Another view of the selective model of thymocyte selection

Allelic exclusion of mouse T cell receptor alpha chains occurs at the time of thymocyte TCR up-regulation

We report a detailed analysis of TCR V alpha and V beta chain expression on immature versus mature thymocytes of normal, TCR beta-transgenic, and TCR alpha-hemizygous mice. Chain pairing between TCR V alpha and V beta chains is random on immature thymocytes, but individual chain pairs are selected in mature thymocytes. This indicates that V alpha-V beta chain pairing preferences are determined during thymic selection, and not as a result of structural constraints. Dual V alpha chain expression is found frequently on immature, but not mature thymocytes. It is not found in TCR alpha-hemizygous mice, showing that cell surface expression of dual alpha chains is caused by lack of allelic exclusion in immature thymocytes. Down-regulation of one of the alpha chains occurs concurrently with differentiation from TCRlo, CD69- to TCRhi, CD69+ phenotype, suggesting that it is associated with positive selection of the functional TCR.

TCR-associated zeta-Fc epsilon RI gamma heterodimers on CD4-CD8- NK1.1+ T cells selected by specific class I MHC antigen

The origin of autoreactive CD4-CD8- T cells is largely unknown. In TCR transgenic (Tg) mice expressing the cognate class I MHC antigen, CD4-CD8- T cells differed depending on characteristics of Tg-TCR/antigen interaction. Tg-TCR/CD3lo CD4-CD8- T cells expressing the NK1.1 marker were observed only for a Tg-TCR whose stimulation by antigen was independent of CD8. Unlike normal T cells, which have essentially TCR-associated zeta homodimers, these cells had a high proportion of TCR-associated zeta-Fc epsilon RI gamma heterodimers. They were also characterized by an unusually high content of Fc epsilon RI gamma mRNA and low content of mRNA encoding CD3 epsilon, CD3 gamma, CD3 delta, and zeta. Based on their phenotype and selection requirements, it is proposed that CD4-CD8- thymic precursor cells can be driven along the CD4-CD8-NK1.1+ pathway following coreceptor-independent TCR signaling at an intrathymic stage when Fc epsilon RI gamma and CD3 components are coexpressed.

The influence of invariant chain on the positive selection of single T cell receptor specificities

The appearance of peptide-loaded major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules at the cell surface depends critically on the invariant chain (Ii). We have studied the influence of Ii on the positive selection of CD4+ T cells, mediated by class II molecules expressed on thymic stromal cells. Invariant chain-deficient mice (Iio) were crossed with different T cell receptor (TcR) transgenic strains and the emergence of mature CD4 single-positive thymocytes measured in Iio/TcR transgenic offspring. Positive selection was nearly absent in Iio/2B4 mice, which display receptors specific for a moth cytochrome c (MCC) peptide in the context of Ek. In addition, no T cell response was elicited when nontransgenic Iio animals were injected with this peptide, even though antigen-presenting cells (APC) from such mice were perfectly capable of presenting it, suggesting that selection of the entire anti-MCC 88-103 repertoire depends on Ii. Positive selection also appeared strongly reduced in another line of Iio/TcR transgenic mice (Iio/BDC2.5). However, in sharp contrast, a third line (Iio/3A9) exhibited almost normal positive selection of thymocytes displaying the transgene-encoded receptor. These thymocytes were exported to the periphery: peripheral T cells could respond normally to the appropriate peptide in vitro. The most likely interpretation of these findings is that selection of most CD4+ T cells depends on MHC class II complexes loaded with peptide in an Ii-dependent pathway, but some can be selected on class II complexes that are either loaded along an alternative, Ii-independent, route or are empty. This is consistent with the involvement of peptide in positive selection of CD4+ T cells, for which there exists little prior evidence.

Positive selection of T cells: rescue from programmed cell death and differentiation require continual engagement of the T cell receptor

Positive selection of T cells is a complex developmental process generating long-lived, functionally mature CD4+CD8- and CD4-CD8+ cells from short-lived, immature CD4+CD8+ precursors. The process is initiated in the thymus by interaction of the alpha beta TCR with molecules encoded by the MHC, occurs without cell division, and involves rescue from programmed cell death (PCD), as well as induction of differentiation and maturation of selected precursors. It is unclear whether development of small, positively selected CD4+CD8+ thymocytes (characterized by up-regulated levels of TCR and CD69 molecules) depends on further interactions with MHC molecules and, if so, whether such interactions are required for survival, for maturation, or for both. The involvement of the TCR and/or CD4/CD8 coreceptors in transmitting additional signals is also unknown. We have examined these questions by analyzing survival and differentiation of early (CD4+CD8+TCRhi) and later (CD4-CD8+TCRhi) postselection stages of thymocytes from normal and bcl-2 transgenic mice expressing transgenic, class I MHC-restricted TCR, upon intrathymic transfer into recipients that lacked ligands either for both the TCR and CD8 coreceptor, or for the TCR only. The results provide direct evidence that induction of differentiation of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes by recognition of MHC molecules does not rescue them from PCD and is insufficient to activate the entire maturation program. Both processes require continual engagement of the TCR by positively selecting MHC molecules that, at least in the case of class I MHC-restricted CD4-CD8+ T cells, cannot be substituted by the engagement of coreceptor alone.

A Myc-associated zinc finger protein binding site is one of four important functional regions in the CD4 promoter

The CD4 promoter plays an important role in the developmental control of CD4 transcription. In this report, we show that the minimal CD4 promoter has four factor binding sites, each of which is required for full function. Using biochemical and mutagenesis analyses, we determined that multiple nuclear factors bind to these independent sites. We determined that an initiator-like sequence present at the cap site and an Ets consensus sequence are required for full promoter function. We also demonstrate that the Myc-associated zinc finger protein (MAZ) appears to be the predominant factor binding to one of these sites. This last site closely resembles the ME1a1 G3AG4AG3 motif previously shown to be a critical element in the P2 promoter of the c-myc gene. We therefore believe that the MAZ transcription factor is also likely to play an important role in the control of developmental expression of the CD4 gene.

Stochastic coreceptor shut-off is restricted to the CD4 lineage maturation pathway

Kinetics of mature T cell generation in the thymus of normal or major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I- or II-deficient mice were studied by the bromodeoxyuridine pulse labeling method. As previously described, the early activation and final maturation phases were found to be synchronous for the two T cell lineages, but CD4+8- cells were generated faster than CD4-8+ cells in MHC class I- and II-deficient mice, respectively. CD8 downregulation started on day 2 after cell proliferation even in the absence of MHC class II expression. CD8 downregulation thus appears to be stochastic at its beginning. By contrast, CD4 shut-off was found totally instructive, as the generation of CD4lo8+ cells with a high TCR density was not observed in class I-deficient mice. The analysis of the V beta 14 TCR frequencies in CD4/8 subsets in normal and MHC-deficient mice confirmed that CD4 and CD8 generation pathways are not symmetrical. These findings show that commitment towards the CD4+8- or CD4-8+ phenotype is controlled at the CD8lo step for the former and at the CD4+8+ double-positive stage for the latter.

Intermediate steps in positive selection: differentiation of CD4+8int TCRint thymocytes into CD4-8+TCRhi thymocytes

The differentiation potential of putative intermediates between CD4+8+ thymocytes and mature T cells has been examined. Such intermediate populations were sorted, in parallel with CD4+8+ thymocytes, from three types of C57BL/6 mice: major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II-deficient mice, mice transgenic for an alpha/beta T cell receptor (TCR) restricted by class I MHC and normal mice. The sorted populations were then transferred into the thymus of nonirradiated C57BL/Ka mice differing in Thy 1 allotype, and the progeny of the transferred cells were analyzed 2 d later. Surprisingly, with all three types of donor mice, a major proportion of the CD4+8intTCRint-derived progeny were found to be CD4-8+TCRhi cells, thus delineating a new alternative pathway for development of the CD8 lineage. In contrast, the transfer of CD4int8+TCRint thymocytes produced CD4-8+TCRhi cells but no significant proportion of CD4+8-TCRhi cells, suggesting that there is no equivalent alternative pathway for the CD4 lineage. The results negate some of the evidence for a stochastic/selective model of lineage commitment, and point to an asymmetry in the steps leading to CD4-8+ versus CD4+8- T cells.

Asymmetric signaling requirements for thymocyte commitment to the CD4+ versus CD8+ T cell lineages: a new perspective on thymic commitment and selection

Differentiation of immature CD4+ CD8+ thymocytes into mature CD4+ CD8- and CD4-CD8+ T cells requires that synthesis of one or the other coreceptor molecule be terminated, a process referred to as lineage commitment. The present study has utilized a novel coreceptor reexpression assay to identify lineage commitment in immature thymocytes and has found that the MHC recognition requirements for CD4 commitment and CD8 commitment fundamentally differ from one another. Remarkably, we found that thymocyte commitment to the CD8+ lineage requires MHC class I-dependent instructional signals, whereas thymocyte commitment to the CD4+ lineage is MHC independent and may occur by default. In addition, an unanticipated relationship between lineage commitment and surface phenotype has been identified. These results are incompatible with current concepts and require a new perspective on lineage commitment and positive selection, which we refer to as asymmetric commitment.

Positive selection of T cells

In the past year, significant technical developments have provided the opportunity to investigate the more mechanistic features of positive selection. Major progress has been made in determining the structure and function of the early pre-T cell receptor, in defining cell types that mediate positive selection, and in analyzing the contribution of MHC and co-receptors to CD4/CD8 lineage commitment. The most revealing studies have been those addressing the role of peptides in thymic selection.

Intrathymic T cell receptor (TcR) targeting in mice lacking CD4 or major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II: rescue of CD4 T cell lineage without co-engagement of TcR/CD4 by MHC class II

A critical step during intrathymic T cell development, termed positive selection, is associated with rescue of short-lived, immature thymocytes from programmed cell death, T cell lineage commitment, and induction of lineage-specific differentiation programs. T cell receptor (TcR)-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) interactions during positive selection can be closely mimicked by targeting TcR on immature thymocytes to cortical epithelial cells in situ via hybrid antibodies. Here, we show that antibody-mediated TcR signaling in mice deficient for CD4 or MHC class II expression induces polyclonal differentiation of the CD4 T cell lineage. Following a single TcR signal pulse in situ, a temporal sequence of phenotype changes can be discerned: CD69 up-regulation (< 1 day), CD8 down-regulation, TcR up-regulation (1-1.5 days) and down-regulation of the heat-stable antigen (1.5-2 days). Differentiation of phenotypically and functionally mature CD4 T cells in situ is attained within 3 days. Rescue of CD4 lineage T cells in the absence of TcR/CD4 co-engagement by MHC class II in this experimental system supports the stochastic/selective model of T cell lineage commitment.

Defective T-cell receptor signalling and positive selection of Vav-deficient CD4+ CD8+ thymocytes

During lymphocyte development, cellular proliferation and positive and negative selection events ensure the production of T and B lymphocytes bearing highly diverse, but self-tolerant, repertoires of antigen receptors. These processes are initiated when engagement of growth-factor receptors, or the T and B lymphocyte antigen receptors, induces tyrosine phosphorylation of specific SH2- and SH3-domain-containing cytoplasmic proteins, including Vav. Here we show that vav-/- embryonic stem cells generate only limited numbers of immature and mature T and B lymphocytes in the RAG-2 blastocyst complementation assay. Furthermore, Vav-deficient T lymphocytes showed severely impaired antigen receptor signalling. Finally, we demonstrate that Vav-dependent signalling pathways regulate maturation, but not CD4/CD8 lineage commitment, during T-cell-receptor-mediated positive selection of immature CD4+ CD8+ precursors into mature CD4+ CD8- or CD4- CD8+ T cells.

T cell receptor-mediated signaling events in CD4+CD8+ thymocytes undergoing thymic selection: requirement of calcineurin activation for thymic positive selection but not negative selection

The goal of this study was to identify the differences of intracellular signals between the processes of thymic positive and negative selection. The activation of calcineurin, a calcium- and calmodulin-dependent phosphatase, is known to be an essential event in T cell activation via the T cell receptor (TCR). The effect of FK506, an inhibitor of calcineurin activation, on positive and negative selection in CD4+CD8+ double positive (DP) thymocytes was examined in normal mice and in a TCR transgenic mouse model. In vivo FK506 treatment blocked the generation of mature TCRhighCD4+CD8- and TCRhighCD4-CD8+ thymocytes, and the induction of CD69 expression on DP thymocytes. In addition, the shutdown of recombination activating gene 1 (RAG-1) transcription and the downregulation of CD4 and CD8 expression were inhibited by FK506 treatment suggesting that the activation of calcineurin is required for the first step (or the very early intracellular signaling events) of TCR-mediated positive selection of DP thymocytes. In contrast, FK506-sensitive calcineurin activation did not appear to be required for negative selection based on the observations that negative selection of TCR alpha beta T cells in the H-2b male thymus (a negative selecting environment) was not inhibited by in vivo treatment with FK506 and that there was no rescue of the endogenous superantigen-mediated clonal deletion of V beta 6 and V beta 11 thymocytes in FK506-treated CBA/J mice. DNA fragmentation induced by TCR activation of DP thymocytes in vitro was not affected by FK506. In addition, different effects of FK506 from Cyclosporin A on the T cell development in the thymus were demonstrated. The results of this study suggest that different signaling pathways work in positive and negative selection and that there is a differential dependence on calcineurin activation in the selection processes.

Regional specialization of intraepithelial T cells in the murine small and large intestine

We investigated intraepithelial T cells from the small intestine, SI (jejunum, ileum) and the large intestine, LI (colon) of euthymic (BALB/c, H-2d; C.B-17+/+, H-2d; C57BL/6, H-2b) and athymic (C57BL/6 nu/nu; BNX bg/bg nu/nu xid/xid) mice. From individual euthymic and athymic mice, 7 x 10(6) intraepithelial lymphocytes (IEL) per mouse were isolated from the SI. Ten-fold lower numbers of IEL were obtained from the LI epithelium (4 x 10(5) IEL per mouse). Thymus-dependent and -independent T cells represented > 80% of SI-IEL but the fraction of T cells was reduced from 20% to 40% in LI-IEL. In euthymic mice, alpha beta T cells predominated in SI-IEL and in particular in LI-IEL populations, while SI-IEL and LI-IEL populations of athymic mice contained predominantly gamma delta T cells. The intraepithelial T cell subset distribution was different in SI versus LI: mainly CD8+ T cells were present in the SI, but a large CD4+ T cell subset was present in the LI. 'Double positive' CD4+ CD8 alpha+ T cells were present mainly in the SI epithelium but were rare in the LI epithelium. In euthymic as well as athymic mice, T cells expressing the homodimeric CD8 alpha alpha isoform predominated in the SI epithelium, while T cells expressing the heterodimeric CD8 alpha beta isoform predominated in the LI epithelium. LI-derived TCR alpha beta+ IEL displayed the CD2+ CD28+ LPAM-1/2- M290+ phenotype, and a fraction of them expressed the L-selectin LECAM-1. In contrast, a large fraction of TCR alpha beta+ SI-IEL was CD2- CD28- LPAM-1/2- M290+ and LECAM-1-. RAG-1/2 expression was detectable by RT-PCR in IEL from the SI but not the LI. Striking differences in phenotype were thus apparent between thymus-dependent and thymus-independent T cells in the epithelial layer of the jejunum/ileum and the colon of the mouse.

The function of the CD4 coreceptor in the development of T cells

T cells with helper activity can be found in mice that lack expression of the CD4 glycoprotein. The CD4 promoter is active in these cells; they respond to antigens presented by MHC class II molecules; they do not express CD8 and they do not depend on MHC class I for their development. By such criteria, these CD8- T cells resemble normal CD4+ helper T cells. The development of the helper lineage in CD4-null mice can be potentiated by expression of transgenes that encode either wild type CD4, or a deletion mutant of CD4 that lacks the cytoplasmic tail and therefore cannot interact with the tyrosine kinase p56lck. These observations suggest that CD4 is not absolutely required for the specification of the helper cell lineage. The role of the CD4 molecule in the development of T cells and possible mechanisms by which it achieves its functions are discussed.

The influence of positive selection on RAG expression in thymocytes

The expression of recombination activating gene (RAG) products, responsible for T cell receptor (TcR) gene rearrangement, is shut off during positive selection of thymocytes. The precise stage at which this down-regulation occurs remains somewhat controversial. We have analyzed RAG-1 expression in thymocytes of TcR transgenic mice carried on selecting versus non-selecting genetic backgrounds, both by in situ hybridization on thymus sections and by polymerase chain reaction amplification of RNA from sorted cells. The data from several transgenic lines indicate that RAG expression is already reduced in immature, cortical, CD4+CD8+ cells in the presence of positively selecting major histocompatibility complex molecules, although complete shut-off is not achieved until the mature, medullary, single-positive stage. This finding has practical and theoretical significance for studies on the mechanism of positive selection.

A signal strength hypothesis of thymic selection: preliminary considerations

During their differentiation, thymocytes are subjected to two rounds of selection. First, CD4-8- double-negative (DN) thymocytes with a functional TCR-beta chain express a alpha-beta+ CD3 complex on their surface and, as a consequence, are selected to mature to the CD4+8+ double-positive (DP) stage. This round ends after the initial proliferation of young DP thymocytes and is termed beta-chain selection. Second, DP thymocytes are selected on the basis of their alpha+beta+ CD3 complex. This is termed repertoire selection and the cells are given three choices: death by neglect selection, death by positive selection, or deletion by negative selection. Using anti-CD3 epsilon mAb as invariant ligand, signals for beta-chain selection of DN cells including proliferation of DP cells do not require a Ca2+ response, are independent of CD3 zeta, and are only slightly impaired in the absence of p56lck (lck). Signals that induce positive selection of DP thymocytes require a partial Ca2+ response and CD3 zeta but are independent of lck. Deletion of DP thymocytes requires a full-blown Ca2+ response and both, CD3 zeta and lck. Thymic selection thus appears to be governed by a gradient of signal intensities.

The majority of postselection CD4+ single-positive thymocytes requires the thymus to produce long-lived, functional T cells

We have previously isolated, and characterized in vitro, two subsets of CD4hi T cell receptor (TCR)hi single positive (SP) thymocytes: CD8- and CD8lo. In this report, we have analyzed phenotypic, functional, and developmental characteristics of these "late" CD4hi SP thymocyte subsets. The TCRhi phenotype and the elimination of T cells expressing TCR V beta segments reactive with endogenous mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) products suggested that both subsets had undergone positive and negative selection. CD8-4hi thymocytes were functional, as judged by their ability to: (a) induce lethal graft versus host disease (GVHD); (b) survive and expand in peripheral lymphoid organs; and (c) proliferate, rather than undergo apoptosis, in response to in vitro TCR cross-linking. By contrast, CD8lo4hi cells could not induce GVHD, were unable to expand (and perhaps even survive) in peripheral organs and underwent apoptosis upon TCR cross-linking. However, when reintroduced into the thymus, these cells matured into functional, long-lived CD8-4hi lymphocytes. These results document an obligatory requirement for the thymic microenvironment in the final maturation of the majority of CD4hi SP postselection thymocytes, and demonstrate the existence of a previously unrecognized control point in T cell development.

Altered major histocompatibility complex restriction in the NK1.1+Ly-6Chi autoreactive CD4+ T cell subset from class II-deficient mice

We previously demonstrated selective enrichment of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II-specific autoreactive T cells in a subset of mouse CD4+ thymocytes. Here we show that a significant fraction of these autoreactive cells in the normal adult thymus expresses NK1.1 and high levels of Ly-6C and also exhibits flexibility in MHC restriction. In normal mice, this NK1.1+Ly-6Chi subfraction accounts for 10-50% of the CD4+ autoreactive subset and is enriched for MHC class II-restricted autoreactive cells as determined by mixed leukocyte reaction frequency analysis, similar to NK1.1-Ly-6C-CD4+ autoreactive cells. In contrast, in the thymus of class II-deficient littermate mice, NK1.1+Ly-6Chi cells account for most of the mature heat stable antigen (HSA)-CD4+ fraction and exhibit MHC-restricted non-class II autoreactivity. Thus, NK1.1+Ly-6ChiCD4+ T cells show flexibility in MHC class restriction, but their autoreactivity remains MHC dependent.

Bcl-2 and Bcl-x: regulatory switches for lymphoid death and survival

The survival and death of lymphoid cells is under the control of a genetic program. Cell death is activated at different stages of development and serves to remove unnecessary and autoreactive lymphocytes, as well as to limit the immune response. The survival of cells is regulated by a set of genes that act as repressors of the cell death mechanism. Of these, bcl-2 and bcl-x exhibit a striking pattern of regulation during lymphoid maturation and can inhibit several forms of apoptotic cell death. Here, Gabriel Núñez and colleagues review recent developments in the field, particularly focusing on the role of the Bcl-2 and Bcl-x proteins in regulating lymphoid death and survival.

Bcl-2 expression during T-cell development: early loss and late return occur at specific stages of commitment to differentiation and survival

During T-cell development CD3-CD4-CD8- (double-negative) thymocytes proliferative and produce an enormous number of CD3loCD4+CD8+ (double-positive) thymocytes which are destined to die intrathymically unless rescued by positive selection. Those which survive become mature CD3hiCD4/8+ (single-positive) cells and are the precursor of peripheral blood lymphocytes. The product of the bcl-2 protooncogene has been implicated in preventing programmed cell death and is required for prolonged lymphocyte survival following maturation. Previously we and others have reported that Bcl-2 protein expression is biphasic, being high in proliferating double-negative stem cells, low in all double-positive thymocytes except for 1-5% of these cells, and restored in mature, single-positive thymocytes. However, it remained unclear which signaling and selection events regulate Bcl-2 during T-cell maturation. Now we have utilized four-color flow cytometry in normal and genetically altered mice for a detailed analysis of Bcl-2 expression as it relates to T-cell receptor (TCR) expression and positive selection. These studies show that (i) expression of a transgenic TCR in double-negative thymocytes does not lead to premature loss of Bcl-2; thus, Bcl-2 downregulation is not solely due to TCR expression; (ii) Bcl-2 expression is lost at the early transitional CD3-/loCD4-CD8+ stage, prior to expression of CD4; (iii) the Bcl-2+ double-positive thymocytes are those which have undergone positive selection; and (iv) upregulation of Bcl-2 during positive selection requires participation of the CD4 or CD8 co-receptor. These results demonstrate that Bcl-2 and TCR expression are regulated independently during T-cell development, and suggest a role for the CD4 or CD8 co-receptor in Bcl-2 induction during positive selection.

The balance between deletion and activation of CD4+8+ thymocytes is controlled by T cell receptor-antigen interactions and is affected by cyclosporin A

The sensitivity of immature thymocytes to antigen-induced deletion has been shown to correlate with their differentiation status. By using an in vitro approach we have investigated whether parameters of antigenic stimulation may also affect the response of thymocytes. Two T cell receptor (TcR)-transgenic (Tg) mouse models have been compared, both of which recognize the allo-antigen H-2Kb but are functionally CD8"-dependent" (KB5.C20-Tg) and "-independent" (BM3.3-Tg). Presentation of the antigen H-2Kb on the surface of fibroblasts; to thymocytes in vitro, resulted in the apoptosis of CD4+8+ thymocytes. In contrast to in vivo deletion, in vitro deletion was much greater for KB5.C20-Tg than for BM3.3-Tg. In the absence of engagement of CD8 (using an altered H-2Kb-alpha 3 domain or CD8-specific antibodies), the H-2Kb-induced deletion of CD4+8+ thymocytes was decreased for KB5.C20-Tg, but no change in the pattern of deletion for BM3.3-Tg occurred. CD4+8+ thymocytes which remained viable after in vitro exposure to antigen, were shown to have been activated. Cyclosporin A (CsA), which has been reported to inhibit activation-induced cell death, did not affect antigen-induced deletion of CD4+8+ thymocytes from KB5.C20-Tg. More strikingly, deletion of CD4+8+ thymocytes from BM3.3-Tg increased, whilst activation was partially inhibited by CsA. These results provide direct evidence that presentation of antigen to thymocytes can result in deletion or activation, depending on not only the differentiation status of the cell, but also parameters of TcR-antigen interaction. Additionally, the effects of CsA suggest that activation can prevent the induction of deletion.

Positive selection of CD4+ T cells by TCR ligation without aggregation even in the absence of MHC

The developmental fate of immature thymocytes is determined by the specificity of their T-cell antigen receptors (TCRs). Immature CD4+8+ thymocytes are positively selected to differentiate into mature T cells by recognition of peptides associated with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) encoded molecules on thymic epithelial cells. But neither the identity of molecules transducing positive selection signals nor the nature of the signals themselves is fully known. Here we report that direct ligation of TCR molecules by monoclonal antibodies specific for either clonotypic or CD3 chains can signal immature thymocytes to differentiate into mature CD4+8- T cells, even in the absence of MHC expression and MHC-dependent CD4 co-receptor signalling. Moreover, we show that TCR engagement induces positive selection signals only in the absence of TCR aggregation and that TCR aggregation is inhibitory for positive selection. Thus, low valency of TCR crosslinking is a critical parameter, distinguishing positive selection from other TCR-mediated signalling events.

Evidence for a selective and multi-step model of T cell differentiation: CD4+CD8low thymocytes selected by a transgenic T cell receptor on major histocompatibility complex class I molecules

We have characterized a prominent (15-20%) thymocyte population expressing CD4 at a high and CD8 at a low level (CD4+8lo) in mice transgenic for a T cell receptor (TCR) restricted by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules. The results demonstrate that the CD4+8lo population is an intermediate stage between immature CD4+8+ and end-stage CD4+8- thymocytes and that the survival of these cells crucially depends on the successful interaction of the transgenic TCR with self MHC class I molecules. In addition we demonstrate that the avidity of the interaction between TCR and self MHC class I molecules determines whether CD4+8lo thymocytes are found in significant numbers in this transgenic model. Our findings support a selective and multi-step model of T cell differentiation in the thymus.

An invariant T cell receptor alpha chain is used by a unique subset of major histocompatibility complex class I-specific CD4+ and CD4-8- T cells in mice and humans

The mouse thymus contains a mature T cell subset that is distinguishable from the mainstream thymocytes by several characteristics. It is restricted in its usage of T cell receptor (TCR) V beta genes to V beta 8, V beta 7, and V beta 2. Its surface phenotype is that of activated/memory cells. It carries the natural killer NK1.1 surface marker. Furthermore, though it consists entirely of CD4+ and CD4-8- cells, its selection in the thymus depends solely upon major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I expression by cells of hematopoietic origin. Forced persistence of CD8, in fact, imparts negative selection. Here, we have studied the TCR repertoire of this subset and found that, whereas the beta chain V-D-J junctions are quite variable, a single invariant alpha chain V alpha 14-J281 is used by a majority of the TCRs. This surprisingly restricted usage of the V alpha 14-J281 alpha chain is dependent on MHC class I expression, but independent of the MHC haplotype. In humans, a similar unusual population including CD4-8- cells can also be found that uses a strikingly homologous, invariant alpha chain V alpha 24-JQ. Thus, this unique V alpha-J alpha combination has been conserved in both species, conferring specificity to some shared nonpolymorphic MHC class I/peptide self-ligand(s). This implies that the T cell subset that it defines has a specialized and important role, perhaps related to its unique ability to secrete a large set of lymphokines including interleukin 4, upon primary stimulation in vitro and in vivo.

Discrimination between thymic epithelial cells and peripheral antigen-presenting cells in the induction of immature T cell differentiation

During their intrathymic migration, immature CD4+ CD8+ thymocytes that express a TCR able to recognize the expressed MHC molecules are positively selected, i.e., complete their differentiation program and become mature T cells. Using the immature CD4+CD8+ T cell line DPK, which can be induced to differentiate in culture, we show here that a subset of isolated thymic epithelial cells, but not peripheral antigen-presenting cells, can induce differentiation, suggesting a unique function of these cells in T cell development. In addition, analysis of activation markers induced by thymic epithelial cells versus specific antigen gives the first direct evidence that positive selection is associated with low level cell activation. In contrast with strict affinity-avidity models of thymic selection, we propose that a specialized antigen-presenting cell environment is an essential contributor to TCR-mediated differentiation in the thymus.

A human CD4 transgene rescues CD4-CD8+ cells in beta 2-microglobulin-deficient mice

The specificity of the alpha beta T cell receptor for class I or class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules determines whether a mature T cell will be of the CD4-CD8+ or CD4+CD8- phenotype, respectively. We show here that a human CD4 transgene can rescue a significant fraction of CD4-CD8+ T cells in beta 2-microglobulin-deficient mice. Cells with this phenotype could be induced to become potent killers of targets expressing allogeneic MHC antigens, indicating that lineage commitment can precede the rescue of developing cells by the T cell receptor for antigen and the CD4 coreceptor.

Functional commitment to helper T cell lineage precedes positive selection and is independent of T cell receptor MHC specificity

Thymocyte differentiation proceeds from double positive CD4+CD8+ to single positive T cells. It has been proposed that this process occurs by an instructive or a stochastic mechanism. In this report, we show that in recombination-deficient mice (RAG-1-I-) constitutive expression of a CD8 transgene allows maturation of CD4+(CD8tg+) cells, which express mature levels of a transgenic class I-restricted T cell receptor, F5. Rescued F5+CD4+(CD8tg+) cells have equivalent levels of T cell receptor expression as CD8end+ cells, respond to cognate antigen and, upon stimulation, they exhibit a phenotype characteristic of CD4+ helper T cells. These data are consistent with a model of differentiation that predicts that thymocytes become functionally committed to a helper or cytotoxic lineage before the final step of positive selection and independently of MHC specificity of their T cell receptor.

Disruption of T lymphocyte positive and negative selection in mice lacking the CD8 beta chain

The CD4 and CD8 coreceptors have been shown to play significant roles in the differentiation and activation of helper and cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs), respectively. Coordinate binding of coreceptor and T cell receptor (TCR) to the same major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule and coreceptor interaction with the tyrosine kinase p56lck are required for effective signaling. Whereas CD4 is a monomer, CD8 consists of either alpha alpha homodimers or alpha beta heterodimers. Signaling properties of CD8 have been ascribed to the alpha chain, which binds to both the MHC class I and to p56lck, respectively. To study CD8 beta specifically, we have generated mice defective in its expression. We observe a significant reduction in the numbers of CD8+ T cells, but these cells have normal CTL activity. By breeding CD8 beta null mice with animals expressing a class I-specific TCR transgene, we show that CD8 beta plays a significant role in both positive and negative selection of developing thymocytes.

Thymic selection of CD8+ single positive cells with a class II major histocompatibility complex-restricted receptor

We describe mice that express a transgenic T cell receptor alpha/beta (TCR-alpha/beta) specific for peptide 111-119 from influenza hemagglutinin presented by I-Ed class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. The transgenic TCR is expressed on CD4+8- as well as CD4-8+ mature T cells even in mice that are deficient in rearrangement or do not express endogenous TCR-alpha genes. The CD4-8+ T cells require I-Ed class II MHC molecules for positive selection and can be activated to proliferate and to kill by I-Ed molecules presenting the relevant peptide. Full maturation of these cells, however, also requires the presence of class I MHC molecules. The results are compatible with the notion that T cell maturation requires multiple receptor-ligand interactions and establish an exception to the rule that class II-restricted TCRs are exclusively expressed by mature CD4+8- cells.

Class I dependence of the development of CD4+ CD8- NK1.1+ thymocytes

A small subset of functionally active CD4+ CD8- thymocytes express the NK1.1 marker, as do most CD4-CD8- NK1.1+ thymocytes. Previous studies have failed to implicate a role for major histocompatibility complex (MHC) or related molecules in the selection of the CD4+ CD8- NK1.1+ subset. We report here that the development of most of these cells is sharply reduced in class I-deficient mice, but not in class II-deficient mice. Hence, some CD4+ T cells are class I dependent and not class II dependent. Unlike conventional T cells, however, the development of NK1.1+ thymocytes in both the CD4+ CD8- and CD4- CD8- subsets is dependent on class I MHC expression by hematopoietic cells and not thymic epithelial cells. We propose that these populations are selected by nonpolymorphic class Ib or CD1 molecules.

Constitutive CD8 expression allows inefficient maturation of CD4+ helper T cells in class II major histocompatibility complex mutant mice

Although mature CD4+ T cells bear T cell receptors (TCRs) that recognize class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and mature CD8+ T cells bear TCRs that recognize class I MHC, it is possible that the initial commitment of an immature thymocyte to a CD4 or CD8 lineage is made without regard to the specificity of the TCR. According to this model, CD4+ cells with class I TCR do not mature because the CD8 coreceptor is required for class I MHC recognition and positive selection. If this model is correct, constitutive expression of CD8 should allow CD4+ T cells with class I-specific TCRs to develop. In this report, we show that mature peripheral CD4+ cells are present in class II MHC-deficient mice that express a constitutive CD8.1 transgene. These cells share a number of properties with the major class II MHC-selected CD4 population, including the ability to express CD40 ligand upon activation. Although mature CD4 cells are also detectable in the thymus of class II MHC mutant/CD8.1 transgenic mice, they represent a small fraction of the mature CD4 cells found in mice that express class II MHC. These results indicate that some T cells choose the CD4 helper lineage independent of their antigen receptor specificity; however, the inefficiency of generating class I-specific CD4 cells leaves open the possibility that an instructive signal generated upon MHC recognition may bias lineage commitment.

Bcl-2 is upregulated at the CD4+ CD8+ stage during positive selection and promotes thymocyte differentiation at several control points

In vivo thymocyte maturation models were used to investigate the differentiation role of Bcl-2. In alpha/beta T cell receptor (TCR) class II-restricted transgenic mice, Bcl-2 was upregulated at the CD4+ CD8+ stage during positive selection. The lckpr-bcl2 transgene was bred onto MHC classes I-I- and II-I-, MHC-I-, and alpha/beta TCR backgrounds to determine whether Bcl-2 promoted thymocyte maturation in the absence of coreceptor-MHC interaction. Bcl-2 rescued CD8+ thymocytes in class I-I- and alpha/beta TCR in mice; however, they were not exported to the periphery. Bcl-2 had no effect on CD4 lineage maturation in class II-I- mice. No single-positive thymocytes accumulate in MHC-I- mice despite overexpressed Bcl-2. Thus, Bcl-2 enables selection of certain TCRs on class II molecules and their differentiation along the CD8 pathway; however, Bcl-2 did not substitute for positive selection. In RAG-1-I- mice, Bcl-2 promoted differentiation to the CD4+ CD8+ stage. Bcl-2 can promote thymocyte maturation at several control points.

Constitutive activation of integrin alpha 4 beta 1 defines a unique stage of human thymocyte development

Our understanding of thymocyte development and of the positive and negative selection events involved in shaping the repertoire of mature T lymphocytes has been greatly facilitated by the use of transgenic and gene knockout animals. Much less is known about the factors that control the homing and population of the thymus by T cell precursors and the subsequent migration of developing thymocytes through the thymic architecture. As the integrins represent a candidate group of cell surface receptors that may regulate thymocyte development, we have analyzed the expression and function of alpha 4 beta 1 and alpha 5 beta 1 on human thymocytes. A major portion of double positive (CD4+ CD8+) human thymocytes express alpha 4 beta 1 in a constitutively active form and adhere to fibronectin and vascular cell adhesion molecule 1. alpha 4 beta 1 expression is similar on adherent and nonadherent populations, thus, activity reflects the receptor state and not simple expression. The adherent cells are immature, expressing high levels of CD4/CD8 and low levels of CD3 and CD69. In contrast, nonadherent cells possess the phenotype of thymocytes after positive selection, expressing intermediate levels of CD4 and/or CD8 and high levels of CD3 and CD69. The adherent population fails to respond to activation with anti-CD3 and fibronectin, whereas nonadherents exhibit an alpha 5 beta 1-dependent proliferation. Differential regulation of alpha 4 beta 1 and alpha 5 beta 1 receptors may provide a mechanism controlling cellular traffic, differentiation, and positive selection of thymocytes.

Early progression of thymocytes along the CD4/CD8 developmental pathway is regulated by a subset of thymic epithelial cells expressing transforming growth factor beta

Precursor cells differentiate into mature CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in the inductive environment of the thymus by undergoing a series of distinct developmental steps marked by expression of the coreceptor molecules CD4 and CD8. Among the earliest cells to enter the CD4/CD8 developmental pathway are CD4-CD8lo precursors cells that differentiate into CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. Here we show that differentiation of precursor cells into CD4+CD8+ thymocytes requires at least one cell division and that their progression through a cell cycle is specifically retarded in the thymus by interaction with thymic epithelial cells that express transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) proteins. We also demonstrate that TGF-beta proteins, either in solution or bound to cell membranes, can regulate cell cycle progression and differentiation of CD4-CD8lo precursor cells into CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. The regulatory effect of TGF-beta is specific for CD4-CD8lo precursor cells as TGF-beta proteins do not regulate the earlier generation of CD4-CD8lo precursor cells from CD4-CD8- thymocytes. Finally, we demonstrate that TGF-beta proteins are expressed in vivo in the intact thymus on subcapsular and cortical thymic epithelium where they can contact developing CD4-CD8lo precursor cells. Thus, thymic epithelial cells expressing TGF-beta proteins can actively regulate the rate at which CD4+CD8+ thymocytes are generated from CD4-CD8lo precursor cells.

Human CD4 restores normal T cell development and function in mice deficient in murine CD4

The ability of a human coreceptor to function in mice was investigated by generating human CD4 (hCD4)-expressing transgenic mice on a mouse CD4-deficient (mCD4-/-) background. From developing thymocyte to matured T lymphocyte functions, hCD4 was shown to be physiologically active. By examining the expansion and deletion of specific V beta T cell families in mutated mice with and without hCD4, it was found that hCD4 can participate in positive and negative selection. Mature hCD4 single positive cells also were found in the periphery and they were shown to restore MHC class II-restricted alloreactive and antigen-specific T cell responses that were deficient in the mCD4 (-/-) mice. In addition, these hCD4 reconstituted mice can generate a secondary immunoglobulin G humoral response matching that of mCD4 wild-type mice. The fact that human CD4 is functional in mice and can be studied in the absence of murine CD4 should facilitate studies of human CD4 activity in general and human immunodeficiency virus 1 gp120-mediated pathogenesis in acquired immune deficiency syndrome specifically.

Thymocyte lineage commitment: is it instructed or stochastic?

Thymocytes co-expressing the CD4 and CD8 co-receptors differentiate into mature T cells that express either CD4 or CD8 and have helper or cytotoxic functions, respectively. Recent studies indicate that commitment to the CD4+ or CD8+ lineages occurs stochastically, but retention of the appropriate co-receptor is required to complete development.

Signaling mechanisms in thymocyte selection

The processes known as positive and negative selection that determine the fate of T and B cells depend on finely tuned interactions between the T-cell receptor complex, CD4 or CD8 co-receptors, and a peptide-MHC complex. New work indicates that the avidity of this interaction is critical in the determination of its outcome. The effects of these interactions on developing thymocytes are also a function of the unique activation properties with which thymocytes are programmed just before they undergo selection.

A subset of CD4+ thymocytes selected by MHC class I molecules

To complete their maturation, most immature thymocytes depend on the simultaneous engagement of their antigen receptor [alpha beta T cell receptor (TCR)] and their CD4 or CD8 coreceptors with major histocompatibility complex class II or I ligands, respectively. However, a normal subset of mature alpha beta TCR+ thymocytes did not follow these rules. These thymocytes expressed NK1.1 and a restricted set of alpha beta TCRs that are intrinsically class I-reactive because their positive selection was class I-dependent but CD8-independent. These cells were CD4+ and CD4-8- but never CD8+, because the presence of CD8 caused negative selection. Thus, neither CD4 nor CD8 contributes signals that direct their maturation into the CD4+ and CD4-8- lineages.