Forebrain overgrowth (fog): a new mutation in the mouse affecting neural tube development

Apaf1 apoptotic function critically limits Sonic hedgehog signaling during craniofacial development

Apaf1 is an evolutionarily conserved component of the apoptosome. In mammals, the apoptosome assembles when cytochrome c is released from mitochondria, binding Apaf1 in an ATP-dependent manner and activating caspase 9 to execute apoptosis. Here we identify and characterize a novel mouse mutant, yautja, and find it results from a leucine-to-proline substitution in the winged-helix domain of Apaf1. We show that this allele of Apaf1 is unique, as the yautja mutant Apaf1 protein is stable, yet does not possess apoptotic function in cell culture or in vivo assays. Mutant embryos die perinatally with defects in craniofacial and nervous system development, as well as reduced levels of apoptosis. We further investigated the defects in craniofacial development in the yautja mutation and found altered Sonic hedgehog (Shh) signaling between the prechordal plate and the frontonasal ectoderm, leading to increased mesenchymal proliferation in the face and delayed or absent ossification of the skull base. Taken together, our data highlight the time-sensitive link between Shh signaling and the regulation of apoptosis function in craniofacial development to sculpt the face. We propose that decreased apoptosis in the developing nervous system allows Shh-producing cells to persist and direct a lateral outgrowth of the upper jaw, resulting in the craniofacial defects we see. Finally, the novel yautja Apaf1 allele offers the first in vivo understanding of a stable Apaf1 protein that lacks a function, which should make a useful tool with which to explore the regulation of programmed cell death in mammals.

Discovery Genetics - The History and Future of Spontaneous Mutation Research

Historically, spontaneous mutations in mice have served as valuable models of heritable human diseases, contributing substantially to our understanding of both disease mechanisms and basic biological pathways. While advances in molecular technologies have improved our ability to create mouse models of human disease through targeted mutagenesis and transgenesis, spontaneous mutations continue to provide valuable research tools for discovery of novel genes and functions. In addition, the genetic defects caused by spontaneous mutations are molecularly similar to mutations in the human genome and, therefore often produce phenotypes that more closely resemble those characteristic of human disease than do genetically engineered mutations. Due to the rarity with which spontaneous mutations arise and the animal intensive nature of their genetic analysis, large-scale spontaneous mutation analysis has traditionally been limited to large mammalian genetics institutes. More recently, ENU mutagenesis and new screening methods have increased the rate of mutant strain discovery, and high-throughput DNA sequencing has enabled rapid identification of the underlying genes and their causative mutations. Here, we discuss the continued value of spontaneous mutations for biomedical research.

Craniofacial features resembling frontonasal dysplasia with a tubulonodular interhemispheric lipoma in the adult 3H1 tuft mouse

Intracranial lipomas are rare, but 45% of them occur along the midline cisterns between the hemispheres and are often associated with corpus callosum hypoplasia and craniofacial defects. They are difficult to detect as they are generally asymptomatic and visible by MRI or by postmortem examination. The exact cause of these interhemispheric lipomas is not known, but they arise from a developmental defect resulting in the maldifferentiation of mesenchymal cells into mesodermal derivatives that are not normally present. We have identified a new mouse mutant called tuft, exhibiting a forebrain, intracranial lipoma with midline craniofacial defects resembling frontonasal dysplasia (FND) that arose spontaneously in our wild-type 3H1 colony. The tuft trait seems to be transmitted in recessive fashion, but approximately 80% less frequent than the expected Mendelian 25%, due to either incomplete penetrance or prenatal lethality. MRI and histologic analysis revealed that the intracranial lipoma occurred between the hemispheres and often protruded through the sagittal suture. We also observed a lesion at the lamina terminalis (LT) that may indicate improper closure of the anterior neuropore. We have mapped the tuft trait to within an 18 cM region on mouse chromosome 10 by microsatellite linkage analysis and identified several candidate genes involved with craniofacial development and cellular differentiation of adipose tissue. Tuft is the only known mouse model for midline craniofacial defects with an intracranial lipoma. Identifying the gene(s) and mutation(s) causing this early developmental defect will help us understand the pathogenesis of FND and related craniofacial disorders.

Genetics and development of neural tube defects

Congenital defects of neural tube closure (neural tube defects; NTDs) are among the commonest and most severe disorders of the fetus and newborn. Disturbance of any of the sequential events of embryonic neurulation produce NTDs, with the phenotype (eg anencephaly, spina bifida) varying depending on the region of neural tube that remains open. While mutation of > 200 genes is known to cause NTDs in mice, the pattern of occurrence in humans suggests a multifactorial polygenic or oligogenic aetiology. This emphasizes the importance of gene-gene and gene-environment interactions in the origins of these defects. A number of cell biological functions are essential for neural tube closure, with defects of the cytoskeleton, cell cycle and molecular regulation of cell viability prominent among the mouse NTD mutants. Many transcriptional regulators and proteins that affect chromatin structure are also required for neural tube closure, although the downstream molecular pathways regulated by these proteins is unknown. Some key signalling pathways for NTDs have been identified: over-activation of sonic hedgehog signalling and loss of function in the planar cell polarity (non-canonical Wnt) pathway are potent causes of NTD, with requirements also for retinoid and inositol signalling. Folic acid supplementation is an effective method for primary prevention of a proportion of NTDs in both humans and mice, although the embryonic mechanism of folate action remains unclear. Folic acid-resistant cases can be prevented by inositol supplementation in mice, raising the possibility that this could lead to an additional preventive strategy for human NTDs in future.

Pharmacological inhibition of mitochondrial membrane permeabilization for neuroprotection

Recent data have provided important clues about the molecular mechanisms underlying certain neurodegenerative diseases. Most cell death in vertebrates proceeds via the mitochondrial pathway of apoptosis. Mitochondria contain proapoptotic factors such as cytochrome c and AIF in their intermembrane space. Furthermore, mitochondrial membrane permeabilization (MMP) is a critical event during apoptosis, representing the "point of no return" of the lethal process. Modern medicine is developing an increasing number of drugs for neurodegenerative disease, but no neuroprotective treatment has yet been established. While current treatments temporarily alleviate symptoms, they do not halt disease progression. This paper briefly reviews the pharmacological inhibition of mitochondrial membrane permeabilization for neuroprotection.

HIV protease inhibitors provide neuroprotection through inhibition of mitochondrial apoptosis in mice

Neuroprotection can be achieved by preventing apoptotic death of postmitotic cells. Apoptotic death can occur by either a caspase-dependent mechanism, involving cytochrome c, apoptosis protease-activating factor-1 (Apaf-1), and caspase-9, or a caspase-independent mechanism, involving apoptosis-inducing factor (AIF). HIV protease inhibitors (PIs) avert apoptosis in part by preventing mitochondrial outer membrane permeabilization (MOMP), but the precise mechanism by which they work is not known. Here, we evaluated the impact of the PIs in a mouse model of retinal detachment (RD) in vivo and in murine primary retinal cell cultures in vitro. Oral administration of the PIs nelfinavir and ritonavir significantly inhibited photoreceptor apoptosis, while preventing the translocation of AIF from mitochondria to the nucleus as well as the activation of caspase-9. RD-induced photoreceptor apoptosis was similarly inhibited in mice carrying hypomorphic mutations of the genes encoding AIF or Apaf-1. Nelfinavir attenuated apoptosis as well as mitochondrial release of AIF and cytochrome c, and subsequent activation of caspase-9 in vitro, in photoreceptor cultures exposed to starvation or monocyte chemoattractant protein-1-stimulated (MCP-1-stimulated) macrophages. Our results suggest that the MOMP inhibition by PIs involved interruption of both caspase-dependent and caspase-independent apoptosis pathways and that PIs may be clinically useful for the treatment of diseases caused by excessive apoptosis.

Developing postmitotic mammalian neurons in vivo lacking Apaf-1 undergo programmed cell death by a caspase-independent, nonapoptotic pathway involving autophagy

Previous studies have shown that caspases and Apaf-1 are required for the normal programmed cell death (PCD) in vivo of immature postmitotic neurons and mitotically active neuronal precursor cells. In contrast, caspase activity is not necessary for the normal PCD of more mature postmitotic neurons that are establishing synaptic connections. Although normally these cells use caspases for PCD, in the absence of caspase activity these neurons undergo a distinct nonapoptotic type of degeneration. We examined the survival of these more mature postmitotic neuronal populations in mice in which Apaf-1 has been genetically deleted and find that they exhibit quantitatively normal PCD of developing postmitotic neurons. We next characterized the morphological mode of PCD in these mice and show that the neurons degenerate by a caspase-independent, nonapoptotic pathway that involves autophagy. However, autophagy does not appear to be involved in the normal PCD of postmitotic neurons in which caspases and Apaf-1 are present and functional because quantitatively normal neuronal PCD occurred in the absence of a key gene required for autophagy (ATG7). Finally, we examined the possible role of another caspase-independent type of neuronal PCD involving the apoptosis-inducing factor (AIF). Mice deficient in AIF also exhibit quantitatively normal PCD of postmitotic neurons after caspase inhibition. Together, these data indicate that, when key components of the type 1 apoptotic pathway (i.e., caspases and Apaf-1) are perturbed in vivo, developing postmitotic neurons nonetheless undergo quantitatively normal PCD by a caspase-independent pathway involving autophagy and not requiring AIF.

Mouse mutants with neural tube closure defects and their role in understanding human neural tube defects

BACKGROUND

The number of mouse mutants and strains with neural tube closure defects (NTDs) now exceeds 190, including 155 involving known genes, 33 with unidentified genes, and eight "multifactorial" strains.

METHODS

The emerging patterns of mouse NTDs are considered in relation to the unknown genetics of the common human NTDs, anencephaly, and spina bifida aperta.

RESULTS

Of the 150 mouse mutants that survive past midgestation, 20% have risk of either exencephaly and spina bifida aperta or both, parallel to the majority of human NTDs, whereas 70% have only exencephaly, 5% have only spina bifida, and 5% have craniorachischisis. The primary defect in most mouse NTDs is failure of neural fold elevation. Most null mutations (>90%) produce syndromes of multiple affected structures with high penetrance in homozygotes, whereas the "multifactorial" strains and several null-mutant heterozygotes and mutants with partial gene function (hypomorphs) have low-penetrance nonsyndromic NTDs, like the majority of human NTDs. The normal functions of the mutated genes are diverse, with clusters in pathways of actin function, apoptosis, and chromatin methylation and structure. The female excess observed in human anencephaly is found in all mouse exencephaly mutants for which gender has been studied. Maternal agents, including folate, methionine, inositol, or alternative commercial diets, have specific preventative effects in eight mutants and strains.

CONCLUSIONS

If the human homologs of the mouse NTD mutants contribute to risk of common human NTDs, it seems likely to be in multifactorial combinations of hypomorphs and low-penetrance heterozygotes, as exemplified by mouse digenic mutants and the oligogenic SELH/Bc strain.

Apoptosome impairment during development results in activation of an autophagy program in cerebral cortex

The deficiency of upstream regulators of the mitochondrial death pathway has been recently shown to trigger in vitro a cellular process of self-clearance with features of autophagy. We show here that, when Apaf1 (responsible for apoptosome formation) is downregulated in vivo in cortical precursors, cells express markers of neuronal differentiation, accumulate in ectopic cortical masses and show hallmarks of the beclin-1-dependent pathway of autophagy, probably activated by a depletion in growth factors in the cells' microenvironment. To visualize this process in a cell culture model system, we also used a neural precursor cell line to mimic growth factor starvation in the absence of the apoptosome and tracked autophagolysosome formation. Our findings demonstrate the existence of an interplay between the autophagy and apoptosis pathways in vivo in brain development, and possibly link the absence of apoptosis to the occurrence of pathological conditions associated with peculiar cellular morphotypes.

Neurulation in the cranial region--normal and abnormal

Cranial neurulation is the embryonic process responsible for formation of the brain primordium. In the mouse embryo, cranial neurulation is a piecemeal process with several initiation sites and two neuropores. Variation in the pattern of cranial neurulation occurs in different mouse strains, and a simpler version of this morphogenetic scheme has been described in human embryos. Exencephaly is more common in females than in males, an unexplained phenomenon seen in both mice and humans. As the cranial neural tube closes, a critical morphogenetic event is the formation of dorsolateral bending points near the neural fold tips, which enables subsequent midline fusion of the neural folds. Many mutant and gene-targeted mouse strains develop cranial neural tube defects, and analysis of the underlying molecular defects identifies several requirements for normal dorsolateral bending. These include a functional actin cytoskeleton, emigration of the cranial neural crest, spatio-temporally regulated apoptosis, and a balance between cell proliferation and the onset of neuronal differentiation. A small number of mouse mutants exhibit craniorachischisis, a combined brain and spine neurulation defect. Recent studies show that disturbance of a single molecular signalling cascade, the planar cell polarity pathway, is implicated in mutants with this defect.

Complementary expression pattern ofZfhx1 genesSip1 andδEF1 in the mouse embryo and their genetic interaction revealed by compound mutants

In mouse embryos, the Zfhx1 transcription factor genes, Sip1 and deltaEF1, are expressed in complementary domains in many tissues. Their possible synergism in embryogenesis was investigated by comparing the phenotype of Sip1-/-;deltaEF1-/- double homozygotes with single homozygous embryos. Unexpectedly, in Sip1-/- embryos deltaEF1 was ectopically activated, suggesting a negative regulation of deltaEF1 expression by Sip1. Sip1-/-;deltaEF1-/- embryos were similar to Sip1-/- embryos in short somite production and developmental arrest around E8.5, but showed more severe defects in dorsal neural tube morphogenesis accompanied by a larger reduction of Sox2 expression, ascribable to the loss of the ectopic deltaEF1 expression. Sip1+/-;deltaEF1-/- embryos develop various morphological defects after E10 that were absent in deltaEF1-/- embryos even in tissues without significant overlap of Sip1 and deltaEF1 expression, and arrested during mid gestation earlier than deltaEF1-/- embryos. These findings indicate that complex synergistic interactions occur between Zfhx1 transcription factor genes during mouse embryogenesis.

Expanding roles of programmed cell death in mammalian neurodevelopment

Programmed cell death is an orchestrated form of cell death in which cells are actively involved in their own demise. During neural development in mammals, many progenitor cells, immature cells or differentiated cells undergo the most clearly characterized type of cell death, apoptosis. Several pathways of apoptosis have been linked to neural development, but according to the numerous and striking phenotypes observed when apoptotic genes are inactivated, the mitochondrial death-route is the most important pathway in this context. Here, we discuss the relative importance of pro-growth/pro-death factors in the control of neural tissue development. We also discuss the impact of studying programmed cell death in development in order to better understand the basis of several human diseases and embryonic defects of the nervous system.

Hemimegalencephaly: part 2. Neuropathology suggests a disorder of cellular lineage

Cerebral tissue from hemispherectomy in three children (two 4-month-old girls and one 4-year-old boy) with hemimegalencephaly was studied using histochemical and immunocytochemical markers of neuronal and glial maturation and identity. Histologic abnormalities of cellular growth and cytomorphology, including "balloon cells," were present in both gray and white matter, in addition to disorganized tissue architecture. Cells in the mitotic cycle were absent. Many hypertrophic, atypical cells with enlarged processes exhibited mixed or ambiguous lineage, with immunoreactivity for both glial (glial fibrillary acidic protein [GFAP]; S-100beta) and neuronal proteins (microtubule-associated protein 2 [MAP2], neuronal nuclear antigen, chromogranin A, and neurofilament protein [NFP]). Strong vimentin reactivity was present in neurons, as well as glial cells and cells of mixed lineage, suggesting incomplete maturation. Synaptophysin-reactive axons terminated on a minority of balloon cells and on most heterotopic single neurons in white matter, confirmed by electron microscopy, demonstrating that single heterotopic neurons are not synaptically "isolated," as they may appear; thus, they are capable of contributing to epilepsy. Oligodendrocytes are the least affected cells, at least in some cases. The findings are reminiscent of the hamartomas of tuberous sclerosis. We conclude that hemimegalencephaly is a primary disorder of neuroepithelial lineage and cellular growth. A migratory disturbance contributes to disorderly tissue architecture but is secondary. No pathologic difference is detected between isolated and syndromic forms of hemimegalencephaly.

The genetic basis of mammalian neurulation

More than 80 mutant mouse genes disrupt neurulation and allow an in-depth analysis of the underlying developmental mechanisms. Although many of the genetic mutants have been studied in only rudimentary detail, several molecular pathways can already be identified as crucial for normal neurulation. These include the planar cell-polarity pathway, which is required for the initiation of neural tube closure, and the sonic hedgehog signalling pathway that regulates neural plate bending. Mutant mice also offer an opportunity to unravel the mechanisms by which folic acid prevents neural tube defects, and to develop new therapies for folate-resistant defects.

Murine calmodulin binding protein 1 (Calmbp1): tissue-specific expression during development and in adult tissues

Expression of the 1.9 kb cDNA of murine Calmbp1 has been shown to interfere with the mitotic S-M checkpoint in yeast (J. Cell Sci. 111 (1998) 3609). The physiological function and expression pattern of Calmbp1 in mice, however, are unknown. We have investigated the expression of Calmbp1 in mid-gestation and late-gestation fetuses and in adult organs of the mouse. In Northern blot analyses, using a Calmbp1-specific probe, a single mRNA of more than 7.4 kb was found that showed a progressive decline in total RNA preparations of fetal heads during the period from day E12 to E16. In the adult, this Calmbp1 transcript was detectable by Northern blot analysis exclusively in testis, ovary and spleen of all organs examined. In situ hybridizations revealed that Calmbp1 is expressed (a) in the differentiating central and peripheral nervous system, (b) in the epithelial cells lining the crypts of the small intestine in late gestation and adult mice, (c) in the fetal, but not the adult liver, (d) in both the fetal and adult spleen, where the signal colocalized with hematopoetic cells in the red pulp, (e) in late gestation embryos in the thymus, S-shaped tubules in the kidney, epidermis, and (f) in leptotene, zygotene and pachytene spermatocytes of the adult testis and the follicle epithelium of the activated follicles in the adult ovary.

Hemimegalencephaly: part 1. Genetic, clinical, and imaging aspects

Hemimegalencephaly is a rare hamartomatous malformation of the brain, remarkable for its extreme asymmetry. It can be isolated or associated with several neurocutaneous syndromes; less frequently, it also involves the brain stem and cerebellum. Traditionally, hemimegalencephaly has been considered a primary neuroblast migratory disturbance. At present, genetic theories of pathogenesis and modern histopathology provide a basis for this complex malformation as a primary disturbance in cellular lineage, differentiation, and proliferation, interacting with a disturbance in gene expression of body symmetry, with earlier onset than radial neuroblast migration. From my personal experience with 10 patients with hemimegalencephaly and review of the literature, I have found the same clinical neurologic, neuroimaging, and neuropathologic features in isolated and syndromic hemimegalencephaly. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) reveals abnormal gyration, ventriculomegaly, colpocephaly, an "occipital sign" (displacement of the occipital lobe across the midline), and increased volume and T2 signal of white matter, in addition to the overall increased size of the involved hemisphere. Mild, moderate, and severe grades of severity can be recognized, providing a functional neurologic prognosis and therapeutic plan. Early diagnosis is crucial because despite neuroimaging and pathologic evidence, hemimegalencephaly sometimes still is unrecognized. Also, misdiagnosis of obstructive hydrocephalus or cerebral neoplasm can lead to unnecessary surgical procedures. Although hemispherectomy has a high morbidity, it is recommended early for patients with severe, intractable epilepsy. The mildest forms of hemimegalencephaly are infrequent and the least recognized.

Apaf-1 deficiency and neural tube closure defects are found in fog mice

The forebrain overgrowth mutation (fog) was originally described as a spontaneous autosomal recessive mutation mapping to mouse chromosome 10 that produces forebrain defects, facial defects, and spina bifida. Although the fog mutant has been characterized and available to investigators for several years, the underlying mutation causing the pathology has not been known. Because of its phenotypic resemblance to apoptotic protease activating factor-1 (Apaf-1) knockout mice, we have investigated the possibility that the fog mutation is in the Apaf-1 gene. Allelic complementation, Western blot analysis, and caspase activation assays indicate that fog mutant mice lack Apaf-1 activity. Northern blot and reverse transcription-PCR analysis show that Apaf-1 mRNA is aberrantly processed, resulting in greatly reduced expression levels of normal Apaf-1 mRNA. These findings are strongly suggestive of the fog mutation being a hypomorphic Apaf-1 defect and implicate neural progenitor cell death in the pathogenesis of spina bifida-a common human congenital malformation. Because a complete deficiency in Apaf-1 usually results in perinatal lethality and fog/fog mice more readily survive into adulthood, these mutants serve as a valuable model with which apoptotic cell death can be studied in vivo.

Neurofibromin deficiency in mice causes exencephaly and is a modifier for Splotch neural tube defects

Neural tube defects are common and serious human congenital anomalies. These malformations have a multifactorial etiology and can be reproduced in mouse models by mutations of numerous individual genes and by perturbation of multiple environmental factors. The identification of specific genetic interactions affecting neural tube closure will facilitate our understanding of molecular pathways regulating normal neural development and will enhance our ability to predict and modify the incidence of spina bifida and other neural tube defects. Here, we report a genetic interaction between Nf1, encoding the intracellular signal transduction protein neurofibromin, and Pax3, a transcription factor gene mutated in the Splotch mouse. Both Pax3 and Nf1 are important for the development of neural crest-derived structures and the central nervous system. Splotch is an established model of folate-sensitive neural tube defects, and homozygous mutant embryos develop spina bifida and sometimes exencephaly. Neural development is grossly normal in heterozygotes and neural tube defects are not seen. In contrast, we found a low incidence of neural tube defects in heterozygous Splotch mice that also harbored a mutation in one Nf1 allele. All compound homozygotes had severe neural tube defects and died earlier in embryogenesis than either Nf1(-/-) or Sp(-/-) embryos. We also report occasional exencephaly in Nf1(-/-) mice and identify more subtle CNS abnormalities in normal-appearing Nf1(-/-) embryos. Though other genetic loci and environmental factors affect the incidence of neural tube defects in Splotch mice, these results establish Nf1 as the first known gene to act as a modifier of neural tube defects in Splotch.

Apaf1 (CED-4 homolog) regulates programmed cell death in mammalian development

The cytosolic protein APAF1, human homolog of C. elegans CED-4, participates in the CASPASE 9 (CASP9)-dependent activation of CASP3 in the general apoptotic pathway. We have generated by gene trap a null allele of the murine Apaf1. Homozygous mutants die at embryonic day 16.5. Their phenotype includes severe craniofacial malformations, brain overgrowth, persistence of the interdigital webs, and dramatic alterations of the lens and retina. Homozygous embryonic fibroblasts exhibit reduced response to various apoptotic stimuli. In situ immunodetection shows that the absence of Apaf1 protein prevents the activation of Casp3 in vivo. In agreement with the reported function of CED-4 in C. elegans, this phenotype can be correlated with a defect of apoptosis. Our findings suggest that Apaf1 is essential for Casp3 activation in embryonic brain and is a key regulator of developmental programmed cell death in mammals.

Genetic landmarks for defects in mouse neural tube closure

Many mutations cause neural tube closure defects (NTDs, exencephaly or spina bifida) in mice and the gene loci are widely distributed in the mouse genome. This compilation summarizes the map position of 40 mouse NTD mutations and the corresponding human linkage homology of each. It includes the nature of the gene product where known, and whether the NTD is part of a syndrome involving other developmental systems. Also listed are the several mouse strains known to have genetic susceptibility to exencephaly, with multifactorial genetic cause in at least one case. The purposes of this mouse NTD compilation are to enable recognition of patterns in genetic causes of NTDs, of molecular pathways essential for closure of specific regions of the mammalian neural tube, and of candidate regions for mapping loci contributing to human multifactorial NTDs.