Estimation of the pore size of the large-conductance mechanosensitive ion channel of Escherichia coli

Channels in microbes: so many holes to fill

Among players in neurobiology, ion channels are the demigods that underlie all our senses, behaviour and intelligence. In animals, these 'gated pores' detect ligands, voltage, heat or stretch forces and emit electric or ionic signals. Patch clamp and genome sequencing now show that nearly all microbes also have these 'smart' molecules. Microbial channel proteins have yielded crystal structures so dear to neuroscientists. However, their natural roles in microbial physiology remain largely unknown. The intellectual and technical schisms between 'neuro' and 'micro' biology must be bridged before we know how we became so smart, and whether microbes are just as smart.

Lipid bilayer pressure profiles and mechanosensitive channel gating

The function of membrane proteins often depends on the proteins' interaction with their lipid environment, spectacularly so in the case of mechanosensitive channels, which are gated through tension mediated by the surrounding lipids. Lipid bilayer tension is distributed quite inhomogeneously, but neither the scale at which relevant variation takes place nor the effect of varying lipid composition or tension has yet been investigated in atomic detail. We calculated lateral pressure profile distributions in lipid bilayers of various composition from all-atom molecular dynamics simulations totaling 110.5 ns in length. Reproducible pressure profile features at the 1 A length scale were determined. Lipids with phosphatidylcholine headgroups were found to shift the lateral pressure out of the hydrophobic core and into the headgroup region by an amount that is independent of area per lipid. POPE bilayers simulated at areas smaller than optimal exerted dramatically higher lateral pressure in a narrow region at the start of the aliphatic chain. Stretching of POPC bilayers increased tension predominantly in the same region. A simple geometric analysis for the gating of the mechanosensitive channel MscL suggests that pressure profiles affect its gating through the second moment of the profile in a tension-independent manner.

Cysteine scanning of MscL transmembrane domains reveals residues critical for mechanosensitive channel gating

The mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL), a bacterial channel, is perhaps the best characterized mechanosensitive protein. A structure of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis ortholog has been solved by x-ray crystallography, but details of how the channel gates remain obscure. Here, cysteine scanning was used to identify residues within the transmembrane domains of Escherichia coli MscL that are crucial for normal function. Utilizing genetic screens, we identified several mutations that induced gain-of-function or loss-of-function phenotypes in vivo. Mutants that exhibited the most severe phenotypes were further characterized using electrophysiological techniques and chemical modifications of the substituted cysteines. Our results verify the importance of residues in the putative primary gate in the first transmembrane domain, corroborate other residues previously noted as critical for normal function, and identify new ones. In addition, evaluation of disulfide bridging in native membranes suggests alterations of existing structural models for the "fully closed" state of the channel.

Loss-of-function mutations at the rim of the funnel of mechanosensitive channel MscL

MscL is a bacterial mechanosensitive channel that is activated directly by membrane stretch. Although the gene has been cloned and the crystal structure of the closed channel has been defined, how membrane tension causes conformational changes in MscL remains largely unknown. To identify the site where MscL senses membrane tension, we examined the function of the mutants generated by random and scanning mutagenesis. In vitro (patch-clamp) and in vivo (hypoosmotic-shock) experiments showed that when a hydrophilic amino acid replaces one of the hydrophobic residues that are thought to make contact with the membrane lipid near the periplasmic end of the M1 or M2 transmembrane domain, MscL loses the ability to open in response to membrane tension. Hydrophilic (asparagine) substitution of the other residues in the lipid-protein interface did not impair the channel's mechanosensitivity. These observations suggest that the disturbance of the hydrophobic interaction between the membrane lipid and the periplasmic rim of the channel's funnel impairs the function of MscL.

Genetic Models of Mechanotransduction: The NematodeCaenorhabditis elegans

Mechanotransduction, the conversion of a mechanical stimulus into a biological response, constitutes the basis for a plethora of fundamental biological processes such as the senses of touch, balance, and hearing and contributes critically to development and homeostasis in all organisms. Despite this profound importance in biology, we know remarkably little about how mechanical input forces delivered to a cell are interpreted to an extensive repertoire of output physiological responses. Recent, elegant genetic and electrophysiological studies have shown that specialized macromolecular complexes, encompassing mechanically gated ion channels, play a central role in the transformation of mechanical forces into a cellular signal, which takes place in mechanosensory organs of diverse organisms. These complexes are highly efficient sensors, closely entangled with their surrounding environment. Such association appears essential for proper channel gating and provides proximity of the mechanosensory apparatus to the source of triggering mechanical energy. Genetic and molecular evidence collected in model organisms such as the nematode worm Caenorhabditis elegans, the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster, and the mouse highlight two distinct classes of mechanically gated ion channels: the degenerin (DEG)/epithelial Na+channel (ENaC) family and the transient receptor potential (TRP) family of ion channels. In addition to the core channel proteins, several other potentially interacting molecules have in some cases been identified, which are likely parts of the mechanotransducing apparatus. Based on cumulative data, a model of the sensory mechanotransducer has emerged that encompasses our current understanding of the process and fulfills the structural requirements dictated by its dedicated function. It remains to be seen how general this model is and whether it will withstand the impiteous test of time.

Defining the physical gate of a mechanosensitive channel, MscL, by engineering metal-binding sites

The mechanosensitive channel of large conductance, MscL, of Escherichia coli is one of the best-studied mechanosensitive proteins. Although the structure of the closed or "nearly-closed" state of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis ortholog has been solved and mechanisms of gating have been proposed, the transition from the closed to the open states remains controversial. Here, we probe the relative position of specific residues predicted to line the pore of MscL in either the closed state or during the closed-to-open transition by engineering single-site histidine substitutions and assessing the ability of Ni2+, Cd2+ or Zn2+ ions to affect channel activity. All residues predicted to be within the pore led to a change in channel threshold pressure, although the direction and extent of this change were dependent upon the mutation and metal used. One of the MscL mutants, L19H, exhibited gating that was inhibited by Cd2+ but stimulated by Ni2+, suggesting that these metals bind to and influence different states of the channel. Together, the results derived from this study support the hypotheses that the crystal structure depicts a "nearly closed" rather than a "fully closed" state of MscL, and that a clockwise rotation of transmembrane domain 1 occurs early in the gating process.

Thermodynamic and Kinetic Stability of Synthetic Multifunctional Rigid-Rod β-Barrel Pores: Evidence for Supramolecular Catalysis

The lessons learned from p-octiphenyl beta-barrel pores are applied to the rational design of synthetic multifunctional pore 1 that is unstable but inert, two characteristics proposed to be ideal for practical applications. Nonlinear dependence on monomer concentration provided direct evidence that pore 1 is tetrameric (n = 4.0), unstable, and "invisible," i.e., incompatible with structural studies by conventional methods. The long lifetime of high-conductance single pores in planar bilayers demonstrated that rigid-rod beta-barrel 1 is inert and large (d approximately 12 A). Multifunctionality of rigid-rod beta-barrel 1 was confirmed by adaptable blockage of pore host 1 with representative guests in planar (8-hydroxy-1,3,6-pyrenetrisulfonate, KD = 190 microM, n = 4.9) and spherical bilayers (poly-L-glutamate, KD < or = 105 nM, n = 1.0; adenosine triphosphate, KD = 240 microM, n = 2.0) and saturation kinetics for the esterolysis of a representative substrate (8-acetoxy-1,3,6-pyrenetrisulfonate, KM = 0.6 microM). The thermodynamic instability of rigid-rod beta-barrel 1 provided unprecedented access to experimental evidence for supramolecular catalysis (n = 3.7). Comparison of the obtained kcat = 0.03 min(-1) with the kcat approximately 0.18 min(-1) for stable analogues gave a global KD approximately 39 microM3 for supramolecular catalyst 1 with a monomer/barrel ratio approximately 20 under experimental conditions. The demonstrated "invisibility" of supramolecular multifunctionality identified molecular modeling as an attractive method to secure otherwise elusive insights into structure. The first molecular mechanics modeling (MacroModel, MMFF94) of multifunctional rigid-rod beta-barrel pore hosts 1 with internal 1,3,6-pyrenetrisulfonate guests is reported.

Multiple paths for nonphysiological transport of K+ in Escherichia coli

Mutants of Escherichia coli lacking all of the known saturable K+ transport systems, "triple mutants," require elevated K+ concentrations for growth. K+ transport activity in such mutants, called TrkF activity, has low substrate specificity and a low rate that increases with increasing external pH. Attempts to isolate mutants requiring even higher concentrations of K+ failed, implying that either TrkF is essential or is composed of multiple minor K+ transport activities. Instead, we sought mutations that allowed triple mutants to grow at lower K+ concentrations. Mutations so identified include ones altering MscL, the large mechanosensitive channel, or Opp, the oligopeptide permease. However, a possible contribution of wild-type Opp and MscL to TrkF activity was not proven. In contrast, expression of wild-type ProP, TrkG, and TrkH proteins increased uptake when encoded on multicopy plasmids. In all of these situations, the driving force for K+ appeared to be the transmembrane electric potential, and in most cases substrate specificity was low; these are characteristics of TrkF activity. These results support the view that TrkF is composed of multiple, "aberrant" K+ transport activities, i.e., paths that, regardless of their physiological function, allow K+ to cross the cell membrane by a uniport process.

An in vivo assay identifies changes in residue accessibility on mechanosensitive channel gating

MscL is a mechanosensitive channel of large conductance that functions as an "emergency release valve," allowing bacteria to survive acute hypoosmotic stress. Although Escherichia coli MscL is the best-studied mechanosensitive channel, structural rearrangements occurring during gating remain disputed. Introduction of a charged residue into the pore of MscL was shown to result in a reduced-viability phenotype. Here, we probe for residues in the transmembrane domains that are exposed to the aqueous environment in the presence and absence of hypoosmotic shock by reacting a charged sulfhydryl reagent with substituted cysteines. Subsequent analysis of cell viability allows for an assessment of residues exposed in the closed and opening states in vivo. The results suggest that the crystal structure of MscL derived from the Mycobacterium tuberculosis orthologue may reflect a nearly closed rather than fully closed state and support a clockwise rotation of the pore-forming first transmembrane domain on gating.

Gating of MscL studied by steered molecular dynamics

Steered molecular dynamics simulations of the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance, MscL, were used to investigate how forces arising from membrane tension induce gating of the channel. A homology model of the closed form of MscL from Escherichia coli was subjected to external forces of 35-70 pN applied to residues near the membrane-water interface. The magnitude and location of these forces corresponded to those determined from the lateral pressure profile computed from a lipid bilayer simulation. A fully expanded state was obtained on the 10-ns timescale that revealed the mechanism for transducing membrane forces into channel opening. The expanded state agrees well with proposed models of MscL gating, in that it entails an irislike expansion of the pore accompanied by tilting of the transmembrane helices. The channel was most easily opened when force was applied predominantly on the cytoplasmic side of MscL. Comparison of simulations in which gating progressed to varying degrees identified residues that pose steric hindrance to channel opening.

Probing the pore of the auditory hair cell mechanotransducer channel in turtle

Hair cell mechano-electric transducer (MET) channels play a pivotal role in auditory and vestibular signal detection, yet few data exist regarding their molecular nature. Present work characterizes the MET channel pore, a region whose properties are thought to be intrinsically determined. Two approaches were used. First, the channel was probed with antagonists of candidate channel subtypes including: cyclic nucleotide-gated channels, transient receptor potential channels and gap-junctional channels. Eight new antagonists were identified. Most of the effective antagonists had a partially charged amine group predicted to penetrate the channel pore, antagonizing current flow, while the remainder of the molecule prevented further permeation of the compound through the pore. This blocking mechanism was tested using curare to demonstrate the open channel nature of the block and by identifying methylene blue as a permeant channel blocker. The second approach estimated dimensions of the channel pore with simple amine compounds. The narrowest diameter of the pore was calculated as 12.5 +/- 0.8 A and the location of a binding site approximately 45% of the way through the membrane electric field was calculated. Channel length was estimated as approximately 31 A and the width of the pore mouth at < 17 A. Each effective antagonist had a minimal diameter, measured about the penetrating amine, of less than the pore diameter, with a direct correlation between IC(50) and minimal diameter. The IC(50) was also directly related to the length of the amine side chains, further validating the proposed pore blocking mechanism. Data provided by these two approaches support a hypothesis regarding channel permeation and block that incorporates molecular dimensions and ion interactions within the pore.

Purification and functional reconstitution of N- and C-halves of the MscL channel

MscL is a mechanosensitive channel gated by membrane tension in the lipid bilayer alone. Its structure, known from x-ray crystallography, indicates that it is a homopentamer. Each subunit comprises two transmembrane segments TM1 and TM2 connected by a periplasmic loop. The closed pore is lined by five TM1 helices. We expressed in Escherichia coli and purified two halves of the protein, each containing one of the transmembrane segments. Their electrophysiological activity was studied by the patch-clamp recording upon reconstitution in artificial liposomes. The TM2 moiety had no electrophysiological activity, whereas the TM1 half formed channels, which were not affected by membrane tension and varied in conductance between 50 and 350 pS in 100 mM KCl. Coreconstitution of the two halves of MscL however, yielded mechanosensitive channels having the same conductance as the native MscL (1500 pS), but exhibiting increased sensitivity to pressure. Our results confirm the current view on the functional role of TM1 and TM2 helices in the MscL gating and emphasize the importance of helix-helix interactions for the assembly and functional properties of the channel protein. In addition, the results indicate a crucial role of the periplasmic loop for the channel mechanosensitivity.

Mechanosensitive channels: multiplicity of families and gating paradigms

Mechanosensitive ion channels are the primary transducers that convert mechanical force into an electrical or chemical signal in hearing, touch, and other mechanical senses. Unlike vision, olfaction, and some types of taste, which all use similar kinds of primary heterotrimeric GTP-binding protein-coupled receptors, mechanosensation relies on diverse types of transducer molecules. Unrelated types of channels can be used for the perception of various mechanical stimuli, not only in distant groups of organisms, but also in separate locations of the same organism. The extreme sensitivity of the transduction mechanism in the auditory system, which relies on an elaborate structure of rigid cilia, filamentous links, and molecular motors to focus force on transduction channels, contrasts with that of the bacterial channel MscL, which is opened by high lateral tension in the membrane and fulfills a safety-valve rather than a sensory function. The spatial scales of conformational movement and force in these two systems are described, and are shown to be consistent with a general physical description of mechanical channel gating. We outline the characteristics of several types of mechanosensitive channels and the functional contexts in which they participate in signaling and cellular regulation in sensory and nonsensory cells.

Crystal structure of coproporphyrinogen III oxidase reveals cofactor geometry of Radical SAM enzymes

'Radical SAM' enzymes generate catalytic radicals by combining a 4Fe-4S cluster and S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) in close proximity. We present the first crystal structure of a Radical SAM enzyme, that of HemN, the Escherichia coli oxygen-independent coproporphyrinogen III oxidase, at 2.07 A resolution. HemN catalyzes the essential conversion of coproporphyrinogen III to protoporphyrinogen IX during heme biosynthesis. HemN binds a 4Fe-4S cluster through three cysteine residues conserved in all Radical SAM enzymes. A juxtaposed SAM coordinates the fourth Fe ion through its amide nitrogen and carboxylate oxygen. The SAM sulfonium sulfur is near both the Fe (3.5 A) and a neighboring sulfur of the cluster (3.6 A), allowing single electron transfer from the 4Fe-4S cluster to the SAM sulfonium. SAM is cleaved yielding a highly oxidizing 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical. HemN, strikingly, binds a second SAM immediately adjacent to the first. It may thus successively catalyze two propionate decarboxylations. The structure of HemN reveals the cofactor geometry required for Radical SAM catalysis and sets the stage for the development of inhibitors with antibacterial function due to the uniquely bacterial occurrence of the enzyme.

Dynamical properties of the MscL of Escherichia coli: a normal mode analysis

The mechanosensitive channel (MscL) is an integral membrane protein which gates in response to membrane tension. Physiological data have shown that the gating transition involves a very large change in the conformation, and that the open state of the channel forms a large non-specific pore with a high conductance. The Escherichia coli channel structure was first modeled by homology modeling, starting with the X-ray structure of the homologous from Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Then, the dynamical and conformational properties of the channel were explored, using normal mode analysis. Such an analysis was also performed with the different structures proposed recently by Sukharev and co-workers. Similar dynamical behaviors are observed, which are characteristic of the channel architecture, subtle differences being due to the different relative positioning of the structural elements. The ability of particular regions of the channel to deform is discussed with respect to the functional and structural properties, implied in the gating process. Our results show that the first step of the gating mechanism can be described with three low-frequency modes only. The movement associated to these modes is clearly an iris-like movement involving both tilt and twist rotation.

Investigating lipid composition effects on the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL) using molecular dynamics simulations

Previous experimental work has shown that the functional properties of the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL) are affected by variations in lipid composition. Here, we utilize molecular dynamics simulations of Mycobacterium tuberculosis MscL to investigate such lipid composition effects on a molecular level. In particular, two sets of simulations were performed. In the first, trajectories using lipids with different headgroups (phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine) were compared. Protein-lipid interactions were clearly altered by the headgroup changes, leading to conformational differences in the C-terminal region of M. tuberculosis MscL. In the second set of simulations, lipid tails were gradually shortened, thinning the membrane over a molecular dynamics trajectory. These simulations showed evidence of hydrophobic matching between MscL and the lipid membrane, as previously proposed. For all simulations, protein-lipid interaction energies in the second transmembrane region were correlated to mutagenic data, emphasizing the importance of lipid interactions for proper MscL function.

Structure and mechanism in prokaryotic mechanosensitive channels

Mechanosensitive channels function as electromechanical switches with the capability to sense the physical state of lipid bilayers. The X-ray crystal structures of MscL and MscS offer a unique opportunity to identify the types of protein motions associated with the opening and closing of these structurally unrelated channels, while providing the framework to address a mechanism of tension sensing that is defined by channel-lipid interactions. Recent functional, structural and dynamic data offer fresh insights into the molecular basis of gating for these membrane proteins.

Generation and evaluation of a large mutational library from the Escherichia coli mechanosensitive channel of large conductance, MscL: implications for channel gating and evolutionary design

Random mutagenesis of the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL) from Escherichia coli coupled with a high-throughput functional screen has provided new insights into channel structure and function. Complementary interactions of conserved residues proposed in a computational model for gating have been evaluated, and important functional regions of the channel have been identified. Mutational analysis shows that the proposed S1 helix, despite having several highly conserved residues, can be heavily mutated without significantly altering channel function. The pattern of mutations that make MscL more difficult to gate suggests that MscL senses tension with residues located near the lipid headgroups of the bilayer. The range of phenotypical changes seen has implications for a proposed model for the evolutionary origin of mechanosensitive channels.

Complementary characteristics of homologous p-octiphenyl beta-barrels with ion channel and esterase activity

We report that decreasing beta-sheet length in homologous multifunctional rigid-rod beta-barrels with internal histidines increases ion channel stability by three orders of magnitude, reduces binding activity by four orders of magnitude, and reduces esterase activity up to 22-times. These results are further used to evaluate methods employed to characterize suprastructure and activity of synthetic multifunctional pores formed by p-octiphenyl beta-barrels with emphasis on applicability of the Hille model to determine internal diameters and the Woodhull equation to locate internal active sites.

Open-state disulfide crosslinking between Mycobacterium tuberculosis mechanosensitive channel subunits

The mechanosensitive channel of large conductance from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Tb-MscL) was subjected to cysteine-scanning mutagenesis at several residues in the M1 region. The V15C channel displayed disulfide crosslinking in air, but not in the presence of 100 mM beta-mercaptoethanol. In single-channel experiments, the V15C channel was more sensitive to tension than was wild-type Tb-MscL. In air, Tb-MscL V15C occasionally displayed signature-events: at constant tension, there was first a sojourn in the highest conductance open state, then a series of transitions to substates. During a signature-event, these transitions do not appear to be reversible. Some sojourns in the lower conductance states lasted for > or =100 s. These signature-events were abolished by 100 mM beta-mercaptoethanol and did not occur in a cysteineless gain-of-function mutant, suggesting that the signature-events represent disulfide crosslinking between channel subunits. We conclude that the crosslinking occurs during an open state during asymmetric sojourns that bring the alpha-carbons of adjacent 15C side chains within 3.6-6.8 A. Such asymmetric structures must be considered in models of TB-MscL gating.

Molecular mechanisms of mechanosensation: big lessons from small cells

Little is known of molecular mechanisms of human mechanosensation. Only now are candidate eukaryotic sensors being identified. In contrast, bacterial sensors, including mechanosensitive channels, have been cloned, sequenced, reconstituted, and functional mutants characterized. Moreover, crystal structures for bacterial mechanosensitive channels have been resolved and structural gating transitions predicted. These studies give clues to general principles underlying the ability of a membrane protein to sense and respond to perturbations of its lipid environment that may be conserved between bacteria and humans.

On the conformation of the COOH-terminal domain of the large mechanosensitive channel MscL

COOH-terminal (S3) domains are conserved within the MscL family of bacterial mechanosensitive channels, but their function remains unclear. The X-ray structure of MscL from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (TbMscL) revealed cytoplasmic domains forming a pentameric bundle (Chang, G., R.H. Spencer, A.T. Lee, M.T. Barclay, and D.C. Rees. 1998. SCIENCE: 282:2220-2226). The helices, however, have an unusual orientation in which hydrophobic sidechains face outside while charged residues face inside, possibly due to specific crystallization conditions. Based on the structure of pentameric cartilage protein, we modeled the COOH-terminal region of E. coli MscL to better satisfy the hydrophobicity criteria, with sidechains of conserved aliphatic residues all inside the bundle. Molecular dynamic simulations predicted higher stability for this conformation compared with one modeled after the crystal structure of TbMscL, and suggested distances for disulfide trapping experiments. The single cysteine mutants L121C and I125C formed dimers under ambient conditions and more so in the presence of an oxidant. The double-cysteine mutants, L121C/L122C and L128C/L129C, often cross-link into tetrameric and pentameric structures, consistent with the new model. Patch-clamp examination of these double mutants under moderately oxidizing or reducing conditions indicated that the bundle cross-linking neither prevents the channel from opening nor changes thermodynamic parameters of gating. Destabilization of the bundle by replacing conservative leucines with small polar residues, or complete removal of COOH-terminal domain (Delta110-136 mutation), increased the occupancy of subconducting states but did not change gating parameters substantially. The Delta110-136 truncation mutant was functional in in vivo osmotic shock assays; however, the amount of ATP released into the shock medium was considerably larger than in controls. The data strongly suggest that in contrast to previous gating models (Sukharev, S., M. Betanzos, C.S. Chiang, and H.R. Guy. 2001a. NATURE: 409:720-724.), S3 domains are stably associated in both closed and open conformations. The bundle-like assembly of cytoplasmic helices provides stability to the open conformation, and may function as a size-exclusion filter at the cytoplasmic entrance to the MscL pore, preventing loss of essential metabolites.

Open channel structure of MscL and the gating mechanism of mechanosensitive channels

Mechanosensitive channels act as membrane-embedded mechano-electrical switches, opening a large water-filled pore in response to lipid bilayer deformations. This process is critical to the response of living organisms to direct physical stimulation, such as in touch, hearing and osmoregulation. Here, we have determined the structural rearrangements that underlie these events in the large prokaryotic mechanosensitive channel (MscL) using electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy and site-directed spin labelling. MscL was trapped in both the open and in an intermediate closed state by modulating bilayer morphology. Transition to the intermediate state is characterized by small movements in the first transmembrane helix (TM1). Subsequent transitions to the open state are accompanied by massive rearrangements in both TM1 and TM2, as shown by large increases in probe dynamics, solvent accessibility and the elimination of all intersubunit spin-spin interactions. The open state is highly dynamic, supporting a water-filled pore of at least 25 A, lined mostly by TM1. These structures suggest a plausible molecular mechanism of gating in mechanosensitive channels.

The alpha-helix and the organization and gating of channels

The structures of an increasing number of channels and other alpha-helical membrane proteins have been determined recently, including the KcsA potassium channel, the MscL mechanosensitive channel, and the AQP1 and GlpF members of the aquaporin family. In this chapter, the orientation and packing characteristics of bilayer-spanning helices are surveyed in integral membrane proteins. In the case of channels, alpha-helices create the sealed barrier that separates the hydrocarbon region of the bilayer from the permeation pathway for solutes. The helices surrounding the permeation pathway tend to be rather steeply tilted relative to the membrane normal and are consistently arranged in a right-handed bundle. The helical framework further provides a supporting scaffold for nonmembrane-spanning structures associated with channel selectivity. Although structural details remain scarce, the conformational changes associated with gating transitions between closed and open states of channels are reviewed, emphasizing the potential roles of helix-helix interactions in this process.

A high-throughput screen for MscL channel activity and mutational phenotyping

A novel fluorescence-based screen for bacterial mechanosensitive ion-channel activity has been developed. This assay is capable of clearly distinguishing the previously observed gain of function and loss of function phenotypes for the Escherichia coli mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (Ec-MscL). The method modifies Molecular Probes' Live/Dead BacLight bacterial viability assay to monitor MscL channel activity as a function of bacterial survival from osmotic downshock.

Structural models of the MscL gating mechanism

Three-dimensional structural models of the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance, MscL, from the bacteria Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Escherichia coli were developed for closed, intermediate, and open conformations. The modeling began with the crystal structure of M. tuberculosis MscL, a homopentamer with two transmembrane alpha-helices, M1 and M2, per subunit. The first 12 N-terminal residues, not resolved in the crystal structure, were modeled as an amphipathic alpha-helix, called S1. A bundle of five parallel S1 helices are postulated to form a cytoplasmic gate. As membrane tension induces expansion, the tilts of M1 and M2 are postulated to increase as they move away from the axis of the pore. Substantial expansion is postulated to occur before the increased stress in the S1 to M1 linkers pulls the S1 bundle apart. During the opening transition, the S1 helices and C-terminus amphipathic alpha-helices, S3, are postulated to dock parallel to the membrane surface on the perimeter of the complex. The proposed gating mechanism reveals critical spatial relationships between the expandable transmembrane barrel formed by M1 and M2, the gate formed by S1 helices, and "strings" that link S1s to M1s. These models are consistent with numerous experimental results and modeling criteria.

Site-directed spin-labeling analysis of reconstituted Mscl in the closed state

The mechanosensitive channel from Escherichia coli (Eco-MscL) responds to membrane lateral tension by opening a large, water-filled pore that serves as an osmotic safety valve. In an attempt to understand the structural dynamics of MscL in the closed state and under physiological conditions, we have performed a systematic site-directed spin labeling study of this channel reconstituted in a membrane bilayer. Structural information was derived from an analysis of probe mobility, residue accessibility to O(2) or NiEdda and overall intersubunit proximity. For the majority of the residues studied, mobility and accessibility data showed a remarkable agreement with the Mycobacterium tuberculosis crystal structure, clearly identifying residues facing the large water-filled vestibule at the extracellular face of the molecule, the narrowest point along the permeation pathway (residues 21-26 of Eco-MscL), and the lipid-exposed residues in the peripheral transmembrane segments (TM2). Overall, the present dataset demonstrates that the transmembrane regions of the MscL crystal structure (obtained in detergent and at low pH) are, in general, an accurate representation of its structure in a membrane bilayer under physiological conditions. However, significant differences between the EPR data and the crystal structure were found toward the COOH-terminal end of TM2.

The staphylococcal leukocidin bicomponent toxin forms large ionic channels

The genes encoding the F and S components of a leukocidin, LukF (HlgB) and LukS (HlgC), a pore-forming binary toxin, were amplified from the Smith 5R strain of Staphylococcus aureus both with and without sequences encoding 3'-hexahistidine tags. The His-tagged components were expressed in Escherichia coli and purified under nondenaturing conditions. In addition, the two unmodified proteins and the His-tagged versions were produced in an E. coli cell-free in vitro transcription and translation system. An SDS-stable oligomer of approximately 200 kDa appeared when both components were cotranslated in the presence of rabbit erythrocyte membranes. Hemolytic activity of the combined components against rabbit erythrocytes was measured for both in vitro- and in vivo-produced polypeptides, yielding similar HC(50) values of approximately 0.14 microg/mL. The pore-forming properties of the recombinant leukocidin were also investigated with planar lipid bilayers of diphytanoylphosphatidylcholine. Although leukocidins and staphylococcal alpha-hemolysin share partial sequence identity and related folds, LukF and LukS produce a pore with a unitary conductance of 2.5 nS [1 M KCl and 5 mM HEPES (pH 7.4)], which is more than 3 times greater than that of alpha-hemolysin measured under the same conditions. Therefore, if the leukocidin pore were a cylinder, its diameter would be almost twice that of alpha-hemolysin. In addition, the leukocidin pore is weakly cation selective and exhibits gating at low positive potentials, while alpha-hemolysin is weakly anion selective and gates only at high potentials. Taken together, these data suggest that the structure of the oligomeric pore formed by the leukocidin examined here has diverged significantly from that of alpha-hemolysin.

Channel gating: twist to open

Recent studies of the bacterial mechanosensitive channel MscL have combined a number of different approaches to come up with a model for the channel gating mechanism.

Chemically charging the pore constriction opens the mechanosensitive channel MscL

MscL is a bacterial mechanosensitive channel that protects the cell from osmotic downshock. We have previously shown that substitution of a residue that resides within the channel pore constriction, MscL's Gly-22, with all other 19 amino acids affects channel gating according to the hydrophobicity of the substitution (). Here, we first make a mild substitution, G22C, and then attach methanethiosulfonate (MTS) reagents to the cysteine under patch clamp. Binding MTS reagents that are positively charged ([2-(trimethylammonium)ethyl] methanethiosulfonate and 2-aminoethyl methanethiosulfonate) or negatively charged (sodium (2-sulfonatoethyl)methanethiosulfonate) causes MscL to gate spontaneously, even when no tension is applied. In contrast, the polar 2-hydroxyethyl methanethiosulfonate halves the threshold, and the hydrophobic methyl methanethiolsulfonate increases the threshold. These observations indicate that residue 22 is in a hydrophobic environment before gating and in a hydrophilic environment during opening to a substate, a finding consistent with our previous study. In addition, we have found that cysteine 22 is accessible to reagents from the cytoplasmic side only when the channel is opened whereas it is accessible from the periplasmic side even in the closed state. These results support the view that exposure of hydrophobic surfaces to a hydrophilic environment during channel opening serves as the barrier to gating.

Structural and functional differences between two homologous mechanosensitive channels of Methanococcus jannaschii

We report the molecular cloning and characterization of MscMJLR, a second type of mechanosensitive (MS) channel found in the archaeon Methanococcus jannaschii. MscMJLR is structurally very similar to MscMJ, the MS channel of M.jannaschii that was identified and cloned first by using the TM1 domain of Escherichia coli MscL as a genetic probe. Although it shares 44% amino acid sequence identity and similar cation selectivity with MscMJ, MscMJLR exhibits other major functional differences. The conductance of MscMJLR of approximately 2 nS is approximately 7-fold larger than the conductance of MscMJ and rectifies with voltage. The channel requires approximately 18 kT for activation, which is three times the amount of energy required to activate MscMJ, but is comparable to the activation energy of Eco-MSCL: Our study indicates that a multiplicity of conductance-wise and energetically well-tuned MS channels in microbial cell membranes may provide for cell survival by the sequential opening of the channels upon challenge with different osmotic cues.

Molecular basis of mechanotransduction in living cells

The simplest cell-like structure, the lipid bilayer vesicle, can respond to mechanical deformation by elastic membrane dilation/thinning and curvature changes. When a protein is inserted in the lipid bilayer, an energetic cost may arise because of hydrophobic mismatch between the protein and bilayer. Localized changes in bilayer thickness and curvature may compensate for this mismatch. The peptides alamethicin and gramicidin and the bacterial membrane protein MscL form mechanically gated (MG) channels when inserted in lipid bilayers. Their mechanosensitivity may arise because channel opening is associated with a change in the protein's membrane-occupied area, its hydrophobic mismatch with the bilayer, excluded water volume, or a combination of these effects. As a consequence, bilayer dilation/thinning or changes in local membrane curvature may shift the equilibrium between channel conformations. Recent evidence indicates that MG channels in specific animal cell types (e.g., Xenopus oocytes) are also gated directly by bilayer tension. However, animal cells lack the rigid cell wall that protects bacteria and plants cells from excessive expansion of their bilayer. Instead, a cortical cytoskeleton (CSK) provides a structural framework that allows the animal cell to maintain a stable excess membrane area (i.e., for its volume occupied by a sphere) in the form of membrane folds, ruffles, and microvilli. This excess membrane provides an immediate membrane reserve that may protect the bilayer from sudden changes in bilayer tension. Contractile elements within the CSK may locally slacken or tighten bilayer tension to regulate mechanosensitivity, whereas membrane blebbing and tight seal patch formation, by using up membrane reserves, may increase membrane mechanosensitivity. In specific cases, extracellular and/or CSK proteins (i.e., tethers) may transmit mechanical forces to the process (e.g., hair cell MG channels, MS intracellular Ca(2+) release, and transmitter release) without increasing tension in the lipid bilayer.

The gating mechanism of the large mechanosensitive channel MscL

The mechanosensitive channel of large conductance, MscL, is a ubiquitous membrane-embedded valve involved in turgor regulation in bacteria. The crystal structure of MscL from Mycobacterium tuberculosis provides a starting point for analysing molecular mechanisms of tension-dependent channel gating. Here we develop structural models in which a cytoplasmic gate is formed by a bundle of five amino-terminal helices (S1), previously unresolved in the crystal structure. When membrane tension is applied, the transmembrane barrel expands and pulls the gate apart through the S1-M1 linker. We tested these models by substituting cysteines for residues predicted to be near each other only in either the closed or open conformation. Our results demonstrate that S1 segments form the bundle when the channel is closed, and crosslinking between S1 segments prevents opening. S1 segments interact with M2 when the channel is open, and crosslinking of S1 to M2 impedes channel closing. Gating is affected by the length of the S1-M1 linker in a manner consistent with the model, revealing critical spatial relationships between the domains that transmit force from the lipid bilayer to the channel gate.

Molecular identification of a mechanosensitive channel in archaea

The TM1 domain of the large conductance mechanosensitive (MS) channel of Escherichia coli was used as a genetic probe to search the genomic database of the archaeon Methanoccoccus jannashii for MscL homologs. We report that the hypothetical protein MJ0170 of M. jannashii exhibited 38.5% sequence identity with the TM1 domain of Eco-MscL. Moreover, MJ0170 was found to be a conserved homolog of MscS, the second type of E. coli MS channel encoded by the yggB gene. Furthermore, we identified a cluster of charged residues KIKEE in the C-terminus of MJ0170 that strikingly resembled the charged C-terminal amino acid cluster present in Eco-MscL (RKKEE). We cloned and expressed MJ0170 in E. coli, which when reconstituted into liposomes or expressed in the cell membrane of giant E. coli spheroplasts, exhibited similar activity to the bacterial MS channels. Our study suggests that the M. jannashii MS channel and its homologs evolved as a result of gene duplication of the ancestral MscL-like molecule with the TM1 domain remaining the most conserved structural motif among prokaryotic MS channels.

Contributions of the different extramembranous domains of the mechanosensitive ion channel MscL to its response to membrane tension

MscL is a mechanosensitive channel that is gated by tension in the membrane bilayer alone. It is a homo-oligomer of a protein comprising two transmembrane segments connected by an external loop, with the NH(2) and COOH termini located in the cytoplasm. The contributions of the extramembranous domains of the channel to its activity were investigated by specific proteolysis during patch-clamp experiments. Limited proteolysis of the COOH terminus or the NH(2) terminus increased the mechanosensitivity of the channel without changing its conductance. Strikingly, after cleavage of the external loop of each monomer, the channel was still functional, and its mechanosensitivity was increased dramatically, indicating that the loop acts as a spring that resists the opening of the channel and promotes its closure when it is open. These results indicate that the integrity of most of the extramembranous domains is not essential for mechanosensitivity. They suggest that these domains counteract the movement of the transmembrane helices to which they are connected, thus setting the level of sensitivity of the channel to tension.

Elongation factor Tu and DnaK are transferred from the cytoplasm to the periplasm of Escherichia coli during osmotic downshock presumably via the mechanosensitive channel mscL

Upon osmotic downshock, a few cytoplasmic proteins, including thioredoxin, elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), and DnaK, are released from Tris-EDTA-treated Escherichia coli cells by an unknown mechanism. We have shown previously that deletion of mscL, the gene coding for the mechanosensitive channel of the plasma membrane with the highest conductance, prevents the release of thioredoxin. We confirm and extend the implication of MscL in this process by showing that the release of EF-Tu and DnaK is severely impaired in MscL-deficient strains. Release of these proteins is not observed in the absence of a Tris-EDTA treatment which disrupts the outer membrane, indicating that, in intact cells, they are transferred to the periplasm upon shock, presumably through the MscL channel.

Structure and function of the bacterial mechanosensitive channel of large conductance

Mechanosensation in bacteria involves transducing membrane stress into an electrochemical response. In Escherichia coli and other bacteria, this function is carried out by a number of proteins including MscL, the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance. MscL is the best characterized of all mechanosensitive channels. It has been the subject of numerous structural and functional investigations. The explosion in experimental data on MscL recently culminated in the solution of the three-dimensional structure of the MscL homologue from Mycobacterium tuberculosis. In this review, much of these data are united and interpreted in terms of the newly published M. tuberculosis MscL crystal structure.

Hydrophilicity of a single residue within MscL correlates with increased channel mechanosensitivity

Mechanosensitive channel large (MscL) encodes the large conductance mechanosensitive channel of the Escherichia coli inner membrane that protects bacteria from lysis upon osmotic shock. To elucidate the molecular mechanism of MscL gating, we have comprehensively substituted Gly(22) with all other common amino acids. Gly(22) was highlighted in random mutagenesis screens of E. coli MscL (, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA. 95:11471-11475). By analogy to the recently published MscL structure from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (, Science. 282:2220-2226), Gly(22) is buried within the constriction that closes the pore. Substituting Gly(22) with hydrophilic residues decreased the threshold pressure at which channels opened and uncovered an intermediate subconducting state. In contrast, hydrophobic substitutions increased the threshold pressure. Although hydrophobic substitutions had no effect on growth, similar to the effect of an MscL deletion, channel hyperactivity caused by hydrophilic substitutions correlated with decreased proliferation. These results suggest a model for gating in which Gly(22) moves from a hydrophobic, and through a hydrophilic, environment upon transition from the closed to open conformation.

Bacterial mechanosensitive channels: integrating physiology, structure and function

When confronted with hypo-osmotic stress, many bacterial species are able rapidly to adapt to the increase in cell turgor pressure by jettisoning cytoplasmic solutes into the medium through membrane-tension-gated channels. Physiological studies have confirmed the importance of these channels in osmoregulation. Mutagenesis of one of these channels, combined with structural information derived from X-ray crystallography, has given the first clues of how a mechanosensitive channel senses and responds to membrane tension.

Mechanosensitive channels in bacteria as membrane tension reporters

The purpose of this short review is to discuss recent data on the molecular structure and mechanism of gating of MscL, a mechanosensitive channel of large conductance from Escherichia coli. MscL is the first isolated molecule shown to convert mechanical stress of the membrane into a simple response, the opening of a large aqueous pore. The functional complex appears to be a stable homo-pentamer of 15-kDa subunits, the gating transitions in which are driven by stretch forces conveyed through the lipid bilayer. We have measured the open probability of MscL and the kinetics of transitions as a function of membrane tension. The parameters extracted from the single-channel current recordings and dose-response curves such as the energy difference between the closed, open, and intermediate conducting states, and the transition-related changes in protein dimensions suggest a large conformational rearrangement of the channel complex. The estimations show that in native conditions MscL openings could be driven primarily by forces of osmotic nature. The thermodynamic and spatial parameters reasonably correlate with the available data on the structure of a single MscL subunit and multimeric organization of the complex. Combined with the functional analysis of mutations, these data give grounds to hypotheses on the nature of the channel mechanosensitivity.

Channel gate! Tension, leak and disclosure

The crystal structure of a bacterial MscL shows how this homopentameric channel protein is held tightly shut to prevent leakage whilst at rest. By inference, the structure also shows how a stretch force in the lipid bilayer causes the channel to open. We now have a concrete picture as to how a stimulus 'gates' an ion channel.

Estimated single-channel conductance of mechanically-activated channels in a spider mechanoreceptor

Noise analysis was used to estimate the single-channel conductance and number of channels responsible for the mechanically-activated current in the sensory neurons of a spider mechanoreceptor organ. External slits of the VS-3 slit-sense organ in the patellar cuticle of Cupiennius salei were moved with a piezoelectric stimulator while glass microelectrodes penetrated the adjacent cell bodies. Receptor currents were measured by the switching single-electrode voltage clamp technique during both step and ramp displacements of the slits. Current records were segmented in time, and the variance and amplitude of the current were obtained from each segment, to allow fitting of the variance vs. amplitude relationship by a standard equation based on a two-state channel. Mean values of 7.5 pS and 253 were obtained for the conductance and number of channels from 75 separate recordings. These values are in good agreement with the small number of other estimates of these parameters from different mechanoreceptor preparations.

Energetic and spatial parameters for gating of the bacterial large conductance mechanosensitive channel, MscL

MscL is multimeric protein that forms a large conductance mechanosensitive channel in the inner membrane of Escherichia coli. Since MscL is gated by tension transmitted through the lipid bilayer, we have been able to measure its gating parameters as a function of absolute tension. Using purified MscL reconstituted in liposomes, we recorded single channel currents and varied the pressure gradient (P) to vary the tension (T). The tension was calculated from P and the radius of curvature was obtained using video microscopy of the patch. The probability of being open (Po) has a steep sigmoidal dependence on T, with a midpoint (T1/2) of 11.8 dyn/cm. The maximal slope sensitivity of Po/Pc was 0.63 dyn/cm per e-fold. Assuming a Boltzmann distribution, the energy difference between the closed and fully open states in the unstressed membrane was DeltaE = 18.6 kBT. If the mechanosensitivity arises from tension acting on a change of in-plane area (DeltaA), the free energy, TDeltaA, would correspond to DeltaA = 6.5 nm2. MscL is not a binary channel, but has four conducting states and a closed state. Most transition rates are independent of tension, but the rate-limiting step to opening is the transition between the closed state and the lowest conductance substate. This transition thus involves the greatest DeltaA. When summed over all transitions, the in-plane area change from closed to fully open was 6 nm2, agreeing with the value obtained in the two-state analysis. Assuming a cylindrical channel, the dimensions of the (fully open) pore were comparable to DeltaA. Thus, the tension dependence of channel gating is primarily one of increasing the external channel area to accommodate the pore of the smallest conducting state. The higher conducting states appear to involve conformational changes internal to the channel that don't involve changes in area.

Mechanosensitive channel functions to alleviate the cell lysis of marine bacterium, Vibrio alginolyticus, by osmotic downshock

The mechanosensitive channel with large conductance of Escherichia coli is the first to be cloned among stretch-activated channels. Although its activity was characterized by a patch clamp method, a physiological role of the channel has not been proved. The marine bacterium, Vibrio alginolyticus, is sensitive to osmotic stress and cell lysis occurs under osmotic downshock. We introduced an mscL gene into Vibrio alginolyticus, and the mechanosensitive channel with large conductance functions was found to alleviate cell lysis by osmotic downshock. This is the first report to show a physiological role of the mechanosensitive channel with large conductance.

Release of thioredoxin via the mechanosensitive channel MscL during osmotic downshock of Escherichia coli cells

Escherichia coli cells possess several mechanosensitive ion channels but only MscL, the channel with the highest conductance, which is activated at the highest membrane tension, has been cloned. We investigated the putative involvement of MscL in the effluxes caused by osmotic downshock. Osmotic shock caused the release of potassium glutamate, trehalose, and glycine betaine from wild type cells and cells lacking MscL. There was no difference between the two strains, but the extreme rapidity of the efflux process, as shown herein for glycine betaine, suggests that it is channel-mediated. Osmotic downshock also induces the release of some cytosolic proteins from EDTA-treated cells. We investigated the release of thioredoxin. This protein was totally released from wild type cells but was retained by MscL- cells. Release was restored by expression of the gene coding for MscL. Thus MscL is not necessary for the excretion of osmoprotectants, but it does open in vivo during shock and catalyzes the efflux of thioredoxin and possibly other small cytosolic proteins. It follows that the other mechanosensitive channels, which are known to be activated at lower tension, must also open during osmotic shock. Their opening and that of MscL could account for the rapid release of osmolytes.

One face of a transmembrane helix is crucial in mechanosensitive channel gating

MscL is a mechanosensitive channel in bacteria that responds directly to membrane tension by opening a large conductance pore. To determine functionally important residues within this molecule, we have randomly mutagenized mscL, expressed the genes in living bacteria, and screened for gain-of-function mutants with hampered growth. Expression of these genes caused leakage of cytoplasmic solutes on little or no hypo-osmotic stress. In excised patches, the mutant channels gated at membrane tensions that are less than that required for the gating of the wild-type MscL. Hence, the data suggest that the slowed or no-growth phenotype is caused by solute loss because of inappropriate gating of the channel. Most of the mutations mapped to the first transmembrane domain. When this domain is modeled as an alpha-helix, the most severe mutations are substitutions of smaller amino acids (three glycines and one valine) on one facet, suggesting an important role for this structure in MS channel gating.

A hexameric transmembrane pore revealed by two-dimensional crystallization of the large mechanosensitive ion channel (MscL) of Escherichia coli

We have established a reconstitution method of the detergent-solubilized recombinant large mechanosensitive ion channel of Escherichia coli (MscL) that yielded two-dimensional crystals. For that purpose, we have developed a new protocol using Triton X-100 to solubilize and purify the MscL protein. This protocol not only allowed an increase in the protein yield but also made it possible to obtain a homogeneous delipidated and reproducible preparation of the purified protein. When examined by the patch-clamp method MscL channels were found to be fully functional, exhibiting characteristic conductance and activation by pressure. For electron crystallography the homogeneous Triton X-100-purified recombinant MscL was further reconstituted at low lipid-to-protein ratios using Bio-Beads SM2 to remove the detergent. Two-dimensional crystals, exhibiting a p6 plane group symmetry, have been produced and examined by negative stain electron microscopy. Image processing of selected micrographs yielded a projection map at 15-A resolution that provided the first explicit structural information about the molecular boundary and homohexameric organization of the MscL channels in the membrane bilayer.