Why is digital pathology in cytopathology lagging behind surgical pathology?

How many more slides to go until we fully adopt digital cytology?

Two‐liner/synopsis: The digital cytology hub (DCH) has been established under the umbrella of the Cytopathology journal. DCH will help bring about the crucial changes needed to make digital cytology the way of practicing cytology in our laboratories.

Validation of digital image slides for diagnosis in cervico-vaginal cytology

OBJECTIVE

To test the diagnostic concordance between microscopic (MI) and digital (DG) observation of cervico-vaginal (CV) cytology in a validation study of the technique.

METHODS

Five cytotechnologists (CT) reviewed 888 routine CV cytology cases from the Cervical Pathology Unit of our center over a 2-week period of time. The cases were first observed by MI and at the end of the day the cases were observed by DG.

STATISTICAL ANALYSIS USED

Agreement calculated using the Kappa index.

RESULTS

Most of the diagnoses corresponded to benign (64%) or inflammatory conditions (14%) and 24% corresponded to the intraepithelial lesion or malignancy (ILM) category. The overall kappa coefficient of concordance was strong (0.87). Among the different CTs it was almost perfect in two, strong in two and moderate in one. In 18 cases (10%) there were discrepancies between techniques in the category of ILM. In 10 (56%) cases there was an overdiagnosis in DG and in 8 (44%) an overdiagnosis in MI. Only in two cases, the diagnostic discrepancy exceeded one degree of difference between lesions, and they were ASCUS or AGUS for DG and CIN 2 for MI.

CONCLUSIONS

In this validation test in which routine cases during a two-week period have been used, observing the cases with both techniques on the same day, we have obtained a strong degree of concordance. The discordances obtained have not been considered relevant.

Whole Slide Imaging Technology and Its Applications: Current and Emerging Perspectives

Background. Whole slide imaging (WSI) represents a paradigm shift in pathology, serving as a necessary first step for a wide array of digital tools to enter the field. It utilizes virtual microscopy wherein glass slides are converted into digital slides and are viewed by pathologists by automated image analysis. Its impact on pathology workflow, reproducibility, dissemination of educational material, expansion of service to underprivileged areas, and institutional collaboration exemplifies a significant innovative movement. The recent US Food and Drug Administration approval to WSI for its use in primary surgical pathology diagnosis has opened opportunities for wider application of this technology in routine practice. Main Text. The ongoing technological advances in digital scanners, image visualization methods, and the integration of artificial intelligence-derived algorithms with these systems provide avenues to exploit its applications. Its benefits are innumerable such as ease of access through the internet, avoidance of physical storage space, and no risk of deterioration of staining quality or breakage of slides to name a few. Although the benefits of WSI to pathology practices are many, the complexities of implementation remain an obstacle to widespread adoption. Some barriers including the high cost, technical glitches, and most importantly professional hesitation to adopt a new technology have hindered its use in routine pathology. Conclusions. In this review, we summarize the technical aspects of WSI, its applications in diagnostic pathology, training, and research along with future perspectives. It also highlights improved understanding of the current challenges to implementation, as well as the benefits and successes of the technology. WSI provides a golden opportunity for pathologists to guide its evolution, standardization, and implementation to better acquaint them with the key aspects of this technology and its judicial use. Also, implementation of routine digital pathology is an extra step requiring resources which (currently) does not usually result increased efficiency or payment.

Changing digital and telecytology practices post COVID-19 comparing ASC survey results from 2016 to 2023

INTRODUCTION

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the need for digital pathology tools became more urgent. However, there needs to be more knowledge of the use in cytology. We aimed to evaluate current digital cytology practices and attitudes and compare the results with a pre-COVID-19 American Society of Cytopathology (ASC) survey.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fourteen survey questions assessing current attitudes toward digital cytology were developed from a 2016 ASC Digital Pathology Survey. Ten new survey questions were also created to evaluate telecytology use. The survey was e-mailed to ASC members over 6 weeks in 2023.

RESULTS

A total of 123 individuals responded (116 in 2016). Attitudes toward digital cytology were unchanged; most participants stated digital cytology is beneficial (87% 2023 versus 90% 2016). The percentage of individuals using digital cytology was unchanged (56% in 2016 and 2023). However, telecytology for rapid onsite assessment (ROSE) is now considered the best application (55% 2023 versus 31% 2016). Forty-three institutions reported using digital and telecytology tools; 40% made implementations after 2020; most did not feel that COVID-19 affected digital cytology (56%). Telecytology for ROSE is the most common application now (78%) compared with education (30%) in 2016. Limitations for implementing digital imaging in cytology included inability to focus (38%) and expense (33%).

CONCLUSIONS

General attitudes toward digital tools by the cytology community have essentially remained the same between 2016 and now. However, telecytology for ROSE is increasingly being used, which supports a need for validation and competency guidelines.

Digital analyses of nuclear features can help discriminate among non-invasive follicular thyroid neoplasm with papillary-like nuclear features, papillary thyroid carcinoma follicular subtype, and follicular carcinoma in cytological specimens

BACKGROUND

As it stands, the diagnosis of non-invasive follicular thyroid neoplasm with papillary-like nuclear features (NIFTP) is primarily based on histological analysis. We hypothesised that computerised analysis of nuclear images of cytological specimens could be used to differentiate NIFTP from papillary thyroid carcinoma follicular subtype (PTCFS) and follicular carcinoma (FC), influencing patient management.

METHODS

We employed a retrospective analytical observational study based on nuclear morphometric variables of cytological material from thyroid nodules classified as PTCFS, NIFTP, or FC. Five cases of each entity were analysed. Cytological slides were photographed, and 1170 cells for each entity were analysed digitally. The captured images were evaluated (blindly) using the ImageJ software package. The morphometric evaluation included area, perimeter, width, height, and circularity. Numerical variables were expressed as mean, median, minimum, and maximum (min; max) values. Kruskal-Wallis and Dunn's tests were used with a 5% significance level.

RESULTS

Regarding nuclear analysis, all variables differed among the three groups (p < 0.001). Given the interdependence among the variables, these data indicated that nuclear size was greatest in the NIFTP group, followed by FC and PTCFS.

DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION

Our analysis of the digital images, with a focus on nuclear parameters, found significantly difference among cytological specimens from cases of NIFTP, PTCFS and FC. Thus, this tool has the potential to provide additional information that may help in the diagnosis of NIFTP, even during the preoperative period. Additional studies are needed to create protocols, evaluate the applicability of nuclear morphological and morphometric parameters-focusing on digital pathology-and create algorithms and tools to assist cytopathologists with their diagnostic routines.

Integrating cytology into routine digital pathology workflow: a 5-year journey

Despite recent advances in digital imaging, the adoption of digital cytology is challenging due to technical limitations. This study describes our 5-year institutional experience with the implementation of digital cytology. The routine cytology workflow included conventional two-step screening by cytotechnologists, followed by sign out by pathologists. We introduced sign out of cytologic cases using a microscopic digital imaging platform operated by cytotechnologists, which allowed for remote review of slides by cytopathologists via video streaming. We also provided cytologic correlation to support the virtual slide-based sign out of histopathological specimens and for a weekly pathology-radiology conference. In addition, positive cytology cases were archived for integration into the laboratory information system and for prospective computational pathology studies. We also summarized lessons learned over the years and outlined our vision for future developments. This unique experience may serve as a role model for other institutions.

Validation of full-remote reporting for cervicovaginal cytology: the Caltagirone-Acireale distributed lab

INTRODUCTION

Cervical cancer is the fourth most common cancer in women, and its prevention is based on vaccination and screening. Screening consists of molecular human papillomavirus (HPV) testing and cytologic analysis of cervical smears, which require expensive equipment and the interaction of numerous professionals such as biologists, cytologists, laboratory technicians, and pathologists.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We centralize the cervical samples from more than 51 clinics in 1 main laboratory, where automated HPV testing is performed. HPV-positive cases are collected and used to prepare a liquid-based cytology slide, which is stained and immediately scanned. The resulting whole-slide images (WSIs) are immediately available in a remote laboratory where they are examined by experienced cytologists using virtual microscopy. This setup was validated by making each of the 3 readers independently diagnose 506 specimens in random order, using both conventional light microscopy (CLM) and WSIs, with a minimum wash-out period of 3 weeks and with a final discussion for all cases.

RESULTS

Intraobserver agreement among CLM and WSI ranged from 0.71 to 0.79, and interobserver agreement for the 3 readers compared with the consensus diagnosis was similar for the 2 modes of assessment. Readers subjectively felt confident in their WSI diagnosis for inadequate and negative cases, but less so in other cases. The perceived difficulty was slightly higher in WSI readings.

CONCLUSIONS

Interobserver agreement in cervicovaginal cytology is moderate and does not vary if the slides are examined conventionally or digitally. Despite higher reported subjective difficulty and lower confidence in the WSI diagnosis, we did not observe a deterioration in diagnostic performance using WSI compared with CLM.

The slow-paced digital evolution of pathology: lights and shadows from a multifaceted board

Objective

The digital revolution in pathology represents an invaluable resource fto optimise costs, reduce the risk of error and improve patient care, even though it is still adopted in a minority of laboratories. Barriers include concerns about initial costs, lack of confidence in using whole slide images for primary diagnosis, and lack of guidance on transition. To address these challenges and develop a programme to facilitate the introduction of digital pathology (DP) in Italian pathology departments, a panel discussion was set up to identify the key points to be considered.

Methods

On 21 July 2022, an initial conference call was held on Zoom to identify the main issues to be discussed during the face-to-face meeting. The final summit was divided into four different sessions: (I) the definition of DP, (II) practical applications of DP, (III) the use of AI in DP, (IV) DP and education.

Results

Essential requirements for the implementation of DP are a fully tracked and automated workflow, selection of the appropriate scanner based on the specific needs of each department, and a strong commitment combined with coordinated teamwork (pathologists, technicians, biologists, IT service and industries). This could reduce human error, leading to the application of AI tools for diagnosis, prognosis and prediction. Open challenges are the lack of specific regulations for virtual slide storage and the optimal storage solution for large volumes of slides.

Conclusion

Teamwork is key to DP transition, including close collaboration with industry. This will ease the transition and help bridge the gap that currently exists between many labs and full digitisation. The ultimate goal is to improve patient care.

Digital pathology world tour

Objective

Digital pathology (DP) is currently in the spotlight and is rapidly gaining ground, even though the history of this field spans decades. Despite great technological progress, the adoption of DP for routine clinical diagnostic use remains limited.

Methods

A systematic search was conducted in the electronic databases Pubmed-MEDLINE and Embase. Inclusion criteria were all published studies that encompassed any application of DP.

Results

Of 4888 articles retrieved, 4041 were included. Relevant articles were categorized as "diagnostic" (147/4041, 4%) where DP was utilized for routine diagnostic workflow and "non-diagnostic" (3894/4041, 96%) for all other applications. The "non-diagnostic" articles were further categorized according to DP application including "artificial intelligence" (33%), "education" (5%), "narrative" (17%) for reviews and editorials, and "technical" (45%) for pure research publications.

Conclusion

This manuscript provided temporal and geographical insight into the global adoption of DP by analyzing the published scientific literature.

Assessing the quality of cytopathology whole slide imaging for education from archived cases

INTRODUCTION

Many institutions have cytopathology case archives for education. Unfortunately, these slides deteriorate over time and have limited accessibility. Whole slide imaging (WSI) can overcome these limitations. However, suboptimal image quality and scanning effort are barriers.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We selected 123 slides from cytopathology study sets for WSI scanning at 400x magnification without z-stacking. The Ventana DP 200 scanner and Virtuoso software were used. Slides were scanned in 2 rounds: the first round of slides was prepared for scanning with light cleaning, and the second round was performed only on slides that had unacceptable WSI quality after thorough cleaning. Slides were assessed with a 4-tier grading system created by the authors. Time to scan each slide was recorded.

RESULTS

Within the first round, 96 of 123 (78%) slides scanned were determined to be of acceptable quality. After the second round of scanning, in total, 118 of 123 (95.9%) slides were determined to be of acceptable quality. The average time needed to scan each slide was 213 seconds.

CONCLUSIONS

The majority of slides scanned were of acceptable quality in the first round of scanning. After cleaning and rescanning, nearly every slide investigated was of acceptable quality. The primary objective is to provide other institutions that may be considering a similar project a benchmark so that they know what to expect in terms of slide scan success rate and the amount of time needed to digitize slides for educational archiving. This pilot study demonstrates the feasibility of using WSI for cytology education cases.

Evaluating the role of Z-stack to improve the morphologic evaluation of urine cytology whole slide images for high-grade urothelial carcinoma: Results and review of a pilot study

BACKGROUND

Whole slide imaging (WSI) adoption has been slower in cytopathology due, in part, to challenges in multifocal plane scanning on 3-dimensional cell clusters. ThinPrep and other liquid-based preparations may alleviate the issue by reducing clusters in a concentrated area. This study investigates the use of Z-stacked images for diagnostic assessment and the experience of evaluating urine ThinPrep WSI.

METHODS

Thirty ThinPrep urine cases of high-grade urothelial carcinoma (n = 22) and cases of negative for high-grade urothelial carcinoma (n = 8) were included. Slides were scanned at 40× magnification without Z-stack and with Z-stack at 3 layers, 1 μm each. Six cytopathologists and 1 cytotechnologist evaluated the cases in 2 rounds with a 2-week wash-out period in a blinded manner. A Cohen's Kappa (CK) calculated concordance rates. A survey after each round evaluated participant experience.

RESULTS

CK with the original report ranged from 0.606 to 1.0 (P < .05) without Z-stack and 0.533 to 1.0 (P < .05) with Z-stack both indicating substantial-to-perfect concordance. For both rounds, interobserver CK was moderate-to-perfect (0.417-1.0, P < .05). Intraobserver CK was 0.697-1.0 (P < 0.05), indicating substantial to perfect concordance. The average scan time and file size for slides without Z-stack and with Z-stack are 6.27 minute/0.827 GB and 14.06 minute/2.650 GB, respectively. Surveys demonstrated a range in comfort and use with slightly more favorable opinions for Z-stacked cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Z-stack images provide minimal diagnostic benefit for urine ThinPrep WSI. In addition, Z-stacked urine WSI does not justify the prolonged scan times and larger storage needs compared to those without Z-stack.

Digital validation of breast biomarkers (ER, PR, AR, and HER2) in cytology specimens using three different scanners

Progression in digital pathology has yielded new opportunities for a remote work environment. We evaluated the utility of digital review of breast cancer immunohistochemical prognostic markers (IHC) using whole slide images (WSI) from formalin fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) cytology cell block specimens (CB) using three different scanners.CB from 20 patients with breast cancer diagnosis and available IHC were included. Glass slides including 20 Hematoxylin and eosin (H&E), 20 Estrogen Receptor (ER), 20 Progesterone Receptor (PR), 16 Androgen Receptor (AR), and 20 Human Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor 2 (HER2) were scanned on 3 different scanners. Four breast pathologists reviewed the WSI and recorded their semi-quantitative scoring for each marker. Kappa concordance was defined as complete agreement between glass/digital pairs. Discordances between microscopic and digital reads were classified as a major when a clinically relevant change was seen. Minor discordances were defined as differences in scoring percentages/staining pattern that would not have resulted in a clinical implication. Scanner precision was tabulated according to the success rate of each scan on all three scanners.In total, we had 228 paired glass/digital IHC reads on all 3 scanners. There was strong concordance kappa ≥0.85 for all pathologists when comparing paired microscopic/digital reads. Strong concordance (kappa ≥0.86) was also seen when comparing reads between scanners.Twenty-three percent of the WSI required rescanning due to barcode detection failures, 14% due to tissue detection failures, and 2% due to focus issues. Scanner 1 had the best average precision of 92%. HER2 IHC had the lowest intra-scanner precision (64%) among all stains.This study is the first to address the utility of WSI in breast cancer IHC in CB and to validate its reporting using 3 different scanners. Digital images are reliable for breast IHC assessment in CB and offer similar reproducibility to microscope reads.

Digital Pathology Workflow Implementation at IPATIMUP

The advantages of the digital methodology are well known. In this paper, we provide a detailed description of the process for the digital transformation of the pathology laboratory at IPATIMUP, the major modifications that operate throughout the processing pipeline, and the advantages of its implementation. The model of digital workflow implementation at IPATIMUP demonstrates that careful planning and adoption of simple measures related to time, space, and sample management can be adopted by any pathology laboratory to achieve higher quality and easy digital transformation.

High throughput slanted scanning whole slide imaging system for digital pathology

In whole slide imaging (WSI), normally only a one layer imaging of the slide is performed. Autofocus at multiple positions is usually required. But defocus blur still exists due to tissue folding or specimen thickness. Repeated Z-stack scan be applied here, which, however, is too time consuming. Here, a high throughput slanted scanning WSI system is reported. In this system, the slide surface was slanted 1° relative to the focal plane. Thus, the focal plane spanned multiple layers of the sample. By moving the slide, multi-layer image data of the sample can be acquired simultaneously at a time frame comparable to conventional 1-layer imaging. With image fusion, defocus blur can be avoided. High quality and fast imaging of both cytological and histological slide specimens was demonstrated without applying aberration correction. The system can be a highly efficient way for the application of WSI in digital pathology.

Development and validation of a deep learning system for ascites cytopathology interpretation

BACKGROUND

Early diagnosis of Peritoneal metastasis (PM) is clinically significant regarding optimal treatment selection and avoidance of unnecessary surgical procedures. Cytopathology plays an important role in early screening of PM. We aimed to develop a deep learning (DL) system to achieve intelligent cytopathology interpretation, especially in ascites cytopathology.

METHODS

The original ascites cytopathology image dataset consists of 139 patients' original hematoxylin-eosin (HE) and Papanicolaou (PAP) Staining images. DL system was developed using transfer learning (TL) to achieve cell detection and classification. Pre-trained alexnet, vgg16, goolenet, resnet18 and resnet50 models were studied. Cell detection dataset consists of 176 cropped images with 6573 annotated cell bounding boxes. Cell classification data set consists of 487 cropped images with 18,558 and 6089 annotated malignant and benign cells in total, respectively.

RESULTS

We established a novel ascites cytopathology image dataset and achieved automatically cell detection and classification. DetectionNet based on Faster R-CNN using pre-trained resnet18 achieved cell detection with 87.22% of cells' Intersection of Union (IoU) bigger than the threshold of 0.5. The mean average precision (mAP) was 0.8316. The ClassificationNet based on resnet50 achieved the greatest performance in cell classification with AUC = 0.8851, Precision = 96.80%, FNR = 4.73%. The DL system integrating the separately trained DetectionNet and Classificationnet showed great performance in the cytopathology image interpretation.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrate that the integration of DL can improve the efficiency of healthcare. The DL system we developed using TL techniques achieved accurate cytopathology interpretation, and had great potential to be integrated into clinician workflow.

Learning cytology in times of pandemic: an educational institutional experience with remote teaching

Introduction

As the coronavirus pandemic swept across national and state borders, institutions of higher learning, including cytology, began closing campuses and moving instruction online. We have described a method of remotely teaching cytology in our institution, including using the telecytology concept used with rapid onsite evaluation and remote conferencing and educational tools to conduct eCytology learning. This is a cost-effective method to transition a traditional in-classroom program into online teaching for cytology. It can also be implemented quickly.

Materials and methods

In March 2020, our cytology program developed a method for teaching cytology remotely. The distance-learning teaching method included the use of remote conferencing (Zoom platform) and learning management platforms (Canvas) to present lectures and administer tests. Remote multihead sessions were conducted by adapting the telecytology rapid onsite evaluation concept, which attaches a mobile device to the microscope to transmit live video to remote learners.

Results

When asked about their experience with online learning, the students had responded positively. All the students indicated a willingness to attend classes remotely in the future, even when the traditional in-classroom learning option is available.

Conclusions

We have presented a method for educating students remotely using existing technology that is affordable and can be implemented quickly by nearly all cytology education programs.

•

Our experience with teaching eCytology in times of pandemic can serve as a cost-effective way to transition a traditionally in-classroom program, into an online teaching in cytology. It can also be implemented quickly.

•

Remote multi-head sessions, conducted by adapting the tele-cytology ROSE concept with an attached mobile device to the microscope, is an effective approach to distance learning in times of social distancing and is a promising tool for the future cytology education.

•

The students, when asked about their experiences with online learning, responded positively.

Current state of whole slide imaging use in cytopathology: Pros and pitfalls

Whole slide imaging (WSI) allows generation of large whole slide images and their navigation with zoom in and out like a true virtual microscope. It has become widely used in surgical pathology for many purposes, such as education and training, research activity, teleconsultation, and primary diagnosis. However, in cytopathology, the use of WSI has been lagging behind histology, mainly due to the cytological specimen's characteristics, as groups of cells of different thickness are distributed throughout the slide. To allow the same focusing capability of light microscope, slides have to be scanned at multiple focal planes, at the cost of longer scan times and larger file size. These are the main technical pitfalls of WSI for cytopathology, partly overcome by solutions like liquid-based preparations. Validation studies for the use in primary diagnosis are less numerous and more heterogeneous than in surgical pathology. WSI has been proved effective for training students and successfully used in proficiency testing, allowing the creation of digital cytology atlases. Longer scan times are also a barrier for use in rapid on-site evaluation, but WSI retains its advantages of easy sharing of images for consultation, multiple simultaneous viewing in different locations, the possibility of unlimited annotations and easy integration with medical records. Moreover, digital slides set the laboratory free from reliance on a physical glass slide, with no more concern of fading of stain or slide breakage. Costs are still a problem for small institutions, but WSI can also represent the beginning of a more efficient way of working.

A small-scale experimental study of breast FNA consultation on the internet using Panoptiq

INTRODUCTION

To test the potential for cytopathology consultation using Panoptiq (ViewsIQ, Richmond, BC, Canada; this is a new type of whole-slide image that is made manually and incorporates video content), we investigated its application in the cytopathological diagnosis of cases that were difficult to diagnose by breast fine-needle aspiration (FNA).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Panoptiq files were created from liquid-based cytology slides prepared by the BD CytoRich Red (BD, Franklin Lakes, NJ) method. The slides were prepared from 23 consecutive samples of breast FNA that had been diagnosed as atypical or suspicious by the Hokkaido Cancer Center, Hokkaido, Japan. Nine volunteer reviewers, who were provided with the URL of the Panoptiq file, the original cytopathological diagnosis, and the clinical information, were asked to classify the cytopathological diagnosis of each case into 4 diagnostic categories (benign, atypical, suspicious, or malignant). We examined the consultation benefit (CB)-how much closer the reviewer's cytopathology diagnosis came to the final histopathological diagnosis than the original cytodiagnosis. The CB scoring system was decided in advance.

RESULTS

All 9 reviewers showed a positive total CB score and 2 reviewers showed a significantly higher CB score (Wilcoxon's signed rank test). The representative diagnosis (ie, the most frequently rendered diagnosis in each case) also showed a significant CB.

CONCLUSIONS

Our small-scale experimental study, in which Panoptiq was used in the diagnosis of cases that were difficult to diagnose definitively by breast FNA, revealed a positive CB score by every reviewer and the representative diagnosis showed a significant CB. The study suggests that Panoptiq could be used for cytopathology consultation.

Digital pathology: semper ad meliora

This review is an evidence-based summary of digital pathology: past, present and future. It discusses digital surgical pathology and the cytopathology digitisation challenge as well as the performance of digital histopathology and cytopathology as a diagnostic tool, particularly in contrast to user perceptions. Time and cost efficiency of digital pathology, learning curves, education and quality assurance, with the importance of validation of systems, is emphasised. The review concludes with a discussion of digital pathology as a source of 'big data' and where this might lead pathologists in the digital pathology future.

Constant Quest for Quality: Digital Cytopathology

Background:

Special consideration should be given when creating and selecting cytopathology specimens for digitization to maximize quality. Advances in scanning and viewing technology can also improve whole-slide imaging (WSI) output quality.

Methods:

Accumulated laboratory experience with digitization of glass cytopathology slides was collected.

Results:

This paper describes characteristics of a cytopathology glass slide that can reduce quality on resulting WSI. Important points in the glass cytopathology slide selection process, preparation, scanning, and WSI-editing process that will maximize the quality of the resulting acquired digital image are covered. The paper outlines scanning solutions which have potential to predict issues with a glass cytopathology slide before image acquisition, allowing for adjustment of the scanning approach. WSI viewing solutions that better simulate the traditional microscope experience are also discussed.

Conclusion:

In addition to taking advantage of technical advances, practical steps can taken to maximize quality of cytopathology WSI.