A twisted hand: bHLH protein phosphorylation and dimerization regulate limb development

Partially Penetrant Cardiac Neural Crest Defects in Hand1 Phosphomutant Mice: Dimer Choice That Is Not So Critical

Hand1 is a basic Helix-loop-Helix transcription factor that exhibits post-translationally regulated dimer partner choice that allows for a diverse set of Hand1 transcriptional complexes. Indeed, when Hand1 phosphoregulation is altered, conditionally activated hypophorylation (Hand1^PO4-) and phosphorylation mimic (Hand1^PO4+) Hand1 alleles disrupt both craniofacial and limb morphogenesis with 100% penetrance. Interestingly, activation of conditional Hand1 Phosphomutant alleles within post-migratory neural crest cells produce heart defects that include ventricular septal defects, double-outlet right ventricle, persistent truncus arteriosus with partial penetrance. Single versus double-lobed thymus is a distinguishing feature between Wnt1-Cre;Hand1^PO4-/+ and Wnt1-Cre;Hand1^PO4+/+ mice. These data show that although Hand1 dimer regulation plays critical and consistent roles in disrupting craniofacial and limb morphogenesis, Hand1 dimer regulation during cardiac outflow track formation is less critical for normal morphogenesis. This review will present the OFT phenotypes observed in Hand1 Phosphomutant mice, and discuss possible mechanisms of how penetrance differences within the same tissues within the same embryos could be variable.

Exclusion of Dlx5/6 expression from the distal-most mandibular arches enables BMP-mediated specification of the distal cap

Cranial neural crest cells (crNCCs) migrate from the neural tube to the pharyngeal arches (PAs) of the developing embryo and, subsequently, differentiate into bone and connective tissue to form the mandible. Within the PAs, crNCCs respond to local signaling cues to partition into the proximo-distally oriented subdomains that convey positional information to these developing tissues. Here, we show that the distal-most of these subdomains, the distal cap, is marked by expression of the transcription factor Hand1 (H1) and gives rise to the ectomesenchymal derivatives of the lower incisors. We uncover a H1 enhancer sufficient to drive reporter gene expression within the crNCCs of the distal cap. We show that bone morphogenic protein (BMP) signaling and the transcription factor HAND2 (H2) synergistically regulate H1 distal cap expression. Furthermore, the homeodomain proteins distal-less homeobox 5 (DLX5) and DLX6 reciprocally inhibit BMP/H2-mediated H1 enhancer regulation. These findings provide insights into how multiple signaling pathways direct transcriptional outcomes that pattern the developing jaw.

Hand1 phosphoregulation within the distal arch neural crest is essential for craniofacial morphogenesis

In this study we examine the consequences of altering Hand1 phosphoregulation in the developing neural crest cells (NCCs) of mice. Whereas Hand1 deletion in NCCs reveals a nonessential role for Hand1 in craniofacial development and embryonic survival, altering Hand1 phosphoregulation, and consequently Hand1 dimerization affinities, in NCCs results in severe mid-facial clefting and neonatal death. Hand1 phosphorylation mutants exhibit a non-cell-autonomous increase in pharyngeal arch cell death accompanied by alterations in Fgf8 and Shh pathway expression. Together, our data indicate that the extreme distal pharyngeal arch expression domain of Hand1 defines a novel bHLH-dependent activity, and that disruption of established Hand1 dimer phosphoregulation within this domain disrupts normal craniofacial patterning.

Twist2 contributes to termination of limb bud outgrowth and patterning through direct regulation of Grem1

Twist1 has been demonstrated to play critical roles in the early development of neural crest and mesodermally derived tissues including the limb. Twist2 has been less well characterised but its relatively late onset of expression suggests specific roles in the development of a number of organs. Expression of Twist2 within the developing limbs begins after formation of the limb bud and persists within the peripheral mesenchyme until digital rays condense. We have used RCAS-mediated overexpression in chick to investigate the function of Twist2 in limb development. Viral misexpression following injection into the lateral plate mesoderm results in a spectrum of hypoplastic limb phenotypes. These include generalized shortening of the entire limb, fusion of the autopod skeletal elements, loss of individual digits or distal truncation resulting in complete loss of the autopod. These phenotypes appear to result from a premature termination of limb outgrowth and manifest as defective growth in both the proximal-distal and anterior-posterior axes. In situ hybridisation analysis demonstrates that many components of the Shh/Grem1/Fgf regulatory loop that controls early limb growth and patterning are downregulated by Twist2 overexpression. Grem1 has a complementary expression pattern to Twist2 within the limb primordia and co-expression of both Grem1 and Twist2 results in a rescue of the Twist2 overexpression phenotype. We demonstrate that Twist proteins directly repress Grem1 expression via a regulatory element downstream of the open reading frame. These data indicate that Twist2 regulates early limb morphogenesis through a role in terminating the Shh/Grem1/Fgf autoregulatory loop.

Downregulation of Dlx5 and Dlx6 expression by Hand2 is essential for initiation of tongue morphogenesis

Lower jaw development is a complex process in which multiple signaling cascades establish a proximal-distal organization. These cascades are regulated both spatially and temporally and are constantly refined through both induction of normal signals and inhibition of inappropriate signals. The connective tissue of the tongue arises from cranial neural crest cell-derived ectomesenchyme within the mandibular portion of the first pharyngeal arch and is likely to be impacted by this signaling. Although the developmental mechanisms behind later aspects of tongue development, including innervation and taste acquisition, have been elucidated, the early patterning signals driving ectomesenchyme into a tongue lineage are largely unknown. We show here that the basic helix-loop-helix transcription factor Hand2 plays key roles in establishing the proximal-distal patterning of the mouse lower jaw, in part through establishing a negative-feedback loop in which Hand2 represses Dlx5 and Dlx6 expression in the distal arch ectomesenchyme following Dlx5- and Dlx6-mediated induction of Hand2 expression in the same region. Failure to repress distal Dlx5 and Dlx6 expression results in upregulation of Runx2 expression in the mandibular arch and the subsequent formation of aberrant bone in the lower jaw along with proximal-distal duplications. In addition, there is an absence of lateral lingual swelling expansion, from which the tongue arises, resulting in aglossia. Hand2 thus appears to establish a distal mandibular arch domain that is conducive for lower jaw development, including the initiation of tongue mesenchyme morphogenesis.

Twist1 activity thresholds define multiple functions in limb development

The basic helix-loop-helix transcription factor Twist1 is essential for normal limb development. Twist1(-/-) embryos die at midgestation. However, studies on early limb buds found that Twist1(-/-) mutant limb mesenchyme has an impaired response to FGF signaling from the apical ectodermal ridge, which disrupts the feedback loop between the mesenchyme and AER, and reduces and shifts anteriorly Shh expression in the zone of polarizing activity. We have combined Twist1 null, hypomorph and conditional alleles to generate a Twist1 allelic series that survives to birth. As Twist1 activity is reduced, limb skeletal defects progress from preaxial polydactyly to girdle reduction combined with hypoplasia, aplasia or mirror symmetry of all limb segments. With reduced Twist1 activity there is striking and progressive upregulation of ectopic Shh expression in the anterior of the limb, combined with an anterior shift in the posterior Shh domain, which is expressed at normal intensity, and loss of the posterior AER. Consequently limb outgrowth is initially impaired, before an ectopic anterior Shh domain expands the AER, promoting additional growth and repatterning. Reducing the dosage of FGF targets of the Etv gene family, which are known repressors of Shh expression in anterior limb mesenchyme, strongly enhances the anterior skeletal phenotype. Conversely this and other phenotypes are suppressed by reducing the dosage of the Twist1 antagonist Hand2. Our data support a model whereby multiple Twist1 activity thresholds contribute to early limb bud patterning, and suggest how particular combinations of skeletal defects result from differing amounts of Twist1 activity.

PKB/AKT phosphorylation of the transcription factor Twist-1 at Ser42 inhibits p53 activity in response to DNA damage

Protein kinase B (PKB/Akt) is ubiquitously expressed in cells. Phosphorylation of its multiple targets in response to various stimuli, including growth factors or cytokines, promotes cell survival and inhibits apoptosis. PKB is upregulated in many different cancers and a significant amount of the enzyme is present in its activated form. Here we show that PKB phosphorylates one of the anti-apoptotic proteins--transcription factor Twist-1 at Ser42. Cells expressing Twist-1 displayed inefficient p53 upregulation in response to DNA damage induced by gamma-irradiation or the genotoxic drug adriamycin. This influenced the activation of p53 target genes such as p21(Waf1) and Bax and led to aberrant cell-cycle regulation and the inhibition of apoptosis. The impaired induction of these p53 effector molecules is likely to be mediated by PKB-dependent phosphorylation of Twist-1 because, unlike the wild-type mutant, the Twist-1 S42A mutant did not confer cell resistance to DNA damage. Moreover, phosphorylation of Twist-1 at Ser42 was shown in vivo in various human cancer tissues, suggesting that this post-translational modification ensures functional activation of Twist-1 after promotion of survival during carcinogenesis.

Transforming growth factor-beta and Wnt signals regulate chondrocyte differentiation through Twist1 in a stage-specific manner

We investigated the molecular mechanisms underlying the transition between immature and mature chondrocytes downstream of TGF-beta and canonical Wnt signals. We used two developmentally distinct chondrocyte models isolated from the caudal portion of embryonic chick sternum or chick growth plates. Lower sternal chondrocytes exhibited immature phenotypic features, whereas growth plate-extracted cells displayed a hypertrophic phenotype. TGF-beta significantly induced beta-catenin in immature chondrocytes, whereas it repressed it in mature chondrocytes. TGF-beta further enhanced canonical Wnt-mediated transactivation of the Topflash reporter expression in lower sternal chondrocytes. However, it inhibited Topflash activity in a time-dependent manner in growth plate chondrocytes. Our immunoprecipitation experiments showed that TGF-beta induced Sma- and Mad-related protein 3 interaction with T-cell factor 4 in immature chondrocytes, whereas it inhibited this interaction in mature chondrocytes. Similar results were observed by chromatin immunoprecipitation showing that TGF-beta differentially shifts T-cell factor 4 occupancy on the Runx2 promoter in lower sternal chondrocytes vs. growth plate chondrocytes. To further determine the molecular switch between immature and hypertrophic chondrocytes, we assessed the expression and regulation of Twist1 and Runx2 in both cell models upon treatment with TGF-beta and Wnt3a. We show that Runx2 and Twist1 are differentially regulated during chondrocyte maturation. Furthermore, whereas TGF-beta induced Twist1 in mature chondrocytes, it inhibited Runx2 expression in these cells. Opposite effects were observed upon Wnt3a treatment, which predominates over TGF-beta effects on these cells. Finally, overexpression of chick Twist1 in mature chondrocytes dramatically inhibited their hypertrophy. Together, our findings show that Twist1 may be an important regulator of chondrocyte progression toward terminal maturation in response to TGF-beta and canonical Wnt signaling.

Mutations within helix I of Twist1 result in distinct limb defects and variation of DNA binding affinities

Twist1 is a basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) factor that plays an important role in limb development. Haploinsufficiency of Twist1 results in polydactyly via the inability of Twist1 to antagonistically regulate the related factor Hand2. The mechanism modulating Twist1-Hand2 antagonism is via phosphoregulation of conserved threonine and serine residues in helix I of the bHLH domain. Phosphoregulation alters the dimerization affinities for both proteins. Here we show that the expression of Twist1 and Twist1 phosphoregulation mutants results in distinct limb phenotypes in mice. In addition to dimer regulation, Twist1 phosphoregulation affects the DNA binding affinities of Twist1 in a partner-dependent and cis-element-dependent manner. In order to gain a better understanding of the specific Twist1 transcriptional complexes that function during limb morphogensis, we employ a series of Twist1-tethered dimers that include the known Twist1 partners, E12 and Hand2, as well as a tethered Twist1 homodimer. We show that these dimers behave in a manner similar to monomerically expressed bHLH factors and result in distinct limb phenotypes that correlate well with those observed from the limb expression of Twist1 and Twist1 phosphoregulation mutants. Taken together, this study shows that the Twist1 dimer affinity for a given partner can modulate the DNA binding affinity and that Twist1 dimer choice determines phenotypic outcome during limb development.

Hand2 is necessary for terminal differentiation of enteric neurons from crest-derived precursors but not for their migration into the gut or for formation of glia

Hand genes encode basic helix-loop-helix transcription factors that are expressed in the developing gut, where their function is unknown. We now report that enteric Hand2 expression is limited to crest-derived cells, whereas Hand1 expression is restricted to muscle and interstitial cells of Cajal. Hand2 is developmentally regulated and is intranuclear in precursors but cytoplasmic in neurons. Neurons develop in explants from wild-type but not Hand2(-/-) bowel, although, in both, crest-derived cells are present and glia arise. Similarly, small interfering RNA (siRNA) silencing of Hand2 in enteric crest-derived cells prevents neuronal development. Terminally differentiated enteric neurons do not develop after conditional inactivation of Hand2 in migrating crest-derived cells; nevertheless, conditional Hand2 inactivation does not prevent precursors from expressing early neural markers. We suggest that enteric neuronal development occurs in stages and that Hand2 expression is required for terminal differentiation but not for precursors to enter the neuronal lineage.

The C. elegans Twist target gene, arg-1, is regulated by distinct E box promoter elements

Proper metazoan mesoderm development requires the function of a basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) transcription factor, Twist. Twist-containing dimers regulate the expression of target genes by binding to E box promoter elements containing the site CANNTG. In Caenorhabditis elegans, CeTwist functions in a subset of mesodermal cells. Our study focuses on how CeTwist controls the expression of its target gene, arg-1. We find that a 385bp promoter region of arg-1, which contains three different E box elements, is sufficient for maintaining the full CeTwist-dependent expression pattern. Interestingly, the expression of arg-1 in different tissues is regulated distinctly, and each of the three E boxes plays a unique role in the regulation. The first and the third E boxes (E1 and E3) are required for expression in a distinct subset of the mesodermal tissues where arg-1 is normally expressed, and the second E box (E2) is required for expression in the full set of those tissues. The essential role of E2 in arg-1 regulation is correlated with the finding that E2 binds with greater affinity than E1 or E3 to CeTwist dimers. A potential role for additional transcription factors in mesodermal gene regulation is suggested by the discovery of a novel site that is also required for arg-1 expression in a subset of the tissues but is not bound in vitro by CeTwist. On the basis of these results, we propose a model of CeTwist gene regulation in which expression is controlled by tissue-specific binding of distinct sets of E boxes.