Positive selection of antigen-specific T cells in thymus by restricting MHC molecules

The Src-like adaptor protein downregulates the T cell receptor on CD4+CD8+ thymocytes and regulates positive selection

In this report, we show that the Src-like adaptor protein (SLAP) plays an important role in thymocyte development. SLAP expression is developmentally regulated; it is low in CD4-CD8- thymocytes, it peaks in the CD4+CD8+ subset, and it decreases to low levels in more mature cells. Disruption of the SLAP gene leads to a marked upregulation of TCR and CD5 expression at the CD4+CD8+ stage. The absence of SLAP was also developmentally significant because it enhanced positive selection in mice expressing the DO11.10 transgenic T cell receptor. Moreover, SLAP deletion at least partially rescued the development of ZAP-70-deficient thymocytes. These results demonstrate that SLAP participates in a novel mechanism of TCR downregulation at the CD4+CD8+ stage and regulates positive selection.

T cell development and T cell responses in mice with mutations affecting tyrosines 292 or 315 of the ZAP-70 protein tyrosine kinase

After stimulation of the T cell receptor (TCR), the tyrosine residues 292 and 315 in interdomain B of the protein tyrosine kinase ZAP-70 become phosphorylated and plausibly function as docking sites for Cbl and Vav1, respectively. The two latter proteins have been suggested to serve as substrates for ZAP-70 and to fine-tune its function. To address the role of these residues in T cell development and in the function of primary T cells, we have generated mice that express ZAP-70 molecules with Tyr to Phe substitution at position 292 (Y292F) or 315 (Y315F). When analyzed in a sensitized TCR transgenic background, the ZAP-70 Y315F mutation reduced the rate of positive selection and delayed the occurrence of negative selection. Furthermore, this mutation unexpectedly affected the constitutive levels of the CD3-zeta p21 phosphoisoform. Conversely, the ZAP-70 Y292F mutation upregulated proximal events in TCR signaling and allowed more T cells to produce interleukin 2 and interferon gamma in response to a given dose of antigen. The observation that ZAP-70 Y292F T cells have a slower rate of ligand-induced TCR downmodulation suggests that Y292 is likely involved in regulating the duration activated TCR reside at the cell surface. Furthermore, we showed that Y292 and Y315 are dispensable for the TCR-induced tyrosine phosphorylation of Cbl and Vav1, respectively. Therefore, other molecules present in the TCR signaling cassette act as additional adaptors for Cbl and Vav1. The present in vivo analyses extend previous data based on transformed T cell lines and suggest that residue Y292 plays a role in attenuation of TCR signaling, whereas residue Y315 enhances ZAP-70 function.

Requirement for tyrosine residues 315 and 319 within zeta chain-associated protein 70 for T cell development

Engagement of the T cell antigen receptor (TCR) induces the transphosphorylation of the zeta chain-associated protein of 70,000 Mr (ZAP-70) protein tyrosine kinase (PTK) by the CD4/8 coreceptor associated Lck PTK. Phosphorylation of Tyr 493 within ZAP-70's activation loop results in the enzymatic activation of ZAP-70. Additional tyrosines (Tyrs) within ZAP-70 are phosphorylated that play both positive and negative regulatory roles in TCR function. Phosphorylation of Tyr residues (Tyrs 315 and 319) within the Interdomain B region of the ZAP-70 PTK plays important roles in the generation of second messengers after TCR engagement. Here, we demonstrate that phosphorylation of these two Tyr residues also play important roles in mediating the positive and negative selection of T cells in the thymus.

Flexibility in MHC and TCR Recognition: Degenerate Specificity at the T Cell Level in the Recognition of Promiscuous Th Epitopes Exhibiting No Primary Sequence Homology

Recognition of peptide Ags by T cells through the TCR can be highly specific. In this report we show the degeneracy of Ag recognition at both MHC and TCR levels. We present evidence that unrelated promiscuous Th cell epitopes from various protein sources exhibit sufficient structural homology, despite minimal structural identity, to elicit cross-reactive proliferative responses at the bulk T cell level. This epitopic mimicry was also observed when peptide (CS.T3(378-395) and TT(830-844))-specific CD4+ T cell lines and T cell hybridoma clones were used in proliferation and Ag presentation assays. A scrambled CS.T3(378-395) peptide did not show any proliferation, indicating that the specificity of the cross-reactive responses may be linked with the primary structure of the peptides. Blocking of CS.T3(378-395)-specific CD4+ T cell proliferation by anti-MHC class II mAb showed that recognition of promiscuous T cell epitopes is largely in association with MHC class II molecules. These findings suggest that promiscuous Th epitopes may be useful in designing peptide-based vaccine constructs. At the same time these results show that at the T cell level there may be a great deal of immunological cross-reactivity between heterologous pathogens, and because of this the host's response to a pathogen may be modified by its previous experience with other unrelated pathogens.

Modulation of CD8+ T cell response to antigen by the levels of self MHC class I

The response of H-Y-specific TCR-transgenic CD8(+) T cells to Ag is characterized by poor proliferation, cytolytic activity, and IFN-gamma secretion. IFN-gamma secretion, but not cytotoxic function, can be rescued by the B7.1 molecule, suggesting that costimulation can selectively enhance some, but not all, effector CD8(+) T cell responses. Although the H-Y epitope binds H-2D(b) relatively less well than some other epitopes, it can induce potent CTL responses in nontransgenic mice, suggesting that the observed poor responsiveness of transgenic CD8(+) T cells cannot be ascribed to the epitope itself. Previously reported reactivity of this TCR to H-2A(b) is also not the cause of the poor responsiveness of the H-Y-specific CD8(+) T cells, as H-Y-specific CD8(+) T cells obtained from genetic backgrounds lacking H-2A(b) also responded poorly. Rather, reducing the levels of H-2(b) class I molecules by breeding the mice to (C57BL/6 x B10.D2)F(1) or TAP1(+/-) backgrounds partially restored cytotoxic activity and enhanced proliferative responses. These findings demonstrate that the self MHC class I gene dosage may regulate the extent of CD8(+) T cell responsiveness to Ag.

A role for accessibility to self-peptide-self-MHC complexes in intrathymic negative selection

Whether intrathymic-positive and -negative selection of conventional alpha beta T cells occur in anatomically distinct sites is a matter of debate. By using a system composed of two distinct immune receptors, the Y-Ae mAb and the 1H3.1 (V alpha 1/V beta 6) TCR, both directed against the 52--68 fragment of the I-E alpha-chain (E alpha 52--68) bound to I-A(b), we examined the occurrence of negative selection imposed in vivo by a self-peptide-self-MHC class II complex with differential tissue expression. 1H3.1 TCR-transgenic (Tg) mice were bred to mice having an I-E alpha transgene with expression directed to all MHC class II-positive cells, restricted to thymic epithelial cells, or restricted to B cells, dendritic cells, and medullary thymic epithelial cells. All 1H3.1 TCR/I-E alpha double-Tg mice revealed a severely diminished thymic cellularity. Their lymph node cells were depleted of V beta 6(+)CD4(+) cells and were unresponsive to E alpha 52--68 in vitro. The absolute number of CD4(+)CD8(+) thymocytes was drastically reduced in all combinations, indicating that negative selection caused by an endogenously expressed self-determinant can effectively occur in the thymic cortex in vivo. Moreover, both cortical epithelial cells and, interestingly, the few cortical dendritic cells were able to support negative selection of CD4(+)CD8(+) thymocytes, albeit with a distinct efficiency. Collectively, these observations support a model where, in addition to the avidity of the thymocyte/stromal cell interaction, in vivo negative selection of autoreactive TCR-Tg T cells is determined by accessibility to self-peptide-self-MHC complexes regardless of the anatomical site.

A kinetic window constricts the T cell receptor repertoire in the thymus

To characterize the ligand binding properties of a naive T cell repertoire capable of responding to a foreign antigen, we analyzed T cell populations from T cell receptor (TCR) beta transgenic mice using a novel, single cell peptide/major histocompatibility complex (MHC) tetramer dissociation assay. The largely CD4+CD8(-/low) antigen-specific thymocyte repertoire exhibited a broad, bimodal distribution of tetramer binding half-lives (t(1/2)s), with a significant underrepresentation in the intermediate half-life range in which the majority of the peripheral repertoire lies. Thus, cells with the potential to bind foreign antigen with the lowest and highest stability are likely to be selectively removed from the repertoire prior to their establishment in the periphery. These studies provide direct evidence that thymic selection biases the naive peripheral T cell repertoire toward TCR-ligand interactions that fall within a moderate half-life "window."

Positive and negative selection of thymocytes depends on Lck interaction with the CD4 and CD8 coreceptors

Considerable evidence supports a role for the Src family protein tyrosine kinase Lck in regulating multiple aspects of thymocyte development. In this report, we establish that early events in T lymphopoiesis are restored to Lck-deficient mice by provision of a transgene encoding a version of Lck that cannot interact with the coreceptors CD4 and CD8. In addition, we demonstrate that later events in thymocyte development, specifically, the processes of positive and negative selection, are compromised in mice where the only Lck available cannot associate with either CD4 or CD8. We conclude that not only is Lck activity required for positive and negative selection, but that that activity must be coupled to the CD4 and CD8 coreceptors.

Absence of CD43 fails to alter T cell development and responsiveness

Genetic elimination of CD43 has been associated with increased T cell adhesiveness and T cell hyperresponsiveness to mitogens and alloantigens. Therefore, we investigated whether T cell development was perturbed in CD43-deficient mice by breeding CD43(null) mice with male Ag (Hy)-specific TCR-transgenic mice. Neither positive nor negative thymic selection of male Ag-specific T cells were affected by CD43 status. Furthermore, we did not observe a substantial or consistent hyperresponsive pattern in HY-CD43(null) lymph node cells compared with littermate HY-CD43(+/-) lymph node cells upon analysis of in vitro T cell stimulation with male Ag or mitogen. These observations challenged original conclusions associating absence of CD43 with T cell hyperresponsiveness and led us to re-examine this association. Reported phenotypes of CD43(null) mice have been based on mice with a mixed 129xC57BL/6 genetic background. To exclude a possible influence of genetic background differences among individual mice we analyzed CD43(null) littermates that had been back-bred onto the C57BL/6 background for seven to eight generations. We found that CD43(+) and CD43(null) littermates with the C57BL/6 background exhibited no differences in response to mitogen or alloantigen, thereby establishing that T cell hyperresponsiveness is not a general correlate of CD43 absence.

Disruption of T cell signaling networks and development by Grb2 haploid insufficiency

The developmental processes of positive and negative selection in the thymus shape the T cell antigen receptor (TCR) repertoire and require the integration of multiple signaling networks. These networks involve the efficient assembly of macromolecular complexes and are mediated by multimodular adaptor proteins that permit the functional integration of distinct signaling molecules. We show here that decreased expression of the adaptor protein Grb2 in Grb2+/- mice weakens TCR-induced c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK) and p38, but not extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK), activation. In turn, this selective effect decreases the ability of thymocytes to undergo negative, but not positive, selection. We also show that there are differences in the signaling thresholds of the three mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) families. These differences may provide a mechanism by which quantitative differences in signal strength can alter the balance of downstream signaling pathways to induce the qualitatively distinct biological outcomes of proliferation, differentiation or apoptosis.

V beta T cell repertoire of CD8+ splenocytes selected on nonpolymorphic MHC class I molecules

In this work, we have studied the role of the MHC class Ib molecules in the selection and maintenance of CD8(+) T splenocytes. We have compared the CD8(+) T cell repertoires of wild-type, H-2K-deficient, H-2D-deficient, or double knockout C57BL/6 mice. We show that the different CD8(+) repertoires, selected either by class Ia and class Ib or by class Ib molecules only, use the various V alpha (AV) and V beta (BV) rearrangements in the same proportion and without biases in the CDR3 size distribution. Furthermore, we have estimated the size of the BV repertoire in the four different strains of mice. Interestingly, we have found that the BV repertoire size is proportional to the overall number of CD8(+) splenocytes. This observation implies that BV diversity is positively correlated with the number of CD8(+) cells, even when the number of CD8(+) splenocytes is dramatically reduced (90% in the double knockout mice).

Thymosin alpha1 is a time and dose-dependent antagonist of dexamethasone-induced apoptosis of murine thymocytes in vitro

It is well established that glucocorticoid hormones induce apoptosis in immature developing thymocytes. Thymocyte apoptosis can be modulated by growth factors, anti-oxidants and adhesion receptors. We have previously demonstrated that thymosin alpha1 (Talpha1) antagonizes dexamethasone-induced apoptosis of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes. In the present study, we further characterize the dose and time dependence of Talpha1's antagonism of dexamethasone-induced thymocyte apoptosis. Talpha1 is effective at concentrations ranging from 2 to 100 microg/10(6) thymocytes. Talpha1 pre-treatment is necessary to achieve its anti-apoptotic activity. Talpha1 provides temporary protection to thymocytes by slowing dexamethasone's apoptotic activity up to 12 h post dexamethasone treatment. Additionally, Talpha1's activity is not sensitive to cycloheximide treatment, suggesting Talpha1's activity is independent of protein synthesis. Finally, Talpha1 is unable to antagonize apoptosis induced by the reactive oxygen species, H2O2, suggesting Talpha1's antagonism of dexamethasone occurs at the early stages of dexamethasone-induced apoptosis, prior to the production of reactive oxygen species. This evidence suggests that Talpha1 may provide a mechanism to transiently extend the life of a thymocyte during thymic selection.

Development of myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein autoreactive transgenic B lymphocytes: receptor editing in vivo after encounter of a self-antigen distinct from myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein

We explored mechanisms involved in B cell self-tolerance against brain autoantigens in a double-transgenic mouse model carrying the Ig H-chain (introduced by gene replacement) and/or the L-chain kappa (conventional transgenic) of the mAb 8.18C5, specific for the myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG). Previously, we demonstrated that B cells expressing solely the MOG-specific Ig H-chain differentiate without tolerogenic censure. We show now that double-transgenic (THkappa(mog)) B cells expressing transgenic Ig H- and L-chains are subjected to receptor editing. We show that in adult mice carrying both MOG-specific Ig H- and L-chains, the frequency of MOG-binding B cells is not higher than in mice expressing solely the transgenic Ig H-chain. In fact, in THkappa(mog) double-transgenic mice, the transgenic kappa(mog) L-chain was commonly replaced by endogenous L-chains, i.e., by receptor editing. In rearrangement-deficient RAG-2(-) mice, differentiation of THkappa(mog) B cells is blocked at an immature stage (defined by the B220(low)IgM(low)IgD(-) phenotype), reflecting interaction of the autoreactive B cells with a local self-determinant. The tolerogenic structure in the bone marrow is not classical MOG, because back-crossing THkappa(mog) mice into a MOG-deficient genetic background does not lead to an increase in the proportion of MOG-binding B cells. We propose that an as yet undefined self-Ag distinct from MOG cross-reacts with the THkappa(mog) B cell receptor and induces editing of the transgenic kappa(mog) L-chain in early immature B cells without affecting the pathogenic potential of the remaining MOG-specific B cells. This phenomenon represents a particular form of chain-specific split tolerance.

Genetic modulation of T cell receptor gene segment usage during somatic recombination

Lymphocyte antigen receptors are not encoded by germline genes, but rather are produced by combinatorial joining between clusters of gene segments in somatic cells. Within a given cluster, gene segment usage during recombination is thought to be largely random, with biased representation in mature T lymphocytes resulting from protein-mediated selection of a subset of the total repertoire. Here we show that T cell receptor D beta and J beta gene segment usage is not random, but is patterned at the time of recombination. The hierarchy of gene segment usage is independent of gene segment proximity, but rather is influenced by the ability of the flanking recombination signal sequences (RSS) to bind the recombinase and/or to form a paired synaptic complex. Importantly, the relative frequency of gene segment usage established during recombination is very similar to that found after protein-mediated selection, suggesting that in addition to targeting recombinase activity, the RSS may have evolved to bias the naive repertoire in favor of useful gene products.

Affinity of thymic self-peptides for the TCR determines the selection of CD8(+) T lymphocytes in the thymus

Experiments with synthetic antigen peptides have suggested that a critical parameter that determines the developmental fate of an immature thymocyte is the affinity of interaction between TCR and self-peptide/MHC expressed on thymic stromal cells. To test the physiological relevance of this model for thymocyte development, we determined the affinity of the anti-HY TCR (B6.2.16) expressed on CD8(+) cells for thymic self-peptide/H-2D(b) tetramers, then examined the ability of these self-peptides to determine the outcome of B6.2.16 CD8 cell selection in the thymus. The B6.2.16 TCR bound the male HY self-antigen with high affinity. Thymic self-peptides, which are highly abundant on the surface of thymic epithelial cells, bound the B6.2.16 TCR with low affinity. The ability of self-peptides to trigger positive or negative selection of B6.2.16 CD8 cells in cultured fetal thymi was determined by the relative affinity of self-peptide/H-2D(b) for the B6.2.16 TCR. High-affinity binding of the HY self-peptide resulted in B6.2.16 TCR complex zeta chain phosphorylation and the negative selection of B6.2.16 CD8 cells. Low-affinity binding of thymic self-peptides to B6.2.16 TCR resulted in the positive selection of B6.2.16 CD8 cells. Differences between the binding affinities of self-peptides to B6.2.16 TCR accounted for the self-peptide specificity of B6.2.16 CD8 cell positive selection. We conclude that the relative affinity of TCR for thymic self-peptide/class I MHC is a critical parameter in determining fate of CD8(+) cells during thymic selection.

Alpha beta TCR+ cells are a minimal fraction of peripheral CD8+ pool in MHC class I-deficient mice

MHC class I molecules play a role in the maintenance of the naive peripheral CD8+ T cell pool. The mechanisms of the peripheral maintenance and the life span of residual CD8+ cells present in the periphery of beta 2-microglobulin-deficient (beta 2m-/-) mice are unknown. We here show that very few CD8+ cells in beta 2m-/- mice coexpress CD8 beta, a marker of the thymus-derived CD8+ T cells. Most of the CD8 alpha+ cells express CD11c and can be found in beta 2m/RAG-2 double-deficient mice, demonstrating that these cells do not require rearranged Ag receptors for differentiation and survival and may be of dendritic cell lineage. Rare CD8 alpha+CD8 beta+ cells can be detected following in vivo alloantigenic stimulation 2 wk after the adult thymectomy. Selective MHC class I expression by bone marrow-derived cells does not lead to an accumulation of CD8 beta+ cells in beta 2m-/- mice. These findings demonstrate that 1) thymic export of CD8+ T cells in beta 2m-/- mice is reduced more severely than previously thought; 2) non-T cells expressing CD8 alpha become prominent when CD8+ T cells are virtually absent; 3) at least some beta 2m-/- CD8+ T cells have a life span in the periphery comparable to wild-type CD8+ cells; and 4) similar ligands induce positive selection in the thymus and survival of CD8+ T cells in the periphery.

Impaired assembly yet normal trafficking of MHC class I molecules in Tapasin mutant mice

Loading of peptides onto major histocompatibility complex class I molecules involves a multifactorial complex that includes tapasin (TPN), a membrane protein that tethers empty class I glycoproteins to the transporter associated with antigen processing. To evaluate the in vivo role of TPN, we have generated Tpn mutant mice. In these animals, most class I molecules exit the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) in the absence of stably bound peptides. Consequently, mutant animals have defects in class I cell surface expression, antigen presentation, CD8+ T cell development, and immune responses. These findings reveal a critical role of TPN for ER retention of empty class I molecules. Tpn mutant animals should prove useful for studies on alternative antigen-processing pathways that involve post-ER peptide loading.

Homeostasis of alpha beta TCR+ T cells

Cytokines contribute to T cell homeostasis at all stages of T cell existence. However, the particular cytokine involved varies as T cells progress from a naïve through an activated to a memory state. In many cases the important cytokines are members of the interleukin 2 subfamily of the short-chain type I cytokines. A case is made for the idea that the evolutionary divergence of the short-chain family allowed for concurrent divergence in leukocytes.

Glucocorticoids in T cell development and function*

Glucocorticoids are small lipophilic compounds that mediate their many biological effects by binding an intracellular receptor (GR) that, in turn, translocates to the nucleus and directly or indirectly regulates gene transcription. Perhaps the most recognized biologic effect of glucocorticoids on peripheral T cells is immunosuppression, which is due to inhibition of expression of a wide variety of activationinduced gene products. Glucocorticoids have also been implicated in Th lineage development (favoring the generation of Th2 cells) and, by virtue of their downregulation of fasL expression, the inhibition of activation-induced T cell apoptosis. Glucocorticoids are also potent inducers of apoptosis, and even glucocorticoid concentrations achieved during a stress response can cause the death of CD4(+)CD8(+ )thymocytes. Perhaps surprisingly, thymic epithelial cells produce glucocorticoids, and based upon in vitro and in vivo studies of T cell development it has been proposed that these locally produced glucocorticoids participate in antigen-specific thymocyte development by inhibiting activation-induced gene transcription and thus increasing the TCR signaling thresholds required to promote positive and negative selection. It is anticipated that studies in animals with tissue-specific GR-deficiency will further elucide how glucocorticoids affect T cell development and function.

Size estimate of the alpha beta TCR repertoire of naive mouse splenocytes

The diversity of the T cell repertoire of mature T splenocytes is generated, in the thymus, by pairing of alpha and beta variable domains of the alpha beta TCR and by the rearrangements of various gene segments encoding these domains. In the periphery, it results from competition between various T cell subpopulations including recent thymic migrants and long-lived T cells. Quantitative data on the actual size of the T cell repertoire are lacking. Using PCR methods and extensive sequencing, we have measured for the first time the size of the TCR-alpha beta repertoire of naive mouse T splenocytes. There are 5-8 x 105 different nucleotide sequences of BV chains in the whole spleen of young adult mice. We have also determined the size of the BV repertoire in a subpopulation of AV2+ T splenocytes, which allows us to provide a minimum estimate of the alpha beta repertoire. We find that the mouse spleen harbors about 2 x 106 clones of about 10 cells each. This figure, although orders of magnitude smaller than the maximum theoretical diversity (estimated up to 1015), is still large enough to maintain a high functional diversity.

Thymic and postthymic regulation of diabetogenic CD8 T cell development in TCR transgenic nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice

Natural development of diabetes in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice requires both CD4 and CD8 T cells. Transgenic NOD mice carrying alphabeta TCR genes from a class I MHC (Kd)-restricted, pancreatic beta cell Ag-specific T cell clone develop diabetes significantly faster than nontransgenic NOD mice. In these TCR transgenic mice, a large fraction of T cells express both transgene derived and endogenous TCR beta chains. Only T cells expressing two TCR showed reactivity to the islet Ag. Development of diabetogenic T cells is inhibited in mice with no endogenous TCR expression due to the SCID mutation. These results demonstrate that the expression of two TCRs is necessary for the autoreactive diabetogenic T cells to escape thymic negative selection in the NOD mouse. Further analysis with MHC congenic NOD mice revealed that diabetes development in the class I MHC-restricted islet Ag-specific TCR transgenic mice is still dependent on the presence of the homozygosity of the NOD MHC class II I-Ag7.

Functional and phenotypic evidence for presentation of E alpha 52-68 structurally related self-peptide(s) in I-E alpha-deficient mice

The Y-Ae mAb and the 1H3.1 TCR-alpha beta (V alpha 1/V beta 6) are two immune receptors specific for I-Ab MHC class II molecules complexed to the 52-68 fragment of the alpha-chain of I-E class II molecules (the E alpha 52-68 peptide). A profound intrathymic negative selection occurs in 1H3.1 TCR transgenic mice in the presence of an I-E alpha transgene. The administration of mAbs to 1H3.1/I-E alpha double-transgenic newborn mice reveals that Y-Ae, but not the isotype-matched anti-I-E Y17 mAb, rescues a significant number of mature (V beta 6highCD4+CD8-) thymocytes and allows the detection of E alpha 52-68-reactive T cells in the periphery. These observations indicate that deletion of autoreactive T cells can be specifically inhibited in vivo by an mAb specific for the deleting self-peptide:self-MHC class II complex. Similar inhibition experiments indicate that C57BL/6 (I-Ab+/I-E alpha-) mice constitutively express an E alpha-independent, Y-Ae-recognizable epitope(s). This finding is confirmed by the phenotypic analysis of mature (MHC class II high) C57BL/6 bone marrow-derived dendritic cells. Collectively, these observations further illustrate the peptide specificity of negative selection and demonstrate that MHC class II-positive cells from unmanipulated C57BL/6 mice that lack a functional I-E alpha gene can assemble one or more self-peptide:I-Ab complexes recognizable by the E alpha 52-68:I-Ab complex-specific Y-Ae mAb.

Immune-Associated Nucleotide-1 (IAN-1) Is a Thymic Selection Marker and Defines a Novel Gene Family Conserved in Plants

Positive selection of thymocytes is a complex and crucial event in T cell development that is characterized by cell death rescue, commitment toward the helper or cytotoxic lineage, and functional maturation of thymocytes bearing an appropriate TCR. To search for novel genes involved in this process, we compared gene expression patterns in positively selected thymocytes and their immediate progenitors in mice using the differential display technique. This approach lead to the identification of a novel gene, mIAN-1 (murine immune-associated nucleotide-1), that is switched on upon positive selection and predominantly expressed in the lymphoid system. We show that mIAN-1 encodes a 42-kDa protein sharing sequence homology with the pathogen-induced plant protein aig1 and that it defines a novel family of at least three putative GTP-binding proteins. Analysis of protein expression at various stages of thymocyte development links mIAN-1 to CD3-mediated selection events, suggesting that it represents a key player of thymocyte development and that it participates to peripheral specific immune responses. The evolutionary conservation of the IAN family provides a unique example of a plant pathogen response gene conserved in animals.

Class I MHC molecules on hematopoietic cells can support intrathymic positive selection of T cell receptor transgenic T cells

The identity of cells that mediate positive selection of CD8(+) T cells was investigated in two T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic systems. Irradiated beta(2)-microglobulin mutant mice or mice with mutations in both the K(b) and D(b) genes were repopulated with fetal liver cells from class I(+) TCR transgenic mice. In the case of the 2C TCR, mature transgene-expressing CD8(+) T cells appeared in the thymuses of the chimeras and in larger numbers in the peripheral lymphoid organs. These CD8(+) T cells were functional, exhibited a naive, resting phenotype, and were mostly thymus-dependent. Their development depended on donor cell class I expression. These results establish that thymic hematopoietic cells can direct positive selection of CD8(+) T cells expressing a conventional TCR. In contrast, no significant development of HY (male antigen)-TCR(+) CD8(+) T cells was observed in class I(+) into class I-deficient chimeras. These data suggest that successful positive selection directed by hematopoietic cells depends on specific properties of the TCR or its thymic ligands. The possibility that hematopoietic cell-induced, positive selection occurs only with TCRs that exhibit relatively high avidity interactions with selecting ligands in the thymus is discussed.

Thymus-Derived Glucocorticoids Set the Thresholds for Thymocyte Selection by Inhibiting TCR-Mediated Thymocyte Activation

Selection processes in the thymus eliminate nonfunctional or harmful T cells and allow the survival of those cells with the potential to recognize Ag in association with self-MHC-encoded molecules (Ag/MHC). We have previously demonstrated that thymus-derived glucocorticoids antagonize TCR-mediated deletion, suggesting a role for endogenous thymic glucocorticoids in promoting survival of thymocytes following TCR engagement. Consistent with this hypothesis, we now show that inhibition of thymus glucocorticoid biosynthesis causes an increase in thymocyte apoptosis and a decrease in recovery that are directly proportional to the number of MHC-encoded molecules present and, therefore, the number of ligands available for TCR recognition. Expression of CD5 on CD4+CD8+ thymocytes, an indicator of TCR-mediated activation, increased in a TCR- and MHC-dependent manner when corticosteroid production or responsiveness was decreased. These results indicate that thymus-derived glucocorticoids determine where the window of thymocyte selection occurs in the TCR avidity spectrum by dampening the biological consequences of TCR occupancy and reveal that glucocorticoids mask the high percentage of self-Ag/MHC-reactive thymocytes that exist in the preselection repertoire.

I-Ag7-Mediated Antigen Presentation by B Lymphocytes Is Critical in Overcoming a Checkpoint in T Cell Tolerance to Islet β Cells of Nonobese Diabetic Mice

B cell-deficient nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice are protected from the development of spontaneous autoimmune diabetes, suggesting a requisite role for Ag presentation by B lymphocytes for the activation of a diabetogenic T cell repertoire. This study specifically examines the importance of B cell-mediated MHC class II Ag presentation as a regulator of peripheral T cell tolerance to islet β cells. We describe the construction of NOD mice with an I-Ag7 deficiency confined to the B cell compartment. Analysis of these mice, termed NOD BCIID, revealed the presence of functionally competent non-B cell APCs (macrophages/dendritic cells) with normal I-Ag7 expression and capable of activating Ag-reactive T cells. In addition, the secondary lymphoid organs of these mice harbored phenotypically normal CD4+ and CD8+ T cell compartments. Interestingly, whereas control NOD mice harboring I-Ag7-sufficient B cells developed diabetes spontaneously, NOD BCIID mice were resistant to the development of autoimmune diabetes. Despite their diabetes resistance, histologic examination of pancreata from NOD BCIID mice revealed foci of noninvasive peri-insulitis that could be intentionally converted into a destructive process upon treatment with cyclophosphamide. We conclude that I-Ag7-mediated Ag presentation by B cells serves to overcome a checkpoint in T cell tolerance to islet β cells after their initial targeting has occurred. Overall, this work indicates that the full expression of the autoimmune potential of anti-islet T cells in NOD mice is intimately regulated by B cell-mediated MHC class II Ag presentation.

On the role of thymic epithelium vs. bone marrow-derived cells in repertoire selection of T cells

T lymphocytes mature in the thymus to become functional T cells. Studies with chimeric mice and T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic (tg) mice have indicated that the major histocompatibility gene complex (MHC) of thymic radio-resistant (presumed to be epithelial) cells positively select the MHC-restricted T cell repertoire. Surprisingly, mice without a thymus reconstituted with an MHC-incompatible thymus generate effector T cells which are, in general, specific for the host and not for the thymic MHC. The present study reanalyzed this longstanding paradox in nude mice that were reconstituted with an MHC-incompatible thymus plus or minus immunologically defective bone marrow-derived cells or in nude mice expressing a transgenic T cell receptor. A pathway of thymus-dependent but thymic MHC-independent T cell maturation is revealed where expansion of the antiviral T cell repertoire depends on the MHC of bone marrow-derived cells. These results indicate an alternative, if not a general, pathway of T cell maturation and selection: the thymus may function essentially as an organ promoting T cell receptor expression; T cell specificity, however, reflects repertoire expansion plus cell survival and effector T cell induction driven by the MHC of bone marrow-derived cells. Therefore pure thymus defects can be efficiently reconstituted by allo- and xenogeneic thymic grafts.

Positive selection of an H2-M3 restricted T cell receptor

Thymocytes are positively selected for alphabeta T cell antigen receptors (TCR) that recognize antigen in conjunction with self-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. MHC bound peptides participate in positive selection; however, their role has remained controversial. A TCR transgenic mouse was established using a TCR restricted to the MHC class Ib molecule, H2-M3. Having defined H2-M3 as the positively selecting MHC molecule, the severely limited number of H2-M3 binding peptides allowed us to characterize an NADH dehydrogenase subunit 1 (ND1)-derived peptide as the physiological ligand of positive selection. This peptide bears no apparent sequence homology to the cognate peptide, is expressed ubiquitously, and yet does not interfere with peripheral T cells. Our studies also suggest that positive selection becomes promiscuous at high epitope densities.

Treatment of an autoimmune disease with "classical" T cell veto: a proposal

Immune responses protect against infectious diseases and cancers. In normal circumstances, the immune system is tolerant to self. However, under certain conditions this tolerance is broken. The immune system attacks otherwise normal tissue. An autoimmune disease ensues. Strategies are now being sought that remove the pathogenic T cells without affecting other immune functions. "Classical" veto has been described as an immune suppressive mechanism able to remove T cells in a highly specific and effective manner. The present article briefly reviews the current knowledge on the development of autoreactive T cells and their regulation in the periphery. It describes "classical" veto, its mechanisms, and its novel applications. Finally, it argues that "classical" veto can be adapted to treat an autoimmune disease, such as type I diabetes mellitus.

A potential role for Elf-1 in CD4 promoter function

The control of CD4 gene expression is believed to be linked directly to the signaling events that mediate T cell development and is directly dependent on the CD4 promoter. We have previously determined that this promoter contains four factor-binding sites important for its function. One of these sites, referred to as the P4 site, contains an Ets consensus recognition sequence. Using functional and biochemical analyses, we determine that Elf-1 binds to this site and specifically activates the CD4 promoter, indicating that Elf-1 is playing an important role in CD4 promoter function. In addition, a second nuclear factor binds to this region. Although there are consensus recognition sites for other factors, we demonstrate that none of these factors binds to the P4 site, nor do other known members of the Ets family. Thus, a novel transcription factor may bind to the CD4 promoter and help mediate its function.

Limiting TCR Expression Leads to Quantitative But Not Qualitative Changes in Thymic Selection

Thymic selection is controlled in part by the avidity of the interaction between thymocytes and APCs. In agreement, the selective outcome can be modulated by altering the expression levels of selecting ligands on APCs. Here we test the converse proposition, i.e., whether changing TCR levels on thymocytes can alter the selective outcome. To this end, we have generated mice in which all thymocytes express two transgenic TCRs simultaneously (dual TCR-expressing (DTE) mice), the class I-restricted HY TCR and the class II-restricted AND TCR. Due to mutual dilution, surface expression levels of the two individual transgenic TCRs are diminished in DTE relative to single TCR-expressing mice. We find that thymic selection is highly sensitive to these reductions in TCR surface expression. Positive selection mediated by the AND and HY TCRs is severely impaired or abolished, respectively. Negative selection of the HY TCR in male DTE mice is also partly blocked, leading to the appearance of significant numbers of double positive thymocytes. Also, in the periphery of male, but not female, DTE mice, substantial numbers of single positive CD8bright cells accumulate, which are positively selected in the thymus but by a highly inefficient hemopoietic cell-dependent process. Overall our results favor the interpretation that the outcome of thymic selection is not determined solely by avidity and the resulting signal intensity, but is also constrained by other factors such as the nature of the ligand and/or its presentation by different subsets of APCs.

Differential Presentation of an Altered Peptide Within Fetal Central and Peripheral Organs Supports an Avidity Model for Thymic T Cell Development and Implies a Peripheral Readjustment for Activation

Altered self peptides may drive T cell development by providing avidity of interactions low enough to potentiate positive selection but not powerful enough to trigger programmed cell death. Since the peptide repertoire in both central and peripheral organs is nearly the same, interactions of these peptides with T cells in the thymus would have to be different from those taking place in the periphery; otherwise, T cell development and maturation would result in either autoimmunity or T cell deficiency. Herein, a self and an altered self peptide were delivered to fetuses, and their presentation as well as the consequence of such presentation on T cell development were assessed. The results indicate that the self peptide was presented in both central and peripheral fetal organs and that such presentation abolished T cell responses to both peptides during adult life. However, the altered peptide, although presented in vivo as well as in vitro by splenic cells, was unable to stimulate a specific T cell clone when the presenting cells were of thymic origin and allowed offspring to be responsive to both peptides. These findings indicate that central and peripheral organs accommodate selection and peripheral survival of T cells by promoting differential altered peptide presentation.

Growing up on the streets: why B-cell development differs from T-cell development

B-cell development differs significantly from T-cell development in that negative selection of autoreactive B cells can occur in the same microenvironment in which productive immune responses begin. Here, Sarah Townsend and colleagues discuss how this 'growing up on the streets' might provide a mechanism that fills holes in the B-cell repertoire, much as major histocompatibility complex polymorphism fills holes in the T-cell repertoire.

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes to an unmutated tumor rejection antigen P1A: normal development but restrained effector function in vivo

Unmutated tumor antigens are chosen as primary candidates for tumor vaccine because of their expression on multiple lineages of tumors. A critical issue is whether unmutated tumor antigens are expressed in normal cells, and if so, whether such expression imposes special restrictions on cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses. In this study, we use a transgenic approach to study the development and effector function of T cells specific for P1A, a prototypical unmutated tumor antigen. We report here that although P1A is expressed at low levels in normal tissues, including lymphoid tissues, the P1A-specific transgenic T cells develop normally and remain highly responsive to the P1A antigen. The fact that transgenic expression of P1A antigen in the thymus induces T cell clonal deletion demonstrates that normal hematopoietic cells can process and present the P1A antigen and that P1A-specific T cells are susceptible to clonal deletion. By inference, P1A-specific T cells must have escaped clonal deletion due to low expression of P1A in the thymus. Interestingly, despite the fact that an overwhelming majority of T cells in the T cell receptor for antigen (TCR)-transgenic mice are specific for P1A, these mice are no more resistant to a P1A-expressing plasmocytoma than nontransgenic littermates. Moreover, when the same TCR-transgenic mice were challenged simultaneously with B7-1(+) and B7-1(-) tumors, only B7-1(+) tumors were rejected. Therefore, even though P1A can be a tumor rejection antigen, the effector function of P1A-specific CTL is restrained in vivo. These results have important implications for the strategy of tumor immunotherapy.

Positive selection as a developmental progression initiated by alpha beta TCR signals that fix TCR specificity prior to lineage commitment

During positive selection, immature thymocytes commit to either the CD4+ or CD8+ T cell lineage ("commitment") and convert from short-lived thymocytes into long-lived T cells ("rescue"). By formal precursor-progeny analysis, we now identify what is likely to be the initial positive selection step signaled by alpha beta TCR, which we have termed "induction". During induction, RAG mRNA expression is downregulated, but lineage commitment does not occur. Rather, lineage commitment (which depends upon the MHC class specificity of the alpha beta TCR) only occurs after downregulation of RAG expression and the consequent fixation of alpha beta TCR specificity. We propose that positive selection can be viewed as a sequence of increasingly selective developmental steps (induction-->commitment-->rescue) that are signaled by alpha beta TCR engagements of intrathymic ligands.

Dual MHC Class I and Class II Restriction of a Single T Cell Receptor: Distinct Modes of Tolerance Induction by Two Classes of Autoantigens

In the final stages of thymic development, immature T cells undergo three distinct processes (positive selection, negative selection, and lineage commitment) that all depend on interactions of thymocyte TCRs with MHC molecules. It is currently thought that TCRs are preferentially restricted by either MHC class I or class II molecules. In this report, we present direct evidence that the TCR previously described as H-Y/H-2Db specific cross-reacts with H-2IAb if expressed in CD4+ cells. We also demonstrate an increase in thymocyte numbers in H-Y TCR-trangenic mice deficient in MHC class II, suggesting a relatively discrete form of negative selection by MHC class II compared with that induced by H-Y/H-2Db. We propose that inability to generate CD4+ T cells expressing H-Y TCR in different experimental settings may be due to tolerance to self-MHC class II. These results, therefore, support an intriguing possibility that tolerance to self may influence and/or interfere with the outcome of the lineage commitment.

MHC Class II-Dependent NK1.1+ γδ T Cells Are Induced in Mice by Salmonella Infection

We observed the emergence of a novel population of γδ T cells expressing NK1.1 Ag in the peritoneal cavity of mice infected with Salmonella choleraesuis. The NK1.1+γδ T cells accounted for approximately 20% of all γδ T cells emerging in the peritoneal cavity of C57BL/6 mice and expressed preferentially rearranged Vγ4-Jγ1 and Vδ6.3-Dδ1-Dδ2-Jδ1 genes with N diversity. The γδ T cells proliferated vigorously in response to PHA-treated spleen cells and produced IFN-γ in the culture supernatant. However, spleen cells from Aβb-deficient mice were unable to stimulate the γδ T cells. Furthermore, the NK1.1+γδ T cells were stimulated not only by Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells expressing wild-type IAb but also by those expressing IAb/Eα52-68 or IAb/pigeon cytochrome c-derived analogue peptide complex. These proliferation activities were inhibited by mAb specific for IAb chain. Consistent with these findings, the emergence of NK1.1+γδ T cells was reduced in the peritoneal cavity of Aβb-deficient mice after Salmonella infection, whereas NK1.1+γδ T cells were rather abundant in the peritoneal cavity of Salmonella-infected β2m-deficient mice. Moreover, the NK1.1+γδ T cells were easily identified in the thymus of β2m-deficient but not Aβb-deficient mice. Our results indicated that MHC class II expression is essential for development and activation of NK1.1+γδ T cells in the thymus and the periphery.

T-cell development: a new marker of differentiation state

Differentiation of T cells is a complicated affair and there has been a dearth of markers that faithfully reflect thymocyte phenotype. A new strategy based on T-cell receptor gene sequencing has revealed a marker that can be used to monitor thymocyte differentiation with fidelity and without perturbation.

A T cell receptor-specific blockade of positive selection

To investigate the influence of endogenous peptides on the developmental processes that occur during thymocyte selection, we have used monoclonal antibodies that preferentially recognize the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule I-Ek when it is bound to the moth cytochrome c peptide (88-103). One of these antibodies (G35) specifically blocks the positive selection of transgenic thymocytes expressing a T cell receptor that is reactive to this peptide- MHC complex. Furthermore, G35 does not block the differentiation of transgenic T cells bearing receptors for a different I-Ek-peptide complex. This antibody recognizes a subset of endogenous I-Ek-peptide complexes found on a significant fraction of thymic antigen-presenting cells, including cortical and medullary epithelial cells. The sensitivity of G35 to minor alterations in peptide sequence suggests that the thymic peptide-MHC complexes that mediate the positive selection of a particular class II MHC-restricted thymocyte are structurally related to the complexes that can activate it in the periphery.

Vav regulates peptide-specific apoptosis in thymocytes

The protooncogene Vav functions as a GDP/GTP exchange factor (GEF) for Rho-like small GTPases involved in cytoskeletal reorganization and cytokine production in T cells. Gene-targeted mice lacking Vav have a severe defect in positive and negative selection of T cell antigen receptor transgenic thymocytes in vivo, and vav-/- thymocytes are completely resistant to peptide-specific and anti-CD3/anti-CD28-mediated apoptosis. Vav acts upstream of mitochondrial pore opening and caspase activation. Biochemically, Vav regulates peptide-specific Ca2+ mobilization and actin polymerization. Peptide-specific cell death was blocked both by cytochalasin D inhibition of actin polymerization and by inhibition of protein kinase C (PKC). Activation of PKC with phorbol ester restored peptide-specific apoptosis in vav-/- thymocytes. Vav was found to bind constitutively to PKC-theta in thymocytes. Our results indicate that peptide-triggered thymocyte apoptosis is mediated via Vav activation, changes in the actin cytoskeleton, and subsequent activation of a PKC isoform.

Inhibition of intrathymic T cell development by expression of a transgenic antagonist peptide

The mature T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire is shaped by positive- and negative-selection events taking place during T cell development. These events are regulated by interactions between the TCR and major histocompatibility complex molecules presenting self-peptides. It has been shown that many antagonist peptides are efficient at mediating positive selection. In this study we analyzed the effects of a transgene encoding an antagonist peptide (influenza NP34) that is presented by H-2Db in a Tap-1-independent fashion in mice expressing the influenza NP68-specific TCR F5. We find that the transgenic peptide does not mediate positive or negative selection in F5(+)Tap-1(-/-) mice, but inhibits maturation of CD8(+) single positive thymocytes in F5(+)Tap-1(+) mice without inducing signs of negative selection. We conclude that antagonism of antigen recognition occurs not only at the level of mature T cells but also in T cell development.

Crucial function of the pre-T-cell receptor (TCR) in TCR beta selection, TCR beta allelic exclusion and alpha beta versus gamma delta lineage commitment

The analysis of T-cell receptor (TCR) beta selection, TCR beta allelic exclusion and TCR beta rearrangement in gamma delta T cells from normal and pre-TCR-deficient mice has shown that the pre-TCR has a crucial role in T-lymphocyte development: The pre-TCR is by far the most effective receptor that generates large numbers of CD4+8+ T cells with productive TCR beta rearrangements. In the absence of the pre-TCR, TCR beta rearrangement proceeds in developing cells irrespective of whether they already contain a productive TCR beta gene. The pre-TCR directs developing T cells to the alpha beta lineage because gamma delta T cells from pT alpha-/- mice proceed much further in TCR beta rearrangement than gamma delta T cells from wild-type mice. It is argued that the pre-TCR commits developing T cells to the alpha beta lineage by an instructive mechanism, which has largely replaced an evolutionarily more ancient mechanism that involves stochastic alpha beta lineage commitment.

A new categorization of HLA DR alleles on a functional basis

In this analysis, we introduce a new categorization of HLA DR alleles which are important members of HLA class II genes encoding cell surface glycoproteins that function to present antigenic peptides to T cells. We have grouped all HLA DR molecules into seven different functional categories on the basis of their ability to bind and present antigenic peptides to T cells and their association with susceptibility or resistance to disease. This novel categorization of DR alleles on the basis of function allows for the prediction of seven similar subregion structures (supertypes or supermotifs) within pocket 4 of HLA DR peptide binding groove as the molecular basis for grouping these alleles. The physicochemical characteristics of HLA DR supertype residues, charge in particular, may influence the selectivity for binding peptide, dominate promiscuous T-cell recognition of antigenic peptides, and affect HLA DR disease associations. To rationalize the functional categories of DR alleles, we have further combined the seven DR supertype patterns into three groups based on the charges of residues within the supertypes. Grouping HLA DR alleles into functional categories may assist in understanding the mechanistic basis of autoimmunity, resolving current paradoxes in HLA disease associations, and developing new immunotherapy strategies.

The action of Bax and bcl-2 on T cell selection

T cell development and selection in the thymus are shaped by the induction of apoptosis. However, a direct role in T cell development and selection for any of the molecules known to regulate apoptosis has remained controversial. We have studied the effect of bax and bcl-2 transgenes in recombination activation gene 1-deficient (RAG-1(-/-)) mice transgenic for the major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted F5 T cell receptor. Overexpression of a bax transgene in the thymus seriously impairs the production of mature T cells, whereas bcl-2 overexpression greatly promotes it. The effect of bax and bcl-2 overexpression on antigen-induced negative selection was studied using fetal thymic organ cultures. This analysis showed that Bcl-2 strongly inhibits negative selection, whereas Bax does not affect it. Our data directly show that Bcl-2 family members have specific roles in T cell selection and also lend support to the hypothesis that Bax and Bcl-2 can antagonize each other's action in a certain apoptosis pathway while in another they can be functionally nonreciprocal.