Identification of motor and nonmotor wearing-off in Parkinson's disease: Comparison of a patient questionnaire versus a clinician assessment

The sensitivity and specificity of the 9-item Wearing-off Questionnaire

OBJECTIVE

This multicenter, cross-sectional study was conducted to determine the sensitivity and specificity of a 9-item Wearing-off Questionnaire (WOQ-9) compared with assessment by a clinician.

METHODS

Patients with a diagnosis of Parkinson's disease (PD) for 5 <or=years, and receiving stable antiparkinsonian therapy for >or=90 days, completed the WOQ-9 before independent evaluation by the physician.

RESULTS

One hundred fifty-seven patients reported WO using the WOQ-9; only 79 had been previously diagnosed with WO by a physician. The most frequent items used by physicians to diagnose WO included type of symptoms (69.6%), symptom response (63.3%), and timing of symptom response (58.2%) to medication. Physician assessment of WO and WOQ-9 results corresponded in 76 of 79 cases; physicians disagreed with WO identification in 81 of 157 cases. Sensitivity of the WOQ-9 was 96.2% and specificity was 40.9%.

CONCLUSION

The WOQ-9 is a useful screening tool to aid diagnosis of WO in PD patients.

Entacapone in elderly Parkinsonian patients experiencing levodopa-related wearing-off: a pilot study

Levodopa (LD) provides the most effective symptomatic treatment for Parkinson's disease (PD). Long-term treatment with LD, however, is often associated with the development of response fluctuations. Previous evidence suggests that the short half-life of LD is a major contributor to the development of response fluctuations and the wearing-off phenomenon in particular. Entacapone, a peripheral catechol-O-methyltransferase inhibitor has been shown to reduce OFF time and increase ON time in several therapeutic trials on PD patients treated with LD experiencing motor fluctuations. However, data are missing on the tolerability and efficacy of entacapone in elderly PD patients. This is of particular relevance, as most PD patients develop LD-related motor fluctuations after several years of disease duration. Here we report that addition of entacapone in a group of 45 elderly PD patients with LD-related motor fluctuations is well tolerated and efficacious in reducing the time, frequency and severity of the OFF periods. These data suggest that the drug can be used safely and efficaciously in elderly PD patients.

Effects of chronic subthalamic stimulation on nonmotor fluctuations in Parkinson's disease

The aim of this study was to assess the outcome of nonmotor fluctuations (NMF) after chronic Subthalamic nucleus (STN) Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) in Parkinson's disease(PD). Chronic stimulation of the STN has proved to be an effective treatment for advanced PD with motor complications. The outcome of NMF, which are also disabling, remains unknown. Forty-patients underwent bilateral STN stimulation. Each patient was interviewed before and after 1 yr of STN DBS with a structured questionnaire about their NMF. After 1 yr of chronic stimulation, the improvement in the motor score (UPDRS III) and dyskinesia amounted respectively to 67.4 and 76.3%. The decrease in motor fluctuations (MF) was 59% and 13 patients reported that their MF had disappeared. Comparatively, a reduction of the total number of NMF was also observed (mean number preoperatively: 15.6 per patient, postoperatively: 6.6). Most of the nonmotor fluctuating symptoms occurred in the "off" state preoperatively and no longer depended on the patient's motor state after surgery. The improvement in NMF was not identical for the different categories: pain/sensory fluctuations showed the best response to STN DBS (84.2%). Dysautonomic and cognitive fluctuations were also markedly improved (>60%) while psychic fluctuations remained the most frequent postoperative NMF observed. Some incapacitating manifestations such as drenching sweats and akathisia showed a remarkably good response to STN stimulation. In conclusion STN DBS alleviates NMF. It has strikingly successful effects on sensory, dysautonomic and cognitive fluctuations. However, psychic fluctuations respond less consistently to this treatment.

[Non-motor fluctuations in Parkinson's disease]

Nonmotor fluctuations (NMF) in Parkinson's disease are nonmotor symptoms that occur in coincidence with motor fluctuations or independently. Long under-assessed, NMF are now recognized as frequent and sometimes involving a greater degree of disability than motor fluctuations. They can be classified in three categories: dysautonomic, cognitive/psychiatric and sensory/pain. Recognition of these nonmotor fluctuations as part of Parkinson's disease has important implications. Some symptoms such as dyspnea, chest pain, or abdominal pains can mimic cardiac or gastrointestinal emergencies. The underlying pathogenic mechanisms of NMF are not well known. The dopaminergic system is probably involved via modulation of other systems (serotoninergic, adrenergic) since NMF usually respond to dopaminergic treatment. Subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation alleviates NMF-- particularly sensory, dysautonomic and cognitive fluctuations--while psychic fluctuations respond less consistently to this treatment. The development of new instruments that enable a comprehensive and precocious assessment of NMF is important for optimized management of advanced Parkinson's disease.

Medical management of levodopa-associated motor complications in patients with Parkinson's disease

Parkinson's disease is a neurodegenerative disorder that affects approximately 1% of people over the age of 60 years. Levodopa is standard, and often initial, therapy for patients with this condition; however, with continued treatment and as the disease progresses, up to 80% of patients experience 'wearing-off' symptoms, dyskinesias and other motor complications. These levodopa-associated problems may become disabling and profoundly affect quality of life. Medications commonly used to manage these symptoms include monoamine oxidase type B (MAO-B) inhibitors, catechol-O-methyltransferase (COMT) inhibitors, the NMDA receptor antagonist amantadine and dopamine receptor agonists. Agents that block MAO-B, such as rasagiline and selegiline, are used as both initial and adjunctive therapy in patients with Parkinson's disease. These medications increase concentrations of dopamine in the brain by blocking its reuptake from the synaptic cleft, a mechanism that can slow motor decline, increase 'on' time and improve symptoms of Parkinson's disease. Adverse events with these agents can include confusion, hallucination and orthostatic hypotension. MAO-B inhibition may elicit drug-drug interactions if administered with TCAs, SSRIs or SNRIs. Conventional oral selegiline is associated with potentially harmful plasma concentrations of three major amphetamine metabolites, although metabolite concentrations are significantly lower with a new orally disintegrating tablet (ODT) selegiline formulation. Selegiline ODT is also absorbed more efficiently and shows less pharmacokinetic variability than conventional oral selegiline.COMT mediates peripheral catabolism of levodopa. Therefore, agents that block COMT, such as tolcapone and entacapone, increase the elimination half-life of levodopa. Given adjunctively with levodopa, COMT inhibitors can decrease 'off' time and increase 'on' time, as well as lower the daily levodopa dose. Although more potent than entacapone, tolcapone requires monitoring for hepatotoxicity. Amantadine is a noncompetitive NMDA receptor antagonist shown to lower dyskinesia scores and improve motor complications in patients with Parkinson's disease when given adjunctively with levodopa. Dopamine agonists, also used as initial and adjunctive therapy in Parkinson's disease, improve motor response and decrease 'off' time purportedly through direct stimulation of dopamine receptors. Current dopamine agonists include bromocriptine, pergolide, cabergoline, lisuride, apomorphine, pramipexole, ropinirole and rotigotine. Although effective, this class of medications can be associated with cardiovascular and psychiatric adverse effects that can limit their utility. All medications used to manage levodopa-associated motor complications in patients with Parkinson's disease have had differing degrees of success. Although head-to-head comparisons of drugs within classes are rare, some differences have emerged related to effects on motor fluctuations, dyskinesias and on/off times, as well as to adverse effects. When choosing a drug to treat levodopa-induced complications, it is important to consider the risks and benefits of the different classes and of the specific agents within each class, given the different efficacy and safety profiles of each.

The Patient Card Questionnaire to Identify Wearing-off in Parkinson Disease

This study sought to evaluate the feasibility and performance of the Patient Card (PC), an instrument derived from the Patient Questionnaire by Stacy et al, for detection of wearing-off (W-O), in a very first application to a Spanish population with Parkinson disease. Patients were classified as experiencing W-O on the basis of the clinician's Follow-up Questionnaire, the Unified Parkinson Disease Rating Scale-Item 36, or improvement, after the following scheduled dose of medication, of 1 or more symptoms included in the PC. The highest proportion of patients with W-O was identified by the PC (79.8%), followed by the Follow-up Questionnaire (55.4%), and Unified Parkinson Disease Rating Scale (35.1%) (Cochran Q, P < 0.01). The PC Spanish version performed adequately, capturing W-O symptoms more frequently than did the other methods, as in the original Patient Questionnaire study by Stacy et al. Accordingly, the PC may potentially help clinicians identify W-O phenomena and thereby allow for better management of patients with Parkinson disease.

Selegiline Orally Disintegrating Tablets in Patients With Parkinson Disease and "Wearing Off" Symptoms

BACKGROUND

Selegiline orally disintegrating tablet (ODT; Zelapar) is a selective monoamine oxidase B inhibitor developed as an adjunct to levodopa (LD) for Parkinson disease. Most patients on long-term LD therapy eventually experience deterioration at the end of the LD dosing interval, with predictable "wearing off" and "on-off" fluctuations.

METHODS

We conducted a 12-week, double-blind, placebo-controlled, parallel-design trial of selegiline ODT. The primary efficacy point was reduction in the percentage of average daily "off" time. Secondary measures included reductions in daily off hours and total daily off time, Clinical Global Impressions-Improvement (CGI-I), and Patient Global Impression-Improvement (PGI-I). Patients on LD received selegiline ODT (1.25 mg/d for 6 weeks, then 2.5 mg/d for 6 weeks) or placebo. Safety and tolerability were measured.

RESULTS

The intent-to-treat population included 98 patients receiving selegiline ODT and 50 patients receiving placebo. Combined efficacy results for weeks 10 and 12 revealed an 11.6% reduction in percentage of daily off time for selegiline ODT versus a 9.8% reduction for placebo (NS). PGI-I detected a statistically significant difference between treatment groups in favor of selegiline ODT (P = 0.02), whereas CGI-I detected a strong trend toward improvement (P = 0.06). Selegiline ODT was safe and well tolerated.

CONCLUSIONS

This study showed no significant difference in improvement in percentage of off time with selegiline ODT versus placebo. Some clinical impressions (e.g., PGI-I, CGI-I) improved. This result contrasts with an identically designed study that showed a significant improvement in off time with selegiline ODT. A combined analysis of both studies suggested overall efficacy.

Apomorphine in the treatment of Parkinson's disease

Motor fluctuations, refractory to conventional medical management, are one of the most troubling aspects of Parkinson's disease. Apomorphine is a dopaminergic agent that has been known to the medical community for more than a century, but has only recently been developed to treat such motor fluctuations. In this article, the authors review the historical background, structure, mechanism of action, pharmacologic properties, clinical trials, indications and side effects, as well as avenues of further research, of apomorphine.

Balancing short-term symptom control and long-term functional outcomes in patients with Parkinson's disease

Levodopa has played a central role in the treatment of Parkinson's disease for nearly 40 years and remains the single most effective symptomatic treatment for the disease. However, the response to levodopa therapy changes over time, and its long-term use is commonly associated with disabling motor complications. For this reason, the appropriate role of levodopa in the treatment of Parkinson's disease-in particular, the question of when to initiate therapy with the drug-has been a matter of controversy. Because levodopa is the most effective treatment for Parkinson's disease, the management of this disease becomes a matter of balancing short-term symptom control with long-term functional outcomes. This article provides an overview of the basis for levodopa-associated motor complications and their impact on patients' clinical function and quality of life, followed by a discussion of strategies for managing these complications to achieve optimum symptom control while minimizing the adverse effects of long-term therapy.

Prevalence of nonmotor symptoms in Parkinson's disease in an international setting; Study using nonmotor symptoms questionnaire in 545 patients

2006, there was, no single instrument (questionnaire or scale) for attempting a comprehensive assessment of the wide range of nonmotor symptoms (NMS) of Parkinson's disease (PD). The PD nonmotor group, a multidisciplinary group of experts including patient group representatives developed and validated the NMS screening questionnaire (NMSQuest) comprising 30 items. The NMSQuest is a self completed screening tool designed to draw attention to the presence of NMS. In this paper, we present the results gathered from 545 patients using the definitive version of the NMSQuest highlighting the prevalence of the wide range of NMS flagged in the NMSQuest from consecutive PD patients in an international setting.

Non-motor symptoms in Parkinson's disease: an underdiagnosed problem

Parkinson's disease results from degeneration of the substantia nigra pars compacta and the consequent dysfunction of the dopaminergic nigrostriatal pathway. Serotonergic and noradrenergic pathways are also affected. However, It has been recognized that nondopaminergic and non-motor symptoms are sometimes present prior to diagnosis and these inevitably emerge with disease progression, impacting on morbidity, quality of life and mortality. The non-motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease continue to be poorly recognized and inadequately treated in contrast with motor symptoms, and a modern holistic approach to treatment of Parkinson's disease should therefore include recognition and assessment of non-motor symptoms. Certain aspects of the non-motor symptoms complex of Parkinson's disease can be improved with currently available treatments, but other features may be more refractory and require research into effective nondopaminergic drug therapies for the future.

End-of-dose Wearing Off in Parkinson Disease

We have previously reported that the use of a 32-symptom Wearing-off Questionnaire (WOQ-32) identified wearing off more frequently than a clinician's evaluation or the complications subscale of the Unified Parkinson Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS). However, this prototype tool was not designed for clinical practice and required simplification for daily use. Although wearing off is a commonly understood concept among neurologists caring for Parkinson disease patients, there are a number of definitions in the literature. For the purpose of this study and to include both motor and nonmotor parkinsonian symptoms, wearing off was defined as a generally predictable recurrence of motor and nonmotor symptoms that precedes scheduled doses of anti-parkinsonian medication and usually improves after those doses. Using this definition, retrospective analysis and expert opinion were used to identify the 9 most predictive and relevant of the symptoms previously identified as part of the WOQ-32. The resulting 9-symptom questionnaire (WOQ-9) identified 158 (95.8%) of the 165 subjects captured by the 32-Symptom Wearing-off Questionnaire as having wearing off, excluding 7 subjects reporting only balance difficulty (n = 3), numbness (n = 2), difficulty standing (n = 1), and abdominal discomfort (n = 1). Subjects reporting wearing off with the WOQ-9 were significantly younger, had been longer diagnosed with Parkinson disease, experienced a longer duration of levodopa therapy, exhibited a higher UPDRS total score, had higher levodopa equivalent dosages, and increased dyskinesia compared with patients not identified as wearing off with the WOQ-9. No statistical differences were noted with respect to sex, UPDRS subsection scores, Schwab & England Scale, or Hoehn & Yahr Scale.

Development of a Patient Questionnaire to facilitate recognition of motor and non-motor wearing-off in Parkinson’s disease

We previously reported that the use of a specifically designed Wearing-Off Questionnaire (WOQ) identified symptoms of wearing-off more frequently than standard assessments conducted by movement disorder specialists during a routine office visit. In the previous study we used a WOQ of 32 symptoms; however this tool was not designed for daily use. In this paper we describe the retrospective development of a simpler, 19-symptom WOQ more suitable for routine clinical use.

The levodopa wearing-off phenomenon in Parkinson’s disease: pharmacokinetic considerations

Levodopa is the most efficacious treatment in the management of Parkinson's disease. Unfortunately, chronic use of traditional levodopa/dopa decarboxylase inhibitor formulations is associated with the development of complications, such as wearing-off and dyskinesia. In an attempt to avoid these complications, some physicians delay the introduction of levodopa or employ levodopa-sparing strategies; however, these strategies are frequently suboptimal for patients. As most patients require the superior efficacy of levodopa during the course of their disease, an appreciation of the changing response to levodopa over time and an understanding of the pharmacokinetic principles underlying the development of complications such as wearing-off is essential in the long-term management of the patient.

International multicenter pilot study of the first comprehensive self-completed nonmotor symptoms questionnaire for Parkinson's disease: The NMSQuest study

Nonmotor symptoms (NMS) of Parkinson's disease (PD) are not well recognized in clinical practice, either in primary or in secondary care, and are frequently missed during routine consultations. There is no single instrument (questionnaire or scale) that enables a comprehensive assessment of the range of NMS in PD both for the identification of problems and for the measurement of outcome. Against this background, a multidisciplinary group of experts, including patient group representatives, has developed an NMS screening questionnaire comprising 30 items. This instrument does not provide an overall score of disability and is not a graded or rating instrument. Instead, it is a screening tool designed to draw attention to the presence of NMS and initiate further investigation. In this article, we present the results from an international pilot study assessing feasibility, validity, and acceptability of a nonmotor questionnaire (NMSQuest). Data from 123 PD patients and 96 controls were analyzed. NMS were highly significantly more prevalent in PD compared to controls (PD NMS, median = 9.0, mean = 9.5 vs. control NMS, median = 5.5, mean = 4.0; Mann-Whitney, Kruskal-Wallis, and t test, P < 0.0001), with PD patients reporting at least 10 different NMS on average per patient. In PD, NMS were highly significantly more prevalent across all disease stages and the number of symptoms correlated significantly with advancing disease and duration of disease. Furthermore, frequently, problems such as diplopia, dribbling, apathy, blues, taste and smell problems were never previously disclosed to the health professionals.

Non-motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease: diagnosis and management

The clinical diagnosis of Parkinson's disease rests on the identification of the characteristics related to dopamine deficiency that are a consequence of degeneration of the substantia nigra pars compacta. However, non-dopaminergic and non-motor symptoms are sometimes present before diagnosis and almost inevitably emerge with disease progression. Indeed, non-motor symptoms dominate the clinical picture of advanced Parkinson's disease and contribute to severe disability, impaired quality of life, and shortened life expectancy. By contrast with the dopaminergic symptoms of the disease, for which treatment is available, non-motor symptoms are often poorly recognised and inadequately treated. However, attention is now being focused on the recognition and quantitation of non-motor symptoms, which will form the basis of improved treatments. Some non-motor symptoms, including depression, constipation, pain, genitourinary problems, and sleep disorders, can be improved with available treatments. Other non-motor symptoms can be more refractory and need the introduction of novel non-dopaminergic drugs. Inevitably, the development of treatments that can slow or prevent the progression of Parkinson's disease and its multicentric neurodegeneration provides the best hope of curing non-motor symptoms.