Use of the improved arabinose-resistant assay system of Salmonella typhimurium for mutagenesis testing

Fluorescence-Based Reporters for Detection of Mutagenesis in E. coli

Mutagenesis in model organisms following exposure to chemicals is used as an indicator of genotoxicity. Mutagenesis assays are also used to study mechanisms of DNA homeostasis. This chapter focuses on detection of mutagenesis in prokaryotes, which boils down to two approaches: reporter inactivation (forward mutation assay) and reversion of an inactivating mutation (reversion mutation assay). Both methods are labor intensive, involving visual screening, quantification of colonies on solid media, or determining a Poisson distribution in liquid culture. Here, we present two reversion reporters for in vivo mutagenesis that produce a quantitative output, and thus have the potential to greatly reduce the amount of test chemical and labor involved in these assays. This output is obtained by coupling a TEM β lactamase-based reversion assay with GFP fluorescence, either by placing the two genes on the same plasmid or by fusing them translationally and interrupting the N-terminus of the chimeric ORF with a stop codon. We also describe a reporter aimed at facilitating the monitoring of continuous mutagenesis in mutator strains. This reporter couples two reversion markers, allowing the temporal separation of mutation events in time, thus providing information about the dynamics of mutagenesis in mutator strains. Here, we describe these reporter systems, provide protocols for use, and demonstrate their key functional features using error-prone Pol I mutagenesis as a source of mutations.

Genotoxicity assessment of suspended particulate matter in the Elbe river: comparison of Salmonella microsome test, arabinose resistance test, and umu-test

This study evaluates the applicability of three bacterial short-term genotoxicity test systems to aquatic suspended particulate matter of the Elbe river. This material was sampled in sedimentation vessels after deposition periods of one month. It was extracted in a Soxhlet apparatus with toluene and methanol. Aqueous elutriates were prepared additionally. A solid phase method was developed that enables to incubate bacteria in contact with the particulate material. The test battery consists of two mutagenicity assays (the Ames-test and the Ara-test) and an SOS induction assay (the umu-test). Both mutagenicity assays came to nearly the same assessment of the samples of particulate matter of the Elbe. The quantitative response, however, was higher in the Ara-test. The particulate river material generally induced lower genotoxic potencies in the umu-test than in the mutagenicity assays. This lead to a completely different outcome of the umu-test; 29 out of 35 mutagenic samples were not SOS inducing. No quantitative or rank correlations between the concentrations of anthropogenic contaminants (PAHs, chlorinated hydrocarbons and metals) and the observed effects could be established on a 90% confidence limit. However, there is obvious correspondence between more contaminated regions of the river system and mutagenic effects (Ames- and Ara-test) in the samples from this region, as well as correspondence between low contaminated regions and the absence of mutagenicity. For this reason, the mutagenicity assays appear more favourable to describe the anthropogenic contamination with genotoxins in complex mixtures than the umu-test. The authors recommend the Ara-test for a first genotoxicity screening of complex environmental mixtures. This forward mutagenicity assay is advantageous due to higher effects and lower costs compared to the Ames-test. The development and use of a solid phase version of Ames- and Ara-test revealed the occurrence of a major part of particle-bound mutagens. The hydrophobic nature of these mutagens was also confirmed by the gradually decreasing effects with decreasing lipophilicity of the solvents. The results suggest that the solid phase test and the use of extracts complement each other in detecting mutagens of different lipophilicity. Both versions should be used in order to include a broad variety of compounds.

Genotoxicity of heated cooking oil vapors

Epidemiological studies of lung cancer in Chinese women indicated that factors other than cigarette smoking are related to lung cancer risk. A case-control study suggested that indoor air pollution, particularly from cooking oil emissions, may be involved. Condensates of volatile emissions from rapeseed and soybean cooking oils were prepared and found to be genotoxic in short-term tests including the Salmonella mutation assay, SV50 forward-mutation assay, and sister-chromatid exchange assay, as well as the micronucleus assay in mouse bone marrow. In contrast, condensates from rapeseed oil with butylated hydroxyanisole or hydrogenated rapeseed oil were not mutagenic, implicating oxidation products as the cause for mutagenicity. Peanut oil and lard condensates were not mutagenic in any assay. The association of exposure to Chinese rapeseed cooking-oil emissions and lung-cancer risk may be related to the mutagenic component of these condensates.

Antimutagenicity studies of chlorophyllin using the Salmonella arabinose-resistant assay system

Studies with the arabinose-resistant Salmonella forward mutation assay system were performed to determine the antimutagenic activity of chlorophyllin against the mutagenic activity of aflatoxin B1 (AFB1), 2-aminoanthracene (2AA), benzo[a]pyrene (BaP), N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) and solvent extracts of coal dust (CD), diesel emission particles (DE), airborne particles (AP), tobacco snuff (TS), black pepper (BP) and red wine (RW). Various concentrations of each chemical and complex mixture extract were assayed for mutagenic activity with and/or without S9 in a preincubation test. One concentration of each chemical and complex mixture extract was then tested with various concentrations of chlorophyllin. Results showed that chlorophyllin, at concentrations of 2.5 mg/plate or less, completely or almost completely inhibited the mutagenicity of 2AA, AFB1, BaP, MNNG and solvent extracts of CD, DE and RW. With concentrations from 1.25 to 5 mg/plate, chlorophyllin inhibited over 50% of the mutagenicity of AP, TS and BP extracts. These results further substantiate the antimutagenic efficacy of chlorophyllin against chemicals and complex mixtures.

Comparative antimutagenicity of chlorophyllin and five other agents against aflatoxin B1-induced reversion in Salmonella typhimurium strain TA98

Chlorophyllin was studied for its antimutagenic activity against aflatoxin B1 in Salmonella typhimurium strain TA98 using the plate-incorporation test in the presence of S9 activation. Comparative antimutagenicity between chlorophyllin and certain commonly studied antimutagens (i.e., vitamins A, C, and E, retinoic acid, and beta-carotene) was also examined. A dose-related inhibition of aflatoxin B1 mutagenicity by chlorophyllin was observed, with the mutagenicity being abolished by 860 nmole chlorophyllin per plate. The inhibitory activity of chlorophyllin occurred only when cells were treated concurrently with chlorophyllin and aflatoxin B1. The antimutagenic potency of chlorophyllin was comparable to that of vitamin A and higher than that of retinoic acid and beta-carotene. Vitamins C and E had no effect on aflatoxin B1 mutagenicity under the conditions used. The results of toxicity tests and a reconstruction experiment showed that inhibition of the mutagenicity of aflatoxin B1 by chlorophyllin and the other active agents was due to antimutagenicity.

Preliminary evaluation of treatment and selection conditions which affect expression of anthracycline mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium and a diploid human lymphoblast cell line

Mutagenic potency in the Ames Salmonella test is an important endpoint that can be influenced by biological and technical factors. The ranking of mutagenic activity of a series of anthracyclines was measured using different conditions of exposure and mutation selection. A 20 min preincubation treatment version of the Ames test using a 0.2-2.0 microgram/ml (0.36-3.60 nM/ml) dose range of each of the anthracyclines Adriamycin, Daunomycin, Carminomycin, 4'-O-methyldoxorubicin and 4-demethoxydoxorubicin confirmed the order of mutagenic potency seen with the same compounds under direct plating conditions. Preincubation results also confirm direct-plating results by showing the greater sensitivity of selection to His+ reversion over 8-azaguanine resistance to anthracycline mutagenicity. However, the order of mutagenic potency was changed by lengthening the preincubation treatment time to 2 h or reducing the population density of the treated cell inoculum by ten fold. These results suggest that certain treatment conditions enable the treated cells to diminish the phenotypic expression of anthracycline mutagenicity. For comparative purposes, daunomycin and Adriamycin mutagenicity in response to 0.1-0.2 nM/ml and 0.1-0.3 nM/ml dose ranges, respectively, were assessed in a human cell culture system with 6-thioguanine and 5-trifluorothymidine forward mutation selection. A daunomycin dose of 0.1 nM/ml generated approximately 25-fold and 20-fold increases in mutant fraction with 6-thioguanine and 5-trifluorothymidine selections, respectively. Equivalent dosing with Adriamycin generated approximately a 4-fold increase in mutant fraction with 6-thioguanine selection and little or no increase with 5-trifluothymidine selection.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Comparative mutagenicity studies of azo dyes and their reduction products in Salmonella typhimurium

The arabinose-resistant and Ames assay systems of Salmonella typhimurium were used to evaluate the mutagenic potential of azo dyes and their aromatic amine reduction products. Azo dyes, namely direct black 38, direct blue 15, and direct red 2, were mutagenic in the arabinose-resistant and Ames assays with both hamster and rat liver S9 activation. Both assays gave relatively higher mutagenic responses with hamster S9. Reduction products of these dyes, namely benzidine, o-dianisidine, and o-tolidine, were mutagenic in the Ames assay. Benzidine was weakly mutagenic and o-dianisidine and o-tolidine were nonmutagenic in the arabinose-resistant assay. These results indicate that both arabinose-resistant tester SV50 and Ames tester TA98 were sensitive in detecting mutagenicity of azo dyes. The use of the standard plate protocol with Ames tester TA98 is more efficient than the modified azo dye protocol in detecting mutagenicity of aromatic amine reduction products. Additional modifications in either the standard plate or modified azo dye protocols may improve detection of mutagenicity of these compounds in the arabinose-resistant assay system.

A simple method for the extraction of mutagens from airborne particles

Organic materials were extracted with acetone from filters of airborne particles by soaking, shaking, soxhletion, and sonication. These extracts were tested with and without S9 for mutagenicity using Ames assay and arabinose-resistant assay of Salmonella typhimurium. Among the extraction methods, soaking extract had the highest mutagenic activity followed by sonication, shaking, and soxhletion in both the assays. With the samples studied, it was concluded that soaking with acetone for 1/2 hr is the simplest and an efficient procedure for the extraction of mutagens from airborne particles.

Relationships between structures and mutagenic potencies of 16 heterocyclic nitrogen mustards (ICR compounds) in Salmonella typhimurium

16 heterocyclic nitrogen mustards (ICR compounds), which were synthesized for use as possible antitumor agents by Creech and coworkers, were tested for mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium strains TA1535, TA1536, TA1537, TA1538, TA98 and TA100. The compounds were incorporated into the top agar at 5 doses: 0.5, 1, 2.5, 5 and 10 micrograms/plate. All of the compounds were negative in TA1535 except ICR 449, which was positive in all 6 strains. The other 15 compounds were positive in the remaining strains with the following exceptions: ICR 371 and 355 were negative in TA100; ICR 445 was negative in TA98 and TA100; and ICR 360 was negative in TA1537, TA1538, TA98 and TA100. Good qualitative agreement was observed between the mutagenic and antitumor activities of the 16 compounds, and between the mutagenic and carcinogenic activities of the 5 compounds that have been tested for carcinogenicity by Peck and coworkers. However, no significant correlation was found between mutagenic potency in Salmonella and antitumor potency in mice for the 16 compounds. Also, for the 5 compounds that have been tested for carcinogenicity, no significant correlation was found between their mutagenic potency in Salmonella and their carcinogenic potency in mice. In Salmonella, the secondary (2 degrees) amines generally were more mutagenic than their tertiary (3 degrees) amine homologs, although the opposite result has been reported in certain eukaryotes. Relationships between structures and potencies for the different nuclei of the 16 ICR compounds are discussed, as are similarities and differences in strain sensitivities. We conclude that the Salmonella his reversion test is not a good predictor of the antitumor and carcinogenic potencies of these ICR compounds.

Validation of the Salmonella (SV50)/arabinose-resistant forward mutation assay system with 26 compounds

Mutagenic sensitivity of the Salmonella/arabinose-resistant (Arar) assay system using the tester strain SV50 was evaluated with 26 compounds both by the preincubation and the standard plate incorporation tests. The mutagenic activity of all 26 compounds was also tested with TA98 and/or TA100 of the Ames Salmonella/microsome assay system. The results indicate that 13 and 10 of 26 compounds were mutagenic and nonmutagenic, respectively, in both assay systems. PR toxin and hydrogen peroxide were mutagenic only in the Arar assay, while 2-nitrofluorene was mutagenic only in the Ames assay. The results also show that the mutagenic response of SV50 to 13 of 15 mutagenic compounds was much higher (2.1-154-fold) if the compounds were tested with the preincubation rather than the plate incorporation test. The mutagenic activity of 4 compounds (diethyl sulfate, niridazole, PR toxin and hydrogen peroxide) in the Arar assay was detected only with the preincubation test. Since the Arar assay using tester strain SV50 has similar mutagenic sensitivity as the Ames assay to chemicals with different modes of action and since it requires only one tester strain, we find this assay system to be useful for screening environmental mutagens. Based on the effectiveness of the preincubation test in this study, it is recommended that the preincubation test instead of the plate incorporation test be used for the Arar assay system with tester strain SV50.

Development of an in situ microbial mutagenicity test system for airborne workplace mutagens: laboratory evaluation

A simple on-site Salmonella mutagenicity test system for the detection of airborne mutagens in the workplace is being developed. The system permits entrapment of mutagenic airborne particles and vapors by impinging unfiltered ambient air into trapping medium containing bacterial tester cells. The trapping device consists mainly of a pump, an impinger and a cyclone. The impinging air flow generated by the pump is approximately 3 1/min. New Salmonella typhimurium testers which are resistant to streptomycin (Str) and 8-azaguanine (AG) were derived from the Ames testers TA98 and TA100 and the arabinose-resistant tester SV50, and were used as mutation indicators. Microbial contamination was sufficiently controlled by addition of ampicillin, Str, AG, and cycloheximide to the trapping and plating media. New tester strains retained a high mutagenic sensitivity from their parent strains. Laboratory studies with volatile mutagens (methyl methanesulfonate, ethyl methanesulfonate, and dimethylnitrosamine) showed that the vapor trapping of this system is promising. The study with suspended silica particles coated with a known mutagen (2,4,7-trinitro-9-fluorenone) indicated that the particle trapping of the system is satisfactory. Incorporation of metabolic activation into the trapping medium by confining S9 mix and tester cells in dialysis tubing enabled this system to detect promutagens. This in situ system may be useful for mutagenic monitoring in the workplace.

Mutagens in cooked foods--metabolism and genetic toxicity

Recently developed in our laboratories is an efficient extraction procedure incorporating XAD resin adsorption which yields from 200 degrees C grilled ground beef an extract containing 230 Salmonella TA1538 revertants per g fresh weight of original ground beef. These mutagenic components are specific for frameshift-sensitive Salmonella strains and have an absolute requirement for metabolic activation. S9 activation by cytochrome P-448 inducers, Aroclor 1254 (PCB), 3-methylcholanthrene (3-MC) and B-naphthoflavone (BNF), resulted in the largest mutagenic response. Phenobarbital induction gave 20% of the PCB response and Pregnenolone-16a-carbonitrile and corn oil were inactive. Human liver microsomes and BNF-induced rodent intestinal S9 were also active metabolizing fractions. Normal-phase HPLC separation of methanol-extractable metabolites generated from reaction of 2-amino-3-methylimidazo [4,5-f]quinoline (IQ), a mutagenic component of broiled food, rat liver microsomes and cofactors resulted in one direct-acting mutagenic peak and a second more polar peak still requiring metabolic activation. Two potent thermally-produced bacterial mutagens, Trp-P-2 and IQ, were examined in mammalian cells. In excision repair-deficient CHO cells, Trp-P-2 exposure caused cytotoxicity, mutagenicity (thioguanine and azaadenine resistances), sister chromatid exchange, and chromosomal aberrations at concentrations more than 30-fold lower than those for IQ. In normal repair-proficient CHO cells Trp-P-2 was one-half as active and IQ was inactive. Relative to Trp-P-2, IQ is much more potent in the Salmonella bacterial system than in mammalian CHO cells.

Mutagenicity studies of ambient airborne particles. II. Comparison of extraction methods

Organic materials were extracted with acetone from airborne particles by shaking, soxhletion and sonication for varying durations. 4-h, 1-h and 1/8-min extractions by shaking, soxhletion and sonication, respectively gave maximum his+ revertants with the Ames Salmonella/microsome assay. In a comparative study of extraction methods, sonication gave the highest and soxhletion the lowest mutagenic response. It appears that sonication with acetone is the best procedure for the extraction of mutagens from airborne particles as shown by Ames assay and Arar assay systems in Salmonella typhimurium.

Mutagenic detection of complex environmental mixtures using the Salmonella/arabinose-resistant assay system

The mutagenic sensitivity of SV50, the R-factor plasmid containing tester, of the Salmonella/arabinose-resistant assay system has been evaluated with different environmental complex mixtures, including extracts of airborne and diesel emission particles, oil-shale ash, nitrosated coal dust and water samples. The mutagenicities of all extracts were detectable with this assay. This study indicates that the arabinose-resistant assay with SV50 is useful for the detection of the mutagenic activity of environmental complex mixtures.

Mutagenicity of oil-shale ash

3 oil-shale ash samples were extracted with solvents and analyzed for mutagenicity with a number of tests systems. In Salmonella typhimurium, the ash extracts were highly mutagenic with the Ames his reversion and the ara-resistant systems. Mutation induction by the ash in Salmonella was independent of metabolic activation and was of the frameshift type. These ash extracts showed a substantial killing effect, but failed to induced ad-3 reversion in Neurospora crassa, gene conversion and mitotic crossing-over in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and TGr mutation in cultured CHO cells.