Bifunctional Reagents for Formylglycine Conjugation: Pitfalls and Breakthroughs

Dual-payload antibody-drug conjugates: Taking a dual shot

Antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs) enable the precise delivery of cytotoxic agents by conjugating small-molecule drugs with monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). Over recent decades, ADCs have demonstrated substantial clinical efficacy. However, conventional ADCs often encounter various clinical challenges, including suboptimal efficacy, significant adverse effects, and the development of drug resistance, limiting their broader clinical application. Encouragingly, a next-generation approach-dual-payload ADCs-has emerged as a pioneering strategy to address these challenges. Dual-payload ADCs are characterized by the incorporation of two distinct therapeutic payloads on the same antibody, enhancing treatment efficacy by promoting synergistic effects and reducing the risk of drug resistance. However, the synthesis of dual-payload ADCs is complex due to the presence of multiple functional groups on antibodies. In this review, we comprehensively summarize the construction strategies for dual-payload ADCs, ranging from the design of ADC components to orthogonal chemistry. The subsequent sections explore current challenges and propose prospective strategies, highlighting recent advancements in dual-payload ADC research, thereby laying the foundation for the development of next-generation ADCs.

A gene-encoded aldehyde tag repurposed from RiPP cyclophane-forming pathway

Gene-encoded aldehyde tag technology has been widely utilized in protein bioorthogonal chemistry and biotechnological application. Herein, we report utilization of the promiscuous rSAM cyclophane synthase SjiB involved in triceptide biosynthesis as a dedicated and highly efficient formylglycine synthase. The new aldehyde tag sequence in this system, YQSSI, is biosynthetically orthogonal to the known aldehyde tag (C/S)x(P/A)xR. The potential use of SjiB/YQSSI aldehyde tag system was further validated in fluorescent labelling of model proteins.

Enzymatic Peptide and Protein Bromination: The BromoTrp Tag

Bio-orthogonal reactions for modification of proteins and unprotected peptides are of high value in chemical biology. The combination of enzymatic halogenation with transition metal-catalyzed cross-coupling provides a feasible approach for the modification of proteins and unprotected peptides. By a semirational protein engineering approach, variants of the tryptophan 6-halogenase Thal were identified that enable efficient bromination of peptides with a C-terminal tryptophan residue. The substrate scope was explored using di-, tri-, and tetrapeptide arrays, leading to the identification of an optimized peptide tag we named BromoTrp tag. This tag was introduced into three model proteins. Preparative scale post-translational bromination was possible with only a single cultivation and purification step using the brominating E. coli coexpression system Brocoli. Palladium-catalyzed Suzuki-Miyaura cross-coupling of the bromoarene was achieved with Pd nanoparticle catalysts at 37 °C, highlighting the rich potential of this strategy for bio-orthogonal functionalization and conjugation.

Characterization of an N-Allylglyoxylamide-Based Bioorthogonal Nitrone Trap

Aldehydes are attractive bioorthogonal coupling partners. The ease of manipulation of aldehydes and their orthogonality to other classes of bioorthogonal reactions have inspired the exploration of chemistries, which generate irreversible conjugates. Similarly, nitrones have been shown to be potent 1,3-dipoles in bioorthogonal reactions when paired with strained alkynes. Here, we combine the reactivity of nitrones with the simplicity of aldehydes using an N-allylglyoxylamide, in a cascade reaction with an N-alkylhydroxylamine to produce a bicyclic isoxazolidine. The reaction is found to be catalyzed by 5-methoxyanthranilic acid and proceeds at pH 7 with favorable kinetics. Using the HaloTag7 protein bearing an N-alkylhydroxylamine, we show the reaction to be bioorthogonal in a complex cell lysate and to proceed well at the surface of a HEK293 cell. Furthermore, the reaction is compatible with a typical strain-promoted alkyne-azide click reaction. The characteristics of this reaction suggest it will be a useful addition to the pallet of bioorthogonal reactions that have revolutionized chemical biology.

Bacterial enzymes: powerful tools for protein labeling, cell signaling, and therapeutic discovery

Bacteria have evolved a diverse set of enzymes that enable them to subvert host defense mechanisms as well as to form part of the prokaryotic immune system. Due to their unique and varied biochemical activities, these bacterial enzymes have emerged as key tools for understanding and investigating biological systems. In this review, we summarize and discuss some of the most prominent bacterial enzymes used for the site-specific modification of proteins, in vivo protein labeling, proximity labeling, interactome mapping, signaling pathway manipulation, and therapeutic discovery. Finally, we provide a perspective on the complementary advantages and limitations of using bacterial enzymes compared with chemical probes for exploring biological systems.

Promiscuous Enzymes for Residue-Specific Peptide and Protein Late-Stage Functionalization

The late-stage functionalization of peptides and proteins holds significant promise for drug discovery and facilitates bioorthogonal chemistry. This selective functionalization leads to innovative advances in in vitro and in vivo biological research. However, it is a challenging endeavor to selectively target a certain amino acid or position in the presence of other residues containing reactive groups. Biocatalysis has emerged as a powerful tool for selective, efficient, and economical modifications of molecules. Enzymes that have the ability to modify multiple complex substrates or selectively install nonnative handles have wide applications. Herein, we highlight enzymes with broad substrate tolerance that have been demonstrated to modify a specific amino acid residue in simple or complex peptides and/or proteins at late-stage. The different substrates accepted by these enzymes are mentioned together with the reported downstream bioorthogonal reactions that have benefited from the enzymatic selective modifications.

Exploring the Chemical Properties and Medicinal Applications of Tetramethylthiocycloheptyne Sulfoximine Used in Strain-Promoted Azide-Alkyne Cycloaddition Reactions

The recently developed compound, tetramethylthiocycloheptyne sulfoximine (TMTHSI), has shown to be a promising strained alkyne for strain-promoted azide-alkyne cycloaddition (SPAAC), metal-free click chemistry. This research explores the properties of TMTHSI-based compounds via three aspects: (1) large-scale production, (2) unique stability in acidic conditions and its subsequent use in peptide synthesis, and (3) the functionalization of antibodies. Here, it is shown that (1) scale-up is achieved on a scale of up to 100 g. (2) TMTHSI is remarkably stable against TFA allowing for the site-specific functionalization of peptides on resin. Finally, (3) the functionalization of an antibody with a model payload is very efficient, with antibody conjugation demonstrating more beneficial features such as a high yield and limited hydrophobicity as compared to other alkyne reagent conjugates. These results illustrate the high potential of TMTHSI for diverse bioconjugation applications, with production already being GMP-compatible and a highly efficient conversion resulting in attractive costs of goods.

Enzymatic Bioconjugation: A Perspective from the Pharmaceutical Industry

Enzymes have firmly established themselves as bespoke catalysts for small molecule transformations in the pharmaceutical industry, from early research and development stages to large-scale production. In principle, their exquisite selectivity and rate acceleration can also be leveraged for modifying macromolecules to form bioconjugates. However, available catalysts face stiff competition from other bioorthogonal chemistries. In this Perspective, we seek to illuminate applications of enzymatic bioconjugation in the face of an expanding palette of new drug modalities. With these applications, we wish to highlight some examples of current successes and pitfalls of using enzymes for bioconjugation along the pipeline and try to illustrate opportunities for further development.

Single and dual functionalization of proteins using site-specific nucleophilic carbon ligations

We here found that while Meldrum's acid as the reactive warhead allows for the attachment of a single chemical modification on aldehyde-containing proteins, pyrazolone derivatives in combination with a phosphine nucleophile enable protein dual site-specific conjugation with the same or distinct moieties. These reactions are efficient and convergent under biocompatible conditions and allow access to protein bioconjugates with superior stability, homogeneity and flexibility. Our work expands the repertoire of bioconjugation chemistries and offers opportunities to construct bioconjugates with defined structure that have potential for medical and biomaterial applications.

Galactose Oxidase Enables Modular Assembly of Conjugates from Native Antibodies with High Drug-to-Antibody Ratios

The potential of antibody conjugates with high drug loading in anticancer therapy has recently been highlighted by the approval of Trastuzumab deruxtecan and Sacituzumab govitecan. These biopharmaceutical approaches have spurred interest in bioconjugation strategies with high and defined degrees of drug-to-antibody ratio (DAR), in particular on native antibodies. Here, a glycoengineering methodology was developed to generate antibody drug conjugates with DAR of up to eight, by combining highly selective enzymatic galactosylation and oxidation with biorthogonal tandem Knoevenagel-Michael addition chemistry. This four-step approach offers a selective route to conjugates from native antibodies with high drug loading, and thus illustrates how biocatalysis can be used for the generation of biopharmaceuticals using mild reaction conditions.

Genetically Encoded Ratiometric pH Sensors for the Measurement of Intra- and Extracellular pH and Internalization Rates

pH-sensitive fluorescent proteins as genetically encoded pH sensors are promising tools for monitoring intra- and extracellular pH. However, there is a lack of ratiometric pH sensors, which offer a good dynamic range and can be purified and applied extracellularly to investigate uptake. In our study, the bright fluorescent protein CoGFP_V0 was C-terminally fused to the ligand epidermal growth factor (EGF) and retained its dual-excitation and dual-emission properties as a purified protein. The tandem fluorescent variants EGF-CoGFP-mTagBFP2 (pK′ = 6.6) and EGF-CoGFP-mCRISPRed (pK′ = 6.1) revealed high dynamic ranges between pH 4.0 and 7.5. Using live-cell fluorescence microscopy, both pH sensor molecules permitted the conversion of fluorescence intensity ratios to detailed intracellular pH maps, which revealed pH gradients within endocytic vesicles. Additionally, extracellular binding of the pH sensors to cells expressing the EGF receptor (EGFR) enabled the tracking of pH shifts inside cultivation chambers of a microfluidic device. Furthermore, the dual-emission properties of EGF-CoGFP-mCRISPRed upon 488 nm excitation make this pH sensor a valuable tool for ratiometric flow cytometry. This high-throughput method allowed for the determination of internalization rates, which represents a promising kinetic parameter for the in vitro characterization of protein–drug conjugates in cancer therapy.

Bivalent EGFR-Targeting DARPin-MMAE Conjugates

Epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) is a validated tumor marker overexpressed in various cancers such as squamous cell carcinoma (SSC) of the head and neck and gliomas. We constructed protein-drug conjugates based on the anti-EGFR Designed Ankyrin Repeat Protein (DARPin) E01, and compared the bivalent DARPin dimer (DD1) and a DARPin-Fc (DFc) to the monomeric DARPin (DM) and the antibody derived scFv425-Fc (scFvFc) in cell culture and a mouse model. The modular conjugation system, which was successfully applied for the preparation of protein-drug and -dye conjugates, uses bio-orthogonal protein-aldehyde generation by the formylglycine-generating enzyme (FGE). The generated carbonyl moiety is addressed by a bifunctional linker with a pyrazolone for a tandem Knoevenagel reaction and an azide for strain-promoted azide-alkyne cycloaddition (SPAAC). The latter reaction with a PEGylated linker containing a dibenzocyclooctyne (DBCO) for SPAAC and monomethyl auristatin E (MMAE) as the toxin provided the stable conjugates DD1-MMAE (drug-antibody ratio, DAR = 2.0) and DFc-MMAE (DAR = 4.0) with sub-nanomolar cytotoxicity against the human squamous carcinoma derived A431 cells. In vivo imaging of Alexa Fluor 647-dye conjugates in A431-xenografted mice bearing subcutaneous tumors as the SCC model revealed unspecific binding of bivalent DARPins to the ubiquitously expressed EGFR. Tumor-targeting was verified 6 h post-injection solely for DD1 and scFvFc. The total of four administrations of 6.5 mg/kg DD1-MMAE or DFc-MMAE twice weekly did not cause any sequela in mice. MMAE conjugates showed no significant anti-tumor efficacy in vivo, but a trend towards increased necrotic areas (p = 0.2213) was observed for the DD1-MMAE (n = 5).

Site-Specific Conjugation Strategy for Dual Antibody-Drug Conjugates Using Aerobic Formylglycine-Generating Enzymes

Multiple, site-specific protein conjugation is increasingly attractive for the generation of antibody-drug conjugates (ADCs). As it is important to control the number and position of cargoes in an ADC, position-selective generation of reactive sites in the protein of interest is required. Formylglycine (FGly) residues are generated by enzymatic conversion of cysteine residues embedded in a certain amino acid sequence motif with a formylglycine-generating enzyme (FGE). The addition of copper ions increases FGE activity leading to the conversion of cysteines within less readily accepted sequences. With this tuned enzyme activity, it is possible to address two different recognition sequences using two aerobic formylglycine-generating enzymes. We demonstrate an improved and facile strategy for the functionalization of a DARPin (designed ankyrin repeat protein) and the single-chain antibody scFv425-Fc, both directed against the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). The single-chain antibody was conjugated with monomethyl auristatin E (MMAE) and carboxyfluorescein (CF) and successfully tested for receptor binding, internalization, and cytotoxicity in cell culture, respectively.

Bifunctional Reagents for Formylglycine Conjugation: Pitfalls and Breakthroughs

Formylglycine-generating enzymes specifically oxidize cysteine within the consensus sequence CxPxR to Cα -formylglycine (FGly). This noncanonical electrophilic amino acid can subsequently be addressed selectively by bioorthogonal hydrazino-iso-Pictet-Spengler (HIPS) or Knoevenagel ligation to attach payloads like fluorophores or drugs to proteins to obtain a defined payload-to-protein ratio. However, the disadvantages of these conjugation techniques include the need for a large excess of conjugation building block, comparably low reaction rates and limited stability of FGly-containing proteins. Therefore, functionalized clickable HIPS and tandem Knoevenagel building blocks were synthesized, conjugated to small proteins (DARPins) and subsequently linked to strained alkyne-containing payloads for protein labeling. This procedure allowed the selective bioconjugation of one or two DBCO-carrying payloads with nearly stoichiometric amounts at low concentrations. Furthermore, an azide-modified tandem Knoevenagel building block enabled the synthesis of branched PEG linkers and the conjugation of two fluorophores, resulting in an improved signal-to-noise ratio in live-cell fluorescence-imaging experiments targeting the EGF receptor.