Chemical Morphing of DNA Containing Four Noncanonical Bases

Conformational Morphing by a DNA Analogue Featuring 7-Deazapurines and 5-Halogenpyrimidines and the Origins of Adenine-Tract Geometry

Several efforts are currently directed at the creation and cellular implementation of alternative genetic systems composed of pairing components that are orthogonal to the natural dA/dT and dG/dC base pairs. In an alternative approach, Watson-Crick-type pairing is conserved, but one or all of the four letters of the A, C, G, and T alphabet are substituted by modified components. Thus, all four nucleobases were altered to create halogenated deazanucleic acid (DZA): dA was replaced by 7-deaza-2'-deoxyadenosine (dzA), dG by 7-deaza-2'-deoxyguanosine (dzG), dC by 5-fluoro-2'-deoxycytidine (FdC), and dT by 5-chloro-2'-deoxyuridine (CldU). This base-pairing system was previously shown to retain function in Escherichia coli. Here, we analyze the stability, hydration, structure, and dynamics of a DZA Dickerson-Drew Dodecamer (DDD) of sequence 5'-FdC-dzG-FdC-dzG-dzA-dzA-CldU-CldU-FdC-dzG-FdC-dzG-3'. Contrary to similar stabilities of DDD and DZA-DDD, osmotic stressing revealed a dramatic loss of hydration for the DZA-DDD relative to that for the DDD. The parent DDD 5'-d(CGCGAATTCGCG)-3' features an A-tract, a run of adenosines uninterrupted by a TpA step, and exhibits a hallmark narrow minor groove. Crystal structures─in the presence of RNase H─and MD simulations show increased conformational plasticity ("morphing") of DZA-DDD relative to that of the DDD. The narrow dzA-tract minor groove in one structure widens to resemble that in canonical B-DNA in a second structure. These changes reflect an indirect consequence of altered DZA major groove electrostatics (less negatively polarized compared to that in DNA) and hydration (reduced compared to that in DNA). Therefore, chemical modifications outside the minor groove that lead to collapse of major groove electrostatics and hydration can modulate A-tract geometry.

CRISPR-Cas9 recognition of enzymatically synthesized base-modified nucleic acids

An enzymatic method has been successfully established enabling the generation of partially base-modified RNA (previously named RZA) constructs, in which all G residues were replaced by isomorphic fluorescent thienoguanosine (thG) analogs, as well as fully modified RZA featuring thG, 5-bromocytosine, 7-deazaadenine and 5-chlorouracil. The transcriptional efficiency of emissive fully modified RZA was found to benefit from the use of various T7 RNA polymerase variants. Moreover, dthG could be incorporated into PCR products by Taq DNA polymerase together with the other three base-modified nucleotides. Notably, the obtained RNA products containing thG as well as thG together with 5-bromocytosine could function as effectively as natural sgRNAs in an in vitro CRISPR-Cas9 cleavage assay. N1-Methylpseudouridine was also demonstrated to be a faithful non-canonical substitute of uridine to direct Cas9 nuclease cleavage when incorporated in sgRNA. The Cas9 inactivation by 7-deazapurines indicated the importance of the 7-nitrogen atom of purines in both sgRNA and PAM site for achieving efficient Cas9 cleavage. Additional aspects of this study are discussed in relation to the significance of sgRNA-protein and PAM--protein interactions that were not highlighted by the Cas9-sgRNA-DNA complex crystal structure. These findings could expand the impact and therapeutic value of CRISPR-Cas9 and other RNA-based technologies.

From polymerase engineering to semi-synthetic life: artificial expansion of the central dogma

Nucleic acids have been extensively modified in different moieties to expand the scope of genetic materials in the past few decades. While the development of unnatural base pairs (UBPs) has expanded the genetic information capacity of nucleic acids, the production of synthetic alternatives of DNA and RNA has increased the types of genetic information carriers and introduced novel properties and functionalities into nucleic acids. Moreover, the efforts of tailoring DNA polymerases (DNAPs) and RNA polymerases (RNAPs) to be efficient unnatural nucleic acid polymerases have enabled broad application of these unnatural nucleic acids, ranging from production of stable aptamers to evolution of novel catalysts. The introduction of unnatural nucleic acids into living organisms has also started expanding the central dogma in vivo. In this article, we first summarize the development of unnatural nucleic acids with modifications or alterations in different moieties. The strategies for engineering DNAPs and RNAPs are then extensively reviewed, followed by summarization of predominant polymerase mutants with good activities for synthesizing, reverse transcribing, or even amplifying unnatural nucleic acids. Some recent application examples of unnatural nucleic acids with their polymerases are then introduced. At the end, the approaches of introducing UBPs and synthetic genetic polymers into living organisms for the creation of semi-synthetic organisms are reviewed and discussed.

Traceless enzymatic synthesis of monodispersed hypermodified oligodeoxyribonucleotide polymers from RNA templates

We have developed a new alternative for enzymatic synthesis of single-stranded hypermodified oligodeoxyribonucleotides displaying four different hydrophobic groups based on reverse transcription from RNA templates catalyzed by DNA polymerases using a set of base-modified dNTPs followed by digestion of RNA by RNases. Using mixed oligodeoxyribonucleotide primers containing a ribonucleotide at the 3'-end, RNase AT1 simultaneously digested the template and cleaved off the primer to release a fully modified oligonucleotide that can be further 3'-labelled with a fluorescent nucleotide using TdT. The resulting hypermodified oligonucleotides could find applications in selection of aptamers or other functional macromolecules.

In vivo assembly and expression of DNA containing non-canonical bases in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Chemically modified nucleic acids are of utmost interest in synthetic biology to create a regulable and sophisticated synthetic system with tailor-made properties. Implanting chemically modified nucleic acids in microorganisms might serve biotechnological applications, while using them in human cells might lead to new advanced medicines. Previously, we reported that a fully modified DNA sequence (called DZA) composed of the four base-modified nucleotides - 7-deaza-adenine, 5-chlorouracil, 7-deaza-guanine and 5-fluorocytosine - could function as a genetic template in prokaryotic cells, Escherichia coli . Here, we report the synthesis of long, partially or fully modified DZA fragments that encode the yeast-enhanced red fluorescence protein (yEmRFP). The DZA sequences were directly introduced in the genome of the eukaryotic cells, Saccharomyces cerevisiae , via the yeast natural homologous recombination. The simple and straightforward DZA cloning strategy reported herein might be of interest to scientists working in the field of xenobiology in yeast.

In Vivo Expression of Genetic Information from Phosphoramidate-DNA

Chemically modified genes and genomes with customized properties will become a valuable tool in numerous fields, including synthetic biology, biotechnology, and medicine. These genetic materials are meant to store and exchange information with DNA and RNA while tuning their functionality. Herein, we outline the development of an alternative genetic system carrying phosphoramidate linkages that successfully propagates genetic information in bacteria and at the same time is labile to acidic conditions. The P3'→N5' phosphoramidate-containing DNA (PN-DNA) was enzymatically synthesized by using 5'-amino-2',5'-deoxycytidine 5'-N-triphosphates (NH-dCTPs) as substrates for DNA polymerases and employed to encode antibiotic resistance in Escherichia coli. The resulting PN-DNA can be efficiently destroyed by mild acidic conditions, whereas an unmodified counterpart remains intact. A cloning strategy was proposed for assembling modified fragments into a genome. This method can be of interest to scientists working in the field of orthogonal nucleic acid genes and genomes.

Recent progress in non-native nucleic acid modifications

While Nature harnesses RNA and DNA to store, read and write genetic information, the inherent programmability, synthetic accessibility and wide functionality of these nucleic acids make them attractive tools for use in a vast array of applications.

The Network of Replication, Transcription, and Reverse Transcription of a Synthetic Genetic Cassette

Synthetic nucleic acids, with four non-canonical nucleobases, can function as genetic materials. A comprehensive analysis of PCR amplification, transcription, reverse transcription, and cloning was done to screen for alternative genetic monomers. A small library of six modified nucleobases was selected: the modified 2'-deoxyribonucleoside (dZTPs) and ribonucleoside (rZTPs) triphosphates of 7-deaza-adenine, 5-chlorouracil, 7-deaza-guanine or inosine together with 5-fluorocytosine or 5-bromocytosine. The fragments composed of one to four modified nucleotides (denoted as DZA) have been successfully recognized and transcribed to natural or modified RNA (denoted as RZA) by T7 RNA polymerase. The fully modified RZA fragment could be reverse transcribed and then amplified in the presence of various dZTPs. Noticeably, modified fragments could function as genetic templates in vivo by encoding the 678 base pair gene of a fluorescent protein in bacteria. These results demonstrate the existence of a fully simulated genetic circuit that uses synthetic materials.

Enzymatic synthesis of hypermodified DNA polymers for sequence-specific display of four different hydrophobic groups

A set of modified 2′-deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates (dNTPs) bearing a linear or branched alkane, indole or phenyl group linked through ethynyl or alkyl spacer were synthesized and used as substrates for polymerase synthesis of hypermodified DNA by primer extension (PEX). Using the alkyl-linked dNTPs, the polymerase synthesized up to 22-mer fully modified oligonucleotide (ON), whereas using the ethynyl-linked dNTPs, the enzyme was able to synthesize even long sequences of >100 modified nucleotides in a row. In PCR, the combinations of all four modified dNTPs showed only linear amplification. Asymmetric PCR or PEX with separation or digestion of the template strand can be used for synthesis of hypermodified single-stranded ONs, which are monodispersed polymers displaying four different substituents on DNA backbone in sequence-specific manner. The fully modified ONs hybridized with complementary strands and modified DNA duplexes were found to exist in B-type conformation (B- or C-DNA) according to CD spectral analysis. The modified DNA can be replicated with high fidelity to natural DNA through PCR and sequenced. Therefore, this approach has a promising potential in generation and selection of hypermodified aptamers and other functional polymers.

Modified nucleoside triphosphates in bacterial research for in vitro and live-cell applications

Modified nucleoside triphosphates (NTPs) are invaluable tools to probe bacterial enzymatic mechanisms, develop novel genetic material, and engineer drugs and proteins with new functionalities. Although the impact of nucleobase alterations has predominantly been studied due to their importance for protein recognition, sugar and phosphate modifications have also been investigated. However, NTPs are cell impermeable due to their negatively charged phosphate tail, a major hurdle to achieving live bacterial studies. Herein, we review the recent advances made to investigate and evolve bacteria and their processes with the use of modified NTPs by exploring alterations in one of the three moieties: the nucleobase, the sugar and the phosphate tail. We also present the innovative methods that have been devised to internalize NTPs into bacteria for in vivo applications.

Gene Expression of 4'-Thioguanine DNA via 4'-Thiocytosine RNA

DNA and RNA nucleotides are ubiquitous molecules that store and transmit genetic information. The emergence of synthetic elements that fulfill the function of DNA and RNA provides an alternative gene expression system. Herein, we demonstrate the gene expression of 4'-thioguanine DNA (d^SG DNA) via 4'-thiocytosine RNA (d^SC RNA) to give green fluorescent protein (GFPuv) in a single test tube. In replication, transcription, and translation, DNA/RNA polymerases and Escherichia coli (E. coli) ribosome can tolerate the replacement of O4' with S4' in the nucleotide, despite the fact that sulfur has a larger atomic radius than oxygen. Additionally, d^SG DNA and d^SC RNA acted as alternative genetic polymers to natural DNA and RNA for protein synthesis in artificial cells comprising a reconstituted E. coli gene expression machinery. This work involved simple experiments that are widely used in molecular biology, but which underscore the feasibility of life control by substances other than DNA/RNA nucleotides.

Modified nucleic acids: replication, evolution, and next-generation therapeutics

Modified nucleic acids, also called xeno nucleic acids (XNAs), offer a variety of advantages for biotechnological applications and address some of the limitations of first-generation nucleic acid therapeutics. Indeed, several therapeutics based on modified nucleic acids have recently been approved and many more are under clinical evaluation. XNAs can provide increased biostability and furthermore are now increasingly amenable to in vitro evolution, accelerating lead discovery. Here, we review the most recent discoveries in this dynamic field with a focus on progress in the enzymatic replication and functional exploration of XNAs.

Synthetic Life with Alternative Nucleic Acids as Genetic Materials

DNA, the fundamental genetic polymer of all living organisms on Earth, can be chemically modified to embrace novel functions that do not exist in nature. The key chemical and structural parameters for genetic information storage, heredity, and evolution have been elucidated, and many xenobiotic nucleic acids (XNAs) with non-canonical structures are developed as alternative genetic materials in vitro. However, it is still particularly challenging to replace DNAs with XNAs in living cells. This review outlines some recent studies in which the storage and propagation of genetic information are achieved in vivo by expanding genetic systems with XNAs.

Reprint of: Non Canonical Genetic Material

To increase the scope of natural biosystem, nucleic acids have been intensively modified. One direction includes the development of a synthetic alternative to the native DNA and RNA, denoted Xenobiotic nucleic acids (XNAs) that are able to store and transfer genetic information either by base-modification or backbone-modification. Another line of research aims to develop alternative third base pair additional to natural A:T and G:C. These unnatural base pairs (UBPs) can store increased information content encoded in three base pairs. This review outlines the recent progress made towards XNA and UBP applications as new components of the genomic DNA as well as biostable aptamers. New achievements in the replacement of a bacterial genome by unnatural non-canonical nucleotides are also described.

Nucleic acid enzymes based on functionalized nucleosides

Nucleic acid-based enzymes have recently joined their proteinaceous counterparts as important biocatalysts. While RNA enzymes (ribozymes) are found in nature, deoxyribozymes or DNAzymes are man-made entities. Numerous ribozymes and DNAzymes have been identified by Darwinian selection methods to catalyze a broad array of chemical transformations. Despite these important advances, practical applications involving nucleic acid enzymes are often plagued by relatively poor pharmacokinetic properties and cellular uptake, rapid degradation by nucleases and/or by the limited chemical arsenal carried by natural DNA and RNA. In this review, the two main chemical approaches for the modification of nucleic acid-based catalysts, particularly DNAzymes, are described. These methods aim at improving the functional properties of nucleic acid enzymes by mitigating some of these shortcomings. In this context, recent developments in the post-SELEX processing of existing nucleic acid catalysts as well as efforts for the selection of DNAzymes and ribozymes with modified nucleoside triphosphates are summarized.

Invading Escherichia coli Genetics with a Xenobiotic Nucleic Acid Carrying an Acyclic Phosphonate Backbone (ZNA)

A synthetic orthogonal polymer embracing a chiral acyclic-phosphonate backbone [(S)-ZNA] is presented that uniquely adds to the emerging family of xenobiotic nucleic acids (XNAs). (S)-ZNA consists of reiterating six-atom structural units and can be accessed in few synthetic steps from readily available phophonomethylglycerol nucleoside (PMGN) precursors. Comparative thermal stability experiments conducted on homo- and heteroduplexes made of (S)-ZNA are described that evince its high self-hybridization efficiency in contrast to poor binding of natural complements. Although preliminary and not conclusive, circular dichroism data and dynamic modeling computations provide support to a left-handed geometry of double-stranded (S)-ZNA. Nonetheless, PMGN diphosphate monomers were recognized as substrates by Escherichia coli (E. coli) polymerase I as well as being imported into E. coli cells equipped with an algal nucleotide transporter. A further investigation into the in vivo propagation of (S)-ZNA culminated with the demonstration of the first synthetic nucleic acid with an acyclic backbone that can be transliterated to DNA by the E. coli cellular machinery.

Highly Conductive Nucleotide Analogue Facilitates Base-Calling in Quantum-Tunneling-Based DNA Sequencing

Quantum-tunneling-based DNA sequencing is a single molecular technology that has great potential for achieving facile and high-throughput DNA sequencing. In principle, the sequence of DNA could be read out by the time trace of the tunnel current that can be changed according to molecular conductance of nucleobases passing through nanosized gap electrodes. However, efficient base-calling of four genetic alphabets has been seriously impeded due to the similarity of molecular conductance among canonical nucleotides. In this article, we demonstrate that replacement of canonical 2'-deoxyadenosine (dA) with a highly conductive dA analogue, 7-deaza dA, could expand the difference of molecular conductance between four genetic alphabets. Additionally, systematic evaluation of molecular conductance using a series of dA and dG analogues revealed that molecular conductance of the nucleotide is highly dependent on the HOMO level. Thus, the present study demonstrating that signal characteristics of the nucleotide can be modulated based on the HOMO level provides a widely applicable chemical approach and insight for facilitation of single molecular sensing as well as DNA sequencing based on quantum tunneling.

PCR Amplification of Base-Modified DNA

An efficient PCR amplification of various templates (short 57-mer, random 67- and 82-mer, and long DNA) with base-modified nucleoside triphosphates is presented here. Using 5-substituted pyrimidine and 7-substituted-7-deaza- or 8-substituted purine nucleoside triphosphates as substrates for thermostable DNA polymerases [Taq and Vent (exo^- )], successful PCR amplification of partially or entirely modified DNA libraries and long DNA constructs (up to 1.5 kb) is achieved. Visualization of double-stranded PCR product formation is improved through the use of primers with different fluorescent labels. This allows one to monitor the efficiency of modified substrate incorporation and the enzymatic recognition of the modified template during PCR. The redesigned fully base-modified DNA (denoted 'DZA') can be utilized for the straightforward production of diverse libraries for in vitro selection of aptamer and catalytic nucleic acids as well as for the synthesis of artificial genetic templates, replicons, or complex vectors. © 2018 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Non canonical genetic material

To increase the scope of natural biosystem, nucleic acids have been intensively modified. One direction includes the development of a synthetic alternative to the native DNA and RNA, denoted Xenobiotic nucleic acids (XNAs) that are able to store and transfer genetic information either by base-modification or backbone-modification. Another line of research aims to develop alternative third base pair additional to natural A:T and G:C. These unnatural base pairs (UBPs) can store increased information content encoded in three base pairs. This review outlines the recent progress made towards XNA and UBP applications as new components of the genomic DNA as well as biostable aptamers. New achievements in the replacement of a bacterial genome by unnatural non-canonical nucleotides are also described.

Self-Priming Enzymatic Fabrication of Multiply Modified DNA

The self-priming synthesis of multiply modified DNA by the extension of repeating unit duplex "oligoseeds" provides a source of versatile DNA. Sterically-demanding nucleotides 5-Br-dUTP, 7-deaza-7-I-dATP, 6-S-dGTP, 5-I-dCTP as well as 5-(octadiynyl)-dCTP were incorporated into two extending oligoseeds; [GATC]₅ /[GATC]₅ and [A₄ G]₄ /[CT₄ ]₄ . The products contained modifications on one or both strands of DNA, demonstrating their recognition by the polymerase as both template (reading) and substrate (writing). Nucleobase modifications that lie in the major groove were reliably read and written by the polymerase during the extension reaction, even when bulky or in contiguous sequences. Repeat sequence DNA over 500 bp long, bearing four different modified units was produced by this method. The number, position and type of modification, as well as the overall length of the DNA can be controlled to yield designer DNA that offers sequence-determined sites for further chemical adaptations, targeted small molecule binding studies, or sensing and sequencing applications.

Glycosylation of Pyrrolo[2,3- d]pyrimidines with 1- O-Acetyl-2,3,5-tri- O-benzoyl-β-d-ribofuranose: Substituents and Protecting Groups Effecting the Synthesis of 7-Deazapurine Ribonucleosides

Glycosylation of nonfunctionalized 6-chloro-7-deazapurine with commercially available 1- O-acetyl-2,3,5-tri- O-benzoyl-β-d-ribofuranose (45%) followed by amination and deprotection gave tubercidin in only two steps. Similar conditions applied for the synthesis of 7-deazaguanosine employing pivaloylated 2-amino-6-chloro-7-deazapurine gave 18% glycosylation yield. The less bulky isobutyryl or acetyl protected amino group directed the glycosylation toward the exocyclic amino substituent. 7-Halogenated intermediates were glycosylated followed by dehalogenation to overcome the low glycosylation yield in the synthesis of 7-deazaguanosine.

Modulation of BACE1 Activity by Chemically Modified Aptamers

A modified DNA aptamer that binds BACE1, a therapeutic target involved in Alzheimer's disease has been developed. This ssXNA not only tightly binds to BACE1 but also inhibits its protease activity in vitro in the same range as a previously described unmodified aptamer. We report the in vitro selection of functional oligonucleotides incorporating two nucleobase modifications: 5-chlorouracil and 7-deazaadenine. The nucleoside analogue 5-chloro-2'-deoxyuridine has already been explored as a replacement for thymidine in a chemically modified genome of a bacterium. Thus, 5-chlorouracil modification is a good candidate to support genetic transfer in vivo as well as functional activity.

Nucleic Acid Aptamers: Emerging Applications in Medical Imaging, Nanotechnology, Neurosciences, and Drug Delivery

Recent progresses in organic chemistry and molecular biology have allowed the emergence of numerous new applications of nucleic acids that markedly deviate from their natural functions. Particularly, DNA and RNA molecules-coined aptamers-can be brought to bind to specific targets with high affinity and selectivity. While aptamers are mainly applied as biosensors, diagnostic agents, tools in proteomics and biotechnology, and as targeted therapeutics, these chemical antibodies slowly begin to be used in other fields. Herein, we review recent progress on the use of aptamers in the construction of smart DNA origami objects and MRI and PET imaging agents. We also describe advances in the use of aptamers in the field of neurosciences (with a particular emphasis on the treatment of neurodegenerative diseases) and as drug delivery systems. Lastly, the use of chemical modifications, modified nucleoside triphosphate particularly, to enhance the binding and stability of aptamers is highlighted.

Enzymatic Synthesis, Amplification, and Application of DNA with a Functionalized Backbone

The ability to amplify DNA along with its unprecedented sequence control has led to its use for different applications, but all are limited by the properties available to natural nucleotides. We previously reported the evolution of polymerase SFM4-3, which better tolerates 2'-modified substrates. To explore the utility of SFM4-3, we now report the characterization of its recognition of substrates with 2'-azido, 2'-chloro, 2'-amino, or arabinose sugars. We find that SFM4-3 can efficiently synthesize polymers composed of these nucleotides, and most interestingly, that SFM4-3 can also PCR amplify these modified oligonucleotides. When combined with post-amplification modification, the latter allows for the exponential amplification of polymers that may be functionalized with desired moieties arrayed in a controlled fashion, the utility of which we demonstrate with extensive small molecule functionalization and the production and initial characterization of a novel DNA hydrogel.

Base-Modified Nucleic Acids as a Powerful Tool for Synthetic Biology and Biotechnology

The ability of various nucleoside triphosphate analogues of deoxyguanosine and deoxycytidine with 7-deazadeoxyadenosine (A₁ ) and 5-chlorodeoxyuridine (T₁ ) to serve as substrates for Taq DNA polymerase was evaluated. The triphosphate set composed of A₁ , T₁ , and 7-deazadeoxyguanosine with either 5-methyldeoxycytidine or 5-fluorodeoxycytidine was successfully employed in the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of 1.5 kb fragments as well as random oligonucleotide libraries. Another effective combination of triphosphates for the synthesis of a 1 kb PCR product was A₁ , T₁ , deoxyinosine, and 5-bromodeoxycytidine. In vivo experiments using an antibiotic-resistant gene containing the latter set demonstrated that the bacterial machinery accepts fully modified sequences as genetic templates. Moreover, the ability of the base-modified segments to selectively protect DNA from cleavage by restriction endonucleases was shown. This approach can be used to regulate the endonuclease cleavage pattern.

New synthetic route to ethynyl-dUTP: A means to avoid formation of acetyl and chloro vinyl base-modified triphosphates that could poison SELEX experiments

5-Ethynyl-2'-deoxyuridine is a common base-modified nucleoside analogue that has served in various applications including selection experiments for potent aptamers and in biosensing. The synthesis of the corresponding triphosphates involves a mild acidic deprotection step. Herein, we show that this deprotection leads to the formation of other nucleoside analogs which are easily converted to triphosphates. The modified nucleoside triphosphates are excellent substrates for numerous DNA polymerases under both primer extension and PCR conditions and could thus poison selection experiments by blocking sites that need to be further modified. The formation of these nucleoside analogs can be circumvented by application of a new synthetic route that is described herein.

The 5-chlorouracil:7-deazaadenine base pair as an alternative to the dT:dA base pair

The 5-Cl-dU:7-deaza-dA base pair can be a substitute for the dT:dA base pair in an enzymatic replication process of 2 kb DNA.

Unknown unknowns: essential genes in quest for function

The experimental design of a minimal synthetic genome revealed the presence of a large number of genes without ascribed function, in part because the abstract laws of life must be implemented within ad hoc material contraptions. Creating a function needs recruitment of some pre‐existing structure and this reveals kludges in their set‐up and history. Here, we show that looking for functions as an engineer would help in discovery of a significant number of those, proposed together with conceptual handles allowing investigators to pursue this endeavour in other contexts.