An integrated assessment of sediment remediation in a midwestern U.S. stream using sediment chemistry, water quality, bioassessment, and fish biomarkers

Original and improved interspecies correlation estimation models in China for potential application in water quality criteria

Fluoranthene (FLU) has gained much attention in recent years because of its continuous discharge in natural waters and toxicity to aquatic ecosystems. However, it is difficult to control and manage FLU pollution because of the lack of a rational and scientific water quality criteria (WQC) of FLU. To solve these data gaps, the US EPA established an interspecies correlation estimation (ICE) model, which can be utilized to develop the SSD and HC₅ (hazardous concentration, 5th percentile). Moreover, an improved model was developed using a combination of North American ICE models supplemented with China-specific species. In this study, to verify the applicability of the two ICE models, measured acute toxicity data for FLU were obtained from 9 acute toxicity tests using indigenous Chinese aquatic species from different taxonomic levels. Original and improved ICE-based SSD curves, which were generated using 3 surrogate species (Daphnia magna, Oncorhynchus mykiss, and Lepomis macrochirus), were compared with SSD curves based on measured data. The results showed that HC₅ was 1.838, 1.062, and 0.570 mg/L for the original ICE, improved ICE, and measured data, respectively. The improved ICE-based HC₅ value for FLU was within twofold of the HC₅ value based on measure data, while the original ICE-based HC₅ value was threefold higher than the HC₅ value based on measure data. This indicated that the improved ICE had better predictability in extrapolating data with acceptable deviation than the original ICE. Furthermore, their differences between HC₅ derived from two SSD curves were not significant. Generally, the improved ICE model was verified as a valid approach for generating SSDs with limited toxicity data and for deriving WQC for FLU.

Comparison of the sensitivity between indigenous and exotic aquatic species for fluoranthene and derivation of water quality criteria (WQC)

Fluoranthene (FLU) has shown relatively high toxicity to aquatic life as a priority polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH). Considering the toxic effects of FLU on aquatic organisms and its high detection frequency in the aquatic environment, it is necessary and critical to derive FLU water quality criteria (WQC) for the protection of aquatic organisms and ecological risk assessment. However, due to the lack of toxicity data at different classification levels, there has been no research about the WQC of FLU. In this study, nine acute and three chronic toxicity tests were carried out on 9 Chinese indigenous aquatic species from different classification levels to obtain toxicity data. According to the US EPA guidelines, the criterion maximum concentration of 0.570 mg/L and the criterion continuous concentration of 0.174 mg/L were developed. There is no significant difference when comparing the species sensitivity distributions between indigenous and exotic species. Therefore, it is possible to use toxicity data from organisms in different areas for ecological risk assessment of FLU. CAPSULE: We compared the sensitivity between indigenous and exotic aquatic species for fluoranthene and derived its water quality criteria.

Variation in natural attenuation rates of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) in fish from streams and reservoirs in East Tennessee observed over a 35-year period

Environmental contamination due to human activities is a major concern, particularly for persistent chemicals. Within catchments, persistent chemicals linked to negative health outcomes such as polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) have great potential to be transported, through adsorption or biological uptake, with downstream locations acting as sinks for accumulation. Here we present long-term trends in PCB bioaccumulation in fish found in lower-order tributaries on the Oak Ridge Reservation, an impacted US Department of Energy property in East Tennessee, USA, and a large reservoir system adjacent to it composed of parts of the Clinch and Tennessee Rivers. Given that the reservoir system has experienced no direct PCB mitigation activities, this record offers an opportunity to explore potential natural attenuation of PCBs within a large lotic ecosystem. Attenuation rates ranged from 0% to 8% yr^-1 in minnows and sunfish at stream sites and 5.4-11.3% yr^-1 in catfish at reservoir sites. These rates are comparable to findings from similar studies in other regions, suggesting a consistency in responses since the banning of PCB production in 1979. Further, results suggest that PCB sources from discharge outfalls are important locally but are not primarily responsible for sustaining PCB contamination in downstream reservoirs.

Use of Interspecies Correlation Estimation (ICE) Models to Derive Water Quality Criteria of Microplastics for Protecting Aquatic Organisms

Microplastics (MPs) in the water environment pose a potential threat to aquatic organisms. The Species Sensitivity Distribution (SSD) method was used to assess the ecological risks of microplastics on aquatic organisms in this study. However, the limited toxicity data of aquatic organisms made it impossible to derive water quality criteria (WQC) for MPs and difficult to implement an accurately ecological risk assessment. To solve the data gaps, the USEPA established the interspecies correlation estimation (ICE) model, which could predict toxicity data to a wider range of aquatic organisms and could also be utilized to develop SSD and HC5 (hazardous concentration, 5th percentile). Herein, we collected the acute toxicity data of 11 aquatic species from 10 families in 5 phyla to fit the metrical-based SSDs, meanwhile generating the ICE-based-SSDs using three surrogate species (Oncorhynchus mykiss, Hyalella Azteca, and Daphnia magna), and finally compared the above SSDs, as well as the corresponding HC5. The results showed that the measured HC5 for acute MPs toxicity data was 112.3 μg/L, and ICE-based HC5 was 167.2 μg/L, which indicated there were no significant differences between HC5 derived from measured acute and ICE-based predicted values thus the ICE model was verified as a valid approach for generating SSDs with limited toxicity data and deriving WQC for MPs.

Using solid-phase microextraction during ultrasound reveals higher aqueous PAHs release from contaminated sediment

Ultrasound (US) releases polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) from contaminated creosote sediments and degrades PAHs in aqueous solution. However, it is unclear how much PAHs release occurs during active US compared to after US is stopped. In this study, solid-phase microextraction (SPME) was used to determine aqueous PAH concentrations desorbed from Little Scioto River creosote contaminated sediment during exposure to 20 kHz ultrasound (US) at a power of 430 W L^-1. First, SPME fiber-water partition coefficients,K_SPME, were experimentally determined and shown to be comparable with previous studies. Next, PAH concentrations released into aqueous solution were determined by sequentially exposing fresh, conditioned SPME fibers in a reactor containing the contaminated sediment and DI for 10 min periods. Three consecutive 10 min periods each were measured during US and after US. Compared to mixing only, PAHs desorbed during ultrasound was significantly higher. In addition, for phenanthrene, anthracene, and fluoranthene, US showed significantly higher aqueous concentrations during US compared with after US. For these less soluble PAHs, desorption into the aqueous phase reaches and surpasses expected equilibrium aqueous concentrations. However, when US is ceased, PAHs appear to resorb onto sediment resulting in the lower concentrations measured in these PAH compounds after US that are similar to expected equilibrium aqueous concentrations. Typical analytical extraction methods for determining the effects of US require stopping treatment and may underestimate the potential US has for release of contaminants from sediment during US. Using SPME during US treatment reveals that the concentration of PAHs during US may surpass the expected equilibrium aqueous concentration of some PAHs congeners. To our knowledge, this higher concentration observed during US compared to after US has not been shown previously.

Evaluation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons bioavailability on Santos Bay (Brazil) through levels of biliary metabolites

This study evaluated the PAH bioavailability from Santos Bay (Brazil) in 4 species of fish, using PAH biliary metabolites. The collection was done monthly, between July and December, in three different regions of Santos Bay. The metabolites were analyzed through a high performance liquid chromatograph with fluorescence detectors. Total metabolites concentrations ranged from 65.5 to 589μgg^-1 of bile, evidencing PAH bioavailability on Santos Bay. Levels of phenanthrene and benzo[a]pyrene metabolites were in the classification range of areas moderate contaminated. Those concentrations were lower in Nebris microps and higher in Sphoeroides testudineus (p<0.05). Naphthalene metabolites concentrations did not differ significantly among fish species and were in the classification range of low contaminated areas. There were no significant spatial and temporal differences in levels among sampled areas. These results are environmentally important given the high levels of urbanization and the absence of biomonitoring data in this area.

Evaluation methods for assessing effectiveness of in situ remediation of soil and sediment contaminated with organic pollutants and heavy metals

Soil and sediment contamination has become a critical issue worldwide due to its great harm to the ecological environment and public health. In recent years, many remediation technologies including physical, chemical, biological, and combined methods have been proposed and adopted for the purpose of solving the problems of soil and sediment contamination. However, current research on evaluation methods for assessing these remediation technologies is scattered and lacks valid and integrated evaluation methods for assessing the remediation effectiveness. This paper provides a comprehensive review with an environmental perspective on the evaluation methods for assessing the effectiveness of in situ remediation of soil and sediment contaminated with organic pollutants and heavy metals. The review systematically summarizes recent exploration and attempts of the remediation effectiveness assessment based on the content of pollutants, soil and sediment characteristics, and ecological risks. Moreover, limitations and future research needs of the practical assessment are discussed. These limitations are not conducive to the implementation of the abatement and control programs for soil and sediment contamination. Therefore, more attention should be paid to the evaluation methods for assessing the remediation effectiveness while developing new in situ remediation technologies in future research.

Comparison of species sensitivity distributions constructed with predicted acute toxicity data from interspecies correlation estimation models and measured acute data for benzo[a]pyrene

Benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) is a priority Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon (PAH), which is toxic to aquatic organisms and has been widely detected in the environment. However, ecological risk assessment for BaP is hard to perform because of the absence of water quality criteria (WQC) and lack of toxicity data for this chemical. To fill in the data gaps, a interspecies correlation estimation (ICE) model was developed by USEPA to predict toxicity values for multiple species from the toxicity estimate for one species. In order to validate the applicability of the ICE model for BaP, measured-based-species sensitivity distributions (SSDs) generated using eight Chinese native aquatic species were compared with ICE-based-SSDs generated using the data predicted from three surrogate species (Lepomis macrochirus, Cyprinus carpio and Daphnia magna). The results showed that there were no significant differences between the two SSD curves and the two hazardous concentrations for the 5% of species (HC5) derived from measured acute toxicity data and ICE-based predicted data. The ICE model was verified as a valid approach for generating SSDs with limited toxicity data.

Derivation of water quality criteria of phenanthrene using interspecies correlation estimation models for aquatic life in China

Species sensitivity distribution (SSD) method has been widely used to derive water quality criteria (WQC). However, the toxicity data of some environmental pollutants are not easily accessible, especially for endangered and threatened species. Thus, it would be very desirable and economical to predict the toxicity of those species not subjected to toxicity test with the aid of a mathematical model. The interspecies correlation estimation (ICE) model (developed by the US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA)) uses the initial toxicity estimate for one species to produce correlated toxicity values for multiple species, and it can be utilized to develop SSD and HC5 (hazardous concentration, 5th percentile). In this study, we explored the applicability of ICE to predict toxicity of phenanthrene to various species. ICE-based SSDs were generated using three surrogate species (Oncorhynchus mykiss, Lepomis macrochirus, and Daphnia magna) and compared with the metrical-based SSD. The corresponding HC5 of both models were also compared. The results showed there were no significant differences between HC5 derived from measured acute and ICE-based predicted values. The ICE model was verified as a valid approach for generating SSDs with limited toxicity data and deriving WQC for phenanthrene.

Monitoring exposure of brown bullheads and benthic macroinvertebrates to sediment contaminants in the Ashtabula River before, during, and after remediation

In 2007, approximately 420,500 cubic meters of contaminated sediment were removed from the Ashtabula River by dredging. The primary objective of the present study was to monitor contaminant exposure in fish and macroinvertebrates before, during, and after dredging. This was done by measuring tissue concentrations of polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) in brown bullhead catfish (Ameriurus nebulosa) and in benthic macroinvertebrates, assessing changes in DNA damage in fish liver and blood, and scoring external and histopathological lesions and anomalies in the fish. In surficial sediment PCBs and PAHs were also quantified in conjunction with the biological sampling. The results show a significant reduction in contaminant levels in both fish and macroinvertebrates following dredging, indicating the effectiveness of the remediation in reducing exposure of biota to the primary contaminants of concern. Similarly, DNA damage levels in fish collected from the Ashtabula River significantly declined following dredging; however, a similar reduction in DNA damage over time was seen in fish collected from a reference site (Conneaut Creek), making interpretation difficult. Macroinvertebrate PCB concentrations were reflective of the sediment concentrations in the areas where Hester-Dendy samplers were deployed for macroinvertebrate collection. The present study demonstrates that these methods can be used to evaluate and assess the effectiveness of remediation techniques at contaminated sediment sites.

Development of water quality criteria for phenanthrene and comparison of the sensitivity between native and non-native species

Phenanthrene (PHE) is a priority polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) which is toxic to aquatic organisms.However, there has been no paper dealing with water quality criteria (WQC) of PHE due to the shortage of toxicity data of different taxonomic levels. In the present study, toxicity data were obtained from 8 acute toxicity tests and 3 chronic toxicity tests using 8 Chinese native aquatic species from different taxonomic levels, and the water quality criteria was derived using 3 methods. Furthermore, differences of species sensitivity distributions (SSDs) between native and non-native species were compared. A criterion maximum concentration of 0.0514 mg/L and a criterion continuous concentration of 0.0186 mg/L were developed according to the US EPA guidelines. Finally, by using risk quotient (RQ) to assess the site-specific ecological risk in Liao River, the results indicated that the PHE might pose no risk to local aquatic species.