HSP100/Clp proteins: a common mechanism explains diverse functions

Molecular chaperones: clamps for the Clps?

The Clp/Hsp100 molecular chaperones are unusual in their ability to tease apart protein aggregates and complexes. Recent results make a good case that these chaperones bind substrates via PDZ-like domains; this may reflect a general strategy for manipulating the] assembly state of substrate proteins.

Enzymatic and structural similarities between the Escherichia coli ATP-dependent proteases, ClpXP and ClpAP

Escherichia coli ClpX, a member of the Clp family of ATPases, has ATP-dependent chaperone activity and is required for specific ATP-dependent proteolytic activities expressed by ClpP. Gel filtration and electron microscopy showed that ClpX subunits (Mr 46, 000) associate to form a six-membered ring (Mr approximately 280, 000) that is stabilized by binding of ATP or nonhydrolyzable analogs of ATP. ClpP, which is composed of two seven-membered rings stacked face-to-face, interacts with the nucleotide-stabilized hexamer of ClpX to form a complex that could be isolated by gel filtration. Electron micrographs of negatively stained ClpXP preparations showed side views of 1:1 and 2:1 ClpXP complexes in which ClpP was flanked on either one or both sides by a ring of ClpX. Thus, as was seen for ClpAP, a symmetry mismatch exists in the bonding interactions between the seven-membered rings of ClpP and the six-membered rings of ClpX. Competition studies showed that ClpA may have a slightly higher affinity (approximately 2-fold) for binding to ClpP. Mixed complexes of ClpA, ClpX, and ClpP with the two ATPases bound simultaneously to opposite faces of a single ClpP molecule were seen by electron microscopy. In the presence of ATP or nonhydrolyzable analogs of ATP, ClpXP had nearly the same activity as ClpAP against oligopeptide substrates (>10,000 min-1/tetradecamer of ClpP). Thus, ClpX and ClpA interactions with ClpP result in structurally analogous complexes and induce similar conformational changes that affect the accessibility and the catalytic efficiency of ClpP active sites.

Expression of the early-onset torsion dystonia gene (DYT1) in human brain

Early-onset torsion dystonia, an autosomal dominant disease associated with the DYT1 locus on 9q34, is the most frequent genetic form of dystonia. Recent work has revealed that the causative mutation in most cases is deletion of a glutamate residue from the carboxy terminal of torsinA, a 332 amino acid protein encoded by the DYT1 gene. To gain insight into how deletion of a single amino acid can produce such a profound movement disorder, we have mapped the expression of the DYT1 gene in normal human postmortem brain. DYT1 mRNA is highly enriched in the dopamine neurons of the substantia nigra pars compacta. Intense expression was also found in the cerebellum and hippocampal subfields. The prominent expression of the DYT1 gene within the substantia nigra pars compacta, which provides dopaminergic innervation to the basal ganglia, implicates a disturbance of dopaminergic function in the pathophysiology of early-onset torsion dystonia.

Transcriptional and translational regulation of major heat shock proteins and patterns of trehalose mobilization during hyperthermic recovery in repressed and derepressed Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Patterns of heat shock gene transcription and translation, as well as trehalose content, were investigated in both glucose (repressed) and acetate (derepressed) grown cells of Saccharomyces cerevisiae during heat shock and subsequent return of cells to 25 degrees C. Heat-shocked cells (37 degrees C for 30 min), grown in either glucose- or acetate-supplemented media, initially acquired high thermotolerance to a 50 degrees C heat stress, which was progressively lost when cultures were allowed to recover at 25 degrees C and subsequently exposed to a second heat stress. In all cases, with the notable exception of repressed cells of a relatively thermosensitive strain, inhibition of protein synthesis and coincident decrease in trehalose accumulation during the heat shock had little effect on the kinetics of loss of thermotolerance. Heat shock at 37 degrees C elicited a marked increase in transcription and translation of genes encoding major heat shock proteins (hsps). During recovery at 25 degrees C, both metabolic activities were suppressed followed by a gradual increase in hsp mRNA transcription to levels observed prior to heat shock. De novo translation of hsp mRNAs, however, was no longer observed during the recovery phase, although immunodetection analyses demonstrated persistence of high levels of hsps 104, 90, 70, and 60 in cells throughout the 240-min recovery period. In addition, while heat shock induced trehalose was rapidly degraded during recovery in repressed cells, levels remained high in derepressed cells. Results therefore indicated that the progressive loss of induced thermotolerance exhibited by glucose- and acetate-grown cells was not closely correlated with levels of hsp or trehalose. It was concluded that both constitutive and de novo synthesized hsps require heat shock associated activation to confer thermotolerance and this modification is progressively reversed upon release from the heat-shocked state.

Interactions of the chaperone Hsp104 with yeast Sup35 and mammalian PrP

[PSI+] is a genetic element in yeast for which a heritable change in phenotype appears to be caused by a heritable change in the conformational state of the Sup35 protein. The inheritance of [PSI+] and the physical state of Sup35 in vivo depend on the protein chaperone Hsp104 (heat shock protein 104). Although these observations provide a strong genetic argument in support of the "protein-only" or "prion" hypothesis for [PSI+], there is, as yet, no direct evidence of an interaction between the two proteins. We report that when purified Sup35 and Hsp104 are mixed, the circular dichroism (CD) spectrum differs from that predicted by the addition of the proteins' individual spectra, and the ATPase activity of Hsp104 is inhibited. Similar results are obtained with two other amyloidogenic substrates, mammalian PrP and beta-amyloid 1-42 peptide, but not with several control proteins. With a group of peptides that span the PrP protein sequence, those that produced the largest changes in CD spectra also caused the strongest inhibition of ATPase activity in Hsp104. Our observations suggest that (i) previously described genetic interactions between Hsp104 and [PSI+] are caused by direct interaction between Hsp104 and Sup35; (ii) Sup35 and PrP, the determinants of the yeast and mammalian prions, respectively, share structural features that lead to a specific interaction with Hsp104; and (iii) these interactions couple a change in structure to the ATPase activity of Hsp104.

Chaperone-supervised conversion of prion protein to its protease-resistant form

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSEs) are lethal, infectious disorders of the mammalian nervous system. A TSE hallmark is the conversion of the cellular protein PrPC to disease-associated PrPSc (named for scrapie, the first known TSE). PrPC is protease-sensitive, monomeric, detergent soluble, and primarily alpha-helical; PrPSc is protease-resistant, polymerized, detergent insoluble, and rich in beta-sheet. The "protein-only" hypothesis posits that PrPSc is the infectious TSE agent that directly converts host-encoded PrPC to fresh PrPSc, harming neurons and creating new agents of infection. To gain insight on the conformational transitions of PrP, we tested the ability of several protein chaperones, which supervise the conformational transitions of proteins in diverse ways, to affect conversion of PrPC to its protease-resistant state. None affected conversion in the absence of pre-existing PrPSc. In its presence, only two, GroEL and Hsp104 (heat shock protein 104), significantly affected conversion. Both promoted it, but the reaction characteristics of conversions with the two chaperones were distinct. In contrast, chemical chaperones inhibited conversion. Our findings provide new mechanistic insights into nature of PrP conversions, and provide a new set of tools for studying the process underlying TSE pathogenesis.

Structure-function studies on small heat shock protein oligomeric assembly and interaction with unfolded polypeptides

The small heat shock protein (smHSP) and alpha-crystallin genes encode a family of 12-43-kDa proteins which assemble into large multimeric structures, function as chaperones by preventing protein aggregation, and contain a conserved region termed the alpha-crystallin domain. Here we report on the structural and functional characterization of Caenorhabditis elegans HSP16-2, a 16-kDa smHSP produced only under stress conditions. A combination of sedimentation velocity, size exclusion chromatography, and cross-linking analyses on wild-type HSP16-2 and five derivatives demonstrate that the N-terminal domain but not most of the the C-terminal extension which follows the alpha-crystallin domain is essential for the oligomerization of the smHSP into high molecular weight complexes. The N terminus of HSP16-2 is found to be buried within complexes which can accommodate at least an additional 4-kDa of heterologous sequence per subunit. Studies on the interaction of HSP16-2 with fluorescently-labeled and radiolabeled actin and tubulin reveal that this smHSP possesses a high affinity for unfolded intermediates which form early on the aggregation pathway, but has no apparent substrate specificity. Furthermore, both wild-type and C-terminally-truncated HSP16-2 can function as molecular chaperones by suppressing the thermally-induced aggregation of citrate synthase. Taken together, our data on HSP16-2 and a unique 12.6-kDa smHSP we have recently characterized demonstrate that multimerization is a prerequisite for the interaction of smHSPs with unfolded protein as well as for chaperone activity.

The early-onset torsion dystonia gene (DYT1) encodes an ATP-binding protein

Early-onset torsion dystonia is a movement disorder, characterized by twisting muscle contractures, that begins in childhood. Symptoms are believed to result from altered neuronal communication in the basal ganglia. This study identifies the DYT1 gene on human chromosome 9q34 as being responsible for this dominant disease. Almost all cases of early-onset dystonia have a unique 3-bp deletion that appears to have arisen idependently in different ethnic populations. This deletion results in loss of one of a pair of glutamic-acid residues in a conserved region of a novel ATP-binding protein, termed torsinA. This protein has homologues in nematode, rat, mouse and humans, with some resemblance to the family of heat-shock proteins and Clp proteases.

Proteolytic activity of the ATP-dependent protease HslVU can be uncoupled from ATP hydrolysis

HslVU is a new Escherichia coli ATP-dependent protease composed of two multimeric complexes: the HslU ATPase and the HslV peptidase. Prior studies indicated that HslVU requires ATP hydrolysis for the cleavage of peptides and proteins. We show here that ATP concentrations that activate hydrolysis of benzyloxycarbonyl-Gly-Gly-Leu-7-amido-4-methylcoumarin are 50-100 fold lower than those necessary for degradation of proteins (e.g. casein). Also, the nonhydrolyzable analogs of ATP, 5'-adenylyl beta, gamma-imidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP) and adenosine 5'-(alpha, beta-methylene)triphosphate, can support peptide hydrolysis, but only after an initial time lag not seen with ATP. This delay decreased at higher temperatures and with higher HslU or HslV concentrations and was eliminated by preincubation of HslU and HslV together. Thus, ATP hydrolysis accelerates the association of HslU and HslV, which occurs slowly with the nonhydrolyzable analog. The addition of KCl stimulated 4-6-fold the peptidase activity with AMP-PNP present and eliminated the time lag, but KCl had no stimulatory effect with ATP. NH4+ and Cs+ had similar effects as K+, but Na+ and Li+ were ineffective. AMP-PNP by itself supported hydrolysis of casein and other polypeptides only 20% as well as ATP, but in the presence of K+, Cs+, or NH4+, AMP-PNP activated casein degradation even better than ATP, although it was not hydrolyzed. In addition, MgCl2, MnCl2, and CaCl2 allowed some peptidase and caseinase activity in the absence of any nucleotide. However, Mn2+ and Ca2+, unlike Mg2+, abolished ATP hydrolysis and prevented further activation by ATP or AMP-PNP. These findings indicate that ATP binding to a high affinity site triggers the formation of an active state capable of peptide cleavage, although ATP hydrolysis facilitates this process. Rapid degradation of proteins requires a distinct state of the enzyme, which is normally reached through ATP hydrolysis at low affinity sites. However, AMP-PNP binding together with K+ can induce a form of HslVU that degrades proteins without energy consumption.

Induction of the heat shock protein ClpB affects cold acclimation in the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. strain PCC 7942

The heat shock protein ClpB is essential for acquired thermotolerance in cyanobacteria and eukaryotes and belongs to a diverse group of polypeptides which function as molecular chaperones. In this study we show that ClpB is also strongly induced during moderate cold stress in the unicellular cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. strain PCC 7942. A fivefold increase in ClpB (92 kDa) content occurred when cells were acclimated to 25 degrees C over 24 h after being shifted from the optimal growth temperature of 37 degrees C. A corresponding increase occurred for the smaller ClpB' (78 kDa), which arises from a second translational start within the clpB gene of prokaryotes. Shifts to more extreme cold (i.e., 20 and 15 degrees C) progressively decreased the level of ClpB induction, presumably due to retardation of protein synthesis within this relatively cold-sensitive strain. Inactivation of clpB in Synechococcus sp. increased the extent of inhibition of photosynthesis upon the shift to 25 degrees C and markedly reduced the mutant's ability to acclimate to the new temperature regime, with a threefold drop in growth rate. Furthermore, around 30% fewer delta clpB cells survived the shift to 25 degrees C after 24 h compared to the wild type, and more of the mutant cells were also arrested during cell division at 25 degrees C, remaining attached after septum formation. Development of a cold thermotolerance assay based on cell survival clearly demonstrated that wild-type cells could acquire substantial resistance to the nonpermissive temperature of 15 degrees C by being pre-exposed to 25 degrees C. The same level of cold thermotolerance, however, occurred in the delta clpB strain, indicating ClpB induction is not necessary for this form of thermal resistance in Synechococcus spp. Overall, our results demonstrate that the induction of ClpB contributes significantly to the acclimation process of cyanobacteria to permissive low temperatures.

Molecular characterization of a small heat shock/alpha-crystallin protein in encysted Artemia embryos

Molecular chaperones protect cells during stress by limiting the denaturation/aggregation of proteins and facilitating their renaturation. In this context, brine shrimp embryos can endure a wide variety of stressful conditions, including temperature extremes, prolonged anoxia, and desiccation, thus encountering shortages of both energy (ATP) and water. How the embryos survive these stresses is the subject of continuing study, a situation true for other organisms facing similar physiological challenges. To approach this question we cloned and sequenced a cDNA for p26, a molecular chaperone specific to oviparous Artemia embryos. p26 is the first representative of the small heat shock/alpha-crystallin family from crustaceans to be sequenced, and it possesses the conserved alpha-crystallin domain characteristic of these proteins. The secondary structure of this domain was predicted to consist predominantly of beta-pleated sheet, and it appeared to lack regions of alpha-helix. Unique properties of the nonconserved amino terminus, which showed weak similarity to nucleolins and fibrillarins, are enrichments in both glycine and arginine. The carboxyl-terminal tail is the longest yet reported for a small heat shock/alpha-crystallin protein, and it is hydrophilic, a common attribute of this region. Site-specific differences between amino acids from p26 and other small heat shock/alpha-crystallin proteins bring into question the functions proposed for some of these residues. Probing of Southern blots disclosed a multi-gene family for p26, whereas two size classes of p26 mRNA at 0.7 and 1.9 kilobase pairs were seen on Northern blots, the larger probably representing nonprocessed transcripts. Examination of immunofluorescently stained samples with the confocal microscope revealed that a limited portion of intracellular p26 is found in the nuclei of encysted embryos and that it resides within discrete compartments of this organelle. The results in this paper demonstrate clearly that p26 is a novel member of the small heat shock/alpha-crystallin family of proteins. These data, in concert with its restriction to embryos undergoing oviparous development, suggest that p26 functions as a molecular chaperone during exposure to stress, perhaps able to limit protein degradation and thus ensure a ready supply of functional proteins when growth is reinitiated.

Crystal structure of heat shock locus V (HslV) from Escherichia coli

Heat shock locus V (HslV; also called ClpQ) is the proteolytic core of the ATP-dependent protease HslVU in Escherichia coli. It has sequence similarity with the beta-type subunits of the eukaryotic and archaebacterial proteasomes. Unlike these particles, which display 72-point symmetry, it is a dimer of hexamers with 62-point symmetry. The crystal structure of HslV at 3.8-A resolution, determined by isomorphous replacement and symmetry averaging, shows that in spite of the different symmetry of the particle, the fold and the contacts between subunits are conserved. A tripeptide aldehyde inhibitor, acetyl-Leu-Leu-norleucinal, binds to the N-terminal threonine residue of HslV, probably as a hemiacetal, relating HslV also functionally to the proteasomes of archaea and eukaryotes.

A regulatory switch involving a Clp ATPase

Clp ATPase chaperone proteins are found in procaryotes and eucaryotes. Recently, ClpC of Bacillus subtilis was found to be part of a regulatory switch(1). ClpC, in combination with the MecA and ComS proteins, regulates the activity of a transcription factor, ComK, which is necessary for the development of genetic competence (the ability to bind and take up exogenous DNA). The complex of ClpC:MecA:ComK renders ComK inactive. Interaction between ComS and the ternary complex releases active ComK. This regulatory switch controls ComK activity in response to cell density signals that affect production of ComS. Regulated interaction between Clp ATPase and target proteins might prove to be widespread.