Differential influence of the E4 adenoviral genes on viral and cellular promoters

Inhibition of hepatitis C virus gene expression by adenoviral vectors encoding antisense RNA in vitro and in vivo

BACKGROUND & AIMS

In this study, adenoviral vectors encoding an antisense RNA complementary to the 5' non-coding region (5'NCR) of the HCV-genome were generated to inhibit HCV-RNA gene expression in cell culture and in vivo.

METHODS

First and second-generation (with E4-deletion) adenoviruses encoding the HCV5'NCR in antisense direction (Ad-NCRas and Ad-E4del-NCRas) were generated. Inhibition of HCV gene expression was analyzed in hepatoma cells stably transfected with the HCV5'NCR cDNA fused to the firefly luciferase gene (NCRluc), as well as in the HCV subgenomic replicon (genotypes 1b and 2a) and the fully infectious HCV JFH-1 cell culture systems. For in vivo experiments, an adenovirus encoding the NCRluc-gene was injected intravenously to achieve a NCR-dependent luciferase-expression in the liver of C3H/HeNcrl-mice.

RESULTS

Forty eight hours after transduction with GFP-encoding adenoviruses, >85% of HepG2-, CCL13-and Huh7-cells expressed GFP. Surprisingly, GFP-expression of E4-deleted adenoviruses was considerably reduced at the same MOI. Using antisense first-generation adenoviruses (Ad-NCRas), a significant inhibition of the 5'NCR-dependent HCV-gene expression (54±19% in HepG2-cells and 66.2±15% in Huh7-cells) was achieved 48h after transduction. In Huh7-cells containing the HCV subgenomic replicons and in infectious HCV JFH-1 cell cultures, adenovirus-mediated transcription of antisense 5'NCR significantly blocked HCV-replication (40% and 76%, respectively). Corresponding to low transgene expression, the maximal inhibition reached with Ad-delE4-NCRas was 30%. In vivo, antisense adenoviral vectors also showed a significant inhibition (40%) of NCR-dependent luciferase expression compared to control adenoviruses (p<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The data indicate that HCV gene expression can be inhibited by antisense RNA encoding adenoviruses in the tested settings.

Regulatable gene expression systems for gene therapy

It is feasible to restrict transgene expression to a tissue or region in need of therapy by using promoters that respond to focusable physical stimuli. The most extensively investigated promoters of this type are radiation-inducible promoters and heat shock protein gene promoters that can be activated by directed, transient heat. Temporal regulation of transgenes can be achieved by various two- or three-component gene switches that are triggered by an appropriate small molecule inducer. The most commonly considered gene switches that are reviewed herein are based on small molecule-responsive transactivators derived from bacterial tetracycline repressor, insect or mammalian steroid receptors, or mammalian FKBP12/FRAP. A new generation of gene switches combines a heat shock protein gene promoter and a small molecule-responsive gene switch and can provide for both spatial and temporal regulation of transgene activity.

Adenovirus: from foe to friend

Human adenoviruses (HAdVs) can cause mild respiratory, gastrointestinal, urogenital and ocular disease. Knowledge about HAdVs has been expanding for more than five decades putting them amongst the most-studied viruses. This continued interest stems, to a great extent, from the fact that these double-stranded DNA viruses have proven to be a versatile tool to probe the basic phenomena of eukaryotic cells. HAdV research has led to the discovery of, for instance, RNA splicing and greatly contributed to our knowledge of processes as fundamental as replication, transcription and translation. Moreover, the transformation of rodent cells by HAdVs has provided a system to unravel the molecular pathways that control cell proliferation. As a result, the genetic organisation of these agents is known in great detail allowing the straightforward manipulation of their genomes. In addition, the virus itself became renowned for its ability to produce large amounts of progeny and to efficiently infect mammalian cells regardless of their cell cycle status. These features contributed to the broad use of recombinant HAdVs as gene carriers particularly in in vivo settings where the vast majority of target cells are post-mitotic. The most advanced type of HAdV vectors can accommodate up to 37 kb of foreign DNA and are devoid of viral genes. With the aid of these high-capacity HAdV vectors large physiologically responsive transcriptional elements and/or genes can be efficiently introduced into target cells while minimising adaptive immune responses against the transduced cells. This article provides information on HAdV especially on the aspects pertinent to the design, production and performance of its recombinant forms. The development and characteristics of the main HAdV-based vector types are also briefly reviewed.

Chimpanzee-origin adenovirus vectors as vaccine carriers

Vaccines based on replication-defective adenoviral vectors are being developed for infectious agents and tumor-associated antigens. Early work focused on vaccines derived from a common human serotype of adenovirus, that is, adenovirus of the serotype 5 (AdHu5). Neutralizing antibodies against AdHu5 virus, present in a large percentage of the human population, dampen the efficacy of vaccines based on this carrier. To circumvent this problem, we generated vectors derived from chimpanzee adenoviruses. Here we describe some basic parameters of vectors derived from chimpanzee adenoviruses C68 and C7, including growth characteristics, yields of infectious particles, effects of additional deletions in E3 and E4 and lengths of the inserted foreign sequence as they relate to the suitability for their eventual development as vaccine carriers for clinical use.

Regulatable gene expression systems for gene therapy applications: progress and future challenges

Gene therapy aims to revert diseased phenotypes by the use of both viral and nonviral gene delivery systems. Substantial progress has been made in making gene transfer vehicles more efficient, less toxic, and nonimmunogenic and in allowing long-term transgene expression. One of the key issues in successfully implementing gene therapies in the clinical setting is to be able to regulate gene expression very tightly and consistently as and when it is needed. The regulation ought to be achievable using a compound that should be nontoxic, be able to penetrate into the desired target tissue or organ, and have a half-life of a few hours (as opposed to minutes or days) so that when withdrawn or added (depending on the regulatable system used) gene expression can be turned "on" or "off" quickly and effectively. Also, the genetic switches employed should ideally be nonimmunogenic in the host. The ability to switch transgenes on and off would be of paramount importance not only when the therapy is no longer needed, but also in the case of the development of adverse side effects to the therapy. Many regulatable systems are currently under development and some, i.e., the tetracycline-dependent transcriptional switch, have been used successfully for in vivo preclinical applications. Despite this, there are no examples of switches that have been employed in a human clinical trial. In this review, we aim to highlight the main regulatable systems currently under development, the gene transfer systems employed for their expression, and also the preclinical models in which they have been used successfully. We also discuss the substantial challenges that still remain before these regulatable switches can be employed in the clinical setting.

Avian adenovirus vector CELO-TK displays anticancer activity in human cancer cells and suppresses established murine melanoma tumors

Avian adenovirus CELO is a novel adenovirus vector system with the advantages of efficient production, high virion stability, and the absence of crossreactivity with Ad5-neutralizing antibodies. In this study, we evaluated the anticancer efficacy of a CELO vector encoding the herpes simplex virus type 1 thymidine kinase, a prodrug-activating therapeutic gene. Vectors carrying the gene for HSV-tk or EGFP under the control of the HCMV promoter in place of the "nonessential" region of the CELO genome were constructed. Anticancer activity of the CELO-TK vector was studied in vitro, in human and murine tumor cells in cell culture, and in vivo, in established subcutaneous murine B16 melanoma tumors in C57BL/6 mice. The CELO-TK vector mediated delivery of functional HSV-tk to tumor cell lines in cell culture. Comparison of the CELO-TK vector to a first-generation human adenovirus type 5 vector Ad5-TK in cultured H1299 cells showed equal levels of functional activity at increasing multiplicities of infection with CELO-based vector. CELO vectors allowed for transduction and expression of EGFP and HSV-tk genes in subcutaneous melanoma tumors in C57BL/6 mice. Intratumoral injections of CELO-TK followed by ganciclovir administration resulted in suppression of tumor growth and significantly increased the median of survival. The results of the study demonstrated the efficacy of CELO vector as a vehicle for the delivery of prodrug-activating genes such as HSV-tk to tumor cells in vitro and in vivo.

Vaccination with helper-dependent adenovirus enhances the generation of transgene-specific CTL

Recombinant adenoviral vectors (AdV) have been used experimentally as vaccines to present antigenic transgenes in vivo. However, administration of first-generation vectors (FG-AdV) is often limited by their induction of antiviral immunity. To address this limitation, helper-dependent vectors (HD-AdV) were developed that lack viral coding regions. While the administration of HD-AdV results in long-term gene expression in vivo, their utility as immunogens has never been examined. Direct vaccination with 10(8) blue-forming units (BFU) of HD-AdV injected into C57BL/6 mice lead to superior transgene-specific CTL and antibody responses when compared to the same amount of a FG-AdV. The antibody responses to viral antigens were high in response to both the vectors. As a mechanism to reduce viral exposure, dendritic cells (DC) were transduced with HD-AdV in vitro and then used as a cell-based vaccine. DC transduced with HD-AdV expressed higher levels of transgene-specific mRNA and up to 1200-fold higher levels of transgene protein than did DC transduced with a FG-AdV. In addition, HD-AdV-transduced DC stimulated superior transgene-specific CTL responses when administered in vivo, an effect that was further enhanced by maturing the DC with LPS prior to administration. In contrast to direct immunization with HD-AdV, vaccination with HD-AdV-transduced DC was associated with limited antibody responses against the AdV. We conclude that HD-AdV stimulates superior transgene-specific immune responses when compared to a FG-AdV, and that immunization with a DC-based vaccine maintains this efficacy while limiting antiviral reactivity.

The CCT promoter directs high-level transgene expression in distal lung epithelial cell lines

Gene therapy requires the presence of a robust and yet small promoter to drive high-level expression of desired proteins. In comparative analysis, we investigated the promoter strength of the CTP:phosphocholine cytidylyltransferase promoter (CCT alpha) with other commonly used promoters, which were all cloned into a similar background vector (PGL3 basic). Transient promoter-reporter assays in murine lung epithelial (MLE-12) cells revealed that the core CCT alpha promoter (240 bp) was observed to exhibit a 40-fold, 8-fold, and 3-fold higher level of activity compared with the simian virus 40, human cytomegalovirus, and Rous sarcoma virus promoters, respectively. The CCT alpha promoter was significantly more active than the Clara cell 10, thymidine kinase, and phosphoglycerate kinase promoters. This pattern of high-level expression for CCT alpha was detected primarily in cell lines of distal lung epithelial origin (MLE-12, RLE, H441) and was reduced in other cell lines (A549, CHO, HepG 2). CCT alpha promoter-reporter activity, CCT alpha transcript levels, and immunoreactive protein levels increased significantly in the presence of all-trans retinoic acid. The CCT alpha promoter, in a retinoic acid-inducible manner, efficiently directed expression of murine erythropoietin in MLE-12 cells. Collectively, these observations suggest that the CCT alpha construct might be useful to drive high-level, regulatable expression of heterologous proteins in alveolar epithelia.

Comparative analysis of the effects of packaging signal, transgene orientation, promoters, polyadenylation signals, and E3 region on growth properties of first-generation adenoviruses

First-generation adenovectors have been developed for gene therapy and vaccine applications. The construction of these adenovectors has entailed the use of numerous types of expression cassettes. It has long been known that first-generation adenovectors can be rescued more easily and to higher titers with some transgenes than with others. This study has systematically shown that there can be marked differences in growth properties of recombinant adenovectors attributable to the use of promoters, the orientation of the transgene within the E1A/E1B-deleted region, and the inclusion of the E3 region. In addition, we had demonstrated the benefit of extending the packaging signal region to include elements V, VI, and VII. The effects of the complete packaging region were studied by plasmid competition studies between original and modified adenovectors. Similar competition studies between E3(+) and E3(-) adenovectors were performed and showed that the E3(+) vector had a growth advantage over its E3(-) counterpart. By making various changes, we have enhanced the growth capacity of our recombinant adenovector by more than 3-fold under serum-free and cell suspension growth conditions. Along with this enhanced growth, our adenovectors have maintained their genetic stability after 21 successive passages in cell culture. This increased robustness will be critical when adapting first-generation recombinant adenovectors to commercial production.

Episomal persistence of recombinant adenoviral vector genomes during the cell cycle in vivo

Previously we showed that recombinant adenoviral helper-dependent (HD) vectors result in long-term transgene expression levels in vivo which slowly declined by 95% over a period of 1 year. In this study, we further establish that this was not predominantly immune mediated. To determine if cell turnover was responsible for the loss of transgene expression, we induced rapid hepatocyte cell cycling in mouse liver, by performing a surgical two-thirds partial hepatectomy. We observed a 55 and 65% reduction in transgene expression levels and a 50 and 71% loss of vector genomes for the HD vector and the first-generation adenoviral vector. In sharp contrast, in nonviral, episomal plasmid DNA-injected mice, transgene expression levels and DNA copy numbers decreased by 95 and 99%, respectively. These findings suggest that cell division alone was not the primary reason for the slow decrease in transgene expression levels and that recombinant adenoviral vectors have a more robust mechanism for maintaining persistence during cell cycling. Several potential mechanisms are proposed.

Gene therapy for pituitary tumors: from preclinical models to clinical implementation

Gene therapy, which entails the use of nucleic acids as drugs, is a new approach to treat disease. Gene therapy has been successfully implemented in several preclinical animal models, including several paradigms of experimental pituitary tumors. In spite of these successes, several critical issues need to be addressed before gene therapy can become a clinical reality for the treatment of pituitary tumors. These include the development of safer and more effective gene delivery vectors, the uncovering of novel therapeutic targets, the development of molecular switches which will allow turning therapeutic transgene expression "on" and "off" as and when it is needed, and the ability to scale up the vector preparations devoid of any putative contaminants. There are still many basic science developments that must take place in order to allow this new therapeutic technology to make its way successfully into the clinical arena to treat pituitary disease. We envisage these developments taking place within the next five years, gene therapy for pituitary tumors will then form part of the armamentarium available to better treat and manage pituitary tumors.

Persistent hepatic expression of human apo A-I after transfer with a helper-virus independent adenoviral vector

Gene transfer with 'gutted' vectors is associated with persistent transgene expression and absence of hepatotoxicity, but the requirement of helper viruses hampers efficient production and leads to contamination of viral batches with these helper-viruses. In the present study, gene transfer with a helper-virus independent E(1)/E(3)/E(4)-deleted adenoviral vector induced persistent expression of human apo A-I (200 +/- 16 mg/dl at day 35, 190 +/- 15 mg/dl at 4 months, 170 +/- 16 mg/dl at 6 months) and stable transgene DNA levels (3.5 +/- 0.60 at day 35, 3.3 +/- 0.39 at 4 months, 3.1 +/- 0.47 mg/dl at 6 months) in C57BL/6 mice in the absence of significant toxicity. The vector contained the 1.5 kb human alpha(1)-antitrypsin promoter in front of the genomic human apo A-I sequence and four copies of the human apo E enhancer (hAAT.gA-I.4xapoE) and was deleted in E(1), E(3) and E(4). Reintroduction of E(4) ORF 3 and E(4) ORF 4 in the viral backbone caused a more than four-fold decline of transgene DNA between day 35 and 4 months after transfer both in wild-type and in C57BL/6 SCID and C57BL/6 Rag-1(-/-) mice, indicating that the effect of E(4) ORF 3 and E(4) ORF 4 is independent of a cellular immune response against viral epitopes. Co-injection of an E(1)-deleted vector containing no expression cassette and the E(1)/E(3)/E(4)-deleted vector containing the hAAT.gA-I.4xapoE expression cassette indicated that E(4) gene products destabilize transgene DNA in trans. Gene transfer with an E(1)/E(3)/E(4)-deleted vector containing only E(4) ORF 3 and the hAAT.gA-I.4xapoE expression cassette was associated with transgene DNA decline, but not with hepatotoxicity, indicating that transgene DNA persistence and hepatotoxicity are dissociated processes. After transfer with E(1)/E(3)/E(4)-deleted vectors containing expression cassettes with a different promoter or a different position of the apo E enhancers, transgene DNA levels were less stable than after transfer with the vector containing hAAT.gA-I.4xapoE, indicating that the expression cassette is an important determinant of episomal stability. In conclusion, gene transfer with an E(1)/E(3)/E(4)-deleted vector containing the hAAT.gA-I.4xapoE expression cassette induces persistent expression of human apo A-I in the absence of hepatotoxicity. Transgene DNA turnover is independent of an adaptive cellular immune response against viral epitopes and of hepatotoxicity. E(1)/E(3)/E(4)-deleted vectors containing transgenes under control of the hAAT promoter in combination with four copies of the human apo E enhancer may be suitable for hepatocyte-specific overexpression of transgenes after gene transfer. doi:10.1038/sj.gt.3301824

Variables affecting in vivo performance of high-capacity adenovirus vectors

In high-capacity adenovirus (HC-Ad) vectors the size and/or composition of the vector genome influences vector stability during production and the expression profile following gene transfer. Typically, an HC-Ad vector will contain both a gene or an expression cassette and stuffer DNA that is required to balance the final vector genome to a size of between 27 and 36 kb. To gain an improved understanding of factors that may influence gene expression from HC-Ad vectors, we have generated a series of vectors that carry different combinations of human alpha-1 antitrypsin (hAAT) expression constructs and stuffer DNAs. Expression in vitro did not predict in vivo performance: all vectors expressed hAAT at similar levels when tested in cell culture. Hepatic expression was evaluated following in vivo gene transfer in C57BL/6J mice. hAAT levels obtained from genomic DNA were significantly higher than levels achieved with small cDNA expression cassettes. Expression was independent of the orientation and only marginally influenced by the location of the expression cassette within the vector genome. The use of lambda stuffer DNA resulted in low-level but stable expression for at least 3 months when higher doses were applied. A potential matrix attachment region element was identified within the hAAT gene and caused a 10-fold increase in expression when introduced in an HC-Ad vector genome carrying a phosphoglycerate kinase (pgk) hAAT cDNA construct. We also illustrate the influence of the promoter on anti-hAAT antibody formation in C57BL/6J mice: a human cytomegalovirus but not a pgk promoter resulted in an anti-hAAT antibody response. Thus, the overall design of HC-Ad vectors may significantly influence amounts and duration of gene expression at different levels.

Molecular regulation and biological function of adenovirus early genes: the E4 ORFs

Over the past few years there have been a number of interesting advances in our understanding of the functions encoded by the adenovirus early transcription unit 4 (Ad E4). A large body of recent data demonstrates that E4 proteins encompass an unexpectedly diverse collection of functions required for efficient viral replication. E4 gene products operate through a complex network of protein interactions with key viral and cellular regulatory components involved in transcription, apoptosis, cell cycle control and DNA repair, as well as host cell factors that regulate cell signaling, posttranslational modifications and the integrity of nuclear multiprotein complexes known as nuclear bodies (NBs) or PML oncogenic domains (PODs). As understood at present, some of the lytic functions overlap with roles in oncogenic transformation of primary mammalian cells. These observations, together with findings that E4 proteins substantially affect cell toxicity and the immune response of the host have profound implications for the development of Ad vectors for gene therapy. In this article we will summarize recent findings regarding the diverse functions of E4 gene products in the context of earlier work. We will emphasize the interaction of E4 proteins with cellular and viral interaction partners, the role of these interactions for lytic virus growth and how these interactions may contribute to viral oncogenesis. Finally, we will discuss their role in Ad vector and adeno-associated virus infections.

Dystrophin expression in muscle following gene transfer with a fully deleted ("gutted") adenovirus is markedly improved by trans-acting adenoviral gene products

Helper-dependent adenoviruses (HDAd) are Ad vectors lacking all or most viral genes. They hold great promise for gene therapy of diseases such as Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), because they are less immunogenic than E1/E3-deleted Ad (first-generation Ad or FGAd) and can carry the full-length (Fl) dystrophin (dys) cDNA (12 kb). We have compared the transgene expression of a HDAd (HDAdCMVDysFl) and a FGAd (FGAdCMV-dys) in cell culture (HeLa, C2C12 myotubes) and in the muscle of mdx mice (the mouse model for DMD). Both vectors encoded dystrophin regulated by the same cytomegalovirus (CMV) promoter. We demonstrate that the amount of dystrophin expressed was significantly higher after gene transfer with FGAdCMV-dys compared to HDAdCMVDysFl both in vitro and in vivo. However, gene transfer with HDAdCMVDysFl in the presence of a FGAd resulted in a significant increase of dystrophin expression indicating that gene products synthesized by the FGAd increase, in trans, the amount of dystrophin produced. This enhancement occurred in cell culture and after gene transfer in the muscle of mdx mice and dystrophic golden retriever (GRMD) dogs, another animal model for DMD. The E4 region of Ad is required for the enhancement, because no increase of dystrophin expression from HDAdCMVDysFl was observed in the presence of an E1/E4-deleted Ad in vitro and in vivo. The characterization of these enhancing gene products followed by their inclusion into an HDAd may be required to produce sufficient dystrophin to mitigate the pathology of DMD by HDAd-mediated gene transfer.