Long-term follow-up after single toxic exposure to trichloroethylene

Occupational exposures and parkinsonism

In recent years, the contribution of exposure to environmental toxicants has been recognized as a significant contributor to the etiopathogenesis of parkinsonism. Of these toxicants, exposure to pesticides, metals, solvents used in manufacturing processes, as well as flame-retardant chemicals used in consumer and commercial products, has received the greatest attention as possible risk factors. Related to this, individuals who are exposed to these compounds at high concentrations or for prolonged periods of time in an occupational setting appear to be one of the more vulnerable populations to these effects. Our understanding of which compounds are involved and the potential molecular pathways that are susceptible to these chemicals and may underlie the pathogenesis has greatly improved. However, there are still hundreds of chemicals that we are exposed to in the environment for which we do not have any information on their potential neurotoxicity on the nigrostriatal dopamine system. Thus, using our past accomplishments as a blueprint, future endeavors should focus on elaborating upon these initial findings in order to identify specific and relevant chemical toxicants in our environment that can impact the risk of parkinsonism and work towards a means to attenuate or abolish their effects on the human population.

Industrial toxicants and Parkinson's disease

The exposure of the human population to environmental contaminants is recognized as a significant contributing factor for the development of Parkinson's disease (PD) and other forms of parkinsonism. While pesticides have repeatedly been identified as risk factors for PD, these compounds represent only a subset of environmental toxicants that we are exposed to on a regular basis. Thus, non-pesticide contaminants, such as metals, solvents, and other organohalogen compounds have also been implicated in the clinical and pathological manifestations of these movement disorders and it is these non-pesticide compounds that are the subject of this review. As toxic exposures to these classes of compounds can result in a spectrum of PD or PD-related disorders, it is imperative to appreciate shared clinico-pathological characteristics or mechanisms of action of these compounds in order to further delineate the resultant disorders as well as identify improved preventive strategies or therapeutic interventions.

Myoclonic encephalopathy after exposure to trichloroethylene

Trichloroethylene is a widely-used industrial solvent that is absorbed through the digestive or respiratory tracts or cutaneously. It has a selective tropism for the cardiovascular and central nervous systems and may cause death due to cardiac arrest or neurological sequelae. We present the case of a 25-yr-old women who was exposed to trichloroethylene in the workplace for 18 months and who developed a disabling myoclonic encephalopathy. Non-toxicological causes were excluded. Although the exposure ceased, the disease progressed with thalamic and cerebellar involvement. The patient, who had only a partial response to symptomatic treatment, suffered severe limitations in the activities of daily living and was registered as permanently disabled due to a work-related disability.

Crises temporales symptomatiques d’une intoxication au trichloroéthylène

INTRODUCTION

Trichloroethylene (TCE) is extensively used as a degreasing agent in the metal industry and as a solvent for organic compounds. Its neurotoxicity (with respect to both the peripheral and central nervous systems) is now widely acknowledged.

OBSERVATION

Here, we report the case of a 32-year-old male drug addict presenting temporal seizures after "huffing" TCE (i.e. voluntary inhalation). The patient also deve loped a "psycho-organic syndrome" which included cognitive dysfunction (with memory disorders in particular) and personality changes. These disorders had not been noticed by the patient's wife prior to the last episode of inhalation. Four months later, the cognitive disorders had stabilized and no further seizures had been observed.

CONCLUSION

The patient's overall clinical picture (notably featuring neuropsychological disorders) and electroencephalographic and brain imaging data argue in favor of a selective effect of TCE on the temporal lobe.

Toxic Encephalopathies

Effective brain function is dependent on precise and complex interactions among neurotransmitters, hormones, enzymes, and electrolytes. Many of the chemically complex substances with which we come into contact can disrupt this intricately balanced system. Toxic substances, whether ingested, inhaled, or absorbed through the skin, may cause an encephalopathic state directly by affecting the brain itself or indirectly by compromising the brain's supportive systems. The article focuses on neurotoxins (heavy metals, solvents and vapors, pesticides, and natural neurotoxins) that directly induce an encephalopathic state.

Biochemical and pharmacological characterization of 1-trichloromethyl-1,2,3,4-tetrahydro-beta-carboline: a biologically relevant neurotoxin?

Acute and long-term effects of exposure to reactive compounds as the result of environmental pollution, workplace conditions or dietary intake are suspected to be involved in the etiology of a variety of disorders, including neurodegenerative disorders such as Parkinson's disease. The recognition in 1970s that 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP), a neurotoxic by-product of illicit meperidine synthesis, elicits parkinsonian symptoms in primates, including man, prompted the search for naturally occurring analogs which might be involved in human disease. It has been suggested that one candidate, 1-trichloromethyl-1,2,3,4-tetrahydro-beta-carboline (TaClo), a potent dopaminergic neurotoxin, might be formed endogenously in humans following the administration of the hypnotic chloral hydrate or after the exposure to the industrial solvent trichloroethylene. Such spontaneous formation has, indeed, been recently reported. The biochemical and pharmacological characteristics of TaClo and related compounds are thus reviewed here, and their potential significance for human neurodegenerative disease discussed.

Neuropsychological dysfunction, mood disturbance, and emotional status of munitions workers

The objective of this study was to compare the neuropsychological function, emotional status, visual function, and illness prevalence of 265 former munitions plant workers (M age = 56.7 years, M years of education = 12.07; 201 African American, 64 White) exposed to organic solvents for an average of 17.03 years with that of a group of 77 unexposed controls (M age = 51.3 years, M years of education = 13.07; 30 African American, 47 White). Neuropsychological tests were selected from the World Health Organization Neurobehavioral Core Test Battery, Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-III (WAIS-III), and Wechsler Memory Scale-III (WMS-III) and also included the Brief Symptom Inventory, Profile of Mood States, Beck Anxiety Inventory, and Beck Depression Inventory. Vision tests included the Lanthony d-15 color vision, the Vistech Contrast Sensitivity, and the Snellen. The exposed group showed greater deficits than the controls in verbal learning (WMS-III Logical Memory I Learning Slope and Word Lists I Recall), visuomotor tracking speed (Cancellation H, WAIS-III Digit Symbol-Coding) and psychomotor function (Dynamometer and Grooved Pegboard), and dysfunction in emotional status, illness prevalence, and visual function. African American workers reported higher levels of exposure than Whites. Exposure relations demonstrated increased neuropsychological dysfunction with increased exposure.

Evaluation of blink reflex results obtained from workers previously diagnosed with solvent-induced toxic encephalopathy

We reviewed blink reflexes recorded from 51 railroad workers with long-term occupational exposure to solvents who were diagnosed by others with solvent-induced toxic encephalopathy. No worker fulfilled conventional clinical criteria for dementia or trigeminal mononeuropathy. All workers had normal R1 and R2 blink reflex latencies. R1 latencies correlated significantly with several nerve conduction measures, including F wave latencies, suggesting that some intersubject variability reflected intrinsic conduction properties, not isolated brain-stem function. Although normal, the workers' R1 latencies were significantly prolonged compared with historical control groups, including gender-matched control subjects of similar mean age (11.2 ms vs 9.9 ms; P < 0.0001). Stepwise multiple regression models demonstrated significant associations of R1 latency with age and use of CNS-active prescription medications (P = 0.003), but duration of occupational solvent exposure did not enter into the models. Paradoxically, workers using CNS-active medications had significantly shorter R1 latencies compared with workers not using such medications (10.9 vs 11.7 ms; P = 0.01). Job title, another potential surrogate measure of exposure, was not significantly related to reflex latencies. The geographical site of predominant solvent exposure did influence R1 latency, and workers from one site had longer exposure duration and longer R1 latencies than remaining workers. However, an interaction between age and exposure duration (r = 0.39; P = 0.003) confounded interpretation of this observation. Disability or work status, mental status findings, or classification of encephalopathy did not influence blink reflex latencies. The overall results do not support, but do not entirely exclude, a possible relationship between subclinical blink reflex abnormalities and occupational exposure to solvents. Nevertheless, it is clear from these results that the small group differences in R1 latency between exposed workers and control subjects are of no diagnostic importance and of uncertain physiologic importance, and they may reflect unrecognized confounders and technical factors.

Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry's 1997 priority list of hazardous substances. Latent effects--carcinogenesis, neurotoxicology, and developmental deficits in humans and animals

In support of Superfund re-authorization legislation, the Division of Toxicology of the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) prepared a chemical-specific consultation document for Congress that identified those chemicals with carcinogenic, neurological, or developmental adverse effects having a latency period longer than 6 years. The review was limited to the top 50 substances listed on ATSDR's 1997 Priority List of Hazardous Substances (Priority List). Among the top 50 chemicals, a review of the technical literature indicated that 38 (76%) were classified as "reasonably anticipated," "possibly," or "probably" capable of causing cancer in humans, based either on human and animal data. Eight chemicals (16%) had well-established cancer latency periods in humans of 6 years or more following exposure. Three substances (6%)--arsenic, creosote, and benzidine--had data indicating latency periods longer than 6 years. The technical literature review likewise confirmed the potential for neurological and developmental effects with a latency of 6 years. Twenty-seven (54%) of the top 50 substances caused acute and/or chronic neurotoxic effects; a number of these also caused neurological effects that persisted beyond 6 years (or the equivalent in animal studies) such as: behavioral problems, neurological deficiencies, reduced psychomotor development, cognitive deficiencies, and reduced IQ. Twenty-eight substances (56%) caused adverse developmental effects in offspring of exposed individuals or animals including increased fetal and infant mortality, decreased birth weights and litter sizes, and growth delays. Latency periods for related chemicals are expected to be similar due to structural and toxicological similarities.

Neurobehavioral and respiratory findings in jet engine repair workers: A comparison of exposed and unexposed volunteers

Workers repairing jet engines had respiratory, rheumatic, and neurobehavioral symptoms. They had welded and ground stainless steel parts using hard metal tools and cleaned metal with chlorinated and fluorinated organic solvents. We compared 154 workers and 112 unexposed subjects, all volunteers of similar ages and with similar educational levels, for abnormalities on chest radiographs, spirometric measurements, and questionnaires. Also appraised were performance of reaction time, balance, blink reflex latency, color discrimination, Culture Fair, vocabulary, slotted pegboard, trail making A and B, profile of mood states (POMS), and frequencies of 35 symptoms. Compared to unexposed subjects, workers had significantly more respiratory symptoms but no differences in pulmonary function. They had significantly prolonged simple and choice reaction time (P<0.0001), and abnormal balance with eyes open and eyes closed (P<0. 0001), and abnormal color discrimination. Blink reflex latency was abnormal in both exposed workers and in local unexposed compared to other reference groups. Focus of the inquiry on lung disease helped ensure that for neurobehavioral tests confounding factors were minimal and known biases were small. We tentatively attribute the neurobehavioral impairments and increased symptom frequencies to chlorinated solvent exposure. Excessive respiratory symptoms are attributed to welding stainless steel combined with cigarette smoking. Specifically, manganese exposure may have affected the respiratory and the central nervous systems.

Exposure to trihalomethanes and adverse pregnancy outcomes

Exposure during pregnancy to disinfection by-products in drinking water has been hypothesized to lead to several adverse reproductive outcomes. We performed a retrospective cohort study to examine the relation of trihalomethane exposure during the third trimester of pregnancy to low birthweight, term low birthweight, and preterm delivery. We matched Colorado birth certificates from January 1, 1990, through December 31, 1993, to historical water sample data with respect to time and location of maternal residence based on census block groups. After excluding births from all census block groups with no trihalomethane sample data and restricting to singleton white births with 28-42 weeks of completed gestation (>400 gm), we studied 1,893 livebirths within 28 census block groups. We found a weak association of trihalomethane exposure during the third trimester with low birthweight (odds ratio = 2.1 for the highest exposure level; 95% confidence interval = 1.0-4.8); a large increase in risk for term low birthweight at the highest level of exposure (odds ratio = 5.9; 95% confidence interval = 2.0-17.0); and no association between exposure and preterm delivery (odds ratio = 1.0 for the highest exposure level; 95% confidence interval = 0.3-2.8). The small number of adverse outcomes reduced the precision of risk estimates, but these data indicate a potentially important relation between third trimester exposure to trihalomethanes and retarded fetal growth.

Solvents and neurotoxicity

We describe the clinical evaluation of the nervous-system effects of solvent exposure. We review the current evidence in the epidemiological literature on neurotoxicological effects of solvents, and outline methods and issues to be taken into account in assessment of the patient whose symptoms may be related to solvent toxicity. Primary prevention of these disorders is essential, because treatment options are limited.

Long-term cognitive sequelae of solvent intoxication

Memory problems lasting 8 months have previously been described for a small group of female solvent workers following an accidental workplace solvent intoxication. Three years after the intoxication the presence of longer-term residual impairment of cognitive functions was evaluated. The major residual difficulty uncovered related to the speed of processing linguistic material, with workers showing slower verification on tasks probing syntactic and semantic reasoning within the context of relatively unimpaired response execution speeds. Of particular interest was the intoxicated workers' difficulty with the conceptually more complex negative syntactic reasoning problems. This difficulty was also shared by solvent workers who were not involved in that accidental intoxication. In addition, decision fatigue was observed following prolonged responding in a continuous choice reaction time task, although ability to maintain vigilance and concentration were unaffected. Taken together, these findings indicate that a single solvent intoxication can give rise to long-term cognitive sequelae in solvent workers.

Trichloroethylene--a review of the literature from a health effects perspective

This report reviews the literature on the impact of exposure to trichloroethylene (TCE) on human health. Special emphasis is given to the health effects reported in excess of national norms by participants in the TCE Subregistry of the Volatile Organic Compounds Registry of the National Exposure Registries--persons with documented exposure to TCE through drinking and use of contaminated water. The health effects reported in excess by some or all of the sex and age groups studied were speech and hearing impairments, effects of stroke, liver problems, anemia and other blood disorders, diabetes, kidney disease, urinary tract disorders, and skin rashes.

Neuropsychological effects of exposure to naphtha among automotive workers

The association between exposure to naphtha and neurobehavioural measures was examined prospectively over one year among workers employed at an automotive plant that used naphtha to calibrate fuel injectors. The neurobehavioural tests included those that assess mood, basic intelligence, and functioning of the cerebral frontal lobes and limbic system and were designed so that acute, reversible, and chronic effects of solvent exposure could be assessed. Participants were 248 workers in June 1988, and the testing was repeated on 185 of these workers in 1989. Concentrations of naphtha at the plant ranged from six to 709 mg/m3, although exposure was greater in 1988 than in 1989. Duration of exposure for individual subjects ranged from 0.8 to 7.3 years. Cross sectional data analyses showed significant associations between level of exposure to naphtha and slower timed scores on trails A, and greater reports of negative affective symptoms on profile of mood states scales in 1988 but not 1989. Threshold model analyses of the 1989 data showed an association between score on visual reproductions immediate recall and daily exposure to naphtha at or above 1050 h x mg/m3. Models of chronic exposure showed no associations between chronic exposure and negative neurobehavioural outcome. Results suggest that naphtha produces mild acute reversible effects on function of the central nervous system at or above daily exposures of 540 h x mg/m3 (approximately 90 ppm/h).

Idiopathic generalized myokymia

Idiopathic generalized myokymia (IGM) is a rare, heterogeneous, and poorly understood syndrome. We present analysis of 75 reported cases in the world literature. IGM affects men and women equally, with a mean age of onset 29 +/- 19 years. Patients' common presenting complaints are stiffness (60%), cramps (12%), weakness (12%), and muscle twitching (4%). Family history is positive in 30%. In addition to generalized clinical myokymia (92%), abnormal neurologic findings include: hyporeflexia (70%), weakness (45%), grip myotonia (39%), and calf hypertrophy (16%). Electrical activity consisting of spontaneous continuous motor unit activity and/or electrical myokymia was documented in all patients. When electrical myokymia was observed (66%), the grouped discharges where irregular and had an interburst frequency of 2-300 Hz. Both phenytoin and carbamazepine are effective treatments. We conclude that IGM has a wide spectrum of symptoms and severity and should be considered in all patients that present with stiffness, cramps, or muscle twitching. EMG greatly aids in diagnosis.

Mid-frequency hearing loss and reduction of acoustic startle responding in rats following trichloroethylene exposure

Modification of auditory evoked startle responding using prepulse inhibition was used to examine the effects of trichloroethylene (TCE) exposure on auditory thresholds. Rats were exposed by inhalation to 0, 1500, or 3000 ppm TCE for 18 hours per day, 5 days a week for 3 weeks. Auditory thresholds for 5 and 20 kHz tones were measured before exposure and at 1, 3, and 6 weeks postexposure. In addition, hearing thresholds for 5 and 35 kHz tones were examined at a 5-week postexposure time-point. Results indicated that hearing thresholds for 20 kHz but not for 5 or 35 kHz prepulses were significantly increased in rats exposed to 3000 ppm TCE. These findings demonstrate a selective hearing loss in the 20 kHz range by short-term, high-level TCE exposure. With respect to effects on startle responding per se, the present study also found that compared to controls, TCE-exposed rats failed to show an increase in baseline startle with repeated testing. This difference could not be attributed to differences in body weight and was persistent throughout the postexposure period.

Solvent-induced chronic toxic encephalopathy

Chlorinated solvents, especially trichloroethylene, have been extensively used for metal degreasing since the beginning of this century. There have been case reports of cranial nerve damage and symptoms of acute and reversible encephalopathy. However, another issue during the last decade is the possible existence of a syndrome of chronic cerebral dysfunction. Our study deals with the risk of developing a state of psychoorganic syndrome after long-term exposure to solvents, mainly trichloroethylene. In this historical cohort study, 96 metal degreasers participated in a clinical medical and psychological examination. The risk of developing psychoorganic syndrome was proportional to the exposure duration, to increasing age, and to decreasing primary intellectual level. Using logistic regression analysis, there was a significantly increased risk of developing psychoorganic syndrome from solvent exposure. There was an odds ratio of 5.6 (0.93-34.3) for psychoorganic syndrome in the medium-exposed group. In the most highly exposed group, with a mean full-time exposure duration of 11 years, there was a significantly increased risk of psychoorganic syndrome, the adjusted odds ratio was 11.2 (1.9-66.6). None of four other potential confounders (arteriosclerotic disease, neurologic/psychiatric disease, alcohol abuse, and current solvent exposure) had any significant associations to psychoorganic syndrome.

Effects on neurobehavioral performance of chronic exposure to chemically contaminated well water

Occupational exposure to trichloroethylene (TCE) and other solvents impairs neurobehavioral performance. Use of well water contaminated with TCE and solvents has been associated with excessive symptoms, cancers, birth defects and impaired blink reflex. We extended these observations by measuring the neurophysiological (NPH) and neuropsychological (NPS) status of subjects who used water contaminated with 6 to 500 ppb of TCE for 1 to 25 years. The 170 well-water exposed subjects who resided in southwest Tucson, Arizona overlying the Santa Cruz River aquifer, were compared to 68 referent subjects for NPH and NPS tests. Also, 113 histology technicians (HT) were referents for blink reflex latency only. Affective status was assayed by a Profile of Mood States (POMS). Exposed subjects were statistically significantly impaired when compared to referents for NPH tests. These impairments included sway speed with eyes open and closed, blink reflex latency (R-1), eye closure speed, and two choice visual reaction time. NPS status was statistically significant impaired for Culture Fair (intelligence) scores, recall of stories, visual recall, digit span, block design, recognition of fingertip numbers, grooved pegboard and Trail making A and B. POMS scores were elevated. Prolonged residential exposure to well-water containing TCE at lower levels than occupational exposures, but without time away from exposure for metabolism and excretion of toxins, was associated with neurobehavioral impairment.

Clinical neurological findings among metal degreasers exposed to chlorinated solvents

Among industrial solvents in present use trichloroethylene belongs to those which have been the concern of most neurological and occupational investigations since the beginning of this century. Reports on a broad spectrum of neurotoxicity are however mostly based on case-studies and accidental circumstances. The object of this study was to examine clinical neurological manifestations after long-term exposure to degreasing solvents, mainly trichloroethylene. The population was 99 metal degreasers, the design a historical cohort study. The most marked finding was a highly significant dose-response relation between solvent exposure and motor dyscoordination--a finding that was retained after multivariate control of relevant confounders. Vibration thresholds increased by solvent exposure at bivariate level, but the multivariate analysis showed that age was explaining most of the increase. No significant cranial nerve dysfunction was found.

Blink reflex measurement of effects of trichloroethylene exposure on the trigeminal nerve

Trichloroethylene (TCE) exposure is known to have specific toxic effects on cranial nerves, the trigeminal nerve (V) in particular. The electrophysiological measurement of the blink reflex (BR) can quantify latency changes in the Vth and VIIth cranial nerve reflex arc. Prior study looked at the blink reflex measurement in a community group exposed to TCE in their drinking water. This study evaluated the use of the electrophysiologic blink reflex as an indicator of neurotoxic effects of TCE in occupationally exposed workers. The BR was tested in individual cases with documented histories of exposure to known chemical neurotoxins including TCE (n = 18). When compared with the nonexposed laboratory control values (n = 30), the subjects with a significant history of TCE exposure demonstrated the most prolonged latencies (greater than or equal to 3.0 SD above the nonexposed group mean) in the R1 component of the blink reflex measurement. The electrophysiological study of the blink reflex has application in assessing TCE exposure and in documenting the neurotoxic effects of that exposure on trigeminal nerve functions in humans.

Generalized eruption with severe liver dysfunction associated with occupational exposure to trichloroethylene

Generalized dermatitis due to trichloroethylene is rare. A 21-year-old printer developed exfoliative dermatitis with mucous membrane involvement, fever and liver dysfunction after a 2-week occupational exposure to trichloroethylene. Positive patch-test reactions to trichloroethylene and to one of its metabolites, trichloroethanol, were observed. This dermatitis is considered to be mediated by a delayed-type hypersensitivity mechanism.

Blink reflex latency after exposure to trichloroethylene in well water

The electrophysiological measurement of the blink reflex (BR) can quantify the conduction latency in the reflex arc involving the Vth (trigeminal) and VIIth (facial) cranial nerves. We measured the electrophysiological BR in a population (N = 21), which had alleged chronic exposure to trichloroethylene (TCE) through the public drinking water at levels 30-80 times higher than the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Maximum Contamination Level (MCL). A highly significant difference was observed in the conduction latency means of the BR components (p less than .0001), when the study population was compared with laboratory controls (N = 27). This difference suggests a subclinical alteration of the Vth cranial nerve function due to chronic, environmental exposure to TCE.