A Unified View of the Role of Electrostatic Interactions in Modulating the Gating of Cys Loop Receptors

Allosteric modulation of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors

Allosteric modulation refers to the concept that proteins could exist in multiple conformational states and that binding of allosteric ligands alters the energy barriers or "isomerization coefficients" between various states. In the context of ligand gated ion channels such as nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAChRs), it implies that endogenous ligand acetylcholine binds at the orthosteric site, and that molecules that bind elsewhere on the nAChR subunit(s) acts via allosteric interactions. For example, studies with the homomeric alpha7 nAChRs indicate that such ligand interactions can be well described by an allosteric model, and that positive allosteric effectors can affect energy transitions by (i) predominantly affecting the peak current response (Type I profile) or, (ii) both peak current responses and time course of agonist-evoked response (Type II profile). The recent discovery of chemically heterogeneous group of molecules capable of differentially modifying nAChR properties without interacting at the ligand binding site illustrates the adequacy of the allosteric model to predict functional consequences. In this review, we outline general principles of the allosteric concept and summarize the profiles of novel compounds that are emerging as allosteric modulators at the alpha7 and alpha4beta2 nAChR subtypes.

GABA(A) receptors: structure and function in the basal ganglia

gamma-Aminobutyric acid type A (GABA(A)) receptors, the major inhibitory neurotransmitter receptors responsible for fast inhibition in the basal ganglia, belong to the superfamily of "cys-cys loop" ligand-gated ion channels. GABA(A) receptors form as pentameric assemblies of subunits, with a central Cl(-) permeable pore. On binding of two GABA molecules to the extracellular receptor domain, a conformational change is induced in the oligomer and Cl(-), in most adult neurons, moves into the cell leading to an inhibitory hyperpolarization. Nineteen mammalian subunit genes have been identified, each showing distinct regional and cell-type-specific expression. The combinatorial assembly of the subunits generates considerable functional diversity. Here we place the focus on GABA(A) receptor expression in the basal ganglia: striatum, globus pallidus, substantia nigra and subthalamic nucleus, where, in addition to the standard alpha1beta2/3gamma2 receptor subtype, significant levels of other subunits (alpha2, alpha3, alpha4, gamma1, gamma3 and delta) are expressed in some nuclei.

Establishing an ion pair interaction in the homomeric rho1 gamma-aminobutyric acid type A receptor that contributes to the gating pathway

gamma-Aminobutyric acid type A (GABA(A)) receptors are members of the Cys-loop superfamily of ligand-gated ion channels. Upon agonist binding, the receptor undergoes a structural transition from the closed to the open state, but the mechanism of gating is not well understood. Here we utilized a combination of conventional mutagenesis and the high precision methodology of unnatural amino acid incorporation to study the gating interface of the human homopentameric rho1 GABA(A) receptor. We have identified an ion pair interaction between two conserved charged residues, Glu(92) in loop 2 of the extracellular domain and Arg(258) in the pre-M1 region. We hypothesize that the salt bridge exists in the closed state by kinetic measurements and free energy analysis. Several other charged residues at the gating interface are not critical to receptor function, supporting previous conclusions that it is the global charge pattern of the gating interface that controls receptor function in the Cys-loop superfamily.

Gating of nicotinic ACh receptors; new insights into structural transitions triggered by agonist binding that induce channel opening

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAChRs) are in the superfamily of Cys-loop ligand-gated ion channels, and are pentameric assemblies of five subunits, with each subunit arranged around the central ion-conducting pore. The binding of ACh to the extracellular interface between two subunits induces channel opening. With the recent 4 A resolution of the Torpedo nAChR, and the crystal structure of the related molluscan ACh binding protein, much has been learned about the structure of the ligand binding domain and the channel pore, as well as major structural rearrangements that may confer channel opening. For example, the putative pathway coupling agonist binding to channel gating may include a major rearrangement of the C-loop within the ligand binding pocket, and the disruption of a salt bridge between an arginine residue at the end of the beta10 strand and a glutamate residue in the beta1-beta2 linker. Here we will review and discuss the latest structural findings aiming to further refine the transduction pathway linking binding to gating for the nAChR channels, and discuss similarities and differences among the different members of this Cys-loop superfamily of receptors.

Crystal structure of the extracellular domain of nAChR alpha1 bound to alpha-bungarotoxin at 1.94 A resolution

We determined the crystal structure of the extracellular domain of the mouse nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) alpha1 subunit bound to alpha-bungarotoxin at 1.94 A resolution. This structure is the first atomic-resolution view of a nAChR subunit extracellular domain, revealing receptor-specific features such as the main immunogenic region (MIR), the signature Cys-loop and the N-linked carbohydrate chain. The toxin binds to the receptor through extensive protein-protein and protein-sugar interactions. To our surprise, the structure showed a well-ordered water molecule and two hydrophilic residues deep in the core of the alpha1 subunit. The two hydrophilic core residues are highly conserved in nAChRs, but correspond to hydrophobic residues in the nonchannel homolog acetylcholine-binding proteins. We carried out site-directed mutagenesis and electrophysiology analyses to assess the functional role of the glycosylation and the hydrophilic core residues. Our structural and functional studies show essential features of the nAChR and provide new insights into the gating mechanism.

Non-charged amino acids from three different domains contribute to link agonist binding to channel gating in alpha7 nicotinic acetylcholine receptors

Binding of agonists to nicotinic acetylcholine receptors results in channel opening. Previously, we have shown that several charged residues at three different domains of the alpha7 nicotinic receptor are involved in coupling binding and gating, probably through a network of electrostatic interactions. This network, however, could also be integrated by other residues. To test this hypothesis, non-charged amino acids were mutated and expression levels and electrophysiological responses of mutant receptors were determined. Mutants at positions Asn47 and Gln48 (loop 2), Ile130, Trp134, and Gln140 (loop 7), and Thr264 (M2-M3 linker) showed poor or null functional responses, despite significant membrane expression. By contrast, mutants F137A and S265A exhibited a gain of function effect. In all cases, changes in dose-response relationships were small, EC(50) values being between threefold smaller and fivefold larger, arguing against large modifications of agonist binding. Peak currents decayed at the same rate in all receptors except two, excluding large effects on desensitization. Thus, the observed changes could be mostly caused by alterations of the gating characteristics. Moreover, analysis of double mutants showed an interconnection between some residues in these domains, especially Gln48 with Ile130, suggesting a potential coupling between agonist binding and channel gating through these amino acids.

Transducing agonist binding to channel gating involves different interactions in 5-HT3 and GABAC receptors

5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT)3 and gamma-aminobutyric acid, type C (GABAC) receptors are members of the Cys-loop superfamily of neurotransmitter receptors, which also includes nicotinic acetylcholine, GABAA, and glycine receptors. The details of how agonist binding to these receptors results in channel opening is not fully understood but is known to involve charged residues at the extracellular/transmembrane interface. Here we have examined the roles of such residues in 5-HT3 and GABAC receptors. Charge reversal experiments combined with data from activation by the partial agonist beta-alanine show that in GABAC receptors there is a salt bridge between Glu-92 (in loop 2) and Arg-258 (in the pre-M1 region), which is involved in receptor gating. The equivalent residues in the 5-HT3 receptor are important for receptor expression, but charge reversal experiments do not restore function, indicating that there is not a salt bridge here. There is, however, an interaction between Glu-215 (loop 9) and Arg-246 (pre-M1) in the 5-HT3 receptor, although the coupling energy determined from mutant cycle analysis is lower than might be expected for a salt bridge. Overall the data show that charged residues at the extracellular/transmembrane domain interfaces in 5-HT3 and GABAC receptors are important and that specific, but not equivalent, molecular interactions between them are involved in the gating process. Thus, we propose that the molecular details of interactions in the transduction pathway between the binding site and the pore can differ between different Cys-loop receptors.

Evidence that ethanol acts on a target in Loop 2 of the extracellular domain of alpha1 glycine receptors

Considerable evidence indicates that ethanol acts on specific residues in the transmembrane domains of glycine receptors (GlyRs). In this study, we tested the hypothesis that the extracellular domain is also a target for ethanol action by investigating the effect of cysteine substitutions at positions 52 (extracellular domain) and 267 (transmembrane domain) on responses to n-alcohols and propyl methanethiosulfonate (PMTS) in alpha1GlyRs expressed in Xenopus oocytes. In support of the hypothesis: (i) The A52C mutation changed ethanol sensitivity compared to WT GlyRs; (ii) PMTS produced irreversible alcohol-like potentiation in A52C GlyRs; and (iii) PMTS binding reduced the n-chain alcohol cutoff in A52C GlyRs. Further studies used PMTS binding to cysteines at positions 52 or 267 to block ethanol action at one site in order to determine its effect at other site(s). In these situations, ethanol caused negative modulation when acting at position 52 and positive modulation when acting at position 267. Collectively, these findings parallel the evidence that established the TM domain as a target for ethanol, suggest that positions 52 and 267 are part of the same alcohol pocket and indicate that the net effect of ethanol on GlyR function reflects the summation of its positive and negative modulatory effects on different targets.

Exploring ligand recognition and ion flow in comparative models of the human GABA type A receptor

We present two comparative models of the GABA(A) receptor. Model 1 is based on the 4-A resolution structure of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor from Torpedo marmorata and represents the unliganded receptor. Two agonists, GABA and muscimol, two benzodiazepines, flunitrazepam and alprazolam, together with the general anaesthetic halothane, have been docked to this model. The ion flow is also explored in model 1 by evaluating the interaction energy of a chloride ion as it traverses the extracellular, transmembrane and intracellular domains of the protein. Model 2 differs from model 1 only in the extracellular domain and represents the liganded receptor. Comparison between the two models not only allows us to explore commonalities and differences with comparative models of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor, but also suggests possible protein sub-domain interactions with the GABA(A) receptor not previously addressed.

Agonist-driven conformational changes in the inner beta-sheet of alpha7 nicotinic receptors

Cys-loop ligand-gated ion channels assemble as pentameric proteins, and each monomer contributes two structural elements: an extracellular ligand-binding domain (LBD) and a transmembrane ion channel domain. Models of receptor activation include rotational movements of subunits leading to opening of the ion channel. We tested this idea using substituted cysteine accessibility to track conformational changes in the inner beta sheet of the LBD. Using a nondesensitizing chick alpha7 background (L(247)T), we constructed 18 consecutive cysteine replacement mutants (Leu(36) to Ile(53)) and tested each for expression of acetylcholine (ACh)-evoked currents and functional sensitivity to thiol modification. We measured rates of modification in the presence and absence of ACh to identify conformational changes associated with receptor activation. Resting modification rates of eight substituted cysteines in the beta1 and beta2 strands and the sequence between them (loop 2) varied over several orders of magnitude, suggesting substantial differences in the accessibility or electrostatic environment of individual side chains. These differences were in general agreement with structural models of the LBD. Eight of 18 cysteine replacements displayed ACh-dependent changes in modification rates, indicating a change in the accessibility or electrostatic environment of the introduced cysteine during activation. We were surprised that the effects of agonist exposure were difficult to reconcile with rotational models of activation. Acetylcholine reduced the modification rate of M(40)C but increased it at N(52)C despite the close physical proximity of these residues. Our results suggest that models that depend strictly on rigid-body rotation of the LBD may provide an incomplete description of receptor activation.

The cellular, molecular and ionic basis of GABA(A) receptor signalling

GABA(A) receptors mediate fast synaptic inhibition in the CNS. Whilst this is undoubtedly true, it is a gross oversimplification of their actions. The receptors themselves are diverse, being formed from a variety of subunits, each with a different temporal and spatial pattern of expression. This diversity is reflected in differences in subcellular targetting and in the subtleties of their response to GABA. While activation of the receptors leads to an inevitable increase in membrane conductance, the voltage response is dictated by the distribution of the permeant Cl(-) and HCO(3)(-) ions, which is established by anion transporters. Similar to GABA(A) receptors, the expression of these transporters is not only developmentally regulated but shows cell-specific and subcellular variation. Untangling all these complexities allows us to appreciate the variety of GABA-mediated signalling, a diverse set of phenomena encompassing both synaptic and non-synaptic functions that can be overtly excitatory as well as inhibitory.

The pre-M1 segment of the alpha1 subunit is a transduction element in the activation of the GABAA receptor

The binding of the neurotransmitter GABA induces conformational changes in the GABAA receptor (GABAAR), leading to the opening of a gate that controls ion permeation through an integral transmembrane pore. A number of structural elements within each subunit, located near the membrane interface, are believed to undergo relative movements during this activation process. In this study, we explored the functional role of the beta-10 strand (pre-M1 segment), which connects the extracellular domain to the transmembrane domain. In alpha1beta2gamma2s GABAARs, analysis of the 12 residues of the beta-10 strand in the alpha1 subunit proximal to the first transmembrane domain identified two residues, alpha1V212 and alpha1K220, in which mutations produced rightward shifts in the GABA concentration-response relationship and also reduced the relative efficacy of the partial agonist, piperidine-4-sulphonic acid. Ultra-fast agonist techniques were applied to mutant alpha1(K220A)beta2gamma2s GABAARs and revealed that the macroscopic functional deficit in this mutant could be attributed to a slowing of the opening rate constant, from approximately 1500 s(-1) in wild-type (WT) channels to approximately 730 s(-1) in the mutant channels, and a reduction in the time spent in the active state for the mutant. These changes were accompanied by a decrease in agonist affinity, with half-maximal activation rates achieved at 0.77 mM GABA in WT and 1.4 mM GABA in the alpha1(K220A)beta2gamma2s channels. The beta-10 strand (pre-M1 segment) emerges, from this and other studies, as a key functional component in the activation of the GABAAR.

Modulating inhibitory ligand-gated ion channels

The glycine and gamma-aminobutyric acid receptors (GlyR and GABA(A)R, respectively) are the major inhibitory neurotransmitter-gated receptors in the central nervous system of animals. Given the important role of these receptors in neuronal inhibition, they are prime targets of many therapeutic agents and are the object of intense studies aimed at correlating their structure and function. In this review, the structure and dynamics of these and other homologous members of the nicotinicoid superfamily are described. The modulatory actions of the major biological macromolecules that bind and allosterically affect these receptors are also discussed.

The net orientation of nicotinic receptor transmembrane alpha-helices in the resting and desensitized states

The net orientation of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor transmembrane alpha-helices has been probed in both the activatable resting and nonactivatable desensitized states using linear dichroism Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy. Infrared spectra recorded from reconstituted nicotinic acetylcholine receptor membranes after 72 h exposure to (2)H2O exhibit an intense amide I component band near 1655 cm(-1) that is due predominantly to hydrogen-exchange-resistant transmembrane peptides in an alpha-helical conformation. The measured dichroism of this band is 2.37, suggesting a net tilt of the transmembrane alpha-helices of roughly 40 degrees from the bilayer normal, although this value overestimates the tilt angle because the measured dichroism at 1655 cm(-1) also reflects the dichroism of overlapping amide I component bands. Significantly, no change in the net orientation of the transmembrane alpha-helices is observed upon agonist binding. In fact, the main changes in structure and orientation detected upon desensitization involve highly solvent accessible regions of the polypeptide backbone. Our data are consistent with a capping of the ligand binding site by the solvent accessible C-loop with little change in the structure of the transmembrane domain in the desensitized state. Changes in structure at the interface between the ligand-binding and transmembrane domains may uncouple binding from gating.

Recent advances in Cys-loop receptor structure and function

Throughout the nervous system, moment-to-moment communication relies on postsynaptic receptors to detect neurotransmitters and change the membrane potential. For the Cys-loop superfamily of receptors, recent structural data have catalysed a leap in our understanding of the three steps of chemical-to-electrical transduction: neurotransmitter binding, communication between the binding site and the barrier to ions, and opening and closing of the barrier. The emerging insights might be expected to explain how mutations of receptors cause neurological disease, but the opposite is generally true. Namely, analyses of disease-causing mutations have clarified receptor structure-function relationships as well as mechanisms governing the postsynaptic response.

Evolutionarily conserved allosteric network in the Cys loop family of ligand-gated ion channels revealed by statistical covariance analyses

The Cys loop family of ligand-gated ion channels mediate fast synaptic transmission for communication between neurons. They are allosteric proteins, in which binding of a neurotransmitter to its binding site in the extracellular amino-terminal domain triggers structural changes in distant transmembrane domains to open a channel for ion flow. Although the locations of binding site and channel gating machinery are well defined, the structural basis of the activation pathway coupling binding and channel opening remains to be determined. In this paper, by analyzing amino acid covariance in a multiple sequence alignment, we have identified an energetically interconnected network in the Cys loop family of ligand-gated ion channels. Statistical coupling and correlated mutational analyses along with clustering revealed a highly coupled cluster. Mapping the positions in the cluster onto a three-dimensional structural model demonstrated that these highly coupled positions form an interconnected network linking experimentally identified binding domains through the coupling region to the gating machinery. In addition, these highly coupled positions are also condensed in the transmembrane domains, which are a recent focus for the sites of action of many allosteric modulators. Thus, our results revealed a genetically interconnected network that potentially plays an important role in the allosteric activation and modulation of the Cys loop family of ligand-gated ion channels.

Role of the Outer β-Sheet in Divalent Cation Modulation of α7 Nicotinic Receptors

alpha-7 Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) exhibit a positive modulation by divalent cations similar to that observed in other AChRs. In the chick alpha7 AChR, this modulation involves a conserved glutamate in loop 9 (Glu172) that undergoes agonist-dependent movements during activation. From these observations, we hypothesized that movements of the nearby beta-sheet formed by the beta7, beta9, and beta10 strands may be involved in agonist activation and/or divalent modulation. To test this hypothesis, we examined functional properties of cysteine mutations of the beta7 and beta10 strands, alone or in pairs. We postulated that reduced flexibility or mobility of the beta7/beta9/beta10-sheet as a result of introduction of a disulfide bond between the beta strands would alter activation by agonists. Using a nondesensitizing alpha7 mutant background (L247T), we identified one mutant pair, K144C + T198C, that exhibited a unique characteristic: it was fully activated by divalent cations (Ca2+, Ba2+, or Sr2+) in the absence of acetylcholine (ACh). Divalent-evoked currents were blocked by the alpha7 antagonist methyllycaconitine and were abolished when Glu172 was mutated to glutamine. When the K144C + T198C pair was expressed in wild-type alpha7 receptors, activation required both ACh and divalent cations. We conclude that the introduction of a disulfide bond into beta7/beta9/beta10 lowers the energetic barrier between open and closed conformations, probably by reducing the torsional flexibility of the beta-sheet. In this setting, divalent cations, acting at the conserved glutamate in loop 9, act as full agonists or requisite coagonists.

Understanding ion channel selectivity and gating and their role in cellular signalling

Ion channels play an essential role in the communication between and within cells. Here some of the different ion channel proteins and the roles they perform are introduced, before a discussion of the mechanisms by which they discriminate between different ion types and open and close to allow the passage of ions at the appropriate times.