CpG-island methylation in aging and cancer

Beyond Watson and Crick: DNA methylation and molecular enzymology of DNA methyltransferases

DNA methyltransferases catalyze the transfer of a methyl group from S-adenosyl-L-methionine to cytosine or adenine bases in DNA. These enzymes challenge the Watson/Crick dogma in two instances: 1) They attach inheritable information to the DNA that is not encoded in the nucleotide sequence. This so-called epigenetic information has many important biological functions. In prokaryotes, DNA methylation is used to coordinate DNA replication and the cell cycle, to direct postreplicative mismatch repair, and to distinguish self and nonself DNA. In eukaryotes, DNA methylation contributes to the control of gene expression, the protection of the genome against selfish DNA, maintenance of genome integrity, parental imprinting, X-chromosome inactivation in mammals, and regulation of development. 2) The enzymatic mechanism of DNA methyltransferases is unusual, because these enzymes flip their target base out of the DNA helix and, thereby, locally disrupt the B-DNA helix. This review describes the biological functions of DNA methylation in bacteria, fungi, plants, and mammals. In addition, the structures and mechanisms of the DNA methyltransferases, which enable them to specifically recognize their DNA targets and to induce such large conformational changes of the DNA, are discussed.

Gene silencing in mammalian cells and the spread of DNA methylation

Aberrant gene silencing in mammalian cells is associated with promoter region methylation, but the sequence of these two events is not clear. This review will consider the possibility that gene silencing is not a single event, but instead a series of events that begins with a dramatic drop in transcription potential and ends with its complete cessation. This transition will be portrayed as a chaotic process that ensues when transcription levels drop and DNA methylation begins spreading haltingly towards the diminished promoter. According to this view, silencing is stabilized when the promoter region is 'captured' by the spread of DNA methylation near or into its transcription factor binding sites.

Methylation reveals a niche: stem cell succession in human colon crypts

Little it known about human stem cells although they are likely to be the earliest progenitors of carcinomas. Just as methylation can substitute for mutations to inactivate tumor suppressor genes, methylation can also substitute for mutations in a phylogenetic analysis. This review explains why stem cell dynamics may be important to tumor progression and how methylation patterns found in a normal human colon can be used to reconstruct the behavior of crypt stem cells. Histories are recorded in sequences and strategies used to reconstruct phylogenies from sequences likely apply to methylation patterns because both exhibit somatic inheritance. Such a quantitative analysis of colon methylation patterns infers stem cells live in niches containing multiple 'stem' cells. Although niche stem cell numbers remain constant, clonal succession is inherent to niches because periodically progeny from a single stem cell become dominant. These niche succession cycles may potentially accumulate multiple alterations because they resemble superficially the clonal succession of tumor progression except that they occur invisibly in the absence of selection or phenotypic change. Alterations without immediate selective value may hitchhike passively in the stem cells that become dominant during niche succession cycles. The inherent ability of a niche to fix alterations (Muller's ratchet) is another potential mechanism besides instability and selection to sequentially accumulate multiple alterations. Many alterations found in colorectal tumors may reflect such occult clonal progression in normal colon.

DNA methylation analysis: a powerful new tool for lung cancer diagnosis

Carcinoma of the lung is the most common cause of cancer death worldwide. The estimated 5-year survival ranges from 6-16%, depending on the cell type. The best opportunity for improving survival of lung cancer patients is through early detection, when curative surgical resection is possible. Although the subjects at increased risk for developing carcinoma of the lung (long-term smokers) can be identified, only 10-20% of this group will ultimately develop the disease. Screening tests of long-term smokers employed to date (radiography and sputum cytology) have not been successful in reducing lung cancer mortality. The application of molecular markers specific for lung cancer offers new possibilities for early detection. Hypermethylation of CpG islands in the promoter regions of genes is a common phenomenon in lung cancer, as demonstrated by the analysis of the methylation status of over 40 genes from lung cancer tumors, cell lines, patient sputum and/or serum. Determination of the methylation patterns of multiple genes to obtain complex DNA methylation signatures promises to provide a highly sensitive and specific tool for lung cancer diagnosis. When combined with the development of non-invasive methods to detect such signatures, this may provide a viable method to screen subjects at risk for lung cancer.

Promoter methylation status of E-cadherin, hMLH1, and p16 genes in nonneoplastic gastric epithelia

Silencing of tumor suppressor and tumor-related genes by hypermethylation at promoter CpG islands is one of the major events in human tumorigenesis. Promoter methylation is also present in nonneoplastic cells as an age-related tissue-specific phenomenon that precedes the development of neoplasia. To clarify the significance of promoter methylation in nonneoplastic gastric epithelia as a precancerous signal, we investigated promoter methylation status of E-cadherin, hMLH1, and p16 genes in nonneoplastic cells of various organs obtained at autopsy, and compared the results with those of nonneoplastic epithelia of a cancerous stomach. Methylation of these genes was not seen in nonneoplastic cells of organs from people who were 22 years and younger (0%, 0 of 6). In contrast, E-cadherin and p16 were methylated in nonneoplastic gastric epithelia of persons who were 45 years or older. The numbers were 86% (12 of 14) and 29% (4 of 14), respectively. E-cadherin methylation occurred preferentially in the intestines, whereas p16 methylation was almost restricted to the stomach. For samples obtained from patients with stomach cancer, methylation was frequently observed in both neoplastic and corresponding nonneoplastic gastric epithelia: 47% (44 of 94) and 67% (63 of 94) for E-cadherin, 32% (30 of 94) and 24% (23 of 94) for hMLH1, and 22% (21 of 94) and 44% (41 of 94) for p16, respectively. hMLH1 methylation was not seen in nonneoplastic gastric epithelia from autopsy samples but occurred significantly in samples from nonneoplastic tissues of individuals with stomach cancer. Therefore, detection of hMLH1 methylation in nonneoplastic gastric epithelia may be useful for screening patients who may be at risk of developing gastric cancer.

Inactivation of p57KIP2 by regional promoter hypermethylation and histone deacetylation in human tumors

To clarify the role of DNA methylation in the silencing of the expression of cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor p57KIP2 seen in certain tumors, we investigated the methylation status of its 5' CpG island in various tumor cell lines and primary cancers. Dense methylation of the region around the transcription start site was detected in 1 out of 10 colorectal, 2 out of 8 gastric, and 6 out of 14 hematopoietic tumor cell lines and in 5 out of 35 (14%) gastric, 6 out of 20 (30%) hepatocellular, and 2 out of 18 (11%) pancreatic cancers; 7 out of 25 (28%) acute myeloid leukemia cases also showed methylation of the p57KIP2 gene, which strongly correlated with the CpG island methylator phenotype (P<0.001). Detailed mapping revealed that dense methylation of the region around the transcription start site (-300 to +400), but not of the edges of the CpG island, was closely associated with gene silencing. 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine, a methyltransferase inhibitor, restored expression of p57KIP2, and chromatin immunoprecipitation using anti-histone H3 and H4 antibodies showed histone to be deacetylated in cell lines where p57KIP2 was methylated at the transcription start site. Regional methylation and histone deacetylation thus appear to be crucially involved in the silencing of p57KIP2 expression in human tumors.

HLTF gene silencing in human colon cancer

Chromatin remodeling enzymes are increasingly implicated in a variety of important cellular functions. Various components of chromatin remodeling complexes, including several members of the SWI/SNF family, have been shown to be disrupted in cancer. In this study we identified as a target for gene inactivation in colon cancer the gene for helicase-like transcription factor (HLTF), a SWI/SNF family protein. Loss of HLTF expression accompanied by HLTF promoter methylation was noted in nine of 34 colon cancer cell lines. In these cell lines HLTF expression was restored by treatment with the demethylating agent 5-azacytidine. In further studies of primary colon cancer tissues, HLTF methylation was detected in 27 of 63 cases (43%). No methylation of HLTF was detected in breast or lung cancers, suggesting selection for HLTF methylation in colonic malignancies. Transfection of HLTF suppressed 75% of colony growth in each of three different HLTF-deficient cell lines, but showed no suppressive effect in any of three HLTF-proficient cell lines. These findings show that HLTF is a common target for methylation and epigenetic gene silencing in colon cancer and suggest HLTF is a candidate colon cancer suppressor gene.

Beyond Watson and Crick: DNA methylation and molecular enzymology of DNA methyltransferases

DNA methyltransferases catalyze the transfer of a methyl group from S-adenosyl-L-methionine to cytosine or adenine bases in DNA. These enzymes challenge the Watson/Crick dogma in two instances: 1) They attach inheritable information to the DNA that is not encoded in the nucleotide sequence. This so-called epigenetic information has many important biological functions. In prokaryotes, DNA methylation is used to coordinate DNA replication and the cell cycle, to direct postreplicative mismatch repair, and to distinguish self and nonself DNA. In eukaryotes, DNA methylation contributes to the control of gene expression, the protection of the genome against selfish DNA, maintenance of genome integrity, parental imprinting, X-chromosome inactivation in mammals, and regulation of development. 2) The enzymatic mechanism of DNA methyltransferases is unusual, because these enzymes flip their target base out of the DNA helix and, thereby, locally disrupt the B-DNA helix. This review describes the biological functions of DNA methylation in bacteria, fungi, plants, and mammals. In addition, the structures and mechanisms of the DNA methyltransferases, which enable them to specifically recognize their DNA targets and to induce such large conformational changes of the DNA, are discussed.

Hypermethylation of the hMLH1 gene promoter in solitary and multiple gastric cancers with microsatellite instability

Human cancers with a high frequency microsatellite instability phenotype develop due to defects in DNA mismatch repair genes. Silencing of a DNA mismatch repair gene, hMLH1 gene, by promoter hypermethylation is a frequent cause of the microsatellite instability-H phenotype. Using methylation specific PCR we investigated the methylation status of the hMLH1 gene promoter in 17 solitary gastric cancers (12 microsatellite instability-H and five microsatellite stable tumours from 17 patients), and 13 multiple gastric cancers (eight microsatellite instability-H, one low frequency microsatellite instability-L and four microsatellite stable tumours from five patients) and also examined non-cancerous gastric mucosa both adjacent to and distant from each tumour. Expression of hMLH1 protein was evaluated by immunohistochemistry. All microsatellite instability-H tumours (20 out of 20) had evidence of methylation of hMLH1 promoter, whereas only one out of 10 microsatellite instability-L and microsatellite stable tumours did (P<0.0000005), and the methylation status correlated with hMLH1 protein expression (P<0.000003). Furthermore, methylation of the hMLH1 promoter was detected in 50% (6 out of 12) and 63% (5 out of 8) of non-cancerous gastric mucosa samples adjacent to, and in 33% (4 out of 12) and 40% (2 out of 5) of those obtained from distant portion of, solitary and multiple cancers with microsatellite instability-H. Thus both solitary and multiple gastric cancers with microsatellite instability-H have evidence of similar high levels of hMLH1 promoter hypermethylation in the surrounding non-cancerous tissue. Hypermethylation of the hMLH1 promoter occurs in non-cancerous gastric mucosa of microsatellite instability-H tumours and may increase the risk of subsequent neoplasia.

Structure and activity of a thermostable thymine-DNA glycosylase: evidence for base twisting to remove mismatched normal DNA bases

The repair of T:G mismatches in DNA is key for maintaining bacterial restriction/modification systems and gene silencing in higher eukaryotes. T:G mismatch repair can be initiated by a specific mismatch glycosylase (MIG) that is homologous to the helix-hairpin-helix (HhH) DNA repair enzymes. Here, we present a 2.0 A resolution crystal structure and complementary mutagenesis results for this thermophilic HhH MIG enzyme. The results suggest that MIG distorts the target thymine nucleotide by twisting the thymine base approximately 90 degrees away from its normal anti position within DNA. We propose that functionally significant differences exist in DNA repair enzyme extrahelical nucleotide binding and catalysis that are characteristic of whether the target base is damaged or is a normal base within a mispair. These results explain why pure HhH DNA glycosylases and combined glycosylase/AP lyases cannot be interconverted by simply altering their functional group chemistry, and how broad-specificity DNA glycosylase enzymes may weaken the glycosylic linkage to allow a variety of damaged DNA bases to be excised.

Lsh, a member of the SNF2 family, is required for genome-wide methylation

Methylation patterns of the mammalian genome are thought to be crucial for development. The precise mechanisms designating specific genomic loci for methylation are not known. Targeted deletion of Lsh results in perinatal lethality with a rather normal development. We report here, however, that Lsh(-/-) mice show substantial loss of methylation throughout the genome. The hypomethylated loci comprise repetitive elements and single copy genes. This suggests that global genomic methylation is not absolutely required for normal embryogenesis. Based on the similarity of Lsh to other SNF2 chromatin remodeling proteins, it suggests that alteration of chromatin affects global methylation patterns in mice.

Regulation of the DNA methylation machinery and its role in cellular transformation

DNA methylation, a covalent modification of the genome, is emerging as an important player in the regulation of gene expression. This review discusses the different components of the DNA methylation machinery responsible for replicating the DNA methylation pattern. Recent data have changed our basic understanding of the DNA methylation machinery. A number of DNA methyltransferases (DNMT) have been identified and a demethylase has recently been reported. Because the DNA methylation pattern is critical for gene expression programs, the cell possesses a number of mechanisms to coordinate DNA replication and methylation. DNMT1 levels are regulated with the cell cycle and are induced upon entry into the S phase of the cell cycle. DNMT1 also regulates expression of cell-cycle proteins by its other regulatory functions and not through its DNA methylation activity. Once the mechanisms that coordinate DNMT1 and the cell cycle are disrupted, DNMT1 exerts an oncogenic activity. Tumor suppressor genes are frequently methylated in cancer but the mechanisms responsible are unclear. Overexpression of DNMT1 is probably not responsible for the aberrant methylation of tumor suppressor genes. Unraveling how the different components of the DNA methylation machinery interact to replicate the DNA methylation pattern, and how they are disrupted in cancer, is critical for understanding the molecular mechanisms of cancer.

Susceptibility of nonpromoter CpG islands to de novo methylation in normal and neoplastic cells

BACKGROUND

Many cancers display alterations in methylation patterns of CpG islands--stretches of DNA rich in CpG dinucleotides often associated with gene promoters that are involved in initiation of gene transcription. This methylation may perturb expression of genes critical to the regulation of cell proliferation. Aberrant methylation is not limited to a few genes or to promoter regions but has been found on a genome-wide scale in a variety of neoplasias, including colorectal cancer and acute myelogenous leukemia. Our goal was to characterize, in a quantitative manner, the profiles of abnormally methylated genes that may be specific for different cancers.

METHODS

Using a quantitative assay, methylation-sensitive single nucleotide primer extension (MS-SNuPE), we have analyzed the methylation levels of promoter and exonic (coding region) CpG islands of two cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors [p15(INK4B) and p16(INK4A)] and the PAX6 gene, which encodes a transcriptional factor involved in neuronal proliferation, in DNA samples taken from patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia, acute myelogenous leukemia, myelodysplastic syndrome, and colorectal cancer.

RESULTS

De novo methylation of all three exonic loci in tumors--relative to baseline levels found in nontumor tissue or blood--was observed in hematologic neoplasias and in solid tumors as well as in normal colonic tissue. However, methylation of promoter regions was more limited. Moreover, two different patterns of promoter methylation distinguished the leukemias from colorectal cancer: p15 promoter hypermethylation was found only in the leukemias, and p16 promoter hypermethylation occurred only in colon tumors. However, we did not address this issue prospectively; therefore, such an observation is only hypothesis generating.

CONCLUSIONS

The methylation patterns that we observed suggest that exonic CpG islands are more susceptible to de novo methylation than promoter islands and that methylation may be seeded in exonic regions, from which it can spread to other islands, including promoter regions. Subsequent selection of cells with a growth advantage conferred by spread of methylation into and inactivation of a particular promoter might then contribute to the genesis of a specific type of cancer.

MMTV promoter hypomethylation is linked to spontaneous and MNU associated c-neu expression and mammary carcinogenesis in MMTV c-neu transgenic mice

The erbB family of receptor tyrosine kinases is frequently implicated in neoplasia. Amplification and overexpression of erbB2/neu has been found in 20 to 40% of human breast cancers. Previous studies using MMTV/c-neu transgenic mice have linked rat neu overexpression to mammary tumor development. In this study, we provide evidence that rat neu overexpression in mammary tumors of MMTV/c-neu transgenic mice is always associated with demethylation of the MMTV promoter, whereas the normal mammary glands of these transgenic mice always contain specific methylated regions of the MMTV promoter. In addition, after exposure to N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU), the latency of mammary tumor development is significantly reduced and again is also associated with MMTV promoter demethylation. Thus, the transition from methylation to hypomethylation of the MMTV promoter induces high-level expression of c-neu and appears to be a prerequisite for transformation from normal to malignant mammary epithelium, either spontaneously or after carcinogen exposure. Expression of transgenic c-neu from the demethylated MMTV promoter appears to be an early event that allows outgrowth of mammary epithelium predisposed to malignant transformation.

Methylation and colorectal cancer

Statistics rate colorectal adenocarcinoma as the most common cause of cancer death on exclusion of smoking-related neoplasia. However, the reported accumulation of genetic lesions over the adenoma to adenocarcinoma sequence cannot wholly account for the neoplastic phenotype. Recently, heritable, epigenetic changes in DNA methylation, in association with a repressive chromatin structure, have been identified as critical determinants of tumour progression. Indeed, the transcriptional silencing of both established and novel tumour suppressor genes has been attributed to the aberrant cytosine methylation of promoter-region CpG islands. This review aims to set these epigenetic changes within the context of the colorectal adenoma to adenocarcinoma sequence. The role of cytosine methylation in physiological and pathological gene silencing is discussed and the events behind aberrant cytosine methylation in ageing and cancer are appraised. Emphasis is placed on the interrelationships between epigenetic and genetic lesions and the manner in which they cooperate to define a CpG island methylator phenotype at an early stage in tumourigenesis. Finally, the applications of epigenetics to molecular pathology and patient diagnosis and treatment are reviewed.

Hypermethylation of CpG islands in the mouse asparagine synthetase gene: relationship to asparaginase sensitivity in lymphoma cells. Partial methylation in normal cells

We have sequenced the promoter region of the murine asparagine synthetase gene and examined its methylation profile in the CpG islands of L-asparaginase-sensitive 6C3HED cells (asparagine auxotrophs) and resistant variants (prototrophs). In the former, complete methylation of the CpG island is correlated with failure of expression of mRNA: cells of the latter possess both methylated and unmethylated alleles, as do cells of the intrinsically asparagine-independent lines L1210 and EL4. A similar phenomenon was seen in normal splenic cells of adult mice. This was age related: no methylation was found in weanlings, but up to 45% of gene copies in animals 18 weeks or older were methylated. It was also tissue related, with methylation occurring rarely in liver cells. The relationship of these changes to oncogenesis is considered.

Adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) gene promoter hypermethylation in primary breast cancers

Similar to findings in colorectal cancers, it has been suggested that disruption of the adenomatous polyposis coli (APC)/beta-catenin pathway may be involved in breast carcinogenesis. However, somatic mutations of APC and beta- catenin are infrequently reported in breast cancers, in contrast to findings in colorectal cancers. To further explore the role of the APC/beta-catenin pathway in breast carcinogenesis, we investigated the status of APC gene promoter methylation in primary breast cancers and in their non-cancerous breast tissue counterparts, as well as mutations of the APC and beta- catenin genes. Hypermethylation of the APC promoter CpG island was detected in 18 of 50 (36%) primary breast cancers and in none of 21 non-cancerous breast tissue samples, although no mutations of the APC and beta- catenin were found. No significant associations between APC promoter hypermethylation and patient age, lymph node metastasis, oestrogen and progesterone receptor status, size, stage or histological type of tumour were observed. These results indicate that APC promoter CpG island hypermethylation is a cancer-specific change and may be a more common mechanism of inactivation of this tumour suppressor gene in primary breast cancers than previously suspected.

Methylation matters

DNA methylation is not just for basic scientists any more. There is a growing awareness in the medical field that having the correct pattern of genomic methylation is essential for healthy cells and organs. If methylation patterns are not properly established or maintained, disorders as diverse as mental retardation, immune deficiency, and sporadic or inherited cancers may follow. Through inappropriate silencing of growth regulating genes and simultaneous destabilisation of whole chromosomes, methylation defects help create a chaotic state from which cancer cells evolve. Methylation defects are present in cells before the onset of obvious malignancy and therefore cannot be explained simply as a consequence of a deregulated cancer cell. Researchers are now able to detect with exquisite sensitivity the cells harbouring methylation defects, sometimes months or years before the time when cancer is clinically detectable. Furthermore, aberrant methylation of specific genes has been directly linked with the tumour response to chemotherapy and patient survival. Advances in our ability to observe the methylation status of the entire cancer cell genome have led us to the unmistakable conclusion that methylation abnormalities are far more prevalent than expected. This methylomics approach permits the integration of an ever growing repertoire of methylation defects with the genetic alterations catalogued from tumours over the past two decades. Here we discuss the current knowledge of DNA methylation in normal cells and disease states, and how this relates directly to our current understanding of the mechanisms by which tumours arise.