Skin graft rejection by beta 2-microglobulin-deficient mice

Positive selection of self- and alloreactive CD8+ T cells in Tap-1 mutant mice

Mice with a homozygous deletion in their Tap-1 gene (-/- mice) express very low levels of cell membrane major histocompatibility complex class I molecules and have < 1% peripheral CD8+ T cells. We show that these -/- mice but not their +/- littermates display strong primary syngeneic anti-H-2Kb and -Db-specific responses mediated by CD8+ T cells. These responses are augmented by in vivo priming. Further, -/- mice primed in vivo with H-2d alloantigens generate an anti-H-2d response which appears nearly as strong as that found in +/- littermates. Both -/- anti-H-2b and anti-H-2d T cells do not recognize target cells from Tap-1 -/- animals or Tap-2-deficient RMA-S cells. Thus, some CD8+ anti-self and alloreactive T cells can be selected in the absence of Tap proteins.

Multiple natural killer cell-activating signals are inhibited by major histocompatibility complex class I expression in target cells

Several lines of evidence indicate that major histocompatibility complex class I molecules expressed by target cells can prevent natural killer cell (NK) lysis, possibly by engaging inhibitory receptors expressed by NK cells. On the other hand it is likely that NK cells must be activated to lysis by the recognition of unidentified NK target structures on target cells. To investigate the relationship between positive activation of NK cells by NK target structures versus inhibition by target cell class I molecules, we have examined various NK/target cell interactions for which the expression of inhibitory class I molecules by the target cells is known. The results suggests that specific properties of the target cell other than the absence of class I expression are necessary to activate NK-mediated lysis. Furthermore, different effector cell populations, i.e. freshly isolated versus interleukin-2 activated NK cells, differ in their capacity to kill class I-deficient lymphoblast target cells. In general, class I-deficient target cells that are resistant to direct lysis by a given NK population can be lysed by the NK cells when the reaction is mediated by antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC). Most significantly, all types of NK-mediated lysis of lymphoblasts, of tumor cells and of almost any target by ADCC can be inhibited by appropriate class I gene expression in the target cell. These results suggest a model in which lysis by NK cells must be triggered by any one of a set of distinct target cell ligands, but that all of these signals can be overruled by class I-mediated inhibition.

The CD8+ T cell repertoire in beta 2-microglobulin-deficient mice is biased towards reactivity against self-major histocompatibility class I

Beta 2-Microglobulin-deficient (beta 2m -/-) mice are reported to lack cell surface expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules, CD8+ T cells, and the ability to mount MHC class I-specific T cell responses. We have observed that beta 2m -/- mice possess CD8+ T cells that can be induced to perform strong allospecific cytotoxic responses against nonself-MHC class I by in vivo priming. We report that these beta 2m -/- cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) differ from those induced in beta 2m-positive littermates in that they cross-react and kill cells expressing self-MHC class I at normal ligand density with beta 2m. beta 2m -/- CTL could even be induced in primary mixed lymphocyte culture by self-MHC class I expressing stimulator cells, whereas allogeneic stimulator cells failed to elicit a response under similar conditions. Cells with a reduced cell surface MHC class I expression were less sensitive, while syngeneic beta 2m -/- cells were resistant to the beta 2m -/- CTL. This antiself-MHC reactivity could not be induced when beta 2m -/- T cells matured in an environment with normal MHC class I expression in bone marrow chimeric mice. Antiself-MHC reactivity was also observed against human peptide loading-deficient cells expressing the appropriate murine class I molecules, suggesting that affinity to self-MHC class I may occur irrespective of peptide content. The results fit with a model where positive and negative selection of CD8+ T cells in beta 2m -/- mice is mediated by low levels of MHC class I free heavy chains. In this model, low ligand density on selecting cells leads to positive selection of rare T cells that bind to low levels of MHC class I free heavy chains, resulting in a very small peripheral CD8+ compartment. Due to low density of the selecting ligand, negative selection does not remove T cells recognizing beta 2m-positive cells expressing self-MHC class I at normal ligand density, which generates a T cell repertoire that would be autoreactive in a beta 2m-positive littermate. The first "MHC deficient" animals thus paradoxically provide a tool for direct demonstration and analysis of self MHC bias in the T cell repertoire.

Increased number of cytotoxic T cells within CD4+8- T cells in beta 2-microglobulin, major histocompatibility complex class I-deficient mice

Targeted disruption of beta 2-microglobulin gene results in deficient major histocompatibility complex class I expression and failure to develop CD4-8+ T cells. Despite this, beta 2 M-/- mice reject skin grafts and cope with most viral infections tested. We asked whether CD4+8- cytotoxic T cells would play a role in compensating for the defect in CD4-8+ cytotoxic T cell function. We found that the cytotoxic activity against class II+ targets is significantly higher among CD4+8- T cells of beta 2M-/- than among those of beta 2M+/+ mice. In the limiting dilution experiment, we showed that the precursor frequency for the cytotoxic, CD4+8-, class II-specific T cells is at least fivefold higher in beta 2M-/- than in beta 2M+/+ mice. These results suggest that CD4+8- cytotoxic T cells could play a major role in carrying out cytotoxic function in beta 2M-/- mice.

Divergence between cytotoxic effector function and tumor necrosis factor alpha production for inflammatory CD4+ T cells from mice with Sendai virus pneumonia

Sendai virus pneumonia in beta 2-microglobulin-deficient [beta 2-m(-/-)] mice lacking CD8+ T cells is characterized by the development of CD4+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes that can be recovered directly from the respiratory tract. These CD4+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes are not found in beta 2-m (+/+) mice, though inflammatory CD4+ T cells from both beta 2-m (-/-) and beta 2-m (+/+) mice produce substantial amounts of tumor necrosis factor alpha. Blocking experiments with a monoclonal antibody that also inhibits tumor necrosis factor beta show that the secreted forms of these two cytokines are not responsible for virus-specific killing of class II major histocompatibility complex-compatible targets. Comparison of electron micrographs indicates that the CD4+ effectors from the beta 2-m (-/-) mice are potent inducers of apoptosis, while this is not the case for the beta 2-m (+/+) CD4+ set. These experiments further define the functional status of virus-specific CD4+ T cells responding in vivo in the presence or absence of CD8+ effectors.

Graft rejection by T cells not restricted by conventional major histocompatibility complex molecules

The appropriate crosses of mice lacking conventional major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I or class II molecules generate single- and double-deficient offspring. These were used as donors for skin grafts across major plus minor, or just minor, histocompatibility differences. Surprisingly, in the two circumstances, there was a rapid rejection of grafts lacking both MHC class I and class II molecules. Rejection was mediated by thymically derived CD4+ T cells of the host. We provide evidence that these T cells recognize an unconventional ligand, capable of activating a pre-formed T cell compartment but incapable of positively selecting it. The existence of this unexpected rejection phenomenon should serve to caution those aiming to engineer "universal donor" cells by simply abrogating expression of MHC class I and class II molecules.

Genetically modified animals and immunodeficiency

Mouse strains with defined genetic defects engineered by the method of targeted gene disruption and homologous recombination have furthered our understanding of immune functions at the single gene level. More importantly, these mutant 'gene knockout' mice are powerful in vivo tools to dissect the complex mechanisms of lymphocyte development and function, complementing our broadening knowledge of congenital and acquired human immunodeficiencies.

Virus infections in mice with targeted gene disruptions

The experimental dissection of the ways that the various cells and molecules of the immune system interact to promote virus clearance has been greatly facilitated by the availability of mice with targeted disruptions of key genes. New insights are emerging, and details of host resistance mechanisms that could only be inferred for the in vivo situation are now being clearly established.

Lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus induces a chronic wasting disease in mice lacking class I major histocompatibility complex glycoproteins

Lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) induces a chronic, wasting syndrome when injected intracerebrally into H-2b mice homozygous for a beta 2-microglobulin (beta 2-m (-/-)) gene disruption. These mice have very few CD8+ T cells and express little class I MHC glycoprotein, though minimal levels of the H-2Db molecule have been detected on in vitro cultured beta 2-m (-/-) cells. The underlying immunopathological process in these beta 2-m (-/-) mice is mediated by virus immune CD4+ effectors. However, adoptively transferred CD8+ T cells from normal, LCMV-infected H-2Db compatible donors induce significant (but low level) meningitis in beta 2-m (-/-) recipients. Such mice develop neither the neurological disease characteristic of LCM nor the persistent, though generally non-fatal, debility that occurs when only the CD4+ T cell subset is involved.

Alloreactive cytotoxic T cells can develop and function in mice lacking both CD4 and CD8

Using the technique of homologous recombination in embryonic stem cells, a mouse strain without functional CD4 and CD8 genes has been generated. Surprisingly, these mice contain significant numbers of alpha beta T cells. Although mice deficient for CD8 only do not show any cytotoxic response when their T cells are stimulated with either alloantigen or viral antigen, the CD4-8- mice do generate alloreactive cytotoxic T cells. These cytotoxic T cells bear the alpha beta T cell receptor and recognize major histocompatibility complex class I antigens. In addition fully allogeneic skin transplants were rejected but skin transplants expressing only minor transplantation antigens were not. Virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes were also not detected. It seems that alloreactive cytotoxic T cells can be induced and exert their effector function in vitro and in vivo in the absence of CD8, and that they can develop and mature in vivo without the CD8 molecule or the signals it might provide.

Mice lacking major histocompatibility complex class I and class II molecules

Mice lacking major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens were generated by mating beta 2-microglobulin-deficient, and therefore class I-deficient, animals with MHC class II-deficient animals. When housed under sterile conditions, the resulting MHC-deficient mice appear healthy, survive for many months, and breed successfully. Phenotypically, MHC-deficient mice are depleted of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in peripheral lymphoid organs due to a lack of appropriate restricting elements. In contrast, the B-cell compartment of these animals appears intact, and MHC-deficient mice can mount specific antibody responses when challenged with a T-independent antigen. Spleen cells from MHC-deficient animals are poor stimulators and responders in a mixed lymphocyte reaction. Despite their relatively weak cellular immune responses in vitro, MHC-deficient mice reject allogeneic skin grafts with little delay, and grafts from MHC-deficient animals are rapidly rejected by normal allogeneic recipients. Taken together, these results emphasize the plasticity of the immune system and suggest that MHC-deficient mice may be useful for examining compensatory mechanisms in severely immunocompromised animals.

Highly lytic CD8+, alpha beta T-cell receptor cytotoxic T cells with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I antigen-directed cytotoxicity in beta 2-microglobulin, MHC class I-deficient mice

Targeted disruption of the beta 2-microglobulin (beta 2m) gene results in major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I deficiency and virtual disappearance of functional CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) in beta 2m-deficient (beta 2m-/-) mice. We asked whether the beta 2m-/- mice are able to reject tumor cells injected i.p. and what is the cellular composition of peritoneal exudate leukocytes (PELs) from such mice. We found that beta 2m-/- mice do reject MHC class I-bearing tumor cells injected i.p. Surprisingly, analysis of PEL CTLs obtained from i.p. tumor-injected beta 2m -/- mice revealed the presence of a large proportion of functional, tumor-destroying CD8+, CD4-, alpha beta T-cell receptor-positive, CD3+, Thy-1+, MHC class I-negative CTLs with strong MHC class I-directed cytotoxic activity. These results call for careful studies of local accumulation of CD8+ CTLs in beta 2m -/- mouse models and suggest that the dramatic decrease in MHC class I expression caused by beta 2m gene disruption does not prevent CD8+/CD4- cell selection and expansion.

CD8 T cells can protect against an intracellular bacterium in an interferon gamma-independent fashion

Specific T-cell immunity to Listeria monocytogenes is thought to occur through the action of lymphokines which activate phagocytes to ingest and kill microorganisms. Interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) has been shown to be an effective mediator of this type of macrophage activation in vivo and in vitro. The monoclonal antibody H22.1 efficiently neutralizes endogenous IFN-gamma, exacerbates disease in a mouse model of L. monocytogenes infection, and inhibits the in vivo protective activity of a Listeria antigen-specific CD4 T-cell line. In contrast, in vivo protection by Listeria-immune CD8 T cells is not inhibited by the neutralizing anti-IFN-gamma monoclonal antibody. These results suggest that CD8 T cells can protect against an intracellular pathogen in an IFN-gamma-independent manner.

Antiviral immune responses of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus-infected mice lacking CD8+ T lymphocytes because of disruption of the beta 2-microglobulin gene

Mice infected intracerebrally with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCM virus) develop a characteristic central nervous system disease and usually die. If the intravenous or intraperitoneal route is used, the infection leads to less severe clinical signs and the virus is eliminated. Illness and virus clearance are immunological phenomena, which are assumed to be caused exclusively by CD8+ T lymphocytes. In contrast, of the two phases of a delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction caused by inoculation of the virus into the mouse's foot, only the first is mediated by CD8+ cells, whereas the second is mediated by CD4+ cells. We have examined LCM virus-specific immune responses in mice devoid of CD8+ T lymphocytes as a result of disruption of the beta 2-microglobulin gene. As expected, the virus persisted but footpad swelling did not occur, although intracerebral infection resulted in CD4+ T-lymphocyte-mediated illness and antiviral antibodies were produced. Different results had been obtained by Fung-Leung et al. (W.-P. Fung-Leung, T. M. Kündig, R. M. Zinkernagel, and T. W. Mak, J. Exp. Med. 174:1425-1429, 1991), who, is essentially identical experiments but with mice lacking CD8+ T lymphocytes as a result of disruption of the Lyt-2-encoding gene, recorded control of the infection and development of a local delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction. We consider these differences important, because they provide us with clues that may help to understand the mode of action of the CD8+ T cells in cell-mediated antiviral immunity.

MHC class I-deficient mice

A great deal has already been learned from the analysis of beta 2m-mutant mice, but it is clear that a great deal remains to be learned. A significant (though unanticipated) problem with this model system is that it is functionally leaky: residual functional class I expression can be detected in beta 2m- mice, and small numbers of functional CD8+ lymphocytes are present in the animals. In many cases, this has frustrated the initial attempts at obtaining immediate definitive resolution of important questions regarding the function of class I molecules. This has occurred primarily in instances in which the class I-deficient mice fail to express an expected phenotype--for example, in studies showing that beta 2m- mice make adequate protective immune responses against certain intracellular pathogens, and are able to reject some allogeneic tissues with a relatively normal pace. On the other hand, it appears that combining the use of beta 2m- mice with other methods (for example, antibody-mediated depletion of CD8+ T cells) is usually adequate to circumvent these difficulties. It remains to be seen whether other better class I deficiencies can be engineered--for example, large deletions of class I genes or mutations in transcription factors essential for class I gene expression. The extent of immunocompetence of beta 2m- mice was somewhat surprising. It was widely expected that class I-deficient mice would be exquisitely sensitive to many viral infections, though the results indicate that sensitivity varies dramatically with the virus and conditions of infection. However, it appears that in lieu of one major arm of the immune system, compensatory immune mechanisms are in many cases able to deal with infection. Similar conclusions are developing from the analysis of several other recently generated mutant mice. Nevertheless, the results indicate a very important role for class I-directed responses in clearing infections mediated by various viral and parasitic agents, particularly in the case of more severe conditions of infection. Although the class I-deficient mice were initially considered primarily a vehicle for analysis of the role of CD8+ T cells, evidence is accumulating that they manifest deficiencies in several other types of lymphocytes, including NK cells, TCR alpha beta+CD4-CD8- cells, and a subset of TCR gamma delta+ cells. This has been a boon for analysis of the development of these cells, but at the same time it has created difficulties in assigning a biological effect of the mutation to a specific lymphocyte deficiency.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Analysis of factors associated with the tumorigenic potential of 12 tumor clones derived from a single rat colon adenocarcinoma

We analyzed several factors which could influence the immunogenicity of colon tumor cells, using a series of clones derived from a single chemically induced rat adenocarcinoma cell line. These clones display variable tumorigenic potential in syngeneic immunocompetent animals, and it has been established that in this model the tumorigenicity of the cells depends on their ability to escape immune surveillance. The results show an absence of relationship between tumorigenicity and expression of MHC-class-I antigens, cell adhesion to rat fibroblasts or fibroblast extracellular matrix. The secretion of latent and active TGF beta I appeared to be quite variable from one clone to the other, but was unrelated to tumorigenicity. Unexpectedly, some regressive clones produced elevated levels of this cytokine, suggesting that in this model, spontaneous secretion of TGF beta I is not sufficient to impair the immune system of the host. In contrast, the more tumorigenic clones were more resistant than less tumorigenic ones to cytotoxicity mediated by NK or LAK cells. They also showed arrest of cell proliferation after reaching confluence, something not observed in the less tumorigenic clones. Finally, the strongest relationship with tumorigenicity was found for expression of blood-group carbohydrate antigens. Increased expression of blood-group-H antigen and, conversely, decreased expression of beta-galactoside precursors of this antigen correlated with increased tumorigenicity.

Cellular mechanisms of rejection

Studies by molecular biologists, protein chemists and cell biologists are rapidly providing new tools and information for those interested in the cellular mechanisms of graft rejection. Despite these contributions, a clear picture of the mechanisms involved in rejection has not yet evolved. However, whole new areas for research have developed, providing opportunities for new insights as well as therapeutic interventions.