Determination of membrane protein structure by rotational resonance NMR: bacteriorhodopsin

Mechanisms of photoreceptor degenerations

The candidate gene approach has identified many causes of photoreceptor rod cell death in retinitis pigmentosa. Some mutations lead to increased cyclicGMP concentrations in rods. Rod photoreceptors are also particularly susceptible to some mutations in housekeeping genes. Although many more cases of macular degeneration than retinitis pigmentosa occur each year, there is much less known about both genetic and sporadic forms of this disease.

Reduced cytoplasmic calcium concentration may be both necessary and sufficient for photoreceptor light adaptation

Light adaptation is modulated almost exclusively by changes in intracellular Ca2+ concentration, and other Ca2+-independent mechanisms are likely to play only a minor role. Changes in Ca2+i may be not only necessary for light adaptation to take place but sufficient to cause it.

The genetic kaleidoscope of vision

Site-specific phenotypic effects of the 73 known alleles in the rhodopsin gene that cause retinal degeneration are difficult to interpret because most alleles are documented in only one case or one family, which means variation in effects could actually arise from interactions with other loci. However, sample sizes necessary to detect epistatic interaction may place an answer to this question beyond our grasp.

Evidence that the type I adenylyl cyclase may be important for neuroplasticity: Mutant mice deficient in the gene for type I adenylyl cyclase show altered behavior and LTP

The regulatory properties of the neurospecific, type I adenylyl cyclase and its distribution within brain have suggested that this enzyme may be important for neuroplasticity. To address this issue, the murine, Ca2+ -stimulated adenylyl cyclase (type I), was inactivated by targeted mutagenesis. Ca2+ -stimulated adenylyl cyclase activity was reduced 40% to 60% in the hippocampus, neocortex, and cerebellum. Long term potentiation in the CA1 region of the hippocampus from mutants was perturbed relative to controls. Both the initial slope and maxim um extent of changes in synaptic response were reduced. Although mutant mice learned to find a hidden platform normally in the Morris water task, they did not display a preference for the region where the platform had been when it was removed. The behavioral phenotype of these mice is very similar to that exhibited by mice which have been surgically lesioned in the hippocampus. These results indicate that disruption of the gene for the type I adenylyl cyclase produces changes in spatial memory and indicate that the cAMP signal transduction pathway may play an important role for synaptic plasticity.

Calcium/calmodulin-sensitive adenylyl cyclase as an example of a molecular associative integrator

Evidence suggests that the Ca2+/calmodulin-sensitive adenylyl cyclase may play a key role in neural plasticity and learning in Aplysia, Drosophila, and mammals. This dually-regulated enzyme has been proposed as a possible site of stimulus convergence during associative learning. This commentary discusses the evidence that is required to demonstrate that a protein in a second messenger cascade actually functions as a molecular site of associative integration. It also addresses the issue of how a dually-regulated protein could contribute to the temporal pairing requirements of classical conditioning: that relationship between stimuli display both temporal contiguity and predictability.

The key to rhodopsin function lies in the structure of its interface with transducin

Light activated rhodopsin functions by catalyzing the exchange of GTP for GDP on numerous copies of transducin. Peptide mapping has shown that at least six regions, three on rhodopsin and three on the transducin alpha subunit, are involved in the active interface between the two proteins. The most informative structural studies of rhodopsin should include focus on the transducin interaction.

Membrane protein structure: the contribution and potential of novel solid state NMR approaches

Alternative methods for describing molecular detail for large integral membrane proteins are required in the absence of routine crystallographic approaches. Novel solid state NMR methods, devised for the study of large molecular assemblies, are now finding applications in biological systems, including integral membrane proteins. Wild-type and genetically engineered proteins can be investigated and detailed information about side chains, prosthetic groups, ligands (e.g. drugs) and binding sites can be deduced. The molecular structure and dynamics of selected parts of the proteins are accessible by a range of different solid state NMR approaches. Inter- and intra-atomic distances can be determined rather accurately (within ångströms) and the orientation of molecular bonds (within 2 degrees) can be measured in ideal cases. Here, a brief description of the methods is given and then some specific examples described with an indication of the future potential for the approaches in studying membrane proteins. It is anticipated that this emerging NMR methodology will be more widely used in the future, not only for resolving local structure, but also for more expansive descriptions of membrane protein structure at atomic resolution.

Chemistry and conformation of vitamin D molecules

1 alpha,25-Dihydroxyvitamin D3 (1,25) is a structurally unique steroid hormone because it not only possesses the complete 25-hydroxycholesterol side chain, but most notably, it possesses a seco-B triene structure (it lacks a B-ring and is usually depicted in a non-steroidal, extended conformation). In contrast, the classical steroid hormones possess a truncated side chain (progesterone, cortisol, and aldosterone) or no side chain (estradiol and testosterone) and they all possess the fully intact ABCD steroid rings. These structural differences render the seco-B-steroid 1,25 considerably more conformationally flexible. Since 1,25 is now known to target a myriad of tissues where specific interactions occur to produce an array of biological responses, it is of interest to determine whether different topologies of 1,25 (resulting from different conformational orientations of 1,25) are necessary to interact effectively at the different target sites. The array of biological responses include both non-genomic and genomic effects and there is considerable promise for the efficacy of 1,25 analogs as chemotherapeutic agents in a variety of human disease states. For the non-genomic calcium transport response of transcaltachia, the finding that two 6-s-cis locked analogs, 1 alpha,25-dihydroxyprevitamin D3 (pre-1,25) and 1 alpha,25-dihydroxylumisterol3 (1,25-Lumi), are equipotent to 1,25, points strongly to the involvement of the 6-s-cis conformer of 1,25 as the biologically active conformer. Since there is a continuum of easily interconvertible 6,7-single bond conformers of the seco-B ring available to 1,25, conformational minima (either local or global) may have little to do with the manner in which 1,25 is bound to receptor. For the genomic calcium transport response, and for other genomic (or non-genomic) effects, there is no clear evidence whether the steroidal (s-cis) or non-steroidal (s-trans) conformer of 1,25 is involved. In order to address this matter further, efforts are underway to evaluate other conformationally locked analogs of 1,25 which might mimic either the planar 6-s-trans-1,25 or some intermediate conformer between it and the planar-6-s-cis form.

Structural model of antagonist and agonist binding to the angiotensin II, AT1 subtype, G protein coupled receptor

BACKGROUND

The family of G protein coupled receptors is the largest and perhaps most functionally diverse class of cell-surface receptors. Due to the difficulty of obtaining structural data on membrane proteins there is little information on which to base an understanding of ligand structure-activity relationships, the effects of receptor mutations and the mechanism(s) of signal transduction in this family. We therefore set out to develop a structural model for one such receptor, the human angiotensin II receptor.

RESULTS

An alignment between the human angiotensin II (type 1; hAT1), human beta 2 adrenergic, human neurokinin-1, and human bradykinin receptors, all of which are G protein coupled receptors, was used to generate a three-dimensional model of the hAT1 receptor based on bacteriorhodopsin. We observed a region within the model that was congruent with the biogenic amine binding site of beta 2, and were thus able to dock a model of the hAT1 antagonist L-158,282 (MK-996) into the transmembrane region of the receptor model. The antagonist was oriented within the helical domain by recognising that the essential acid functionality of this antagonist interacts with Lys199. The structural model is consistent with much of the information on structure-activity relationships for both non-peptide and peptide ligands.

CONCLUSIONS

Our model provides an explanation for the conversion of the antagonist L-158,282 (MK-996) to an agonist by the addition of an isobutyl group. It also suggests a model for domain motion during signal transduction. The approach of independently deriving three-dimensional receptor models and pharmacophore models of the ligands, then combining them, is a powerful technique which helps validate both models.

Site-directed isotope labelling and FTIR spectroscopy of bacteriorhodopsin

Insight into integral membrane proteins function is presently limited by the difficulty of producing three-dimensional crystals. In addition, X-ray structures of proteins normally do not provide information about the protonation state and structural changes of individual residues. We report here the first use of site-directed isotope labelling and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy to detect structural changes at the level of single residues in an integral membrane protein. Two site-directed isotope labeled (SDIL) tyrosine analogues of bacteriorhodopsin were produced which exhibit normal activity. FTIR spectroscopy shows that out of 11 tyrosines, only Tyr 185 is structurally active during the early photocycle and may be part of a proton wire.

Determination of internuclear distances and the orientation of functional groups by solid-state NMR: rotational resonance study of the conformation of retinal in bacteriorhodopsin

We have used a new solid-state NMR technique--rotational resonance--to determine both internuclear distances and the relative orientations of chemical groups (dihedral angles) in retinal bound to bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and in retinoic acid model compounds. By matching the rotational resonance condition (delta = n omega r/2 pi, where delta is the difference in isotropic chemical shifts for two dipolar coupled spins, omega r/2 pi is the mechanical rotational frequency of the sample in the MAS experiment, and n is a small integer denoting the order of the resonance), we selectively reintroduce the dipolar coupling and enhance the rate of magnetization exchange. Spectroscopic data and theoretical simulations of the magnetization exchange trajectories for the 8,18-13C dipolar coupled pair in retinoic acid model compounds, crystallized in both the 6-s-cis and 6-s-trans forms, indicate that an accurate determination of the internuclear distance is possible. For the n = 1 resonance we find the distance determination to be reasonably independent of the relative orientation of the groups. In contrast, for the n = 2 resonance, there is a more pronounced dependence on the relative orientation of the groups which permits an estimate of the angle around the 6-s bond for the cis and trans forms to be 42 +/- 5 degrees and 90 +/- 10 degrees, respectively, in good agreement with crystallography. In bR we demonstrate that the 8-13C-18-13C distance is 4.1 A and the average 8-13C-16-13C/8-13C-17-13C distance is 3.3-3.5 A.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Distorted structure of the retinal chromophore in bacteriorhodopsin resolved by 2H-NMR

Structural details about the geometry of the retinal chromophore in the binding pocket of bacteriorhodopsin are revealed by measuring the orientations of its individual methyl groups. Solid-state 2H-NMR measurements were performed on macroscopically oriented samples of purple membrane patches, containing retinal specifically deuterium-labeled at one of the three methyl groups along the polyene chain (C18, C19, C20). The deuterium quadrupole splitting of each "zero-tilt" spectrum is used to calculate the orientation of the corresponding C-CD3 bond vector with respect to the membrane normal; however, two possible solutions may arise. These ambiguities in angle could be resolved by recording a tilt series of spectra at different sample inclinations to the magnetic field and analyzing the resulting complex line shapes with the aid of computer simulations. The angles for the C18, C19, and C20 group are found to be 37 +/- 1 degree, 40 +/- 1 degree, and 32 +/- 1 degree, respectively. These highly accurate values imply that the polyene chain of the retinal chromophore is not straight but rather has an in-plane curvature and possibly an out-of-plane twist. Together with the angles of the remaining methyl groups on the cyclohexene ring that have been measured previously, an overall picture has thus emerged of the intramolecular conformation and the three-dimensional orientation of retinal within bacteriorhodopsin. The deduced geometry confirms and refines the known structural information on the chromophore, suggesting that this 2H-NMR strategy may serve as a valuable tool for other membrane proteins.

NMR observation of substrate in the binding site of an active sugar-H+ symport protein in native membranes

NMR methods have been adopted to observe directly the characteristics of substrate binding to the galactose-H+ symport protein GalP, in its native environment, the inner membranes of Escherichia coli. Sedimented inner-membrane vesicles containing the GalP protein, overexpressed to levels above 50% of total protein, were analyzed by 13C magic-angle spinning NMR, when in their normal "fluid" state and with incorporated D-[1-13C]glucose. Using conditions of cross-polarization intended to discriminate bound substrate alone, it was possible to detect as little as 250 nmol of substrate added to the membranes containing about 0.5 mumol (approximately 26 mg) of GalP protein. Such high measuring sensitivity was possible from the fluid membranes by virtue of their motional contributions to rapid relaxation recovery of the observed nuclei and due to a high-resolution response that approached the static field inhomogeneity in these experiments. This good spectral resolution showed that the native state of the membranes presents a substrate binding environment with high structural homogeneity. Inhibitors of the GalP protein, cytochalasin B and forskolin, which are specific, and D-galactose, but not L-galactose, prevent or suppress detection of the 13C-labeled glucose substrate, confirming that the observed signal was due to specific interactions with the GalP protein. This specific substrate binding exhibits a preference for the beta-anomer of D-glucose and substrate translocation is determined to be slow, on the 10(-2) s time scale. The work describes a straightforward NMR approach, which achieves high sensitivity, selectivity, and resolution for nuclei associated with complex membrane proteins and which may be combined with other NMR methodologies to yield additional structural information on the binding site for the current transport system without isolating it from its native membrane environment.

Cell-free synthesis, functional refolding, and spectroscopic characterization of bacteriorhodopsin, an integral membrane protein

Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) is an integral membrane protein which functions as a light-driven proton pump in Halobacterium halobium (also known as Halobacterium salinarium). The cell-free synthesis of bR in quantities sufficient for FTIR and NMR spectroscopy and the ability to selectively isotope label bR using aminoacylated suppressor tRNAs would provide a powerful approach for studying the role of specific amino acid residues. However, no integral membrane protein has yet been expressed in a cell-free system in quantities sufficient for such biophysical studies. We report the cell-free synthesis of bacterioopsin, its purification, its refolding in polar lipids from H. halobium, and its regeneration with all-trans-retinal to yield bacteriorhodopsin in a form functionally similar to bR in purple membrane. Importantly, the yields obtained from in vitro and in vivo expression are comparable. Functionality of the cell-free expressed bR is established using static and time-resolved absorption spectroscopy and FTIR difference spectroscopy.

Rotational resonance NMR study of the active site structure in bacteriorhodopsin: conformation of the Schiff base linkage

Rotational resonance, a new solid-state NMR technique for determining internuclear distances, is used to measure a distance in the active site of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) that changes in different states of the protein. The experiments are targeted to the active site of bR through 13C labeling of both the retinal chromophore and the Lys side chains of the protein. The time course of the rotor-driven magnetization exchange between a pair of 13C nuclei is then observed to determine the dipolar coupling and therefore the internuclear distance. Using this approach, we have measured the distance from [14-13C]retinal to [epsilon-13C]Lys216 in dark-adapted bR in order to examine the structure of the retinal-protein linkage and its role in coupling the isomerizations of retinal to unidirectional proton transfer. This distance depends on the configuration of the intervening C=N bond. The 3.0 +/- 0.2 A distance observed in bR555 demonstrates that the C=N bond is syn, and the 4.1 +/- 0.3 A distance observed in bR568 demonstrates that the C=N bond is anti. These direct distance determinations independently confirm the configurations previously deduced from solid-state NMR chemical shift and resonance Raman vibrational spectra. The spectral selectivity of rotational resonance allows these two distances to be measured independently in a sample containing both bR555 and bR568; the presence of both states and of 25% lipid in the sample demonstrates the use of rotational resonance to measure an active site distance in a membrane protein with an effective molecular mass of about 85 kDa.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

NMR studies of retinal proteins

A review is given of the use of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to study bacteriorhodopsin and bovine rhodopsin. Solution and solid-state approaches are included. The studies of the bacterial proton pump examine the chromophore, the peptide backbone, and the protein side chains. The studies of the bovine visual pigment are limited to the chromophore. Various forms of each pigment are considered. Both structural and dynamic features are addressed.

Ring oxidized retinals form unusual bacteriorhodopsin analogue pigments

Three ring oxidized retinal analogues have been isolated from the exhaustive oxidation of all-trans retinal. All-trans 4-oxoretinal and 2,3-dehydro-4-oxoretinal have similar absorption maxima to that of all-trans retinal and have been shown to be in the 6-s-cis conformation in solution. Pigments formed with bacterioopsin exhibit absorption maxima (520 nm) blue-shifted from that of bacteriorhodopsin (bR), indicating a disturbance of the external point charge by the electronegative carbonyl moiety at the 4 position. The third analogue contains a ring contracted to a cyclopentenyl-alpha,beta-dione. Unlike the majority of retinals, this analogue displays a 6-s-trans conformation in solution and has a red-shifted absorption maximum at 435 nm. The resulting bR analogue pigment (515 nm) is formed five times faster than the other oxoretinal pigments. All three oxoretinal pigments show an irreversible 20 nm blue shift upon exposure to white light. The 4-oxo and 2,3-dehydro-4-oxoretinal pigments, after irradiation, undergo a small reversible blue shift (4-8 nm) on dark adaptation. These two pigments pump protons, although with slowed photocycle kinetics, demonstrating that these structural changes (addition of the carbonyl at the C-4 and insertion of a double bond in the ring) do not block the function of the pigment. Extraction of the C-15 tritiated analogue retinals from illuminated and non-illuminated pigments of all three oxoretinals yield identical results. Therefore, any crosslinking of these oxoretinals to the protein is by linkages which are unstable to the extraction procedures.

Retinal analog restoration of photophobic responses in a blind Chlamydomonas reinhardtii mutant. Evidence for an archaebacterial like chromophore in a eukaryotic rhodopsin

The strain CC-2359 of the unicellular eukaryotic alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii originally described as a low pigmentation mutant is found to be devoid of photophobic stop responses to photostimuli over a wide range of light intensities. Photophobic responses of the mutant are restored by exogenous addition of all-trans retinal. We have combined computer-based cell-tracking and motion analysis with retinal isomer and retinal analog reconstitution of CC-2359 to investigate properties of the photophobic response receptor. Most rapid and most complete reconstitution is obtained with all-trans retinal compared to 13-cis, 11-cis, and 9-cis retinal. An analog locked by a carbon bridge in a 6-s-trans conformation reconstitutes whereas the corresponding 6-s-cis locked analog does not. Retinal analogs prevented from isomerization around the 13-14 double bond by a five-membered ring in the polyene chain (locked in either the 13-trans or 13-cis configuration) do not restore the response, but enter the chromophore binding pocket as evidenced by their inhibition of all-trans retinal regeneration of the response. Results of competition experiments between all-trans and each of the 13-locked analogs fit a model in which each chromophore exhibits reversible binding to the photoreceptor apoprotein. A competitive inhibition scheme closely fits the data and permits calculation of apparent dissociation constants for the in vivo reconstitution process of 2.5 x 10(-11) M, 5.2 x 10(-10) M, and 5.4 x 10(-9) M, for all-trans, 13-trans-locked and 13-cis-locked analogs, respectively. The chromophore requirement for the trans configuration and 6-s-trans conformation, and the lack of signaling function from analogs locked at the 13 position, are characteristic of archaebacterial rhodopsins, rather than the previously studied eukaryotic rhodopsins (i.e., visual pigments).

An unusual peptide conformation may precipitate amyloid formation in Alzheimer's disease: application of solid-state NMR to the determination of protein secondary structure

The formation of insoluble proteinaceous deposits is characteristic of many diseases which are collectively known as amyloidosis. There is very little molecular-level structural information available regarding the amyloid deposits due to the fact that the constituent proteins are insoluble and noncrystalline. Therefore, traditional protein structure determination methods such as solution NMR and X-ray crystallography are not applicable. We report herein the application of the solid-state NMR technique rotational resonance (R2) to the accurate measurement of carbon-to-carbon distances in the amyloid formed from a synthetic fragment (H2N-LeuMetValGlyGlyValValIleAla-CO2H) of the amyloid-forming protein of Alzheimer's disease (AD). This sequence has been implicated in the initiation of amyloid formation. Two distances measured by R2 indicate that an unusual structure, probably involving a cis amide bond, is present in the aggregated peptide amyloid. This structure is incompatible with the accepted models of fibril structure. A relationship between this structure and the stability of the amyloid is proposed.