The cerebellum of the bullfrog tadpole (Rana catesbeiana)

Cellular and spatial changes in the anuran superior olive across metamorphosis

In many vertebrate species, the superior olive in the auditory brainstem plays an essential role in sound source localization. Little is known, however, about the structural and functional changes in this nucleus during development when alterations in head size and shape as well as in inner ear projections are expected to affect the perception of binaural cues. Using stereological techniques, we investigated the changes in several cellular and spatial features of the bullfrog superior olive across metamorphosis, the time period during which the animal transforms from a totally aquatic larva to a semiterrestrial adult. The total number of cells shows a strongly linear increase from hatchling through late larval stages. The number of neurons decreases during metamorphic climax stages, and recovers to pre-metamorphic climax levels in the early post-metamorphic froglet stage. The number of glial cells increases during the early larval period, and remains relatively stable, with no systematic variation, from late larval to froglet stages. The volume of the superior olive increases rapidly in early larval stages, followed by a much-attenuated rate of growth between late larval and froglet stages. These morphological changes may provide a substrate for the functional restructuring of the bullfrog superior olive, shortly before the switch from aquatic to mostly atmospheric hearing.

Development of spinocerebellar afferents in the clawed toad, Xenopus laevis

The development of spinocerebellar projections in the clawed toad, Xenopus laevis, was studied with horseradish peroxidase as an anterograde and retrograde tracer. Early in development cells of origin of spinocerebellar projections were found, contralaterally, in or close to the medial motor column. In older tadpoles ipsilaterally projecting spinal neurons were also labeled from the cerebellum. These are virtually indistinguishable from the large primary motoneurons that occupy a very similar position in the spinal cord. Most of the labeled spinal cells were found in the thoracic spinal cord; they lie halfway between the brachial and lumbar secondary motor columns. Surprisingly, no primary spinocerebellar projection arising from dorsal root spinal ganglion cells could be demonstrated in X. laevis tadpoles and adult toads. Therefore, fibers in the cerebellum that were labeled anterogradely from the spinal cord can be expected to originate exclusively from the secondary spinocerebellar tract cells. These fibers appear to cross the cerebellum in or at the border of the granular layer. The present data suggest that in X. laevis early in the development of the cerebellum a distinct secondary spinocerebellar projection is already present, originating in neurons that can be compared with the "spinal border cells" in mammals. The relative sparseness of this secondary spinocerebellar projection and the apparent absence of primary spinocerebellar afferents probably indicate that spinocerebellar pathways are only of minor importance in X. laevis. The possibility remains, however, that the expansion of the secondary spinocerebellar pathway only starts when metamorphosis has been completed.

Autoradiographic studies of cerebellar histogenesis in the premetamorphic bullfrog tadpole: II. Formation of the interauricular granular band

This study examines the origin of cells in the interauricular granular band (iagb) in the cerebellum of the frog tadpole during early stages of development by means of histological and autoradiographic methods. Premetamorphic bullfrog tadpoles were exposed to multiple doses of 3H-thymidine (10 microCi/g body weight per exposure) at developmental stages ranging from 1 week to 1 year and were killed at either 6 or 12 months of age. The autoradiographic data were examined to determine the time when cells of the iagb were generated. Our findings show that initial generation of iagb cells begins at week 3 and that a peak in the formation of postmitotic neurons is reached at the age of 10 weeks. This is followed by other peaks of cell generation at the ages of 16 weeks, 10 months, and 11.5 months. The generation cycles of iagb cells are interrupted by periods of quiescence when label cannot be detected in any of the cells. These quiescent periods occur at the ages of 20-26 weeks, 7 months, and 12 months. These findings indicate that cells of the iagb are generated in a cyclical manner over the entire 1-year period which was studied. Comparison of our present data on iagb cell formation with the generation of cells in the EGL shows that the production of these two groups of cells is overlapping, but cells of the iagb begin and cease production before those of the EGL. On the basis of our findings we propose that the cells of the iagb and the EGL belong in separate cell groups which are generated by distinct subpopulations of germinal cells in the neuroepithelial cap.

Observations on the development of cerebellar afferents in Xenopus laevis

The development of cerebellar afferents has been studied in the clawed toad, Xenopus laevis, from stage 46 to 64, with the horseradish peroxidase retrograde tracer technique. Already in stage 48 tadpoles, i.e. before the formation of the limbs, a distinct set of cerebellar afferents was found. Vestibulocerebellar (mainly arising bilaterally in the nucleus vestibularis caudalis) and contralateral olivo-cerebellar projections dominate. Secondary trigeminocerebellar (from the descending nucleus of the trigeminal nerve) and reticulocerebellar connections were also found. At stage 50, spinocerebellar projections appear originating from cervical and lower thoracic/upper lumbar levels. The cells of origin of the spinocerebellar projection can be roughly divided in two neuronal types: ipsilaterally projecting large cells, which show a marked resemblance to primary motoneurones ('spinal border cells') and smaller contralaterally projecting neurons. Primary spinocerebellar projections from spinal ganglion cells could not be demonstrated. At stage 50, a possible anuran homologue of the mammalian nucleus prepositus hypoglossi was found to project to the cerebellum. In only one of the experiments labeled neurons were found in the contralateral mesencephalic tegmentum. At none of the studied stages a raphecerebellar projection could be demonstrated. It appears that already early in cerebellar development, before the formation of the limbs, most of the cerebellar afferents as found in adult Xenopus laevis are present.

Granule cell development in the frog cerebellum during spontaneous and thyroxine-induced metamorphosis

Granule cell maturation in the cerebellum of bullfrog tadpoles was studied during both spontaneous and thyroxine-induced metamorphosis by using electron microscopy and Golgi-impregnated preparations. The production of cerebellar microneurons, a majority of which are granule cell precursors, was quantitatively compared during spontaneous and thyroxine-induced metamorphosis by using stereological methods and biochemical measurements of DNA. Granule cell migration and differentiation appeared morphologically similar during spontaneous and thyroxine-induced metamorphosis. In both instances, granule cells migrated tangentially along the pial surface, migrated into the internal granular layer, developed dendritic arbors, and formed synaptic contacts with the processes of Golgi cells and with mossy fibers. These events are similar to developmental processes that have been described in detail in other animals. Quantitative stereological measurements demonstrated similar overall patterns of change during spontaneous and thyroxine-induced metamorphosis. Most notably, increases in the volume of the external granule layer correlated with increases in the relative and total amounts of DNA. However, measurements of total DNA were consistently reduced during the period of accelerated change that occurs in thyroxine-induced metamorphosis, although external granular layer volume was greater in these tadpoles after 2 and 3 weeks of thyroxine treatment than in spontaneously metamorphosing tadpoles. While granule cell development in the frog is largely dependent on thyroid hormone, differences between thyroid-hormone-induced and spontaneously metamorphosing tadpoles suggest that normal patterns of cerebellar development are also dependent on events that occur in premetamorphic tadpoles in the absence of thyroid hormone.

Stellate cell development in the frog cerebellum during spontaneous and thyroxine-induced metamorphosis

Stellate cell development was studied in the bullfrog cerebellum during spontaneous and thyroxine-induced metamorphosis using the Golgi-Kopsch method and electron microscopy. Cells that possessed axosomatic synapses and resembled stellate cells were present even in the incipient molecular layer of the cerebellum in the premetamorphic tadpole. These cells may have originated from the early, transient wave of external granule cells that have been reported in the cerebellum of premetamorphic tadpoles in the first 6 months of development, and may constitute the variant population of stellate cells that are present later during development or the degenerating cells that have been observed during metamorphosis as scattered dying cells in the molecular layer. Typical stellate cells, whose development resembled the genesis and differentiation of stellate cells in birds and mammals, were initially observed at the outer border of the molecular layer that is adjacent to the external granular layer during the onset of metamorphosis. These stellate cells were bipolar with processes extending in a plane perpendicular to elongating parallel fibers, and with progressive development, became multipolar with dendrites oriented in various directions with respect to the pia. Stellate cell axons innervate the dendrites and somata of Purkinje cells and other stellate cells, and can be categorized into two types: (1) axons with extensive branching near the soma of origin, and (2) long axons with few branches that occasionally terminate in the Purkinje cell layer. Atypical neurons that did not resemble typical stellate cells were also present in the molecular layer; these might be classified as a stellate cell variant. The generation and differentiation of stellate cells can be induced 1 to 2 years prematurely by administering thyroid hormone to premetamorphic tadpoles. Like most events of cerebellar histogenesis in the frog, stellate cell development also appears to be largely a thyroid-dependent phenomenon.

Early stages in the formation of the cerebellum in the frog

The formation of the cerebellum was studied during the first 6 months of the tadpole stage of the bullfrog by using standard histological methods and reconstructions from serial horizontal sections. Three major developmental phases were noted in the formation of the cerebellum. (1) During the first 5 weeks of development, the neuroepithelium proliferated and the dorsal mesencephalic plates increased in size. (2) Starting in the sixth week, a patch of neuroepithelium began to differentiate and gave rise to a small population of Purkinje cells. In subsequent weeks, the area of differentiation continued to spread and a Purkinje cell layer became established along the dorsal margin of the cerebellar plate. (3) In the 12th week, the ventrolateral part of the cerebellar plate began to increase in size and generate two populations of small cells. The lateralmost part of the neuroepithelium in this area generated a group of cells that formed an external granular layer that was one cell deep. Cells of this external granular layer migrated inward into the primitive molecular layer, and by the 26th week only a remnant of an external granular layer remained in the cerebellum. The more medially situated part of the neuroepithelium gave rise to another population of small cells that formed a column, which appeared to be continuous with the Purkinje cells, but differed from them in size. It should be noted that full maturation of the cerebellum occurs during metamorphosis, which in this species remains some 2 years away.

Purkinje cell maturation in the frog cerebellum during thyroxine-induced metamorphosis

Purkinje cell maturation during thyroxine-induced metamorphosis in premetamorphic bullfrog tadpoles was studied using electron microscopy and Golgi (silver-impregnated) preparations. Cerebella from tadpoles were examined following 1, 2, or 3 weeks of thyroxine treatment. Particular attention was paid to possible differences between the two populations of Purkinje cells previously described, i.e. (i) the smaller population located in the dorsal part of the cerebellum, where the Purkinje cells show dendritic arborization long before the appearance of the external granular layer, and (ii) the larger population located in the middle and ventral regions of the cerebellum, where the Purkinje cells begin to undergo maturation during metamorphosis when the external granular layer is established. Following thyroxine treatment, both populations of Purkinje cells showed rapid maturational change. In the mature (dorsal) group, dendritic growth resumed in the presence of an external granular layer increasing the complexity of their dendritic arbors. Moreover, climbing fiber synapses translocated from contacts on the soma to the thorns of growing dendrites, and somatic processes often disappeared. The immature (ventral) group showed dramatic differentiation of the perikaryon including polarization of cytoplasm with subsequent dendritic outgrowth and formation of somatic processes in the presence of climbing fibers. Stellate cell contacts appeared on the smooth portion of the soma of many Purkinje cells. Dendritic growth during thyroxine-induced metamorphosis was characterized by growth (elongation) with minimal branching, which is initially observed during spontaneous metamorphosis. Typically, these growing dendrites ended in growth cones, some with one or several filopodia. Developing Purkinje cell dendritic spines formed synapses with parallel fibers. The present study has provided an example of the dramatic nature of thyroxine's action in inducing the complex series of detailed maturational changes in the cerebellum 1-2 yr ahead of schedule. In addition, the results show that thyroxine-induced Purkinje cell maturation is more rapid and synchronous than that seen during spontaneous metamorphosis. It is concluded that Purkinje cell maturation during metamorphosis is largely dependent on thyroid hormone.

Golgi studies on Purkinje cell development in the frog during spontaneous metamorphosis. II. Details of dendritic development

The development of Purkinje cell dendrites was studied in the bullfrog from premetamorphic tadpoles to 10-week-old postmetamorphic frog-lets by the Golgi-Kopsch method. In this species two distinct patterns of arbor formation may be seen, which appear to be related to differences in the timing of initial dendritic development. In Purkinje cells that begin development in early tadpole stages, the dendritic tree is elaborated by continuous and concomitant growth and branching, a process by which the developing arbor expands in both height and width. Arbor formation in Purkinje cells that begin development in metamorphosing tadpoles proceeds in two separate steps. Initially, dendrites of such cells elongate, but form only a few poorly developed branches; only when the arbor reaches near-adult height does branching become extensive. Additional differences present in Purkinje cells are reflected in the paucity of growth cones and filopodia in the tadpole, and numerous filopodia and growth cones in the metamorphic period. An interesting feature of dendritic development in this species is a tendency to alter the arboreal domain by the formation of extra-arboreal dendrites, and possibly by the occasional resorbtion of other partially formed dendrites. The pattern of dendritic development in the frog is different than in mammals and is difficult to interpret. Such unusual development may be due to disturbances in the timing of the formation of Purkinje cell dendrites and of the establishment of the external granular layer (EGL).

Ultrastructural studies on cerebellar histogenesis in the frog: the external granular layer and the molecular layer

Maturational changes of the cerebellum of frog tadpoles were studied with the electron miscroscope. In the premetamorphic tadpole, parallel fiber-like processes (PFP) were present in the incipient molecular layer, long before the appearance of the external granular layer (EGL). These PFP showed synaptic contacts with the precociously developed Purkinje cell dendrites. It appears that these PFP may be responsible for inducing the precocious elaboration of the Purkinje cell dendritic arborization. In the metamorphosing tadpoles, the EGL cells migrating into the internal granular layer were frequently seen in close association with the ependymoglial cell processes, which extend from the pia down toward the ependymal surface. This observation lends support to the hypothesis that glial processes guide the migrating EGL cells.

Golgi studies on Purkinje cell development in the frog during spontaneous metamorphosis. I. General pattern of development

The development of Purkinje cells was studied in the bullfrog from prometamorphic tadpoles to 10-week-old postmetamorphic froglets by the Golgi-Kopsch method. In this species, the rate of Purkinje cell development is unusually slow and proceeds in two waves. The first wave of development begins prior to the establishment of the external granular layer (EGL), and proceeds slowly for two to three months during the formation of the EGL; then accelerating as metamorphosis is being completed, the cells reach near-adult dimensions a month later. Even prior to the formation of the EGL these cells are already present in the stage of dendritic orientation and flattening which, however, varies from the norm. The second wave of Purkinje cell development begins during metamorphosis and proceeds at a more rapid pace until two months after metamorphosis, at which time they appear to have reached adult dimensions. In these cells the development of the apical dendrite does not always coincide with the stellate stage but may proceed directly to the stage of dendritic orientation and flattening which, in accordance with the norm, is towards the pia and in the sagittal plane. Many variations are present in the dendritic trees and orientation of the dendritic branches of Purkinje cells throughout their development. These variations are similar to those seen in mammals, however, since the frog cerebellum consists of a simple plate, they cannot be attributed to a Cartesian transformation of dendrites to accomodate the curvatures of a folial pattern. Similarly, since these morphological variations occur in the course of normal development they cannot be attributed to a reaction to, or recovery from, injury during development.