Muscle vibration and prefrontal repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation

Acute and chronic neuromuscular adaptations to local vibration training

Vibratory stimuli are thought to have the potential to promote neural and/or muscular (re)conditioning. This has been well described for whole-body vibration (WBV), which is commonly used as a training method to improve strength and/or functional abilities. Yet, this technique may present some limitations, especially in clinical settings where patients are unable to maintain an active position during the vibration exposure. Thus, a local vibration (LV) technique, which consists of applying portable vibrators directly over the tendon or muscle belly without active contribution from the participant, may present an alternative to WBV. The purpose of this narrative review is (1) to provide a comprehensive overview of the literature related to the acute and chronic neuromuscular changes associated with LV, and (2) to show that LV training may be an innovative and efficient alternative method to the 'classic' training programs, including in the context of muscle deconditioning prevention or rehabilitation. An acute LV application (one bout of 20-60 min) may be considered as a significant neuromuscular workload, as demonstrated by an impairment of force generating capacity and LV-induced neural changes. Accordingly, it has been reported that a training period of LV is efficient in improving muscular performance over a wide range of training (duration, number of session) and vibration (frequency, amplitude, site of application) parameters. The functional improvements are principally triggered by adaptations within the central nervous system. A model illustrating the current research on LV-induced adaptations is provided.

Lower Arm Muscle Activation during Indirect-Localized Vibration: The Influence of Skill Levels When Applying Different Acceleration Loads

We investigated the electromyographic response to synchronous indirect-localized vibration interventions in international and national table tennis players. Twenty-six male table tennis players, in a standing position, underwent firstly an upper arms maximal voluntary contraction and thereafter two different 30-s vibration interventions in random order: high acceleration load (peak acceleration = 12.8 g, frequency = 40 Hz; peak-to-peak displacement = 4.0 mm), and low acceleration load (peak acceleration = 7.2 g, frequency = 30 Hz, peak-to-peak displacement = 4.0 mm). Surface electromyography root mean square from brachioradialis, extensor digitorum, flexor carpi radialis, and flexor digitorum superficialis recorded during the two vibration interventions was normalized to the maximal voluntary contraction recording. Normalized surface electromyography root mean square was higher in international table tennis players with respect to national ones in all the interactions between muscles and vibration conditions (P < 0.05), with the exception of flexor carpi radialis (at low acceleration load, P > 0.05). The difference in normalized surface electromyography root mean square between international table tennis players and national ones increased in all the muscles with high acceleration load (P < 0.05), with the exception of flexor digitorum superficialis (P > 0.05). The muscle activation during indirect-localized vibration seems to be both skill level and muscle dependent. These results can optimize the training intervention in table tennis players when applying indirect-localized vibration to lower arm muscles. Future investigations should discriminate between middle- and long-term adaptations in response to specific vibration loads.

Modulation of soleus corticospinal excitability during Achilles tendon vibration

Soleus (SOL) corticospinal excitability has been reported to increase during Achilles tendon vibration. The aim of the present study was to further investigate SOL corticospinal excitability and elucidate the changes to intracortical mechanisms during Achilles tendon vibration. Motor-evoked potentials (MEPs) were elicited in the SOL by transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) of the corresponding motor cortical area of the leg with and without 50-Hz Achilles tendon vibration. SOL input-output curves were determined. Paired-pulse protocols were also performed to investigate short-interval intracortical inhibition (SICI) and intracortical facilitation (ICF) by conditioning test TMS pulses with sub-threshold TMS pulses at inter-stimulus intervals of 3 and 13 ms, respectively. During Achilles tendon vibration, motor threshold was lower than in the control condition (43 ± 13 vs. 49 ± 11 % of maximal stimulator output; p = 0.008). Input-output curves were also influenced by vibration, i.e. there was increased maximal MEP amplitude (0.694 ± 0.347 vs. 0.268 ± 0.167 mV; p < 0.001), decreased TMS intensity to elicit a MEP of half the maximal MEP amplitude (100 ± 13 vs. 109 ± 9 % motor threshold; p = 0.009) and a strong tendency for decreased slope constant (0.076 ± 0.04 vs. 0.117 ± 0.04; p = 0.068). Vibration reduced ICF (98 ± 61 vs. 170 ± 105 % of test MEP amplitude; p = 0.05), but had no effect on SICI (53 ± 26 vs. 48 ± 22 % of test MEP amplitude; p = 0.68). The present results further document the increased vibration-induced corticospinal excitability in the soleus muscle and suggest that this increase is not mediated by changes in SICI or ICF.

Achilles tendon vibration-induced changes in plantar flexor corticospinal excitability

Daily Achilles tendon vibration has been shown to increase muscle force, likely via corticospinal neural adaptations. The aim of the present study was to determine the extent by which corticospinal excitability is influenced during direct Achilles tendon vibration. Motor-evoked potentials (MEPs) were elicited in the soleus (SOL), gastrocnemius medialis (GM) and tibialis anterior (TA) by transcranial magnetic stimulation of the motor cortical area of the leg with and without Achilles tendon vibration at various frequencies (50, 80 and 110 Hz). Contralateral homologues were also investigated. SOL and GM MEP amplitude significantly increased by 226 ± 188 and 66 ± 39%, respectively, during Achilles tendon vibration, without any difference between the tested frequencies. No MEP changes were reported for TA or contralateral homologues. Increased SOL and GM MEP amplitude suggests increased vibration-induced corticospinal excitability independent of vibration frequency.

Segmental Muscle Vibration Improves Walking in Chronic Stroke Patients With Foot Drop: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Background. Studies have described the effects of segmental muscle vibration (SMV) on brain plasticity and corticomotor excitability. Information on the treatment-induced effects of SMV in stroke patients is, however, still limited. Objectives. To assess whether the application of SMV to ankle dorsiflexor muscles of chronic stroke patients can improve walking. Methods. Forty-four patients were randomly assigned to either an experimental group (EG) or a control group (CG) and underwent 12 sessions over 4 weeks of general physical therapy. Patients in the EG also received SMV at 120 Hz over the peroneus longus and tibialis anterior for 30 minutes at the end of each session. All the participants underwent pretreatment and posttreatment gait analysis assessments. Time—distance, kinematic, and surface electromyography (EMG) data were used as outcome measures. Results. A moderate improvement in mean gait speed, normal-side swing velocity, bilateral stride length, and normal-side toe-off percentage was observed only in the EG. A significant increase in bilateral ankle dorsiflexion angle at heel contact was associated with increased maximum ankle dorsiflexion and plantarflexion degrees during the swing phase on the paretic side after treatment in EG. Surface EMG during the swing phase revealed a significant increase in the activation of the tibialis anterior muscle on the paretic side in the posttreatment assessment in the EG. Conclusions. SMV added to general physical therapy may improve gait performance in patients with foot drop secondary to chronic stroke. The authors hypothesize that this may be due to the mechanical vibration stimulation, probably as a consequence of effective brain reorganization.

Functional lesions and human action monitoring: combining repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation and event-related brain potentials

OBJECTIVE

Electrophysiological recordings of the error-related negativity (ERN) and functional imaging data point to an involvement of medial frontal cortex (including the anterior cingulate cortex, ACC) and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) in the detection and correction of performance errors. Here, we studied this network by applying trains of rapid transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) prior to the recording of the ERN.

METHODS

Low-frequency (0.9 Hz) rTMS was applied to medial frontal or lateral frontal regions (different sessions) for 60 s immediately before each 3 min ERN recording in 11 healthy young subjects. The ERN was obtained by multichannel recordings in a typical Eriksen flanker task with instructions calling for immediate error correction in case a performance error was detected by the subject. Event-related potentials were quantified and statistically evaluated using standard methodology.

RESULTS

Compared to a no-stimulation control condition, medial frontal stimulation led to a small but reliable decrease in the number of corrected errors as well as to an attenuation of the ERN and an increase of the subsequent error-positivity (Pe). No effect on these components was seen after lateral frontal stimulation. No reliable effects on the lateralized readiness potential were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Functional lesions by rTMS appear to interfere with the functions of the medial frontal cortex in error detection and correction.

Impaired sensorimotor integration in cervical dystonia: a study using transcranial magnetic stimulation and muscle vibration

The authors studied the effects of sensorimotor integration (corticocortical inhibition and facilitation during muscle vibration [MV]) in dystonic patients. Eleven patients with cervical dystonia and 11 age-matched healthy control subjects were enrolled in the study. They were examined using transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) and tonic proprioceptive input (MV). Paired-pulse transcranial magnetic stimulation was done at interstimulus intervals of 3 msec (intracortical inhibition) and 13 msec, the intensity of the conditioning stimulus was 70% of the motor threshold, and the test stimulus was 120%. Motor evoked potentials were recorded from the vibrated extensor carpi radialis muscle and its antagonist, the flexor carpi radialis. Duration of MV trains (80 Hz; amplitude, 0.5 mm) was 4 seconds. The authors found differences between patients and healthy control subjects during MV only. Intracortical inhibition was pronounced significantly only in control subjects, whereas intracortical facilitation was significant in patients only (P < 0.05). Furthermore, the significant reduction of motor evoked potentials at 13-msec interstimulus intervals, which can be found in healthy subjects frequently, was observed in one dystonia patient only. The results of the current study suggest that sensorimotor integration is impaired in cervical dystonia, probably by an altered control of proprioceptive (vibratory) input.

Decrease of middle cerebral artery blood flow velocity after low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex

OBJECTIVES

Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) has been tried therapeutically in a variety of neuropsychiatric disorders. Both, inhibition and activation of cortical areas may be achieved using different stimulation parameters. Using low-frequency rTMS (0.9 Hz), inhibition of cortical areas can be observed.

METHODS

In the present study, 38 right-handed, healthy, normotensive subjects (aged 21-50 years, mean 30.2 years, SD=4.9; 17 women) were enrolled. Twenty-five participants received active rTMS (5 min of 0.9 Hz rTMS, stimulus intensity 90% of motor threshold) of the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Sham stimulation (n=13 subjects) occurred in the same manner as active rTMS, except that the angle of the coil was at 45 degrees off the skull. Simultaneously, ipsilateral and contralateral maximal middle cerebral artery (MCA) flow velocity (and pulsatility index, PI) was monitored using transcranial Doppler sonography.

RESULTS

In the group with active rTMS, maximal MCA flow velocity decreased from a baseline (before rTMS) of 101.6 cm/s (SD=26.0) to a mean of 92.6 cm/s (SD=23.7) immediately after rTMS, T=5.06, P<0.001. This equals a mean decrease of 9.0 cm/s (SD=8.3) or approximately 8.9% of baseline flow. Five and 10 min after rTMS, there was a return to baseline. PI significantly decreased 10 min after rTMS (mean difference -0.05, SD=0.05, T=2.29, P<0.05). In the contralateral MCA, maximal flow velocity tended to increase 10 min after rTMS (mean difference +7.4 cm/s, SD=17.5; T=-2.03, P=0.054). With sham rTMS, no significant changes occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

The results from our study support the hypothesis that low-frequency rTMS may influence cerebral blood flow (CBF) over short periods of time, inducing a temporary decrease of maximal CBF in the ipsilateral MCA followed by an increase in the contralateral MCA.

Crossed effects of muscle vibration on motor-evoked potentials

OBJECTIVES

Muscle vibration (MV) to a forearm muscle augments motor-evoked potentials (MEPs) following transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) and the underlying mechanism involves cortical structures. Although MV-induced cortical activation is bilateral, the effects of MV on MEPs in contralateral muscles have not been investigated.

METHODS

Low-amplitude MV (80 Hz, amplitude 0.5 mm, duration 4 s), subthreshold for the tonic vibration reflex, was applied to the right extensor carpi radialis muscle (ECR). MEPs were elicited (0.5, 3 and 5 s after MV onset) in the left and right ECR and flexor carpi radialis muscle (FCR) by TMS (120% of threshold at rest) to the left and right hemisphere, respectively.

RESULTS

During MV of right ECR the left ECR revealed a slight non-significant augmentation of MEPs. In contrast, the left FCR showed a gradual depression of MEPs with ongoing MV and at 3 s the reduction of MEPs was significant. The time course of MEP changes in left FCR correlated with the facilitation of the vibrated right ECR. Post-vibration MEPs at 1 s after the offset of MV were still significantly decreased.

CONCLUSIONS

The study demonstrates crossed effects of MV on motor cortex excitability, suggesting transcallosal MEP modulation.