma development is accompanied by impaired immune effector functions in the initial TDLN, the sentinel lymph node (SLN). Most notably, a reduced frequency and activation state of dendritic cells (DC) interferes with the uptake and presentation of tumour-associated antigens (TAA) to specific anti-tumour cytotoxic T-lymphocytes (CTL) and T helper cells (Th). These impaired immune effector functions may contribute to the early metastatic events that are associated with this tumour type. Since complete surgical excision at an early stage remains the only curative treatment option (adjuvant therapy options are limited and show no survival benefits), immunopotentiation of the SLN to jump-start or boost tumour specific immunity in early stage melanoma may be a valuable adjuvant treatment option that can be generally applied with minimal discomfort to the patient. Early clinical studies indicate that local Granulocyte/Macrophage-Colony Stimulating Factor (GM-CSF) or Cytosine-phosphate-Guanine (CpG) administration leads to activation of different DC subsets and conditions the SLN microenvironment to be more conducive to the generation of T-cell-mediated anti-tumour immunity.

Defective Human Leukocyte Antigen Class I-associated Antigen Presentation Caused by a Novel β2-Microglobulin Loss-of-function in Melanoma Cells

The major histocompatibility complex class I molecules consist of three subunits, the 45-kDa heavy chain, the 12-kDa beta(2)-microglobulin (beta(2)m), and an approximately 8-9-residue antigenic peptide. Without beta(2)m, the major histocompatibility complex class I molecules cannot assemble, thereby abolishing their transport to the cell membrane and the subsequent recognition by antigen-specific T cells. Here we report a case of defective antigen presentation caused by the expression of a beta(2)m with a Cys-to-Trp substitution at position 25 (beta(2)m(C25W)). This substitution causes misfolding and degradation of beta(2)m(C25W) but does not result in complete lack of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I molecule expression on the surface of melanoma VMM5B cells. Despite HLA class I expression, VMM5B cells are not recognized by HLA class I-restricted, melanoma antigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes even following loading with exogenous peptides or transduction with melanoma antigen-expressing viruses. Lysis of VMM5B cells is restored only following reconstitution with exogenous or endogenous wild-type beta(2)m protein. Together, our results indicate impairment of antigenic peptide presentation because of a dysfunctional beta(2)m and provide a mechanism for the lack of close association between HLA class I expression and susceptibility of tumor cells to cytotoxic T lymphocytes-mediated lysis in malignant diseases.

Human T cell responses against melanoma

Many antigens recognized by autologous T lymphocytes have been identified on human melanoma. Melanoma patients usually mount a spontaneous T cell response against their tumor. But at some point, the responder T cells become ineffective, probably because of a local immunosuppressive process occurring at the tumor sites. Therapeutic vaccination of metastatic melanoma patients with these antigens is followed by tumor regressions only in a small minority of the patients. The T cell responses to the vaccines show correlation with the tumor regressions. The local immunosuppression may be the cause of the lack of vaccination effectiveness that is observed in most patients. In patients who do respond to the vaccine, the antivaccine T cells probably succeed in reversing focally this immunosuppression and trigger a broad activation of other antitumor T cells, which proceed to destroy the tumor.

Peptide and dendritic cell vaccines

There has been a rush to convert discovery of new melanoma antigens into cancer vaccines for the therapy of melanoma. The result has been disappointing from a clinical standpoint. The premise behind rapid pursuit of peptide vaccines for melanoma therapy was that the spontaneous tumor-associated immune response was too weak to be effective. However, it is increasingly clear that the host-tumor relationship is a complex interplay of immune response, immune escape, and immune adaptation, with multiple layers of regulatory control and modulation of responses over time. The lesion in the immune response to cancer is much more complex than simply a weak immune response to defined antigens. Current results should serve as a call to take a closer look at immune regulatory processes and principles and to develop more comprehensive and multiagent approaches to modulate the host-tumor relationship. Development of effective immune therapy for cancer will require (a) more comprehensive and real-time immune monitoring in various tissue compartments and (b) patient-specific modulation of immune responses, informed by the real-time monitoring. Peptide antigens associated with MHC class I or class II molecules are the molecular targets for T-cell recognition of cancer. To characterize the host-tumor relationship and to optimize cancer vaccines, clinical studies using defined peptide antigens offer special opportunities to advance the field and thus have an important place in the ongoing development of effective immune therapy of melanoma.

Immunodominance and Immunodomination: Critical Factors in Developing Effective CD8+ T‐Cell–Based Cancer Vaccines

The focusing of cellular immunity toward one, or just a few, antigenic determinant, even during immune responses to complex microorganisms or antigens, is known as immunodominance. Although described in many systems, the mechanisms of determinant immunodominance are only just beginning to be appreciated, especially in relation to the interplay between T cells of differing specificities and the interactions between T cells and the antigen-presenting cells (APCs). The outcome of these cellular interactions can lead to a form of immune suppression of one specificity by another-described as "immunodomination". The specific and detailed mechanisms involved in this process are now partly defined. A full understanding of all the factors that control immunodominance and influence immunodomination will help us to develop better viral and cancer vaccines.

Immunity to melanoma antigens: from self-tolerance to immunotherapy

The development of effective immune therapy for cancer is a central goal of immunologists in the 21st century. Our laboratories have been deeply involved in characterization of the immune response to melanoma and translation of laboratory discoveries into clinical trials. We have identified a cohort of peptide antigens presented by Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) molecules on melanoma cells and widely recognized by T cells from melanoma patients. These have been incorporated into peptide-based vaccines that induce CD8(+) and CD4(+) T-cell responses in 80-100% of patients. Major objective clinical tumor regressions have been observed in some patients, and overall survival in vaccinated patients exceeds expected stage-specific survival. New clinical trials will determine the value of combination of melanoma helper peptides (MHP) into multipeptide vaccines targeting CD8 cells. New trials will also evaluate new approaches to modulating the host-tumor relationship and will develop new combination therapies. Parallel investigations in murine models are elucidating the immunobiology of the melanoma-host relationship and addressing issues that are not feasible to approach in human trials. Based on the fact that the largest cohort of melanoma antigens are derived from normal proteins concerned with pigment production, we have evaluated the mechanisms of self-tolerance to tyrosinase (Tyr) and have determined how T cells in an environment of self-tolerance are impacted by immunization. Using peptide-pulsed dendritic cells as immunogens, we have also used the mouse model to establish strategies for quantitative and qualitative enhancement of antitumor immunity. This information creates opportunities for a new generation of therapeutic interventions using cancer vaccines.

Classical and nonclassical HLA class I antigen and NK Cell-activating ligand changes in malignant cells: current challenges and future directions

Changes in classical and nonclassical HLA class I antigen and NK cell-activating ligand expression have been identified in malignant lesions. These changes, which are described in this chapter, are believed to play a major role in the clinical course of the disease since both HLA class I antigens and NK cell-activating ligands are critical to the interaction between tumor cells and components of both innate and adaptive immune systems. Nevertheless, there is still debate in the literature about the biologic and functional significance of HLA class I antigen and NK cell-activating ligand abnormalities in malignant lesions. The reasons for this debate are reviewed. They include (i) the incomplete association between classical HLA class I antigen changes and the clinical course of the disease; (ii) the relatively limited number of malignant lesions that have been analyzed for nonclassical HLA class I antigen and NK cell-activating ligand expression; and (iii) the conflicting data regarding the role of immunoselection in the generation of malignant cells with HLA antigen and NK cell-activating ligand abnormalities. The technical limitations associated with the assessment of HLA antigen and NK cell-activating ligand expression in malignant lesions as well as the immunological and nonimmunological variables that may confound the impact of HLA antigen and NK cell-activating ligand changes on the clinical course of the disease are also discussed. Future studies aimed at overcoming these limitations and characterizing these variables are expected to provide a solution to the current debate regarding the significance of HLA class I antigen and NK cell-activating ligand abnormalities in malignant lesions.