Activation of epiblast gene expression by the hypoblast layer in the prestreak chick embryo

Molecular anatomy of the pre-primitive-streak chick embryo

The early stages of development of the chick embryo, leading to primitive streak formation (the start of gastrulation), have received renewed attention recently, especially for studies of the mechanisms of large-scale cell movements and those that position the primitive streak in the radial blastodisc. Over the long history of chick embryology, the terminology used to define different regions has been changing, making it difficult to relate studies to each other. To resolve this objectively requires precise definitions of the regions based on anatomical and functional criteria, along with a systematic molecular map that can be compared directly to the functional anatomy. Here, we undertake these tasks. We describe the characteristic cell morphologies (using scanning electron microscopy and immunocytochemistry for cell polarity markers) in different regions and at successive stages. RNAseq was performed for 12 regions of the blastodisc, from which a set of putative regional markers was selected. These were studied in detail by in situ hybridization. Together this provides a comprehensive resource allowing the community to define the regions unambiguously and objectively. In addition to helping with future experimental design and interpretation, this resource will also be useful for evolutionary comparisons between different vertebrate species.

A novel mammal-specific three partite enhancer element regulates node and notochord-specific Noto expression

The vertebrate organizer and notochord have conserved, essential functions for embryonic development and patterning. The restricted expression of developmental regulators in these tissues is directed by specific cis-regulatory modules (CRMs) whose sequence conservation varies considerably. Some CRMs have been conserved throughout vertebrates and likely represent ancestral regulatory networks, while others have diverged beyond recognition but still function over a wide evolutionary range. Here we identify and characterize a mammalian-specific CRM required for node and notochord specific (NNC) expression of NOTO, a transcription factor essential for node morphogenesis, nodal cilia movement and establishment of laterality in mouse. A 523 bp enhancer region (NOCE) upstream the Noto promoter was necessary and sufficient for NNC expression from the endogenous Noto locus. Three subregions in NOCE together mediated full activity in vivo. Binding sites for known transcription factors in NOCE were functional in vitro but dispensable for NOCE activity in vivo. A FOXA2 site in combination with a novel motif was necessary for NOCE activity in vivo. Strikingly, syntenic regions in non-mammalian vertebrates showed no recognizable sequence similarities. In contrast to its activity in mouse NOCE did not drive NNC expression in transgenic fish. NOCE represents a novel, mammal-specific CRM required for the highly restricted Noto expression in the node and nascent notochord and thus regulates normal node development and function.

Sharpening of the anterior neural border in the chick by rostral endoderm signalling

The anterior border of the neural plate, presumed to contain the prospective peripheral portion (roof) of the prospective telencephalon, emerges within a vaguely defined proneural ectodermal region. Fate maps carried out at HH4 in the chick reveal that this region still produces indistinctly neural, placodal and non-neural derivatives; it does not express neural markers. We examined how the definitive anterior border domain of the rostral forebrain becomes established and comes to display a neural molecular profile, whereas local non-neural derivatives become separated. The process, interpreted as a border sharpening mechanism via intercalatory cell movements, was studied using fate mapping, time-lapse microscopy and in situ hybridization. Separation of neural and non-neural domains proceeds along stages HH4-HH4+, is well advanced at HH5, and is accompanied by a novel dorsoventral intercalation, oriented orthogonal to the border, that distributes transitional cells into molecularly distinct neural and non-neural fields. Meanwhile, neuroectodermal Sox2 expression spreads peripherally from the neighbourhood of the node, reaching the nascent anterior border domain at HH5. We also show that concurrent signals from the endodermal layer are necessary to position and sharpen the neural border, and suggest that FGF8 might be a component of this signalling.

The hypoblast (visceral endoderm): an evo-devo perspective

When amniotes appeared during evolution, embryos freed themselves from intracellular nutrition; development slowed, the mid-blastula transition was lost and maternal components became less important for polarity. Extra-embryonic tissues emerged to provide nutrition and other innovations. One such tissue, the hypoblast (visceral endoderm in mouse), acquired a role in fixing the body plan: it controls epiblast cell movements leading to primitive streak formation, generating bilateral symmetry. It also transiently induces expression of pre-neural markers in the epiblast, which also contributes to delay streak formation. After gastrulation, the hypoblast might protect prospective forebrain cells from caudalizing signals. These functions separate mesendodermal and neuroectodermal domains by protecting cells against being caught up in the movements of gastrulation.

A role for the hypoblast (AVE) in the initiation of neural induction, independent of its ability to position the primitive streak

The mouse anterior visceral endoderm (AVE) has been implicated in embryonic polarity: it helps to position the primitive streak and some have suggested that it might act as a "head organizer", inducing forebrain directly. Here we explore the role of the hypoblast (the chick equivalent of the AVE) in the early steps of neural induction and patterning. We report that the hypoblast can induce a set of very early markers that are later expressed in the nervous system and in the forebrain, but only transiently. Different combinations of signals are responsible for different aspects of this early transient induction: FGF initiates expression of Sox3 and ERNI, retinoic acid can induce Cyp26A1 and only a combination of low levels of FGF8 together with Wnt- and BMP-antagonists can induce Otx2. BMP- and Wnt-antagonists and retinoic acid, in different combinations, can maintain the otherwise transient induction of these markers. However, neither the hypoblast nor any of these factors or combinations thereof can induce the definitive neural marker Sox2 or the formation of a mature neural plate or a forebrain, suggesting that the hypoblast is not a head organizer and that other signals remain to be identified. Interestingly, FGF and retinoids, generally considered as caudalizing factors, are shown here to play a role in the induction of a transient "pre-neural/pre-forebrain" state.

Neural induction: old problem, new findings, yet more questions

During neural induction, the embryonic neural plate is specified and set aside from other parts of the ectoderm. A popular molecular explanation is the 'default model' of neural induction, which proposes that ectodermal cells give rise to neural plate if they receive no signals at all, while BMP activity directs them to become epidermis. However, neural induction now appears to be more complex than once thought, and can no longer be fully explained by the default model alone. This review summarizes neural induction events in different species and highlights some unanswered questions about this important developmental process.

Origin, fate, and function of the components of the avian germ disc region and early blastoderm: Role of ooplasmic determinants

In the avian oocytal germ disc region, at the end of oogenesis, we discerned four ooplasms (alpha, beta, gamma, delta) presenting an onion-peel distribution (from peripheral and superficial to central and deep. Their fate was followed during early embryonic development. The most superficial and peripheral alpha ooplasm plays a fundamental role during cleavage. The beta ooplasm, originally localized in the peripheral region of the blastodisc, becomes mainly concentrated in the primitive streak. At the moment of bilateral symmetrization, a spatially oblique, sickle-shaped uptake of gamma and delta ooplasms occurs so that gamma and delta ooplasms become incorporated into the deeper part of the avian blastoderm. These ooplasms seem to contain ooplasmic determinants that initiate either early neurulation or gastrulation events. The early neural plate-inducing structure that forms a deep part of the blastoderm is the delta ooplasm-containing endophyll (primary hypoblast). Together with the primordial germ cells, it is derived from the superficial centrocaudal part of the nucleus of Pander, which also contains delta ooplasm. The other structure (gamma ooplasm) that is incorporated into the caudolateral deep part of the blastoderm forms Rauber's sickle. It induces gastrulation in the concavity of Rauber's sickle and blood island formation exterior to Rauber's sickle. Rauber's sickle develops by ingrowth of blastodermal cells into the gamma ooplasm, which surrounds the nucleus of Pander. Rauber's sickle constitutes the primary major organizer of the avian blastoderm and generates only extraembryonic tissues (junctional and sickle endoblast). By imparting positional information, it organizes and dominates the whole blastoderm (controlling gastrulation, neurulation, and coelom and cardiovascular system formation). Fragments of the horns of Rauber's sickle extend far cranially into the lateral quadrants of the unincubated blastoderm, so that often Rauber's sickle material forms three quarters of a circle. This finding explains the regulative capacities of isolated blastoderm parts, with the exception of the anti-sickle region and central blastoderm region, where no Rauber's sickle material is present. In avian blastoderms, there exists a competitive inhibition by Rauber's sickle on the primitive streak and neural plate-inducing effects of sickle endoblast. Avian primordial germ cells contain delta ooplasm derived from the superficial part of the nucleus of Pander. Their original deep and central ooplasmic localization has been confirmed by the use of a chicken vasa homologue. We conclude that the unincubated blastoderm consists of three elementary tissues: upper layer mainly containing beta ooplasm, endophyll containing delta ooplasm, and Rauber's sickle containing gamma ooplasm). These elementary tissues form before the three classic germ layers have developed.

Competitive inhibition by Rauber's sickle of the primitive streak and/or (pre)neural plate inducing effects of sickle endoblast in avian blastoderms

When in unincubated chicken blastoderms the Rauber's sickle is (sub)totally mechanically removed by selective scraping, the further evolution of the blastoderm in culture is often profoundly disturbed, going from only expansion of the upper layer and preneural plate formation to the development of a slowly growing miniature embryo. Our results suggest that the developmental potencies of the embryo are related to the presence or absence of Rauber's sickle material left after its removal. This can be checked after culture by the presence or nonpresence of junctional endoblast (derived from Rauber's sickle) and the concomitant induction of blood islands in the immediate neighborhood. Our study thus indicates that without Rauber's sickle (in the cases of successful total selective removal), an avian blastoderm cannot develop normally, even in the presence of an intact caudal marginal zone. After placing a fragment of quail sickle endoblast on the anti-sickle region of unincubated chicken blastoderms from which the Rauber's sickle was (sub)totally removed, different developmental scenarios were seen, according to the degree of removal, both in the anti-sickle as in the sickle regions. 1) If Rauber's sickle activity is strongly reduced, then besides a centripetally directed miniature embryo, induced by the remnants of the autochthonous Rauber's sickle, an additional centripetally directed embryo or preneural plate (without accompanying blood islands) develops in the anti-sickle region under inductory influence of the apposed quail sickle endoblast. We make a distinction between a neural plate and a preneural plate. The latter consists of a thickening of the upper layer (with the same initial aspect as a neural plate) adjacent to endophyll or sickle endoblast in the absence of chordomesoblast and gastrulation phenomena. 2) If Rauber's sickle activity is totally absent, then the inducing power of the sickle endoblast fragment becomes maximal and, starting from the anti-sickle region, one single embryo (without blood islands) extending over the whole area centralis appears. 3) If much of the Rauber's sickle material has been left in the blastoderm, then the inducing activity of the sickle endoblast, placed on the anti-sickle region, will be totally suppressed (although the sickle endoblast remains intact) and neither a preneural plate nor a primitive streak was induced. After placing a fragment of quail sickle endoblast on the anti-sickle region of an unincubated chicken blastoderm from which the Rauber's sickle and surrounding tissues were completely excised, an embryo was always induced by the sickle endoblast in the adjacent upper layer of this anti-sickle region. In the absence of sickle endoblast, this never occurred. Thus, our experiments demonstrate that in the absence of the Rauber's sickle, a parent tissue (sickle endoblast) induces both gastrulation and neurulation phenomena, while in the full presence of Rauber's sickle these functions are totally suppressed. Moreover, Rauber's sickle not only organizes gastrulation and blood island formation by itself but also influences neurulation at a distance (in space and time) by part of its cell lineage (i.e., sickle endoblast). Our study suggests that the inhibitory effect of Rauber's sickle on its parent tissue (sickle endoblast) represents an early mechanism impairing polyembryony, so that only a single primary major organizer (Rauber's sickle) remains active in the young avian germinal disc.

A novel role for retinoids in patterning the avian forebrain during presomite stages

Retinoids, and in particular retinoic acid (RA), are known to induce posterior fates in neural tissue. However, alterations in retinoid signalling dramatically affect anterior development. Previous reports have demonstrated a late role for retinoids in patterning craniofacial and forebrain structures, but an earlier role in anterior patterning is not well understood. We show that enzymes involved in synthesizing retinoids are expressed in the avian hypoblast and in tissues directly involved in head patterning, such as anterior definitive endoderm and prechordal mesendoderm. We found that in the vitamin A-deficient (VAD) quail model, which lacks biologically active RA from the first stages of development, anterior endodermal markers such as Bmp2, Bmp7, Hex and the Wnt antagonist crescent are affected during early gastrulation. Furthermore, prechordal mesendodermal and prospective ventral telencephalic markers are expanded posteriorly, Shh expression in the axial mesoderm is reduced, and Bmp2 and Bmp7 are abnormally expressed in the ventral midline of the neural tube. At early somite stages, VAD embryos have increased cell death in ventral neuroectoderm and foregut endoderm, but normal cranial neural crest production, whereas at later stages extensive apoptosis occurs in head mesenchyme and ventral neuroectoderm. As a result, VAD embryos end up with a single and reduced telencephalic vesicle and an abnormally patterned diencephalon. Therefore, we propose that retinoids have a dual role in patterning the anterior forebrain during development. During early gastrulation, RA acts in anterior endodermal cells to modulate the anteroposterior (AP) positional identity of prechordal mesendodermal inductive signals to the overlying neuroectoderm. Later on, at neural pore closure, RA is required for patterning of the mesenchyme of the frontonasal process and the forebrain by modulating signalling molecules involved in craniofacial morphogenesis.

Induction and initial patterning of the nervous system - the chick embryo enters the scene

Until recently, almost everything known about the molecular controls of early neural development came from studies in amphibians. It is now possible to misexpress factors in chick embryos at relatively late stages in development, allowing careful dissection of the timing of cell interactions. This is starting to contribute significantly to our understanding of neural induction and early patterning.

A hierarchy of gene expression accompanying induction of the primitive streak by Vg1 in the chick embryo

In the chick embryo, two secreted factors have recently be shown to cooperate in inducing the first axial structure, the primitive streak: cWnt8C (normally expressed around the circumference of the embryo, in the marginal zone) and the TGF beta superfamily member cVg1 (expressed in the posterior part of the marginal zone) (Development 128 (2001) 2915). Misexpression of Vg1 in the anterior marginal zone induces an ectopic primitive streak and recapitulates the morphological changes associated with normal primitive streak formation. Here, we analyse the time-course of appearance and disappearance of expression of 12 genes (cVg1, Lef1, Nodal, FGF8, cWnt8C, cBra, cNot1, goosecoid, HNF3 beta, Chordin, Otx2 and Sox3, whose normal expression is also polarized at early stages of development) in response to cVg1 misexpression in the anterior marginal zone. We show that a hierarchy of gene expression accompanies induction of the ectopic axis, reminiscent of the order in which the same genes begin to be expressed in the normal embryo.