Generation and molecular analyses of two rheumatoid synovial fluid-derived IgG rheumatoid factors

Human IgG Fc-binding phage antibodies constructed from synovial fluid CD38+ B cells of patients with rheumatoid arthritis show the imprints of an antigen-dependent process of somatic hypermutation and clonal selection

The persistent presence of rheumatoid factors (RFs) in the circulation is a characteristic phenomenon in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Recent data indicate that RFs associated with seropositive RA are derived from terminally differentiated CD20-, CD38+ plasma cells (PCs) present in synovial fluids of the inflamed joints. These cells were shown to secrete RFs actively and are thought to originate from germinal centre (GC)-like structures present in the inflamed synovium. To obtain a representative image of the structural properties of IgM and IgG RFs associated with RA, phage antibody display libraries were constructed from CD38+ PCs isolated from the inflamed joints of RF-seropositive patients with RA. Subsequently, human IgG Fc-binding monoclonal phage antibodies were selected and analysed. The data suggest that RA-associated RFs are encoded by a diverse set of VL and a more restricted set of VH regions. VH gene family usage of PC-derived IgM- and IgG-RFs was found to be restricted to the VH1 and 3 gene families, with a preference for VH3, and many different VL genes were shown to contribute to RF specificity. Clonally related VH as well as VL sequences were identified, based on the presence of identical CDR3 regions and shared somatic mutations. In this B cell selection process base-pair substitutions as well as deletions of triplets in CDR regions, leaving the transcripts in frame, were involved. Together, these data provide further evidence for an Ag-driven immune response in the terminal differentiation into RF-producing PCs in patients with RA, including expansion of clonally related B cells, selection and isotype switching, all hallmarks of a GC reaction.

Polyreactivity of human IgG Fc-binding phage antibodies constructed from synovial fluid CD38+ B cells of patients with rheumatoid arthritis

Recent data indicate that rheumatoid factors (RFs) that occur in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) are derived from Ig-producing terminally differentiated CD20-, CD38+ plasma cells present in synovial fluids (SFs). Phage antibody display libraries were constructed using CD38+ plasma cells isolated from SFs of two RF-seropositive RA patients. The libraries were enriched for phage antibodies (Phabs) binding to human IgG (HuIgG) Fc fragments and the sequences of their V genes were analysed. These data provided further evidence for an Ag-driven immune response in patients with RA, including expansion of clonally related B cells, selection and isotype switching, all hallmarks of a germinal center reaction. In the present study, the functional characteristics of these HuIgG Fc-binding monoclonal (mo) Phabs were further analysed in order to provide more insight into the specificity of HuIgG Fc-binding Phabs. Remarkably, all HuIgG Fc-binding moPhabs tested (n=48; derived from four different libraries) displayed polyreactivity. Structural analysis of the CDR3 regions revealed characteristic features of polyreactive Igs. Most H chain CDR3 regions harboured tryptophan/tyrosine-rich parts and approximately 60% of the L chain CDR3 regions of both RA patients displayed an identical stretch of amino acids (W/Y-D-S-S). Supportive for a dominant role of VH in specificity, exchange of VL regions with a single VH region yielded moPhabs with similar specificities. All together, the data suggest the presence of an Ag-driven process in the joints of patients with RA, including somatic mutation and clonal selection entailing isotype switching, resulting in the differentiation of B cells into polyreactive RF-secreting plasma cells.

Nucleotide sequence analysis of a human monoclonal antibody TONO-1 with cytotoxic potential for T-leukemia/lymphoma cells

A human monoclonal antibody (HuMab) TONO-1 (IgM, lambda) recognizes cell surface antigens associated primarily with human T-leukemia/lymphoma cells. In this study, we investigated the reactivity against T-leukemia/lymphoma cells in detail, cytotoxic potential and primary nucleotide and deduced amino acid sequences of the rearranged heavy and light chains of the HuMab TONO-1. Expression of the molecules (TONO-1 Ags) detected by a HuMab TONO-1 was significantly heterogeneous even in the same T-leukemia/lymphoma cell lines HPB-MLT and MOLT-4F. The flow cytometric curves showed an unusual broad-based spread of fluorescence intensity. HuMab TONO-1 was shown to have the ability to kill the T-leukernia/lymphoma cells efficiently in the presence of rabbit complements. However, HuMab TONO-1 did not demonstrate significant antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxic activity. Furthermore, HuMab TONO-1 heavy and light chain variable regions were cloned, sequenced and analyzed. HuMab TONO-1 uses a V(H) gene member of the V(H)IV gene family V(H)71-4, and is productively rearranged with the germ line D(H) gene D(XP')1, and the germ line J(H)5 gene with multiple somatic mutations. HuMab TONO-1 Vlambda belongs to the lambda light chain variable subgroup I family and is derived from the Vlambdalc germ line gene Humlv1042, and germ line gene Jlambda1 without somatic mutations. The results reveal that the production of HuMab TONO-1, with cytotoxic potential for human T-leukemia/lymphoma cells, is achieved by rearrangement of the V(H)71-4/Humlv1042 germ line variable region gene combination, that is associated with the autoimmune repertoire.

Ability of T cells from patients with rheumatoid arthritis to respond to immunoglobulin G

The ability of T cells from rheumatoid factor (RF)-positive patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) to respond to immunoglobulin G (IgG) was assessed. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from RA patients and normal individuals were cultured with and without human IgG or Mycobacterium tuberculosis-purified protein derivative (PPD) for 7 days and their proliferative response measured at intervals by their ability to take up tritiated thymidine. PBMC from 14/26 RA patients proliferated in response to IgG (taking a stimulation index of 3 or above as positive). The peak response varied between individuals but usually occurred on day 5, the same day, or 1 day later than the peak response to PPD. By contrast, PBMC from a significantly lower proportion (1/9) of normal individuals and patients with other arthritides (0/6) responded to IgG, although all responded to PPD. PBMC from 9/14 RA patients responded to Fab fragments of IgG but only 3/9 to the Fc fragment. Higher proliferative responses from RA PBMC were elicited by IgG aggregates than the original IgG preparation, but PMBC from 5/5 normal individuals and 5/6 patients with other arthritides failed to respond to the aggregates. The response to IgG was human leucocyte antigen (HLA)-DR restricted and mediated by CD4+ T cells. It is considered that these results advance the hypothesis that IgG-reactive T cells contribute to the initiation or perpetuation of RA.

Molecular analysis of rheumatoid factor (RF)-negative B cell hybridomas from rheumatoid synovial tissue: evidence for an antigen-induced stimulation with selection of high mutated IgVH and low mutated IgVL/lambda genes

The mutational pattern of IgVH and IgVL genes from synovial tissue B cell hybridomas (n = 8) of patients (n = 4) with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) was analysed, which had been produced by the electrofusion technique without prior in vitro stimulation. The molecular data were correlated with immunohistopathological data and parameters of local disease activity. The IgVH genes of the B cell hybridomas belonged to the VH3 family (DP42; DP47, n = 2; DP53), the VH1 family (DP75), the VH4 family (DP71) and the VH5 family (DP73); 7/7 IgVH genes showed somatic mutations, the R/S ratio (CDR) was > 3 in 4/7 IgVH genes and the mean R/S ratio of all IgVH genes was 9.3 (CDR) and 1.0 (FR), suggesting an antigen-dependent selection. The IgVL/lambda genes belonged to the Vlambda1 family (DPL2, DPL5, DPL8nf), the Vlambda2 family (DPL11, n = 2) and to the Vlambda6 family (IGLV6S1); 6/6 IgVL genes showed somatic mutations, the R/S ratio (CDR) was > 3 in 3/6 IgVL genes and the mean R/S ratio of all IgVL was 3.0 (CDR) and 2.3 (FR), suggesting an antigen-dependent selection. The synovial tissue exhibited germinal centres in the follicles (3/4), with the unique distribution of Ki-M4+ follicular dendritic cells and Ki-67+ proliferating cells and a dominance of IgA+ plasma cells (3/3). All patients were positive for RF in serum and exhibited severe local symptoms (swelling 4/4; warmth 4/4; effusion 2/4), whereas the hybridomas were negative for RF. Since B cell hybridomas showed hypermutation and affinity selection for IgVH and IgVL/lambda genes and the patients exhibited severe local symptoms with germinal centres in synovial tissue, this study indicates that an antigen-driven process is behind the B cell expansion in the synovial tissue of clinically affected joints. These mutated B hybridomas were negative for RF, thus suggesting that antigens different from RF are also involved in the local B cell expansion and in the chronic synovitis of RA.

Clonal Analysis of a Human Antibody Response. III. Nucleotide Sequences of Monoclonal IgM, IgG, and IgA to Rabies Virus Reveal Restricted Vκ Gene Utilization, Junctional VκJκ and VλJλ Diversity, and Somatic Hypermutation

In previous work, we generated four IgM, five IgG1, and one IgA1 mAbs to rabies virus using B cells from four subjects vaccinated with inactivated rabies virus, a thymus-dependent (TD) mosaic Ag, and sequenced the mAb VHDJH genes. Here, we have cloned the VκJκ and VλJλ genes to complete the primary structure of the Ag-binding site of these mAbs. While the anti-rabies virus mAb selection of Vλ genes (2e.2.2 twice, DPL11, and DPL23) reflected the representation of the Vλ genes in the human haploid genome (stochastic utilization), that of Vκ genes (O2/O12 twice, O8/O18, A3/A19, A27, and L2) did not (p = 0.0018) (nonstochastic utilization). Furthermore, the selection of both Vκ and Vλ genes by the anti-rabies virus mAbs vastly overlapped with that of 557 assorted VκJκ rearrangements, that of 253 VλJλ rearrangements in λ-type gammopathies, and that of other Abs to thymus-dependent Ags, including 23 anti-HIV mAbs and 51 rheumatoid factors, but differed from that of 43 Abs to Haemophilus influenzae type b polysaccharide, a prototypic thymus-independent (TI) Ag. The anti-rabies virus mAb VκJκ and VλJλ segments displayed variable numbers of somatic mutations, which, in mAb58 and the virus-neutralizing mAb57, entailed a significant concentration of amino acid replacements in the complementarity-determining regions (p = 0.0028 and p = 0.0023, respectively), suggesting a selection by Ag. This Ag-dependent somatic selection process was superimposed on a somatic diversification process that occurred at the stage of B cell receptor for Ag rearrangement, and that entailed V gene 3′ truncation and N nucleotide additions to yield heterogeneous CDR3s.

Analysis of the molecular basis of synovial rheumatoid factors in rheumatoid arthritis

The objective of this study was to better understand the molecular basis of IgM rheumatoid factor in rheumatoid arthritis (RA). We recently generated 10 different monoclonal IgM RF (mRF) molecules isolated from the synovium of a single patient with RA. The heavy (H) and light chain (L) variable region (V) genes of these 10 mRFs were cloned and sequenced. Six mRFs used kappa light chains and 4 mRFs used lambda light chains. Of particular interest, 8 of 10 heavy chains used the JH4 joining region gene, and all five VH4 heavy chains used the DK4 diversity region gene with the JH4. Four of the VH4 clones used the same germline gene, likely representing a novel but closely related germline gene to VH4.18, and may be clonally related because of the extensive homology in their heavy chain sequence. Two VH4 clones shared the same light chain gene, VkappaIIIb kv325 (99% homology) and the same JK4 joining region gene, while three VH4 clones used two different light chain genes, an uncommon Vkappa4 and a Vlambda4 gene, respectively. In this RA patient, there was recurrent utilization of VH4-DK4-21/10-JH4 genes and a recurring association with gene elements Vkappa3 and Vlambda4. Recurring usage of Vkappa3 (kv325) and Vlambda4 (lv418) gene elements may result from a light chain editing process whereby immature autoreactive B cells encountering self-antigen attempt, and often succeed, in altering their specificities through secondary Ig light chain gene rearrangement. Moreover, the oligoclonality of these RFs suggest clonal relatedness secondary to an antigen-driven response.

Comparison of rheumatoid factors of rheumatoid arthritis patients, of individuals with mycobacterial infections and of normal controls: evidence for maturation in the absence of an autoimmune response

We analyzed the rheumatoid factors (RF) produced by Epstein-Barr virus-transformed monoclonal B cells established from four patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), three individuals with a history of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (TB) and four normal controls (NI). Fifty-eight RF were analyzed for specific activity (international units-RF/microgram) for the Fc part of IgG and their interaction with tetanus toxoid (TT) and DNA (polyspecificity). Furthermore, we sequenced the V-D-J heavy chain region of 16 (9TB-/7RA-) RF. Significant differences were observed between the NI-RF and the TB- and RA-RF. While the RF repertoire of normal individuals comprised of low-avidity RF of which the majority (15/17) were polyspecific, more than half of the TB- and RA-RF were monoreactive. Furthermore, the monospecific TB- and RA-RF were of significantly higher avidity than the NI-RF (RA > TB > > NI). With respect to polyspecificity specificity, the RF in the three groups were comparable: the interaction with DNA, TT as well as with Fc was inhibited either by an increase of the ionic strength to 0.3-0.5 M NaCl or by addition of the polyanion dextran sulfate, indicating that the antibodies interacted with similar anionic epitopes shared by the three antigens. Analysis of the V-D-J heavy chain regions showed significant differences between the respective RF. The salt-sensitive binding was highly correlated with the presence of arginine in the complementarity-determining region 3 (CDR3). Furthermore, whereas the polyspecific RF consisted predominantly of germ-line encoded antibodies, the genes of the monospecific RA/TB-RF were somatically mutated (RA > TB). It is therefore likely that maturation of RF can be initiated by chronic infections and that monospecific, somatically mutated RF are not a unique characteristic of autoimmune diseases.

Human IgG rheumatoid factors and RF-like immune complexes induce IgG1 rheumatoid factor production in mice

The synovial fluid of patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) was found to contain IgG and/or IgG-containing immune complexes (ICs) that stimulated an intense antibody formation when injected into mice of certain strains, notably of NZ background. The response was characterized by high and sustained levels of IgG1 antibodies with rheumatoid factor (RF) activity. In the study described, we investigated whether it is the antibodies with RF activity in the synovial fluid, that are responsible for stimulation of mouse RF in vivo. Different mouse strains were injected with synovial fluid from a seropositive RA patient (RA-SF), with human monoclonal antibodies with RF activity, with a human non-RF monoclonal antibody or with different preformed RF-like antibody-antibody (Ab-Ab) ICs. The experimental mice were monitored subsequently for IgG1 RF production. IgG1 RF antibodies were found in all strains (NZB, BALB/c and CBA) injected with Ab-Ab ICs formed at equivalence, but only in NZB using RA-SF or human monoclonal antibodies with RF activity. Optimal production of IgG1 RF by Ab-Ab ICs required the integrity of Fc and F(ab)'2 portions respectively of the antibodies; soluble and truncated ICs were less effective. Further studies demonstrated that the IgG1 RF response was not simply the result of a specific immune response against human IgG, since humoral immunity against human IgG was induced only when combined with an efficient adjuvant. During a typical adjuvant-associated primary response specific antibodies of IgM, IgG1 and IgG2a isotypes were found, i.e. quite different from the selective IgG1 response induced by RF-like containing immune complexes. This conclusion is substantiated further by the clear differences in responses to IgG containing fraction obtained from RA-SF in NZ mice compared to other strains. Our findings argue for a different type of reaction leading to the selective IgG1 response and might aid in elucidating the mechanisms for chronic production of antibodies with RF activity in patients with RA.

The identification of germinal centres and follicular dendritic cell networks in rheumatoid synovial tissue

We document here the identification of germinal centres with dark and light zones, a follicular dendritic cell network and clonal expansion in the synovium of rheumatoid arthritis patients. Synovial tissue from 24 patients suffering from rheumatoid arthritis or the polyarticular form of juvenile rheumatoid arthritis were screened for the presence of lymphoid follicles. The synovial tissues of 14 patients contained follicles and four of these had germinal centres and a follicular dendritic cell network. There was a statistically significant association between follicles in the synovium and the presence of rheumatoid factor autoantibodies in the patients' serum indicating a link between local germinal centre formation and the presence of pathological rheumatoid factors. Nucleotide sequencing of monoclonal rheumatoid factors from one of the patients' synovial tissue which contained germinal centres clearly supports the possibility that these rheumatoid factors have gone through a germinal centre reaction. While rheumatoid factors from healthy immunized donors are regulated through a tolerization mechanism which selects against replacement mutations and does not allow affinity maturation, synovial rheumatoid factors seem to lack this tolerization mechanism. The formation of germinal centres where B cells affinity mature and expand at the central site of disease in rheumatoid arthritis may explain why rheumatoid factors in rheumatoid arthritis develop into auto-aggressive antibodies.

IgH and L chain variable region gene sequence analyses of twelve synovial tissue-derived B cell lines producing IgA, IgG, and IgM rheumatoid factors structure/function comparisons of antigenic specificity, V gene sequence, and Ig isotype

In the present study, the complete sequences of the Ig H and L chain variable region genes of twelve RF+ B cell lines from two patients with RA were analyzed. Seven of the RF-producing B cells used VH3 family genes, four used VH4 genes, and one a VH1 gene. All but two of the cell lines expressing VH3 genes utilized different family members; among the VH4-expressing cells, a more restricted pattern was noted. V kappa gene use was restricted to the V kappa I and III families; V lambda gene use was more diverse, involving five different families. Computer comparisons of the expressed VH genes with their presumed germline progenitors indicated significant differences in every instance; eight of the corresponding VL genes also were significantly different. In many cases, assignment of the germline D segment(s) incorporated into the rearranged VH genes was impossible. These differences from the germline gene segments indicated the extensive changes induced by rearrangement, enzymatic activities, and somatic mutation. In hopes of defining a structural reason for the disparate antigen specificities of these cells, the CDR3 amino acid sequences of the multi- vs. the mono-reactive RF-producers were compared. Although CDR3 length was not appreciably different between these two sets of mAb, a greater than two-fold increase in charged amino acids was found in the H chain CDR3 of the multireactive RF. This relationship did not exist for the L chain CDR3. Thus, these sequence data indicate the use of a broad base of Ig V gene segments that have undergone extensive diversification. Based on the localization of R substitutions in the CDR of most of the V genes studied, the diversification appears to be antigen driven and selected. The significance of these findings for the evolution of these B cell clones into isotype-switched producers that are heterogeneous for antigen specificity (mono- vs. multi-reactivity) is discussed.

Defining the genetic origins of three rheumatoid synovium-derived IgG rheumatoid factors

A major diagnostic marker in most rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients is the rheumatoid factor (RF), an autoantibody that binds to the Fc region of IgG. To delineate the Ig genes and the underlying mechanism for RF production in RA patients, we applied a systematic approach to define the genetic origins of three IgG RFs derived from the synovial fluid of two RA patients. The results show that two of three IgG RF have substantial numbers of somatic mutations in their variable (V) regions, ranging from 13 to 23 mutations over a stretch of 291-313 nucleotides, resulting in a frequency of 4.4-7.8%. However, one IgG RF has only one mutation in each V region. This result indicates that an IgG RF may arise from a germline gene by very few mutations. The mutations occur mainly in the complementarity-determining regions (CDRs), and the mutations in the CDRs often lead to amino acid substitutions. Five of the six corresponding germline V genes have been found to encode either natural autoantibodies or autoantibodies in other autoimmune disorders; and three of the six V genes have been found in fetal liver. Taken together with other results, the data show that (a) several potentially pathogenic RFs in RA patients arise from natural autoantibodies, and (b) only a few mutations are required to convert the natural autoantibodies to IgG RFs.

Preferential utilization of a novel V lambda 3 gene in monoclonal rheumatoid factors derived from the synovial cells of rheumatoid arthritis patients

OBJECTIVE

To further our understanding about the molecular genetics of rheumatoid factor (RF) in rheumatoid arthritis (RA).

METHODS

The heavy and light chain variable region (V) genes of 5 new human monoclonal IgM RFs were cloned and sequenced using the polymerase chain reaction and the dideoxynucleotide termination method.

RESULTS

The results reveal the recurrent usage in two RA patients of a novel V lambda 3 germline gene, designated Humlv3c93. Specifically, in 2 of 3 RFs (C93 and D53) from one patient, the light chains in the V lambda gene-encoded region were identical to each other and to the light chain of an RF (H4) from another patient. Serologically, the light chains of these 3 RFs were classified as members of the V lambda 3b sub-subgroup. Each of the RFs was encoded by a different VH gene. Both C93 and D53 bound specifically with human and rabbit IgG, whereas H4 was monospecific for rabbit IgG.

CONCLUSION

Since the lv3c93 gene is not homologous to any reported V lambda sequence from natural autoantibodies, it is possible that lv3c93 may represent a disease-specific RF-related V lambda gene. Moreover, the amino acid sequence CSGGSCY in the third complementarity-determining regions of 2 of the RF heavy chains is encoded by the DLR2 gene segment and has been found previously in 2 other RA-derived RFs, and thus may play a significant role in antigen binding.

Utilization of a potentially universal downstream primer in the rapid identification and characterization of V lambda genes from two new human V lambda gene families

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) has increased dramatically the speed of cloning and characterizing numerous genes. However, its application to identifying and analysing new germline Ig-variable (V) gene families has been hampered by the lack of sequence information in the downstream flanking regions of the concerned V genes, which are deleted during V(D)J rearrangements. To circumvent this problem, the possibility was explored that a degenerate downstream primer may be used in conjunction with a specific upstream primer, to clone members of new V lambda gene families, as much less is known about V lambda genes than Vh and Vk genes in humans. Firstly the feasibility and the specificity of a degenerate primer was examined by comparing it with an established downstream primer in amplifying known V lambda 1 genes. The results were positive. Thus, the degenerate primer was used to clone and characterize germline V lambda genes of the recently defined V lambda 8 and V lambda 9 gene families. This current strategy may help speed up the identification and characterization of all human V lambda genes. Moreover, a similar strategy can be applied to identify and characterize rapidly new V genes of either known or unknown Ig and T-cell receptor V gene families.