Physiological substrates of mammalian monogamy: the prairie vole model

Neuroendocrine perspectives on social attachment and love

The purpose of this paper is to review existing behavioral and neuroendocrine perspectives on social attachment and love. Both love and social attachments function to facilitate reproduction, provide a sense of safety, and reduce anxiety or stress. Because social attachment is an essential component of love, understanding attachment formation is an important step toward identifying the neurobiological substrates of love. Studies of pair bonding in monogamous rodents, such as prairie voles, and maternal attachment in precocial ungulates offer the most accessible animal models for the study of mechanisms underlying selective social attachments and the propensity to develop social bonds. Parental behavior and sexual behavior, even in the absence of selective social behaviors, are associated with the concept of love; the analysis of reproductive behaviors, which is far more extensive than our understanding of social attachment, also suggests neuroendocrine substrates for love. A review of these literatures reveals a recurrent association between high levels of activity in the hypothalamic pituitary adrenal (HPA) axis and the subsequent expression of social behaviors and attachments. Positive social behaviors, including social bonds, may reduce HPA axis activity, while in some cases negative social interactions can have the opposite effect. Central neuropeptides, and especially oxytocin and vasopressin have been implicated both in social bonding and in the central control of the HPA axis. In prairie voles, which show clear evidence of pair bonds, oxytocin is capable of increasing positive social behaviors and both oxytocin and social interactions reduce activity in the HPA axis. Social interactions and attachment involve endocrine systems capable of decreasing HPA reactivity and modulating the autonomic nervous system, perhaps accounting for health benefits that are attributed to loving relationships.

Serotonin and neuropeptides in affiliative behaviors

The neuropharmacological study of serotonin and behavior has followed two fundamentally different strategies. One approach has used behavior as a dependent variable for assaying drug effects. To characterize serotonergic drugs, most studies have used relatively simple behaviors, such as locomotor activity, startle, exploration, operant responses, and sleep. A second approach has focused on behavior, with drugs used as tools to elucidate the physiological role of serotonin. These studies have increasingly focused on behaviors of ethological importance, including aggression, sexual behavior, and other forms of social interaction. Here we review studies using this approach to focus on one particular kind of social interaction: affiliation.

Comparative neuroanatomy of vasotocin and vasopressin in amphibians and other vertebrates

This review focuses on the neuroanatomical distribution of vasotocin (VT) and vasopressin (VP) and presents a comparative analysis of brain areas in which VT and VP cell bodies have been reported in fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals. A comparison of information from previous neuroanatomical studies of VT and VP with findings from a recent study of VT in an amphibian (Taricha granulosa) supports the conclusions that the VT/VP system can be subdivided into identifiable groups of cell bodies, based on neuroanatomical and cell morphology characteristics, and that these cell groups are not necessarily delimited by classical neuroanatomical boundaries. The comparative neuroanatomy of the distribution of VT and VP cell bodies also indicates that the neuroanatomy of the VT/VP system is fairly conserved among vertebrates. The review uses comparative data to present a series of tentative hypotheses about the homology of the VT cell groups and VP cell groups in the different vertebrate taxa.

Brain substrates of infant-mother attachment: contributions of opioids, oxytocin, and norepinephrine

The aim of this paper is to review recent work concerning the psychobiological substrates of social bonding, focusing on the literature attributed to opioids, oxytocin and norepinephrine in rats. Existing evidence and thinking about the biological foundations of attachment in young mammalian species and the neurobiology of several other affiliative behaviors including maternal behavior, sexual behavior and social memory is reviewed. We postulate the existence of social motivation circuitry which is common to all mammals and consistent across development. Oxytocin, vasopressin, endogenous opioids and catecholamines appear to participate in a wide variety of affiliative behaviors and are likely to be important components in this circuitry. It is proposed that these same neurochemical and neuroanatomical patterns will emerge as key substrates in the neurobiology of infant attachments to their caregivers.

Intraspecific variation in the induction of female sexual receptivity in prairie voles

Prairie voles (Microtus ochrogaster) are monogamous New World rodents which show geographic variation in social behavior. In this study, parameters of female reproduction which might be related to mating system were compared in prairie voles from eastern Kansas (KAN) versus central Illinois (ILL). KAN females showed a more rapid onset of natural estrus following exposure to a male and were more likely to respond to injections of a low dose (0.5 microg) of exogenous estradiol benzoate than ILL females. Neither mating duration nor pregnancy success after mate removal differed in KAN versus ILL females. These results suggest that ILL voles are less sensitive than KAN voles to the estrus-inducing effects of either endogenous or exogenous estrogen, supporting the hypothesis that variations in reproductive strategy occur among geographically discrete populations of prairie voles.

Behavioural suppression of female pine voles after replacement of the breeding male

Examination of the mechanism of reproductive suppression includes determining which cues are involved and the context in which they occur. We studied groups of pine voles, Microtus pinetorum, that were disrupted by the replacement of the breeding male and compared them with intact family groups. If reproductive suppression is mediated by chemical cues, then soiled bedding should be sufficient to prevent production of litters by daughters. If reproductive suppression involves a behavioural component, we should observe aggressive behaviours or those indicative of dominance interactions directed from the mother towards the daughter or the replacement male. If replacement of the breeding male leads to conflict between the breeding female and her daughter, then more aggression or dominance interactions would be expected in disrupted than in intact families. The presence of the mother decreased reproduction by daughters, but chemical cues alone were not sufficient to prevent the daughter from mating with the replacement male. Rather, this decrease in reproduction seemed to be mediated by behavioural interactions. We propose that the mother's tugging on the daughter may lead to subordination of the daughter. The mother's presence may also alter the behaviour patterns of the male and daughter, which could delay reproductive activation of the daughter, prevent the formation of pair bonds or inhibit sexual behaviour. These behavioural interactions appear to depend on the presence of an unfamiliar male, because tugging, for example, was less frequent in intact family groups. Copyright 1998 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour Copyright 1998 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour.

Plasma oxytocin levels in autistic children

BACKGROUND

Social impairments are central to the syndrome of autism. The neuropeptide oxytocin (OT) has been implicated in the regulation of social behavior in animals but has not yet been examined in autistic subjects.

METHODS

To determine whether autistic children have abnormalities in OT, midday plasma samples from 29 autistic and 30 age-matched normal children, all prepubertal, were analyzed by radioimmunoassay for levels of OT.

RESULTS

Despite individual variability and overlapping group distributions, the autistic group had significantly lower plasma OT levels than the normal group. OT increased with age in the normal but not the autistic children. Elevated OT was associated with higher scores on social and developmental measures for the normal children, but was associated with lower scores for the autistic children. These relationships were strongest in a subset of autistic children identified as aloof.

CONCLUSIONS

Although making inferences to central OT functioning from peripheral measurement is difficult, the data suggest that OT abnormalities may exist in autism, and that more direct investigation of central nervous system OT function is warranted.

Central nervous system actions of oxytocin and modulation of behavior in humans

The posterior pituitary hormone oxytocin has modulatory effects on neural functioning that are significant to the regulation of behavior. Basic research in animals has established the importance of oxytocin in affiliation, including mating, pair bonding and parenting behaviors. It is also an important regulator of feeding, grooming and responses to stress. The actions of oxytocin in the brain are regulated by gonadal steroid hormones, particularly estrogen. Oxytocin might also influence normal behavior in humans, and dysfunctions in the oxytocin system might be involved in the etiology and expression of neuropsychiatric disorders.

The hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis of prairie voles (Microtus ochrogaster): evidence for target tissue glucocorticoid resistance

Basal plasma corticosterone levels in prairie voles (Microtus ochrogaster) are extremely high, in the absence of any apparent negative consequences of glucocorticoid excess. We tested the hypothesis that prairie voles are a novel rodent model of target tissue resistance to glucocorticoids. Prairie voles had a significantly higher adrenal-to-body weight ratio, 5- to 10-fold greater basal plasma corticosterone, and 2- to 3-fold greater basal plasma ACTH concentrations than montane voles (Microtus montanus) and rats. While plasma corticosterone binding globulin (CBG) was 2-fold higher in prairie voles than in rats, both estimated and directly measured plasma free corticosterone were significantly higher in prairie voles than in rats. Plasma corticosterone levels in prairie voles were responsive to both circadian cues and a stressor, but were resistant to suppression by the synthetic glucocorticoid, dexamethasone (DEX). Western blots of brain and liver protein extracts, using a glucocorticoid receptor (GR) antibody, revealed the presence of a approximately 97 kDa immunoreactive band, the expected size for GR. Binding assays revealed significantly lower DEX affinity of corticosteroid receptors (CR) in cytosol of prairie vole brain and liver than that in the same tissues in rats. We conclude that prairie voles are a novel rodent model of glucocorticoid resistance, and that decreased affinity of CR for ligand might be partially responsible for this phenomenon.

Familiarity and gender influence social preferences in prairie voles (Microtus ochrogaster)

The physiological mechanisms influencing group cohesion and social preferences are largely unstudied in prairie voles (Microtus ochrogaster). In nature, prairie vole family groups usually consist of an adult male and female breeding pair, one or more litters of their offspring, and occasionally unrelated adults. Pair bonds, defined by heterosexual preferences, develop in male and female prairie voles following cohabitation or mating. However, social preferences between members of the same sex also may be important to the maintenance of communal groups. In the present study we compared the development of social preferences for conspecific strangers of the same sex versus preferences for the opposite sex, and examined the effect of the gonadal status of the stimulus animal on initial social preference. The present study revealed that reproductively naive males, but not females, showed initial preferences for partners of the opposite sex. In both sexes preferences for the opposite sex were not influenced by the presence or absence of gonadal hormones. Heterosexual and same-sex preferences for a familiar individual formed following 24 h of nonsexual cohabitation in both males and females. Male and female same-sex preferences, however, were no longer stable when the stranger in the preference test was of the opposite sex to the experimental animal. The development of same-sex preferences may help to maintain group cohesion, but same-sex preferences formed by cohabitation do not withstand the challenge of an opposite-sex stranger.

Perinatal hormone exposure alters the expression of selective affiliative preferences in prairie voles

In the present study, perinatal administration of corticosterone and testosterone significantly influenced affiliative preferences only in females. Despite the very high levels of steroids given, no significant differences were noted among treated and untreated groups of males. Prairie voles apparently are uniquely adapted to tolerate high levels of endogenous steroids. However, females of this species may be capable of exploiting variations in corticosterone levels to regulate sexually dimorphic traits, including social behaviors, in adulthood. Perinatal responsivity to adrenal hormones could allow animals to adapt their social behaviors, including traits that have been used to characterize monogamy and/or communal breeding, to environmental demands.

Molecular aspects of monogamy

Comparative studies of monogamous and nonmonogamous voles demonstrate species differences in the regional expression of oxytocin (OT) receptors in the brain. These species differences have not been observed with other neurotransmitter receptors (except vasopressin). Species differences for OT receptor distribution were also observed in other microtine and murine species selected as monogamous or promiscuous. These chemical neuroanatomic differences appear to be functionally relevant, as treatments with selective OT agonists and antagonists influence those behaviors that appear critical to pair bonding in the monogamous prairie vole. To investigate the mechanism controlling tissue-specific expression of OT receptors, we sequenced the OT receptor gene in both prairie voles and montane voles. The findings are inconclusive. Although both species differ markedly from rat and human in their regulatory (but not their coding) sequences, the species show very subtle differences from each other. Ongoing studies are investigating the consequences of these subtle differences between prairie and montane voles. At the same time, several transactivating factors that might influence OT receptor expression need to be explored. NOTE ADDED IN PROOF: The rat oxytocin receptor gene sequence, cited in FIGURES 4 and 5, was based on an error published in ref. 22. The corrected sequence has now been published (Rosen et al. 1996. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci USA 93: 12501). The correct sequence shows greater homology with the vole oxytocin receptor gene sequences, but the remaining differences support the argument made herein for species differences in regional receptor expression.

Integrative functions of lactational hormones in social behavior and stress management

For mammalian reproduction to succeed, self-defense and asociality must be subjugated to positive social behaviors, at least during birth, lactation, and sexual behavior. Perhaps the important task of regulating the interaction between social and agonistic behaviors is managed, in part, by interactions between two related neurochemical systems that incorporate oxytocin and vasopressin in their functions. The neuropeptides oxytocin and vasopressin participate in important reproductive functions, such as parturition and lactation, and homeostatic responses, including modulation of the adrenal axis. Recent evidence also implicates these hormones in social aspects of reproductive behaviors. For example, oxytocin is important for a variety of positive social behaviors, including the regulation of maternal-infant interactions. In adult animals, oxytocin may facilitate both social contact and selective social interactions associated with social attachment and pair bonding, and it participates in the regulation of parasympathetic functions. Vasopressin, in contrast, is associated with behaviors that might be broadly classified as "defensive" including enhanced arousal, attention, or vigilance, increased aggressive behavior, and a general increase in sympathetic functions. On the basis of the literature on the functions of these hormones and our own recent findings, we propose that dynamic interactions between oxytocin and vasopressin are components of a larger system which integrates the neuroendocrine and autonomic changes associated with mammalian social behaviors and the concurrent regulation of the stress axis. In addition, studies of lactating females provide a valuable model for understanding the more general neuroendocrinology of the stress axis. Peptide hormones, including oxytocin and vasopressin, do not readily cross the blood-brain barrier and must be administered centrally (i.c.v.) to reach the brain. Nasal sprays have been used to promote milk let down and have been used in some behavioral studies, but the extent to which such compounds reach the brain is not known. Therefore, virtually nothing is known regarding the effects in humans of centrally administered oxytocin. The study of human lactation, in conjunction with animal research, provides an opportunity to begin to develop viable hypotheses regarding the behavioral effects of oxytocin.

Adrenocorticoid hormones and the development and expression of mammalian monogamy

Based on research with prairie voles, we hypothesize that the unusual patterns of reproduction and social behavior associated with mammalian monogamy may arise as a consequence of normal developmental exposure to high levels of glucocorticoids and/or other hormones of the HPA axis. Increased HPA activity could functionally inhibit some of the masculinizing processes expected during the perinatal period. We hypothesize that the unique behavioral, physiological, and anatomical changes associated with monogamy may reflect the adaptive consequences of reduced exposure to the masculinizing actions of HPG hormones, such as testosterone. Reproductively naive, unpaired adult prairie voles also show unusual patterns of adrenal activity, including a marked decline in corticosterone levels within minutes following exposure to novel animals of the opposite sex. In females, this decline in corticosterone may contribute to pair bonding, since corticosterone injections inhibit, and adrenalectomy is associated with a facilitation of pair bond formation. In males, corticosterone injections facilitate pair bonding and adrenalectomy has the opposite effect. In animals from established social pairs corticosterone levels also fluctuate according to the social environment of the animal; the absence of a familiar partner is associated with increased corticosterone secretion, and in the presence of the familiar partner corticosterone levels tend to decline. Prairie voles may offer a valuable source of information regarding the behavioral, anatomical, and physiological consequences of long-term and short-term exposure to high levels of adrenal activity in the absence of pathology.