Structural analysis of human alpha-class glutathione transferase A1-1 in the apo-form and in complexes with ethacrynic acid and its glutathione conjugate

Role of the C-terminal helix 9 in the stability and ligandin function of class alpha glutathione transferase A1-1

Helix 9 at the C-terminus of class alpha glutathione transferase (GST) polypeptides is a unique structural feature in the GST superfamily. It plays an important structural role in the catalytic cycle. Its contribution toward protein stability/folding as well as the binding of nonsubstrate ligands was investigated by protein engineering, conformational stability, enzyme activity, and ligand-binding methods. The helix9 sequence displays an unfavorable propensity toward helix formation, but tertiary interactions between the amphipathic helix and the GST seem to contribute sufficient stability to populate the helix on the surface of the protein. The helix's stability is enhanced further by the binding of ligands at the active site. The order of ligand-induced stabilization increases from H-site occupation, to G-site occupation, to the simultaneous occupation of H- and G-sites. Ligand-induced stabilization of helix9 reduces solvent accessible hydrophobic surface by facilitating firmer packing at the hydrophobic interface between helix and GST. This stabilized form exhibits enhanced affinity for the binding of nonsubstrate ligands to ligandin sites (i.e., noncatalytic binding sites). Although helix9 contributes very little toward the global stability of hGSTA1-1, its conformational dynamics have significant implications for the protein's equilibrium unfolding/refolding pathway and unfolding kinetics. Considering the high concentration of reduced glutathione in human cells (about 10 mM), the physiological form of hGSTA1-1 is most likely the thiol-complexed protein with a stabilized helix9. The C-terminus region (including helix9) of the class alpha polypeptide appears not to have been optimized for stability but rather for catalytic and ligandin function.

Glutathione S-transferase catalyzes the isomerization of (R)-2-hydroxymenthofuran to mintlactones

(R)-(+)-Menthofuran is the proximate toxic metabolite of pulegone, the major constituent of the pennyroyal oil, that contributes significantly to the hepatotoxicity resulting from ingestion of this folklore abortifacient pennyroyal oil. Recently, menthofuran was shown to be metabolized by cytochrome P450 to form (R)-2-hydroxymenthofuran. In this paper it is demonstrated that glutathione S-transferase (GST) catalyzes the tautomerization of 2-hydroxymenthofuran to mintlactone and isomintlactone, apparently without the formation of stable glutathione (GSH) conjugates. The reaction strictly required GSH; S-methyl GSH, which binds to the active site and leaves the active site Tyr-9 partly ionized, did not support GST-catalyzed isomerization. It was also determined that the tautomerization reaction requires the active site tyrosine, Tyr-9. The rat GSTA1-1 mutant (Y9F), with the active site tyrosine replaced with phenylalanine, demonstrated no catalytic activity. Rat cytosolic GST A1-1, in the presence of GSH, tautomerized 2-hydroxymenthofuran with apparent K(M) and V(max) values of 110 microM and 190 nmol/min/nmol GST, respectively. However, the site-directed mutant (F220Y), in which Tyr-9 and GSH in the binary complex [GST. GSH] have lower pK(a)s, exhibited K(M) and V(max) values of 97 microM and 280 nmol/min/nmol GST, respectively. Similarly, human liver cytosol catalyzed the tautomerization of 2-hydroxymenthofuran in a GST-dependent reaction. The mechanism most consistent with the data is a general-base catalyzed isomerization with GS(-) serving to deprotonate the substrate to initiate the reaction.

Amino acid substitutions at positions 207 and 221 contribute to catalytic differences between murine glutathione S-transferase Al-1 and A2-2 toward (+)-anti-7,8-dihydroxy-9,10-epoxy-7,8,9, 10-tetrahydrobenzo[a]pyrene

We have previously identified a novel Alpha class murine glutathione (GSH) S-transferase isoenzyme (designated mGSTAl-2) which is exceptionally efficient in catalyzing the GSH conjugation of (+)-anti-7,8-dihydroxy-9,10-epoxy-7,8,9,10-tetrahydrobenzo[a]pyrene [(+)-anti-BPDE], the ultimate carcinogen of widespread environmental pollutant benzo[a]pyrene. Furthermore, we have demonstrated that the Al-type subunit of this isoenzyme is significantly more active toward (+)-anti-BPDE than the other subunit (mGSTA2). To establish the basis for catalytic differences between mGSTAl and mGSTA2, which differ in their primary structures by 10 amino acids [distributed in three sections (I-III) as clusters of two (residues 65 and 95), three (residues 157, 162, and 169), and five (residues 207, 213, 218, 221, and 222) amino acids], three chimeric enzymes were expressed and tested for their activity toward (+)-anti-BPDE. These studies revealed that amino acid substitution(s) in section III determined the high catalytic activity of mGSTAl. Molecular modeling studies suggested that amino acid substitutions at positions 207 and/or 221, but not at positions 213, 218, and 222, may be responsible for such a difference. To test this possibility, amino acids at positions 207 and 221 of mGSTAl were mutated with the equivalent residues of mGSTA2. Kinetic analysis of the wild type and the mutant enzymes revealed that both methionine-207 and isoleucine-221 are critical for higher activity of mGSTA1-1 toward (+)-anti-BPDE compared with that of mGSTA2-2.

High expression of bovine alpha glutathione S-transferase (GSTA1, GSTA2) subunits is mainly associated with steroidogenically active cells and regulated by gonadotropins in bovine ovarian follicles

We have previously shown that a major group of 28-30 kDa proteins decreases after the LH surge in bovine granulosa cells (GC). In the present study, we have characterized two proteins in this group in search of factors that may intervene in folliculogenesis and oocyte maturation. Polyclonal antibodies raised against 28 kDa or 29 kDa bovine GC proteins were used to screen a complementary DNA (cDNA) expression library. This resulted in the characterization of two isoenzyme subunits for alpha class glutathione S-transferase, named bGSTA1 and bGSTA2. Both bGSTA1 (25.4 kDa, pI 8.9; 791 bp cDNA; GenBank Accession No. BTU49179) and bGSTA2 (25.6 kDa, pI 7.2; 959 bp cDNA; GenBank Accession No. AF027386) have 222 amino acids. The deduced amino acid sequences were compared and showed 82% (bGSTA1) and 74% (bGSTA2) identity to human GSTA1, whereas bGSTA1 and bGSTA2 are 81% identical to each other. The bGSTA2 represents a novel GSTA subunit because it harbors a specific 16 amino acid sequence not found in any other species and GST classes. Northern blots showed that bGSTA1 and bGSTA2 are coexpressed and are tissue specific with single transcripts of 1.2 kb and 1.4 kb, respectively for bGSTA1 and bGSTA2. The messenger RNA (mRNA) were detected in GC, corpus luteum, adrenal gland, testis, liver, lung, thyroid, kidney and cotyledon, and the relative abundance of their mRNA varied. Ratios of bGSTA1/bGSTA2 mRNA vary between tisssues, indicating that expression of these genes is controlled differently. Immunohistochemistry observations revealed that expression of GSTA is cell specific, being associated with GC and theca cells, small luteal cells, Leydig cells, hepatocytes, adrenal cortex, specific chromaffin cells in the adrenal medulla, renal proximal convoluted tubular cells, and Clara cells in the bronchioles. Studies in vivo showed that levels of mRNA for bGSTA1 were elevated in follicular wall of preovulatory follicles before hCG treatment, but decreased by 77% 12 h after hCG injection. However, in FSH stimulated preovulatory follicles, the decrease in mRNA for both GSTAs was only 21% at 24 h following hCG injection. We concluded that bGSTA1 and bGSTA2 expression is tissue- and cell-specific, is associated with steroidogenically active cells, and is hormonally regulated by gonadotropins in the bovine ovarian follicle.

Stopped-flow kinetic analysis of the ligand-induced coil-helix transition in glutathione S-transferase A1-1: evidence for a persistent denatured state

Structural studies have suggested that the glutathione S-transferase (GST) A1-1 isozyme contains a dynamic C-terminus which undergoes a ligand-dependent disorder-order transition and sequesters substrates within the active site. Here, the contribution of the C-terminus to the kinetics and thermodynamics of ligand binding and dissociation has been determined. Steady-state turnover rates of the wild type (WT) and a C-terminal truncated (Delta209-222) rGST A1-1 with ethacrynic acid (EA) were measured in the presence of variable concentrations of viscogen. The results indicate that a physical step involving segmental protein motion is at least partially rate limiting at temperatures between 10 and 40 degrees C for WT. Dissociation rates of the glutathione-ethacrynic acid product conjugate (GS-EA), determined by stopped-flow fluorescence, correspond to the steady-state turnover rates. In contrast, the chemical step governs the turnover reaction by Delta209-222, suggesting that the slow rate of product release for WT is controlled by the dynamics of the C-terminal coil-helix transition. In addition, the association reaction of WT rGST A1-1 with GS-EA established that the binding was biphasic and included ligand docking followed by slow isomerization of the enzyme-ligand complex. In contrast, binding of GS-EA to Delta209-222 was a monophasic, bimolecular reaction. These results indicate that the binding of GS-EA to WT rGST A1-1 proceeds via an induced fit mechanism, with a slow conformational step that corresponds to the coil-helix transition. However, the biphasic dissociation kinetics for the wild type, and the recovered kinetic parameters, suggest that a significant fraction of the [GST.GS-EA] complex ( approximately 15%) retains a persistent disordered state at equilibrium.

Benzoic acid derivatives induce recovery of catalytic activity in the partially inactive Met208Lys mutant of human glutathione transferase A1-1

Human glutathione transferase A1-1 (GST A1-1) is a detoxifying enzyme catalyzing the conjugation of glutathione with a variety of hydrophobic, electrophilic substrates. When the role of the hydrophobic substrate-binding site residue Met208 was investigated by random mutagenesis, introduction of charged amino acid residues had the greatest deleterious effect on enzyme activity. However, in the lysine mutant some of the lost activity could be regained by the addition of a benzoic acid derivative to the reaction mixture. The activating molecule has now been optimized such that all activity is recovered. The most potent activator, 4-propylbenzoic acid, has been used in studies of the mechanism behind the activation. A heterodimeric species of GST A1-1, containing only one activatable subunit, has been constructed. The heterodimer shows a strictly additive activation curve when compared to its parental forms, indicating that the activation is not due to co-operativity between the subunits. Furthermore, a novel electrophilic substrate, 4-chloro-3,5-dinitrobenzoic acid, with a carboxylate group expected to interact with residue 208 gives a higher kcat value with the lysine mutant than with wild-type GST A1-1. All results obtained in the here support the view that the positive charge introduced into the lysine mutant adversely affects the structure of the C-terminal helix of this enzyme, preventing it from adopting the conformation needed for full activity. The negatively charged carboxylate group of the activator probably neutralizes the positive charge of the side-chain amino group and thereby restores the substrate-binding site to a form that is favorable for the catalytic function.

Human glutathione transferase A4-4 crystal structures and mutagenesis reveal the basis of high catalytic efficiency with toxic lipid peroxidation products

The oxidation of lipids and cell membranes generates cytotoxic compounds implicated in the etiology of aging, cancer, atherosclerosis, neurodegenerative diseases, and other illnesses. Glutathione transferase (GST) A4-4 is a key component in the defense against the products of this oxidative stress because, unlike other Alpha class GSTs, GST A4-4 shows high catalytic activity with lipid peroxidation products such as 4-hydroxynon-2-enal (HNE). The crystal structure of human apo GST A4-4 unexpectedly possesses an ordered C-terminal alpha-helix, despite the absence of any ligand. The structure of human GST A4-4 in complex with the inhibitor S-(2-iodobenzyl) glutathione reveals key features of the electrophilic substrate-binding pocket which confer specificity toward HNE. Three structural modules form the binding site for electrophilic substrates and thereby govern substrate selectivity: the beta1-alpha1 loop, the end of the alpha4 helix, and the C-terminal alpha9 helix. A few residue changes in GST A4-4 result in alpha9 taking over a predominant role in ligand specificity from the N-terminal loop region important for GST A1-1. Thus, the C-terminal helix alpha9 in GST A4-4 provides pre-existing ligand complementarity rather than acting as a flexible cap as observed in other GST structures. Hydrophobic residues in the alpha9 helix, differing from those in the closely related GST A1-1, delineate a hydrophobic specificity canyon for the binding of lipid peroxidation products. The role of residue Tyr212 as a key catalytic residue, suggested by the crystal structure of the inhibitor complex, is confirmed by mutagenesis results. Tyr212 is positioned to interact with the aldehyde group of the substrate and polarize it for reaction. Tyr212 also coopts part of the binding cleft ordinarily formed by the N-terminal substrate recognition region in the homologous enzyme GST A1-1 to reveal an evolutionary swapping of function between different recognition elements. A structural model of catalysis is presented based on these results.

Solution structure of the carboxyl terminus of a human class Mu glutathione S-transferase: NMR assignment strategies in large proteins

Strategies to obtain the NMR assignments for the HN, N, CO, Calpha and Cbeta resonance frequencies for the human class mu glutathione-S-transferase GSTM2-2 are reported. These assignments were obtained with deuterated protein using a combination of scalar and dipolar connectivities and various specific labeling schemes. The large size of this protein (55 kDa, homodimer) necessitated the development of a novel pulse sequence and specific labeling strategies. These aided in the identification of residue type and were essential components in determining sequence specific assignments. These assignments were utilized in this study to characterize the structure and dynamics of the carboxy-terminal residues in the unliganded protein. Previous crystallographic studies of this enzyme in complex with glutathione suggested that this region may be disordered, and that this disorder may be essential for catalysis. Furthermore, in the related class alpha protein extensive changes in conformation of the C terminus are observed upon ligand binding. On the basis of the results presented here, the time-averaged conformation of the carboxyl terminus of unliganded GSTM2-2 is similar to that seen in the crystal structure. NOE patterns and 1H-15N heteronuclear nuclear Overhauser enhancements suggest that this region of the enzyme does not undergo motion on a rapid time scale.

Role of active-site residues 107 and 108 of glutathione S-transferase mGSTA4-4 in determining the catalytic properties of the enzyme for 4-hydroxynonenal

The murine alpha-class glutathione S-transferase mGSTA4-4 displays a high catalytic activity with 4-hydroxynonenal (4-HNE), a cytotoxic product of lipid peroxidation. The X-ray crystal structure of mGSTA4-4 was used to design mutations targeting the 4-HNE binding site, with the goal of defining the structural elements of the mGSTA4-4 protein necessary for the high conjugative activity with 4-HNE. Two candidate positions, 107 and 108, were investigated. Of these, residue 108 appears to be significant in codetermining the catalytic properties of mGSTA4-4 toward 4-HNE. Systematic mutagenesis of amino acid 108 indicated that high activity toward 4-HNE is contingent on the presence of an aliphatic, hydrophobic side chain in this position. In particular, replacement of the wild-type V108 with leucine led to a more than fivefold increase in both absolute activity of the enzyme for 4-HNE and its selectivity for 4-HNE over the model substrate 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene, due to a selective increase of the turnover number for 4-HNE with no change in the affinity of the protein for this substrate and no changes in the kinetic parameters for 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene. In contrast, the A107L mutation decreased activity of the enzyme for both 4-HNE and CDNB and partially reversed the positive effect of the V108L mutation in a double mutant.

GSTP1-1 stereospecifically catalyzes glutathione conjugation of ethacrynic acid

Using 1H NMR two diastereoisomers of the ethacrynic acid glutathione conjugate (EASG) as well as ethacrynic acid (EA) could be distinguished and quantified individually. Chemically prepared EASG consists of equal amounts of both diastereoisomers. GSTP1-1 stereospecifically catalyzes formation of one of the diastereoisomers (A). The GSTP1-1 mutant C47S and GSTA1-1 preferentially form the same diastereoisomer of EASG as GSTP1-1. Glutathione conjugation of EA by GSTA1-2 and GSTA2-2 is not stereoselective. When human melanoma cells, expressing GSTP1-1, were exposed to ethacrynic acid, diastereoisomer A was the principal conjugate formed, indicating that even at physiological pH the enzyme catalyzed reaction dominates over the chemical conjugation.

A topologically conserved aliphatic residue in alpha-helix 6 stabilizes the hydrophobic core in domain II of glutathione transferases and is a structural determinant for the unfolding pathway

A topologically conserved residue in alpha-helix 6 of domain II of human glutathione transferase (hGST) A1-1 was mutated to investigate its contribution to protein stability and the unfolding pathway. The replacement of Leu-164 with alanine (L164A) did not impact on the functional and gross structural properties of native hGST A1-1. The wild-type protein unfolds via a three-state pathway in which only folded dimer and unfolded monomer were highly populated at equilibrium; a native-like dimeric intermediate with partially dissociated domains I and II was detected using stopped-flow fluorescence studies [Wallace, Sluis-Cremer and Dirr (1998) Biochemistry 37, 5320-5328]. In the present study, urea-induced equilibrium unfolding of L164A hGST A1-1 indicated a destabilization of the native state and suggested the presence of a stable dimeric intermediate. The unfolding kinetic pathway for L164A hGST A1-1, like that for the wild type, is biphasic, with a fast and a slow unfolding event; the cavity-forming mutation has a substantially greater effect on the rate of unfolding of the fast event. The equilibrium and kinetic unfolding data for L164A hGST A1-1 suggest that a rapid pre-equilibrium is established between the native dimer and a dimeric intermediate before complete domain and subunit dissociation and unfolding. It is proposed that the topologically conserved bulky residue in alpha-helix 6 plays a role in specifying and stabilizing the core of domain II and the interface of domains I and II.

Structures of herbicides in complex with their detoxifying enzyme glutathione S-transferase - explanations for the selectivity of the enzyme in plants

BACKGROUND

Glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) are detoxifying enzymes present in all aerobic organisms. These enzymes catalyse the conjugation of glutathione with a variety of electrophilic compounds. In plants, GSTs catalyse the first step in the degradation of several herbicides, such as triazines and acetamides, thus playing an important role in herbicide tolerance.

RESULTS

We have solved the structures of GST-I from maize in complex with an atrazine-glutathione conjugate (at 2.8 A resolution) and GST from Arabidopsis thaliana (araGST) in complex with an FOE-4053-glutathione conjugate (at 2.6 A resolution). These ligands are products of the detoxifying reaction and are well defined in the electron density. The herbicide-binding site (H site) is different in the two structures. The architecture of the glutathione-binding site (G site) of araGST is different to that of the previously described structure of GST in complex with two S-hexylglutathione molecules, but is homologous to that of GST-I.

CONCLUSIONS

Three features are responsible for the differences in the H site of the two GSTs described here: the exchange of hydrophobic residues of different degrees of bulkiness; a slight difference in the location of the H site; and a difference in the degree of flexibility of the upper side of the H site, which is built up by the loop between helices alpha4 and alpha5. Taking these two structures as a model, the different substrate specificities of other plant GSTs may be explained. The structures reported here provide a basis for the design of new, more selective herbicides.

Shifting substrate specificity of human glutathione transferase (from class Pi to class alpha) by a single point mutation

Substrate selectivity, among glutathione transferase (GST) isoenzymes, appears to be determined by a few residues. As part of study to determine which residues are class-specific determinants, Tyr 108 (an important residue of the class Pi) has been changed to a valine, the structural equivalent of a class Alpha enzyme. Using a panel of selected substrates, "diagnostic" for either class Pi or Alpha, it is shown here that this single mutation significantly alters the catalytic properties of the class Pi enzyme and shifts the substrate specificity of the enzyme toward that of the class Alpha enzyme.

Detoxication of carcinogenic fjord-region diol epoxides of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons by glutathione transferase P1-1 variants and glutathione

Epidemiological studies suggest that individuals differing in the expression of allelic variants of the human glutathione transferase (GST) Pi gene differ in susceptibility to chemical carcinogens such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH). This study reports the catalytic efficiencies (k(cat)/Km) of two naturally occurring variants, GSTP1-1/I-105 and GSTP1-1/ V-105, towards a series of fjord-region diol epoxides representing potent biologically active PAH metabolites, and two GSTP1-1 mutants with Ala105 and Trp105 in the active site. The results indicate that individuals who are homozygous for the allele encoding GSTP1-1/V-105 might be more susceptible to PAH carcinogenesis due to other reasons than a reduced capacity for detoxifying diol epoxides.

Class sigma glutathione transferase unfolds via a dimeric and a monomeric intermediate: impact of subunit interface on conformational stability in the superfamily

Solvent-induced equilibrium unfolding of a homodimeric class sigma glutathione transferase (GSTS1-1, EC 2.5.1.18) was characterized by tryptophan fluorescence, anisotropy, enzyme activity, 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonate (ANS) binding, and circular dichroism. Urea induces a triphasic unfolding transition with evidence for two well-populated thermodynamically stable intermediate states of GSTS1-1. The first unfolding transition is protein concentration independent and involves a change in the subunit tertiary structure yielding a partially active dimeric intermediate (i.e., N2 left and right arrow I2). This is followed by a protein concentration dependent step in which I2 dissociates into compact inactive monomers (M) displaying enhanced hydrophobicity. The third unfolding transition, which is protein concentration independent, involves the complete unfolding of the monomeric state. Increasing NaCl concentrations destabilize N2 and appear to shift the equilibrium toward I2 whereas the stability of the monomeric intermediate M is enhanced. The binding of substrate or product analogue (i.e., glutathione or S-hexylglutathione) to the protein's active site stabilizes the native dimeric state (N2), causing the first two unfolding transitions to shift toward higher urea concentrations. The stability of M was not affected. The data implicate a region at/near the active site in domain I (most likely alpha-helix 2) as being highly unstable/flexible which undergoes local unfolding, resulting initially in I2 formation followed by a disruption in quaternary structure to a monomeric intermediate. The unfolding/refolding pathway is compared with those observed for other cytosolic GSTs and discussed in light of the different structural features at the subunit interfaces, as well as the evolutionary selection of this GST as a lens crystallin.

The three-dimensional structure of a class-Pi glutathione S-transferase complexed with glutathione: the active-site hydration provides insights into the reaction mechanism

The structure of mouse liver glutathione S-transferase P1-1 complexed with its substrate glutathione (GSH) has been determined by X-ray diffraction analysis. No conformational changes in the glutathione moiety or in the protein, other than small adjustments of some side chains, are observed when compared with glutathione adduct complexes. Our structure confirms that the role of Tyr-7 is to stabilize the thiolate by hydrogen bonding and to position it in the right orientation. A comparison of the enzyme-GSH structure reported here with previously described structures reveals rearrangements in a well-defined network of water molecules in the active site. One of these water molecules (W0), identified in the unliganded enzyme (carboxymethylated at Cys-47), is displaced by the binding of GSH, and a further water molecule (W4) is displaced following the binding of the electrophilic substrate and the formation of the glutathione conjugate. The possibility that one of these water molecules participates in the proton abstraction from the glutathione thiol is discussed.

Evidence for an induced-fit mechanism operating in pi class glutathione transferases

Three-dimensional structures of the apo form of human pi class glutathione transferase have been determined by X-ray crystallography. The structures suggest the enzyme recognizes its substrate, glutathione, by an induced-fit mechanism. Compared to complexed forms of the enzyme, the environment around the catalytic residue, Tyr 7, remains unchanged in the apoenzyme. This observation supports the view that Tyr 7 does not act as a general base in the reaction mechanism. The observed cooperativity of the dimeric enzyme may be due to the movements of a helix that forms one wall of the active site and, in particular, to movements of a tyrosine residue that is located in the subunit interface.

Equilibrium and kinetic unfolding properties of dimeric human glutathione transferase A1-1

The equilibrium and kinetic unfolding properties of homodimeric class alpha glutathione transferase (hGST A1-1) were characterized. Urea-induced equilibrium unfolding data were consistent with a folded dimer/unfolded monomer transition. Unfolding kinetics were investigated, using stopped-flow fluorescence, as a function of denaturant concentration (3.5-8.9 M urea) and temperature (10-40 degrees C). The unfolding pathway, monitored by tryptophan fluorescence, was biphasic with a fast unfolding event (millisecond time range with enhanced fluorescence properties) and a slow unfolding event (seconds to minutes time range with quenched fluorescence properties). Both events occurred simultaneously from 3.5 M urea. Each phase displayed single-exponential behavior, consistent with two unimolecular reactions. Urea-dependence studies and thermodynamic activation parameters (transition-state theory) suggest that the transition state for each phase is well-structured and is closely related to native protein in terms of solvent exposure. The apparent activation Gibbs free energy change in the absence of denaturant, DeltaG (H2O), indicates that the slow unfolding event represents the transition state for the overall unfolding pathway. The rate and urea independence of each phase on the initial condition exclude the possibility of a preexisting equilibrium between various native forms in the pretransition baseline. The unfolding pathways monitored by energy transfer to or direct excitation of AEDANS covalently linked to Cys111 in hGST A1-1 were monophasic with urea and temperature properties similar to those observed for the slow unfolding event (described above). A sequential unfolding kinetic mechanism involving the partial dissociation of the two structurally distinct domains per subunit followed by complete domain and subunit unfolding is proposed.

Human theta class glutathione transferase: the crystal structure reveals a sulfate-binding pocket within a buried active site

BACKGROUND

Glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) comprise a multifunctional group of enzymes that play a critical role in the cellular detoxification process. These enzymes reduce the reactivity of toxic compounds by catalyzing their conjugation with glutathione. As a result of their role in detoxification, GSTs have been implicated in the development of cellular resistance to antibiotics, herbicides and clinical drugs and their study is therefore of much interest. In mammals, the cytosolic GSTs can be divided into five distinct classes termed alpha, mu, pi, sigma and theta. The human theta class GST, hGST T2-2, possesses several distinctive features compared to GSTs of other classes, including a long C-terminal extension and a specific sulfatase activity. It was hoped that the determination of the structure of hGST T2-2 may help us to understand more about this unusual class of enzymes.

RESULTS

Here we present the crystal structures of hGST T2-2 in the apo form and in complex with the substrates glutathione and 1-menaphthyl sulfate. The enzyme adopts the canonical GST fold with a 40-residue C-terminal extension comprising two helices connected by a long loop. The extension completely buries the substrate-binding pocket and occludes most of the glutathione-binding site. The enzyme has a purpose-built novel sulfate-binding site. The crystals were shown to be catalytically active: soaks with 1-menaphthyl sulfate result in the production of the glutathione conjugate and cleavage of the sulfate group.

CONCLUSIONS

hGST T2-2 shares less than 15% sequence identity with other GST classes, yet adopts a similar three-dimensional fold. The C-terminal extension that blocks the active site is not disordered in either the apo or complexed forms of the enzyme, but nevertheless catalysis occurs in the crystalline state. A narrow tunnel leading from the active site to the surface may provide a pathway for the entry of substrates and the release of products. The results suggest a molecular basis for the unique sulfatase activity of this GST.

Solution structure of glutathione bound to human glutathione transferase P1-1: comparison of NMR measurements with the crystal structure

The conformation of the bound glutathione (GSH) in the active site of the human glutathione transferase P1-1 (EC 2.5.1.18) has been studied by transferred NOE measurements and compared with those obtained by X-ray diffraction data. Two-dimensional TRNOESY and TRROESY experiments have been performed under fast-exchange conditions. The family of GSH conformers, compatible with TRNOE distance constraints, shows a backbone structure very similar to the crystal model. Interesting differences have been found in the side chain regions. After restrained energy minimization of a representative NMR conformer in the active site, the sulfur atom is not found in hydrogen-bonding distance of the hydroxyl group of Tyr 7. This situation is similar to the one observed in an "atypical" crystal complex grown at low pH and low temperature. The NMR conformers display also a poorly defined structure of the glutamyl moiety, and the presence of an unexpected intermolecular NOE could indicate a different interaction of this substrate portion with the G-site. The NMR data seem to provide a snapshot of GSH in a precomplex where the GSH glutamyl end is bound in a different fashion. The existence of this precomplex is supported by pre-steady-state kinetic experiments [Caccuri, A. M., Lo Bello, M., Nuccetelli, M., Nicotra, M., Rossi, P., Antonini, G., Federici, G., and Ricci, G. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 3028-3034] and preliminary time-resolved fluorescence data.

Crystal structure of a murine alpha-class glutathione S-transferase involved in cellular defense against oxidative stress

Glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) are ubiquitous multifunctional enzymes which play a key role in cellular detoxification. The enzymes protect the cells against toxicants by conjugating them to glutathione. Recently, a novel subgroup of alpha-class GSTs has been identified with altered substrate specificity which is particularly important for cellular defense against oxidative stress. Here, we report the crystal structure of murine GSTA4-4, which is the first structure of a prototypical member of this subgroup. The structure was solved by molecular replacement and refined to 2.9 A resolution. It resembles the structure of other members of the GST superfamily, but reveals a distinct substrate binding site.

The three-dimensional structure of Cys-47-modified mouse liver glutathione S-transferase P1-1. Carboxymethylation dramatically decreases the affinity for glutathione and is associated with a loss of electron density in the alphaB-310B region

The three-dimensional structure of mouse liver glutathione S-transferase P1-1 carboxymethylated at Cys-47 and its complex with S-(p-nitrobenzyl)glutathione have been determined by x-ray diffraction analysis. The structure of the modified enzyme described here is the first structural report for a Pi class glutathione S-transferase with no glutathione, glutathione S-conjugate, or inhibitor bound. It shows that part of the active site area, which includes helix alphaB and helix 310B, is disordered. However, the environment of Tyr-7, an essential residue for the catalytic reaction, remains unchanged. The position of the sulfur atom of glutathione is occupied in the ligand-free enzyme by a water molecule that is at H-bond distance from Tyr-7. We do not find any structural evidence for a tyrosinate form, and therefore our results suggest that Tyr-7 is not acting as a general base abstracting the proton from the thiol group of glutathione. The binding of the inhibitor S-(p-nitrobenzyl)-glutathione to the carboxymethylated enzyme results in a partial restructuring of the disordered area. The modification of Cys-47 sterically hinders structural organization of this region, and although it does not prevent glutathione binding, it significantly reduces the affinity. A detailed kinetic study of the modified enzyme indicates that the carboxymethylation increases the Km for glutathione by 3 orders of magnitude, although the enzyme can function efficiently under saturating conditions.

Cloning, sequencing, crystallization and X-ray structure of glutathione S-transferase-III from Zea mays var. mutin: a leading enzyme in detoxification of maize herbicides

Glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) are enzymes that inactivate toxic compounds by conjugation with glutathione and are involved in resistance towards drugs, antibiotics, insecticides and herbicides. Their ability to confer herbicide tolerance in plants provides a tool to control weeds in a wide variety of agronomic crops. GST-III was prepared from Zea mays var. mutin and its amino acid sequence was determined from two sets of peptides obtained by cleavage with endoprotease Asp-N and with trypsin, respectively. Recombinant GST-III was prepared by extraction of mRNA from plant tissue, transcription into cDNA, amplification by PCR and expression. It was crystallized and the crystal structure of the unligated form was determined at 2.2 A resolution. The enzyme forms a GST-typical dimer with one subunit consisting of 220 residues. Each subunit is formed of two distinct domains, an N-terminal domain consisting of a beta-sheet flanked by two helices, and a C-terminal domain, entirely helical. The dimeric molecule is globular with a large cleft between the two subunits. The amino acid sequence of GST-III and its cDNA sequence determined here show differences from sequences published earlier.

The glutathione conjugate of ethacrynic acid can bind to human pi class glutathione transferase P1-1 in two different modes

The diuretic drug ethacrynic acid, an inhibitor of pi class glutathione S-transferase, has been tested in clinical trials as an adjuvant in chemotherapy. We recently solved the crystal structure of this enzyme in complex with ethacrynic acid and its glutathione conjugate. Here we present a new structure of the ethacrynic-glutathione conjugate complex. In this structure the ethacrynic moiety of the complex is shown to bind in a completely different orientation to that previously observed. Thus there are at least two binding modes possible, an observation of great importance to the design of second generation inhibitors of the enzyme.

The structures of human glutathione transferase P1-1 in complex with glutathione and various inhibitors at high resolution

The human pi-class glutathione S-transferase (hGST P1-1) is a target for structure-based inhibitor design with the aim of developing drugs that could be used as adjuvants in chemotherapeutic treatment. Here we present seven crystal structures of the enzyme in complex with substrate (glutathione) and two inhibitors (S-hexyl glutathione and gamma-glutamyl- (S-benzyl)cysteinyl-D-phenylglycine). The binding of the modified glutathione inhibitor, gamma-glutamyl-(S-benzyl)cysteinyl-D-phenylglycine, has been characterized with the phenyl group stacking against the benzyl moiety of the inhibitor and making interactions with the active-site residues Phe8 and Trp38. The structure provides an explanation as to why this compound inhibits the pi-class GST much better than the other GST classes. The structure of the enzyme in complex with glutathione has been determined to high resolution (1.9 to 2.2 A) in three different crystal forms and at two different temperatures (100 and 288 K). In one crystal form, the direct hydrogen-bonding interaction between the hydroxyl group of Tyr7, a residue involved in catalysis, and the thiol group of the substrate, glutathione, is broken and replaced by a water molecule that mediates the interaction. The hydrogen-bonding partner of the hydroxyl group of Tyr108, another residue implicated in the catalysis, is space-group dependent. A high-resolution (2.0 A) structure of the enzyme in complex with S-hexyl glutathione in a new crystal form is presented. The enzyme-inhibitor complexes show that the binding of ligand into the electrophilic binding site does not lead to any conformational changes of the protein.

Glutathione conjugation of bay- and fjord-region diol epoxides of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons by glutathione transferases M1-1 and P1-1

Metabolism of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in mammalian cells results in the formation of vicinal diol epoxides considered as ultimate carcinogens if the oxirane ring is located in a bay- or fjord-region of the parent compound. In the present study, individual stereoisomers of the bay-region diol epoxides of chrysene, dibenz[a,h]anthracene, and benzo[a]pyrene as well as of the fjord-region diol epoxides of benzo[c]phenanthrene, benzo[c]chrysene, and benzo[g]-chrysene have been incubated with GSH in the presence of human glutathione transferases GSTM1-1 (a mu-class enzyme) and GSTP1-1 (a pi-class enzyme). As previously shown with GSTA1-1 (an alpha-class enzyme) both M1-1 and P1-1 demonstrate considerable activity toward a number of the diol epoxides studied, although a great variation in catalytic efficiency and enantioselectivity was observed. With GSTM1-1, the bay-region diol epoxides, in particular the syn-diastereomers were in most cases more efficiently conjugated with GSH than the fjord-region analogues. GSTM1-1 demonstrated an enantioselectivity ranging from no preference (50%) to high preference (> or = 90%) for conjugation of the enantiomers with R-configuration at the benzylic position of the oxirane ring. With GSTP1-1, the enzyme demonstrated appreciable activity toward both bay- and fjord-region diol epoxides and, in most cases, a preference for the anti-diastereomers. In contrast to GSTM1-1 and as previously shown for GSTA1-1, GSTP1-1 showed an exclusive preference for conjugation of the enantiomers with R-configuration at the benzylic oxirane carbon. With both GSTM1-1 and GSTP1-1, the chemically most reactive diol epoxide, the (+)-syn-enantiomer of trans-7,8-dihydroxy-9,10-epoxy-7,8,9,-10-tetrahydrobenzo[a]pyrene (BPDE), was the best substrate. As for GSTA1-1, no obvious correlation between chemical reactivity or lipophilicity of the compounds and catalytic efficiencies was observed. Molecular modeling of diol epoxides in the active sites of GSTP1-1 and -A1-1 is in agreement with the assumption, based on functional studies, that the H-site of GSTA1-1 [Jernström et al. (1996) Carcinogenesis 17, 1491-1498] can accommodate stereoisomers of different sizes. Further, modeling of the enantiomers of anti- and syn-BPDE in the active site of GSTP1-1 provides an explanation for the exclusive preference for the enantiomers with R-configuration at the benzylic oxirane carbon. These isomers could be snuggly fitted in the H-site close to the GSH sulfur, whereas those with opposite stereochemistry could not.

Characterization of chicken-liver glutathione S-transferase (GST) A1-1 and A2-2 isoenzymes and their site-directed mutants heterologously expressed in Escherichia coli: identification of Lys-15 and Ser-208 on cGSTA1-1 as residues interacting with ethacrynic acid

Escherichia coli-expressed chicken-liver glutathione S-transferase, cGSTA1-1, displays high ethacrynic acid (EA)-conjugating activity. Molecular modelling of cGSTA1-1 with EA in the substrate binding site reveals that the side chain of Phe-111 protrudes into the substrate binding site and possibly interacts with EA. Replacement of Phe-111 with alanine resulted in an enzyme (F111A mutant) with a 4.5-fold increase in EA-conjugating activity (9.2 mmol/min per mg), and an incremental Gibbs free energy (DeltaDeltaG) of 4.0 kJ/mol lower than that of the wild-type cGSTA1-1. Two other amino acid residues that possibly interact with EA are Ser-208 and Lys-15. Substitution of Ser-208 with methionine generated a cGSTA1-1(F111AS208M) double mutant that has low EA-conjugating activity (2.0 mmol/min per mg) and an incremental Gibbs free energy of +3.9 kJ/mol greater than the cGSTA1-1(F111A) single mutant. The cGSTA1-1(F111A) mutant, with an additional Lys-15-to-leucine substitution, lost 90% of the EA-conjugating activity (0.55 mmol/min per mg). The Km values of the cGSTA1-1(F111A) and cGSTA1-1(F111AK15L) mutants for EA are nearly identical. The wild-type cGSTA2-2 isoenzyme has a low EA-conjugating activity (0.56 mmol/min per mg). The kcat of this reaction can be increased 2. 5-fold by substituting Arg-15 and Glu-104 with lysine and glycine respectively. The KmEA of the cGSTA2-2(R15KE104G) double mutant is nearly identical with that of the wild-type enzyme. Another double mutant, cGSTA2-2(E104GL208S), has a KmEA that is 3.3-fold lower and a kcat that is 1.8-fold higher than that of the wild-type enzyme. These results, taken together, illustrate the interactions of Lys-15 and Ser-208 on cGSTA1-1 with EA.

Structures of class pi glutathione S-transferase from human placenta in complex with substrate, transition-state analogue and inhibitor

BACKGROUND

Glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) are detoxification enzymes, found in all aerobic organisms, which catalyse the conjugation of glutathione with a wide range of hydrophobic electrophilic substrates, thereby protecting the cell from serious damage caused by electrophilic compounds. GSTs are classified into five distinct classes (alpha, mu, pi, sigma and theta) by their substrate specificity and primary structure. Human GSTs are of interest because tumour cells show increased levels of expression of single classes of GSTs, which leads to drug resistance. Structural differences between classes of GST can therefore be utilised to develop new anti-cancer drugs. Many mutational and structural studies have been carried out on the mu and alpha classes of GST to elucidate the reaction mechanism, whereas knowledge about the pi class is still limited.

RESULTS

We have solved the structures of the pi class GST hP1-1 in complex with its substrate, glutathione, a transition-state complex, the Meisenheimer complex, and an inhibitor, S-(rho-bromobenzyl)-glutathione, and refined them to resolutions of 1.8 A, 2.0 A and 1.9 A, respectively. All ligand molecules are well-defined in the electron density. In all three structures, an additionally bound N-morpholino-ethansulfonic acid molecule from the buffer solution was found.

CONCLUSIONS

In the structure of the GST-glutathione complex, two conserved water molecules are observed, one of which hydrogen bonds directly to the sulphur atom of glutathione and the other forms hydrogen bonds with residues around the glutathione-binding site. These water molecules are absent from the structure of the Meisenheimer complex bound to GST, implicating that deprotonation of the cysteine occurs during formation of the ternary complex which involves expulsion of the inner bound water molecule. The comparison of our structures with known mu class GST structures show differences in the location of the electrophile-binding site (H-site), explaining the different substrate specificities of the two classes. Fluorescence measurements are in agreement with the position of the N-morpholino-ethansulfonic acid, close to Trp28, identifying a possible ligandin-substrate binding site.

Cloning and crystal structure of hematopoietic prostaglandin D synthase

Hematopoietic prostaglandin (PG) D synthase is the key enzyme for production of the D and J series of prostanoids in the immune system and mast cells. We isolated a cDNA for the rat enzyme, crystallized the recombinant enzyme, and determined the three-dimensional structure of the enzyme complexed with glutathione at 2.3 A resolution. The enzyme is the first member of the sigma class glutathione S-transferase (GST) from vertebrates and possesses a prominent cleft as the active site, which is never seen among other members of the GST family. The unique 3-D architecture of the cleft leads to the putative substrate binding mode and its catalytic mechanism, responsible for the specific isomerization from PGH2 to PGD2.

Mechanism-based phage display selection of active-site mutants of human glutathione transferase A1-1 catalyzing SNAr reactions

A library of active-site mutants has been constructed by targeting selected amino acid residues in human glutathione transferase (GST) A1-1 for random mutagenesis. The mutated residues are suitably positioned for interaction with the second, electrophilic substrate, in particular chloronitrobenzene derivatives undergoing SNAr reactions. DNA representing the GST A1-1 mutant library was fused with DNA encoding gene III protein, a component of the coat of filamentous phage. Phage display was used for affinity selection of GST A1-1 mutants with altered catalytic properties. The affinity ligand used was the sigma-complex of 1,3,5-trinitrobenzene and glutathione immobilized to Sepharose. The complex was designed to mimic the transition state of SNAr reactions catalyzed by GSTs. The selection system is based on the combination of affinity for the sigma-complex as well as the ability to promote its formation, thus mimicking two salient features of the assumed catalytic mechanism for the SNAr reactions. Many of the GST A1-1 mutants selected and analyzed contained an aromatic amino acid residue in one of the mutated positions, suggesting favorable interactions with the trinitrocyclohexadienate moiety of the affinity ligand. A mutant C36 was selected for more detailed studies. Its catalytic efficiency with several chloronitrobenzene substrates was 20-90-fold lower than that of wild-type GST A1-1, but fully comparable to naturally evolved GSTs of different classes, providing a 10(5)-fold rate enhancement over the uncatalyzed reaction. In the conjugation of ethacrynic acid, a Michael addition reaction, mutant C36 was 13-fold more efficient than the wild-type enzyme. Within experimental error, the quotient between the KF values for wild-type GST A1-1 and mutant C36 is the same as that between the kcat/KM values determined with 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene for the two enzyme forms. This result indicates that sigma-complex formation is rate-limiting for the catalyzed reaction. Thus, the principle of transition-state stabilization as a component of catalysis has been successfully exploited in affinity selection of catalytically competent GST A1-1 mutants. This mechanism-based procedure also selects for the ability to promote sigma-complex formation, and serves as a probe of the catalytic mechanism.

Identification of the nonsubstrate steroid binding site of rat liver glutathione S-transferase, isozyme 1-1, by the steroid affinity label, 3beta-(iodoacetoxy)dehydroisoandrosterone

3beta-(Iodoacetoxy)dehydroisoandrosterone (3beta-IDA), an analogue of the electrophilic substrate, Delta5-androstene-3,17-dione, as well as an analogue of several other steroid inhibitors of glutathione S-transferase, was tested as an affinity label of rat liver glutathione S-transferase, isozyme 1-1. A time-dependent loss of enzyme activity is observed upon incubation of 3beta-IDA with the enzyme. The rate of enzyme inactivation exhibits a nonlinear dependence on 3beta-IDA concentration, yielding an apparent Ki of 21 microM. Upon complete inactivation of the enzyme, a reagent incorporation of approximately 1 mol/mol of enzyme subunit or 2 mol/mol of enzyme dimer is observed. Protection against inactivation and incorporation is afforded by alkyl glutathione derivatives and nonsubstrate steroid ligands such as 17beta-estradiol-3,17-disulfate but, surprisingly, not by Delta5-androstene-3,17-dione or any other electrophilic substrate analogues tested. These results suggest that the site of reaction is within the nonsubstrate steroid binding site of the enzyme, which is distinguishable from the electrophilic substrate binding site, near the active site of the enzyme. Two cysteine residues, Cys17 and Cys111, are modified in nearly equal amounts, despite an average reagent incorporation of 1 mol/mol enzyme subunit. Isolation of enzyme subunits indicates the presence of unmodified, singly labeled, and doubly labeled subunits, consistent with mutually exclusive modification of cysteine residues across enzyme subunits; i.e., modification of Cys111 on subunit A prevents modification of Cys111 on subunit B and similarly for Cys17. Molecular modeling analysis suggests that Cys17 and Cys111 are located in the nonsubstrate steroid binding site, within the cleft between the subunits of the dimeric enzyme.

Crystal structure of phosphoadenylyl sulphate (PAPS) reductase: a new family of adenine nucleotide alpha hydrolases

BACKGROUND

Assimilatory sulphate reduction supplies prototrophic organisms with reduced sulphur for the biosynthesis of all sulphur-containing metabolites. This process is driven by a sequence of enzymatic steps involving phosphoadenylyl sulphate (PAPS) reductase. Thioredoxin is used as the electron donor for the reduction of PAPS to phospho-adenosine-phosphate (PAP) and sulphite. Unlike most electron-transfer reactions, there are no cofactors or prosthetic groups involved in this reduction and PAPS reductase is one of the rare examples of an enzyme that is able to store two electrons. Determination of the structure of PAPS reductase is the first step towards elucidating the biochemical details of the reduction of PAPS to sulphite.

RESULTS

We have determined the crystal structure of PAPS reductase at 2.0 A resolution in the open, reduced form, in which a flexible loop covers the active site. The protein is active as a dimer, each monomer consisting of a central six-stranded beta sheet with alpha helices packing against each side. A highly modified version of the P loop, the fingerprint peptide of mononucleotide-binding proteins, is present in the active site of the protein, which appears to be a positively charged cleft containing a number of conserved arginine and lysine residues. Although PAPS reductase has no ATPase activity, it shows a striking similarity to the structure of the ATP pyrophosphatase (ATP PPase) domain of GMP synthetase, indicating that both enzyme families have evolved from a common ancestral nucleotide-binding fold.

CONCLUSIONS

The sequence conservation between ATP sulphurylases, a subfamily of ATP PPases, and PAPS reductase and the similarities in both their mechanisms and folds, suggest an evolutionary link between the ATP PPases and PAPS reductases. Together with the N type ATP PPases, PAPS reductases and ATP sulphurylases are proposed to form a new family of homologous enzymes with adenine nucleotide alpha-hydrolase activity. The open, reduced form of PAPS reductase is able to bind PAPS, whereas the closed oxidized form cannot. A movement between the two monomers of the dimer may allow this switch in conformation to occur.

Ligand-based protein alignment and isozyme specificity of glutathione S-transferase inhibitors

Glutathione S-transferases (GST, E.C.2.5.1.18) comprise a family of detoxification enzymes. Elevated levels of specific GST isozymes in tumor cells are thought responsible for resistance to chemotherapeutics, which renders selective GST inhibitors potentially useful pharmaceutical agents. We discuss the development of a structure activity model that rationalizes the isozyme selectivity observed in a series of 12 glutathione (GSH) analogues. Enzymatic activity data was determined for human P1-1, A1-1, and M2-2 isozymes, and these data were then considered in light of structural features of these three GST proteins. A survey of all GST structures in the PDB revealed that GSH binds to these proteins in a single "bioactive" conformation. To focus on differences between binding sites, we exploited our finding of a common GSH conformation and aligned the GST x-ray structures using bound ligands rather than the backbones of the different proteins. Once aligned, binding site lipophilicity and electrostatic potentials were computed, visualized, and compared. Docking and energy minimization exercises provided additional refinements to a model of selectivity developed initially by visual analysis. Our results suggest that binding site shape and lipophilic character are key determinants of GST isozyme selectivity for close GSH analogues.

Multifunctional role of Tyr 108 in the catalytic mechanism of human glutathione transferase P1-1. Crystallographic and kinetic studies on the Y108F mutant enzyme

The possible role of the hydroxyl group of Tyr 108 in the catalytic mechanism of human glutathione transferase P1-1 has been investigated by means of site-directed mutagenesis, steady-state kinetic analysis, and crystallographic studies. Three representative cosubstrates have been used, i.e. ethacrynic acid, 7-chloro-4-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazole, and 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene. In the presence of ethacrynic acid, the enzyme follows a rapid equilibrium random bi-bi mechanism with a rate-limiting step which occurs after the addition of the substrates and before the release of products. The replacement of Tyr 108 with Phe yields a 14-fold decrease of k(cat), while it does not change appreciably the affinity of the H site for the substrate. In this case, it would appear that the role of the hydroxyl function is to stabilize the transition state for the chemical step, i.e. the Michael addition of GSH to the electrophilic substrate. Crystallographic data are compatible with this conclusion showing the hydroxyl group of Y108 in hydrogen bonding distance of the ketone moiety of ethacrynic acid [Oakley, A. J., Rossjohn, J., Lo Bello, M., Caccuri, A. M., Federici, G., & Parker, M. W. (1997) Biochemistry 36, 576-585]. Moreover, no structural differences are observed between the Y108F mutant and the wild type, suggesting that the removal of the hydroxyl group is solely responsible for the loss of activity. A different involvement of Tyr 108 appears in the catalyzed conjugation of 7-chloro-4-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazole with GSH in which the rate-limiting step is of a physical nature, probably a structural transition of the ternary complex. The substitution of Tyr 108 yields an approximately 7-fold increase of k(cat) and a constant k(cat)/Km(NBD-Cl) value. Lack of a critical hydrogen bond between 7-chloro-4-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazole and Tyr 108 appears to be the basis of the increased k(cat). In the 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene/GSH system, no appreciable changes of kinetics parameters are found in the Y108F mutant. We conclude that Y108 has a multifunctional role in glutathione transferase P1-1 catalysis, depending on the nature of the electrophilic cosubstrate.

Pressure-dependent ionization of Tyr 9 in glutathione S-transferase A1-1: contribution of the C-terminal helix to a "soft" active site

The glutathione S-transferase (GST) isozyme A1-1 contains at its active site a catalytic tyrosine, Tyr9, which hydrogen bonds to, and stabilizes, the thiolate form of glutathione, GS-. In the substrate-free GST A1-1, the Tyr 9 has an unusually low pKa, approximately 8.2, for which the ionization to tyrosinate is monitored conveniently by UV and fluorescence spectroscopy in the tryptophan-free mutant, W21F. In addition, a short alpha-helix, residues 208-222, provides part of the GSH and hydrophobic ligand binding sites, and the helix becomes "disordered" in the absence of ligands. Here, hydrostatic pressure has been used to probe the conformational dynamics of the C-terminal helix, which are apparently linked to Tyr 9 ionization. The extent of ionization of Tyr 9 at pH 7.6 is increased dramatically at low pressures (p1/2 = 0.52 kbar), based on fluorescence titration of Tyr 9. The mutant protein W21F:Y9F exhibits no changes in tyrosine fluorescence up to 1.2 kbar; pressure specifically ionizes Tyr 9. The volume change, delta V, for the pressure-dependent ionization of Tyr 9 at pH 7.6, 19 degrees C, was -33 +/- 3 mL/mol. In contrast, N-acetyl tyrosine exhibits a delta V for deprotonation of -11 +/- 1 mL/mol, beginning from the same extent of initial ionization, pH 9.5. The pressure-dependent ionization is completely reversible for both Tyr 9 and N-acetyl tyrosine. Addition of S-methyl GSH converted the "soft" active site to a noncompressible site that exhibited negligible pressure-dependent ionization of Tyr 9 below 0.8 kbar. In addition, Phe 220 forms part of an "aromatic cluster" with Tyr 9 and Phe 10, and interactions among these residues were hypothesized to control the order of the C-terminal helix. The amino acid substitutions F220Y, F2201, and F220L afford proteins that undergo pressure-dependent ionization of Tyr 9 with delta V values of 31 +/- 2 mL/mol, 43 +/- 3 mL/mol, and 29 +/- 2 mL/mol, respectively. The p1/2 values for Tyr 9 ionization were 0.61 kbar, 0.41 kbar, and 0.46 kbar for F220Y, F220I, and F220L, respectively. Together, the results suggest that the C-terminal helix is conformationally heterogeneous in the absence of ligands. The conformations differ little in free energy, but they are significantly different in volume, and mutations at Phe 220 control the conformational distribution.

The three-dimensional structure of the human Pi class glutathione transferase P1-1 in complex with the inhibitor ethacrynic acid and its glutathione conjugate

The potent diuretic drug ethacrynic acid has been tested in clinical trials as an adjuvant in chemotherapy. Its target is the detoxifying enzyme glutathione transferase which is often found overexpressed in cancer tissues. We have solved the crystal structures of human pi class glutathione transferase P1-1 in complex with the inhibitor ethacrynic acid and its glutathione conjugate. Ethacrynic acid is found to bind in a nonproductive mode to one of the ligand binding sites of the enzyme (the H site) while the glutathione binding site (G site) is occupied by solvent molecules. There are no structural rearrangements of the G site in the absence of ligand. The structure indicates that bound glutathione is required for ethacrynic acid to dock into the H site in a productive binding mode. The binding of the ethacrynic acid-glutathione conjugate shows that the contacts of the glutathione moiety with the protein are identical to those observed in crystal structures of the enzyme with other glutathione-based substrates and inhibitors. The ethacrynic acid moiety of the conjugate binds in the H site in a fashion that has not been observed in crystal structures of other glutathione-based inhibitor complexes. The crystal structures implicate Tyr 108 as an electrophilic participant in the Michael addition of glutathione to ethacrynic acid.

Homology model for the human GSTT2 Theta class glutathione transferase

A tertiary model of the human GSTT2 Theta class glutathione transferase is presented based on the recently solved crystal structure of a related thetalike isoenzyme from Lucilia cuprina. Although the N-terminal domains are quite homologous, the C-terminal domains share less than about 20% identity. The model is used to consolidate the role of Ser 11 in the active site of the enzyme as well as to identify other residues and mechanisms of likely catalytic importance. The T2 subfamily of theta class enzymes have been shown to inactivate reactive sulfate esters arising from arylmethanols. A possible reaction pathway involving the conjugation of glutathione with one such sulfate ester, 1-menaphthyl-sulfate, is described. It is also proposed that the C-terminal region of the enzyme plays an important role in allowing substrate access to the active site.

Class-pi glutathione S-transferase is unable to regain its native conformation after oxidative inactivation by hydrogen peroxide

The oxidation of protein sulphydryls to disulphides and their reduction back to sulphydryls is an early cellular response to oxidative stress. Hydrogen-peroxide-mediated oxidation of class-pi glutathione S-transferase results in the formation of disulphide bonds, which inhibits its catalytic function yet allows it to retain its non-substrate-ligand-binding properties. The overall hydrodynamic volume of the oxidised class-pi glutathione S-transferase type-1 homodimer (GSTP1-1) is decreased, and its tertiary-structural and secondary-structural elements are changed with respect to the native protein. Structural differences appear to be prominent in domain 1 of oxidised GSTP1-1, in that the exposure of both tryptophan residues is increased, while the electric potential about one of them is altered. Treatment of the oxidised protein with dithiothreitol or glutathione restores its enzymatic capabilities, albeit with lower specific activities for 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene and ethacrynic acid. The hydrophobic binding site (H-site) for electrophilic substrates is negatively affected in that the K(m) and catalytic-efficiency values are diminished significantly with respect to those values obtained for the native protein. The dithiothreitol-treated oxidised GSTP1-1 is able to regain its overall hydrodynamic volume; however, both its secondary-structural and tertiary-structural elements remain modified with respect to the native protein, as do both tryptophanyl environments. Furthermore, the oxidised glutathione S-transferase and dithiothreitol-treated oxidised glutathione S-transferase are less thermostable (tM = 55.5 degrees C and 56.3 degrees C, respectively) than the native enzyme (tM = 59 degrees C). These results indicate that the class-pi glutathione S-transferase is unable to regain its native conformation after oxidative inactivation.

Phosphono analogues of glutathione as new inhibitors of glutathione S-transferases

Phosphono-analogues of glutathione containing the O = P(OR)2 moiety in place of the cysteinyl residue CH2SH 1a-1d were prepared by solution phase peptide synthesis. Benzyl, benzyloxy-carbonyl, and tert-butyl protecting groups were used to mask the individual amino acid functional groups. The formation of peptide bonds was achieved by the usual peptide synthesis via activation of carboxylic functions with cyclohexylcarbodiimide and subsequent reaction with free amino groups. The thus obtained, fully-protected peptides were each purified by normal phase column chromatography. Deprotection was accomplished by hydrogenolysis and by treatment with HBr/acetic acid yielding the desired phosphonic acid diester 1a-1d. The inhibition of the glutathione conjugation of 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene by human placental glutathione S-transferase was studied by determining the IC50 values of the new glutathione analogues. The IC50 values were 291 microM, 139 microM, 64 microM, and 21 microM for the dimethyl, diethyl, diisopropyl, and di-n-butyl esters, respectively. The results clearly show that the formal substitution of the glutathione thiol function by phosphonic acid esters leads to a new class of glutathione S-transferase inhibitors. Further investigations directed at the question of whether or not these glutathione analogues are suitable for a modulation in chemotherapy are in progress.

Binding of the aflatoxin-glutathione conjugate to mouse glutathione S-transferase A3-3 is saturated at only one ligand per dimer

The binding of two different reaction products (p-nitrobenzyl glutathione and the aflatoxin-glutathione conjugate) to mouse glutathione S-transferase A3-3 (mGSTA3-3) has been measured using equilibrium dialysis and a direct fluorescence quenching technique. As expected, p-nitrobenzyl glutathione was found to bind with a stoichiometry of 2.24 +/- 0.17 mol/mol of dimeric enzyme. However, the much larger aflatoxin-glutathione conjugate, 8, 9-dihydro-8-(S-glutathionyl)-9-hydroxyl-aflatoxin B1 (AFB-GSH), was found to bind with a stoichiometry of 1.12 +/- 0.08 mol/mol of dimeric enzyme. p-Nitrobenzyl glutathione bound mGSTA3-3 with a dissociation constant (Kd) of 59 +/- 17 microM while the aflatoxin-glutathione conjugate bound the enzyme with a Kd of 0.86 +/- 0.19 microM. Glutathione competitively inhibited binding of AFB-GSH to mGSTA3-3 with a Ki of 1.5 mM, suggesting that AFB-GSH was binding to the enzyme active site. Although AFB-GSH bound to mGSTA3-3 with a stoichiometry of 1 mol/mol of dimeric enzyme, AFB-GSH completely inhibited activity toward 1-chloro-2, 4-dinitrobenzene, indicating that AFB-GSH binding to one active site alters affinity for 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene in the active site of the other subunit. To our knowledge, this is the first report of a glutathione S-transferase reaction product which binds to the enzyme with a stoichiometry of 1 mol/mol of dimer.

Determination of a binding site for a non-substrate ligand in mammalian cytosolic glutathione S-transferases by means of fluorescence-resonance energy transfer

To determine the location of the non-substrate-ligand-binding region in mammalian glutathione S-transferases, fluorescence-resonance energy transfer was used to calculate distances between tryptophan residues and protein-bound 8-anilinonaphthalene 1-sulphonate (an anionic ligand) in the human class-alpha glutathione S-transferase, and in a human Trp28-->Phe mutant class-pi glutathione S-transferase. Distance values of 2.21 nm and 1.82 nm were calculated for the class-alpha and class-pi enzymes, respectively. Since glutathione S-transferases bind one non-substrate ligand/protein dimer, the ligand-binding region, according to the calculated distances, is found to be located in the dimer interface near the twofold axis. This region is the same as that in which the parasitic helminth Schistosoma japonicum glutathione S-transferase binds praziquantel, a non-substrate drug used to treat schistosomiasis [McTigue, M. A., Williams, D. R. & Tainer, J. A. (1995) J. Mol. Biol. 246, 21-27]. Since the overall folding topology is conserved and certain features at the dimer interface are similar throughout the superfamily, it is reasonable to expect that all cytosolic glutathione S-transferases bind non-substrate ligands in the amphipathic groove at the dimer interface.

Rational modulation of the catalytic activity of A1-1 glutathione S-transferase: evidence for incorporation of an on-face (pi...HO-Ar) hydrogen bond at tyrosine-9

The alpha-, pi-, and mu-class glutathione S-transferases utilize a hydrogen bond between a conserved tyrosine and glutathione (GSH) to stabilize the nucleophilic thiolate anion, as Tyr-OH...-SG. This hydrogen bond is critical for efficient detoxication catalysis. The detailed structure of this hydrogen bond, however, is controlled by active site features which are not conserved across class boundaries. The alpha-class GST A1-1 has a cluster of aromatic residues on one side of the ring of the catalytic tyrosine, Tyr-9. Also, a hydrophobic Met-16 side chain is packed against the edge of the ring of Tyr-9. Molecular modeling and ab initio calculations suggested that substitution of Phe-220 with tyrosine could generate an aromatic on-face hydrogen bond (pi...HO-Ar) between the ring of Tyr-9 and the hydroxyl group of Tyr-220, and this would lower the pKa of enzyme-bound GSH. Therefore, Phe-220 was replaced by Tyr in the rat A1-1 isozyme. Also, Met-16 was replaced by Thr in order to investigate the effect of a hydrogen bond donor at the Tyr-9 ring edge. UV spectroscopic titration of GST.GSH and steady-state kinetic analysis indicate that substitution of Tyr at Phe-220 results in a decrease of the pKa of the cofactor, whereas substitution of Met-16 with Thr results in an increase of this pKa. Also, the pKa of Tyr-9 in the absence of substrates was determined directly by fluorescence titration. Substitutions F220Y and M16T resulted in a decrease of 0.5 pKa unit and an increase of 0.6 pKa unit, respectively. Together, these results indicate that a weak hydrogen bond between the engineered Tyr-220 side chain and the aromatic ring face of the catalytic Tyr-9 decreases the pKa of GSH and Tyr-9, and this alters the pH dependence of the enzymatic reaction.

Structural flexibility modulates the activity of human glutathione transferase P1-1. Role of helix 2 flexibility in the catalytic mechanism

Presteady-state and steady-state kinetic studies performed on human glutathione transferase P1-1 (EC 2.5.1.18) with 1-chloro-2, 4-dinitrobenzene as co-substrate indicate that the rate-determining step is a physical event that occurs after binding of the two substrates and before the final sigma-complex formation. It may be a structural transition involving the ternary complex. This event can be related to diffusion-controlled motions of protein portions as kcat degrees /kcat linearly increases by raising the relative viscosity of the solution. Similar viscosity dependence has been observed for Km GSH, while Km CDNB is independent. No change of the enzyme structure by viscosogen has been found by circular dichroism analysis. Thus, kcat and Km GSH seem to be related to the frequency and extent of enzyme structural motions modulated by viscosity. Interestingly, the reactivity of Cys-47 which can act as a probe for the flexibility of helix 2 is also modulated by viscosity. Its viscosity dependence parallels that observed for kcat and Km GSH, thereby suggesting a possible correlation between kcat, Km GSH, and diffusion-controlled motion of helix 2. The viscosity effect on the kinetic parameters of C47S and C47S/C101S mutants confirms the involvement of helix 2 motions in the modulation of Km GSH, whereas a similar role on kcat cannot be ascertained unequivocally. The flexibility of helix 2 modulates also the homotropic behavior of GSH in these mutants. Furthermore, fluorescence experiments support a structural motion of about 4 A occurring between helix 2 and helix 4 when GSH binds to the G-site.

Involvement of the carboxyl groups of glutathione in the catalytic mechanism of human glutathione transferase A1-1

The present study proposes the participation of both carboxylate groups of the glutathione molecule as functional entities in the catalytic apparatus of human glutathione transferase (GST) A1-1. Functional studies in combination with structural data provide evidence for the alpha-carboxylate of the Glu residue of glutathione acting as a proton acceptor in the catalytic mechanism. The Glu carboxylate is hydrogen-bonded to a protein hydroxyl group and a main-chain NH, as well as to a water molecule of low mobility in the active site region. The Glu alpha-carboxylate of glutathione is bound in a similar manner to the active sites of mammalian glutathione transferases of classes Alpha, Mu, and Pi, for which three-dimensional structures are known. Mutation of the hydroxyl group that is hydrogen-bonded to the alpha-carboxylate of the Glu residue of glutathione (Thr68->Val) caused a shift of the pH dependence of the enzyme-catalyzed reaction, suggesting that the acidic limb of the pH-activity profile reflects the ionization of the carboxylate of the Glu residue of glutathione. The second carboxylate group of glutathione, which is part of its Gly residue, interacts with two Arg side chains in GST A1-1. One of these residues (Arg45) may influence an ionic interaction (Arg221/Asp42), which appears to contribute to binding of the second substrate by fixing the C-terminal alpha-helix as a lid over the active site. Removal of the Gly residue from the glutathione molecule caused a 13-fold increase in the KM value for the electrophilic substrate. Thus, the Gly carboxylate of glutathione, by way of influencing the topology of the active site, contributes to the binding of the second substrate of the enzyme. Consequently, the glutathione molecule has several functions in the glutathione transferase catalyzed reactions, not only as a substrate providing the thiol group for different types of chemical reactions but also as a substrate contributing a carboxylate that acts as a proton acceptor in the catalytic mechanism and a carboxylate that modulates binding of the second substrate to the enzyme.

Ligand effects on the fluorescence properties of tyrosine-9 in alpha 1-1 glutathione S-transferase

A conserved tyrosine plays a critical role in catalysis by mammalian glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) of the alpha-, mu-, and pi-classes, by forming a hydrogen bond to and stabilizing the thiolate form of glutathione. The hydrogen bonding properties of this tyrosine in the rat A1-1 GST (Tyr-9), in the absence and presence of ligands, have been studied by steady state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy. In order to achieve this, the single tryptophan (Trp 21) found in the rat A1-1 GST has been replaced with the fluorometrically silent phenylalanine (W21F). Additionally, a double mutant lacking this tryptophan and the catalytic tyrosine (W21F:Y9F) has been constructed, and these mutants have been used as probes of ligand effects at Tyr-9. A comparison of the correlated excitation--emission spectra of the W21F mutant and the W21F-Y9F indicates that a red-shifted emission component is contributed by Tyr-9 with excitation bands at 255 and 300 nm, in the ligand-free enzyme. The pH-dependence of the intensity of these spectral cross-peaks is consistent with an active site tyrosine with a pKa of 8.1-8.3. Upon addition of GSH, the red-shifted component is quenched. Multifrequency phase/modulation fluorescence experiments qualitatively demonstrate that GSH causes a decrease in the average excited state lifetime on the red-edge of the spectrum of W21F but not of the W21F:Y9F spectrum. Steady state correlated difference spectra (W21F-W21F:Y9F) have been used to obtain a model for the excitation-emission correlated spectrum of Tyr-9, which indicates that Tyr-9 is heterogeneous at pH 7.5, with properties of both tyrosinate and "normal tyrosine". The tyrosinate fraction is eliminated, and the blue-shifted component becomes more intense upon addition of GSH conjugates, indicating that the weak hydrogen bond between Tyr-9 and thioethers has little charge-transfer character. The S-methyl GSH yields an "anomalous" spectrum at pH 7.5, which retains cross-peaks consistent with ionized tyrosinate. These results indicate that, in the absence of ligand, Tyr-9 forms a strongly polarized hydrogen bond or a fraction of the phenolic hydroxyl group is partially deprotonated. However, when a GSH conjugate with a sufficiently large hydrophobic group occupies the H-site, Tyr-9 is fully protonated, with little charge-transfer character.