Localization of cytosolic aldehyde dehydrogenase in the developing chick retina: in situ hybridization and immunohistochemical analyses

Evolutionary conservation of alternative splicing in chicken

Alternative splicing represents a source of great diversity for regulating protein expression and function. It has been estimated that one-third to two-thirds of mammalian genes are alternatively spliced. With the sequencing of the chicken genome and analysis of transcripts expressed in chicken tissues, we are now in a position to address evolutionary conservation of alternative splicing events in chicken and mammals. Here, we compare chicken and mammalian transcript sequences of 41 alternatively-spliced genes and 50 frequently accessed genes. Our results support a high frequency of splicing events in chicken, similar to that observed in mammals.

The effect of in ovo ethanol exposure on retina and optic nerve in a chick embryo model system

Ocular anomalies seen in children with fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS) suggest that ocular structures are sensitive to alcohol exposure during their development. This study was designed to investigate the effect of in ovo ethanol (EtOH) exposure on retinal development and myelinization of optic nerve fibers at an ultra structural level in a chick embryo model system. Prior to incubation, fertilized chicken eggs were injected once with 100 microl of either 0.9% NaCl (vehicle control), or EtOH solutions at different doses (10, 30, or 50%, v:v in 0.9% NaCl) into their air sacs and incubated at 37.5 degrees C and saturation humidity. On day 20 embryos were analyzed in terms of their viability and growth and the optic cups including the optic nerves were dissected out. Specimens were processed for electron microscopy (EM). Results showed that, EtOH significantly decreased the viability of chick embryos (P < 0.045), and caused significant prenatal growth retardation (P < 0.004) in a dose-dependant manner. Light microscopy of semi thin sections revealed that prenatal exposure to EtOH resulted in both retinal degeneration and optic nerve hypoplasia (P < 0.001) in a dose-dependant manner. EM revealed that a dose-dependant decrease in the number of myelinated nerve fibers was profound in groups exposed to EtOH (P < 0.001). Furthermore, the myelin coats observed were thinner than those seen in control embryos. In groups exposed to EtOH myelin sheets were unorganized and contained vacuolar structures in between them. The tissue in between the cells and optic nerve fibers, on the other hand, lost its intact appearance with vacuolar and vesicular structures in between them. In addition, the optic nerve fibers contained granular accumulations in EtOH exposed groups. A dose dependent degeneration was also observed in retinas of EtOH exposed groups. The effect of EtOH was profound in pigment epithelium (PE), inner plexiform layer (IPL), and ganglion cell layer (GC). Mitochondrial deficiencies, and alterations in melanin granule number and distribution dominated the defects seen in PE. On the other hand, EM findings of all the affected layers were suggestive of induced cell death in EtOH exposed groups. Thus, this study suggests retinal development with the emphasis on melanin pigmentation in PE and optic nerve myelinization as potential targets of prenatal EtOH exposure and discusses potential mechanisms of EtOH action on these tissues.

Isolation of a novel cDNA enriched in the undifferentiated chick retina and lens

By using a differential screening strategy, we have identified a previously uncharacterised gene that is preferentially expressed in chick retinal precursor cells as well as in the anterior epithelial cells of the lens at early stages of development. The EURL transcript has an open reading frame of 293 amino acids and a 3' untranslated region of >850 nucleotides. The only recognizable feature in the EURL (early undifferentiated retina and lens) amino acid sequence is a putative coiled-coil domain located at the C-terminus of the protein. The human EURL orthologue maps to chromosome 21q21. Northern blot analysis, in situ hybridization of tissue sections, and whole-mount hybridization indicate elevated levels of EURL mRNA in the embryonic dorsal retina from stage 14 (day 2) to stage 18 (day 3). At day 3.5, when >90% of the retinal cells are in the proliferative stage, EURL transcripts are found primarily in the peripheral dorsal retina, i.e., the most undifferentiated part of the dorsal retina. EURL transcripts are also detected in the lens at stage 18 and remain abundant in the proliferating epithelial cells of the lens until at least day 11. The distribution pattern of EURL in the developing retina and lens suggest a role before the events leading to cell determination and differentiation.

Retinoic acid signalling centres in the avian embryo identified by sites of expression of synthesising and catabolising enzymes

Retinoic acid is an important signalling molecule in the developing embryo, but its precise distribution throughout development is very difficult to determine by available techniques. Examining the distribution of the enzymes by which it is synthesised by using in situ hybridisation is an alternative strategy. Here, we describe the distribution of three retinoic acid synthesising enzymes and one retinoic acid catabolic enzyme during the early stages of chick embryogenesis with the intention of identifying localized retinoic acid signalling regions. The enzymes involved are Raldh1, Raldh2, Raldh3, and Cyp26A1. Although some of these distributions have been described before, here we assemble them all in one species and several novel sites of enzyme expression are identified, including Hensen's node, the cardiac endoderm, the presumptive pancreatic endoderm, and the dorsal lens. This study emphasizes the dynamic pattern of expression of the enzymes that control the availability of retinoic acid as well as the role that retinoic acid plays in the development of many regions of the embryo throughout embryogenesis. This strategy provides a basis for understanding the phenotypes of retinoic acid teratology and retinoic acid-deficiency syndromes.

Analysis of gene expression in the developing mouse retina

In the visual system, differential gene expression underlies development of the anterior-posterior and dorsal-ventral axes. Here we present the results of a microarray screen to identify genes differentially expressed in the developing retina. We assayed gene expression in nasal (anterior), temporal (posterior), dorsal, and ventral embryonic mouse retina. We used a statistical method to estimate gene expression between different retina regions. Genes were clustered according to their expression pattern and were ranked within each cluster. We identified groups of genes expressed in gradients or with restricted patterns of expression as verified by in situ hybridization. A common theme for the identified genes is the differential expression in the dorsal-ventral axis. By analyzing gene expression patterns, we provide insight into the molecular organization of the developing retina.

Characterization of the rat RALDH1 promoter. A functional CCAAT and octamer motif are critical for basal promoter activity

Retinal dehydrogenase type 1 (RALDH1) catalyzes the oxidation of retinal to retinoic acid (RA), a metabolite of vitamin A important for embryogenesis and tissue differentiation. Rat RALDH1 is expressed to high levels in developing kidney, and in stomach, intestine epithelia. To understand the mechanisms of the transcriptional regulation of rat RALDH1, we cloned a 1360-base pair (bp) 5'-flanking region of RALDH1 gene. Using luciferase reporter constructs transfected into HEK 293 and LLCPK (kidney-derived) cells, basal promoter activity was associated with sequences between -80 and +43. In this minimal promoter region, TATA and CCAAT cis-acting elements as well as SP1, AP1 and octamer (Oct)-binding sites were present. The CCAAT box and Oct-binding site, located between positions -72 and -68 and -56 and -49, respectively, were shown by deletion analysis and site-directed mutation to be critical for promoter activity. Nuclear extracts from kidney cells contain proteins specifically binding the Oct and CCAAT sequences, resulting in the formation of six complexes, while different patterns of complexes were observed with non-kidney cell extracts. Gel shift assays using either single or double mutations of the Oct and CCAAT sequences as well as super shift assays demonstrated single and double occupancy of these two sites by Oct-1 and CBF-A. In addition, unidentified proteins also bound the Oct motif specifically in the absence of CBF-A binding. These results demonstrate specific involvement of Oct and CCAAT-binding proteins in the regulation of RALDH1 gene.

The dorsal-ventral axis of the neural retina is divided into multiple domains of restricted gene expression which exhibit features of lineage compartments

The neural retina is a complex sensory structure designed to receive, integrate, and transmit visual information. An important aspect of retinal development is the establishment of pattern along the dorsal-ventral (D-V) and anterior-posterior (A-P) axes. The recent identification and functional characterization of a dorsal-specific and a ventral-specific transcription factor suggested that the D-V axis is divided into two domains. This study characterizes the expression patterns of these and other D-V markers, and establishes that the retina is subdivided into at least four domains of gene expression along this axis. The composition and spatial relation of these expression domains alters our model of D-V patterning, suggesting more complexity in the way that the retina is patterned than was previously recognized. As domains of gene expression within developing tissues sometimes comprise compartments whose borders are not crossed by clonally related cells, we performed a retroviral lineage study. A strong preference for cells to remain in their original domain of gene expression was observed, suggesting that these borders comprise developmental compartments.

Expression of spermidine/spermine N(1)-acetyltransferase in the Müller glial cells of the developing chick retina

A number of genes have been found to be asymmetrically expressed along the three axes of the retina: central-peripheral, dorsal-ventral, temporal-nasal. Some of the asymmetrically expressed genes have been shown to play a role in the establishment of boundaries required for guiding retinal axons to their correct targets in the brain. Asymmetric expression during development can also be a consequence of the different rates of differentiation along the three retinal axes. The authors have used a differential-display-PCR approach to identify genes asymmetrically expressed along the dorsal-ventral axis in the chick retina. One of the selected genes, spermidine/spermine N(1)-acetyltransferase (SSAT), was preferentially expressed in the dorsal-temporal quadrant of the developing retina. There was a sharp increase in retinal SSAT mRNA levels during the transition stage from proliferation (E7) to early differentiation (E10). SSAT mRNA was found in Müller glial cells and its distribution pattern in these cells closely followed the three differentiation axes of the developing retina, with a central-dorsal-temporal preference. The elevated levels of SSAT mRNA in Müller glial cells may reflect a requirement for acetylated spermine/spermidine or putrescine in the differentiating neuronal cells of the retina.

Role and distribution of retinoic acid during CNS development

Retinoic acid (RA), the biologically active derivative of vitamin A, induces a variety of embryonal carcinoma and neuroblastoma cell lines to differentiate into neurons. The molecular events underlying this process are reviewed with a view to determining whether these data can lead to a better understanding of the normal process of neuronal differentiation during development. Several transcription factors, intracellular signaling molecules, cytoplasmic proteins, and extracellular molecules are shown to be necessary and sufficient for RA-induced differentiation. The evidence that RA is an endogenous component of the developing central nervous system (CNS) is then reviewed, data which include high-pressure liquid chromotography (HPLC) measurements, reporter systems and the distribution of the enzymes that synthesize RA. The latter is particularly relevant to whether RA signals in a paracrine fashion on adjacent tissues or whether it acts in an autocrine manner on cells that synthesize it. It seems that a paracrine system may operate to begin early patterning events within the developing CNS from adjacent somites and later within the CNS itself to induce subsets of neurons. The distribution of retinoid-binding proteins, retinoid receptors, and RA-synthesizing enzymes is described as well as the effects of knockouts of these genes. Finally, the effects of a deficiency and an excess of RA on the developing CNS are described from the point of view of patterning the CNS, where it seems that the hindbrain is the most susceptible part of the CNS to altered levels of RA or RA receptors and also from the point of view of neuronal differentiation where, as in the case of embryonal carcinoma (EC) cells, RA promotes neuronal differentiation. The crucial roles played by certain genes, particularly the Hox genes in RA-induced patterning processes, are also emphasized.

Differential regulation of the aldehyde dehydrogenase 1 gene in embryonic chick retina and liver

Aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH1) is highly expressed in the dorsal cells of the undifferentiated retina, where it has been proposed to play a role in the formation of a retinoic acid gradient along the ventrodorsal axis. In contrast to the retina, ALDH1 levels increase with differentiation in the liver and remain elevated in the adult tissue. To understand the molecular basis for differential expression of ALDH1 during development, we characterized the ALDH1 transcripts expressed in chick retina and liver. By sequencing, primer extension, and S1 nuclease analysis, we show that retina ALDH1 mRNA has an additional 300 nucleotides of 5'-untranslated sequence resulting from the transcription of two 5' noncoding exons. There is a 24-29-kilobase pair (kb) gap between exons 1 and 2 and a 290-base pair gap between exons 2 and 3. Exon 3, which contains the ALDH1 start codon, represents the first exon of the liver transcript. Using a reporter gene assay, we have identified tissue-specific regulatory elements that govern ALDH1 expression in primary retina and liver cultures. Constructs with >1.6 kb of DNA flanking the 5'-end of exon 1 showed elevated activity in retinal cultures but only basal activity in liver cultures. In contrast, constructs with <1 kb of 5'-flanking DNA were active in both retina and liver cultures. Our results suggest that an important mechanism for the control of ALDH1 transcriptional activity is through the presence of inhibitory elements located 0.7-1.6 kb upstream of the ALDH1 gene. DNase I footprint analysis reveal four sites of protein-DNA interaction within this region, one of which is specific to the liver and corresponds to a NF-kappaB/Rel binding site.

Development of the visual system of the chick. II. Mechanisms of axonal guidance

The quest to understand axonal guidance mechanisms requires exact and multidisciplinary analyses of axon navigation. This review is the second part of an attempt to synthesise experimental data with theoretical models of the development of the topographic connection of the chick retina with the tectum. The first part included classic ideas from developmental biology and recent achievements on the molecular level in understanding cytodifferentiation and histogenesis [J. Mey, S. Thanos, Development of the visual system of the chick. (I) Cell differentiation and histogenesis, Brain Res. Rev. 32 (2000) 343-379]. The present part deals with the question of how millions of fibres exit from the eye, traverse over several millimetres and spread over the optic tectum to assemble a topographic map, whose precision accounts for the sensory performance of the visual system. The following topics gained special attention in this review. (i) A remarkable conceptual continuity between classic embryology and recent molecular biology has revealed that positional cellular specification precedes and determines the formation of the retinotectal map. (ii) Graded expression of asymmetric genes, transcriptional factors and receptors for signal transduction during early development seem to play a crucial role in determining the spatial identity of neurons within surface areas of retina and optic tectum. (iii) The chemoaffinity hypothesis constitutes the conceptual framework for development of the retinotopic organisation of the primary visual pathway. Studies of repulsive factors in vitro developed the original hypothesis from a theoretical postulate of chemoattraction to an empirically supported concept based on chemorepulsion. (iv) The independent but synchronous development of retina and optic tectum in topo-chronologically corresponding patterns ensures that ingrowing retinal axons encounter receptive target tissue at appropriate locations, and at the time when connections are due to be formed. (v) The growth cones of the retino-fugal axons seem to be guided both by local cues on glial endfeet and within the extracellular matrix. On the molecular level, the ephrins and their receptors have emerged as the most likely candidates for the material substrate of a topographic projection along the anterior-posterior axis of the optic tectum. Yet, since a number of alternative molecules have been proposed for the same function, it remains the challenge for the near future to define the proportional contribution of each one of the individual mechanisms proposed by matching theoretical predictions with the experimental evidence.

Sources and sink of retinoic acid in the embryonic chick retina: distribution of aldehyde dehydrogenase activities, CRABP-I, and sites of retinoic acid inactivation

Previous experiments in mice and zebrafish led to the hypothesis that an asymmetric distribution of the transcriptional activator retinoic acid (RA) causes ventral-dorsal polarity in the vertebrate eye anlage. A high concentration of RA in the ventral retinal neuroepithelium has been suggested to induce developmental events that finally establish topographic order in the retinotectal projection along the vertical eye axis. In the present study we have investigated potential sources and sinks of RA during embryonic development of the chick retina. At embryonic day (E)1 to E2, when the spatial determination of the eye primordia takes place, no RA synthesis by aldehyde dehydrogenases was detectable, and neither immunoreactivity for retinaldehyde dehydrogenase RALDH-2 nor for cellular retinoic acid binding protein CRABP-I was observed. These components of RA signal transduction appeared in the eye between E3 and E5. At later stages, RA-measurements with a reporter cell line showed highest synthesis in the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and at the ventral and dorsal poles of the retina. RA degradation occurred mostly in a horizontal region in the middle of the retina with only small differences along the nasal-temporal axis. CRABP-I immunoreactivity appeared first in differentiating retinal ganglion cells with no indication of a spatial gradient across the ventral-dorsal eye axis. RA-production depended on three NAD+-dependent enzyme activities, which could be competitively inhibited by citral. One enzyme, located in the dorsal retina (corresponding to mouse RALDH-1), and one enzyme in the RPE (RALDH-2) were aldehyde dehydrogenases of the same molecular weight (monomers about 55 kDa) but with different isoelectric points (6.5-6.9; 4.9-5.4). The third RA-synthesizing activity (pI 6.0-6.3) was limited to the ventral retina, and likely corresponded to mouse RALDH-3. The restricted localization of retinoid-metabolizing activities along the dorsal-ventral axis of the embryonic chick retina does support the idea that RA is involved in dorsal-ventral eye patterning. However, the late time of appearance of aldehyde dehydrogenase activities and CRABP-I points to functions in cellular differentiation that are distinct from the initiation of the dorsal-ventral polarity.

The role of retinoic acid receptors in neurite outgrowth from different populations of embryonic mouse dorsal root ganglia

Dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons can be categorised into at least three types, based upon their neurotrophin requirement for survival. We have analysed the expression of the retinoic acid receptors (RARs) and the retinoid X receptors (RXRs) in NGF, NT-3 and BDNF dependent neurons isolated from embryonic day (E)13.5 mouse DRG. We show that each population of neurons expressed each of the three RXRs, (alpha), (beta) and (gamma); however, whilst the NGF and NT-3 dependent neurons expressed each of the RARs (alpha), (beta) and (gamma), the BDNF dependent neurons only expressed RAR(alpha) and (beta). When retinoic acid was added to each of the neuronal classes only the NGF and NT-3 dependent neurons responded by extending neurites, and this response involved the upregulation of RAR(beta)(2). This specificity was confirmed by the use of receptor-selective agonists as only a RAR(beta)-selective compound stimulated neurite outgrowth. These results suggest a role for RA acting via RAR(beta)(2) in the outgrowth of neurites.

Development of the visual system of the chick. I. Cell differentiation and histogenesis

This review summarizes present knowledge on the embryonic development of the avian visual projections, based on the domestic chick as a model system. The reductionist goal to understand formation and function of complex neuroanatomical systems on a causal level requires a synthesis of classic developmental biology with recent advances on the molecular mechanisms of cell differentiation and histogenesis. It is the purpose of this article. We are discussing the processes underlying patterning of the anterior neural tube, when the retina and optic tectum are specified and their axial polarity is determined. Then the development of these structures is described from the molecular to the anatomical level. Following sections deal with the establishment of secondary visual connections, and the developmental interactions between compartments of the retinotectal system. Using this latter pathway, from the retina to the optic tectum, many investigations aimed at mechanisms of axonal pathfinding and connectivity have accumulated a vast body of research, which will be covered by a following review.

The role of retinoic acid in embryonic and post-embryonic development

Retinoic acid (RA) is the bioactive metabolite of vitamin A (retinol) which acts on cells to establish or change the pattern of gene activity. Retinol is converted to RA by the action of two types of enzyme, retinol dehydrogenases and retinal dehydrogenases. In the nucleus RA acts as a ligand to activate two families of transcription factors, the RA receptors (RAR) and the retinoid X receptors (RXR) which heterodimerize and bind to the upstream sequences of RA-responsive genes. Thus, in addition to the well-established experimental paradigm of depriving animals of vitamin A to determine the role of RA in embryonic and post-embryonic development, molecular biology has provided us with two additional methodologies: knockout the enzymes or the RAR and RXR in the mouse embryo. The distribution of the enzymes and receptors, and recent experiments to determine the endogenous distribution of RA in the embryo are described here, as well as the effects on the embryo of knocking out the enzymes and receptors. In addition, recent studies using the classical vitamin A-deprivation technique are described, as they have provided novel insights into the regions of the embryo which crucially require RA, and the gene pathways involved in their development. Finally, the post-embryonic or regenerating systems in which RA plays a part are described, i.e. the regenerating limb, lung regeneration, hair cell regeneration in the ear and spinal cord regeneration in the adult.

Visually induced changes in components of the retinoic acid system in fundal layers of the chick

Eye growth is visually regulated via messengers that are released from the retina. The retina involves a yet unknown algorithm to analyse the projected image so that the appropriate growth rates for the back of the eye are ensured. One biochemical candidate that could act as a growth controller, is retinoic acid (RA). Previous work (Seko, Shimokawa and Tokoro, 1996; Mertz et al., 1999) has shown that retinal and choroidal RA levels are indeed predictably changed by visual conditions that cause myopia or hyperopia, respectively. We have studied in which fundal tissues aldehyde dehydrogenase-2 (AHD2) and retinaldehyde dehydrogenase-2 (RALDH2), enzymes involved in RA synthesis, are expressed and at which levels the effects of vision on RA levels may be controlled. Using Northern blot analysis, we have found that the retinal mRNA level of the AHD2 is up-regulated after 3 days of treatment with negative lenses (negative lenses place the image behind the retina). The abundance of the retinal mRNA of a RA receptor, RAR-beta, was up-regulated already after 6 hr of treatment with positive lenses (positive lenses place the image in front of the retina). The up-regulation persisted for at least 1 week. Finally, we have studied the effects of an inhibitor of RA synthesis, disulfiram, on the visual control of eye growth. We found inhibition of myopia as induced by frosted goggles ('deprivation myopia') but no significant inhibitory effects on refractive errors induced by +7D or -7D lenses. Our results are in line with the hypothesis that RA may play a role in the visual control of eye growth. The RA system differs from a number of other candidates (dopamine, cholinergic agents, opiates) in that it distinguishes between positive and negative defocus, similar to the immediate early gene ZENK (Stell et al., 1999). The exact time kinetics of the changes have still to be worked out since it is possible that the changes in RA relate to already occurring changes in growth rather than to initial steps of the signaling cascade.

Complementary domains of retinoic acid production and degradation in the early chick embryo

Excess retinoids as well as retinoid deprivation cause abnormal development, suggesting that retinoid homeostasis is critical for proper morphogenesis. RALDH-2 and CYP26, two key enzymes that carry out retinoic acid (RA) synthesis and degradation, respectively, were cloned from the chick and show significant homology with their orthologs in other vertebrates. Expression patterns of RALDH-2 and CYP26 genes were determined in the early chick embryo by in situ hybridization. During gastrulation and neurulation RALDH-2 and CYP26 were expressed in nonoverlapping regions, with RALDH-2 transcripts localized to the presumptive presomitic and lateral plate mesoderm and CYP26 mRNA to the presumptive mid- and forebrain. The two domains of expression were separated by an approximately 300-micrometer-wide gap, encompassing the presumptive hindbrain. In the limb region, a similar spatial segregation of RALDH-2 and CYP26 expression was found at stages 14 and 15. Limb region mesoderm expressed RALDH-2, whereas the overlying limb ectoderm expressed CYP26. RA-synthesizing and -degrading enzymatic activities were measured biochemically in regions expressing RALDH-2 or CYP26. Regions expressing RALDH-2 generated RA efficiently from precursor retinal but degraded RA only inefficiently. Conversely, tissue expressing CYP26 efficiently degraded but did not synthesize RA. Localized regions of RA synthesis and degradation mediated by these two enzymes may therefore provide a mechanism to regulate RA homeostasis spatially in vertebrate embryos.

Misexpression of the Emx-related homeobox genes cVax and mVax2 ventralizes the retina and perturbs the retinotectal map

The mechanisms that establish the dorsal-ventral (D-V) axis of the eye are poorly understood. We isolated two homeobox genes from mouse and chicken, mVax2 and cVax, whose expression during early eye development is restricted to the ventral retina. In chick, ectopic expression of either Vax leads to ventralization of the early retina, as assayed by expression of the transcription factors Pax2 and Tbx5, and the Eph family members EphB2, EphB3, ephrinB1, and ephrinB2, all of which are normally dorsally or ventrally restricted. Moreover, the projections of dorsal but not ventral ganglion cell axons onto the optic tectum showed profound targeting errors following cVax misexpression. mVax2/cVax thus specify positional identity along the D-V axis of the retina and influence retinotectal mapping.

Retinoic acid: its biosynthesis and metabolism

This article presents a model that integrates the functions of retinoid-binding proteins with retinoid metabolism. One of these proteins, the widely expressed (throughout retinoid target tissues and in all vertebrates) and highly conserved cellular retinol-binding protein (CRBP), sequesters retinol in an internal binding pocket that segregates it from the intracellular milieu. The CRBP-retinol complex appears to be the quantitatively major form of retinol in vivo, and may protect the promiscuous substrate from nonenzymatic degradation and/or non-specific enzymes. For example, at least seven types of dehydrogenases catalyze retinal synthesis from unbound retinol in vitro (NAD+ vs. NADP+ dependent, cytosolic vs. microsomal, short-chain dehydrogenases/reductases vs. medium-chain alcohol dehydrogenases). But only a fraction of these (some of the short-chain de-hydrogenases/reductases) have the fascinating additional ability of catalyzing retinal synthesis from CRBP-bound retinol as well. Similarly, CRBP and/or other retinoid-binding proteins function in the synthesis of retinal esters, the reduction of retinal generated from intestinal beta-carotene metabolism, and retinoic acid metabolism. The discussion details the evidence supporting an integrated model of retinoid-binding protein/metabolism. Also addressed are retinoid-androgen interactions and evidence incompatible with ethanol causing fetal alcohol syndrome by competing directly with retinol dehydrogenation to impair retinoic acid biosynthesis.

Interactions of retinoid binding proteins and enzymes in retinoid metabolism

Naturally occurring retinoids (vitamin A or retinol and its active metabolites) are vital for vision, controlling the differentiation program of epithelial cells in the digestive tract and respiratory system, skin, bone, the nervous system, the immune system, and for hematopoiesis. Retinoids are essential for growth, reproduction (conception and embryonic development), and resistance to and recovery from infection. The functions of retinoids in the embryo begin soon after conception and continue throughout the lifespan of all vertebrates. Both naturally occurring and synthetic retinoids are used in the therapy of various skin diseases, especially acne, for augmenting the treatment of diabetes, and as cancer chemopreventive agents. Retinol metabolites serve as ligands that activate specific transcription factors in the superfamily of steroid/retinoid/thyroid/vitamin D/orphan receptors and thereby control gene expression. Additionally, retinoids may also function through non-genomic actions. Various retinoid binding proteins serve as partners in retinoid function. These binding proteins show high specificity and affinity for specific retinoids and seem to control retinoid metabolism in vivo qualitatively and quantitatively by reducing 'free' retinoid concentrations, protecting retinoids from non-specific interactions, and chaperoning access of metabolic enzymes to retinoids. Implementation of the physiological effects of retinoids depends on the spatial-temporal expressions of binding proteins, receptors and metabolic enzymes. This review will discuss current understanding of the enzymes that catalyze retinol and retinoic acid metabolism and their unique and integral relationship to retinoid binding proteins.

Retinoic acid biosynthetic enzyme ALDH1 localizes in a subset of retinoid-dependent tissues during xenopus development

Control of retinoic acid synthesis in vertebrate organisms is undoubtedly important for regulating the numerous retinoid signaling events which occur during development. The mechanisms which accomplish this task involve enzymes such as class I aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH1), which has recently been found to be conserved from amphibians to mammals and which functions as a retinoic acid biosynthetic enzyme in vivo. Here we have found that Xenopus ALDH1 mRNA and protein is expressed in a subset of retinoid-dependent tissues which develop shortly after neurulation during the tail bud stages. ALDH1 mRNA was first clearly detectable by in situ hybridization in stage 28 tail bud embryos localized in the olfactory placode and pronephros, and at stage 35 mRNA was also detected in the pronephric duct. Antibodies were generated against Xenopus ALDH1, and immunohistochemistry was used to demonstrate that ALDH1 protein accumulates in the olfactory placode, pronephros, and dorsal retina at stage 28, and additionally in the lens placode and pronephric duct at stage 35. Neither ALDH1 mRNA nor protein was detected in the posterior region of Xenopus embryos during the tail bud stages. In contrast to neurula stage embryos in which retinoic acid is distributed in an anteroposterior gradient with the high end posteriorly, we found that tail bud stage embryos have retinoic acid present in significant levels in both the head and trunk regions, but with no detection in the posterior region. These findings are consistent with ALDH1 contributing to retinoic acid synthesis needed for development of certain head structures (olfactory placodes, dorsal retina, lens placode) and certain trunk structures (pronephros and pronephric duct). Dev Dyn 1999;215:264-272.

Retinoic acid synthesis in the developing chick retina

The transcriptional activator retinoic acid (RA) has been shown to influence the early patterning of the vertebrate eye. Models for the establishment of the retinofugal projection postulate gradients of cell-surface markers across the retinal surface that are expressed by ganglion cells and mediate the correct connection of fibers within central target fields. Spatial asymmetries of RA and RA-producing enzymes, as have been found in the eyes of mice and zebrafish, could induce the required asymmetry in gene expression. Here we exploited the large size of the retina of the embryonic chick to analyze the spatial and temporal characteristics of the RA system by HPLC in combination with a reporter cell assay. As in other embryonic vertebrates, the chick retina was found to contain different RA-generating enzymes segregated along the dorsoventral axis. The major RA isomer in both dorsal and ventral retina was all-trans RA, and no 9-cis RA could be detected. This excludes a difference in production of these two isomers as an explanation for the expression of different RA-generating enzymes. At developmental stages embryonic days (E) 4 and 5, the ventral retina contained higher all-trans RA levels than the dorsal retina. After E8, however, the difference disappeared, and in embryos at E9 and older the RA concentration was slightly higher in dorsal than ventral retina.

A ventrodorsal GABA gradient in the embryonic retina prior to expression of glutamate decarboxylase

GABA is known to function as a neurotransmitter in the mature nervous system, and in immature neurons it has been linked to neurotrophic actions. While most GABA is generated by glutamate decarboxylase (GAD), an alternative synthetic pathway is known to originate from putrescine, which is converted via gamma-aminobutyraldehyde in an aldehyde-dehydrogenase-requiring step to GABA. In a search for the role of two aldehyde dehydrogenases expressed in segregated compartments along the dorsoventral axis of the developing retina, we assayed dorsal and ventral retina fractions of the mouse for GABA by high performance liquid chromatography. We found GABA to be present in the embryonic retina, long before expression of GAD, and ventral GABA levels exceeded dorsal levels by more than three-fold. Postnatally, when GAD became detectable, overall GABA levels increased, and the ventrodorsal concentration difference disappeared. Our observations indicate that prior to the formation of synapses the embryonic retina contains a ventrodorsal GABA gradient generated by an alternate synthetic pathway.

A gradient of basic fibroblast growth factor in rod photoreceptors in the normal human retina

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) is an inherited disease that causes primary degeneration of rod photoreceptors in the retina. Although the causal gene (e.g. rhodopsin) is thought to be expressed in all rods across the retina, the degeneration is typically nonuniform, with rods in the far periphery surviving significantly longer than those in the midperiphery and macula. Basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) is a putative survival factor for photoreceptors, and the characteristic regional pattern of rod cell survival in RP suggested that bFGF might be distributed nonuniformly in the human retina. We performed double-label immunocytochemistry on 15 normal human retinas, using anti-bFGF and other antibody markers for retinal neurons and glia. Immunoreactivity for bFGF was consistently absent from cones but was present in rods, populations of cone bipolar and amacrine cells, Müller glial cells, and astrocytes. In the macula, the percentage of bFGF-reactive rods was very low (approximately 0.5%) but it increased in a central to peripheral gradient, accounting for up to approximately 88% of the rods in the far periphery. These findings suggest that a central to peripheral gradient of rod bFGF is present in normal human retina and may influence the pattern of photoreceptor degeneration in RP. The absence of bFGF in cones and the low number of bFGF-positive rods in the macula may correlate with the vulnerability of these cells in RP, age-related macular degeneration, and other retinal diseases.

Characterization of aldehyde dehydrogenase-positive amacrine cells restricted in distribution to the dorsal retina

A class 1 aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) catalyzes oxidation of retinaldehyde to retinoic acid in bovine retina. We used immunocytochemistry and in situ hybridization to localize this enzyme in adult and fetal bovine retinas. Specific ALDH immunoreactivity was present in the cytoplasm of wide-field amacrine cells restricted in distribution to the dorsal part of the adult retina. The somata diameters ranged from approximately 8 microns to approximately 15 microns, and the cells increased in density from approximately 125 cells/mm2 near the horizontal meridian to approximately 425 cells/mm2 in the superior far periphery. The ALDH-positive cells had somata on both sides of the inner plexiform layer (IPL) and processes in two IPL strata. The majority of ALDH-positive cells were unreactive with antibodies against known amacrine cell enzymes and neurotransmitters, including GABA and glycine. The ALDH-positive amacrine cells also did not react with anti-cellular retinoic acid-binding protein, which was present in a subset of GABA-positive amacrine cells. In flat-mounted retinas processed by in situ hybridization, the larger ALDH-positive amacrine cells tended to be more heavily labeled. In addition to amacrine cells, Müller cell processes in the inner retina were weakly immunoreactive for ALDH; however, these glial cells did not contain ALDH mRNA. The pattern of ALDH expression in fetal bovine retinas was documented by immunocytochemistry. No ALDH reactivity was found before 5.5 months; for the remainder of the fetal period, ALDH immunoreactivity was present in amacrine cells similar to those in adult retina. The ALDH-positive amacrine cells in bovine retina are novel, being limited in distribution to the dorsal retina and unlabeled with other amacrine cell-specific markers. Identification of ALDH in amacrine cells provides additional evidence that cells of the inner retina are involved in retinoid metabolism.

Initiation of retinoid signaling in primitive streak mouse embryos: spatiotemporal expression patterns of receptors and metabolic enzymes for ligand synthesis

The requirement of vitamin A (retinol) for successful completion of vertebrate embryogenesis is well established. Retinoid signaling involves a two-step metabolic event in which retinol is first converted to retinal, and then retinal is converted to the active ligand retinoic acid, which modulates the transcriptional activity of a nuclear retinoic acid receptor (RAR). During mouse embryogenesis, retinoic acid is not detected at 6.5 days of embryonic development (E6.5) when gastrulation first initiates, but it is detected at E7.5 and later. This suggests that retinoid signaling during embryogenesis may be initiated during the primitive streak stage. Here we have used whole-mount in situ hybridization to examine E6.5-E8.5 mouse embryos for expression of RAR alpha, RAR beta, RAR gamma, and two enzymes, class IV alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH-IV) and class I aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH-I), which have been shown to have retinol and retinal dehydrogenase activities, respectively. At E6.5, RAR alpha mRNA was expressed ubiquitously in embryonic and extraembryonic tissues, RAR gamma mRNA was detected throughout all embryonic tissues, but mRNAs for RAR beta, ADH-IV, and ALDH-I were not detected. By E7.5, RAR alpha mRNA was still ubiquitous, RAR beta mRNA was now observed in presumptive hindbrain ectoderm and adjacent mesenchyme, RAR gamma mRNA was still observed in all embryonic tissues, and ADH-IV as well as ALDH-I mRNAs were now both expressed in primitive streak mesoderm. In E8.5 embryos, RAR alpha mRNA was still ubiquitous, RAR beta mRNA was present in the caudal hindbrain as well as the closed neural tube and foregut, RAR gamma mRNA was widespread but most prevalent in caudal embryonic tissues, and mRNAs for both ADH-IV and ALDH-I were expressed in cranial mesenchyme, somites, and paraxial mesoderm. Thus, ADH-IV and ALDH-1, two metabolic enzymes able to convert retinol to retinoic acid, are both initially expressed in primitive streak mesoderm at E7.5 when retinoic acid is first detectable. On the other hand, RAR alpha and RAR gamma expression is widespread and present at E6.5 prior to retinoic acid detection. These results suggest that upregulation of ADH-IV and ALDH-I gene expression in primitive streak mesoderm may lead to retinoic acid synthesis and initiation of retinoid signaling during mouse embryogenesis.