Cherubism: an analysis of treatment

Defining a new aggressiveness classification and using NFATc1 localization as a prognostic factor in cherubism

Cherubism is a rare genetic disease characterized by bilateral giant cell reparative granuloma of the jaws consisting of a fibrotic stroma with giant multinucleated cells (GMCs) and osteoclastic features. Cherubism severity is highly variable, and recurrence after surgery is the most important risk. Currently, there are no prognostic indicators. The aims of this study were to evaluate the osteoclastogenesis phenotype by histologic examination of nuclear factor of activated T cells 1 (NFATc1) localization and tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) activity and to correlate the results to disease aggressiveness to define prognostic indicators. Based on cherubism evolution 1 year after surgery, 3 classes of cherubism aggressiveness were identified: mild (group A), moderate (group B), and severe (group C). Histologically, in grade A and B cherubism lesions, GMCs were negative for both TRAP activity and NFATc1 nuclear localization. In contrast, in grade C cherubism lesions, GMCs were all positive for TRAP activity and NFATc1 nuclear localization and displayed osteoclast-like features. Other histopathologic findings were not different among the 3 groups. Our results establish that TRAP activity and NFTAc1 nuclear localization are associated with aggressive cherubism and therefore could be added to routine pathologic examination to aid in prognosis and management of the disease. The finding of NFATc1 nuclear localization in aggressive tumors supports the addition of anticalcineurin treatment to the therapeutic arsenal for cherubism.

[Cherubism: a case followed for 18 years]

Cherubism is a rare and benign bone disease affecting the bones of the face, mainly the mandible, sometimes the maxilla and exceptionally the whole skeleton. The physiopathology is briefly mentioned, especially the genetic aspect of the disease. Subsequently, we present the case of a patient suffering from cherubism, a case we have been following from the age of four and a half to the age of 22. Each step of the surgical treatment is illustrated through a wide iconography. The discussion analyses the intellectual process that leads to diagnosis. The clinical examination is fundamental, as well as the radiological check-up but the latter may not be feasible due to the young age of the patient. The definite diagnosis relies on the histological examination of the bone concerned. It will show an association of dense, abundant and highly vascularised conjunctive tissue together with giant plurinuclear cells, without any mitosis nor any cellular atypia. The other bone diseases affecting the bones of the face will have to be sought, of course, and eliminated through the clinical and radiological examinations and, above all, by the histological examination which is the basis of the definite diagnosis. The treatment of cherubism is still a controversial issue: some authors are in favour of therapeutic abstention while others support the recourse to surgery to deal with the functional and aesthetic dimensions of the disease. In conclusion, the authors insist that the diagnosis of cherubism is apparently easy. Cherubism must be envisaged in the case of a chubby-cheeked child and a sample of pathological bone should be taken in order to ascertain the diagnosis.

Bone Lesions of the Head and Neck

This article describes the clinical, radiographic, and pathologic features of tumors and tumorlike lesions affecting the bones of the head and neck region. Emphasis is placed on common bone lesions affecting the craniofacial skeleton, particularly those that occur with more frequency or those that are unique to this part of the skeleton. Several of these lesions pose a diagnostic challenge to the pathologist. To ensure that a correct diagnosis is rendered, it is of utmost importance that accurate and detailed clinical and radiographic information is available.

Cherubism: a clinical, radiographic, and histopathologic comparison of 7 cases

PURPOSE

Cherubism is an uncommon fibro-osseous disorder of the jaws that presents with varying degrees of involvement and a tendency toward spontaneous remission. Lesions are characterized by replacement of bone with fibrovascular tissue containing abundant multinucleated giant cells. We attempted to study the relationships among the degree of cherubism, the radiographic extent of the jaw lesions, the histopathologic findings, and the clinical course of 7 patients.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In 7 patients diagnosed with cherubism, we evaluated the degree of fibrosis and perivascular cuffing, the presence of focal hemosiderin deposits, and giant multinucleated cell density (absent, few, moderate, or severe). Clinical course and progression were also assessed using a 4-point scale (improvement, no changes, modest progression, and marked progression).

RESULTS

The patients were followed up for an average of 8.5 years. Two patients exhibited clinical and radiographic improvement, while 3 showed no changes, and 2 progressed despite surgical treatment in 1 of them.

CONCLUSION

The course of cherubism in 1 of our patients may represent evidence of an association between the presence of abundant multinucleated giant cells, an increased extent of the lesions, and a more aggressive behavior of the disease.

Clinical and radiological evaluation of cherubism: a sporadic case report and review of the literature

Many cases have been published on cherubism since Jones described it first time in three children of the same family [Am. J. Cancer 17 (1933) 946]. Cherubism is an autosomal-dominant disorder in which the normal bone is replaced by cellular fibrous tissue and immature bone. Extracranial skeletal involvement is rarely seen in hereditary and non-hereditary forms of the disorder. The mandible is the most severely affected craniofacial component, in which uncontrolled growth of the malady deteriorates the aesthetic balance of the face. Bilateral swelling of the cheeks, mandibular enlargement and maxillary spongious hypertrophy cause orbital manifestations and tendency of eyes looking up to the sky. Thus, the pathognomic clinical feature resembles the appearance of "raised to heaven" Renaissance cherubs. The sporadic case concerns a child affected by cherubism. Radiographic and clinical data of the patient are presented and brief review of the literature is included.

Cherubism: clinical evidence and therapy

Cherubism is a hereditary childhood disease of autosomal dominant inheritance that is more common in the male sex. Some cases have also revealed a mutation of the gene FGF-RIII (fibroblast growth factor receptor III). The clinical picture of cherubism is characterized by painless symmetrical swelling of the mandible and polycystic destruction of the mandibular bone structure. Complications include delayed dentition, dental root resorption, malalignment of teeth, and impacted teeth. The disease progression comes to a halt of its own accord at the end of puberty. Spontaneous recoveries have been observed. Histologically, multinuclear giant cells with osteoclastic activity, which correspond to a giant cell granuloma, are found in fibrous stroma. It is generally agreed that decisions about surgical intervention should be considered carefully. A case report describes the course of the disease and therapy of a female patient with a periorbital manifestation of cherubism. The latero-orbital enlargement of the intraorbital and latero-orbital region of the zygomatic bone resulted in displacement of the orbital contents with a motility disorder of the eyes. The motility disorder was eliminated by reduction of the diseased hard tissue as well as by carrying out a modeling orbitotomy and by reconstructing an anatomically correct localized and irregular bilateral osseous structure of the zygomatic bone in the intraorbital and latero-orbital region.

[Clinical and molecular genetic observations on families with cherubism over three generations]

BACKGROUND

Cherubism is a rare fibro-osseous disorder that almost exclusively affects the maxilla and mandible.

CASE REPORT

We report on three affected males in three generations in family A, and ten affected patients in family B. The youngest affected relative in family A also had craniosynostosis. His father and grandfather had cherubism and clubbed fingers.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Cherubism was mapped to region 4p16.3. Because of the associated craniosynostosis, we excluded the FGFR3 gene as a candidate gene for cherubism. The inheritance pattern is autosomal dominant with variable expression. The penetrance is 100% in males and 50-70% in females. We found incomplete penetrance in males, which does not conform with all publications.

Vascular transformation in cherubism

Cherubism is a well-known disease entity that was first described by Jones in 1933. A case is presented in which the usual course of the lesion changed dramatically during treatment. The lesion demonstrated unilateral growth with a vascular proliferation after surgical recontouring. Vascular transformation and surgical activation of cherubism, as well as treatment considerations, are discussed.

Cherubism: diagnosis, treatment, and comparison with central giant cell granulomas and giant cell tumors

An extensive case of cherubism in a 17-year-old girl with no apparent familial history is presented. The rationale for treatment is presented and is compared with previous reports that have advocated nontreatment. The clinical and histologic similarities of cherubism to central giant cell granuloma and the giant cell tumor of bone are also discussed.

The Noonan syndrome/cherubism association

Noonan syndrome is characterized by short stature, unusual facies, congenital heart disease, chest deformity, mild mental retardation, and cryptorchidism in males. It may be sporadic or inherited as an autosomal dominant trait and occurs between 1 in 1000 and 1 in 2500 live births. Cherubism is a giant cell lesion of the jaws thought to be transmitted as an autosomal dominant trait. It is usually recognized by age 7 years, follows a variable course, and is not known to be related to other genetic disorders. We herein report on four patients with Noonan syndrome, all of whom had cherubism. Two other probable cases are cited in the literature for a total of six known cases.

Cherubism: report of a nonfamilial case

A case of nonfamilial cherubism and a review of literature have been reported. A diagnosis of cherubism was based on clinical and histopathologic examinations.

Diagnosis and treatment of jaw tumors in children

A retrospective review of experience with jaw tumors in 48 children over a ten-year period was made. These were predominantly benign, nonodontogenic, mesenchymal tumors. Clinical behavior was variable and often did not correspond to the histologic patterns. The clinically aggressive variants displayed rapid growth usually with associated pain. Resection rather than curettage is appropriate therapy when there has been earlier treatment failure by local tumor removal or rapid tumor expansion, or when tumor extensively invades the jaw. When resection is carried out, facial growth is not adversely affected if early reconstruction with autogenous bone is performed.

Cherubism

Cherubism is a benign, hereditary giant cell lesion of the jaws, that appears in children as a bilateral painless swelling, between the ages of 2 and 5 years and progresses until puberty, when it spontaneously regresses. It normally requires no treatment. We had the chance to operate on a 5-year-old boy with cherubism 8 years ago, and used homogenous bone grafts to replace the diseased tissue to avoid pathological fracture of the mandible. Since then we have been following the patient, witnessing the gradual involvement of other sites in the jaws and the displacement of teeth and tooth germs.

Cherubism: a report on three cases

Three cases of cherubism not previously recorded in the literature are described. They are three members of a Greek Cypriot family; the mother aged 49 years had residual mandibular deformity; the first daughter aged 17 years had facial swelling and anterior rib lesions; the second daughter aged 14 years presented with a unilateral giant-cell granuloma in the mandible.