Enhancement in Igha mouse strains of the "natural" suppressive activity of normal T splenocytes against the expression of Igh-1b allotype. I. Molecular aspects of the chronic suppression obtained

Activation and tolerance in CD4(+) T cells reactive to an immunoglobulin variable region

Antibody diversity creates an immunoregulatory challenge for T cells that must cooperate with B cells, yet discriminate between self and nonself. To examine the consequences of T cell reactions to the B cell receptor (BCR), we generated a transgenic (Tg) line of mice expressing a T cell receptor (TCR) specific for a κ variable region peptide in monoclonal antibody (mAb) 36-71. The κ epitope was originally generated by a pair of somatic mutations that arose naturally during an immune response. By crossing this TCR Tg mouse with mice expressing the κ chain of mAb 36-71, we found that κ-specific T cells were centrally deleted in thymi of progeny that inherited the κTg. Maternally derived κTg antibody also induced central deletion. In marked contrast, adoptive transfer of TCR Tg T cells into κTg recipients resulted in T and B cell activation, lymphadenopathy, splenomegaly, and the production of IgG antichromatin antibodies by day 14. In most recipients, autoantibody levels increased with time, Tg T cells persisted for months, and a state of lupus nephritis developed. Despite this, Tg T cells appeared to be tolerant as assessed by severely diminished proliferative responses to the Vκ peptide. These results reveal the importance of attaining central and peripheral T cell tolerance to BCR V regions. They suggest that nondeletional forms of T tolerance in BCR-reactive T cells may be insufficient to preclude helper activity for chromatin-reactive B cells.

Role of CD40 in a T cell-mediated negative regulation of Ig production

To investigate the possible role of CD40 in a negative regulation of Ig production, we used the mouse Ig allotype suppression model. T splenocytes from IGH(a/a) mice are able in vivo to totally and chronically inhibit the production of IgG(2a)(b) (IgG2a from the IGH(b) haplotype). Accordingly, postnatal transfer of IGH(a/a) T splenocytes into histocompatible IGH(a/b) F(1) or congenic IGH(b/b) mice leads to a characteristic IgG(2a)(b) suppression. The helper action of anti-IgG(2a)(b) CD4(+) T cells is required for the recruitment of anti-IgG(2a)(b) CD8(+) T suppression effectors. The latter use perforin (pore-forming protein, Pfp)- and/or Fas-dependent cytotoxic pathways to continuously eliminate B cells recently committed to IgG(2a)(b) production. In the present study we first showed that in vivo agonistic anti-CD40 mAb treatment of IGH(a/a) mice, deprived of their CD4(+) T cell compartment, could bypass the help of Ig allotype-specific CD4(+) T cells and generate CD8(+) T effector cells able to strongly inhibit IgG(2a)(b) production. This result demonstrates the usefulness of CD40 triggering in setting up an immune regulatory mechanism. Furthermore, with regard to the suppression-effector mechanism, we demonstrated that B cell CD40 expression was required for full suppression establishment via the Fas-dependent pathway. Indeed, IGH(a/a) PFP(degrees/degrees) T cells (using exclusively the Fas pathway) induced full IgG(2a)(b) suppression against IGH(b/b) CD40(+/+) B cells, but only partial inhibition of IgG(2a)(b) production against IGH(b/b) CD40(degrees/degrees) B cells. This finding provides the first demonstration of direct involvement of B cell CD40 expression in in vivo negative control of an Ig production.

Central tolerance induction in natural immunoglobulin-allotype-specific T cells

While self toleance is induced to IgG(b)(2a) in Igh(b / b) mice, an anti-IgG(b)(2a) T cell activity emerges in their Igh(a / a) congenic counterparts. This activity is revealed by postnatal transfer of Igh(a / a) T splenocytes into Igh(a / b) F(1), in which total suppression of IgG(2a)(b) expression is established. Here, we sought to determine whether the natural T cell unresponsiveness to IgG(2a)(b) in Igh(b / b) mice involved a central tolerance. Based on the kinetics of postnatal thymic C(gamma2a)(b) gene expression in Igh(b / b) mice, we transplanted thymi from Igh(b / b) donors of diverse ages into tolerogen-free Igh(a / a) nu / nu recipients. The state of T cell tolerance or responsiveness to IgG(2a)(b) in these reconstituted nu / nu hosts was determined by monitoring the capacity of their splenocytes to induce suppression in Igh(a / b) F(1). These experiments demonstrated that: (i) in the Igh(a / a) nu / nu recipients of adult Igh(b / b) thymi, 33 to 65 % T splenocytes were from nu / nu recipient origin, but these peripheral Igh(a / a) T cells were rendered tolerant to IgG(2a)(b) during their differentiation through the adult Igh(b / b) thymi, (ii) circulating IgG(2a)(b) was not a prerequisite for this tolerance induction, (iii) Igh(b / b) thymic epithelium was unable to induce tolerance to IgG(2a)(b) and (iv) IgG(2a)(b)-producing / presenting cells, colonizing the Igh(b / b) thymi, were certainly responsible of full tolerance induction to IgG(2a)(b).

Non-overlapping Fas- and BCL-2-regulated death pathways in IgG2a(b)-producing B cells

Using perforin (Pfp)- and/or Fas-dependent cytotoxic pathways, T splenocytes from Igh(a/a) mice are able in vivo to totally and chronically eliminate congenic Igh(b/b) B cells committed to IgG2a(b) production. This phenomenon leads to a characteristic absence of serum IgG2a(b) expression (IgG2a(b) allotype suppression) in, for instance, histocompatible Igh(a/b) or Igh(b/b) mice, having neonatally received such T cells. Because the study of the protective role of BCL-2 oncoprotein against Fas-mediated cell death has generated contradictory findings, we examined the possible impact of constitutive overexpression of transgenic human BCL-2 protein in Igh(b/b) B cells when the latter were exposed in vivo exclusively with the Fas-dependent, anti-IgG2a(b) T cell activity of Igh(a/a) Pfp(0/0) mice. We observed that, despite high intracellular expression of functional transgenic BCL-2 and no up-regulation of the principal BCL-2 inhibitors in whole Igh(b/b) B cells, total, chronic and specific IgG2a(b) suppression was exerted by Igh(a/a) Pfp(0/0) cytotoxic T cells. These data show that, in this model of negative regulation of Ig production, Fas- and BCL-2-regulated mechanisms belong to non-overlapping death pathways at the level of IgG2a(b)-producing B cells, targets of Igh(a/a) T cell-mediated cytotoxicity. Thus, in these mature B cells, the Fas signaling-directly operating via caspase 8-does not involve a mitochondria-dependent pathway regulated by BCL-2.

Evidence of Alternative or Concomitant Use of Perforin- and Fas-Dependent Pathways in a T Cell-Mediated Negative Regulation of Ig Production

To study the possible involvement of perforin (Pfp)- and/or Fas-dependent cytotoxicity pathways in a T cell-mediated negative regulation of Ig production, we used the T cell-induced Ig-allotype suppression model. T splenocytes from Igha/a mice, when neonatally transferred into histocompatible Igha/b F1 or Ighb/b congenic hosts, are intrinsically able to totally, specifically, and chronically suppress the production of IgG2a of the Ighb haplotype (IgG2ab). It has not been established whether the suppression effectors, which are anti-IgG2ab MHC class I-restricted CD8+ T cells, cytolyse IgG2ab+ B targets or whether they only silence Ig production. In this study, using T cells from Igha/a Pfp+/+ or Pfpo/o mice, the latter obtained by crossbreeding, and B cells from Ighb/b Fas+/+ or Faslpr/lpr (lymphoproliferation) mice in appropriate adoptive transfer models, we demonstrated that: 1) under blockage of the Pfp-mediated pathway, Igha/a T cells were still able to induce suppression against wild-type IgG2ab+ B cells, 2) IgG2ab+ B cells with impaired Fas expression were also subjected to suppression by WT Igha/a T splenocytes, and 3) the suppression establishment was totally inhibited when both Pfp- and Fas-dependent mechanisms were simultaneously blocked, i.e., when Igha/a Pfpo/o T cells were used to induce suppression against Ighb/b Faslpr/lpr B cells. These results provide the first demonstration of the existence of alternative or simultaneous use of the major cytotoxic mechanisms in a T cell-mediated down-regulation of an Ig production.

Inhibition of IgG2ab production by Ig allotype-specific T cells can Be mediated without T-B cell contact

The growth of IgG2ab-producing CB101 myeloma cells, subcutaneously or intraperitoneally inoculated into histocompatible BALB/c Igha mice sensitized against this Ig allotype, was delayed by 2-4 weeks compared to normal mice. While IgG2ab production was detected in the sera of 75-100% of normal mice, it was irreversibly inhibited in 100% of sensitized mice. IgG2ab suppression (IgG2ab sup) was also systematically obtained in sensitized but not normal recipients, implanted ip with a 0.1-micrometer-pore diffusion chamber (DC) containing CB101 cells. This time, the specific IgG2ab sup was reversible in vitro in the absence of anti-IgG2ab T cells. Adoptive transfer, of unfractionated or T but not B splenocytes from their sensitized counterparts into normal mice, 1 day before DC implantation, induced IgG2ab sup as well. These results indicate that, in these experimental circumstances, IgG2ab sup can also be mediated by diffusible suppressive factors produced by the effector T cells, without direct T-B-cell contact.

The T/B cell interaction involved in induction of the mouse IgG2ab suppression is restricted by major histocompatibility complex class I, but not class II molecules

To determine the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) restriction of the T/ B cell interaction involved in a negative regulation of Ig production, we used mouse model of T cell-induced IgG2ab suppression in vivo. Normal or specifically triggered T splenocytes from mice of the Igha haplotype, when neonatally transferred into histocompatible Igha/b heterozygotes, are able to induce a specific and total suppression of the IgG2ab allotype. Nevertheless, only transfer of IgG2ab-primed Igha T splenocytes induces this suppression in Ighb/b homozygous congenic mice in which the whole IgG2a isotype production is inhibited. This suppression is chronically maintained by CD8+ T cells, but can be experimentally reversed. We have established that the suppression induction required a CD4+CD8+ T cell cooperation and operated via the recognition by the involved TCR of C gamma 2ab-derived peptides presented by the target B cells in an MHC haplotype-restricted manner. Here, by using Ighb mice genetically deficient for MHC class I (beta 2-microglobulin%, or beta 2m%) or class II (I-A beta%) molecules, we demonstrate functionally that the suppression induction implicates an MHC class I-, but not class II-restricted interaction. Indeed, the anti-IgG2ab T cells transferred into Ighb H-2b I-A beta% mice carry out the suppression process normally, while in Ighb H-2b beta 2m% recipients, their suppression induction capacity is significantly inhibited. Moreover, the C gamma 2ab 103-118 peptide, identified as the sole C gamma 2ab-derived peptide able to amplify the anti-IgG2ab T cell reactivity in Igha H-2b mice, is also able to stabilize the H-2Db, but not the H-2Kb class I molecules at the surface of RMA-S (TAP2-, H-2b) cells. These results indicate that, despite the CD4+/CD8+ T cell cooperation during the induction phase of suppression only MHC class I molecule expression is required at the surface of IgG2ab+ B cells for suppression establishment.

T lymphocytes mediate immunologic control of C3 gene expression

Immunologic control of C3 gene expression by tissue macrophages can be accomplished by treatment of spleen fragments with anti-C3 antibody. We now demonstrate that suppression of C3 requires participation of T lymphocytes of both the CD4+ and CD8+ phenotypes. Pretreatment of splenic tissue with anti-Thy-1.2 monoclonal antibody blocks the ability of the anti-C3 antibody to induce C3 suppression. Reduction in either the CD4+ or CD8+ subpopulations of T lymphocytes also abrogates C3 suppression demonstrating that both T cell subsets are required in addition to the inducing antibody. Artificially elevating intracellular levels of cAMP with cholera toxin can partially substitute for the effects mediated by T cells in this reaction. Therefore, normal expression of the C3 gene can be suppressed by a regulatory network that requires the presence of a specific inducing antibody and T lymphocytes of both the CD4+ and CD8+ subsets. This regulatory network has many similarities to regulatory networks that have been well documented in suppression of specific murine immunoglobulin allotypes.

Igh-1b-specific CD4+CD8- T cell clones of the Th1 subset selectively suppress the Igh-1b allotype in vivo

The demonstration of major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T helper (Th) cells specific for peptides from the variable (V) regions of syngeneic immunoglobulin (Ig) (idiopeptides) opens the possibility that Th cells regulate B cell functions via idiopeptide-based cognate T-B interactions. As a model for such interactions we investigated the influence of Ig allotype-specific T cells on the differentiation of H-2-syngeneic B cells expressing that particular Ig allotype. We established a BALB/c (H-2d, Iga) CD4+CD8- T cell line and clones of the Th1 subset (interleukin 2+, interleukin 4-, interferon-gamma+, tumor necrosis factor-alpha+) that recognized Igh-1 (IgG2a) of the b allotype (Igh-1b) together with I-Ad. These T cells specifically suppressed surface Igh-1b+ B cells in vitro and in vivo. In 12 out of 15 6-week-old (BALB/c X B10.D2)F1 mice neonatally injected with Igh-1b-specific T cells, the serum Igh-1b concentrations were less than 5% of the levels in the controls. Thus, allotype suppression can be accomplished solely by adoptive transfer of Igh-1b-specific CD4+ T cells. The in vivo suppression was specific for Igh-1b+ B cells as the recipients' levels of Igh-1a and Igh-4b (IgG1b) were unaffected. The V beta 14-specific anti-T cell receptor (TcR) monoclonal antibody 14-2 inhibited activation of hybridomas derived from two of the clones. Collectively the data indicate that suppression resulted from cognate interactions between allopeptide-specific TcR alpha/beta+ T cells and normal unmanipulated B lymphocytes presenting their endogenous Igh-1b in association with MHC class II molecules. The data support the possibility that normal B cells can be suppressed by idiopeptide-specific T cells in vivo.

The splenic pool of mouse stem cells: in vitro differentiation and expression of the BP-1 alloantigen on cells of the lymphoid and myeloid lineages

The relative paucity of data about the development of the stem cell pool present in the spleen prompted this study. During in vitro cultures of B-enriched lymphocytes from mouse spleens and in the presence of a culture supernatant of WEHI-3 cells (WEHI-SUP), a population of cells expressing the BP-1 antigen appears progressively, reaches an optimal size 8 days after initiation of the culture, and disappears on day 28. In 8-day-old cultures, a minor population of cells bearing both BP-1 and B220 can be detected. The growth of this cell population, with characteristics of the B lymphoid lineage (pro-B), is strictly dependent on the presence of WEHI-SUP in the medium. After 2 weeks of culture, the BP-1 antigen is expressed on a cell population, which is essentially constituted of B220-, polynuclear cells. The BP-1 antigen, which is considered as characteristic of early cells of the B lymphoid lineage, can therefore also be expressed on cells of the myeloid lineage. The injection of BP-1+ or B220+ cells in irradiated mice can hardly reconstitute their B cell pool, whereas BP-1- and B220- cells are much more efficient in vivo progenitors of this cell lineage.

Cellular induction of chronic allotype suppression of IgG2a in Ighb/b homozygous mice and its abrogation by in vivo treatment with anti-CD8 monoclonal antibody

We report here the successful induction of allotype suppression in homozygous Ighb/b mice (CB20 or C57BL/6) by neonatal injection of T splenocytes from Igha congenic sensitized mice (BALB/c or BC8, respectively). The sensitization of the T cell donors was achieved by two intravenous injections of B splenocytes from Ighb congenic mice. Treated homozygous Ighb/b mice developed, as of 16-24 wk of age, a chronic suppression of Igh-1b expression (IgG2a of Ighb haplotype). The other productions tested (IgM, IgD, and IgA) of Ighb haplotype were unaffected. In vivo treatment with cytotoxic anti-CD4 or anti-CD8 mAb of mice subjected to chronic Igh-1b suppression clearly showed that CD8+ lymphocytes (suppressor or cytotoxic cell) were essential for the maintenance of the suppression. The suppression was indeed abrogated after a 1-wk treatment with anti-CD8 mAb containing culture supernatant, whereas, the anti-CD4-treated mice continued to be subjected to suppression. This anti-CD8 in vivo treatment was shown to have no effect on thymus but to severely reduce the percentages of CD8+ cells in spleen and in peripheral blood without affecting the percentages of CD4+ cells, leading to a large and rapid Igh-1b expression (up to 0.5 mg per ml of serum, the day after the end of the treatment). This suppression abrogation, and thus the Igh-1b expression, was either transient or permanent. When it was transient, a second 1-wk treatment with anti-CD8 mAb containing culture supernatant induced once again a rapid and significant production of Igh-1b (up to 0.3 mg of Igh-1b per ml of serum).