Theoretical Optimization of Compositions of High-Entropy Oxides for the Oxygen Evolution Reaction

A Density Functional Theory Analysis of Electrochemical Oxidation of Methane to Alcohol over High-Entropy Oxide (CoCrFeMnNi)3O4 Catalysts

The direct conversion of methane into alcohol is a promising approach for achieving a low-carbon future, yet it remains a major challenge. In this study, we utilize density functional theory to explore the potential of the (CoCrFeMnNi)3O4 (CCFMNO) high entropy oxide (HEO) for electrochemical oxidation of methane to methanol and ethanol, alongside their competition with CO2 production. Our primary focus in this study is on thermodynamics, enabling a prompt analysis of the catalyst's potential, with the calculation of electrochemical barriers falling beyond our scope. Among all potential active sites within CCFMNO HEO, we identify Co as the most active site for methane activation when using carbonate ions as oxidants. This results in methanol production with a limiting potential of 1.4 VCHE, and ethanol and CO2 productions with a limiting potential of 1.2 VCHE. Additionally, our findings suggest that the occupied p-band center of O* on CCFMNO HEO is a potential descriptor for identifying the most active site within CCFMNO HEO. Overall, our results indicate that CCFMNO HEO holds promise as catalysts for methane oxidation to alcohols, employing carbonate ions as oxidants.

Supervised AI and Deep Neural Networks to Evaluate High-Entropy Alloys as Reduction Catalysts in Aqueous Environments

Competitive surface adsorption energies on catalytic surfaces constitute a fundamental aspect of modeling electrochemical reactions in aqueous environments. The conventional approach to this task relies on applying density functional theory, albeit with computationally intensive demands, particularly when dealing with intricate surfaces. In this study, we present a methodological exposition of quantifying competitive relationships within complex systems. Our methodology leverages quantum-mechanical-guided deep neural networks, deployed in the investigation of quinary high-entropy alloys composed of Mo-Cr-Mn-Fe-Co-Ni-Cu-Zn. These alloys are under examination as prospective electrocatalysts, facilitating the electrochemical synthesis of ammonia in aqueous media. Even in the most favorable scenario for nitrogen fixation identified in this study, at the transition from O and OH coverage to surface hydrogenation, the probability of N2 coverage remains low. This underscores the fact that catalyst optimization alone is insufficient for achieving efficient nitrogen reduction. In particular, these insights illuminate that system consideration with oxygen- and hydrogen-repelling approaches or high-pressure solutions would be necessary for improved nitrogen reduction within an aqueous environment.

The Promising Seesaw Relationship Between Activity and Stability of Ru-Based Electrocatalysts for Acid Oxygen Evolution and Proton Exchange Membrane Water Electrolysis

The development of electrocatalysts that are not reliant on iridium for efficient acid-oxygen evolution is a critical step towards the proton exchange membrane water electrolysis (PEMWE) and green hydrogen industry. Ruthenium-based electrocatalysts have garnered widespread attention due to their remarkable catalytic activity and lower commercial price. However, the challenge lies in balancing the seesaw relationship between activity and stability of these electrocatalysts during the acid-oxygen evolution reaction (OER). This review delves into the progress made in Ru-based electrocatalysts with regards to acid OER and PEMWE applications. It highlights the significance of customizing the acidic OER mechanism of Ru-based electrocatalysts through the coordination of adsorption evolution mechanism (AEM) and lattice oxygen oxidation mechanism (LOM) to attain the ideal activity and stability relationship. The promising tradeoffs between the activity and stability of different Ru-based electrocatalysts, including Ru metals and alloys, Ru single-atomic materials, Ru oxides, and derived complexes, and Ru-based heterojunctions, as well as their applicability to PEMWE systems, are discussed in detail. Furthermore, this paper offers insights on in situ control of Ru active sites, dynamic catalytic mechanism, and commercial application of PEMWE. Based on three-way relationship between cost, activity, and stability, the perspectives and development are provided.

Recent progress of Ni-based nanomaterials for the electrocatalytic oxygen evolution reaction at large current density

The precise design and development of high-performing oxygen evolution reaction (OER) for the production of industrial hydrogen gas through water electrolysis has been a widely studied topic. A profound understanding of the nature of electrocatalytic processes reveals that Ni-based catalysts are highly active toward OER that can stably operate at a high current density for a long period of time. Given the current gap between research and applications in industrial water electrolysis, we have completed a systematic review by constructively discussing the recent progress of Ni-based catalysts for electrocatalytic OER at a large current density, with special focus on the morphology and composition regulation of Ni-based electrocatalysts for achieving extraordinary OER performance. This review will facilitate future research toward rationally designing next-generation OER electrocatalysts that can meet industrial demands, thereby promoting new sustainable solutions for energy shortage and environment issues.

High-entropy alloys in electrocatalysis: from fundamentals to applications

High-entropy alloys (HEAs) comprising five or more elements in near-equiatomic proportions have attracted ever increasing attention for their distinctive properties, such as exceptional strength, corrosion resistance, high hardness, and excellent ductility. The presence of multiple adjacent elements in HEAs provides unique opportunities for novel and adaptable active sites. By carefully selecting the element configuration and composition, these active sites can be optimized for specific purposes. Recently, HEAs have been shown to exhibit remarkable performance in electrocatalytic reactions. Further activity improvement of HEAs is necessary to determine their active sites, investigate the interactions between constituent elements, and understand the reaction mechanisms. Accordingly, a comprehensive review is imperative to capture the advancements in this burgeoning field. In this review, we provide a detailed account of the recent advances in synthetic methods, design principles, and characterization technologies for HEA-based electrocatalysts. Moreover, we discuss the diverse applications of HEAs in electrocatalytic energy conversion reactions, including the hydrogen evolution reaction, hydrogen oxidation reaction, oxygen reduction reaction, oxygen evolution reaction, carbon dioxide reduction reaction, nitrogen reduction reaction, and alcohol oxidation reaction. By comprehensively covering these topics, we aim to elucidate the intricacies of active sites, constituent element interactions, and reaction mechanisms associated with HEAs. Finally, we underscore the imminent challenges and emphasize the significance of both experimental and theoretical perspectives, as well as the potential applications of HEAs in catalysis. We anticipate that this review will encourage further exploration and development of HEAs in electrochemistry-related applications.

Low-Dimensional High-Entropy Alloys for Advanced Electrocatalytic Reactions

Low-dimensional high-entropy alloy (HEA) nanomaterials are widely employed as electrocatalysts for energy conversion reactions, due to their inherent advantages, including high electron mobility, rich catalytically active site, optimal electronic structure. Moreover, the high-entropy, lattice distortion, and sluggish diffusion effects also enable them to be promising electrocatalysts. A thorough understanding on the structure-activity relationships of low-dimensional HEA catalyst play a huge role in the future pursuit of more efficient electrocatalysts. In this review, we summarize the recent progress of low-dimensional HEA nanomaterials for efficient catalytic energy conversion. By systematically discussing the fundamentals of HEA and properties of low-dimensional nanostructures, we highlight the advantages of low-dimensional HEAs. Subsequently, we also present many low-dimensional HEA catalysts for electrocatalytic reactions, aiming to gain a better understanding on the structure-activity relationship. Finally, a series of upcoming challenges and issues are also thoroughly proposed as well as their future directions.

A Flexible Theory for Catalysis: Learning Alkaline Oxygen Reduction on Complex Solid Solutions within the Ag-Pd-Pt-Ru Composition Space

Compositionally complex materials such as high-entropy alloys and oxides have the potential to be efficient platforms for catalyst discovery because of the vast chemical space spanned by these novel materials. Identifying the composition of the most active catalyst materials, however, requires unraveling the descriptor-activity relationship, as experimentally screening the multitude of possible element ratios quickly becomes a daunting task. In this work, we show that inferred adsorption energy distributions of *OH and *O on complex solid solution surfaces within the space spanned by the system Ag-Pd-Pt-Ru are coupled to the experimentally observed electrocatalytic performance for the oxygen reduction reaction. In total, the catalytic activity of 1582 alloy compositions is predicted with a cross-validated mean absolute error of 0.042 mA/cm2 by applying a theory-derived model with only two adjustable parameters. Trends in the discrepancies between predicted electrochemical performance values of the model and the measured values on thin film surfaces subsequently provide insight into the alloys' surface compositions during reaction conditions. Bridging this gap between computationally modeled and experimentally observed catalytic activities, not only reveals insight into the underlying theory of catalysis but also takes a step closer to realizing exploration and exploitation of high-entropy materials.

Synergistic effects of mixing and strain in high entropy spinel oxides for oxygen evolution reaction

Developing stable and efficient electrocatalysts is vital for boosting oxygen evolution reaction (OER) rates in sustainable hydrogen production. High-entropy oxides (HEOs) consist of five or more metal cations, providing opportunities to tune their catalytic properties toward high OER efficiency. This work combines theoretical and experimental studies to scrutinize the OER activity and stability for spinel-type HEOs. Density functional theory confirms that randomly mixed metal sites show thermodynamic stability, with intermediate adsorption energies displaying wider distributions due to mixing-induced equatorial strain in active metal-oxygen bonds. The rapid sol-flame method is employed to synthesize HEO, comprising five 3d-transition metal cations, which exhibits superior OER activity and durability under alkaline conditions, outperforming lower-entropy oxides, even with partial surface oxidations. The study highlights that the enhanced activity of HEO is primarily attributed to the mixing of multiple elements, leading to strain effects near the active site, as well as surface composition and coverage.

High-Entropy Layered Double Hydroxides with Highly Adjustable Components for Enhancing Electrocatalytic Oxygen Evolution

The main obstacle to the development of large-scale electrochemical hydrogen production based on water splitting is the slow four-electron kinetics of OER (oxygen evolution reaction). The most efficient method is to create sophisticated and effective OER catalysts. Here, we proposed the controlled synthesis of high-entropy layered double hydroxides (HELDH) for wide component regulation and the component design of high OER activity to make up for the restricted component regulation in conventional catalysts. Through the use of coprecipitation and hydrothermal synthesis, the representative sample (MgCoNi)3(FeAl)-LDH is created and systematically characterized. Significantly, this technique of preparation may generically synthesize a variety of HELDH with various component combinations, demonstrating the remarkable adaptability of the HELDH components. Subsequently, (FeCoNi)3(FeCr)-LDH with high OER activity is designed and synthesized. (FeCoNi)3(FeCr)-LDH shows excellent OER activity (overpotential is only 230 mV at 10 mA cm-2). A new platform for the creation of high-performance catalysts and high-entropy materials was established by the synthesis and design of HELDH.

Influence of Temperature on the Performance of Carbon- and ATO-supported Oxygen Evolution Reaction Catalysts in a Gas Diffusion Electrode Setup

State-of-the-art industrial electrocatalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) under acidic conditions are Ir-based. Considering the scarce supply of Ir, it is imperative to use the precious metal as efficiently as possible. In this work, we immobilized ultrasmall Ir and Ir_0.4Ru_0.6 nanoparticles on two different supports to maximize their dispersion. One high-surface-area carbon support serves as a reference but has limited technological relevance due to its lack of stability. The other support, antimony-doped tin oxide (ATO), has been proposed in the literature as a possible better support for OER catalysts. Temperature-dependent measurements performed in a recently developed gas diffusion electrode (GDE) setup reveal that surprisingly the catalysts immobilized on commercial ATO performed worse than their carbon-immobilized counterparts. The measurements suggest that the ATO support deteriorates particularly fast at elevated temperatures.

Synthesis and Magnetic, Optical, and Electrocatalytic Properties of High-Entropy Mixed-Metal Tungsten and Molybdenum Oxides

High-entropy oxides (HEOs) are of interest for their unique physical and chemical properties. Significant lattice distortions, strain, and tolerance for high-vacancy concentrations set HEOs apart from single-metal or mixed-metal oxides. Herein, we synthesized and characterized the structures and compositions, along with the optical, magnetic, and electrocatalytic properties, of two families of high-entropy mixed-metal tungsten and molybdenum oxides, AWO₄ and B₂Mo₃O₈, where A and B are 3d transition metals. The HEOs A⁶WO₄ (A = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, and Zn) and B₂⁵Mo₃O₈ (B = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, and Zn), as well as all accessible single-metal AWO₄ and B₂Mo₃O₈ parent compounds, were synthesized using high-temperature solid-state methods. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy analysis of the surfaces revealed that the HEOs largely had the metal oxidation states expected from the bulk chemical formulas, but in some cases they were different than in the parent compounds. A⁶WO₄ exhibited antiferromagnetic (AFM) ordering with a Néel temperature of 30 K, which is less than the average of its AFM parent compounds, and had a narrow band gap of 0.24 eV, which is much lower than all of its parent compounds. B₂⁵Mo₃O₈ was paramagnetic, despite the existence of AFM and ferromagnetic ordering in several of its parent compounds and had no observable band gap, which is analogous to its parent compounds. Both A⁶WO₄ and B₂⁵Mo₃O₈ exhibited superior catalytic activity relative to the parent compounds for the oxygen evolution reaction, the oxidation half reaction of overall water splitting, under alkaline conditions, based on the overpotential required to reach the benchmark surface area normalized current density. Consistent with literature predictions of OER durability for ternary tungsten and molybdenum oxides, A⁶WO₄ and B₂⁵Mo₃O₈ also exhibited stable performance without significant dissolution during 10 h stability experiments at a constant current.

Scalable Synthesis of Multi-Metal Electrocatalyst Powders and Electrodes and their Application for Oxygen Evolution and Water Splitting

Multi-metal electrocatalysts provide nearly unlimited catalytic possibilities arising from synergistic element interactions. We propose a polymer/metal precursor spraying technique that can easily be adapted to produce a large variety of compositional different multi-metal catalyst materials. To demonstrate this, 11 catalysts were synthesized, characterized, and investigated for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). Further investigation of the most active OER catalyst, namely CoNiFeMoCr, revealed a polycrystalline structure, and operando Raman measurements indicate that multiple active sites are participating in the reaction. Moreover, Ni foam-supported CoNiFeMoCr electrodes were developed and applied for water splitting in flow-through electrolysis cells with electrolyte gaps and in zero-gap membrane electrode assembly (MEA) configurations. The proposed alkaline MEA-type electrolyzers reached up to 3 A cm^-2 , and 24 h measurements demonstrated no loss of current density of 1 A cm^-2 .

Reviving Oxygen Evolution Electrocatalysis of Bulk La-Ni Intermetallics via Gaseous Hydrogen Engineering

A hydrogen processing strategy is developed to enable bulk LaNi₅ to attain high activity and long-term stability toward the electrocatalytic oxygen evolution reaction (OER). By a combination of in situ Raman and quasi in situ X-ray absorption (XAS) spectra, secondary-electron-excited scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) patterns as well as the Rietveld method and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, it is discovered that hydrogen-induced lattice distortion, grain refinement, and particle cracks dictate the effective reconstruction of the LaNi₅ surface into a porous hetero-nanoarchitecture composed of uniformly confined active γ-NiOOH nanocrystals by La(OH)₃ layer in the alkaline OER process. This significantly optimizes the charge transfer, structural integrity, active-site exposure, and adsorption energy toward the reaction intermediates. Benefiting from these merits, the overpotential (322 mV) at 100 mA cm^-2 for the hydrogen-processed OER catalyst deposited on nickel foam is reduced by 104 mV as compared to the original phase. Notably, it exhibits remarkable stability for 10 days at an industrial-grade current density of more than 560 mA cm^-2 in alkaline media.

Designing strategies and enhancing mechanism for multicomponent high-entropy catalysts

High-entropy materials (HEMs) are new-fashioned functional materials in the field of catalysis owing to their large designing space, tunable electronic structure, interesting "cocktail effect", and entropy stabilization effect. Many effective strategies have been developed to design advanced catalysts for various important reactions. Herein, we firstly review effective strategies developed so far for optimizing HEM-based catalysts and the underlying mechanism revealed by both theoretical simulations and experimental aspects. In light of this overview, we subsequently present some perspectives about the development of HEM-based catalysts and provide some serviceable guidelines and/or inspiration for further studying multicomponent catalysts.

Theoretical Optimization of Compositions of High-Entropy Oxides for the Oxygen Evolution Reaction

High‐entropy oxides are oxides consisting of five or more metals incorporated in a single lattice, and the large composition space suggests that properties of interest can be readily optimised. For applications within catalysis, the different local atomic environments result in a distribution of binding energies for the catalytic intermediates. Using the oxygen evolution reaction on the rutile (110) surface as example, here we outline a strategy for the theoretical optimization of the composition. Density functional theory calculations performed for a limited number of sites are used to fit a model that predicts the reaction energies for all possible local atomic environments. Two reaction pathways are considered; the conventional pathway on the coordinatively unsaturated sites and an alternative pathway involving transfer of protons to a bridging oxygen. An explicit model of the surface is constructed to describe the interdependency of the two pathways and identify the composition that maximizes catalytic activity.