Intravenous immune globulin treatment inhibits crossmatch positivity and allows for successful transplantation of incompatible organs in living-donor and cadaver recipients

Detecting and monitoring human leukocyte antigen-specific antibodies

Renewed awareness of the relevance of HLA-specific antibodies to transplantation and the development of protocols to reduce or eliminate sensitization have made monitoring of antibodies and accurate interpretation of test results increasingly important. Here we review the various tests available and provide guidelines for the development of monitoring protocols.

Rituximab and intravenous immune globulin for desensitization during renal transplantation

BACKGROUND

Few options for transplantation currently exist for patients highly sensitized to HLA. This exploratory, open-label, phase 1-2, single-center study examined whether intravenous immune globulin plus rituximab could reduce anti-HLA antibody levels and improve transplantation rates.

METHODS

Between September 2005 and May 2007, a total of 20 highly sensitized patients (with a mean [+/-SD] T-cell panel-reactive antibody level, determined by use of the complement-dependent cytotoxicity assay, of 77+/-19% or with donor-specific antibodies) were enrolled and received treatment with intravenous immune globulin and rituximab. We recorded rates of transplantation, panel-reactive antibody levels, cross-matching results at the time of transplantation, survival of patients and grafts, acute rejection episodes, serum creatinine values, adverse events and serious adverse events, and immunologic factors.

RESULTS

The mean panel-reactive antibody level was 44+/-30% after the second infusion of intravenous immune globulin (P<0.001 for the comparison with the pretreatment level). At study entry, the mean time on dialysis among recipients of a transplant from a deceased donor was 144+/-89 months (range, 60 to 324). However, the time to transplantation after desensitization was 5+/-6 months (range, 2 to 18). Sixteen of the 20 patients (80%) received a transplant. At 12 months, the mean serum creatinine level was 1.5+/-1.1 mg per deciliter (133+/-97 micromol per liter), and the mean survival rates of patients and grafts were 100% and 94%, respectively. There were no infusion-related adverse events or serious adverse events during the study. Long-term monitoring for infectious complications and neurologic problems revealed no unanticipated events.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggest that the combination of intravenous immune globulin and rituximab may prove effective as a desensitization regimen for patients awaiting a transplant from either a living donor or a deceased donor. Larger and longer trials are needed to evaluate the clinical efficacy and safety of this approach. (ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00642655.)

The spectrum of antibody-mediated renal allograft injury: implications for treatment

Improvements in anti-HLA antibody detection and diagnostic criteria have increased recognition of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) following renal transplantation. Therapy of acute AMR is directed toward rapidly lowering circulating donor-specific antibody (DSA) activity. Despite reversal of acute renal dysfunction, however, antibody-secreting plasma cells in spleen and bone marrow are not depleted by treatment and circulating DSA commonly remains detectable in peripheral blood. Sequential ultrastructural studies of renal allografts during acute AMR show progression of microvascular endothelial abnormalities from necrosis and apoptosis to glomerular and peritubular capillary basement membrane duplication, termed transplant glomerulopathy (TG), a manifestation of chronic AMR. Additionally, long-term exposure to anti-HLA antibodies (particularly against class II antigens) is associated with shortened allograft survival and TG even in the absence of documented acute AMR. The association of TG with prior acute AMR and with circulating DSA provides evidence that antibody-mediated allograft injury exists as a spectrum of renal injury. Although effective therapy is available for acute AMR, allografts remain at risk for chronic AMR and shortened survival. The optimum approach to treatment for chronic AMR remains to be determined.

Anti-CD20 antibody suppresses anti-HLA antibody formation in a HLA-A2 transgenic mouse model of sensitization

BACKGROUND

B cell depletion by anti-CD20 antibody is used in desensitization protocols and for treatment of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR). However, little is known about the efficacy and the mechanism(s) of action.

METHODS

A mouse model of HLA sensitization was used to study the effectiveness of anti-CD20 treatment on B cell depletion and anti-HLA antibody suppression.

RESULTS

Immunization of C57BL/6 mice with skin grafts from a transgenic C57BL.Tg/HLA-A2.1 mouse resulted in robust production of anti-HLA IgM and IgG antibodies, and accelerated rejection of a secondary skin allograft (within 3 days) featured by intragraft IgG and C4d deposition. Both IgM and IgG alloantibodies are specific to HLA-A2 as well as to a panel of class I HLA, including A1, A3, A25, A26, A29, and A30. These alloantibodies were complement-dependently cytotoxic (CDC) against HLA-A2 expressing target cells. Administration of 2 doses of a mouse-anti-mouse CD20 monoclonal antibody significantly reduced the levels of anti-HLA IgG2a antibodies, suppressed serum CDC, and prolonged survival of the secondary skin allografts. Suppression of anti-HLA IgG antibodies was associated with significant depletion of B220(+)/CD5(-) B cells from the blood, the spleen and the bone marrow of the treated animals.

CONCLUSION

Anti-CD20 treatment effectively depletes B220(+)/CD5(-) B cells, resulting in potent suppression of anti-HLA IgG and prolongation of skin graft survival. The data are in support for the use of anti-CD20 antibodies in highly-HLA sensitized patients undergoing desensitization and for the treatment of AMR.

Addition of plasmapheresis decreases the incidence of acute antibody-mediated rejection in sensitized patients with strong donor-specific antibodies

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study was to investigate the effects of desensitization protocols using intravenous Ig with or without plasmapheresis in patients with donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies on prevention of antibody-mediated rejection and downregulation of donor-specific antibodies.

DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS

Thirty-five complement-dependent cytotoxicity T cell cross-match-negative but complement-dependent cytotoxicity B cell and/or flow cytometry cross-match-positive kidney transplant recipients were treated with high-dosage intravenous Ig plus Thymoglobulin induction treatment. Donor-specific antibody strength was stratified as strong, medium, or weak by Luminex flow beads. Group 1 patients had weak/moderate and group 2 strong donor-specific antibodies

RESULTS

Whereas no group 1 patients had acute rejection, 66% of group 2 had acute rejection (44% antibody-mediated rejection, 22% cellular rejection). The protocol was then changed to the addition of peritransplantation plasmapheresis to patients with strong donor-specific antibodies (group 3). This change resulted in a dramatic decrease in the acute rejection rate to 7%. During a median 18 mo of follow-up, patient survival was 100, 100, and 93% and graft survival was 100, 78, and 86% in groups 1, 2, and 3, respectively. During follow-up, 17 (52%) patients lost donor-specific antibodies completely, and 10 (30%) lost some of donor-specific antibodies and/or decreased the strength of existing donor-specific antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicated that in patients with strong donor-specific antibodies, the addition of plasmapheresis to high-dosage intravenous Ig decreases the incidence of acute rejection. The majority of the patients, whether they received intravenous Ig alone or with plasmapheresis, lost their donor-specific antibodies during follow-up.

Results of positive cross-match transplantation in African American renal transplant recipients

Positive cross-match (PXM) renal transplantation has been utilized to address the issue of the increasing demand for transplantation with the shortage of suitable organs. Our primary objective was to analyze the outcomes of African American (AA) PXM renal transplant recipients utilizing AA negative cross-match (NXM) renal transplant recipients as a comparator group. This was a retrospective study consisting of all PXM patients who underwent a desensitization protocol and all AA NXM transplant recipients at the University of Illinois at Chicago from July 2001 to March 2007. We found that AA PXM recipients had significantly lower estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) at 1 year than AA NXM (46.2 vs. 60.6, p = 0.007). AA PXM who experienced acute rejection within the first year were more likely to have an eGFR less than 30 mL/min/1.73 m(2) at 1 year compared to their NXM counterparts (45.5% vs. 12.5%, p = 0.034). Positive cross-match renal transplantation in AA seems to be associated with a high degree of AR and severe renal compromise at 1 year. Larger studies are needed to determine if protocols that are associated with good short-term outcomes in non-AA need to be modified for the AA population.

Arteriosclerosis in kidneys from healthy live donors: comparison of wedge and needle core perioperative biopsies

CONTEXT

Although risks associated with live kidney donation are low, there are few pathologic studies of kidneys from live donors, and possible risk factors for development of hypertension or renal insufficiency remain unknown. There are many studies of histopathologic changes in deceased donor kidneys and how these changes affect subsequent graft function; most are based on wedge rather than needle core biopsies.

OBJECTIVE

To examine the frequency and severity of arterial fibrointimal thickening and other pathologic lesions in kidneys from healthy live donors and compare wedge and needle core biopsies as methods for evaluating these changes.

DESIGN

For 36 of 332 live donor renal transplantations performed from January 2004 through November 2006, a wedge biopsy of the transplanted kidney was done prior to and/or after implantation, and a needle core biopsy was done postimplantation or during the ensuing 7 days. For these 36 allografts, we compared pathologic features of the wedge and core perioperative biopsies.

RESULTS

Findings on core and wedge biopsies were similar, except for arterial fibrointimal thickening. Moderate thickening (Banff cv2) was present on 13 core biopsies, and mild thickening (cv1) was present on another 10; by contrast, no wedge biopsies showed cv2 lesions, and only 8 showed cv1. Arterial thickening on core but not wedge biopsies correlated significantly with increasing patient age.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings indicate that needle core biopsies are superior to wedge biopsies for evaluating vascular changes in donor kidneys, and they suggest a need for studies correlating such changes with long-term outcomes of live donors, particularly older donors.

Cytomegalovirus-associated allograft rejection in heart transplant patients

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Modern antiviral strategies are effective in controlling the clinical syndromes associated with acute cytomegalovirus infection in heart transplant recipients. Despite this effectiveness, subclinical cytomegalovirus infection is a common finding in these patients and its impact on long-term graft outcome is currently underestimated.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent studies provide evidence implicating subclinical cytomegalovirus infection in the pathogenesis of allograft rejection and cardiac allograft vasculopathy. In this process, cytomegalovirus interacts with local inflammatory pathways, and systemic immune-regulation mechanisms, which may lead to graft damage, even in the absence of cytomegalovirus replication within the graft. Consequently, in addition to pharmacologic strategies that inhibit viral replication, immune-based therapies that abrogate host immune response may provide an effective tool to prevent the indirect impact of cytomegalovirus on graft function.

SUMMARY

Current evidence suggests that subclinical cytomegalovirus infection plays an important role in the pathogenesis of long-term graft dysfunction in heart transplant recipients and in other solid organ transplant recipients. Pending the availability of definitive data from randomized trials, we propose that the use of pharmacologic and immune-based approaches, directed at complete suppression of cytomegalovirus infection, represents the best strategy for prevention of cytomegalovirus-induced rejection, cardiac allograft vasculopathy and chronic allograft damage.

Antibody-Mediated Rejection

The introduction of both complement 4d (C4d) staining in renal allograft biopsies and sensitive methods to detect anti-human leukocyte antigen antibodies, such as single antigen bead flow assays, into tissue-typing techniques have shown the importance of antibody-mediated alloimmune response in kidney transplantation. The use of these sensitive methods, combined with the increased number of transplants in highly sensitized patients with donor-specific antibodies, or patients receiving desensitization protocols, have increased the awareness and thus the incidence of acute antibody-mediated rejection. Chronic rejection also can be mediated through alloantibodies, and the term chronic antibody-mediated rejection recently was proposed. In this review article we summarize the current knowledge of the role of alloantibodies in transplantation, the diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic antibody-mediated rejection, and their effect on graft function and outcome.

Failure of prophylactic intravenous immunoglobulin to prevent sensitization to cryopreserved allograft tissue used in congenital cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVE

Cryopreserved allograft tissue used in the Norwood procedure for infants with hypoplastic left heart syndrome causes profound immunologic sensitization, which may complicate future transplantation. Intravenous immunoglobulin has been shown to reduce sensitization after it has developed, allowing successful transplantation. The purpose of this pilot trial was to determine whether intravenous immunoglobulin given before and after the procedure could prevent sensitization to cryopreserved allograft patches used in the initial repair of hypoplastic left heart syndrome.

METHODS

Intravenous immunoglobulin (2 g/kg) was given preoperatively, 3 weeks postoperatively, and 4 months postoperatively to 7 infants undergoing the Norwood procedure. Panel-reactive antibodies were measured with flow cytometry preoperatively and at 1, 4, 6, and 12 months postoperatively and compared with values from a contemporary cohort of 12 infants undergoing the Norwood procedure who did not receive intravenous immunoglobulin.

RESULTS

The groups were well matched for length and weight at time of surgery. Control infants were somewhat younger than the cohort receiving intravenous immunoglobulin (8 +/- 5 vs 17 +/- 14 days, P = .021). There were no differences in transfusion requirements. There was no difference in the degree of sensitization between control and intravenous immunoglobulin groups at 1 month (class I panel-reactive antibodies 20% +/- 30% vs 4% +/- 9%, P = .443, class II panel-reactive antibodies 17% +/- 27% vs 20% +/- 17%, P = .400), 4 months (class I panel-reactive antibodies 62% +/- 40% vs 73% +/- 41%, P = .813, class II panel-reactive antibodies 49% +/- 42% vs 54% +/- 41%, P = .706), and 12 months (class I panel-reactive antibodies 49% +/- 42% vs 58% +/- 39%, P = .686, class II panel-reactive antibodies 44% +/- 36% vs 49% +/- 42%, P = .651).

CONCLUSION

Despite studies showing intravenous immunoglobulin to reduce sensitization, we were unable to demonstrate that intravenous immunoglobulin prevented sensitization after exposure to allograft tissue in neonates undergoing congenital cardiac surgery.

Five Years of Single-Center Experience With Paired Kidney Exchange Transplantation

INTRODUCTION

Due to the organ shortage, living donor transplantation has become a method to bridge the gap. Paired kidney exchange program (PKEP) is a viable method especially when there are incompatible related living donors. Even if there are still some unanswered questions, this program is current in some centers, and there appears to be a tendency to extend it in Europe. The aim of our study was to assess our results with PKEP after 5 years.

METHODS

Between January 2001 and December 2005, we performed 56 living donor kidney transplantations using this method. We performed 26 kidney exchange procedures: 23 with two pairs, two with three pairs, and one with four pairs. Extensive preoperative work was necessarily to obtain equivalent pairs from the anatomic, functional, and immunological points of view. The same team performed all transplants. The mean recipient age was 35.59 years (range 29 to 44). Mean waiting time for a renal transplant was 33.27 months (range 11 to 87).

RESULTS

At a median follow-up of 41 months (range 7 to 59), the rates of acute rejection and graft survival-19.64% and 98.21%-were similar to direct living donation-14.66% and 97.92%, respectively (P = .35 and .88, respectively).

CONCLUSION

The paired kidney exchange program is a viable procedure medically and economically, which can be promoted in centers with a low deceased donor transplantation rate and a high number of incompatible related donors.

Paired exchange programmes can expand the live kidney donor pool

Background

Kidney paired donation (KPD) is an exchange of organs between two live donors, who are otherwise ABO incompatible or cross-match positive, and their intended recipients. The outcome is the generation of compatible transplants conferring an improvement in quality of life and longevity.

Methods

Medline was searched for articles on KPD using a combination of keywords. Publications focusing on protocols and policy, mathematical modelling, ethical controversies, and legal and logistical barriers were identified.

Results

Many are precluded from transplantation because of incompatibilities with their intended donors. KPD has the potential to increase the rate of transplantation by facilitating exchange transplants between otherwise incompatible donor–recipient couples. Ethical controversies surrounding paired donation include confidentiality, conditionality of donation, synchronicity of operations and the possibility of disadvantaging blood group O recipients. Logistical barriers hampering KPD programmes involve the location of donor surgery and organ transport.

Conclusion

Paired donation may expand the living donor pool by providing an alternative successful strategy for incompatible donor–recipient couples. Its widespread implementation will depend on resolving ethical and logistical constraints.

Posttransplant prophylactic intravenous immunoglobulin in kidney transplant patients at high immunological risk: a pilot study

The effects of posttransplant prophylactic intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) were investigated in renal transplant recipients at high immunological risk. Thirty-eight deceased-donor kidney transplant recipients with previous positive complement-dependent cytotoxicity crossmatch (n=30), and/or donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies (n=14) were recruited. IVIg (2 g/kg) was administrated on days 0, 21, 42 and 63 with quadruple immunosuppression. Biopsy-proven acute cellular and humoral rejection rates at month 12 were 18% and 10%, respectively. Glomerulitis was observed in 31% and 60% of patients at months 3 and 12, respectively, while allograft glomerulopathy rose from 3% at month 3 to 28% at 12 months. Interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy increased from 18% at day 0 to 51% and 72% at months 3 and 12 (p<0.0001). GFR was 50 +/- 17 mL/min/1.73 m(2) and 48 +/- 17 mL/min/1.73 m(2) at 3 and 12 months. PRA decreased significantly after IVIg (class I: from 18 +/- 27% to 5 +/- 12%, p<0.01; class II: from 25 +/- 30% to 7 +/- 16%, p<0.001). Patient and graft survival were 97% and 95%, respectively and no graft was lost due to rejection (mean follow-up 25 months). In conclusion, prophylactic IVIg in high-immunological risk patients is associated with good one-year outcomes, with adequate GFR and a profound decrease in PRA level, but a significant increase in allograft nephropathy.

14th International HLA and Immunogenetics Workshop: Report on understanding antibodies in transplantation

A session of the 14 International Histocompatibility Workshop brought together experts representing the major clinical protocols, clinical research, and basic research dealing with overcoming the barrier of alloantibody in transplantation and in understanding the mechanisms by which those antibodies exert their effect on a transplanted organ. This report is an integration of the presentations of those scientists.

Intravenous immunoglobulin, HLA allele typing and HLAMatchmaker facilitate successful transplantation in highly sensitized pediatric renal allograft recipients

The use of intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) in sensitized transplant candidates has resulted in reduced HLA antibody levels and shorter transplant wait times. In addition, the HLAMatchmaker program has been used to identify acceptable mismatches to permit transplantation in highly sensitized patients. We used IVIG desensitization in conjunction with high resolution HLA allele typing and HLAMatchmaker grading of donor offers to facilitate successful transplantation in two highly sensitized children who were awaiting second renal transplants. Both patients lost their initial transplant in <10 days to accelerated acute rejection, and were on dialysis for an average of 50 months with high panel reactive antibody (PRA) levels. They were started on monthly IVIG infusions (2 g/kg/dose). Within one wk following their third and fifth IVIG doses, both patients received a crossmatch compatible, deceased donor renal transplant selected by HLAMatchmaker as a suitable donor offer. Both patients remain rejection free with excellent renal function 19 and 15 months post-transplant, respectively. In conclusion, combining IVIG therapy and donor selection by HLA humoral epitope matching permitted successful transplantation of two highly sensitized children. Further studies in larger numbers of patients with longer follow-up are needed to determine the individual role played by, and relative importance of each component of this combined strategy.

The effect of desensitization protocols on human splenic B-cell populations in vivo

Rituximab, intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) and rabbit antithymocyte globulin (rATG) all have been suggested to have an effect on antibody producing cells, however, supporting data are lacking. To assess the impact of these agents on splenic B-cell populations in vivo, we retrospectively examined 25 spleens removed from patients treated with these agents as part of desensitization protocols in either ABO incompatible or positive crossmatch living donor kidney transplantation. These were compared to control (CTL) spleens removed for trauma. CTLs and spleens removed at transplant after multiple pretransplant plasmaphereses (PP) plus low-dose IVIG showed similar large numbers of naïve B cells (CD20+ and CD79+), plasma cells (CD138+) and memory B cells (CD27+ cells). Adding rituximab to this PP/IVIG regimen reduced the number naïve B cells, but had no effect on memory or plasma cells. Combination treatment (PP/IVIG, rituximab and rATG) showed a trend toward the reduction of CD27+ cells, but again plasma cells were unchanged. We conclude that none of these protocols reduces splenic plasma cells in vivo. PP/low-dose IVIG does not alter splenic B cells, but the addition of rituximab decreases mature B cells. Memory B cells may be affected by combination therapy including rATG and requires further study.

Living donor renal transplantation: recent developments and perspectives

Renal transplantation is the optimal treatment for patients of all ages with end-stage renal disease. Life expectancy of the population in general is increasing consistently, as is the age of the dialysis population. Consequently, the average ages of kidney donors and recipients are rising. The combination of a growing number of patients with end-stage renal disease and a shortage of organs poses a significant challenge to the transplant community. Donor shortage is associated with unfavorable consequences (e.g. prolonged waiting time, and compromised graft and patient survival). As such, multidirectional efforts are required to expand the donor pool. Increasing the frequency of living donation seems to be an efficient solution. Living donation is associated with superior results for the recipient, and relatively benign long-term outcomes for donors. Reluctance to use organs from living donors whose eligibility was previously considered marginal (e.g. elderly donors) is declining. Although increased donor age is associated with reduced graft survival rates, this should not preclude use of older living donors; transplantation is definitely superior to remaining on dialysis. Thorough, standardized evaluation and careful screening for premorbid conditions in both elderly donors and elderly recipients are essential. Here, we present various options for expanding the living donor pool, with emphasis on the utilization of elderly living donors and transplantation in elderly recipients.

Desensitization strategies enabling successful renal transplantation in highly sensitized patients

Currently, the number of highly sensitized patients awaiting a renal transplant is increasing on the waiting lists of different organ exchange organizations. Due to the presence of antibodies against a broad variety of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) specificities, highly sensitized patients have a markedly reduced chance of receiving a crossmatch-negative organ. It has long been recognized that hyperacute rejection is associated with the presence of donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies at the time of transplantation. Meanwhile treatment protocols have been developed to achieve successful transplantation across antibody barriers. Therefore, the presence of donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies and a positive serological crossmatch are no longer considered as an absolute contraindication to renal transplantation. Mainly, two desensitization protocols have been established in order to overcome a positive crossmatch or to enhance the chance of highly sensitized patients to receive a crossmatch-negative organ: high-dose intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) or low-dose IVIg in combination with plasmapheresis. Herein, we summarize the characteristics of these two treatment regimes along with other alternative approaches that are currently used for the management of kidney graft recipients with broad alloantibody reactivity against potential kidney donors.

Transplanting the highly sensitized patient: The emory algorithm

Renal transplant patients sensitized to HLA antigens comprise nearly one-third of the UNOS wait-list and receive 14% of deceased donor (DD) transplants, a rate half that of unsensitized patients. Between 1999 and 2003, we performed 492 adult renal transplants from DD; 120 patients (approximately 25%) had a panel reactive antibody (PRA) of >30%, with nearly half (n = 58) having a PRA of >80%. Our approach is based upon high-resolution solid-phase HLA antibody analysis to identify class I/II antibodies and a 'virtual crossmatch' to predict compatible donor/recipient combinations. Recipients are excluded from the United Network for Organ Sharing match run if donors possess unacceptable antigens. Thus, when sensitized patients appear on the match run, they have a high probability of a negative final crossmatch. Here, we describe our 5-year experience with this approach. Five-year graft survival ranged from 66% to 70% among unsensitized (n = 272), moderately sensitized (PRA < 30%, n = 100) and highly sensitized (>30% PRA; n = 120) patients, equal to the average national graft survival (65.7%). The application of this approach (the Emory Algorithm) provides a logical and systematic approach to improve the access of sensitized patients to DD organs and promote more equitable allocation to a highly disadvantaged group of patients awaiting renal transplantation.

Effect of induction therapy protocols on transplant outcomes in crossmatch positive renal allograft recipients desensitized with IVIG

Here we retrospectively examine the efficacy of two antibody induction regimens using Zenapax or Thymoglobulin in patients with positive complement-dependent cytotoxicity crossmatches (CDC-CMXs) desensitized with IVIG (intravenous immunoglobulin). Between January 1999 and March 2005, 97 patients with (+) CDC-CMXs received kidney transplants (43 deceased donors/54 living donors). All patients received at least 2 g/kg IVIG (maximum four doses) until an acceptable CMX was obtained. Patients were divided into two groups: 1. IVIG + Zenapax (n = 58), 2. IVIG + Thymoglobulin (n = 39). A total of 94% of patients in Group 1 and 84% in G2 have at least 2 years of follow up. Patient and graft survival was 96%/84% in Group 1 and 100%/90% in Group 2, p = NS. The number and severity of AR episodes were similar (36% Group 1 vs. 31% Group 2, p = NS) as was the incidence of C4d (+) antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) (Banff Grade II/III) (22% Group 1 vs. 21% Group 2). Mean serum creatinines (SCrs) at 24 months were similar (Group 1: 1.4 +/- 0.7 vs. G2: 1.5 +/- 0.7 mg/dL). Induction therapy with Zenapax or Thymoglobulin results in excellent patient, graft survival and graft function at 2 years. There was no increased risk of viral infections or malignancies with either agent. Neither agent was effective in reducing the incidence of AMR.

Low-Dose Prophylactic Intravenous Immunoglobulin Does Not Prevent HLA Sensitization in Left Ventricular Assist Device Recipients

BACKGROUND

The use of left ventricular assist devices is associated with human leukocyte antigen (HLA) allosensitization. We investigated whether prophylactic treatment with low-dose intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG), analogous to the use of IgG anti-D (anti-Rh) in preventing Rh immunization, can abrogate HLA allosensitization after left ventricular assist device implantation.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the data from 84 consecutive heart failure patients who underwent implantation of a left ventricular assist device as a bridge to transplantation. After implantation, panel reactive antibody (PRA) was measured biweekly to assess sensitization (defined by PRA > 10%). Patients who were sensitized before left ventricular assist device implantation were excluded from further analysis (n = 12). Patients who either did not require perioperatively transfusions of cellular blood products or received other immunomodifying regimens were also excluded from further analysis (n = 21). The rest of the patients were divided into two groups based on whether they received IVIG, 10 g daily for 3 days (IVIG group, n = 26; non-IVIG group, n = 25). The decision as to whether patients received IVIG was not randomized but was based on surgeon preference.

RESULTS

The sensitization rates (expressed as ratio of sensitized patients to total patients at risk) in the two groups were similar at consecutive time points (2, 4, 6, 8, 12, 20 weeks) after left ventricular assist device implantation. Also, mean PRA at the same time points did not differ between the two groups. Overall, 34.6% (9 of 26) of the IVIG group became sensitized during mechanical support, compared with 32% (8 of 25) of the non-IVIG group (p = 1.0). A PRA of 90% or greater (high-degree sensitization) occurred in 15.3% (4 of 26) of the IVIG group and 12.0% (3 of 25) of the non-IVIG group (p = 0.5).

CONCLUSIONS

The use of low-dose prophylactic IVIG after left ventricular assist device implantation affects neither the incidence nor the severity of HLA allosensitization.

Successful renal transplantation despite low levels of donor-specific HLA class I antibody without IVIg or plasmapheresis

We prospectively transplanted 10 primary kidney recipients with deceased donor organs (nine kidney and one pancreas/kidney) when their flow cytometric T-cell IgG, HLA class I donor-specific crossmatch was positive but the AHG T-cell crossmatch was negative, with a median follow-up of 1.8 yr. No pre- or peri-operative IVIg or plasmapheresis was administered to any patient. All but one of the 11 organs transplanted into patients with a flow T(+)/AHG(-) crossmatch is currently functioning despite the continued presence of circulating low levels of HLA class I antibody. Flow HLA class I antigen-coated beads showed the presence of at least one donor-specific HLA class I antibody at transplantation in each of the 10 cases. No rejections were observed in seven of the 10 cases (70%). Six rejection episodes, four cellular and two humoral, occurred in three patients. Each rejection was successfully treated. The only graft loss occurred in a kidney recipient on day 667 secondary to ischemia to the kidney because of cardiac surgery. Thus, short-term (one to two years) graft survival in primary transplants was not influenced by low levels of donor-specific HLA class I antibody present at transplantation and no prophylactic treatment such as IVIg, plasmapheresis, anti-CD20 or splenectomy was needed peri-operatively.

Histologic findings one year after positive crossmatch or ABO blood group incompatible living donor kidney transplantation

Recent protocols have allowed successful positive crossmatch (+XM) and ABO incompatible (ABOI) kidney transplantation, although their long-term outcome is not clear. To begin to assess this issue we compared protocol biopsies performed 12 months posttransplant in 37 +XM, 24 ABOI and 198 conventional allografts. Although the majority in all three groups had only minimal histologic changes, transplant glomerulopathy (TG) was significantly increased in +XM (22% vs. 13% ABOI vs. 8% conventional, p = 0.015), and correlated with prior humoral rejection (HR) by multivariate analysis (odds ratio 17.5, p < or = 0.0001). Patients with a prior history of HR also had a significant increase in interstitial fibrosis (No HR 54% vs. HR 86%, p = 0.045). In the absence of HR no difference in histologic changes was seen between groups, although all three groups had a demonstrable mild increase in interstitial fibrosis from biopsies performed at the time of transplant. Thus, although HR is associated with an increase in TG, in its absence allograft histology is similar in +XM, ABOI and conventional allografts 1 year posttransplant.

Pretransplant immunomodulation of highly sensitized small bowel transplant candidates with intravenous immune globulin

Presence of preformed lymphocytotoxic antibodies may represent a barrier to isolated intestinal transplantation (IITx). We developed an intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIg) based desensitization protocol for candidates with high panel-reactive antibodies (PRA). Six patients with a mean PRA of 72+/-22% were included in a four-level (L) protocol with escalating doses of IVIg (L1, L2), addition of mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) or plasmapheresis (L3); and anti-CD20 (Rituximab) (L4). Four of six candidates improved their PRAs (from a mean of 66.2% to 25.5%; P=0.01) and were successfully transplanted. At a mean follow-up of 8 months, number and severity of rejection episodes of protocol patients did not differ from patients with low PRA transplanted during the same period. These data support the use of IVIg to desensitize patients waiting for IITx. It increases the applicability of IITx, and reduces the waiting time and mortality on the waiting list with outcomes comparable to nonsensitized recipients.

Alloantibodies and the outcome of cadaver kidney allografts

The role of humoral immunity in causing antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) of organ allografts has been extensively documented. For this reason, negative complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) cross-matches between recipient sera and donor T and B lymphocytes have become a mandatory requirement for cadaveric kidney transplantation. However, the significance of donor-specific antibodies (DSAs) detectable only by flow cytometry (FC) or solid phase assays (SPA) but not CDC is still controversial. We have performed a retrospective analysis of FC cross-matching results in 80 consecutive cadaver kidney allograft recipients. Antibodies against HLA class I and class II antigens were measured by CDC and SPA in sequential samples of sera obtained prior to transplantation. The preoperative cross-match was performed by CDC using magnetically sorted T and B cells from donor spleen. Sera obtained from each patient before and at the time of transplantation were included in the final cross-match. The sample of serum obtained at the time of transplantation was cross-matched retrospectively by FC and analyzed for anti-HLA antibody specificity on high resolution SPA. The actuarial kidney allograft survival at one year was 98%. Two of these eighty patients lost the graft, one due to AMR, the other for reasons unrelated to DSAs. Donor-specific antibodies were detected by FC in 17 of 80 patients, yet only 6 of 17 had an early episode of AMR. This episode was successfully reversed by desensitization therapy using intravenous immunoglobin (IVIG) and plasmapheresis. Flow cytomery cross-matching showed 95% specificity but only 35% sensitivity for prediction of AMR (p = 0.002). There was a significant correlation between high panel reactive antibodies (PRA) and positive FC cross-matching (p = 0 .0001), as well as high PRA and AMR (p = 0.0004 by CDC and 0.0011 by Luminex). Reversible AMR occurred 12-30 days post-transplantation in 8 patients. Of these 8 patients, 3 had no detectable DSAs in spite of C4d positivity, 4 had C4d deposition in conjunction with anti-HLA antibodies, and 1 patient had DSAs (anti-MICA) yet no C4d deposition. We conclude that early initiation of desensitization protocols can prevent transplant failure and that retrospective FC cross-matches may facilitate the diagnosis of AMR. Extensive analysis of patients' sera using a comprehensive set of tests may contribute to early treatment and better understanding of the mechanism underlying humoral rejection.

Safety and Adverse Events Profiles of Intravenous Gammaglobulin Products Used for Immunomodulation: A Single-Center Experience

Intravenous Ig (IVIg) products are used in various medical conditions. Differences in excipients account for most adverse events (AE). Reports of complications including acute myocardial infarction (AMI) and acute renal failure (ARF) have emerged. Herein is described one institution's experience with IVIg-related complications. This study is a retrospective analysis of infusion-related AE that are associated with various IVIg products. Infusion-related AE were monitored during and after the administration of three IVIg products: Gamimune-N 10% (n = 76), Polygam (n = 105), and Carimune (n = 98). AE segregated to specific IVIg products. No patients who received Gamimune-N experienced AMI or ARF. Five (4.7%) patients (P < 0.01) in the Polygam group experienced AMI. Eight (8.2%) patients (P < 0.0001) in the Carimune group developed ARF. IVIg was safe to give on hemodialysis. IVIg products differ in osmolality, pH, and sugar and sodium content; this results in specific AE. Polygam resulted in no ARF but an increase in AMI. Carimune products at 9% concentration resulted in an increase in ARF. Gamimune-N 10% and other IVIg products were frequently associated with headaches. Administration of IVIg to patients who are on hemodialysis seems to be safe and effective.

Increasing the opportunity of live kidney donation by matching for two- and three-way exchanges

BACKGROUND

To expand the opportunity for paired live donor kidney transplantation, computerized matching algorithms have been designed to identify maximal sets of compatible donor/recipient pairs from a registry of incompatible pairs submitted as candidates for transplantation.

METHODS

Demographic data of patients who had been evaluated for live donor kidney transplantation but found to be incompatible with their potential donor (because of ABO blood group or positive crossmatch) were submitted for computer analysis and matching. Data included ABO and HLA types of donor and recipient, %PRA and specificity of recipient alloantibody, donor/recipient relationship, and the reason the donor was incompatible. The data set used for the initial simulation included 29 patients with one donor each and 16 patients with multiple donors for a total of 45 patients and 68 donor/patient pairs. In addition, a simulation based on OPTN/SRTR data was used to further assess the practical importance of multiple exchange combinations.

RESULTS

If only exchanges involving two patient-donor pairs were allowed, a maximum of 8 patient-donor pairs in the data set could exchange kidneys. If three-way exchanges were also allowed, a maximum of 11 pairs could exchange kidneys. Simulations with OPTN/SRTR data demonstrate that the increase in the number of potential transplants if three-way exchanges are allowed is robust, and does not depend on the particular patients in our sample.

CONCLUSIONS

A computerized matching protocol can be used to identify donor/recipient pairs from a registry of incompatible pairs who can potentially enter into donor exchanges that otherwise would not readily occur.

Transplantation across previously incompatible immunological barriers

This article reviews recent advances, which allow the transplantation across or around previously incompatible immunological barriers such as a positive crossmatch or ABO blood group incompatibility.

Presensitization: the problem and its management

Much attention has been placed recently on transplantation in highly HLA-sensitized patients. In attempts to remove these antibodies and enable successful transplantation, several novel approaches have been developed. These include intravenous Ig (IVIg), mycophenolate mofetil, sirolimus, alemtuzumab, protein A immunoabsorption, and rituximab. IVIg has emerged as a very effective agent when used alone in high dose or when used in low dose and combined with plasmapheresis. Although alemtuzumab has been used to eliminated B cells, it fails to prevent antibody-mediated rejection and therefore probably is not suitable for desensitization. Rituximab, a B cell-specific antibody, seems to be safe and to have some efficacy as a sole agent in elimination of alloantibodies but most likely will require combination therapy with IVIg or other agents. Newer agents, such as humanized anti-CD20, are being developed. Despite the great interest in the problem of allosensitization, with one notable exception, there is a major deficiency in controlled clinical trials, the conduct of which should be a focus for the near future.

Role of Flow Cytometry to Define Unacceptable HLA Antigens in Lung Transplant Recipients with HLA-Specific Antibodies

BACKGROUND

Antidonor HLA-specific antibodies have been associated with hyperacute rejection and primary graft failure in lung transplant recipients. Thus, transplant candidates with HLA-specific antibodies generally undergo prospective crossmatching to exclude donors with unacceptable HLA antigens. However, the need to perform a prospective crossmatch limits the donor pool and is associated with increased waiting list times and mortality. A virtual crossmatch strategy using flow cytometry, which enables precise determination of HLA-specific antibody specificity, was compared to prospective crossmatching in sensitized lung transplant candidates.

METHODS

In all, 341 lung transplant recipients were analyzed retrospectively (April 1992 to July 2003). Sixteen patients with HLA-specific antibodies underwent transplantation based on flow cytometric determination of antibody specificity and 10 underwent prospective crossmatching.

RESULTS

Freedom from bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome (BOS) at three years was similar in those undergoing a virtual crossmatch, those undergoing prospective crossmatching, and those without HLA-specific antibodies (80.4% +/- 13.4, 85.7% +/- 13.2, and 73.8% +/- 2.8, respectively, P = 0.88). Three-year survival was also comparable (87.5% +/- 8.3, 70.0% +/- 14.5, and 78.5% +/- 2.4, respectively, P = 0.31). Elimination of prospective crossmatching for sensitized patients was associated with a significant decrease in time on the waiting list (P < 0.01) and in waiting list mortality (P < 0.05). All 16 patients undergoing a virtual crossmatch had negative retrospective crossmatches.

CONCLUSIONS

By carefully determining the specificity of HLA-specific antibodies, flow cytometry methodologies enable the prediction of negative crossmatch results with up to 100% accuracy, enabling the determination of appropriateness of donors. Using this virtual crossmatch strategy, crossmatching can be safely omitted prior to lung transplantation, thereby decreasing waiting list time and mortality rates for candidates with HLA-specific antibodies.

Intravenous gammaglobulin (IVIG): a novel approach to improve transplant rates and outcomes in highly HLA-sensitized patients

Intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) products are derived from pooled human plasma and have been used for the treatment of primary immunodeficiency disorders for more than 24 years. Shortly after their introduction, IVIG products were also found to be effective in the treatment of autoimmune and inflammatory disorders. Over the past 2 decades, the list of diseases where IVIG has a demonstrable beneficial effect has grown rapidly. These include Kawasaki disease, Guillain-Barre syndrome, myasthenia gravis, dermatomyositis and demyelinating polyneuropathy. Recently, we have described a beneficial effect on the reduction of anti-HLA antibodies with subsequent improvement in transplantation of highly HLA-sensitized patients as well as a potent anti-inflammatory effect that is beneficial in the treatment of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR). These advancements have enabled transplantation of patients previously considered untransplantable. These studies and relevant mechanism(s) of action will be discussed here.

Anti-HLA alloantibodies in pediatric solid organ transplantation

An increasing number of studies demonstrate the clinical impact of preformed and de novo anti-human leucocyte antigen alloantibody (HLA-Ab) in solid organ transplantation (Tx). The screening of HLA-Ab in candidates and transplant recipients has evolved over time, with continuous improvement in the sensitivity and specificity of assays for HLA-Ab detection. Furthermore, histologic markers of complement activation pathways are currently implemented in the diagnosis of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR). Therapeutic strategies, including depletion of HLA-Ab and B cells, have allowed Tx across antibody barriers, or have rescued patients with AMR. The purpose of the present review is to summarize the state-of-the-art of HLA-Ab detection, clinical significance and therapeutic strategies in pediatric solid organ Tx.

A comparison of plasmapheresis versus high-dose IVIG desensitization in renal allograft recipients with high levels of donor specific alloantibody

Several protocols allow for the successful transplantation of sensitized renal allograft recipients, yet no one best method has emerged. The aim of the current study was to compare the efficacy of high-dose IVIG with two different plasmapheresis (PP)-based regimens in kidney transplant recipients with high levels of donor specific alloantibody (DSA) defined as a positive T-cell cytotoxicity crossmatch. With the primary goal of achieving a negative crossmatch, we employed three protocols sequentially between April 2000 and May 2005: (i) PP, low-dose IVIG, anti-CD20 antibody (n = 32); (ii) high-dose IVIG (n = 13); and (iii) PP, low-dose IVIG, anti-CD20 antibody and pre-transplant Thymoglobulin combined with post-transplant DSA monitoring (n = 16). IVIG decreased DSA activity in all treated patient, yet only 38% (5/13) achieved a negative crossmatch. In contrast, a negative crossmatch was achieved in 84% in PP group and 88% in the PP/monitoring group (p < 0.01 vs. IVIG). Even with a negative crossmatch, the rejection rates were 80% (IVIG), 37% (PP) and 29% (PP/monitoring), respectively, (p < 0.05 IVIG vs. PP). We conclude that multiple PP treatments leads to more reproducible desensitization and lower humoral rejection rates than a single high-dose of IVIG, but that no regimen was completely effective in preventing humoral rejection.

Sensitization after Kidney Transplantation: Table 1

Kidney transplant recipients may develop de novo anti-HLA and non-HLA antibodies after transplantation. Although these antibodies may be donor-specific or non-donor-specific, their presence may increase the risk for acute and chronic rejection, thereby decreasing allograft survival. The introduction of more sensitive and specific methods to detect anti-HLA antibodies, such as Flow Specific Beads and FlowPRA, both before and after transplantation, will help to define immunologically high-risk kidney transplant recipients. Thus, posttransplantation monitoring of anti-HLA antibody production will allow the identification of kidney transplant recipients who might be at increased risk for late allograft failure. Moreover, knowledge of alloantibody status after transplantation may help to guide the appropriate use of immunomodulatory agents to downregulate anti-HLA antibody production.

Considerations in retransplantation of the failed renal allograft recipient

Routine success in kidney transplantation has significantly improved the quality and length of life for the majority of recipients and made this option the treatment of choice for suitable candidates. Improved patient survival combined with a relative static improvement in long-term graft outcomes has led to an increasing number of transplant recipients with failed allografts who face the eventual option of either returning to dialysis or seeking retransplantation. Although retransplantation is presumed to be a favorable option for many, data to support this belief is limited. Given the wide variance in predicted outcomes for retransplantation, on the basis of the underlying kidney disease and other individual patient comorbidities as well as the expected wait time for a second transplant, each case should be evaluated independently. This review discusses available data and individual considerations that should be taken into account when retransplantation is proposed after failure of a primary allograft.

Late Developing C4d-Positive Humoral Renal Allograft Rejection Associated With Withdrawal of Mycophenolate Mofetil

In renal transplantation, C4d-positive acute humoral rejection (AHR) usually develops in the early stage posttransplantation. It is clear C4d can be detected late after the operation, when it is associated with chronic renal allograft rejection. We report a case of a renal allograft recipient who experienced C4d-positive acute renal allograft rejection associated with withdrawal of mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) at 10 months after transplantation. This 21-year-old single male patient received his first cadaveric renal allograft under immunosuppression with cyclosporine, MMF, and prednisolone. The serum creatinine recovered to the normal range within 4 days. A protocol biopsy performed at 1 month after transplantation revealed no signs of rejection. The graft function was stable until 10 months postoperation, when MMF was converted to mizoribin. Three days later a biopsy showed a C4d-positive rejection. Patient had no response to the MMF combined with tacrolimus and steroid bolus therapy, which generally improves 85% of AHR among Chinese. He finally returned to dialysis. Our report suggested that C4d positive AHR may occur late after transplantation. MMF is important to suppress the body's humoral response to allograft; when MMF was converted to a weaker immunosuppressant, the dose of the other immunosuppressants (cyclosporine for example) must be adjusted properly.

Overcoming Immunologic Incompatibility: Transplanting the Difficult to Transplant Patient

Immunologic incompatibilities between donor and recipient have limited the access to renal transplantation for many patients. Previously the presence of donor-specific alloantibodies directed against donor major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens or natural antibodies directed against donor ABO blood group antigens was considered an absolute contraindication to renal transplantation. However, with the current understanding of humoral immune responses, superior immunosuppressive agents, and improved diagnosis and treatment of antibody-mediated rejection, renal transplantation can be safely performed with outstanding results despite the presence of donor-specific antibody. In this review we discuss the biology of antibody-mediated rejection and sensitization. We discuss the diagnostic tests necessary to characterize the type, affinity, and avidity of the donor-directed antibodies. Current methods for performing renal transplants across ABO and human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-sensitized barriers are covered, including the potential morbidities. The rest of the review focuses on advances in managing these antibodies to increase the likelihood of receiving a deceased donor kidney or allow transplantation from a living donor against whom one has a prohibitive antibody.

IVIG and HLA antibodies. Evidence for inhibition of complement activation but not for anti-idiotypic activity

The immediate effects of IVIG can be due to the presence of anti-idiotypic antibodies or inhibition of complement, but there is limited data about these possible mechanisms specifically on HLA antibodies (HLA Abs). Potential blocking activity of IVIG on HLA Ab binding and complement activation was investigated by flow cytometry. IVIG did not inhibit the IgG binding of any of 23 sera from sensitized patients containing Abs to several different HLA specificities. In contrast, IVIG produced significant dose-dependent complement inhibition. Low IVIG concentrations could be inhibitory if there was little C3 activation, but high concentrations were needed when C3 was activated more efficiently. The data do not support any significant contribution of anti-idiotypic antibodies against HLA Abs to the activity of IVIG. The results also highlight a relationship between the magnitude of C activation and the C inhibitory effect of IVIG.