Anophthalmia, cleft lip/palate, facial anomalies, and CNS anomalies and hypothalamic disorder in a newborn: a midline developmental field defect

A Comprehensive Assessment of Co-occurring Birth Defects among Infants with Non-Syndromic Anophthalmia or Microphthalmia

PURPOSE

Infants with anophthalmia or microphthalmia frequently have co-occurring birth defects. Nonetheless, there have been few investigations of birth defect patterns among these children. Such studies may identify novel multiple malformation syndromes, which could inform future research into the developmental processes that lead to anophthalmia/microphthalmia and assist physicians in determining whether further testing is appropriate.

METHODS

This study includes cases with anophthalmia/microphthalmia identified by the Texas Birth Defects Registry from 1999 to 2014 without clinical or chromosomal diagnoses of recognized syndromes. We calculated adjusted observed-to-expected ratios for two - through five-way birth defect combinations involving anophthalmia/microphthalmia to estimate whether these combinations co-occur more often than would be expected if they were independent. We report combinations observed in ≥5 cases.

RESULTS

We identified 653 eligible cases with anophthalmia/microphthalmia (514 [79%] with co-occurring birth defects), and 111 birth defect combinations, of which 44 were two-way combinations, 61 were three-way combinations, six were four-way combinations and none were five-way combinations. Combinations with the largest observed-to-expected ratios were those involving central nervous system (CNS) defects, head/neck defects, and orofacial clefts. We also observed multiple combinations involving cardiovascular and musculoskeletal defects.

CONCLUSION

Consistent with previous reports, we observed that a large proportion of children diagnosed with anophthalmia/microphthalmia have co-occurring birth defects. While some of these defects may be part of a sequence involving anophthalmia/microphthalmia (e.g., CNS defects), other combinations could point to as yet undescribed susceptibility patterns (e.g., musculoskeletal defects). Data from population-based birth defect registries may be useful for accelerating the discovery of previously uncharacterized malformation syndromes.

An update on oculocerebrocutaneous (Delleman-Oorthuys) syndrome

Oculocerebrocutaneous syndrome (OCCS) is a rare disorder characterized primarily by congenital skin, eye, and brain anomalies. The most distinctive findings are hypoplastic or aplastic skin defects; pedunculated, typically hamartomatous, or nodular skin appendages; cystic microphthalmia; and a combination of forebrain anomalies and a specific mid-hindbrain malformation. Based on a review of 40 patients with OCCS, existing clinical criteria have been revised. Because of the asymmetric and patchy distribution of features, lack of recurrence in families, male preponderance and completely skewed X-inactivation in one female, OCCS is hypothesized to result from postzygotic mosaic variants in an X-linked gene. Whole exome and genome sequencing on blood DNA in two patients failed to identify pathogenic variants so far. In view of the overlapping features, in particular of the brain, of OCCS and Aicardi syndrome, both may be pathogenetically related or even result from different variants in the same gene. For the elucidation of the cause of OCCS, exome or genome sequencing on multiple lesional tissues is the primary goal.

Truncating RAX Mutations: Anophthalmia, Hypopituitarism, Diabetes Insipidus, and Cleft Palate in Mice and Men

CONTEXT

The transcription factor RAX is a paired-type homeoprotein that plays a critical role in eye and forebrain development of vertebrate species. RAX knockout mice have anophthalmia, cleft palate, and an abnormal hypothalamus and display perinatal lethality. In humans, homozygous or compound heterozygous RAX mutations have been reported to cause bilateral microphthalmia or anophthalmia without consistent associated features. Congenital hypopituitarism can be associated with various eye or craniofacial anomalies; however, the co-occurrence of congenital hypopituitarism, anophthalmia, cleft palate, and diabetes insipidus has been very rare.

RESULTS

We report the case of a child with anophthalmia, congenital hypopituitarism, diabetes insipidus, and bilateral cleft lip and palate who had a homozygous frameshift truncating mutation c.266delC (p.Pro89Argfs*114) in exon 1 of the RAX gene. Rax knockout mice show loss of ventral forebrain structures, pituitary, and basosphenoid bone and palate and a misplaced anterior pituitary gland along the roof of the oral cavity.

CONCLUSIONS

Our patient's phenotype was more severe than that reported in other patients. Although most of the previously reported patients with RAX mutations showed either a missense or some less severe mutation in at least one of their RAX alleles, our patient was homozygous for truncating mutations that would yield a severe, null protein phenotype. The severity of the genetic defect, the precise match between the knockout mouse and the patient's endocrine phenotypes, and the prominent roles of RAX in eye and pituitary development and diencephalic patterning suggest that the RAX null mutations could fully account for the observed phenotype.

Clinical and mutation analysis of 51 probands with anophthalmia and/or severe microphthalmia from a single center

Clinical evaluation and mutation analysis was performed in 51 consecutive probands with severe eye malformations - anophthalmia and/or severe microphthalmia - seen in a single specialist ophthalmology center. The mutation analysis consisted of bidirectional sequencing of the coding regions of SOX2, OTX2, PAX6 (paired domain), STRA6, BMP4, SMOC1, FOXE3, and RAX, and genome-wide array-based copy number assessment. Fifteen (29.4%) of the 51 probands had likely causative mutations affecting SOX2 (9/51), OTX2 (5/51), and STRA6 (1/51). Of the cases with bilateral anophthalmia, 9/12 (75%) were found to be mutation positive. Three of these mutations were large genomic deletions encompassing SOX2 (one case) or OTX2 (two cases). Familial inheritance of three intragenic, plausibly pathogenic, and heterozygous mutations was observed. An unaffected carrier parent of an affected child with an identified OTX2 mutation confirmed the previously reported nonpenetrance for this disorder. Two families with SOX2 mutations demonstrated a parent and child both with significant but highly variable eye malformations. Heterozygous loss-of-function mutations in SOX2 and OTX2 are the most common genetic pathology associated with severe eye malformations and bi-allelic loss-of-function in STRA6 is confirmed as an emerging cause of nonsyndromal eye malformations.

Anophthalmia, cleft lip/palate, absent vomer bone, nystagmus, and mental-motor retardation: a new syndrome or Fryns "anophthalmia-plus" syndrome?

OBJECTIVE

We report that a 4-year-old boy presented with right unilateral complete cleft lip and palate, right anophthalmos, left congenital nystagmus, absence of the vomer bone, mental-motor retardation, and normal lymphocyte karyotype (46, XY).

METHODS

For reconstruction of the deformities, we performed cleft lip repair by Millard's rotation-advancement technique and planned cleft palate repair.

CONCLUSIONS

This combination of cleft lip and palate, anophthalmos, congenital nystagmus, absent vomer bone, and mental-motor retardation has not, to our knowledge, previously been described. We suggest that this represents either another case of the rare Fryns "anophthalmia-plus" syndrome or a new syndrome.

Anophthalmia-plus syndrome: a clinical report and review of the literature

We describe a term male infant of healthy non-consanguineous parents, born with congenital malformations, including bilateral cleft palate and lip, mild microphthalmia with iris coloboma and glaucoma of the right eye, and blepharophimosis with severe microphthalmia of the left eye. Spine radiograph and MRI showed first sacral hemivertebra with spina bifida, and agenesis of the 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th sacral vertebrae and coccyx. Spine MRI showed caudal tethering of spinal cord at L(3) level, filum terminalis lipoma and a syringomyelia. Brain ultrasound and MRI showed hypoplasia of corpus callosum with mild dilatation of the lateral ventricles. Orbital MRI showed bilateral microphthalmia-distorted small left eyeball with posteriorly located lens, and a split vitreous body in the right eye, suggestive of primary hyperplastic vitreous. The karyotype was normal. Summary of the findings in nine cases (our case and eight published cases) support the notion that anophthalmia-plus syndrome (APS) is a distinct syndrome. Gene locus of APS is yet to be identified.

Oculocerebrocutaneous and encephalocraniocutaneous lipomatosis syndromes: blind men and an elephant or separate syndromes?

The discovery of relevant causative genes has subdued the lumping versus splitting debate with respect to a growing number of syndromes. However, it remains paramount to define unknown genesis syndromes as precisely and appropriately as possible in order to provide accurate prognosis and to facilitate future research. The presentation of a 14-month-old girl, of normal intelligence, who had a colobomatous right eye with cyst, minor intracranial MRI variants, and an area of sparse scalp hair containing a 1 by 1.5 cm, soft, domed, and indented skin lesion suggested a diagnosis of mild oculocerebrocutaneous syndrome (OCCS). An initial exploration of the literature exposed the extreme variability in cases that have been reported as OCCS, and emphasized its possible relationship to encephalocraniocutaneous lipomatosis (ECCL), thus challenging the initial diagnosis. Cases reported, or discussed by others, as possible OCCS (40) and ECCL (44) were reviewed as completely as possible in an effort to determine whether diagnostic criteria could be developed for these syndromes, and to see whether or not evidence favored their continued separation as two syndromes. The approach used was to summarize the data for all cases, to select major and minor diagnostic criteria on the basis of the relative specificity and/or frequency of a sign, to then apply the criteria in a standard fashion and to review the outcome to see if the classification of cases made clinical sense, and to make appropriate adjustments. The criteria were not chosen so as to separate the syndromes and in some instances the same criteria could apply to either syndrome. An approach is outlined for handling reports of patients that purport to be variants or to expand the spectrum of a syndrome, and in the case of OCCS and ECCL this resulted in most such examples being excluded. Application of diagnostic criteria suggests that OCCS and ECCL are distinct, and that some case reports, including some purporting to expand the spectrum of OCCS, should be excluded, at least until such time as the etiology of these conditions is known and those cases can be tested. These diagnostic criteria were developed on the basis of literature reports that varied in their quantity and quality of detail. Furthermore, in many cases reliance had to be placed on copies of original studies with resultant degradation of photographic information. Modern ocular imaging, and histopathology of eye and skin malformations, will often clarify the specific nature of a malformation and, therefore, define exact diagnostic criteria and leave fewer uncertain cases. In the absence of anomalies in those systems, or if histopathology or appropriate imaging is unavailable, the diagnosis in some cases will continue to remain uncertain; this is not an argument for lumping the syndromes.

Oculocerebrocutaneous syndrome: the brain malformation defines a core phenotype

BACKGROUND

Oculocerebrocutaneous syndrome (OCCS) is characterised by orbital cysts and anophthalmia or microphthalmia, focal aplastic or hypoplastic skin defects, skin appendages, and brain malformations. The eye and skin abnormalities are well described but the neuropathological features less so. To date, 28 patients with an unequivocal diagnosis of OCCS have been reported, with a preponderance of males.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the brain imaging studies, clinical records, photographs, and pathological material of two new and nine previously reported cases of OCCS.

RESULTS

There was a consistent pattern of malformations in eight of the 11 cases, consisting of frontal predominant polymicrogyria and periventricular nodular heterotopia, enlarged lateral ventricles or hydrocephalus, agenesis of the corpus callosum sometimes associated with interhemispheric cysts, and a novel mid-hindbrain malformation. The latter consisted of a giant and dysplastic tectum, absent cerebellar vermis, small cerebellar hemispheres in most cases, and a large posterior fossa fluid collection.

CONCLUSIONS

The mid-hindbrain malformation appears pathognomonic for OCCS. The eye and skin features of OCCS show considerable overlap with several other syndromes, such as encephalocraniocutaneous lipomatosis, oculo-auriculo-vertebral spectrum, and focal dermal hypoplasia, none of which has a comparable pattern of brain malformations. In particular the unique mid-hindbrain malformation also distinguishes OCCS from related syndromes with comparable forebrain anomalies. The pattern of malformation described thus helps in differentiating OCCS from other entities. The mid-hindbrain malformation points to a defect of the mid-hindbrain organiser as the underlying pathogenic mechanism.

14q(22) deletion in a familial case of anophthalmia with polydactyly

We report a family of anophthalmia with ocular and extraocular manifestations. The proband, his three sisters, and two sons had anophthalmia and preaxial polydactyly in the right hand. Cytogenetic analysis was done for the proband and two of his sons, one of whom was affected. Another male child was affected but was not available for cytogenetic analysis. Karyotypes of both affected individuals showed deletion on long arm of 14q22q23. Literature review shows four cases of anophthalmia with extra ocular anomalies associated with 14q (q22q23) deletion. Recently it has been suggested that the human homeobox gene, SIX6, and the BMP-4 gene are responsible for eye development. Both are located in the chromosome 14q22.3-q23 region. Deletion in this region has been known to be associated with anophthalmia and pituitary anomalies. This is the first family of anophthalmia, which showed polydactyly with a chromosomal deletion in the 14q22-q23 region and its familial transmission in two generations with a total of six affected individuals.

Facial dysgenesis: a novel facial syndrome with chromosome 7 deletion p15.1-21.1

We describe a female neonate with a unique constellation of features including anophthalmia and cryptophthalmos, temporal remnant "eye tags," bilateral cleft lip, unilateral cleft palate, a proboscis with absent nasal septum, choanal atresia, micrognathia, square stoma, and bilateral external auditory canal atresia. Gross brain structure, pituitary function, limbs, trunk, and genitalia were normal. Skeletal survey, echocardiogram and abdominal viscera were unremarkable except for a split central sinus of the right kidney. BAER exam indicated she could hear and temporal CT confirmed the presence of cochlea and possible ossicles. Cytogenetic evaluation revealed an interstitial deletion at chromosome 7p15.1-21.1. TWIST, a gene encoding a transcription factor involved in craniofacial development, is deleted by FISH analysis. The absence of a mutation on the non-deleted allele of TWIST as determined by sequencing virtually eliminates complete loss of the TWIST gene as the cause of this patient's severe phenotype. The HOXA gene cluster also encodes transcription factors that are crucial for directing cephalad to caudad somatic fetal development. HOXA1, the most telomeric of the 13 members of the HOXA gene cluster, is located at the centromeric boundary of the patient's chromosome 7 deletion. By FISH analysis, neither allele of HOXA1 is deleted and sequencing reveals no mutations. Haploinsufficiency or complete loss of the HOXA1 gene also does not appear to cause this patient's severe phenotype. Previous reports of chromosome 7p15-21 deletions do not have phenotypes similar to this patient.

Fryns "Anophthalmia-Plus" syndrome associated with developmental regression

We report a boy with a nasal deformity, choanal atresia, bifid uvula, severe bilateral microphthalmia and a facial cleft who showed regression of development at the age of 2 years with subsequent improvement. We suggest he represents a further case of the rare Fryns "Anophthalmia-Plus" syndrome.

Exclusion of SIX6 hemizygosity in a child with anophthalmia, panhypopituitarism and renal failure

We report a patient who presented with anophthalmia, panhypopituitarism, early onset of end stage renal failure, and craniofacial abnormalities. MRI at age 3 revealed that the pituitary was absent and renal biopsy demonstrated nephronophthisis as the cause of the renal failure. A similar syndrome has been associated with interstitial deletions of chromosome 14q22 and in one case hemizygosity for SIX6 was demonstrated. The patient reported here had a normal karyotype and Southern blot did not reveal loss of one copy of SIX6. We discuss other possible candidate genes that could be implicated in this syndrome.

Severe oculocerebrocutaneous (Delleman) syndrome: overlap with Goldenhar anomaly

Oculocerebrocutaneous syndrome (OCCS), or Delleman syndrome, is a multiple congenital anomaly syndrome characterized by orbital cysts, cerebral malformations, and focal dermal hypoplasia [Delleman and Oorthuys, 1981, Clin Genet 19:191-198; Delleman et al., 1984, Clin Genet 25:470-472]. Two previous reports presented children having what is suggested as the more severe form of the OCCS syndrome who also had anophthalmia, congenital hydrocephalus, and cleft lip and palate [Leichtman et al., 1994, Am J Med Genet 50:39-41; Angle and Hersh, 1997, Am J Med Genet 68:39-42]. We report on a third case of severe OCCS, an infant girl with a similar constellation of findings and additional anomalies including lateral facial cleft, vertebral anomaly, and ventricular septal defect. The additional findings in our patient highlight the phenotypic overlap of OCCS and the Goldenhar anomaly, an overlap previously noted by Delleman and Oorthuys [1981], and others [Al-Gazali et al., 1988, J Med Genet 25: 773-778]. We suggest that the minimal diagnostic criteria for Delleman syndrome include central nervous system cyst or hydrocephalus, orbital cysts or microphthalmia, and focal skin defects.

New syndrome with the Sakoda complex, bilateral anophthalmia, and cortical dysgenesis

An 8-year-old Japanese boy had Sakoda complex (basal encephalomeningocele, agenesis of the corpus callosum, and cleft lip and/or palate) associated with bilateral anophthalmia, dysgenesis of the cerebral cortex, severe mental retardation, and intractable epilepsy as core symptoms and hemiparesis, microcephalus, short stature, and hemivertebra. Tada and Nakamura described the first case of the Sakoda complex associated with bilateral anophthalmia, cortical dysgenesis, neonatal-onset seizures, and severe mental retardation. Fourteen patients with the Sakoda complex with or without ocular dysplasia were reviewed. It is proposed that these cases belong to a clinical entity that is distinguishable from the remaining 12 patients because of bilateral anophthalmia, cortical dysgenesis, and its resulting severe mental retardation and intractable epilepsy. There is a possibility that these two cases are one severe end of certain spectrum disorders in which certain common gene(s) might be implicated.

Anophthalmia-microphthalmia-oblique clefting syndrome: confirmation of the Fryns anophthalmia syndrome

We describe a patient with bilateral extreme microphthalmia with bilateral congenital glaucoma, bilateral medial oblique facial cleft ending in lid colobomas, bilateral stenosis of the choanae, bifid uvula, frontal encephalocele, and premature craniosynostosis. The cause is unknown, but the phenotype resembles the Fryns anophthalmia-plus syndrome, which may be a recessive trait, although intrauterine environmental factors cannot be excluded.

Microphthalmia, marked short stature, hearing loss, and developmental delay: extension of the phenotype of GOMBO syndrome?

An adult male with microphthalmia, severe developmental delay, conductive hearing loss, marked short stature of prenatal onset, and radiographic skeletal changes is described. A review of the literature, focusing on his major findings, suggests that his manifestations might be an extension of the phenotype of GOMBO (growth retardation, ocular abnormalities, microcephaly, brachydactyly, oligophrenia) syndrome.

Anophthalmia, intracerebral cysts, and cleft lip/palate: expansion of the phenotype in oculocerebrocutaneous syndrome?

We report on a patient with multiple congenital anomalies including anophthalmia, cleft lip and palate, and central nervous system anomalies similar to the case reported by Leichtman et al. [1994: Am J Med Genet 50:39-41] and to oculocerebrocutaneous (Delleman) syndrome. Although the two cases and those with oculocerebrocutaneous syndrome may represent separate but overlapping entities, our patient and the case described by Leichtman et al. [1994: Am J Med Genet 50:39-41] may represent a more severe form of oculocerebrocutaneous syndrome.

Apparently new "anophthalmia-plus" syndrome in sibs

The index patient of this report is a 17-week-gestation female fetus with bilateral anophthalmia, bilateral cleft lip/cleft palate, macrotia with bilateral lateral facial cleft, large open sacral neural tube defect, and uterus unicornis. Parents were normal and nonconsanguineous with an unremarkable family history. Their first child, a 4-year-old boy, is normal. The second child, a 2 1/2-year-old boy, has bilateral anophthalmia and an abnormal left ear with absent lobule as the sole additional anomaly. These 2 sibs seem to be the first examples of a new "anophthalmia-plus" syndrome apparently inherited as autosomal-recessive.