T cell tolerance by clonal elimination in the thymus

Minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mls) gene products in mice influence their genetic resistance or susceptibility to induction of autoimmune encephalomyelitis

The role of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene products in the genetics of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) is well established. Here we demonstrate how non-MHC gene products, stimulatory to T cells specific to myelin basic protein (MBP), can affect the MHC control in determining genetic susceptibility or resistance to induction of EAE. I-As-restricted MBP-specific T cells derived from SJL/J mice are shown to cross-react with Mls-2a gene products. The Mls-2a gene product expressed by (SJL/J X BALB/c)F1 mice tolerize T cells recognizing I-As/MBP and favor the development of I-Es/d-restricted MBP-specific T cells mediating EAE in the (SJL/J x BALB/c)F1 mice. These I-Es/d/MBP-specific T cells, cross-reactive with Mls-1a, and the I-As/MBP-specific T cells, cross-reactive with Mls-2a gene products, are both eliminated by self tolerance mechanisms in the H-2-matched (SJL/J X DBA/2)F1 mice, expressing Mls-1a2a gene products, and thereby confer genetic resistance to EAE on the (SJL/J X DBA/2)F1 mice bearing EAE-permissive MHC alleles. These results reflect a developmental selection of a T cell repertoire to the self antigen MBP, imposed by self tolerance to self Mls gene products, which affect the genetic susceptibility to EAE. These studies also demonstrate that self tolerance to Mls gene products can strengthen the tolerance to organ-specific self antigens such as MBP, which may not be expressed or which are absent in the thymus at the time of thymic selection.

HLA class II polymorphism and genetic susceptibility to insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus

As we have discussed previously (Horn et al. 1988a; Erlich et al. 1989b; Horn et al. 1988b), there are no unique class II sequences associated with IDDM, which suggests that "normal" class II alleles confer susceptibility. Given the estimates of concordance--under 50% of monozygotic twins and approximately 15% (Tattersol, Pyle 1972 and Thomson 1988) for HLA-identical sibs--, it is not surprising that some unaffected individuals contain putative susceptibility alleles. Perhaps some environmental "triggering" agent, such as viral infection (Yoon, this volume), is required for the disease to develop in susceptible individuals. Other non-MHC linked genes which contribute to susceptibility may account for the difference in concordance rates for monozygotic twins and for HLA-identical sibs. In the nonobese diabetic mouse and the BB rat models for IDDM, non-MHC susceptibility loci have been identified and mapped (Hattori et al. 1986; Colle et al. 1981), but in humans the analysis of non-MHC candidate loci (i.e., the T cell receptor) has thus far failed to reveal any other susceptibility loci. In general, the HLA-linked genetic susceptibility to IDDM, as well as to other autoimmune diseases, appears to be associated with specific combinations of class II epitopes (e.g., alleles, haplotypes, or genotypes) rather than with specific individual residues or epitopes. Understanding the role of these predisposing sequences will require structural analysis of the class II molecules as well as in vitro and in vivo functional studies of interactions with putative autoantigens and T cell receptors. In the meantime, DNA typing offers the potential for identifying individuals at high risk for IDDM.

Surprisingly uneven distribution of the T cell receptor V beta repertoire in wild mice

We have examined TCR V beta expression in a collection of wild mice. Many of the mice were homozygous for a large deletion at the V beta locus, and many animals also suppressed expression of several V betas using self superantigens. Expression of V beta 8.2 was unexpectedly suppressed by a self superantigen in some wild mice, which was due to the presence in these animals of a variant V beta 8.2 gene. The amino acid changes in this gene product suggest contact sites between V beta and the superantigen. Although all V betas are expressed within each wild mouse population, individual mice have a limited and variable V beta repertoire. The independent origin of multiple V beta deletions and the presence of polymorphic self superantigens suggest that this variation may be maintained by balancing selection.

Transgenic mice as probes into complex systems

The transfer of genetic information into mouse embryos to stably alter the genetic constitution of mice is affording new insights into and opportunities in a wide variety of biological problems. Higher eukaryotes are composed of many interacting cells and organs. The properties of individual cell systems are often discernible only by studying natural or induced disruptions in their functions. Transgenic mice represent a new form of perturbation analysis whereby the selective expression of novel or altered genes can be used to perturb complex systems in ways that are informative about their development, their functions, and their malfunctions. The utility of this strategy is illustrated by recent research into immunological self-tolerance, oncogenes and cancer, and development.

Positive and negative selection of T cell receptor V beta domains controlled by distinct cell populations in the thymus

The role of thymic MHC class II-bearing cells in the selection of the TCR repertoire has been investigated in allogeneic radiation bone marrow chimeras. Positive selection of mature CD4+ T lymphocytes expressing the V beta 6+ TCR domain was found to depend upon radioresistant (presumably epithelial) I-E+ thymic cells. On the other hand, negative selection of CD4+ V beta 6+ cells (which was additionally dependent upon expression of the Mls-1a gene product) was controlled by a radiosensitive I-E+ thymic component (most likely dendritic cells). These data argue in favor of a compartmentalization of positive and negative selection events during T cell development.

Contrasting effects of glucocorticoids on the capacity of T cells to produce the growth factors interleukin 2 and interleukin 4

The molecular mechanisms which govern the biosynthesis and secretion of the various T cell-derived lymphokines are poorly understood at this time, in spite of their tremendous importance to the control of the mammalian immune system. Here we provide compelling evidence that production of the murine T cell growth factors interleukin (IL) 2 and IL4 are differentially regulated by glucocorticoid (GCS) hormones. Under conditions where IL2 production is reduced by GCS hormones, IL4 production is increased. In vivo, this effect on T cell production of growth factors is manifest at low GCS concentrations that are well within physiologic ranges. In vitro, splenocytes isolated from antigen-stimulated donors, as well as antigen-specific cloned T cell lines, undergo alterations in their capacity to secrete T cell growth factors when stimulated with antigens in the presence of GCS. Responses normally dominated by IL2 are dramatically shifted to a condition where IL4 represents the major species of T cell growth factor produced. Similar changes in the pattern of T cell growth factor production are observed following short pulses with low-dose GCS in vitro, and the steroid-induced depression in IL2 production can be reversed and/or inhibited by treatment with the potent steroid antagonist RU486. Our results imply that GCS hormones, presumably through their capacity to activate a specified family of ligand-dependent transcriptional regulatory proteins (steroid hormone receptors), function to control the pattern of lymphokines produced by activated T cells. Steroid-mediated regulation of lymphokine gene expression could serve to dictate the types of immune effector mechanisms which can be initiated subsequent to antigen exposure.

In vitro induction of immunological tolerance

IL-2 was previously shown to induce cytotoxic effectors with a broad spectrum of target specificities in thymus and spleen cell cultures. This study was designed to show whether T cells activated by H-2 allogeneic cells in MLC or by syngeneic tumor cells in MLTC are also potential targets for these cytotoxic effectors. We found that thymocytes activated in vitro for 5 days by rIL-2 were capable of killing tumor cells as well as activated T cells. Thymocytes activated by IL-2 were accordingly utilized as a means of effecting clonal deletion of T cells activated by H-2 allogeneic target cells in MLC. To establish whether the unresponsiveness is specific. IL-2-activated thymocytes were added as third party cells to MLC and MLTC. The results showed that both T cells, proliferating in response to H-2 allogeneic cells, and CTL, reactive against syngeneic tumors or H-2 allogeneic cells, are eliminated from the T cell pool. Only alloreactive T cells are specifically eliminated in MLC by IL-2-activated thymocytes, as the remaining T cells are capable of proliferating and generating CTL in response to antigenically unrelated third party allogeneic cells. The possibility that unresponsiveness might be due to soluble factors was ruled out by studies performed with a diffusable "chamber insert" culture system. The results provide evidence that IL-2-activated thymocytes induce in vitro T cell tolerance.

Identification and characterization of new murine T cell receptor beta chain variable region (V beta) genes

By screening previously isolated genomic clones spanning the mouse TCR V beta locus with V beta-specific oligonucleotides, we have isolated one new functional V beta gene and six V beta pseudogenes. Because this method of identifying new genes does not depend on expression levels, we conclude that most, if not all, V beta genes in the mouse have been identified. The newly identified pseudogenes increase the frequency of mouse TCR V beta pseudogenes to 28%, a frequency similar to that estimated for mouse Ig VH pseudogenes (24). Three of the newly discovered pseudogenes are clustered in a region around another pseudogene (V beta 17b). The extensive DNA diversity, as reflected in both the nucleotide sequence and the RFLP, indicates that this genomic region is a possible hotspot of recombination. The new functional gene, V beta 19a, is expressed at very low levels, which explains why it has not been isolated earlier. V beta 19 shows expression patterns that correlate with the previously described Va beta and Vb beta haplotypes.

Peripheral tolerance to allogeneic class II histocompatibility antigens expressed in transgenic mice: evidence against a clonal-deletion mechanism

To examine the effects of aberrant expression of class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins on tolerance development, transgenic mice expressing the I-Ad genes under control of the pancreatic elastase promoter were produced. Such transgenic mice express I-Ad exclusively on exocrine pancreas, without expression in thymus or by lymphocytes. No spontaneous development of autoimmune reactivity toward exocrine pancreas was found in transgene-expressing mice of an H-2b background even though such mice could produce in vitro allogeneic responses against I-Ad. When T cells from nontransgenic H-2b mice as well as transgenic H-2b mice were activated in vitro by I-Ad allogeneic stimulator cells and transferred to transgenic mice, an intense, destructive lymphocytic infiltrate specific for exocrine pancreas developed. These findings suggest that aberrant class II MHC expression alone may not trigger autoimmune reactions. Rather, the unresponsiveness to allogenic class II MHC may result from the inability of exocrine pancreas to initiate primary responses by T cells.

A spontaneous sarcoma dependent on host tumor-specific immune lymphocytes

The immune surveillance theory postulates that spontaneous tumors are normally rejected by the immune system and appear only when they override host-immune recognition and rejection mechanisms. The present mini-review describes a spontaneous tumor system, the reticulum cell sarcomas (RCS) in SJL/J mice, that is dependent on host tumor-specific immune lymphocytes for growth. This continuous tumor-specific response results in tumor progression and death of the host. This tumor system contradicts the basic concept of immune surveillance. We propose as an explanation that some highly antigenic tumors, like the RCS, may have evolved in a non-autonomous fashion but, nevertheless, have lost regulatory controls of cell proliferation. In the RCS system, the tumor expresses Class II MHC I-E like specificities that are not expressed on the host cells and which selectively stimulate a subpopulation of I-E specific T cells, the V beta 17 a+ clonotype, leading to their expansion and continuous nurturing of the tumor via secreted lymphokines. This neoantigenic stimulation bypasses the tumor regulatory response that might have resulted if the tumor had not expressed neoantigens. Furthermore, passive administration of anti-clonotypic antibody to tumor-bearing mice results in tumor regression and long-term survival through removal of the tumor reactive T cells. Thus, in this tumor system, immunosuppressive treatments are the prescription for tumor rejection.

Capacity of unprimed CD4+ and CD8+ T cells expressing V beta 11 receptors to respond to I-E alloantigens in vivo

Self tolerance induction in the thymus is known to delete T cells expressing certain V beta TCR molecules. In particular, V beta 17a+ and V beta 11+ T cells are selectively deleted in mice expressing H-2 I-E molecules. Although this finding implies that V beta 17a+ and V beta 11+ T cells have specificity for self I-E molecules, studies with V beta 11+ hybridomas prepared from mature lymphocytes taken from I-E- mice have shown that the vast majority of these hybridomas do not display I-E alloreactivity, at least in vitro. To examine whether V beta 11+ T cells are capable of reacting to I-E antigens in vivo, normal unprimed T cells from I-E- B10.A(4R) mice were transferred to irradiated I-E+ B10.A(2R) hosts and harvested from thoracic duct lymph of the recipients at various intervals. The donor T cells recovered in early lymph collections showed no reactivity to the I-E antigens of the host in vitro, presumably as a reflection of selective sequestration of the host-reactive cells in the lymphoid organs. Significantly, the disappearance of functional host-reactive cells from TDL was paralleled by a 90-95% reduction of V beta 11+ CD4+ cells. Blast cells were rare in early lymph collections but accounted for nearly all of the lymph-borne cells by day 3 after transfer. These blast cell populations contained a surprisingly high proportion of V beta 11+ cells, i.e., up to 25% in some experiments. Interestingly, the enrichment for V beta 11+ cells in the blast populations applied to CD8+ cells as well as to CD4+ cells. Collectively, the data suggest that in marked contrast to the failure of V beta 11+ cells to respond to I-E antigens in vitro, a high proportion of normal resting V beta 11+ cells are capable of reacting to I-E alloantigens in vivo.

I-E-linked control of spontaneous rheumatoid factor production in normal mice

The concentration of serum IgM molecules binding to IgG2a (rheumatoid factor [RF]) in solid phase assays is 10-100-fold higher in normal, unmanipulated C3H/HeJ (H-2k) than in C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice. Analysis of MHC-congenic mice with the prototype strains show that C3H SW (H-2b) are low, and B6.H-2k are high RF expressor strains, respectively. Furthermore, segregation of RF phenotypes in progenies from backcrosses to C3H/HeJ of (C3H/HeJ x C57BL/6)F1 hybrid mice shows MHC- and IgH-linked controls. RF phenotypes also segregate as if they are MHC linked in crosses between H-2-congenic strains (C3H/HeJ and C3H.SW). The study of intra-H-2 (k/b and k/s) recombinant mice suggested that RF phenotype control is linked to the I-E region. This was confirmed by the typing of C57BL/6 mice expressing a transgenic E alpha chain, and thus, I-E+, which, in contrast to nontransgenic littermates, are high expressors of RF.

Tolerance-related V beta clonal deletions in normal CD4-8-, TCR-alpha/beta + and abnormal lpr and gld cell populations

We have analyzed tolerance-related clonal deletion of Mls-and I-E-reactive thymocytes at the RNA level using a multi-V beta probe RNAse protection assay, and used this phenomenon to identify the maturation stage of the abnormally expanded CD4-8-, TCR-alpha/beta + subset in lpr and gld homozygous mice, and of the phenotypically similar minor thymocyte subset found in normal mice. Essentially complete V beta clonal deletions were detected in lpr and gld cells of all appropriate background strains. Substantial, but not complete, V beta clonal deletions were also detected in the CD4-8- TCR-alpha/beta + subset of normal mice. Since expression of CD4/CD8 is required for V beta clonal deletions to occur, we conclude that lpr and gld cells, and at least a portion of CD4-8- TCR-alpha/beta + thymocytes in normal mice, are derived by secondary loss of CD4/CD8 accessory molecules from more mature CD4+8+ precursors. One possible interpretation of these findings is that such CD4/CD8 loss may affect a class of self-reactive thymocytes that have escaped direct clonal deletion. Exportation and expansion of such cells in the periphery may be an important contributory factor in the induction of systemic autoimmunity.

A specific HLA-DP beta allele is associated with pauciarticular juvenile rheumatoid arthritis but not adult rheumatoid arthritis

Nonradioactive sequence-specific oligonucleotide probes specific for the HLA-DP beta locus have been used in a simple dot-blot format to type samples amplified by the polymerase chain reaction from 44 patients with pauciarticular juvenile rheumatoid arthritis, 32 patients with adult rheumatoid arthritis, and 50 random controls. The sequences of four new DP beta alleles derived from these patients and controls are reported, bringing the total number of alleles identified thus far to 19. The DPB2.1 allele is significantly increased in juvenile rheumatoid arthritis patients over controls; this allele is not increased in patients with adult rheumatoid arthritis. The association of juvenile rheumatoid arthritis with the DPB2.1 allele is independent of linkage with previously defined HLA-D region markers of disease. Analysis of the DPB2.1 sequence shows that it differs from the nonsusceptible DPB4.2 allele by only 1 amino acid at position 69 in the beta 1 domain.

Reactivity of V beta 17a+ CD8+ T cell hybrids. Analysis using a new CD8+ T cell fusion partner

Tolerance to IE molecules leads to deletion of V beta 17a-bearing T cells. Both, the CD4+ as well as the CD8+ T cell subsets are affected. A large percentage of CD4+ V beta 17a+ T cell hybrids recognize IE molecules. We now have investigated the reactivity for IE antigens of CD8+ V beta 17a+ T cell hybrids. Using a transfection approach, we have introduced the murine CD8 molecule into different V beta 17a+ T cell hybrids. Furthermore, the CD8 cDNA was transfected into the BW5147 alpha-beta- fusion partner. This allowed us to generate a large number of V beta 17a+ T cell hybrids by fusion with the appropriate T cells. Only 6% of T cell hybrids were stimulated to produce IL-2 upon incubation with IE+ cells. However, in those, the CD8 molecule seemed not to contribute to the IE reactivity of the hybrid, since mAbs against the CD8 molecule failed to inhibit their reactivity. This low percentage of V beta 17a+ CD8+ IE-reactive T cell hybrids contrasts with the strong reduction of CD8+ V beta 17a+ T cells in IE+ mice, strongly suggesting that elimination of such cells in the thymus occurs when they are coexpressing CD4 and CD8. This view was confirmed by the occasional expression of CD4 in some hybrids in which case IE reactivity was detected. Furthermore, we demonstrated the functional integrity of the introduced CD8 molecule by: (a) reconstitution of the IL-2 response in a class I-restricted TNP-specific T cell hybrid; and (b) by generation of alloreactive class I-restricted T cell hybrids using the new CD8+ fusion cell line. This CD8+ fusion partner, BWLyt2-4, should prove useful to study antigen processing and antigen presentation requirements of class I-restricted T cells.

T-cell tolerance by clonal anergy in transgenic mice with nonlymphoid expression of MHC class II I-E

T-cell reactivity to the class II major histocompatibility complex I-E antigen is associated with T-cell antigen receptors containing the V beta gene segments V beta 17a and V beta 5. Mice expressing I-E with the normal tissue distribution (on B cells, macrophages, dendritic cells and thymic epithelium) induce tolerance to self I-E by clonal deletion in the thymus. By contrast, we find that transgenic INS-I-E mice that express I-E on pancreatic beta-cells, but not in the thymus or peripheral lymphoid organs, are tolerant to I-E but have not deleted V beta 5- and V beta 17a-bearing T cells. Moreover, whereas T-cell populations from nontransgenic mice proliferate in response to receptor crosslinking with V beta 5- and V beta 17a-specific antibodies, T cells from INS-I-E mice do not. Thus, our experiments provide direct evidence that T-cell tolerance by clonal paralysis does occur during normal T-cell development in vivo.

Tolerance induction in double specific T-cell receptor transgenic mice varies with antigen

The crucial role of the thymus in immunological tolerance has been demonstrated by establishing that T cells are positively selected to express a specificity for self major histocompatibility complex (MHC), and that those T cells bearing receptors potentially reactive to self antigen fragments, presumably presented by thymic MHC, are selected against. The precise mechanism by which tolerance is induced and the stage of T-cell development at which it occurs are not known. We have now studied T-cell tolerance in transgenic mice expressing a T-cell receptor with double specificities for lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV)-H-2Db and for the mixed-lymphocyte stimulatory (MIsa) antigen. We report that alpha beta TCR transgenic mice tolerant to LCMV have drastically reduced numbers of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes and of peripheral T cells carrying the CD8 antigen. By contrast, tolerance to MIsa antigen in the same alpha beta TCR transgenic MIsa mice leads to deletion of only mature thymocytes and peripheral T cells and does not affect CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. Thus the same transgenic TCR-expressing T cells may be tolerized at different stages of their maturation and at different locations in the thymus depending on the antigen involved.

Thymic requirement for clonal deletion during T cell development

During T cell differentiation, self tolerance is established in part by the deletion of self-reactive T cells within the thymus (negative selection). The presence of T cell receptor (TCR)-alpha beta + T cells in older athymic (nu/nu) mice indicates that some T cells can also mature without thymic influence. Therefore, to determine whether the thymus is required for negative selection, TCR V beta expression was compared in athymic nu/nu mice and their congenic normal littermates. T cells expressing V beta 3 proteins are specific for minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mlsc) determinants and are deleted intrathymically due to self tolerance in Mlsc+ mouse strains. Here it is shown that V beta 3+ T cells are deleted in Mlsc+ BALB/c nu/+ mice, but not in their BALB/c nu/nu littermates. Thus, the thymus is required for clonal deletion during T cell development.

A nondeletional mechanism of thymic self tolerance

T cells become tolerant of self antigens during their development in the thymus. Clonal deletion of thymocytes bearing self-reactive T cell receptors is a major mechanism for generating tolerance and occurs readily for antigens expressed by bone marrow-derived cells. Tolerance to antigens expressed on the radioresistant thymic stromal elements is demonstrated here to occur via a nondeletional mechanism. For minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls-1a) and major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens, this alternate form of tolerance induction results in clonal anergy.

Induction of self-tolerance in mature peripheral B lymphocytes

In transgenic mice, mature peripheral B lymphocytes in lymphoid follicles, like immature B cells, are rendered tolerant by encounter with self-antigen, provided receptor occupancy by self-antigen exceeds a critical threshold. The tolerant state of the B cell is closely correlated with down-regulation of membrane IgM but not IgD antigen-receptors. Identical changes in antigen-receptor expression occur in a subset of follicular B cells in nontransgenic mice, suggesting that clonally silenced self-reactive cells are common in the peripheral B-cell repertoire.

Syngeneic preference manifested by thymic stroma during development of thymocytes from bone marrow cells

The question whether major histocompatibility complex (MHC) recognition is expressed in interactions between thymocyte progenitors and thymic stroma cells was investigated in an organ culture system, in which inductive interactions between thymic stroma cells and thymocyte progenitors of different MHC haplotypes could be measured. Thymocyte-depleted fetal thymuses were reconstituted with mixtures of syngeneic and allogeneic bone marrow cells, which also differed in their Thy-1 allele. The relative repopulating ability of the cells was estimated by determining the percentage of emerging Thy-1.1+ vs. Thy-1.2+ thymocytes. Similar values of Thy-1+ cells of the bone marrow donor type developed when the thymus were reconstituted by bone marrow from donors which were either syngeneic or allogeneic to the thymic explants. However, when a 1:1 mixture of syngeneic and allogeneic cells was applied to the thymus, a syngeneic preference was manifested in development of Thy-1+ cells. When mixtures of bone marrow cells from C57BL/Ka (Thy-1.1) and B10.A MHC-congenic (Thy-1.2) mice were used, this developmental preference was found to map to the I-E region. Thymocytes derived from bone marrow cells allogeneic to the stroma, seeded on their own, manifested an advantage over allogeneic bone marrow cells from a different MHC haplotype, in a secondary reconstitution. This suggested that allogeneic bone marrow progenitor cells can be "educated" by the host thymic stroma to behave, in the competitive reconstitution, like syngeneic cells.

Self-reactive T cells in murine lupus: analysis of genetic contributions and development of self-tolerance

Our understanding of the immune mechanisms that lead to systemic lupus erythematosus has been greatly advanced by the availability of murine models which display both serological and clinical features of the human disease. Studies have demonstrated that CD4+ T cells are required for the full expression of disease in these mice. (NZB X NZW)F1 mice exhibit a lupus-like disease (elevated levels of IgG antinuclear antibodies and a fatal glomerulonephritis) that is not characteristic of either parent. At least three gene loci have been identified in NZW mice that could potentially contribute to a T cell-dependent autoimmune disease, including the T cell receptor alpha- and beta-chain gene complexes and the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). The NZW T cell receptor beta-chain complex appeared to be particularly unusual in that the C beta 1, D beta 2, and J beta 2 gene segments have been deleted. However, an analysis of (NZB X NZW)F1 X NZB back-cross mice revealed no association of disease expression with the presence of this allele. There was also no correlation of disease incidence with the presence of the NZW T cell receptor alpha-chain allele. In contrast, nearly 90% of the backcross mice with the NZW MHC expressed severe autoimmune disease compared with 12% of the mice that did not carry this haplotype. Additional studies strongly suggested that the gene(s) within the NZW MHC is the only dominant NZW genetic contribution to F1 disease. We also determined if self-reactive T cells are able to escape thymic tolerance in autoimmune New Zealand and MRLlpr/lpr mice. In nonautoimmune mice expressing I-E, T cells utilizing V beta 17a and V beta 11 encoded domains have been shown to be clonally eliminated in the thymus. Similarly, V beta 8.1+ and V beta 6+ T cells are tolerized in nonautoimmune mice expressing Mls-1a. These T cell subsets were quantified in the lymph nodes and spleens of (NZB X NZW)F1, (NZB X SWR)F1, and MRL-lpr/lpr mice before and after the development of lupus-like disease. The results indicate that peripheral T cells in these mice, including the massive CD4-, CD8- T cell population in lpr mice, have been modified by normal mechanisms of tolerance such that potential self-reactive V beta specificities have been eliminated in the thymus.

Graft-versus-host disease: an alternative hypothesis

Medawar and Billingham in their classic experiments described three prerequisites for the development of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD): first, the presence of immunocompetent cells in the donor inoculum; second, the inability of the recipient to reject the donor cells; and third, a histocompatibility difference between the donor and recipient. These experiments are the basis for all later hypotheses related to the pathogenesis of GVHD. Recently, de Gast and colleagues reviewed the role of environmental antigens in the pathogenesis of GVHD and suggested that immunological responses to environmental antigens by the transplanted donor cells might contribute to an increased donor anti-recipient response. An area not addressed in that review was the potential role of autoreactivity in GVHD. In this short article, Robertson Parkman highlights the role of autoreactivity and autoantigens in the pathogenesis of both acute and chronic GVHD in histocompatible bone marrow transplantation.

Engagement of CD4 and CD8 expressed on immature thymocytes induces activation of intracellular tyrosine phosphorylation pathways

Accumulating data suggest that the target cells for selection events leading to establishment of the mature T cell repertoire are the functionally immature double-positive (CD4+/CD8+) thymocytes, and that the CD4 and CD8 antigens expressed on these cells play important roles in these processes. In an attempt to define the biochemical pathways implicated in these events, we have studied the effects of engagement of accessory molecules on tyrosine protein phosphorylation. The results of our experiments demonstrate that engagement of CD4 and CD8 expressed on double-positive thymocytes is coupled with a rapid tyrosine protein phosphorylation signal. Further analyses have revealed that these two surface molecules are physically associated with the internal membrane tyrosine protein kinase p56lck in immature thymocytes, and that the catalytic function of lck expressed in double-positive thymocytes is significantly enhanced upon engagement of CD4. These data provide evidence that tyrosine-specific protein phosphorylation pathways coupled to the CD4 and CD8 T cell surface antigens are functional in immature thymocytes, and therefore, formally prove that signaling functions of CD4 and CD8 molecules are operative in immature thymocytes.

Tolerance induced by physiological levels of secreted proteins in transgenic mice expressing human insulin

We have used transgenic mice to study immune tolerance to autologous, non-MHC encoded proteins that are expressed at physiological levels in the circulation. The transgenic mice used in these studies express the human preproinsulin gene and synthesize human proinsulin. Human and mouse insulin are secreted from the pancreatic islets of transgenic mice in response to normal physiological stimuli, such as glucose. Our data demonstrate that the transgenic mice have acquired tolerance to human insulin. The repertoire of T cells specific for exogenous antigens is shaped by the acquired tolerance to autologous proteins since pork but not beef or sheep insulin is also nonimmunogenic in the transgenic mice. We also found that the transgenic mice were tolerant to human proinsulin, the intracellular precursor of insulin. Unresponsiveness to human proinsulin most likely results from tolerance of insulin-specific and proinsulin-specific T cells that recognize the secreted enzymatic cleavage products of proinsulin, insulin and C-peptide.

Interaction of Staphylococcus aureus toxin "superantigens" with human T cells

A modification of the polymerase chain reaction has been used to establish the fact that a collection of Staphylococcus aureus toxins are "superantigens," each of which interacts with the T-cell alpha beta receptor of human T cells by means of a specific set of V beta elements.

Positive selection of CD4+ T cells mediated by MHC class II-bearing stromal cell in the thymic cortex

T lymphocytes differentiate in the thymus, where functionally immature, CD4+CD8+ (double positive) thymocytes develop into functionally mature CD4+ helper cells and CD8+ cytotoxic (single positive) T cells. The thymus is the site where self-reactive T cells are negatively selected (clonally deleted) and where T cells with the capacity to recognize foreign antigens in association with self-proteins encoded by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) are positively selected. The net result of these developmental pathways is a T-cell repertoire that is both self-tolerant and self-restricted. One unresolved issue is the identity of the thymic stromal cells that mediate the negative and positive selection of the T-cell repertoire. Previous work has pointed to a bone-marrow-derived macrophage or dendritic cell as the inducer of tolerance, whereas a radiation-resistant, deoxyguanosine-resistant thymic cell seems to mediate the positive selection of self-MHC restricted T cells. Thymic stromal cells in the cortex interact with the T-cell antigen receptor on thymocytes. Using several strains of transgenic mice that express the class II MHC molecule I-E in specific regions of the thymus, we show directly that the positive selection of T cells is mediated by an I-E-bearing cell in the thymic cortex.

Intrathymic signalling in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes results in tyrosine phosphorylation of the T-cell receptor zeta chain

Thymic selection of the developing T-cell repertoire occurs in immature CD4+CD8+ double-positive thymocytes and is thought to be mediated by signals transduced by T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) molecules and possibly by CD4 and CD8 accessory molecules as well. It is not known, however, which signal-transduction mechanisms function in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes on engagement of TCR, CD4 or CD8 molecules. In mature T cells, CD4 and CD8 molecules are each associated with the src-like protein tyrosine kinase p56 lck and signals transduced by TCR and CD4 activate tyrosine kinases that phosphorylate TCR-zeta chains and other intracellular substrates. Consequently, we examined whether tyrosine kinases could be similarly activated in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. Unexpectedly, we found that TCR-zeta chains from CD4+CD8+ thymocytes were already phosphorylated in vivo, and that dephosphorylation of this TCR subunit occurred on removal of CD4+CD8+ cells from their intrathymic environment. Rephosphorylation of TCR-zeta in cultured CD4+CD8+ thymocytes occurred rapidly in vitro, either in response to cross-linking of TCR, CD4 or CD8 by specific monoclonal antibodies, or on cell-cell contact. These observations indicate that tyrosine kinases are activated in vivo in immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes undergoing thymic differentiation and selection. They also indicate that TCR, CD4 and CD8 molecules can function in CD4+CD8+ thymocytes as signalling molecules to activate tyrosine kinases and that phosphorylated TCR-zeta serves as a marker of these signalling events.

Effects of cyclosporine A on thymocyte differentiation in fetal thymus organ culture

During the course of differentiation in the thymus, precursor T cells are negatively selected by a self-tolerance mechanism or positively selected to acquire restriction specificity to self major histocompatibility complexes. We investigated the process of T cell differentiation and those selections using a fetal thymus organ culture with or without cyclosporine A. The agent blocked the maturation step from CD4+8+ double positive cells to mature CD4-8+ or CD4+8- single positive cells. On the other hand, the agent did not inhibit the development of CD3+4-8- T cell receptor (TCR)alpha beta- cells, which were supposed to be T cells bearing gamma delta-TCR chains. These results suggest that the development of thymocytes bearing alpha beta- or gamma delta-TCR chains differ in requirement for thymocyte-stromal cell interaction.

Selective decreases in T cell receptor V beta expression. Decreased expression of specific V beta families is associated with expression of multiple MHC and non-MHC gene products

Previous reports of TCR V beta usage, studying either expression of a single V beta in a wide panel of strains (6, 7, 10, 12, 13), or expression of multiple V beta s in a very limited strain distribution (14, 15), have identified instances of clonal deletion of potentially autoreactive T cells specific for either self E alpha E beta or minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) antigens. The present study has investigated the range of self antigens that can influence V beta usage by evaluating expression of 16 V beta families in 30 strains of mice. It was found that significant decreases in expression occur in at least 8 of the 16 V beta families and that dominant influences on the T cell V beta repertoire are exerted by expression of Mlsa, Mlsc, and MHC gene products. Decreased expressions of V beta 5, -11, -12, and -16 were influenced by MHC gene products. The patterns of decreased expression seen in intra-MHC recombinant strains and strains of different non-MHC background were distinct for V beta 11, -12, and -16, suggesting that different ligands are involved in the deletion of T cells expressing each of these V beta genes. Mice expressing Mlsa show decreased expression of V beta 9 as well as V beta 6. Mlsc mice lacked V beta 3 expression in those strains where the expressed MHC type was compatible with a strongly stimulatory Mlsc phenotype. V beta 7 was strongly influenced by both MHC and non-MHC products that are not yet identified. These results demonstrate that strain-specific decreases of mRNA expression occur in a major portion of the TCR repertoire. Self antigens including Mlsa, Mlsc, and E alpha E beta, as well as additional MHC and non-MHC products, appear to induce these decreases in expression in the process of eliminating self-reactive T cells from the mature T cell pool.

Expression of non-MHC-restricted T cell antigen-binding molecules by thymic lymphocytes

Heterologous antisera which recognize non-major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T cell antigen-binding molecules (TABM) were used to characterize the expression and structure of TABM on thymic lymphocytes. Approximately 70% of thymocytes express membrane molecules bound by anti-TABM antibodies (mTABM). Antibody activity for thymocyte TABM could be removed by adsorption to splenic T cells, but not by adsorption to splenic B cells. Similarly, adsorption of the antiserum to thymocytes or splenic T cells removed antibody activity to a purified TABM whereas adsorption with B cells had no effect. Radioiodinated thymic and splenic T cell mTABM were resolved by 2D-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and when reduced, both populations of mTABM migrated primarily as Mr 23,000 proteins with an isoelectric point range of 6.8-7.8. Multimers of this protein were also observed at Mr 85-97,000 and 130-150,000 on both thymocytes and splenic T cells. These data indicate that MHC-unrestricted antigen-binding molecules are expressed by a majority of thymocytes and these thymic TABM are structurally and antigenically similar to mTABM on peripheral cells. This suggests an ontogenic relationship between thymic TABM and peripheral TABM.

An explanation for the protective effect of the MHC class II I-E molecule in murine diabetes

Insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus is widely believed to be an autoimmune disease. Recent onset diabetics show destruction of insulin-secreting pancreatic beta-cells associated with a lymphocytic infiltrate (insulitis), with autoantibodies to beta-cells being found even before the onset of symptoms. Susceptibility to the disease is strongly influenced by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II polymorphism in both man and experimental animal models such as the non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse. As MHC class II molecules are usually associated with dominant immune responsiveness, it was surprising that introduction of a transgenic class II molecule, I-E, protected NOD mice from insulitis and diabetes. This could be explained by a change either in the target tissue or in the T cells presumed to be involved in beta-cell destruction. Recently, several studies have shown that I-E molecules are associated with ontogenetic deletion of T cells bearing antigen/MHC receptors encoded in part by certain T-cell receptor V beta gene segments. To determine the mechanism of the protective effect of I-E, we have produced cloned CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell lines from islets of recently diabetic NOD mice. These cloned lines are islet-specific and pathogenic in both I-E- and I-E+ mice. Both CD4+ and CD8+ cloned T cells bear receptors encoded by a V beta 5 gene segment, known to be deleted during development in I-E expressing mice. Our data provide, therefore, an explanation for the puzzling effect of I-E on susceptibility to diabetes in NOD mice.

Positive selection of the T cell repertoire: where and when does it occur?

The T cell repertoire is shaped by both positive and negative influences. T lymphocytes that express the V beta 6 variable region are positively selected in the thymus by cells expressing major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II E molecules. To identify these cells, we have quantitated V beta 6+ T lymphocytes in a set of transgenic mice showing variant patterns of E expression in the thymus. We demonstrate that class II molecules must be expressed on epithelial cells of the cortex for positive selection to occur. Using a direct assay of unmanipulated thymocytes, we show that positive selection is manifest only as a rather late event in thymocyte differentiation, after the maturation of cortical double-positives into single-positives.

Expression of a hybrid immunoglobulin-T cell receptor protein in transgenic mice

We have constructed a hybrid immunoglobulin (VDJH)-T cell receptor (C alpha) gene using the VDJH exon from a digoxin-specific antibody. This gene was used to make a line of transgenic mice. The hybrid VDJH-C alpha protein is expressed on a subset of T cells in these mice, and we have shown that it forms part of a functional TCR complex by the criteria of coprecipitation and comodulation of CD3 and TCR beta chain components and T cell activation with anti-idiotypic antibodies or digoxin. Furthermore, in cells expressing the hybrid protein, there is allelic exclusion of endogenous TCR alpha genes. We discuss the implications for the comparative structure of T cell receptors and immunoglobulins.

In vivo expression and function of hybrid Ia dimers (E alpha A beta) in recombinant and transgenic mice

We have found cell surface expression of an E alpha molecule in recombinant and transgenic mouse strains lacking an E beta molecule. Flow cytometry has shown low level expression of E alpha in B10.RQB3 (I-AqEk alpha) and B10.RFB2 (I-AfEk alpha) mice. We have also found that B10.Q (H-2q) mice can express the Ek alpha transgene. Since these strains do not have functional E beta chains, we propose that the E alpha A beta hybrid dimers are formed in low numbers and can be picked up by FACS analysis. So far we have not been able to identify these hybrid molecules by cytotoxicity or immunoprecipitation. The E alpha/A beta molecule can function in vivo during thymic selection in the clonal deletion of two V beta TCR subsets, V beta 11 and V beta 6, which have been shown to interact with the intact I-E molecule.

Only dull CD3+ thymocytes bind to thymic epithelial cells. The binding is elicited by both CD2/LFA-3 and LFA-1/ICAM-1 interactions

In view of the necessity for thymocytes to interact with thymic epithelial cells to differentiate into mature T cells, this study analyzed the binding between human thymocytes, cultured thymic epithelial cells (CTEC) and the required adhesion molecules. Immediately after separation, thymic epithelial cells (TEC) readily expressed ICAM-1, which is one of the ligands of LFA-1 cell adhesion molecules. However, the ICAM-1 expression was gradually lost upon culture of TEC. IFN-gamma re-induced ICAM-1 on the CTEC, and the ability of CTEC to bind to thymocytes was also increased by IFN-gamma treatment. The increase in binding seemed to be caused by the LFA-1/ICAM-1 interaction, since it was inhibited by anti-ICAM-1 monoclonal antibody (mAb) and anti-LFA-1 mAb. This suggests that the LFA-1/ICAM-1 interaction is also involved in vivo with the binding of thymocytes to TEC, which have been shown to express ICAM-1. To better understand the nature of the cells involved in binding, thymocytes were sorted into CD3-, CD3dull+, and CD3bright+ subsets (which are supposed to represent the immature, intermediate and mature stages of differentiation, respectively), and were examined for their binding to IFN-gamma-treated CTEC. The result showed that only the CD3dull+ subset bound to CTEC. CD3-, CD3bright+ cells and peripheral blood T lymphocytes did not bind, but they were induced to bind by neuramidase treatment All these bindings were inhibited by anti-LFA-1 mAb and anti-CD2 mAb. These findings indicate that CD3dull+ cells can bind to TEC via CD2/LFA-3 and LFA-1/ICAM-1 interactions. Other cells seemed not to bind to TEC because of sialylation.

Influence of non-major histocompatibility complex differences on the severity of lymphocytic choriomeningitis

The role of the non-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genetic background in the development of lymphocytic choriomeningitis (LCM) was examined for a range of mouse strains of the H-2k haplotype. The onset of meningitis relative to the time of injection of LCM virus was delayed and the maximal level of cellular extravasation into cerebrospinal fluid was lower in C3H/HeJ and CBA/H compared with AKR/J, B10.Br and BALB/c.H-2k mice. Adoptive transfer experiments indicated that the C3H mice are genuine low responders, but immune spleen cells from the CBA/H were as potent on a cell-for-cell basis as those from the AKR/J. Further analysis with CBA/H, AKR/J and (CBA/H x AKR/J)F1 mice showed that the pattern of high response for the AKR/J was dominant, with the differential kinetics of the development of meningitis correlating with the cellularity of the cervical lymph nodes. Thus, the generation of the LCM inflammatory process is not dictated solely by the MHC phenotype.

Loss of tolerance associated with disappearance of B cells in a patient sequentially transplanted with paternal and maternal bone marrow for the treatment of severe combined immunodeficiency disease

We have studied the tolerance of engrafted T cells from a severe combined immunodeficiency disease patient sequentially transplanted with T-cell-depleted bone marrow from both HLA haploidentical parents. The T cells from this patient were shown by HLA typing and cytogenetic analysis to be of material origin (donor of the second graft) while HLA typing of peripheral E--populations and of an Epstein-Barr virus-transformed B-cell line established 2 1/2 years after transplantation revealed the presence of host, maternal, and paternal (donor of the first graft) HLA antigens. When tested at 30 and 60 months after the last transplant, engrafted T cells from this patient had only weak mixed lymphocyte culture reactivity to paternal cells which could be inhibited by monoclonal antibodies to HLA-DQ and DR but not by anti-DP. T cells obtained 60 months after transplant were stimulated with paternal cells in both bulk and limiting dilution cultures and failed to generate typical allocytotoxic cells to paternal T- or B-cell targets. Mixed lymphocyte cultures performed at 71 months revealed an increased proliferative response by patient cells to paternal antigens; however, the engrafted T cells remained tolerant to maternal and host antigens. Limiting dilution analysis performed at this time revealed the presence of cytolytic cells directed to paternal antigens. There were no detectable B cells (only identified source of paternal antigen) as measured by immunofluorescent analysis of peripheral blood, nor any evidence of B-cell function as assessed by in vitro assays (proliferation to staphylococcus aureus Cowen strain A and mitogen-stimulated immunoglobulin production) or in vivo production of serum immunoglobulin at 60 and 71 months. The appearance of alloreactivity associated with the loss of B cells in this patient further supports the conclusion that the maintenance of tolerance to major histocompatibility complex disparate cells requires the continued in vivo presence of cells bearing the tolerizing antigens.

Tolerance induction in the organ-cultured thymus lobes upon intimate contact with allogeneic thymus lobes

In an organ-cultured murine fetus thymus, precursor cytotoxic T lymphocytes (pCTL) specific for alloantigens developed successfully but those reactive with self antigens were eliminated. In attempting to dissect the mechanism of self tolerance, intrathymic chimera was made by culturing two genetically disparate thymuses in close contact with each other (parabiosis of thymuses). This maneuver resulted in the induction of specific and mutual CTL tolerance. It seems that CTL tolerance was induced by clonal deletion but not by active suppression. Since 2'-deoxyguanosine treatment abolished the tolerogenic capability of the thymus, hemopoietic cells capable of migrating to and fro in the parabiotic thymuses are thought to be responsible for tolerance induction. Induction of CTL tolerance was dependent on the maturation stages of T cells in the thymus: T cells in 5-day-, but not in 7-day-cultured thymuses were susceptible to tolerance induction, indicating that T cells expressing T cell receptors at low density are susceptible to tolerance induction.

Elimination of self-tolerogen turns nonresponder mice into responders

Two sets of genes control the immune response of H-2d mice to the synthetic antigen poly(Glu50Tyr50) (GT). One set involves class II major histocompatibility complex (Mhc) loci encoding an Ad product that serves as a recognition context to GT-reactive helper T cells (Th). The other one is a background gene, the product of which, in association with the same Mhc-restricting element, mimics the GT/Ad complex. Mice expressing the GT-mimicking background-encoded structure (Imgt), which is preferentially displayed on B lymphoblasts, do not respond to GT as a consequence of self-tolerance. On the other hand, elimination of cells bearing Imgt renders these mice responsive to GT, demonstrating that tolerance to self can impoverish the immune system. Imgt is probably not identical to GT, but resembles it in the way it forms complexes with Ad molecules of Mhc.

Inhibition of MHC class II-restricted T cell response by Lyt-2 alloantigen

T cell hybridomas were established by fusing a CD8+ V beta 8.1+ CTL clone and a CD4+ V beta 8.1+ helper T lymphocyte (HTL) clone to the thymoma cell line BW5147. In contrast to the HTL x BW hybridomas, which retain the same antigen specificity as the original T cell clone, the CTL x BW hybridomas lost the class I MHC-restricted antigen response but acquired a new specificity to Mlsa antigen. Mlsa reactivity of CTL x BW hybridomas was shown to be mediated by the CTL TCR as assayed by inhibition using an anticlonotypic antibody to the CTL clone. Since hybridomas established with BW5147 lose CD8 expression, we have introduced the CD8 molecule into CTL x BW5147 hybridomas by gene transfection. The CD8+ V beta 8.1+ hybridoma was no longer capable of reacting to Mlsa antigen but exhibited the same antigen specificity as the parental CTL clone. Furthermore, the presence of the transfected CD8 molecule in the HTL x BW hybridomas was found to be inhibitory to class II MHC-restricted antigen reactivity. These results demonstrate that, besides its role in increasing the overall avidity of T cell-class I MHC/antigen interaction, the CD8 molecule inhibits T cell-class II MHC gene product/antigen interaction. This negative effect of the CD8 molecule on a class II MHC-restricted response may account for the failure of CD8+ T cells using either V beta 8.1 or V beta 6, which impart reactivity to the Mlsa antigen on CD4+ T cells, to respond to the Mlsa antigen.

Neonatal thymectomy results in a repertoire enriched in T cells deleted in adult thymus

In B6AF1 mice, T lymphocytes that use the V beta 11-positive (and not V beta 6-positive or V beta 8-positive) segment in their receptor for antigen are greatly reduced in the thymus and peripheral lymphoid tissues, most likely as a result of clonal deletion. The relative number of V beta 11-positive cells in adult lymph nodes was ten times as high in B6AF1 mice thymectomized 1 to 4 days after birth as in normal mice. Moreover, for the first 10 days of life of B6AF1 mice, mature V beta 11-positive T cells were readily detected in the thymus and spleen. Thus neonatal thymectomy results in the maintenance of the receptor repertoire of early postnatal life, and this correlates with the subsequent development of organ-specific autoimmune diseases.

Phenotypic differences between alpha beta versus beta T-cell receptor transgenic mice undergoing negative selection

T-cell differentiation in the thymus is thought to involve a progression from the CD4-CD8- phenotype through CD4+CD8+ intermediates to mature CD4+ or CD8+ cells. There is evidence that during this process T cells bearing receptors potentially reactive to 'self' are deleted by a process termed 'negative selection' One example of this process occurs in mice carrying polymorphic Mls antigens, against which a detectable proportion of T cells are autoreactive. These mice show clonal deletion of thymic and peripheral T-cell subsets that express the autoreactive V beta 3 segment of the T-cell antigen receptor, but at most a two-fold depletion of thymic cells at the CD4+CD8+ stage. By contrast, transgenic mice bearing both alpha and beta chain genes encoding autoreactive receptors recognizing other ligands, show severe depletion of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes as well, suggesting that negative selection occurs much earlier. We report here the Mls 2a/3a mediated elimination of T cells expressing a transgene encoded V beta 3-segment, in T-cell receptor alpha/beta and beta-transgenic mice. Severe depletion of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes is seen only in the alpha/beta chain transgenic mice, whereas both strains delete mature V beta 3 bearing CD4+ and CD8+ T cells efficiently. We conclude that severe CD4+CD8+ thymocyte deletion in alpha/beta transgenic mice results from the premature expression of both receptor chains, and does not reflect a difference in the timing or mechanism of negative selection for Mls antigens as against the allo- and MHC class 1-restricted antigens used in the other studies.

Transgenic HLA-DR alpha faithfully reconstitutes IE-controlled immune functions and induces cross-tolerance to E alpha in E alpha 0 mutant mice

We have constructed transgenic mice that express the human class II MHC molecule HLA-DR alpha on a genetic background in which the equivalent endogenous gene, H-2 IE alpha, is not expressed. In these mice, DR alpha complemented the E beta chain such that tissue-specific expression of an interspecies hybrid DR alpha-E beta heterodimer was obtained. Despite 25% amino acid differences between DR alpha and E alpha, immune responsiveness to IE-controlled antigens, clonal deletion of IE-reactive T cells, and alloantigenicity were quantitatively and qualitatively indistinguishable in IE-positive mice and in mice that had integrated at least four copies of the transgene. These results demonstrate a remarkable degree of structural, regulatory, and functional conservation. They also suggest that tolerance induction involves only discrete portions of MHC molecules.