Monitoring of immunologic status of patients receiving BCG therapy for malignant disease

Immunologic parameters as significant prognostic factors in lung cancer

Immunologic prognostic factors in lung cancer have not been fully clarified. We report the results of a prospective study undertaken to clarify the correlation between various cellular immunologic parameters and the survival of lung cancer patients. A total of 287 lung cancer patients were enrolled in this study. Representative in vitro cellular immune activities including lymphoblastogenesis and natural killer cell activities, in addition to the percentage of main lymphocyte subsets (CD3, CD4, CD8, HLA-DR, and Fc gamma R III on T cells) in the peripheral blood were evaluated before the initiation of therapy. The immune factors that influence the prognosis were analyzed by the log rank test and a multivariate analysis using the Cox proportional hazards model. Univariate analysis of the survival curves revealed a significant difference with regard to disease stage (P<0.0001), age (P=0.007), gender (P=0.0037), and HLA-DR (%) (P=0.048), when all the non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients (n=257) were analyzed together. This analysis, based on the histologic type, revealed that HLA-DR (%) was a significant predictor of survival in squamous cell carcinoma (P=0.0013) and small cell carcinoma (P=0.0025). A decreased CD4/CD8 ratio in small cell carcinoma (P=0.0062) and male gender in adenocarcinoma (P=0.0086) were factors associated with a worse prognosis. Multivariate analysis identified a significant correlation between survival and disease stage (P<0.0001) and gender (P=0.0243) in adenocarcinoma, disease stage (P<0.0001), age (P=0.0436) and HLA-DR (%) (P=0.0142) in squamous cell carcinoma, and HLA-DR (%) (P=0.0212) and CD4/CD8 (P=0.0112) in small cell carcinoma, suggesting independent prognostic significance. A variety of immunologic indices have prognostic significance for the different types of lung cancer. Among these, the HLA-DR (%) in the peripheral blood is the most reliable factor for squamous cell carcinoma and small cell carcinoma.

An analysis of skin tests and their relationship to recurrence and survival in stage III and stage IV melanoma patients

One-hundred-two patients with Stage III and IV malignant melanoma were analyzed to determine whether immunologic status in terms of skin testing along with sex and age played a role in recurrence and survival. Before treatment, patients had skin tests with five recall antigens (monilia, mumps, PPD, SK-SD, trichophyton) along with phytohemagglutinin (PHA). Univariate statistical analysis revealed sex as the major significant variable with respect to survival for Stage IVB patients, with female patients surviving longer than males. Patients with resected disease and greater SK-SD skin test reactivity tended to survive longer than those with impaired reactivity. Similarly, reactivity to trichophyton was associated with improved survival among patients with metastases. A multivariate analysis of the patients shows improved remission duration with mumps positivity in Stage III and Stage IVA patients. It appears that certain skin tets analyzed in this fashion have prognostic importance in these patients and should be analyzed with other variables of disease status.

Effects of diphenylhydantoin on killer cell activity and other immunological functions. A sequential study including the interaction of Corynebacterium parvum in melanoma patients

The effects of a single Phenytoin dose, given to patients with malignant melanoma, upon peripheral blood counts, serum immunoglobulins, lymphocyte subpopulations and lymphocytotoxicity (using Chang target cells) were recorded. Sequential blood samples were taken before and 10, 14, 34, 38 and 58 h after the Phenytoin. Early reductions (P less than 0.05) in lymphocyte count, NK, K and PHA induced cytotoxicity, when compared with initial, pre-Phenytoin values were noted. Immunisation with i.v. C. parvum prevented the reductions occurring after a second dose of Phenytoin. Indeed, significant increases above the values of samples taken immediately before the second dose, were observed in T cells, PHA blastogenesis, NK and K cell Cytotoxicity. The second dose did however cause some immunosuppression; the increase in T cells, NK and PHA induced cytotoxicity above initial values expected from previous investigations were not observed. The immunosuppression, particularly of killer cell function, occurring after phenytoin could have implications for the pathogenesis of malignancy and transplacental carcinogenesis, reported as following Phenytoin exposure.

Surgery, BCG immunotherapy, and multichemotherapy in T3 stage-3 bronchogenic carcinoma

Thirteen consecutive unselected patients suffering from stage-3 bronchogenic carcinomas (12 with T3 tumors and one T2 primary bilateral simultaneous carcinoma) underwent surgical resection followed by intrapleural, deep upper bilateral intercostal injections and oral immunostimulation with living fresh Pasteur strains of bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG). Since the 30th postoperative day, patients were started on intermittent multichemotherapy with suboptimal doses of methotrexate, 5-fluorouracil, and cyclophosphamide associated with oral therapy with BCG. The length of survival in the "study group" was compared to the results observed in nine unselected, consecutive, and concomitant semirandomized patients with T3 stage-3 carcinomas treated with cobalt therapy plus identical immunochemotherapy (control group A). Comparison of results was also made with 69 out of 100 consecutive patients with T3 stage-3 unresectable carcinomas who survived longer than two months after exploratory thoracotomies (control group B), representing the natural course of unresectable cases. Twelve (92 percent) of the 13 patients in the study group survived longer than six months, ten (77 percent) survived more than 12 months, six (46 percent) lived 18 months or more, and five (37 percent) have surpassed the 24th month of survival to date. Differences in survival at 6, 12, 18, and 24 months and the average length of survival in the study group to date (19.1 months) are statistically significant when compared to control groups A and B. The quality of postoperative life measured by the performance status according to Karnofsky's scale demonstrates an average of 79.3 percent for the entire study group.

Immunological status may predict clinical outcome in BCG treated melanoma

Twenty-seven patients with surgically resected stage II or III malignant melanoma were treated with bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) and followed prospectively to determine whether relapse could be predicted. Peripheral blood mononuclear (lymphocyte plus monocyte) counts (PBM), T and B cell counts, phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) cytotoxicity, PHA transformation, antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) and serum immunoglobulin concentrations were studied before and during therapy. Patients ultimately classified as having a poor clinical outcome (inoperable recurrence) were compared with those with a more favourable outcome. Prior to therapy, poor outcome patients had lower PBM and T cell counts but there was some overlap. After three months, these differences were more pronounced. Low PHA cytotoxicity was also associated with poor outcome; again the differences were more apparent at 3 months than prior to therapy. These results suggest that PBM, T cell counts and PHA cytotoxicity may predict poor outcome some months before inoperable recurrence in apparent clinically.

Prolonged BCG treatment of melanoma: does it suppress the immune capacity?

The immunological status of seven patients with disseminated melanoma during BCG scarification was followed. As parameters, the total peripheral blood leukocyte and lymphocyte counts, serum immunoglobulin levels, natural ABO blood group antibodies, lymphocyte responses in vitro to PHA and PPD, and skin reactivity against PPD and candidin were followed during a period of 2--36 months. The EAC-rosette-forming cells increased and the E-rosette-forming cells decreased during prolonged BCG therapy. The skin reactions and lymphocyte responses showed in most patients conversion from negative to positive or augmentation at the start of the therapy. Later on, however, the values in most patients dropped before disseminated disease became clinically apparent. In the only surviving patient the values first increased, remained high, and after 100 weeks treatment decreased. After 140 weeks' treatment immunological parameters are similar to pre-treatment levels. The possibility that prolonged intensive BCG treatment might eventually suppress the immune system, and thus result in an enhanced risk of dissemination of the disease, is discussed.

Cell-mediated immunity in operable bronchial carcinoma: the effect of injecting irradiated autologous tumour cells and BCG

In 52 patients undergoing tests of cell-mediated immunity before surgical resection of bronchial carcinoma a positive tuberculin test result was found in 71% compared with 68% of age- and sex-matched controls. Sensitisation to DNCB occurred in 52% of 37 patients but in 78% of controls. There was depression of lymphocyte transformation by PPD in 19 patients compared with controls (P=0.001), but there was no difference in lymphocyte transformation by PHA or pokeweed mitogen between 34 patients and controls. In a pilot study patients were randomly allocated to autograft (eight) or non-autograft (seven) groups. The autograft group were given an intradermal injection of a suspension of irradiated autologous tumour-cells mixed with intradermal BCG on the day of operation. Tests of cell-mediated immunity were repeated two weeks after operation. Five patients in each group received a course of radiotherapy to the mediastinum three weeks after operation. There was a rise in cutaneous tuberculin reactivity (P=0.08) and total leucocyte count (P=0.09) in the autograft group postoperatively with a fall in total lymphocyte and T lymphocyte counts in the non-autograft group (P less 0.05). These differences, however, were not followed by any difference in the frequency of tumour recurrence or the survival rate two years after operation. The results show that the immunological surveillance mechanism is impaired even in patients with early bronchial carcinoma and that it is possible to overcome postoperative immunological depression with specific immunotherapy combined with BCG. This treatment did not produce any clinical advantage in this small number of patients and the skin lesions caused the patients considerable discomfort.

Immunological responsiveness and adjunct immunotherapy in lung cancer

Immunocompetency was assessed before and after the operation in 40 patients with lung cancer by skin reaction against tuberculin (PPD) and dinitrochlorobenzene (DNCB), lymphocyte response to PHA, proportion of T-cells, macrophage migration inhibition test (MIT) and the presence of blocking factor. MIT was positive in 27 per cent and blocking factor was positive in 42 per cent. Immune response paralleled the clinical stage of the lesion. In curative resection cases, the immune response rose postoperatively, but declined in non-resectable or recurrent cases. The influence of postoperative radiation therapy, cancer chemotherapy and host mediated agents on the patients was observed. The feasibility of adjuvant specific immunotherapy is discussed.

Current concepts of tumor immunology. II. Tumor immunodetection

A great deal of investigation is presently underway to develop methods of effectively assessing the status of an individual patient's immune system. Such methods might provide a means of early detection of tumor or of indicating prognosis so that treatment modalities may be tailored to individual patient needs. The cell-mediated response may be monitored using intradermal skin tests and in vitro lymphocyte stimulation and cytotoxicity tests. Humoral responses have been monitored using assays for antibodies against tumor specific as well as tumor associated antigens. Assays have been developed which are capable of detecting circulating fetal antigens in very small concentrations. Thus far no one assay technique has proven to be sufficiently sensitive nor specific to be clinically useful. However, by utilizing a battery of tests before, during and after treatment, it is possible to determine a great deal about individual patient response to treatment and prognosis. With so many investigators focusing upon this problem, it seems likely that more effective methods of immunodetection will soon be developed.