The ribosome at improved resolution: new techniques for merging and orientation refinement in 3D cryo-electron microscopy of biological particles

Determining the structure of biological macromolecules by transmission electron microscopy, single particle analysis and 3D reconstruction

Single particle analysis and 3D reconstruction of molecules imaged by transmission electron microscopy have provided a wealth of medium to low resolution structures of biological molecules and macromolecular complexes, such as the ribosome, viruses, molecular chaperones and photosystem II. In this review, the principles of these techniques are introduced in a non-mathematical way, and single particle analysis is compared to other methods used for structural studies. In particular, the recent X-ray structures of the ribosome and of ribosomal subunits allow a critical comparison of single particle analysis and X-ray crystallography. This has emphasised the rapidity with which single particle analysis can produce medium resolution structures of complexes that are difficult to crystallise. Once crystals are available, X-ray crystallography can produce structures at a much higher resolution. The great similarities now seen between the structures obtained by the two techniques reinforce confidence in the use of single particle analysis and 3D reconstruction, and show that for electron cryo-microscopy structure distortion during sample preparation and imaging has not been a significant problem. The ability to analyse conformational flexibility and the ease with which time-resolved studies can be performed are significant advantages for single particle analysis. Future improvements in single particle analysis and electron microscopy should increase the attainable resolution. Combining single particle analysis of macromolecular complexes and electron tomography of subcellular structures with high-resolution X-ray structures may enable us to realise the ultimate dream of structural biology-a complete description of the macromolecular complexes of the cell in their different functional states.

A comparison of the yeast and rabbit 80 S ribosome reveals the topology of the nascent chain exit tunnel, inter-subunit bridges and mammalian rRNA expansion segments

Protein synthesis in eukaryotes is mediated by both cytoplasmic and membrane-bound ribosomes. During the co-translational translocation of secretory and membrane proteins, eukaryotic ribosomes dock with the protein conducting channel of the endoplasmic reticulum. An understanding of these processes will require the detailed structure of a eukaryotic ribosome. To this end, we have compared the three-dimensional structures of yeast and rabbit ribosomes at 24 A resolution. In general, we find that the active sites for protein synthesis and translocation have been highly conserved. It is interesting that a channel was visualized in the neck of the small subunit whose entrance is formed by a deep groove. By analogy with the prokaryotic small subunit, this channel may provide a conserved portal through which mRNA is threaded into the decoding center. In addition, both the small and large subunits are built around a dense tubular network. Our analysis further suggests that the nascent chain exit tunnel and the docking surface for the endoplasmic reticulum channel are formed by this network. We surmise that many of these features correspond to rRNA, based on biochemical and structural data. Ribosomal function is critically dependent on the specific association of small and large subunits. Our analysis of eukaryotic ribosomes reveals four conserved inter-subunit bridges with a geometry similar to that found in prokaryotes. In particular, a double-bridge connects the small subunit platform with the interface canyon on the large subunit. Moreover, a novel bridge is formed between the platform and the base of the L1 domain. Finally, size differences between mammalian and yeast large subunit rRNAs have been correlated with five expansion segments that form two large spines and three extended fingers. Overall, we find that expansion segments within the large subunit rRNA have been incorporated at positions distinct from the active sites for protein synthesis and translocation.

Visualization of tRNA movements on the Escherichia coli 70S ribosome during the elongation cycle

Three-dimensional cryomaps have been reconstructed for tRNA-ribosome complexes in pre- and posttranslocational states at 17-A resolution. The positions of tRNAs in the A and P sites in the pretranslocational complexes and in the P and E sites in the posttranslocational complexes have been determined. Of these, the P-site tRNA position is the same as seen earlier in the initiation-like fMet-tRNA(f)(Met)-ribosome complex, where it was visualized with high accuracy. Now, the positions of the A- and E-site tRNAs are determined with similar accuracy. The positions of the CCA end of the tRNAs at the A site are different before and after peptide bond formation. The relative positions of anticodons of P- and E-site tRNAs in the posttranslocational state are such that a codon-anticodon interaction at the E site appears feasible.

The structure of the C949S mutant human alpha(2)-macroglobulin demonstrates the critical role of the internal thiol esters in its proteinase-entrapping structural transformation

A three-dimensional reconstruction of a protein-engineered mutant alpha(2)-macroglobulin (alpha(2)M) in which a serine residue was substituted for the cysteine 949 (C949S), making it unable to form internal thiol ester moieties, was compared with native and methylamine-transformed alpha(2)Ms. The native alpha(2)M structure consists of two oppositely oriented Z-shaped strands. Thiol ester cleavage following an encounter with a proteinase or a nucleophilic attack by methylamine causes a structural transformation in which the strands assume an opposite handedness and a significant portion of the protein density migrates from the distal ends of the molecule toward the center. The C949S mutant showed a protein density distribution very similar to that of transformed alpha(2)M, with a compact central region of protein density connected to two receptor-binding arms on each end of the molecule. Since no particle shapes characteristic of native or half-transformed alpha(2)Ms were seen in electron micrographs and the C949S mutant and alpha(2)M-methylamine structures are highly similar, we conclude that the intact thiol esters maintain native alpha(2)M in a quasi-stable state. In their absence, alpha(2)M folds into the more stable transformed structure, which displays the functionally important receptor-binding domains and contains the proteinase-entrapping internal cavity.

Three-dimensional cryo-electron microscopy localization of EF2 in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae 80S ribosome at 17.5 A resolution

Using a sordarin derivative, an antifungal drug, it was possible to determine the structure of a eukaryotic ribosome small middle dotEF2 complex at 17.5 A resolution by three-dimensional (3D) cryo-electron microscopy. EF2 is directly visible in the 3D map and the overall arrangement of the complex from Saccharomyces cerevisiae corresponds to that previously seen in Escherichia coli. However, pronounced differences were found in two prominent regions. First, in the yeast system the interaction between the elongation factor and the stalk region of the large subunit is much more extensive. Secondly, domain IV of EF2 contains additional mass that appears to interact with the head of the 40S subunit and the region of the main bridge of the 60S subunit. The shape and position of domain IV of EF2 suggest that it might interact directly with P-site-bound tRNA.

Reassembly of Lumbricus terrestris hemoglobin: a study by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry and 3D reconstruction from frozen-hydrated specimens

Dodecamers and four types of linker chains (L1-L4) were purified from dissociated hemoglobin of the earthworm Lumbricus terrestris. Various preparations comprising dodecamer of globin chains and linker chains were allowed to reassemble at neutral pH. They produced various oligomers that were purified by gel filtration, analyzed in matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry and submitted to 3D reconstruction from isolated particles observed in cryoelectron microscopy. Despite the impossibility to completely free the L2, L3, and L4 preparations from L1, the following conclusions were obtained. First, hemoglobin molecules indistinguishable from native hemoglobin at 25 A resolution were obtained in the absence of linker chains L2, L3, or L4. Second, the 3D reconstruction volumes of reassembled hemoglobins containing dodecamers and L1+L3 or dodecamers and L1+L4 demonstrate that reassembly of native-like structures can be obtained from at most two linker chains and dodecamers. Third, the 3D reconstruction volumes of native and reassembled hemoglobins containing dodecamers and (1) L1, L2, and L4, (2) L1, L3, and L4, (3) L1 and L4, and (4) L1 and L3 were highly similar. Since these structures comprise two types of substructures (one involved in the c3a, c3b, and c4 linking units of the hollow globular substructure and the other in the c5 connection and the toroid), it seems highly probable that the minimal number of linker chains required to reassemble native-like hemoglobin is at most two.

Three-dimensional reconstructions of calcium/calmodulin-dependent (CaM) kinase IIalpha and truncated CaM kinase IIalpha reveal a unique organization for its structural core and functional domains

Studies of the structural organization of calcium/ calmodulin-dependent protein kinase IIalpha (CaM KIIalpha) and truncated CaM KIIalpha by three-dimensional electron microscopy and protein engineering show that the structures consist of 12 subunits that are organized in two stacked hexameric rings with 622 symmetry. The body of CaM KIIalpha is gear-shaped, consisting of six slanted flanges, and has six foot-like processes attached by narrow appendages to both ends of the flanges. Truncated CaM KIIalpha that lacks functional domains has a structure that is very similar to the body of CaM KIIalpha. Thus, the functional domains reside in the foot-like processes, and the association domain comprises the gear-shaped core. The ribbon diagram of the bilobate structure of CaM KI fits nicely in the envelope of the foot-like component and indicates that the crevice between the two lobes comprising the functional domains is near the middle portion of the foot. The clustering of the functional domains provides a favorable arrangement for the autophosphorylation reaction, and the unusual arrangement of the catalytic domain on extended tethers appears to be significant for the remarkable functional diversity of CaM KIIalpha in cellular regulation.

Solution structure of the E. coli 70S ribosome at 11.5 A resolution

Over 73,000 projections of the E. coli ribosome bound with formyl-methionyl initiator tRNAf(Met) were used to obtain an 11.5 A cryo-electron microscopy map of the complex. This map allows identification of RNA helices, peripheral proteins, and intersubunit bridges. Comparison of double-stranded RNA regions and positions of proteins identified in both cryo-EM and X-ray maps indicates good overall agreement but points to rearrangements of ribosomal components required for the subunit association. Fitting of known components of the 50S stalk base region into the map defines the architecture of the GTPase-associated center and reveals a major change in the orientation of the alpha-sarcin-ricin loop. Analysis of the bridging connections between the subunits provides insight into the dynamic signaling mechanism between the ribosomal subunits.

Amino acid residues 4425-4621 localized on the three-dimensional structure of the skeletal muscle ryanodine receptor

We have localized a region contained within the sequence of amino acid residues 4425-4621 on the three-dimensional structure of the skeletal muscle ryanodine receptor (RyR). Mouse monoclonal antibodies raised against a peptide comprising these residues have been complexed with ryanodine receptors and imaged in the frozen-hydrated state by cryoelectron microscopy. These images, along with images of antibody-free ryanodine receptor, were used to compute two-dimensional averaged images and three-dimensional reconstructions. Two-dimensional averages of immunocomplexes in which the ryanodine receptor was in the fourfold symmetrical orientation disclosed four symmetrical regions of density located on the edges of the receptor's cytoplasmic assembly that were absent from control averages of receptor without added antibody. Three-dimensional reconstructions revealed the antibody-binding sites to be on the so-called handle domains of the ryanodine receptor's cytoplasmic assembly, near their junction with the transmembrane assembly. This study is the first to demonstrate epitope mapping on the three-dimensional structure of the ryanodine receptor.

Sepia officinalis hemocyanin: A refined 3D structure from field emission gun cryoelectron microscopy

The extracellular respiratory pigment of the cuttlefish Sepia officinalis was observed by cryoelectron microscopy with conventional LaB(6) and field emission gun electron sources at 100 and 200 kV, respectively. Each image series was used to compute one 3D reconstruction volume with correction of the contrast transfer function by Wiener filtering. A strong boosting of the contrast was corrected by band-pass filtering of the final volumes, and a qualitative gain in resolution was observed when using the field emission gun electron microscope. In this volume, a strong signal is present down to 1/18 A(-1) and some meaningful information is obtained down to 1/12.5 A(-1). The complex is composed of five pairs of polypeptide chains and resembles a hollow cylinder with five wall oblique units and five inner arches. Three types of wall-wall connections termed pillar P1 to P3 are visible in this volume and the four functional units present in the arches are each linked to the wall by two arch-wall connections. The dispositions of the functional units in the arches of Sepia and Octopus hemocyanins share no common feature.

Structure of the Ni/Fe-S protein subcomponent of the acetyl-CoA decarbonylase/synthase complex from Methanosarcina thermophila at 26-A resolution

The acetyl-CoA decarbonylase/synthase (ACDS) complex is responsible for synthesis and cleavage of acetyl-CoA in methanogens. The complex is composed of five different subunits, with a probable stoichiometry of alpha(8)beta(8)gamma(8)delta(8)epsilon(8). The native molecular mass of a subcomponent of the ACDS complex from Methanosarcina thermophila, the Ni/Fe-S protein containing the 90-kDa alpha and 19-kDa epsilon subunits, was determined by scanning transmission electron microscopy. A value of 218.6 +/- 19.6 kDa (n = 566) was obtained, thus establishing that the oligomeric structure of this subcomponent is alpha(2)epsilon(2). The three-dimensional structure of alpha(2)epsilon(2) was determined at 26-A resolution by analysis of a large number of electron microscopic images of negatively stained, randomly oriented particles. The alpha(2)epsilon(2) subcomponent has a globular appearance, 110 A in diameter, and consists of two large, hemisphere-like masses that surround a hollow internal cavity. The two large masses are connected along one face by a bridge-like structure and have relatively less protein density joining them at other positions. The internal cavity has four main openings to the outside, one of which is directly adjacent to the bridge. The results are consistent with a structure in which the large hemispheric masses are assigned to the two alpha subunits, with epsilon(2) as the bridge forming a structural link between them. The structure of the alpha(2)epsilon(2) subcomponent is discussed in connection with biochemical data from gel filtration, crosslinking, and dissociation experiments and in the context of its function as a major component of the ACDS complex.

Three-dimensional structure of the human TFIID-IIA-IIB complex

The multisubunit transcription factor IID (TFIID) is an essential component of the eukaryotic RNA polymerase II machinery that works in concert with TFIIA (IIA) and TFIIB (IIB) to assemble initiation complexes at core eukaryotic promoters. Here the structures of human TFIID and the TFIID-IIA-IIB complex that were obtained by electron microscopy and image analysis to 35 angstrom resolution are presented. TFIID is a trilobed, horseshoe-shaped structure, with TFIIA and TFIIB bound on opposite lobes and flanking a central cavity. Antibody studies locate the TATA-binding protein (TBP) between TFIIA and TFIIB at the top of the cavity that most likely encompasses the TATA DNA binding region of the supramolecular complex.

Haloarcula marismortui 50S subunit-complementarity of electron microscopy and X-Ray crystallographic information

The large 50S subunit of the Haloarcula marismortui 70S ribosome was solved to 19 A using cryo-electron microscopy and single particle reconstruction techniques and to 9 A using X-ray crystallography. In the latter case, phases were determined by multiple isomorphous replacement and anomalous scattering from three heavy atom derivatives. The availability of X-ray and electron microscopy (EM) data has made it possible to compare the results of the two experimental methods. In the flexible regions of the 50S subunit, small differences in the mass distribution were detected. These differences can be attributed to the influence of packing in the crystal cell. The rotationally averaged power spectra of X-ray and EM were compared in an overlapping spatial frequency range from 60 to 13 A. The resulting ratio of X-ray to EM power ranges from 1 to 15, reflecting a progressively larger underestimation of the Fourier amplitudes by the electron microscope.

Structural comparison of cephalopod hemocyanins: phylogenetic significance

Hemocyanins, the respiratory molecules of cephalopod mollusks, are hollow cylinders with five internal arches. Three hemocyanins representative of three orders of cephalopods (Benthoctopus species, Octopoda; Vampyroteuthis infernalis, Vampyromorpha; Sepia officinalis, Sepioidea) were subjected to cryoelectron microscopy and three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction. The structure of Benthoctopus hemocyanin, solved at 26.4-A resolution, possesses arches comprising two identical functional units. The similarity between these functional units and the structure recently observed in X-ray crystallography for Octopus by Cuff et al. (J. Mol. Biol., 1998, 232, 522-529) allows the identification of their N- and C-terminal domains in the 3D reconstruction volume. Conversely, arches present in the 3D reconstruction volume of Sepia hemocyanin (21.8 A resolution) contain four functional units that are disposed differently. The strong resemblance between the reconstruction volumes of Vampyroteuthis (21.4-A resolution) and Benthoctopus hemocyanins suggests that Sepioidea diverged from a group containing Octopoda and Vampyromorpha.

A two-exposure technique for ice-embedded samples successfully reconstructs the chlorocruorin pigment of Sabella spallanzanii at 2. 1 Nm resolution

A technique for reconstructing ice-embedded macromolecules from electron micrographs taken at two specimen tilts (+/-23 degrees ) has been used to determine the structure of chlorocruorin isolated from the Polychaete annelid Sabella spallanzanii. Images of individual molecules were extracted in couples from two micrographs of the same field of view so each couple consists of two projections of the same molecule. One couple was used as a fixed reference for alignment. Different references yielded reconstructions with different orientations. These were merged to give a model against which the orientation of 1624 first-exposure images was refined to give a final reconstruction at 2.1 nm resolution. The structure of this hematic pigment, essentially the same as that for Lumbricus terrestris, is a bilayer structure with overall symmetry D6, containing six hollow groups per layer. A hollow group is formed by six globular masses and has approximate threefold symmetry. Other structural elements connect the two layers and the hollow groups in a layer. This non-globin material occupies about 15% of the total molecular volume. The results show that the double-exposure strategy, previously described by some of the authors and tested in computer simulations, performs well in real experiments and could be used to obtain preliminary reconstructions in a semiautomatic way.

Three-dimensional location of the imperatoxin A binding site on the ryanodine receptor

Cryo-electron microscopy and three-dimensional, single-particle image analysis have been used to reveal the specific binding site of imperatoxin A (IpTx(a)) on the architecture of the calcium release channel/ryanodine receptor from skeletal muscle (RyR1). IpTx(a) is a peptide toxin that binds with high affinity to RyR1 and affects its functioning. The toxin was derivatized with biotin to enhance its detection with streptavidin. IpTx(a) binds to the cytoplasmic moiety of RyR1 between the clamp and handle domains, 11 nm away from the transmembrane pore. The proposed mimicry by IpTx(a) of the dihydropyridine receptor (DHPR) II-III loop, thought to be a main physiological excitation-contraction trigger, suggests that the IpTx(a) binding location is a potential excitation-contraction signal transduction site.

Three-dimensional reconstruction of Lumbricus terrestris hemoglobin at 22 A resolution: intramolecular localization of the globin and linker chains

A 3D reconstruction of the hemoglobin (Hb) of the earthworm Lumbricus terrestris was carried out by the 3D projection alignment method from electron microscopy images of a frozen-hydrated specimen at 22 A resolution. The results were analyzed by a new approach taking into account the evolution of the 210 densities forming the 3D volume as a function of the threshold of surface representation. The whole oligomer with D6point-group symmetry is comprised of 12 hollow globular substructures (HGS) with local 3-fold symmetry tethered to a complex network of linking subunits (linker complex). The 12 globin subunits of each HGS are distributed around local 3-fold axis in four layers of three subunits. The first layer, the most external, contains monomeric globin chains 2A, 3A, and 5A. The three trimers corresponding to the nine remaining subunits have one subunit in each of the second (2B, 3B, 5B), third (1A, 4A, 6A), and fourth (1B, 4B, 6B) layer. The distances between the centers of the globin chains forming the trimers are in the ranges 20-32 A and 45-52 A. The linker complex is made up of two types of linking units. The first type forms three loops connecting globin chains of the second, third and fourth layers. The average molecular mass (Mm) of these subunits was 25 kDa. The second type forms the central structure, termed hexagonal toroid, and its 12 connections to the HGS. This structure corresponds to a hexamer of a single linking unit with a Mm (31.2 kDa), size and a shape different from those of the HGS loops. A careful study of 3D volume architecture shows that each toroid linking unit is bound to the three loops of a HGS pair located in the upper and lower hexagonal layers, respectively. As shown in a model of architecture, hexagonal bilayered (HBL) Hbs can be built very simply from 144 globin chains and 42 linker chains belonging to two different types. We also propose a simple assembly sequence for the construction of HBL Hbs based on the architecture model.

Location of translational initiation factor IF3 on the small ribosomal subunit

The location of translational initiation factor IF3 bound to the 30S subunit of the Thermus thermophilus ribosome has been determined by cryoelectron microscopy. Both the 30S.IF3 complex and control 30S subunit structures were determined to 27-A resolution. The difference map calculated from the two reconstructions reveals three prominent lobes of positive density. The previously solved crystal structure of IF3 fits very well into two of these lobes, whereas the third lobe probably arises from conformational changes induced in the 30S subunit as a result of IF3 binding. Our placement of IF3 on the 30S subunit allows an understanding in structural terms of the biochemical functions of this initiation factor, namely its ability to dissociate 70S ribosomes into 30S and 50S subunits and the preferential selection of initiator tRNA by IF3 during initiation.

Effect of buffer conditions on the position of tRNA on the 70 S ribosome as visualized by cryoelectron microscopy

The effect of buffer conditions on the binding position of tRNA on the Escherichia coli 70 S ribosome have been studied by means of three-dimensional (3D) cryoelectron microscopy. Either deacylated tRNAfMet or fMet-tRNAfMet were bound to the 70 S ribosomes, which were programmed with a 46-nucleotide mRNA having AUG codon in the middle, under two different buffer conditions (conventional buffer: containing Tris and higher Mg2+ concentration [10-15 mM]; and polyamine buffer: containing Hepes, lower Mg2+ concentration [6 mM], and polyamines). Difference maps, obtained by subtracting 3D maps of naked control ribosome in the corresponding buffer from the 3D maps of tRNA.ribosome complexes, reveal the distinct locations of tRNA on the ribosome. The position of deacylated tRNAfMet depends on the buffer condition used, whereas that of fMet-tRNAfMet remains the same in both buffer conditions. The acylated tRNA binds in the classical P site, whereas deacylated tRNA binds mostly in an intermediate P/E position under the conventional buffer condition and mostly in the position corresponding to the classical P site, i. e. in the P/P state, under the polyamine buffer conditions.

Structure and structural variations of the Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal subunit as revealed by three-dimensional cryo-electron microscopy

A three-dimensional reconstruction of the 30 S subunit of the Escherichia coli ribosome was obtained at 23 A resolution. Because of the improved resolution, many more structural details are seen as compared to those obtained in earlier studies. Thus, the new structure is more suitable for comparison with the 30 S subunit part of the 70 S ribosome, whose structure is already known at a better resolution. In addition, we observe relative and, to some extent, independent movements of three main structural domains of the 30 S subunit, namely head, platform and the main body, which lead to partial blurring of the reconstructed volume. An attempt to subdivide the data set into conformationally defined subsets reveals the existence of conformers in which these domains have different orientations with respect to one another. This result suggests the existence of dynamic properties of the 30 S subunit that might be required for facilitating its interactions with mRNA, tRNA and other ligands during protein biosynthesis.

Structure of the insect troponin complex

Isolated troponin-tropomyosin complex from Lethocerus indicus asynchronous flight muscle forms paracrystals on a positively charged lipid monolayer. Single particle analysis was carried out on individual complexes selected from electron micrographs of negatively stained paracrystals. By a combination of correlation and classification techniques, different average projections of the object were obtained. An initial three-dimensional model was calculated by determining the Euler angles for the different views using a common line approach. This starting model was then used as a reference for the further three-dimensional refinement of the model using the original data set. The refined model of the troponin complex has a diameter of approximately 90 A and a volume corresponding with a molecular mass of about 120 kDa for the globular domain. The resolution of the reconstruction was determined to be 32 A using the differential phase residual method and 26 A using the Fourier shell correlation criterion.

The ribosome-structure and functional ligand-binding experiments using cryo-electron microscopy

Cryo-electron microscopy has greatly advanced our understanding of the basic steps of protein synthesis in the bacterial ribosome. This article gives an overview of what has been achieved so far. Through three-dimensional visualization of complexes that represent the ribosome in defined binding states, locations were derived for the tRNA in A, P, and E sites, as well as the elongation factors. In addition, the pathways of messenger RNA and the exiting polypeptide chain could be inferred.

Three-dimensional structure of the human plasmin alpha2-macroglobulin complex

The three-dimensional reconstructions of the human plasmin alpha2-macroglobulin binary complex were computed from electron microscopy images of stain and frozen-hydrated specimens. The structures show excellent agreement and reveal a molecule with approximate dimensions of 170 (length) x 140 (width) x 140 A (depth). The asymmetric plasmin structure imparts significant asymmetry to the plasmin alpha2-macroglobulin complex not seen in the structures resulting from the reaction of alpha2-macroglobulin with methylamine or chymotrypsin. The structure shows, when combined with other studies, that the C-terminal catalytic domain of the rod-shaped plasmin molecule is entrapped inside of the alpha2-macroglobulin cavity, whereas its N-terminal kringle domains protrude outside one end between the two arm-like features of the transformed alpha2-macroglobulin structure. This arrangement ensures that the catalytic site of plasmin is prevented from degrading plasma proteins. The internalized C-terminal portion of the plasmin structure resides primarily on the major axis of alpha2-macroglobulin, suggesting that after the initial cleavage of the two bait domains and the thiol esters, the rod-shaped plasmin molecule enters the alpha2-macroglobulin cavity through the large openings afforded by the half-transformed structure. This mode of entrapment requires the untwisting and the separation of the two strands that constitute the alpha2-macroglobulin structure.

Clathrin coats at 21 A resolution: a cellular assembly designed to recycle multiple membrane receptors

We present a map at 21 A resolution of clathrin assembled into cages with the endocytic adaptor complex, AP-2. The map was obtained by cryo-electron microscopy and single-particle reconstruction. It reveals details of the packing of entire clathrin molecules as they interact to form a cage with two nested polyhedral layers. The proximal domains of each triskelion leg depart from a cage vertex in a skewed orientation, forming a slightly twisted bundle with three other leg domains. Thus, each triskelion contributes to two connecting edges of the polyhedral cage. The clathrin heavy chains continue inwards under the vertices with local 3-fold symmetry, the terminal domains contributing to 'hook-like' features which form an intermediate network making possible contacts with the surface presented by the inner adaptor shell. A node of density projecting inwards from the vertex may correspond to the C-termini of clathrin heavy chains which form a protrusion on free triskelions at the vertex. The inter-subunit interactions visible in this map provide a structural basis for considering the assembly of clathrin coats on a membrane and show the contacts which will need to be disrupted during disassembly.

Cryoelectron microscopy and image analysis of the cardiac ryanodine receptor

The three-dimensional structure of the cardiac muscle ryanodine receptor (RyR2) is described and compared with its skeletal muscle isoform (RyR1). Previously, structural studies of RyR2 have not been as informative as those for RyR1 because optimal conditions for electron microscopy, which require low levels of phospholipid, are destabilizing for RyR2. A simple procedure was devised for diluting RyR2 (in phospholipid-containing buffer) into a lipid-free buffer directly on the electron microscope grid, followed by freezing within a few seconds. Cryoelectron microscopy of RyR2 so prepared yielded images of sufficient quality for analysis by single particle image processing. Averaged projection images for RyR2, as well as for RyR1, prepared under the same conditions, were found to be nearly identical in overall dimensions and appearance at the resolution attained, approximately 30 A. An initial three-dimensional reconstruction of RyR2 was determined (resolution approximately 41 A) and compared with previously reported reconstructions of RyR1. Although they looked similar, which is consistent with the similarity found for the projection images, and with expectations based on the 66% amino acid sequence identity of the two isoforms, structural differences near the corners of the cytoplasmic assembly were observed in both two- and three-dimensional studies.

Escherichia coli 70 S ribosome at 15 A resolution by cryo-electron microscopy: localization of fMet-tRNAfMet and fitting of L1 protein

Cryo-electron microscopy of the ribosome in different binding states with mRNA and tRNA helps unravel the different steps of protein synthesis. Using over 29,000 projections of a ribosome complex in single-particle form, a three-dimensional map of the Escherichia coli 70 S ribosome was obtained in which a single site, the P site, is occupied by fMet-tRNAfMet as directed by an AUG codon containing mRNA. The superior resolution of this three-dimensional map, 14.9 A, has made it possible to fit the tRNA X-ray crystal structure directly and unambiguously into the electron density, thus determining the locations of anticodon-codon interaction and peptidyltransferase center of the ribosome. Furthermore, at this resolution, one of the distinctly visible domains corresponding to a ribosomal protein, L1, closely matches with its X-ray structure.

A 9 A resolution X-ray crystallographic map of the large ribosomal subunit

The 50S subunit of the ribosome catalyzes the peptidyl-transferase reaction of protein synthesis. We have generated X-ray crystallographic electron density maps of the large ribosomal subunit from Haloarcula marismortui at various resolutions up to 9 A using data from crystals that diffract to 3 A. Positioning a 20 A resolution EM image of these particles in the crystal lattice produced phases accurate enough to locate the bound heavy atoms in three derivatives using difference Fourier maps, thus demonstrating the correctness of the EM model and its placement in the unit cell. At 20 A resolution, the X-ray map is similar to the EM map; however, at 9 A it reveals long, continuous, but branched features whose shape, diameter, and right-handed twist are consistent with segments of double-helical RNA that crisscross the subunit.

Visualization of elongation factor G on the Escherichia coli 70S ribosome: the mechanism of translocation

During protein synthesis, elongation factor G (EF-G) binds to the ribosome and promotes the step of translocation, a process in which tRNA moves from the A to the P site of the ribosome and the mRNA is advanced by one codon. By using three-dimensional cryo-electron microscopy, we have visualized EF-G in a ribosome-EF-G-GDP-fusidic acid complex. Fitting the crystal structure of EF-G-GDP into the cryo density map reveals a large conformational change mainly associated with domain IV, the domain that mimics the shape of the anticodon arm of the tRNA in the structurally homologous ternary complex of Phe-tRNAPhe, EF-Tu, and a GTP analog. The tip portion of this domain is found in a position that overlaps the anticodon arm of the A-site tRNA, whose position in the ribosome is known from a study of the pretranslocational complex, implying that EF-G displaces the A-site tRNA to the P site by physical interaction with the anticodon arm.

Three-dimensional structure of bovine NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I) at 22 A in ice

NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I) is the first and largest complex in the electron transport chain of mitochondria. The bovine complex purified from cardiac muscle consists of at least 42 different subunits with a combined molecular mass of about 890 kDa. The three-dimensional structure of the complex was determined at 22 A from single particles embedded in vitrified ice using electron cryo-microscopy. The structure was calculated using a new program to align particles, to correct for the contrast transfer function of the microscope, and to carry out the three-dimensional reconstruction of the complex. The bovine complex has the overall L-shaped appearance found in earlier studies of the closely related complex I from Neurospora crassa, but it differs by having a thin stalk region linking the membrane-bound globular arm with the intrinsic membrane domain. Thus, the stalk which measures about 30 A in diameter is likely to contain part of the electron transfer pathway linking the NADH binding site in the globular arm with the ubiquinone binding site in the membrane domain. The globular domain of bovine complex I is significantly bigger than that of the N. crassa enzyme, suggesting that the apparent additional subunit complexity of the bovine enzyme is associated with the globular part.

On the structural changes of native human alpha2-macroglobulin upon proteinase entrapment. Three-dimensional structure of the half-transformed molecule

The reconstructions of an intermediate form of human alpha2-macroglobulin (half-transformed alpha2M) in which two of its four bait regions and thiol ester sites were cleaved by chymotrypsin bound to Sepharose were obtained by three-dimensional electron microscopy from stain and frozen-hydrated specimens. The structures show excellent agreement and reveal a structure with approximate dimensions of 195 (length) x 135 (width) and 130 A (depth) with an internal funnel-shaped cavity. The structure shows that a chisel-shaped body is connected to a broad base at the opposing end by four stands. Four approximately 45 A diameter large openings in the body of the structure result in a central cavity that is more accessible to the proteinase than those associated with the native or fully transformed structures. The dissimilarity in the shapes between the two ends of alpha2M half-transformed and the similarity between its chisel-shaped body and that of native alpha2M indicate that the chymotrypsin has cleaved both bait regions in the bottom-half of the structure. Consequently, its functional division lies on the minor axis. The structural organization is in accord with biochemical studies, which show that the half-transformed alpha2M migrates on native polyacrylamide gels at a rate intermediate to the native and fully transformed alpha2M and is capable of trapping 1 mol of proteinase. Even though its upper portion is similar to the native molecule, significant differences in their shapes are apparent and these differences may be related to its slower reaction with a proteinase than the native structure. These structural comparisons further support the view that the transformation of alpha2M involves an untwisting of its strands with an opening of the cavity for entrance of the proteinase and a retwisting of the strands around the proteinase resulting in its encapsulation.

3D reconstruction in electron microscopy using ART with smooth spherically symmetric volume elements (blobs)

Algebraic reconstruction techniques (ART) are iterative procedures for solving systems of linear equations. They have been used in tomography to recover objects from their projections. In this work we apply an ART approach in which the basis functions used to describe the objects are not based on voxels, but are much smoother functions named "blobs". The data collection studied in this work follows the so-called "conical tilt geometry" that is commonly used in many applications of three-dimensional electron microscopy of biological macromolecules. The performance of ART with blobs is carefully compared with a currently well-known three dimensional (3D) reconstruction algorithm (weighted back projection) using a methodology which assigns a level of statistical significance to a claim of relative superiority of one algorithm over another for a particular task. The conclusion we reach is that ART with blobs produces high-quality reconstructions and is, in particular, superior to weighted backprojection in recovering features along the "vertical" direction. For the exact implementation recommended in this paper, the computational costs of ART are almost an order of magnitude smaller than those of WBP.

Consistent structure between bacterial and mitochondrial NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I)

Respiratory chains of bacteria and mitochondria contain closely related forms of the proton-pumping NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I). In bacteria the complex has a molecular mass of approximately 530 kDa and consists of 14 different subunits. The homologues of these 14 subunits together with some 27 additional subunits make up the mitochondrial complex, adding up to a molecular mass of approximately 1 MDa. We calculated three-dimensional models at medium resolution of isolated and negatively stained complex I particles from Eschericha coli and Neurospora crassa by electron microscopy using the random conical tilt reconstruction technique. Both the bacterial and the mitochondrial complexes are L-shaped molecules with an intrinsic membrane arm extending into the lipid bilayer and a peripheral arm protruding from the membrane. It is discussed whether the consistent length of the arms of both complexes has an implication for their function. The additional protein mass of the mitochondrial complex is distributed along both arms, but especially around the junction between the two arms and around the membrane arm. It appears that the structural framework of procaryotic complex I is stabilized in eucaryotes by this additional mass. A discrete location of additional protein in the peripheral arm of the mitochondrial complex is interpreted as being the possible position of two subunits with a specialized role in the biosynthesis of a yet unknown cofactor of complex I.

Three-dimensional structure of the yeast ribosome

The 80S ribosome from Saccharomyces cerevisiae has been reconstructed from cryo electron micrographs to a resolution of 35 A. It is strikingly similar to the 70S ribosome from Escherichia coli, while displaying the characteristic eukaryotic features familiar from reconstructions of ribosomes from higher eukaryotes. Aside from the elaboration of a number of peripherally located features on the two subunits and greater overall size, the largest difference between the yeast and E.coli ribosomes is in a mass increase on one side of the large (60S) subunit. It thus appears more elliptical than the characteristically globular 50S subunit from E.coli. The interior of the 60S subunit reveals a variable diameter tunnel spanning the subunit between the interface canyon and a site on the lower back of the subunit, presumably the exit site through which the nascent polypeptide chain emerges from the ribosome.

Alignment of conduits for the nascent polypeptide chain in the ribosome-Sec61 complex

An oligomer of the Sec61 trimeric complex is thought to form the protein-conducting channel for protein transport across the endoplasmic reticulum. A purified yeast Sec61 complex bound to monomeric yeast ribosomes as an oligomer in a saturable fashion. Cryo-electron microscopy of the ribosome-Sec61 complex and a three-dimensional reconstruction showed that the Sec61 oligomer is attached to the large ribosomal subunit by a single connection. Moreover, a funnel-shaped pore in the Sec61 oligomer aligned with the exit of a tunnel traversing the large ribosomal subunit, strongly suggesting that both structures function together in the translocation of proteins across the endoplasmic reticulum membrane.

Automated correlation and averaging of three-dimensional reconstructions obtained by electron tomography

We have developed a least-squares refinement procedure that in an automated way performs three-dimensional alignment and averaging of objects from multiple reconstructions. The computer implementation aligns the three-dimensional structures by a two-step procedure that maximizes the density overlap for all objects. First, an initial average density is built by successive incorporation of individual objects, after a global search for their optimal three-dimensional orientations. Second, the initial average is subsequently refined by excluding individual objects one at a time, realigning them with the reduced average containing all other objects and including them into the average again. The refinement is repeated until no further change of the average occurs. The resulting average model is therefore minimally biased by the order in which the individual reconstructions are incorporated into the average. The performance of the procedure was tested using a synthetic data set of randomly oriented objects with Poisson-distributed noise added. The program managed well to align and average the objects at the signal/noise ratio 1.0. The increase in signal/noise ratio was in all investigated cases almost equal to the expected square root of the number of objects. The program was also successfully tested on a set of authentic three-dimensional reconstructions from an in situ specimen containing Escherichia coli 70S ribosomes, where the immediate environment of the reconstructed objects may also contain variable amounts of other structures.

Electron Tomography of Single Ice-Embedded Macromolecules: Three-Dimensional Alignment and Classification

From 3-D reconstructions of automatically recorded tilt series of ice-embedded macromolecules, several hundred 3-D images of single particles can be extracted. Here we describe correlation-based techniques to align the particles with respect to translation and orientation in 3-D and the calculation of an averaged reconstruction after application of the correct weighting function to the particle projections. Multivariate statistical analysis and classification are applied to the set of three-dimensionally reconstructed particles to investigate interimage variations on the 3-D level. Copyright 1997 Academic Press. Copyright 1997 Academic Press

Flexibility within myosin heads revealed by negative stain and single-particle analysis

Electron microscopy of negatively stained myosin has previously revealed three discrete regions within the heads of the molecule. However, despite a probable resolution of approximately 2 nm, it is difficult to discern directly consistent details within these regions. This is due to variability in both head conformation and in staining. In this study, we applied single-particle image processing and classified heads into homogeneous groups. The improved signal-to-noise ratio after averaging these groups reveals substantially improved detail. The image averages were compared to a model simulating negative staining of the atomic structure of subfragment-1 (S1). This shows that the three head regions correspond to the motor domain and the essential and regulatory light chains. The image averages were very similar to particular views of the S1 model. They also revealed considerable flexibility between the motor and regulatory domains, despite the molecules having been prepared in the absence of nucleotide. This flexibility probably results from rotation of the regulatory domain about the motor domain, where the relative movement of the regulatory light chain is up to 12 nm, and is most clearly illustrated in animated sequences (available at http://www.leeds.ac.uk/chb/muscle/myosinhead.htm l). The sharply curved conformation of the atomic model of S1 is seen only rarely in our data, with straighter heads being more typical.

Utility of Butvar support film and methylamine tungstate stain in three-dimensional electron microscopy: agreement between stain and frozen-hydrated reconstructions

A random conical tilt reconstruction of negatively stained Saccharomyces cerevisiae fatty acid synthase was used as a model to compute a three-dimensional reconstruction from untilted stain specimens of the molecules in multiple orientations using a three-dimensional projection alignment method. The resulting structure (24 A resolution) has a more uniform resolution than the initial structure and the handedness revealed in the random conical tilt method is preserved. In a similar approach, this model was used to compute a 21-A-resolution frozen-hydrated structure from untilted specimens of the molecules in multiple orientations. Even though the reconstructions are in close agreement, the stain structure appears to enhance the protein density associated with less robust features. These procedures significantly reduce the time and effort required to obtain a three-dimensional reconstruction from frozen-hydrated data with a resolution that is comparable to the best obtained by more laborious methods. The agreement between the stain and frozen-hydrated reconstructions affords convincing evidence concerning the validity of the structure and the information afforded by the two reconstructions significantly enhances the structural analysis of the molecule.

Structure of keyhole limpet hemocyanin type 1 (KLH1) at 15 A resolution by electron cryomicroscopy and angular reconstitution

A three-dimensional reconstruction of keyhole limpet hemocyanin type 1 (KLH1) has been obtained using electron cryomicroscopy at liquid helium temperatures and single particle image processing. The use of a high-contrast embedding medium, 1% (w/v) glucose and 2% (w/v) ammonium molybdate (pH 7.0), enables high-resolution electron micrographs to be recorded close to focus, i.e. with excellent transfer of high-resolution information, while maintaining enough image contrast to localise the individual macromolecules in the images. When low-pass filtered to approximately 45 A resolution, the new 15 A resolution reconstruction is very similar to the earlier reconstructions of gastropodan hemocyanins of specimens embedded in vitreous ice. The map shows much detail and reveals many new symmetry elements in this very large cylindrical molluscan hemocyanin. The full KLH1 didecamer has D5 pointgroup symmetry, yet within the KLH1 decameric half-molecules local 2-fold axes have emerged that make the wall of the KLH1 decamer, in spite of its having an exact C5 symmetry only, resemble the D5-symmetric wall of the decameric cephalopod hemocyanins. In fact, the outside of each tier of this six-tiered gastropodan hemocyanin was found to have an approximate D5 symmetry. Local 2-fold axes also relate the "functional units" within the dimeric "morphological units" of the wall and the collar areas of the 8 MDa KLH1 molecule. Certain local-symmetry-related surface motifs may be present up to 60 times on the outside wall of this highly symmetric cylindrical hemocyanin. Keyhole limpet hemocyanin is used clinically as an immunostimulant. The very strong immune reaction elicited by this hemocyanin may be associated with its intricate hierarchy of local-symmetry components.

Three-dimensional reconstruction with contrast transfer function correction from energy-filtered cryoelectron micrographs: procedure and application to the 70S Escherichia coli ribosome

Cryoelectron microscopy provides the means of studying macromolecules in their native state. However, the contrast transfer function (CTF) makes the images and the three-dimensional (3D) maps derived from them difficult to interpret. We developed methods to determine the CTF from experimental data and to obtain a CTF-corrected 3D reconstruction. The CTF correction and 3D reconstruction accomplished in one step make it easy to combine different defocus data sets and decrease the error accumulation in the computation. These methods were applied to energy-filtered images of the 70S Escherichia coli ribosome, resulting in a distortion-free 3D map of the ribosome at 1/24.5 A-1 resolution, as determined by the differential phase residual resolution criterion.

Three-dimensional reconstruction of Limulus polyphemus hemocyanin from cryoelectron microscopy

Hemocyanin (Hc) the respiratory pigment of the horseshoe crab Limulus polyphemus (Lp) is composed of 48 approximately 75 kDa copper-containing subunits arranged in eight hexameric groups. In this study, we used the random conical tilt series method to do a three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction of Lp Hc observed in vitreous ice. This approach allowed the unambiguous determination of the handedness of the molecule. Lp Hc contains two superimposed 4 x 6mer structures possessing the same structural features as the other 4 x 6meric Hcs, namely flip and flop views and a rocking effect. Moreover, 3D fitting of the X-ray structure of subunit LpII with the reconstruction volume shows that the intra4 x 6meric contacts described in arthropod Hcs also occur within Limulus Hc. The two half-molecules composing the 8 x 6mer have their flop faces in contact (flop/flop association), the main links being formed by subunits LpIV. Model building shows that the flop/flop association is the only possible arrangement which allows the assembly of the whole particle. The two alternate constructions (flip/flop and flip/flip) are forbidden because of steric hindrance.

Structure-function relationships of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae fatty acid synthase. Three-dimensional structure

The three-dimensional structure of the Saccharomyces cerevisie fatty acid synthase was computed from electron microscopy of stain images. The barrel-shaped structure (point group symmetry 32) has major and minor axes of approximately 245 x 220 A, respectively, and consists of two different subunits organized in an alpha6beta6 complex (Mr = 2.5 x 10(6)). Two sets of three beta subunits form triangle-shaped caps that enclose the ends of the barrel. The wall of the barrel appears to consist of three N-shaped alpha subunit pairs each with an over and underlying arch-shaped beta subunit. Inside the molecule there are three major interconnected cavities that are tilted approximately 20 degrees with respect to its major axis. An axle-shaped structure extends the length of the cavity on the 3-fold axis and is connected to the two ends of the barrel. The cavities are partially divided on the equator of the molecule by three spokes that extend from the axle on the 2-fold axis to the exterior wall. We propose that these six cavities constitute the six equivalent sites of fatty acid synthesis resulting in an extraordinary structure-function relationship with the 42 catalytic sites involved in fatty acid synthesis inside the molecule. The six cavities each have two funnel-shaped openings ( approximately 20 A in diameter) which may serve to permit the diffusion of substrates and products in and out of these functional units. The subunits appear to be arranged in a manner that affords extensive intermolecular interactions contributing to the stability of this macromolecular complex.

Three-dimensional reconstruction of the hexagonal bilayer hemoglobin of the hydrothermal vent tube worm Riftia pachyptila by cryoelectron microscopy

A frozen-hydrated specimen of the V1 hemoglobin of the hydrothermal vent tube worm Riftia pachyptila was observed in the electron microscope and subjected to three-dimensional reconstruction by the method of random conical tilt series. The 3D volume possesses a D6 point-group symmetry. When viewed along its 6-fold axis the vertices of its upper hexagonal layer are 16 degrees clockwise rotated compared to those of the lower layer. A central linker complex is decorated by 12 hollow globular substructures. The linker complex comprises (i) a central hexagonal toroid, (ii) two internal bracelets onto which the hollow globular substructures are built, and (iii) six structures connecting the two hexagonal layers. The hollow globular substructures, related to the dodecamers of globin chains resulting from the dissociation of the hexagonal bilayer hemoglobin, have a local pseudo 3-fold symmetry and are composed each of three elongated structures visible when the volume is displayed at high threshold. At a resolution of 36 A, the 3D volumes of the hexagonal bilayer hemoglobins of Riftia pachyptyla and of the leech Macrobdella decora look almost perfectly identical.