Biphasic retinal neurogenesis in the brush-tailed possum, Trichosurus vulpecula: further evidence for the mechanisms involved in formation of ganglion cell density gradients

Development of the retina and optic pathway

Our understanding of the development of the retina and visual pathways has seen enormous advances during the past 25years. New imaging technologies, coupled with advances in molecular biology, have permitted a fuller appreciation of the histotypical events associated with proliferation, fate determination, migration, differentiation, pathway navigation, target innervation, synaptogenesis and cell death, and in many instances, in understanding the genetic, molecular, cellular and activity-dependent mechanisms underlying those developmental changes. The present review considers those advances associated with the lineal relationships between retinal nerve cells, the production of retinal nerve cell diversity, the migration, patterning and differentiation of different types of retinal nerve cells, the determinants of the decussation pattern at the optic chiasm, the formation of the retinotopic map, and the establishment of ocular domains within the thalamus.

Early born lineage of retinal neurons express class III beta-tubulin isotype

AIM

Class III beta-tubulin, a constituent of neuronal microtubules, has been frequently used as a marker for the neuronal lineage in developmental biology. In retina, it is often used as a marker for ganglion cells. We investigated the developmental expression of this protein in retina and identified the cell types expressing it to gain a better understanding of whether preferred expression of this isotype in certain retinal neurons plays a cell specific role, or whether it is only a part of an intrinsic developmental program.

METHODS

Immunohistochemistry was done using an antibody against class III beta-tubulin and other retinal cell specific markers in adult retinae of mice. Rabbit and human retinae were used to investigate if there are any species-specific differences.

RESULTS

Class III beta-tubulin was found in ganglion cells, certain amacrine cells, some horizontal cell processes and cone photoreceptors. Class III beta-tubulin was already expressed in the earliest developmental stage studied (Embryonic day 14) in developing nerve fiber layer but became distinct at the day of birth when immunoreactive cells were located in the ganglion cell layer (ganglion and displaced amacrine cells), proximal parts of neuroblastic/inner nuclear layer (amacrine cells) and distal part of neuroblastic/outer nuclear layer (photoreceptors). In one animal, class III beta-tubulin containing bodies were found in the retinal pigment epithelium cells.

CONCLUSIONS

Class III beta-tubulin is not solely expressed by ganglion cells and, therefore, cannot be used as an exclusive marker for these cells. Results show that the expression of class III beta-tubulin was not related to cell morphology or cell function, but rather to the cell lineage (early born retinal neurons) suggesting that the expression of class III beta-tubulin in certain cell types may be due to the cell specific developmental program.

Differentiation and morphological integration of neural progenitor cells transplanted into the developing mammalian eye

Transplantation of neural stem/progenitor cells has been proposed as a novel approach for the replacement and repair of damaged CNS tissues. We have evaluated the influence of the host cellular microenvironment upon the survival, differentiation, and integration of neural progenitor cells transplanted into the CNS. Using this approach, we have investigated the fate of neural progenitor cells in vivo following transplantation into the developing mammalian eye. Murine brain progenitor cells (mBPCs) isolated from neonatal mice expressing the green fluorescent protein (GFP) transgene were transplanted into the eyes of Brazilian opossums (Monodelphis domestica). Monodelphis pups are born in an extremely immature, fetal-like state. The eyes of neonatal pups provide a fetal-like environment in which to study cellular interactions between host tissues and transplanted neural progenitor cells. mBPCs were transplanted by intraocular injection in hosts ranging in age from 5 days postnatal to adult. The transplanted cells were easily identified because of their GFP fluorescence. Extensive survival, differentiation, and morphological integration of mBPCs within the host tissue was observed. We found that the younger retinas provided a more supportive environment for the morphological integration of the transplanted mBPCs. Cells with morphologies characteristic of specific retinal cell types were observed. Moreover, some transplanted mBPCs were labeled with antibodies characteristic of specific neural/retinal phenotypes. These results suggest that the host environment strongly influences progenitor cell differentiation and that transplantation of neural progenitor cells may be a useful approach aimed at treating degeneration and pathology of the CNS.

Repeated ultrasound guided fetal injections of corticosteroid alter nervous system maturation in the ovine fetus

INTRODUCTION

Recent studies in sheep have shown that repeated maternal injections of betamethasone are associated with adverse effects within the nervous system. Repeated fetal injections of betamethasone achieve serial improvements in preterm lung function in sheep and are a possible alternative to repeated maternal therapy. We have evaluated the effect of repeated fetal administration of betamethasone on nervous system maturation in an ovine model.

METHODS

Date-mated ewes (n = 48) were randomized to receive ultrasound-guided fetal injections of betamethasone or saline between days 104 to 124 of gestation and were delivered by cesarean section on day 125 or 145 (term = 150). Optic and sciatic nerves were prepared for light and electronmicroscopy. Eye diameters were measured and transverse sections of retinae were evaluated. Data were analyzed using a mixed model analysis of variance.

RESULTS

Repeated fetal administration of corticosteroid did not significantly affect optic nerve myelination but resulted in significant delays in sciatic axonal growth (p < 0.02) and retinal maturation (p < 0.04). The process of performing repeated fetal injections also significantly affected some retinal parameters.

CONCLUSION

Repeated fetal administration of betamethasone alters some aspects of nervous system maturation in sheep. It is premature to plan trials of repeated fetal corticosteroid therapy in humans.

Differential localization of SNARE complex proteins SNAP-25, syntaxin, and VAMP during development of the mammalian retina

SNARE complex proteins have critical functions during regulated vesicular release of neurotransmitter. In addition, they play critical roles during neurite outgrowth and synaptogenesis. Although it is clear that the function of any one SNARE complex protein during release of neurotransmitter is dependent on its association with other members of the complex, it is less certain whether their function during development and differentiation is dependent on interaction with one another. Previously, we have observed transient high levels of SNARE complex protein SNAP-25 in developing cholinergic amacrine cells (West Greenlee et al. [1998] J Comp Neurol 394:374-385). In addition, we detected, high levels of SNAP-25 in developing and mature photoreceptors. To better understand the functional significance of these high levels of SNAP-25 expression, we used immunocytochemistry to examine the developmental expression of the three members of the SNARE complex, SNAP-25, Syntaxin, and vesicle associated membrane protein (VAMP/also Synaptobrevin). Our results demonstrate that the high levels of SNAP-25 in cholinergic amacrine cells and photoreceptors are not accompanied by the same relatively high levels of other SNARE complex proteins. These results suggest that high levels of SNAP-25 in specific cell types may function independently of association with Syntaxin and VAMP. In this analysis, we characterized the changing patterns of immunoreactivity for the three SNARE complex proteins during the development and differentiation of the mammalian retina. We have compared the pattern of expression of the core SNARE complex proteins in the Brazilian opossum, Monodelphis domestica, and in the rat and found common patterns of expression between these diverse mammalian species. We observed temporal differences in the onset of immunoreactivity between these three proteins, and differences in their localization within synaptic layers in the developing and mature mammalian retina. This study is the first to characterize the changing expression patterns of the three SNARE complex proteins in the developing central nervous system. The differential distribution of SNAP-25, Syntaxin, and VAMP may indicate additional roles for these proteins during vesicle trafficking events, which are independent of their association with one another.

Horizontal cell differentiation in the retina of the Brazilian opossum, Monodelphis domestica

Differentiation of many diverse neuronal phenotypes is an essential part of nervous system development. We have studied the differentiation of horizontal cells, one of the basic neuronal types in the vertebrate retina, in a small, easily maintained marsupial by immunocytochemistry using antineurofilament and antivimentin antibodies. At birth the retina consists of proliferating neural epithelial cells, with a few early ganglion cells. Horizontal cells were first detected in 12-day-old pups; somas were within the epithelial neuroblastic layer and processes extended radially. By 19 days there were tangentially oriented dendrites and a few longer processes, the beginning of the outer plexiform (first synaptic) layer. By the time of eye opening (about 34 days) the basic histological organization of the mature retina was established. In the mature retina and during development, horizontal cell neurites in the outer plexiform layer, as well as ganglion cell axons, reacted strongly with several antineurofilament antibodies and with antivimentin; horizontal cell somas were detected only with one antineurofilament antibody. Only one population was detected, which we identify as the short-axon subtype, by comparison with horizontal cells in other marsupials and in eutherian mammals. This is the first description of the putative absence in a marsupial of one of the two horizontal cell subtypes found in most amniotes, including mammals so far studied, except murid rodents, which have only the short-axon subtype. Absence of one subtype in Monodelphis supports the hypothesis that the short-axon cell is the basic conserved phenotype of this class and suggests that experimental analysis of differentiation of horizontal cells in Monodelphis and murid rodents, compared to marsupials and eutherian mammals which have the basic two subtypes, can help elucidate mechanisms for controlling differentiation of specific cellular phenotypes and the variations in neurons within and among species.

Spatiotemporal pattern of ontogenetic expression of calbindin-28/kD in the retinorecipient layers of rat superior colliculus

Using an antibody against calbindin-28kD, we have studied the spatial pattern of expression of this protein in the superior colliculi (SC) of four strains of mature laboratory rats. In all four strains, calbindin-expressing cells (CECs) formed horizontally oriented tiers in the retinorecipient and intermediate gray layers but were diffusely distributed throughout the deep layers. Ontogenetically, calbindin-28kD was expressed for the first time in the retinorecipient layers at postconceptional day 20 (PCD 20), by cells located in the rostrolateral region where the first born retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) are represented. Although on the day of birth (PCD 22/23), the CECs were distributed more widely, they were still absent in the most medial part of the SC, that is, the region where the latest born RGCs are represented. The spatial distribution of CECs became adultlike only by PCD 29, that is, at the end of the period of the naturally occurring death of the RGCs. Monocular eye enucleations on PCD 23 prevented the expression of calbindin in the medial fifth of the retinorecipient layers of the contralateral SC, while the unilateral removal of the visual cortices had no discernable effect on the numbers and distribution of the CECs in either SC. Thus, the spatiotemporal pattern of ontogenetic expression of calbindin-28kD in the retinorecipient layers of SC reflects the spatiotemporal pattern of generation of the RGCs, and the retinal input appears to induce neuronal expression of calbindin-28kD in these layers.

Maturational gradients in the retina of the ferret

In the present set of studies, we have examined the site for the initiation of retinal maturation in the ferret. A variety of maturational features across the developing inner and outer retina were examined by using standard immunohistochemical, carbocyanine dye labelling, and Nissl-staining techniques, including 1) two indices of early differentiation of the first-born retinal ganglion cells, the presence of beta-tubulin and of neuron-specific enolase; 2) the receding distribution of chondroitin sulfate proteoglycans within the inner retina; 3) the distribution of the first ganglion cells to grow axons along the optic nerve; 4) the emergence of the inner plexiform layer; 5) the emergence of the outer plexiform layer and 6) the onset of synaptophysin immunoreactivity within it; 7) the differentiation of calbindin-immunoreactive horizontal cells; and 8) the cessation of proliferative activity at the ventricular surface. Although we were able to define distinct maturational gradients that are associated with many of these features of inner and outer retinal development (each considered in detail in this report), with dorsal retina maturing before ventral retina, and with peripheral retina maturing last, none showed a clear initiation in the region of the developing area centralis. Rather, maturation began in the peripapillary retina dorsal to the optic nerve head, which is consistent with previous studies on the topography of ganglion cell genesis in the ferret. These results make clear that the order of retinal maturation and the formation of the area centralis are not linked, at least not in the ferret.

Retinal pigment epithelium and photoreceptor maturation in a wallaby, the quokka

Cell generation and the early stages of maturation of the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and photoreceptors were examined in a marsupial, the quokka, Setonix brachyurus. Results are presented for animals aged up to postnatal day (P)250. RPE cell generation was studied by analysis of cell number from wholemounted retinae and by tritiated thymidine (3HThy) autoradiography in sectioned material. For 3HThy autoradiography, quokkas aged P1-P200 were injected with 3HThy and killed either 6-20 hours later (pulse-kill) or at P100 or P250 (pulse-leave). The extent of pigmentation of the RPE sheet was examined from sections of embryonic and early postnatal stages. Retinae from animals aged P5 to P160 were also examined at the electron microscope. By P100, RPE cell number is within the range found in adults. New RPE cells are generated in a peripheral band which moves outwards as cells leave the cell cycle in more central locations. RPE cells thus complete their last cell division in a centre-to-periphery wave centred about the optic nerve head. At any given retinal location, RPE cells complete their last cell division earlier than the overlying layers of the neural retina. Cells of the RPE rapidly develop a mature morphology. For example, melanin granules are observed at P5 and Verhoeff's membrane (the terminal bar complex) is evident by P25. By contrast, photoreceptor development in this species is protracted; cone inner segments are observed by P40, whilst the first rod inner segments are observed at P60. Despite being generated earlier, morphological maturation of the cones appears retarded and prolonged compared with that of the rods. The last stages of RPE cell maturation occur late in development, in synchrony with the generation of rods.

Distinct temporal patterns of expression of sodium channel-like immunoreactivity during the prenatal development of the monkey and cat retina

Polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies prepared against the alpha-subunit of the voltage-gated sodium channel (alpha NaCh) were used to examine the distribution of sodium channel-like immunoreactivity during the prenatal development of the cat and rhesus monkey (Macaca mulatta) retina. At all prenatal ages studied, beginning on embryonic day 29 (E29) in the cat and E52 in the monkey, both antibodies labelled optic axons. With the polyclonal antibodies, the appearance of positive cells largely mirrored the onset of their morphological maturation. Immunoreactivity appeared first in the somata of ganglion cells, and subsequently the inner plexiform layer could be distinguished by its intense immunolabelling. A few weeks later horizontal cells displayed immunolabelling that extended to their dendrites in the developing outer plexiform layer. This was followed by immunoreactive cones, with bipolar cells labelled only postnatally. By contrast, with the monoclonal antibody some cells were found to be immunoreactive while their somata were still in the ventricular layer (E33 in cat and E52 in monkey). Many of these cells appeared to migrate to the outer portion of the prospective inner nuclear layer, where they gradually acquired the morphological appearance of bipolar cells. Transient expression of immunolabelling with monoclonal sodium channel antibody was found in the cones of the cat and cones and rods of the monkey. These results indicate that different types of alpha NaCh-like proteins are expressed in the mammalian retina at distinct developmental periods. Their presence at very early stages during development suggests that these proteins could play a specific role in the commitment and/or differentiation of specific retinal cell types.

The morphological development of the inferior colliculus in a marsupial, the Northern quoll (Dasyurus hallucatus)

As a part of a project concerning the development of hearing, some features of the morphological development of the inferior colliculus were studied in a marsupial, the Northern quoll or native cat (Dasyurus hallucatus). Marsupials are of particular interest in developmental studies because much embryonic development occurs outside the uterus, in the pouch. Nissl-stained material was prepared from pouch-young at various ages between 11 and 81 days, and for a number of adults. Four pouch-young were injected with tritiated thymidine and killed later during pouch life. The inferior colliculus is first recognizable in pouch-young aged 23 days, when it is bordered by a cell-sparse ring of tissue. By this time, the labelling patterns following injections of tritiated thymidine made on days 7-9 suggest that migration of cells to the inferior colliculus from the ventricular germinal zone has been largely completed. At 81 days, close to the time when the young move out of the pouch, the adult cytoarchitecture--a central nucleus flanked by dorsal and lateral cortical regions--is clear. Cell areas expand monotonically as a function of age. The period of days 45-50 is associated with a large expansion of cell volume and a concomitant decrease in packing density. It is likely that functional connections are forming during this period, which may herald the onset of hearing in the quoll. Total cell numbers increase to a peak at day 36, fall to a minimum at day 50, and rise again to the adult value. The second increase is likely to be a phase of glial proliferation, in part associated with the onset of myelination. This increase correlates with departure of the young from the pouch.

Morphology and birth dates of horizontal cells in the retina of a marsupial

Most eutherian (placental) mammals have two horizontal cell types; however, one type only has been seen in rodents. In order to assess whether one type of horizontal cell or two is a basic mammalian feature, we have examined the morphology of horizontal cells in a marsupial, the quokka wallaby, by Golgi staining or horseradish peroxidase labelling. The birth dates of horizontal cells have also been determined by 3H-thymidine/autoradiography. There are two types of horizontal cell in the wallaby retina. One type has no axon and corresponds to the axonless cell in eutherian species; the other has shorter dendrites, an axon, and an axonal arbor, corresponding to the eutherian short-axon cell. As in eutherian mammals, the dendrites of each horizontal cell type lie in the outer plexiform layer (OPL) and contact cones and the axonal arbor of the short-axon cell contacts rods. The dendrites of the axonless cells are long, with an average length of 250 microns, and each cell has one, sometimes two, short, stubby processes, which branch off a dendrite, traverse the inner nuclear layer, and reach the inner plexiform layer. The dendritic field of these cells is elongated, and dendrites show a preferential orientation at right angles to the trajectory of overlying ganglion cell axons. Short-axon cells have a morphology similar to that seen in other species, although the axonal arbor is relatively small. Both types of horizontal cell are generated in the first phase of retinal cell generation.