From Reductionism Toward Integration: Understanding How Social Behavior Emerges From Integrated Circuits

Complex social behaviors are emergent properties of the brain's interconnected and overlapping neural networks. Questions aimed at understanding how brain circuits produce specific and appropriate behaviors have changed over the past half century, shifting from studies of gross anatomical and behavioral associations, to manipulating and monitoring precisely targeted cell types. This technical progression has enabled increasingly deep insights into the regulation of perception and behavior with remarkable precision. The capacity of reductionist approaches to identify the function of isolated circuits is undeniable but many behaviors require rapid integration of diverse inputs. This review examines progress toward understanding integrative social circuits and focuses on specific nodes of the social behavior network including the medial amygdala, ventromedial hypothalamus (VMH) and medial preoptic area of the hypothalamus (MPOA) as examples of broad integration between multiple interwoven brain circuits. Our understanding of mechanisms for producing social behavior has deepened in conjunction with advances in technologies for visualizing and manipulating specific neurons and, here, we consider emerging strategies to address brain circuit function in the context of integrative anatomy.

Interactive Mechanisms of Supraspinal Sites of Opioid Analgesic Action: A Festschrift to Dr. Gavril W. Pasternak

Almost a half century of research has elaborated the discoveries of the central mechanisms governing the analgesic responses of opiates, including their receptors, endogenous peptides, genes and their putative spinal and supraspinal sites of action. One of the central tenets of "gate-control theories of pain" was the activation of descending supraspinal sites by opiate drugs and opioid peptides thereby controlling further noxious input. This review in the Special Issue dedicated to the research of Dr. Gavril Pasternak indicates his contributions to the understanding of supraspinal mediation of opioid analgesic action within the context of the large body of work over this period. This review will examine (a) the relevant supraspinal sites mediating opioid analgesia, (b) the opioid receptor subtypes and opioid peptides involved, (c) supraspinal site analgesic interactions and their underlying neurophysiology, (d) molecular (particularly AS) tools identifying opioid receptor actions, and (e) relevant physiological variables affecting site-specific opioid analgesia. This review will build on classic initial studies, specify the contributions that Gavril Pasternak and his colleagues did in this specific area, and follow through with studies up to the present.

Opioid receptors mRNAs expression and opioids agonist-dependent G-protein activation in the rat brain following neuropathy

Potent opioid-based therapies are often unsuccessful in promoting satisfactory analgesia in neuropathic pain. Moreover, the side effects associated with opioid therapy are still manifested in neuropathy-like diseases, including tolerance, abuse, addiction and hyperalgesia, although the mechanisms underlying these effects remain unclear. Studies in the spinal cord and periphery indicate that neuropathy alters the expression of mu-[MOP], delta-[DOP] or kappa-[KOP] opioid receptors, interfering with their activity. However, there is no consensus as to the supraspinal opioidergic modulation provoked by neuropathy, the structures where the sensory and affective-related pain components are processed. In this study we explored the effect of chronic constriction of the sciatic nerve (CCI) over 7 and 30 days (CCI-7d and CCI-30d, respectively) on MOP, DOP and KOP mRNAs expression, using in situ hybridization, and the efficacy of G-protein stimulation by DAMGO, DPDPE and U-69593 (MOP, DOP and KOP specific agonists, respectively), using [35S]GTPγS binding, within opioid-sensitive brain structures. After CCI-7d, CCI-30d or both, opioid receptor mRNAs expression was altered throughout the brain: MOP - in the paracentral/centrolateral thalamic nuclei, ventral posteromedial thalamic nuclei, superior olivary complex, parabrachial nucleus [PB] and posterodorsal tegmental nucleus; DOP - in the somatosensory cortex [SSC], ventral tegmental area, caudate putamen [CPu], nucleus accumbens [NAcc], raphe magnus [RMg] and PB; and KOP - in the locus coeruleus. Agonist-stimulated [35S]GTPγS binding was altered following CCI: MOP - CPu and RMg; DOP - prefrontal cortex [PFC], SSC, RMg and NAcc; and KOP - PFC and SSC. Thus, this study shows that several opioidergic circuits in the brain are recruited and modified following neuropathy.

Ultrastructural analysis of rat ventrolateral periaqueductal gray projections to the A5 cell group

Stimulation of neurons in the ventrolateral periaqueductal gray (PAG) produces antinociception as well as cardiovascular depressor responses that are mediated in part by pontine noradrenergic neurons. A previous report using light microscopy has described a pathway from neurons in the ventrolateral PAG to noradrenergic neurons in the A5 cell group that may mediate these effects. The present study used anterograde tracing and electron microscopic analysis to provide more definitive evidence that neurons in the ventrolateral PAG form synapses with noradrenergic and non-catecholaminergic A5 neurons in Sasco Sprague-Dawley rats. Deposits of anterograde tracer, biotinylated dextran amine, into the rat ventrolateral PAG labeled a significant number of axons in the region of the rostral subdivision of the A5 cell group, and a relatively lower number in the caudal A5 cell group. Electron microscopic analysis of anterogradely-labeled terminals in both rostral (n=127) and caudal (n=70) regions of the A5 cell group indicated that approximately 10% of these form synapses with noradrenergic dendrites. In rostral sections, about 31% of these were symmetric synapses, 19% were asymmetric synapses, and 50% were membrane appositions without clear synaptic specializations. In caudal sections, about 22% were symmetric synapses, and the remaining 78% were appositions. In both rostral and caudal subdivisions of the A5, nearly 40% of the anterogradely-labeled terminals formed synapses with non-catecholaminergic dendrites, and about 45% formed axoaxonic synapses. These results provide direct evidence for a monosynaptic pathway from neurons in the ventrolateral PAG to noradrenergic and non-catecholaminergic neurons in the A5 cell group. Further studies should evaluate if this established monosynaptic pathway may contribute to the cardiovascular depressor effects or the analgesia produced by the activation of neurons in the ventrolateral PAG.

The effects of local perfusion of DAMGO on extracellular GABA and glutamate concentrations in the rostral ventromedial medulla

Electrophysiological data suggest an involvement of rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM) GABA and glutamate (GLU) neurons in morphine analgesia. Direct evidence that extracellular concentrations of GABA or GLU are altered in response to mu opioid receptor (MOP-R) activation is, however, lacking. We used in vivo microdialysis to investigate this issue. Basal GABA overflow increased in response to intra-RVM perfusion of KCl (60 mmol/L). Reverse microdialysis of the MOP-R agonist D-Ala(2),NMePhe(4),Gly-ol(5)]enkephalin (DAMGO) (20-500 micromol/L) produced a concentration-dependent decrease of RVM GABA overflow. Behavioral testing revealed that concentrations that decreased GABA levels increased thermal withdrawal thresholds. A lower agonist concentration that did not increase GABA failed to alter thermal thresholds. DAMGO did not alter GLU concentrations. However, KCl also failed to modify GLU release. Since rapid, transporter-mediated uptake may mask the detection of changes in GLU release, the selective excitatory amino acid transporter inhibitor pyrrolidine-2,4-dicarboxylic acid (tPDC, 0.6 mmol/L) was added to the perfusion medium for subsequent studies. tPDC increased GLU concentrations, confirming transport inhibition. KCl increased GLU dialysate levels in the presence of tPDC, demonstrating that transport inhibition permits detection of depolarization-evoked GLU overflow. In the presence of tPDC, DAMGO increased GLU overflow in a concentration-dependent manner. These data demonstrate that MOP-R activation decreases GABA and increases GLU release in the RVM. We hypothesize that the opposing effects of MOP-R on GLU and GABA transmission contribute to opiate antinociception.

Potentiation of morphine antinociception by pentobarbital in female vs. male rats

It has been shown previously that female rats are more sensitive than males to barbiturate anesthesia, whereas males may be more sensitive than females to opioid antinociception. The aim of the present study was to determine whether enhancement of morphine antinociception by pentobarbital, previously demonstrated in male animals and humans, occurs similarly in females. Pentobarbital (50 mg/kg i.p.) produced longer-lasting anesthetic effects (loss of muscle tone, righting reflex) in gonadally intact female rats than in males, but greater antinociceptive effects in males at some time points post-injection. There were no significant sex differences in morphine-induced anesthesia or antinociception; however, 50 mg/kg pentobarbital produced greater leftward shifts in the morphine antinociceptive dose-effect curve in gonadally intact females than males, whether pentobarbital was administered 30 vs. 120 min before morphine (times at which there were no sex differences vs. sex differences, respectively, in pentobarbital's effects when administered alone). Dose-addition analysis confirmed that pentobarbital enhancement of morphine antinociception was supra-additive in both sexes; morphine also significantly enhanced pentobarbital-induced anesthesia in both sexes. In gonadectomized males, testosterone did not significantly alter pentobarbital enhancement of morphine antinociception; in contrast, in gonadectomized females, estradiol significantly attenuated the drug interaction. Estradiol did not significantly alter the effects of pentobarbital alone or morphine alone, indicating that the attenuation of the pentobarbital's potentiation of morphine antinociception in estradiol-treated rats is specific to the drug interaction. These results suggest that barbiturate potentiation of opioid antinociception may be greater in females - particularly those in low ovarian hormone states - than in males.

Activation of μ-Opioid Receptors Inhibits Synaptic Inputs to Spinally Projecting Rostral Ventromedial Medulla Neurons

The rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM) is a major locus for the descending control of nociception and opioid analgesia. However, it is not clear how opioids affect synaptic inputs to RVM neurons. In this study, we determined the effect of mu-opioid receptor activation on excitatory and inhibitory synaptic transmission in spinally projecting RVM neurons. RVM neurons were retrogradely labeled with a fluorescent tracer injected into the dorsal horn of the spinal cord in rats. Whole-cell voltage-clamp recordings were performed on labeled RVM neurons in brain slices in vitro. The mu-receptor agonist [D-Ala(2),N-Me-Phe(4),Gly(5)-ol]-enkephalin (DAMGO, 1 microM) significantly decreased the amplitude of evoked excitatory postsynaptic currents (EPSCs) in 52% (9 of 17) of labeled cells. DAMGO also significantly reduced the amplitude of evoked inhibitory postsynaptic currents (IPSCs) in 69% (11 of 16) of cells examined. Furthermore, DAMGO significantly decreased the frequency of miniature EPSCs in 55% (15 of 27) of cells and significantly decreased the frequency of miniature IPSCs in all 12 cells studied. Although most EPSCs and IPSCs were mediated by glutamate and GABA, the nicotinic and glycine receptor antagonists attenuated EPSCs and IPSCs, respectively, in some labeled RVM neurons. Immunocytochemical labeling revealed that only 35% of recorded RVM neurons were tryptophan hydroxylase-positive, and 15% cells had GABA immunoreactivity. Thus, this study provides important functional evidence that activation of mu-opioid receptors decreases the release of both excitatory and inhibitory neurotransmitters onto most spinally projecting RVM neurons.

Antinociception and modulation of rostral ventromedial medulla neuronal activity by local microinfusion of a cannabinoid receptor agonist

Systemic administration of a cannabinoid agonist produces antinociception through the activation of pain modulating neurons in the rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM). The aim of the present study was to determine how a cannabinoid receptor agonist acting directly within the RVM affects neuronal activity to produce behaviorally measurable antinociception. In lightly anesthetized rats, two types of RVM neurons have been defined based on changes in tail flick-related activity. On-cells increase firing (on-cell burst), whereas off-cells cease firing (off-cell pause), just prior to a tail flick. The cannabinoid receptor agonist WIN55,212-2 was microinfused directly into the RVM while monitoring tail flick latencies and on- and off-cell activity. Microinfusion of WIN55,212-2 (2.0 microg/microl and 0.4 microg/microl) reduced the tail flick-related on-cell burst, decreased the duration of the off-cell pause, and increased off-cell ongoing activity. These changes were prevented by co-infusing the CB1 receptor antagonist, SR141716A (0.35 microg/microl), with WIN55,212-2 (0.4 microg/microl). Furthermore, 2.0 microg/microl WIN55,212-2 delayed the onset of the off-cell pause and increased tail flick latencies. Microinfusion of WIN55,212-2 to brain regions caudal or lateral to the RVM had no effect on RVM neuronal activity or tail flick latencies. These results indicate that cannabinoids act directly within the RVM to affect off-cell activity, providing one mechanism by which cannabinoids produce antinociception.

Heterogeneous synaptic inputs from the ventrolateral periaqueductal gray matter to neurons responding to somatosensory stimuli in the rostral ventromedial medulla of rats

The ventrolateral cell column of the midbrain periaqueductal gray matter (vl-PAG) plays a major role in the attenuation of pain behaviour. It is established that this effect is exerted via modulation of neuronal activities in the rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM). Until recently it has been generally accepted that the vl-PAG exerts its modulatory effects upon RVM neurons through a direct monosynaptic pathway. However, recent data suggest that an additional indirect, di- or polysynaptic pathway may also exist. Using in vivo intracellular recordings we tested this hypothesis, by studying synaptic responses of somatosensory receptive RVM neurons evoked by electric stimulation of the vl-PAG in rats. RVM neurons were regarded as somatosensory receptive if they responded to electrical stimulation of the sciatic nerve. Most of the recorded RVM cells were excited by vl-PAG stimulation. Some of them responded with a short onset latency (3.6+/-0.9 ms) corresponding to monosynaptic excitation. All of these neurons were also excited by sciatic nerve stimulation at nociceptive intensities. In contrast to this, another proportion of the recorded RVM neurons responded with a four times longer (14.8+/-3 ms) onset latency to the vl-PAG stimulation, corresponding to polysynaptic modulation. All of these neurons were inhibited by sciatic nerve stimulation. The findings show that RVM neurons receive heterogeneous monosynaptic and polysynaptic inputs from the vl-PAG. The results also suggest that the monosynaptic and polysynaptic pathways modulate the activity of functionally distinct groups of RVM neurons.

Ultrastructural analysis of ventrolateral periaqueductal gray projections to the A7 catecholamine cell group

Stimulation of neurons in the ventrolateral periaqueductal gray produces antinociception that is mediated in part by pontine noradrenergic neurons. Previous light microscopic analysis provided suggestive evidence for a direct projection from neurons in the ventrolateral periaqueductal gray to noradrenergic neurons in the A7 cell group that innervate the spinal cord dorsal horn. Therefore, the present ultrastructural study used anterograde tracing combined with tyrosine hydroxylase immunoreactivity to provide definitive evidence that neurons in the ventrolateral periaqueductal gray form synapses with the somata and dendrites of noradrenergic neurons of the A7 cell group. Injections of the anterograde tracers biotinylated dextran amine or Phaseolus vulgaris leucoagglutinin into the ventrolateral periaqueductal gray of Sasco Sprague-Dawley rats yielded a dense innervation in the region of the lateral pons containing the A7 cell group. Electron microscopic analysis of anterogradely labeled terminals (n=401) in the region of the A7 cell group indicated that approximately 10% of these formed plasmalemmal appositions to tyrosine hydroxylase-immunoreactive dendrites with no intervening astrocytic processes. About 23% of these were asymmetric synapses, 10% were symmetric synapses, and 67% did not exhibit clearly differentiated synaptic specializations. The majority of anterogradely labeled terminals (60%) formed plasmalemmal appositions with dendrites and somata that lacked detectable tyrosine hydroxylase immunoreactivity. About 35% of these were symmetric synapses, 9% were asymmetric synapses and 56% did not form synaptic specializations. Approximately 30% of all anterogradely labeled terminals displayed features characteristic of axo-axonic synapses.The present results provide direct ultrastructural evidence to support the hypothesis that the analgesia produced by stimulation of neurons in the ventrolateral periaqueductal gray is mediated, in part, by activation of spinally projecting noradrenergic neurons in the A7 catecholamine cell group.

Distinct effect of orphanin FQ in nucleus raphe magnus and nucleus reticularis gigantocellularis on the rat tail flick reflex

The aim of the present study is to investigate the effects of orphanin FQ (OFQ) microinjected into the nucleus raphe magnus (NRM) and the nucleus reticularis gigantocellularis (NGC) on pain modulation. The tail-flick latency (TFL) was used as a behavioral index of nociceptive responsiveness. The result showed microinjection of OFQ into the NRM significantly increased the TFL, whereas microinjection of OFQ into the NGC decreased the TFL, suggesting the analgesic effect of OFQ in the NRM and the hyperalgesic effect of OFQ in the NGC. As there are three classes of putative pain modulating neurons in the rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM), the hyperalgesic or analgesic effect of OFQ in the RVM might depend upon the different class of the neurons being acted.

Periaqueductal gray neurons monosynaptically innervate extranuclear noradrenergic dendrites in the rat pericoerulear region

Previous reports using light microscopy have provided anatomical evidence that neurons in the ventrolateral periaqueductal gray (PAG) innervate the medial pericoerulear dendrites of noradrenergic neurons in the nucleus locus coeruleus (LC). The present study used anterograde tracing and electron microscopic analysis to provide more definitive evidence that neurons in the ventrolateral PAG form synapses with the somata or dendrites of noradrenergic LC neurons. Deposits of either biotinylated dextran amine or Phaseolus vulgaris leucoagglutinin into the rat ventrolateral PAG labeled a moderate to high number of axons in the region of the medial pericoerulear region and Barrington's nucleus, but a relatively low number were labeled in the nuclear core of the LC. Ultrastructural analysis of anterogradely labeled terminals at the levels of the rostral (n = 233) and caudal (n = 272) subdivisions of the LC indicated that approximately 20% of these form synapses with tyrosine hydroxylase-immunoreactive dendrites; most of these were located in the medial pericoerulear region. In rostral sections, about 12% of these were symmetric synapses, 9% were asymmetric synapses, and 79% were membrane appositions without clear synaptic specializations. In caudal sections, about 30% were symmetric synapses, 11% were asymmetric synapses, and 59% were appositions. In both rostral and caudal sections, 60% of the anterogradely labeled terminals formed synapses with noncatecholamine dendrites, and 20% formed axoaxonic synapses. These results provide direct evidence for monosynaptic projections from neurons in the ventrolateral PAG to the extranuclear dendrites of noradrenergic LC neurons. This monosynaptic pathway may mediate in part the analgesia, reduced responsiveness to external stimuli, and decreased excitability of somatic motoneurons produced by stimulation of neurons in the ventrolateral PAG.

Supraspinal circuitry mediating opioid antinociception: antagonist and synergy studies in multiple sites

Supraspinal opioid antinociception is mediated by sensitive brain sites capable of supporting this response following microinjection of opioid agonists. These sites include the ventrolateral periaqueductal gray (vIPAG), the rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM), the locus coeruleus and the amygdala. Each of these sites comprise an interconnected anatomical and physiologically relevant system mediating antinociceptive responses through regional interactions. Such interactions have been identified using two pharmacological approaches: (1) the ability of selective antagonists delivered to one site to block antinociception elicited by opioid agonists in a second site, and (2) the presence of synergistic antinociceptive interactions following simultaneous administration of subthreshold doses of opioid agonists into pairs of sites. Thus, the RVM has essential serotonergic, opioid, cholinergic and NMDA synapses that are necessary for the full expression of morphine antinociception elicited from the vIPAG, and the vIPAG has essential opioid synapses that are necessary for the full expression of opioid antinociception elicited from the amygdala. Further, the vIPAG, RVM, locus coeruleus and amygdala interact with each other in synergistically supporting opioid antinociception.

Ovarian steroids and serotonin neural function

The serotonin neural system originates from ten nuclei in the mid- and hindbrain regions. The cells of the rostral nuclei project to almost every area of the forebrain, including the hypothalamus, limbic regions, basal ganglia, thalamic nuclei, and cortex. The caudal nuclei project to the spinal cord and interact with numerous autonomic and sensory systems. This article reviews much of the available literature from basic research and relevant clinical research that indicates that ovarian steroid hormones, estrogens and progestins, affect the function of the serotonin neural system. Experimental results in nonhuman primates from this laboratory are contrasted with studies in rodents and humans. The sites of action of ovarian hormones on the serotonin neural system include effects within serotonin neurons as well as effects on serotonin afferent neurons and serotonin target neurons. Therefore, information on estrogen and progestin receptor-containing neurons was synthesized with information on serotonin afferent and efferent circuits. The ability of estrogens and progestins to alter the function of the serotonin neural system at various levels provides a cellular mechanism whereby ovarian hormones can impact mood, cognition, pain, and numerous other autonomic functions.