Induction of memory and effector suppressor T cells by perinatal exposure to antigen

Special regulatory T-cell review: T-cell dependent suppression revisited

The concept of T-cell dependent regulation of immune responses has been a central tenet of immunological thinking since the delineation of the two cell system in the 1960s. Indeed T-cell dependent suppression was discovered before MHC restriction. When reviewing the data from the original wave of suppression, it is intriguing to reflect not just on the decline and fall of suppressor T cells in the 1980s, but on their equally dramatic return to respectability over the past decade. Hopefully their resurgence will be supported by solid mechanistic data that will underpin their central place in our current and future understanding of the immune system. Cannon to right of them, Cannon to left of them, Cannon in front of them Volley'd and thunder'd Storm'd at with shot and shell, Boldly they rode and well, Into the jaws of Death, Into the mouth of Hell, Rode the six hundred (suppressionists). (Adapted from The Charge of the Light Brigade, Alfred, Lord Tennyson)

Effects of halothane reexposure in female mice and their offspring

Female CBi mice subjected to multiple exposures to halothane inhalation anesthesia before mating were investigated for the potential effects of such intervention on a specific antibody response mounted by them and their offspring. An assessment of the toxicologic and reproductive performance of female mice undergoing anesthesia was also performed. Adult female mice received three episodes of halothane anesthesia at weekly intervals. Seventy-two hours after the last dose, mice were subjected to the following procedures: 1) study of the specific humoral immune response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC); 2) hematologic, hepatologic, and histopathologic studies; and 3) mating with syngeneic sires. Halothane-treated females had increased amounts of specific antibody secreting B cells, with liver studies showing evidence of microscopic fatty changes and decreased lipid peroxidation. Anesthesia did not alter reproductive performance but lowered offspring survival. Offspring displayed depressed antibody response after challenge with SRBC at weaning and at 60 d of age. The anti-SRBC antibody response that was found to be enhanced in halothane anesthetized females, seemed to be conversely impaired when studied in the offspring.

Bovine gamma globulin-specific CD4+ T cells are retained by bovine gamma-globulin-tolerant mice

Immunological tolerance is an acquired state of antigen-specific nonresponsiveness which is generally attributed to either the deletion or suppression of tolerogen-specific T helper cell clones. Unresponsiveness to xenogeneic immunoglobulins can be readily induced and has been extensively studied in order to ascertain the means by which tolerance is established and maintained. As an absence of reactivity to foreign immunoglobulin has been noted in situations where suppressor cell activity was minimized, this tolerant state has often been ascribed to clonal deletion. The present study demonstrates that bovine gamma-globulin (BGG)-tolerant mice are unable to generate humoral responses to BGG in vivo and yet harbor BGG-specific CD4+CD8- T cells which can divide and secrete interleukin 2 when stimulated in vitro. Indeed, the in vitro reactivity to BGG of these cells exceeded that of a similar population of non-immune cells. This is in direct opposition to the loss of response that would be expected if clonal deletion were operative. The presence of BGG-specific CD4+ T cells, which appear to be at least partly primed, in mice unresponsive to BGG, indicates that tolerance to BGG is likely to be dependent on unidentified immunoregulatory processes rather than clonal deletion.

A neonatally tolerant mouse model to assess pathogenicity of human autoantibodies

Since certain autoimmune diseases, including myasthenia gravis and pemphigus vulgaris can be reproduced in mice by passive transfer of immunoglobulins from affected patients, we assessed whether this procedure could be optimised. Repeated injections of human IgG into mice during pregnancy induced tolerance to human IgG in the litter, and this persisted for at least 9 months. We show that three different human autoantibodies, to mitochondria, centromere and collagen, were retained in the serum of neonatally tolerized mice, but pathogenic effects of these particular autoantibodies were not demonstrable over the four week time scale of our experiments. However, our model should be applicable to studies on human autoantibodies which might damage the appropriate tissue in a heterologous species.

The Florey lecture, 1989. Self-tolerance: the key to autoimmunity

'Horor autotoxicus', as it was termed by Erhlich, is a rare clinical event despite the genetic potential of every individual to mount immune responses to self-antigens. This can be explained by the fact that the developing immune system learns to recognize self-antigens and to tolerate them. The key to autoimmunity therefore lies in unravelling the mechanisms of self-tolerance. Studies of conventional models of unresponsiveness have failed to provide a definitive answer owing to the difficulty in controlling for the large number of antigen-related variables associated with self-tolerance and in following the fate of individual clones of self-reactive lymphocytes which emerge in very low numbers from the pre-immune repertoire. These problems have now been overcome by creation of transgenic mice tolerant to endogenous antigens and containing high frequencies of autoreactive T or B lymphocytes. According to the results obtained to date, different mechanisms of tolerance induction operate for self-reactive T lymphocytes compared with B lymphocytes. Thus self-tolerance in T lymphocytes appears to depend largely on clonal deletion within the thymus. By contrast, self-reactive B lymphocytes are functionally silenced without undergoing deletion provided that the transgenic B lymphocytes express both IgM and IgD on their surfaces. This dichotomy makes good sense given that the T-lymphocyte repertoire once shaped within the thymus is not subject to further mutation whereas antigen receptors on mature B lymphocytes undergo hypermutation in the periphery.

Specific neonatally-induced tolerance to rat male accessory glands antigens. Transference of specific suppression by spleen mononuclear cells

The immune response of infant rats was studied following (1) immunization of their mothers with modified rat male accessory glands (MRAG) emulsified in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA), (5 mg/ml or 25 mg/ml) or with human serum albumin (HSA), (5 mg/ml or 25 mg/ml) and (2) intradermal immunization of the offspring at 21 days of age with 5 mg of MRAG-CFA and 5 mg of HSA-CFA. Antibodies to MRAG or to HSA were observed in the sera obtained 20 days after the birth of the offspring. Delayed hypersensitivity (DTH) against MRAG studied 13 days after immunization was significantly reduced in the male offspring born to mothers immunized with 5 mg of MRAG-CFA compared with that of males born to mothers immunized with the same dose of HSA-CFA (P less than 0.0005). In contrast, when 25 mg of MRAG-CFA were used to immunize the mothers, the lack of DTH response to MRAG was observed in male and female offspring (P less than 0.0005 for both groups). In all cases, the DTH response to HSA was positive. The spleen mononuclear (SpM) cells transferred from rats unresponsive to MRAG to normal rats 24 h before the immunization with MRAG-CFA and HSA-CFA did not suppress the immune response whereas transference of SpM cells from suppressed animals to animals previously immunized depressed the DTH response to MRAG (suppression of the expression). The response to HSA was not affected. We can conclude that the suppression is antigen specific.

Defence against allergic sensitization in the healthy lung: the role of inhalation tolerance

Experimental animal studies indicate that under normal steady-state conditions, initial encounters with non-pathogenic antigens (i.e. inert proteins, such as pollens) do not trigger immune responses, but instead activate antigen-specific suppressor T cells which protect against subsequent allergic sensitization by inducing a state of immunological tolerance towards the inhaled antigen. This inhalation tolerance phenomenon appears analogous to the more familiar process of oral tolerance in the gastrointestinal tract, and is proposed to serve as the 'last line of defence' against sensitization to aero-allergens which have evaded other levels of containment in the respiratory tract. It is postulated that this tolerance process plays a similar protective role in man, as the final component of a multi-layer defence system centering upon the respiratory epithelium. Recent findings which indicate that both oral and inhalation tolerance mechanisms are relatively slow to develop postnatally, provides a possible basis for the increased risk of allergic sensitization recognized in infancy.

Maternal autoimmune disease influences self-tolerance in offspring: the role of suppressor cells and materno-foetal cell traffic

Autoimmune haemolytic anaemia (AIHA) was induced in normal strain (CBA/Ca/T6) mice by repeated intraperitoneal injection of rat red blood cells (RRBC). Antibody production to cross-reactive antigens on mouse red blood cells (MRBC) and foreign antigens on RRBC was measured by the direct antiglobulin test (DGAT) and serum haemagglutination, respectively. RRBC primed female or male mice and sheep red blood cell (SRBC) primed controls were mated with naive partners and their progeny immunized with RRBC in adult life. The offspring of mothers but not fathers with active autoimmune disease showed a significant reduction in antibody response to self (MRBC) antigens, whereas the response to non-self (RRBC) was unaffected. Transfer of 30 X 10(6) spleen cells from the progeny of RRBC primed mothers into non-irradiated normal recipients resulted in selective suppression of the anti-self response following challenge with RRBC, provided that the cell donors had been boosted with RRBC 7-10 days before the transfer was performed. Thus the progeny of mothers with AIHA possessed self-reactive memory suppressor cells (Ts) shown previously to belong to the Thy-1+ I-J+ Ly-2+ T cell subset in this model. To test whether the Ts were of maternal or foetal origin the suppressor assay was repeated with spleen cells from the F1 offspring of RRBC primed B10.A(3R) (I-Jb) mothers and normal CBA(I-Jk) fathers. Pretreatment with anti-I-Jb serum plus complement completely abrogated suppression on adoptive transfer but anti-I-Jk serum failed to do so, indicating that the Ts were derived from the mothers. These findings emphasize the potential importance of Ts in induction of self tolerance during early ontogeny.

Immunological discrimination between self and non-self by precursor depletion and memory accumulation

We study processes by which T-lymphocytes "learn" to discriminate "self" from "non-self". We show that intrinsic features of the T cell activation and proliferation process are sufficient to tolerize (self) reactive T-lymphocyte clones. Self vs non-self discrimination therefore develops without any down-regulatory (e.g. suppressive) interactions. T-lymphocyte clones will expand by proliferation only if the IL2 concentration is high enough to induce a proliferation rate larger than the rate of cell decay. This concentration is the proliferation threshold. Because effector T cells are short-lived the proliferation threshold must be quite high. Such high numbers of cells producing IL2 are achieved only when sufficient (memory) precursors are activated. Self and non-self antigens differ with respect the number of (memory) precursor cells they accumulate, as a result of two processes, i.e. precursor depletion and memory accumulation, and can thus be discriminated. Precursor depletion: the dynamics of long-lived precursors can cause tolerization. In neonatal circumstances precursor influx is still low, newborn cells reacting with self antigens are immediately activated, generating (few), i.e. fewer than the proliferation threshold, effectors that decay rapidly. Thus total lymphocyte numbers remain low, yielding self tolerance. Conversely, large doses of similar antigens introduced in mature systems push "their" lymphocyte clone over the proliferation threshold because a large (accumulated) precursor population is rapidly activated. Small doses are however low zone tolerized. Memory accumulation: peripheral T-lymphocyte populations in fact consist of a mixture of virgin precursors and memory cells. If the formation process of (long-lived) memory cells is taken into account and virgin precursors are made short-lived, the proliferation threshold again accounts for self non-self discrimination. Memory cells accumulate when antigenic restimulation is low; it is low when the antigen concentration and/or the antigen affinity is low. Therefore self antigens, which are present in relatively high concentrations, fail to accumulate high affinity memory cells, and are hence tolerated. Memory cells crossreacting to self antigens with low affinity, however accumulate neonatally, pushing those clones over the proliferation threshold whenever "their" high affinity antigen enters the immune system. Thus the model generates differences in the antigenicity (i.e. memory precursor frequency) of self and non-self.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

A role for suppressor T cells in induction of self-tolerance

The potential role of suppressor T cells (Ts) in the induction of self-tolerance was investigated by eliminating I-J+ cells during ontogeny (I-J antigens are encoded by the I-J subregion of the murine major histocompatibility complex). To achieve this, F1 mice were exposed to anti-I-J antibodies via the transplacental route by mating B10.A(3R) females, preimmunized with B10.A(5R) cells, with CBA males. At 6 weeks of age, the offspring were injected with rat erythrocytes (RRBC) to induce erythrocyte autoantibodies. By comparison with age-matched controls, Ts-depleted mice produced significantly higher titers of autoantibody, whereas there was no difference in the antibody response of the two groups to the foreign determinants on the RRBC. The selective increase in autoantibody production was mirrored at the clonal level by the appearance of self-reactive B-cell hybridomas after fusion of RRBC-immune spleen cells with the NS-1 cell line. On the other hand, when helper cell function of RRBC-primed cells was measured in a T-cell proliferative assay, Ts depletion in utero resulted in enhanced T-cell activity to nonself (RRBC) but not to self (mouse erythrocyte) determinants. Thus, helper T cells recognizing nonself determinants on RRBC appeared to be responsible for activating self-specific B cells, presumably through linked recognition of different epitopes on mouse erythrocytes. Taken together, these findings indicate that elimination of I-J+ cells during ontogeny can lead to the appearance and activation of "forbidden" B-cell clones and points to a central role for Ts in induction as well as maintenance of self-tolerance.

T cell tolerance studied at the level of antigenic determinants. I. Latent reactivity to lysozyme peptides that lack suppressogenic epitopes can be revealed in lysozyme-tolerant mice

Whether T cell tolerance represents direct inactivation of antigen-specific T cells via recognition of antigen plus major histocompatibility complex, or via T suppressor (Ts) cells, or a combination of these mechanisms, remains to be clarified. This problem was investigated using a novel approach based on the finding in several systems that T helper/proliferative (Th/Tp) cell-inducing antigenic determinants are dissociable from Ts cell-inducing determinants. Thus, peptide probes containing known sites that stimulate T proliferative activity, as well as peptides from distinct sites assumed to bear Ts-inducing determinants, were used in studying hen (chicken) eggwhite lysozyme (HEL)-tolerant mice. The clear prediction from clonal deletion model is that Th/Tp response potential to short peptides in the tolerant mouse would not exist, while regulatory suppression models predict the coexistence of antigen-reactive cells and antigen-specific regulatory cells that prevent their expression. Adult mice, treated with 2 mg HEL in saline, were tolerant to HEL in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA). Latent T cell proliferative responses could be revealed to determinants within two HEL peptide probes, which lacked the amino-terminal region of the molecule. This responsiveness suggested two conclusions: first, Ts cells directed against the amino terminus of lysozyme exist in the tolerant genetic responder B10.A; second, these Ts regulate the activity of functional antigen-reactive T cells directed against epitopes elsewhere on the molecule, but only in the presence of the complete molecule, HEL. Examination of neonatally induced tolerance did not reveal any latent responsiveness, supporting the hypothesis that clonal deletion or anergy is the relevant mechanism in this situation. Possible reservations in these explanations of the two tolerant states, plus analysis of the more complex "split tolerance" resulting from 20 mg HEL in saline treatment in adults, are discussed. The approach of dissociation of proliferation-inducing determinants from suppression-inducing determinants clarifies our understanding of the tolerant state and holds promise for more definitive exploration of mechanisms of T cell tolerance.

Self- and allo-specific suppressor T cells evoked by intravenous injection of F protein

The liver/serum protein F appears to inactivate clones reactive towards itself in the T helper cell but not the B cell compartment. To examine the extent of self-reactivity in the T suppressor cell compartment, the well-established procedure of i.v. injecting milligram doses of the protein was used. To detect suppression, an entirely in vitro proliferation assay was devised, based on use of immunopurified F antigen. In this way T suppressor cells could be detected after activation either by allogeneic F, or (though to a lesser extent) by self-F protein. Thus the T suppressor cell compartment contains potentially self-reactive clones, and to that extent the receptor repertoire of T suppressor cells overlaps with B rather than T helper cells.