Reversible 100 % Linkage Isomerization in a Single-Crystal to Single-Crystal Transformation: Photocrystallographic Identification of the Metastable [Ni(dppe)(η1-ONO)Cl] Isomer

Methods in molecular photocrystallography

Over the last three decades, the technology that makes it possible to follow chemical processes in the solid state in real time has grown enormously. These studies have important implications for the design of new functional materials for applications in optoelectronics and sensors. Light-matter interactions are of particular importance, and photocrystallography has proved to be an important tool for studying these interactions. In this technique, the three-dimensional structures of light-activated molecules, in their excited states, are determined using single-crystal X-ray crystallography. With advances in the design of high-power lasers, pulsed LEDs and time-gated X-ray detectors, the increased availability of synchrotron facilities, and most recently, the development of XFELs, it is now possible to determine the structures of molecules with lifetimes ranging from minutes down to picoseconds, within a single crystal, using the photocrystallographic technique. This review discusses the procedures for conducting successful photocrystallographic studies and outlines the different methodologies that have been developed to study structures with specific lifetime ranges. The complexity of the methods required increases considerably as the lifetime of the excited state shortens. The discussion is supported by examples of successful photocrystallographic studies across a range of timescales and emphasises the importance of the use of complementary analytical techniques in order to understand the solid-state processes fully.

Electronic structure of light-induced nitrosyl linkage isomers revealed by X-ray absorption spectroscopy at Ru L3,2-edges

X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) is a powerful tool for examining changes of the electronic and molecular structure following light-induced excitation of a molecule. Specifically, this method can be applied to investigate the ground (GS, RuNO) and metastable states (MS1, RuON and MS2, Ruη2(NO)) of the nitrosyl ligand (NO), which differ in their coordination mode to the metal. In this work, we report for the first time experimental and theoretical (DFT) Ru L3,2-edge XA spectra for the octahedral complex trans-[RuNOPy4F](ClO4)2 (1, Py = pyridine) in both ground and metastable states. The transition from GS to MS1 using 420 nm light excitation leads to a significant downshift of the 2p → LUMO(+1) peaks by about 0.5-0.8 eV, attributed to the destabilisation of 2p orbitals and stabilization of LUMO(+1). Subsequent irradiation of MS1 at 920 nm produces isomer MS2, for which even greater stabilization of LUMO occurs, though without a significant change in 2p energy. The change in 2p energy is attributed to a variation in the charge on the Ru atom after NO isomerization, while LUMO(+1) stabilization is related to changes in the Ru(NO) bond length and the composition of this orbital.

Pressure-induced single-crystal-to-single-crystal nitrite ligand isomerisation accompanied by a piezochromic effect

High-pressure structural study of a piezochromic crystal of a rare di-exo-nitrito nickel(II) complex supported by computational analysis is presented. The examined system is not photoswitchable, however, in the 0-6.2 GPa pressure range the crystal undergoes two phase-transitions accompanied by a colour change and the nitrite ligand isomerisation, which is unique.

Photoinitiated Single-Crystal to Single-Crystal Redox Transformations of Titanium-Oxo Clusters

Titanium-oxo clusters can undergo photochemical reactions under UV light, resulting in the reduction of the titanium-oxo core and oxidation of surface ligands. This is an important step in photocatalytic processes in light-absorbing Ti/O-based clusters, metal-organic frameworks, and (nano)material surfaces; however, studying the direct outcome of this photochemical process is challenging due to the fragility of the immediate photoproducts. In this report, titanium-oxo clusters [TiO(OiPr)(L)]n (n = 4, L = O2PPh2, or n = 6, L = O2CCH2tBu) undergo a two-electron photoredox reaction in the single-crystal state via an irreversible single-crystal to single-crystal (SC-SC) transformation initiated by a UV laser. The process is monitored by single crystal X-ray diffraction revealing the photoreduction of the cluster with coproduction of an (oxidized) acetone ligand, which is retained in the structure as a ligand to Ti(3+). The results demonstrate that photochemistry of inorganic molecules can be studied in the single crystal phase, allowing characterization of photoproducts which are unstable in the solution phase.

Photocrystallography of [Ru(bpy)2(dmso)2]2+ reveals an O-bonded metastable state

We report the first instance of observing the phototriggered isomerization of dmso ligands on a bis sulfoxide complex, [Ru(bpy)₂(dmso)₂], in the crystalline solid state. The solid-state UV-vis spectrum of the crystal demonstrates an increase in optical density around 550 nm after irradiation, which is consistent with the solution isomerization results. Digital images of the crystal before and after irradiation display a notable color change (pale orange to red) and cleavage occurs along planes, (1̄01) and (100), during irradiation. Single crystal X-ray diffraction data also confirms that isomerization is occurring throughout the lattice and a structure that contains a mix of the S,S and O,O/S,O isomer was attained from a crystal irradiated ex situ. In situ irradiation XRD studies reveal that the percentage of the O-bonded isomer increases as a function of 405 nm exposure time.

Molecular Design of a Metal-Nitrosyl Ferroelectric with Reversible Photoisomerization

The development of photo-responsive ferroelectrics whose polarization may be remotely controlled by optical means is of fundamental importance for basic research and technological applications. Herein, we report the design and synthesis of a new metal-nitrosyl ferroelectric crystal (DMA)(PIP)[Fe(CN)₅(NO)] (1) (DMA = dimethylammonium, PIP = piperidinium) with potential phototunable polarization via a dual-organic-cation molecular design strategy. Compared to the parent non-ferroelectric (MA)₂[Fe(CN)₅(NO)] (MA = methylammonium) material with a phase transition at 207 K, the introduction of larger dual organic cations both lowers the crystal symmetry affording robust ferroelectricity and increases the energy barrier of molecular motions, endowing 1 with a large polarization of up to 7.6 μC cm^-2 and a high Curie temperature (T_c) of 316 K. Infrared spectroscopy shows that the reversible photoisomerization of the nitrosyl ligand is accomplished by light irradiation. Specifically, the ground state with the N-bound nitrosyl ligand conformation can be reversibly switched to both the metastable state I (MSI) with isonitrosyl conformation and the metastable state II (MSII) with side-on nitrosyl conformation. Quantum chemistry calculations suggest that the photoisomerization significantly changes the dipole moment of the [Fe(CN)₅(NO)]^2- anion, thus leading to three ferroelectric states with different values of macroscopic polarization. Such optical accessibility and controllability of different ferroelectric states via photoinduced nitrosyl linkage isomerization open up a new and attractive route to optically controllable macroscopic polarization.

Photogeneration of Several Linkage Isomers and Investigation of Forward and Backward Nitro-Nitrito Isomerization Processes in a Palladium Complex

Photoinduced linkage isomers (PLIs) of the nitro-ligand were generated and comprehensively characterized in a square planar unit [Pd(NH₃)₃NO₂]⁺ of the complex salts [Pd(NH₃)₄][Pd(NH₃)₃NO₂][MOx₃]·yH₂O (M = Cr (Cr), Rh (Rh), Co (Co), Ox = oxalate). Structural (XRD) and spectroscopic (IR, UV-vis) investigations at 10 and 150 K allowed determining the structures of several photoinduced linkage isomers, endo-ONO (PLI1, 2) and exo-ONO (PLI3, 4) isomers generated by irradiation with 365 nm from the initial NO₂ (GS), along with the assignment of the infrared (IR) bands to each structural isomer. Based on a combination of these methods, the photo- and thermally induced interplay of PLIs was investigated. Irradiation in the temperature range of 10-80 K induces the formation of both endo- and exo-ONO isomers, while increasing the temperature up to 150 K results in the formation of only endo-ONO isomers. The structural arrangement of the endo-ONO and exo-ONO PLI is strongly influenced by intermolecular interactions due to the partial occupation of a neighboring site by water molecules. The investigation of thermal dynamics of PLIs revealed that the thermal decay of the exo-ONO isomer occurs via two steps exo-ONO → endo-ONO → NO₂. The kinetic parameters (E_a, k₀) of both decay processes were determined together with the characteristic decay temperatures (T_d) by IR spectroscopy. According to the photoinduced dynamics measured by IR spectroscopy, the mechanism of PLI formation in [Pd(NH₃)₃NO₂]⁺ could be described as NO₂ → endo-ONO → exo-ONO.

An optically reversible room-temperature solid-state cobalt(III) photoswitch based on nitro-to-nitrito linkage isomerism

A simple trinitro cobalt complex [Co(3,3'-diamino-N-methylpropanediamine)(NO₂)₃] was proven to be photoswitchable at room temperature as the Pca2₁ polymorph with the maximum nitro-to-nitrito conversion reaching ca. 55%. Solid-state IR, UV-vis and XRD indicate that the transformation can be triggered optically in both ways via 470 nm and 570-660 nm LED light, respectively.

The influence of trans-ligand to NO on the thermal stability of photoinduced side-bond coordinated linkage isomer

The influence of trans-to NO ligand (X) on the thermal stability of transient side-on coordinated nitrosyl linkage isomer (MS2) is investigated in a series of trans-[RuNOPy4X](PF6)2 (X = F- (RuF),...

Quasi-aromatic Möbius chelates of Cadmium(II) nitrite and/or nitrate

We report the design, structural, spectroscopic and computational characterizations of the two new quasi-aromatic Möbius chelate coordination compounds fabricated from Cd(NO3)2·4H2O and a bulky helical organic ligand derived from benzildihydrazone...

Intermediate snapshots of a 116-nuclear metallosupramolecular cage-of-cage in a homogeneous single-crystal-to-single-crystal transformation

Soaking crystals of an AuI72CdII40NaI4 cage-of-cage in aqueous Co(NO3)2 afforded an analogous AuI72CoII44 cage-of-cage, accompanied by the exchange of NaI and CdII by CoII with retention of the single crystallinity. The homogeneous progress of the transformation led to the direct observation of intermediate species by single-crystal X-ray crystallography.

Photocrystallographic and spectroscopic studies of a model (N,N,O)-donor square-planar nickel(II) nitro complex: in search of high-conversion and stable photoswitchable materials

A new, cheap, easy-to-synthesize and air-stable photoswitchable nickel(II) complex, QTNiNO2, is reported. The metal centre in QTNiNO2 is coordinated by a nitro group and a [2-methyl-8-amino-quinoline]-1-tetralone ligand. The compound crystallizes in the tetragonal space group I41/a with one complex molecule comprising the asymmetric unit, and the crystals are stable under ambient conditions. Irradiation of the solid-state form of QTNiNO2 with 530-660 nm LED light at 160 K converts the ambidentate nitro moiety fully to the nitrito linkage isomer which is stable up to around 230 K, as indicated by IR spectroscopy measurements. The structures of all species present in the examined crystals and their thermal stability were confirmed via X-ray multi-temperature and photocrystallographic experiments. The impact of temperature on the (photo)isomerization reaction taking place in a single crystal was additionally investigated. The experimental results are supported by computational analyses of crystal packing and intermolecular interactions that influence the isomerization process studied.

Contactless Spin Switch Sensing by Chemo-Electric Gating of Graphene

Direct electrical probing of molecular materials is often impaired by their insulating nature. Here, graphene is interfaced with single crystals of a molecular spin crossover complex, [Fe(bapbpy)(NCS)₂ ], to electrically detect phase transitions in the molecular crystal through the variation of graphene resistance. Contactless sensing is achieved by separating the crystal from graphene with an insulating polymer spacer. Next to mechanical effects, which influence the conductivity of the graphene sheet but can be minimized by using a thicker spacer, a Dirac point shift in graphene is observed experimentally upon spin crossover. As confirmed by computational modeling, this Dirac point shift is due to the phase-dependent electrostatic potential generated by the crystal inside the graphene sheet. This effect, named as chemo-electric gating, suggests that molecular materials may serve as substrates for designing graphene-based electronic devices. Chemo-electric gating, thus, opens up new possibilities to electrically probe chemical and physical processes in molecular materials in a contactless fashion, from a large distance, which can enhance their use in technological applications, for example, as sensors.

Photocrystallographic Studies on Transition Metal Nitrito Metastable Linkage Isomers: Manipulating the Metastable State

The design of solid-state materials whose properties and functions can be manipulated in a controlled manner by the application of light is an important objective in modern materials chemistry. When the material changes property or function, it is helpful if a simple measurable response, such as a change in color, can be detected. Potential applications for such materials are wide ranging, from data storage to smart windows. With the growing emphasis on solid-state materials that have two or more accessible energy states and which exhibit bistability, attention has turned to transition metal complexes that contain ambidentate ligands that can switch between linkage isomeric forms when activated by light. Suitable ligands that show promise in this area include nitrosyls, nitro groups, and coordinated sulfur dioxide molecules, each of which can coordinate to a metal center in more than one bonding mode. A nitrosyl normally coordinates through its N atom (η¹-NO) but when photoactivated can undergo isomerism and coordinate through its O atom (η¹-ON). At a molecular level, converting between these two configurations can act as an “on/off” switch. The analysis of such materials has been aided by the development of photocrystallographic techniques, which allow the full three-dimensional structure of a single crystal of a complex, under photoactivation, to be determined, when it is in either a metastable or short-lived excited state. The technique effectively brings the dimension of “time” to the crystallographic experiment and brings us closer to being able to watch solid-state processes occur in real time.

In this Account, we highlight the advances made in photocrystallography for studying solid-state, photoactivated linkage isomerism and describe the factors that favor the switching process and which allow complete switching between isomers. We demonstrate that control of temperature is key to achieving either a metastable state or an excited state with a specific lifetime. We draw our conclusions from published work on the formation of photoactivated metastable states for nitrosyl and sulfur dioxide complexes and from our own work on photoactivated switching between nitro and nitrito groups. We show that efficient switching between isomers is dependent on the wavelength of light used, on the temperature at which the experiment is carried out, on the flexibility of the crystal lattice, and on both the electronic and steric environment of the ambidentate ligand undergoing isomerism. We have designed and prepared a number of nitro/nitrito isomeric metal complexes that undergo reversible 100% conversion between the two forms at temperatures close to room temperature. Through our fine control over the generation of the metastable states, it should be possible to effectively “dial up” a suitable temperature to give a metastable or an excited state with a desired lifetime.

Enantiopure versus Racemic Mixture in Reversible, Two-Step, Single-Crystal-to-Single-Crystal Transformations of Copper(II) Complexes

The reaction of chiral sodium complexes, ¹_∞ [Na(S-valmetH)]⋅H₂ O (1-S) and ¹_∞ [Na(R-valmetH)]⋅H₂ O (1-R), with copper(II) acetate affords chiral one-dimensional coordination polymers with the formulas ¹_∞ [Cu(S-valmet)(H₂ O)]⋅H₂ O (2-S) and ¹_∞ [Cu(R-valmet)(H₂ O)]⋅H₂ O (2-R) (R/S-valmetH₂ are Schiff base proligands resulting from the condensation reactions between o-vanillin and R/S-methionine). The copper ions are connected by the carboxylato groups belonging to the amino-acid moieties, resulting in infinite chains showing syn-anti out-of-plane bridging mode. The circular dichroism spectra of 1-S, 1-R, 2-S, and 2-R confirm their enantiomeric nature. Compounds 2-S and 2-R undergo a two-step single-crystal-to-single-crystal transformation, with the elimination of the lattice and coordinated water molecules: ¹_∞ [Cu(S-valmet)(H₂ O)]⋅H₂ O (2-S)→¹_∞ [Cu(S-valmet)]⋅H₂ O (3-S⋅H₂ O)→¹_∞ [Cu(S-valmet)] (3-S) and ¹_∞ [Cu(R-valmet)(H₂ O)]⋅H₂ O (2-R)→¹_∞ [Cu(R-valmet)]⋅H₂ O (3-R⋅H₂ O)→¹_∞ [Cu(R-valmet)] (3-R), respectively. During these transformations, every pair of face-to-face chains present in 2-S (or 2-R) has been "zipped up" into a chiral double chain through the removal of the aqua ligands and their replacement by the carboxylato oxygen atoms from the neighboring chain. Consequently, each carboxylato group now bridges three copper ions. The conversion of the single chains, 2-S and 2-R, into the double chains, 3-S and 3-R, is accompanied by a change of the strength of the exchange interactions between the copper ions: weak antiferromagnetic couplings are observed in compound 2-S (J/k_B =-1.23(5) K, H=-2J ΣS_i S_i+1 ) and relatively strong in compound 3-S (J/k_B =-76.0(8) K). When the racemic mixture of the ligands, R,S-valmetH₂ , is employed, in the same experimental conditions, a racemic mixture of mononuclear compounds, [Cu(R,S-valmet)(H₂ O)₂ ]⋅H₂ O (4-RS), is obtained. Compound 4-RS also undergoes a SCSC transformation with the elimination of the lattice and one of the coordinated water molecules, resulting in a racemic mixture of chiral chains, ¹_∞ [Cu(R-valmet)(H₂ O)]⋅¹_∞ [Cu(S-valmet)(H₂ O)] (5-RS). In this compound, the coupling of the copper(II) ions within the chains is weak and ferromagnetic (J/k_B =+0.10(2) K). These results prove that the chirality of the valmetH₂ ligands (optically pure or racemic mixture) plays a key role in the self-assembly process of the copper(II) complexes.

The growing importance of crystalline molecular flasks and the crystalline sponge method

This article showcases recent advancements made using crystalline molecular flasks and the widening list of prospective applications for the crystalline sponge method. This expansion has coincided with an increasing number of materials termed crystalline sponges, and a report of a predictive means of identifying candidates from crystallographic databases. The crystalline sponge method's primary application has been determination of absolute configuration, and this has evolved from the analysis of carefully chosen planar aromatic guests to more diverse identification of natural products, biological metabolites, and analysis of volatile chemical components. However with time-resolved X-ray crystallography providing arguably the most informative atomic scale insights of dynamic chemical processes, this application of the crystalline sponge method may soon eclipse structural determination in terms of importance.

Photochemical reactions of metal complexes in the solid state

This perspective focusses on the solid-state reactivity and structural transformation driven by photochemical methods in discrete metal complexes, organometallic compounds, metallo-macrocycles and cages. Changes in the metal-metal bond distances, racemization of chiral centres, fusion of cages, formation of coordination polymers, expected [2 + 2] and [4 + 4] cycloaddition products, unusual phenyl-olefin dimerization, and linkage isomerization of -SO₂, -NO & -NO₂ ligands cause the structural transformations. Of these, [2 + 2] photo-cycloaddition reactions have been widely studied and the photoreactions are made possible by various supramolecular interactions including hydrogen bonds, metallophilic, ππ and C-Hπ interactions, ligand design and metallic clips to bring the reactive functional groups closely into correct orientation close to the transition state. These photoreactions are often accompanied by crystal bending, mechanical motion, and changes in the magnetic and photoluminescence properties. In several cases, the single crystals have been preserved at the end of the reactions, which are known as single-crystal-to-single-crystal (SCSC) reactions.