Drug-induced hepatitis associated with anticytoplasmic organelle autoantibodies

An analysis of drug-induced liver injury, which showed histological findings similar to autoimmune hepatitis

BACKGROUND

Drug-induced liver injury (DILI) sometimes resembles autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) in its hepatic histology. However, there is lacking data of a comparison of the characteristics between such DILI and DILI without histological findings like AIH.

METHODS

We enrolled 62 patients with DILI who were diagnosed using the Roussel Uclaf Causality Assessment Method, and performed a liver biopsy. These patients were classified into two groups: DILI with histology like AIH (group A, n = 23) and DILI without such histology (group B, n = 39). Sixteen patients of group A could be further classified into two groups: patients with relapse of the liver injury (group C, n = 8) and without relapse (group D, n = 8), after the recovery of the DILI. We compared the clinical and histological findings between group A and B, and group C versus D.

RESULTS

Group A was characterized by an older age (p = 0.043), higher immunoglobulin G level (p = 0.017), positive antinuclear antibody status (p = 0.044), and a higher frequency of complementary alternative medicines and Chinese herbal medicines as the causative drug (p = 0.008). There were no significant differences between group C and D regarding the clinical data and liver histological findings.

CONCLUSIONS

The clinical characteristics of DILI, which showed histological findings similar to AIH, were revealed. In such patients, a liver biopsy is recommended in order to determine the appropriate treatment strategy. In DILI with histology like AIH patients, long-term follow-up is needed to perceive the relapse.

Characteristics of idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury in children: results from the DILIN prospective study

BACKGROUND

The spectrum and severity of idiosyncratic drug-induced liver injury (DILI) in children are not well established.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The DILIN (Drug-Induced Liver Injury Network) Prospective Study is a longitudinal multicenter study designed to determine the etiologies, risk factors, and outcomes of suspected DILI. Between September 2004 and September 2009, 30 children ages 2 to 18 years with suspected DILI who met eligibility criteria were enrolled and studied for at least 6 months.

RESULTS

Mean age was 14 years; 70% were girls. Antimicrobial (50%) and central nervous system agents (40%) were the most commonly implicated drug classes, with minocycline (4), isoniazid (3), azithromycin (3), atomoxetine (3), and lamotrigine (3) the leading agents. Median time from drug initiation to symptom onset was 32 days. Peak (median) liver chemistries were aspartate aminotransferase 503  U/L, alanine aminotransferase 727  U/L, alkaline phosphatase 331  U/L, and total bilirubin 3.9  mg/dL. Autoantibodies were common (64%). Liver injury pattern was hepatocellular 78%, cholestatic 13%, and mixed 9%. The DILI episode was scored: mild 32%, moderate 44%, severe 20%, and fatal (within 6 months) 4%. Causality assessment was definite 36%, very likely 36%, probable 16%, possible 8%, and unlikely 4%. Seven percent had persistent liver test abnormalities at 6-month follow-up suggesting chronic DILI. Liver biopsies from 12 children most frequently demonstrated chronic hepatitis or bile duct injury.

CONCLUSIONS

Idiosyncratic DILI in children is most commonly caused by antimicrobial or central nervous system agents and usually presents with a hepatocellular injury pattern. The majority of patients recover, but morbidity and infrequent mortality are seen.

Anti-cytochrome P450 autoantibodies in drug-induced disease

Drugs may induce hepatitis through immune mechanisms. In this review we have used the examples of 2 drugs to elucidate the first steps leading to the triggering of such disease, namely tienilic acid (TA) and dihydralazine (DH). These drugs are transformed into reactive metabolite(s) by cytochrome P450 (2C9 for TA and 1A2 for DH) (step 1). The reactive metabolites produced are very short-lived and bind directly to the enzymes which generated them (step 2). A neoantigen is thus formed which triggers an immune response (step 3), characterized by the presence of autoantibodies in the patient's serum (step 4). The autoantibodies are directed against the cytochrome P450 which generated the metabolite(s). Although the process by which TA and DH induce-hepatitis has been elucidated, further studies are necessary to generalize this mechanism. In addition, an animal model will also be useful to fully understand the immune mechanism of this type of disease.

Drug-induced liver injury at an Asian center: a prospective study

BACKGROUND/AIMS

The aetiology of drug-induced liver injuries (DILI) in Asia is different from that in the West, as anecdotal studies have shown that traditional complementary and alternative medicines (CAM) accounted for a major proportion of offending drugs in DILI in Asia. We aimed to study DILI in Asia prospectively, and to test whether DILI caused by traditional CAM was related to adulterants.

METHODS

A collaborative group consisting of a tertiary-hospital hepatology department, a pharmaceutical laboratory, and a pharmacovigilance unit was formed to study patients with DILI at a tertiary hospital over a 26-month period prospectively. Traditional medicines that were implicated were tested for the presence of adulterants.

RESULTS

Thirty-one patients with DILI were enrolled: age 51+/-3 (18-79) years, 17 (55%) male. Twenty-three (74%) had hepatocellular, six (19%) had cholestatic, and two (7%) had a mixed pattern of injury. Chinese traditional CAM was the most common medication type implicated, accounting for 17 (55%) patients, followed by Malay CAM in five (16%). Thirty-one traditional medicines from 17 patients were available for chemical analysis. Adulterants were found in nine (29%) of them.

CONCLUSIONS

DILI in Asia has a different aetiology as compared with the West, and could be related to presence of adulterants in traditional CAM.

Antimitochondrial antibodies in patients with epilepsy

Immune mechanisms have been implicated in the pathogenesis of epilepsy. An increased prevalence of autoantibodies, as well as changes in serum immunoglobulin concentrations, has been reported in patients with epilepsy. The presence of unspecific antimitochondrial antibodies (AMAs) and their possible associations with other immunological markers were evaluated in a cohort of 1386 adult patients with epilepsy and population-based reference subjects. Unspecific AMAs were more frequent in epilepsy patients than in the reference group. Thirty-seven epilepsy patients (3.9%) and eleven control subjects (1.9%) had unspecific AMAs (RR 2.1, CI 1.05-4.1, P=0.03). These antibodies were associated with long duration of epilepsy and old age at the onset of epilepsy among patients with epilepsy. Their presence was independent of other immunological markers, comorbidity, and epilepsy medications.

Transition of care between paediatric and adult gastroenterology. Autoimmune hepatitis

Autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) is a rare chronic disease of the liver with an excellent prognosis under medical therapy capable of reaching complete remission. The diagnosis of AIH relies on the exclusion of viral, metabolic, genetic and toxic aetiologies of chronic hepatitis, or hepatic injury. Autoantibodies contribute to the diagnosis of AIH and have led to the serological subclassification into three distinct types. Also, immunogenetic associations suggest heterogeneity of the syndrome of AIH. Treatment is not based on serological types but is uniformly employed for all subtypes of AIH. Although 90% of patients respond to treatment, immunosuppressive drugs used in transplant medicine have been employed for patients with treatment failure. New drugs, such as budenoside, are being evaluated for the long-term treatment of AIH with a reduction in steroid side-effects. Liver transplantation is an established treatment option for patients who fail to reach remission and progress to cirrhosis and liver failure. In Europe, about 4% of cirrhotic patients with the diagnosis of AIH undergo transplantation. The diagnosis and awareness of the disease is designed to reduce mortality and morbidity.

Immune-mediated drug-induced liver disease

Drug-induced immune-mediated hepatic injury is an adverse immune response against the liver that results in a disease with hepatitic, cholestatic, or mixed clinical features. Drugs such as halothane, tienilic acid, dihydralazine, and anticonvulsants trigger a hepatitic reaction, and drugs such as chlorpromazine, erythromycins, amoxicillin-calvulanic acid, sulfonamides and sulindac trigger a cholestatic or mixed reaction. Unstable metabolites derived from the metabolism of the drug may bind to cellular proteins or macromolecules, leading to a direct toxic effect on hepatocytes. Protein adducts formed in the metabolism of the drug may be recognized by the immune system as neoantigens. Immunocyte activation may then generate autoantibodies and cell-mediated immune responses, which in turn damage the hepatocytes. Cytochromes 450 are the major oxidative catalysts in drug metabolism, and they can form a neoantigen by covalently binding with the drug metabolite that they produce. Autoantibodies that develop are selectively directed against the particular cytochrome isoenzyme that metabolized the parent drug. The hapten hypothesis proposes that the drug metabolite can act as a hapten and can modify the self of the individual by covalently binding to proteins. The danger hypothesis proposes that the immune system only responds to a foreign antigen if the antigen is associated with a danger signal, such as cell stress or cell death. Most clinically overt adverse hepatic events associated with drugs are unpredictable, and they have intermediate (1 to 8 weeks) or long latency (up to 12 months) periods characteristic of hypersensitivity reactions. Immune-mediated drug-induced liver disease nearly always disappears or becomes quiescent when the drug is removed. Methyldopa, minocycline, and nitrofurantoin can produce a chronic hepatitis resembling AIH if the drug is continued.

The liver and lovastatin

The cholesterol-lowering agents, known as statins, have been in use for 15 years and are among the most commonly prescribed drugs. Animal studies and premarketing clinical trials have given signals of hepatotoxicity, primarily minor elevations in serum alanine aminotransferase enzyme (ALT) levels. For that reason, all of the cholesterol-lowering drugs have labeling that requires monitoring of liver enzymes. Postmarketing experience, however, suggests that hepatotoxicity is rare and thus it is timely to revisit the issue. The first of the statins, lovastatin, was approved in 1986 and has acquired 24 million patient-years of clinical experience. Minor elevations in liver enzymes, i.e., ALT 3 x the upper limit of normal (ULN) occur in 2.6% and 5.0% of patients on lovastatin doses of 20 and 80 mg/day, respectively. These elevations are reversible with continuing therapy, are dose related, and are probably related to cholesterol lowering per se. Rare cases of acute liver failure (ALF) have been reported with all of the cholesterol-lowering drugs. With lovastatin, the rate is approximately 1/1.14 million patient-treatment years, which is 9% of the background rate of all causes of ALF and approximately equal to the background rate of idiopathic ALF. Monitoring for hepatotoxicity has not been effective in preventing serious liver disease, largely because of its rarity and the poor predictive value of minor ALT elevations. In fact, it may increase patient risk because of needless discontinuation of cholesterol-lowering therapy for false-positive results in patients who are benefiting from treatment.

Ornidazole-induced autoimmune hepatitis

Ornidazole is a commonly prescribed antiparasitic drug for parasitic infestations, including amoebiasis, giardiasis and Trichomonas vaginalis. Several cases of antibiotic-induced autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) or AIH-like syndrome have been reported recently. In this report, we describe a 35-year-old woman with two relapses of AIH induced by ornidazole prescribed for diarrhoea and vaginal infection.

Immunological principles of adverse drug reactions: the initiation and propagation of immune responses elicited by drug treatment

Adverse drug reactions account for between 2 to 5% of all hospital admissions and can prevent the administration of an otherwise effective therapeutic agent. Hypersensitivity or immune-mediated reactions, although less common, tend to be proportionately more serious. There is convincing evidence to implicate the immune system in the pathogenesis of hypersensitivity reactions. Our understanding of the way in which the immune system recognises drugs is based on the hapten hypothesis; the onset of hypersensitivity involves drug bioactivation, covalent binding to proteins, followed by uptake, antigen processing and T cell proliferation. Central to this hypothesis is the critical role of drug metabolism, with the balance between metabolic bioactivation and detoxification being one important component of individual susceptibility. The purpose of this review is to classify drug hypersensitivity reactions in terms of their clinical presentation, and also to consider recent advances in our understanding of the chemical, biochemical and, in particular, cellular immunological mechanisms of hypersensitivity. The following topics are reviewed: (i) drug disposition and cellular metabolism; (ii) mechanisms of antigen processing and presentation; (iii) the role of cytokines and co-stimulatory molecules in the induction and maintenance of a polarised immune response; and (iv) the application of the hapten hypothesis, danger hypothesis and serial triggering model to drug hypersensitivity. A greater understanding of the mechanism(s) of hypersensitivity may identify novel therapeutic strategies and help to combat one of the more severe forms of adverse reactions to drugs.

Drug-induced liver disease

The incidence of drug-induced liver disease appears to be increasing, reflecting the increasing number of new agents that have been introduced into clinical use over the past several decades. Among the topics covered, the author discusses incidence, diagnosis, risk factors, clinical presentations, hepatitis, and vascular injury. The author also reviews the hepatic injury seen with commonly prescribed drugs, emphasizing newer developments in the field and recent publications and reports.

Defining patient risks from expanded preventive therapies

In clinical trials, all lipid-lowering agents have been associated with mild, asymptomatic elevations of alanine aminotransferase (ALT) and asparate aminotransferase enzymes. This, along with the fact that 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl-coenzyme A (HMG-CoA) reductase inhibitors are hepatotoxic in some animals, led the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to recommend monitoring of liver enzymes for all lipid-lowering agents, except the bile acid sequestrants. Because the drugs act by different mechanisms, ALT elevations may be a pharmacodynamic effect related to lipid lowering, rather than a direct effect of the drug. Animal studies support this assumption. ALT elevations of 3 times the upper limit of normal occur in <3% of patients in clinical trials of lipid-lowering drugs. The elevations are transient and often dose-related, and they usually revert to normal while continuing therapy and have never been associated with hepatotoxicity. Confounding factors include alcohol, acetaminophen, and pre-existing liver disease, such as chronic hepatitis C and type II diabetes with fatty liver, which are both associated with mild, intermittent elevations of ALT. The more important issue is whether or not lipid-lowering agents are hepatotoxic. There are case reports of hepatotoxicity (cholestasis, jaundice, hepatitis, chronic active hepatitis, fatty liver, cirrhosis and acute liver failure) with all of the drugs, except cholestyramine. To date there are just 5 cases of documented liver failure linked to lovastatin. There is no evidence that monitoring reduces the rate of hepatotoxicity. Mild elevations of ALT that occur with many drugs, including HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors, do not predict hepatotoxicity. Liver enzyme elevations appear to be a class characteristic of lipid-lowering agents. Hepatotoxicity is a rare idiosyncratic reaction, occurring only with sustained released nicotinic acid.

Drug-induced liver disease

Drug-induced liver disease may account for between 10% and 50% of adult patients with elevated enzymes, especially in patients over age 50 years. It accounts for nearly 25% of patients with fulminant hepatic failure. Liver injury can be cytotoxic, cholestatic, or mixed. A variety of systemic manifestations can accompany drug-induced hepatotoxicity. Drug-induced liver disease can mimic autoimmune hepatitis or it can evolve to cirrhosis. It can also mimic veno-occulusive disorders. The plethora of herbal and traditional agents currently ingested by many people should always be considered in any patient with abnormal hepatic biochemistry.

Case report: a rare association of primary biliary cirrhosis and systemic lupus erythematosus and review of the literature

We report a rare occurrence of systemic lupus erythematosus in a patient known to have had well-documented primary biliary cirrhosis for 10 years. The presentation was dramatic with pericardial tamponade, but responded well to high dose corticosteroid. There are only five such definite associations reported in the literature. In the present case, other possible causes were considered, such as drug-induced cholestasis, drug-induced lupus, autoimmune chronic active hepatitis and the overlap syndrome.

Drug-induced immunotoxicity

Immune-related drug responses are one of the most common sources of idiosyncratic toxicity. A number of organs may be the target of such reactions; however, this review concentrates mostly on the liver. Drug-induced hepatitis is generally divided into two categories: acute hepatitis in which the drug or a metabolite destroys a vital target in the cell; immunoallergic hepatitis in which the drug triggers an adverse immune response directed against the liver. Their clinical features are: a) low frequency; b) dose independence; c) typical immune system manifestations such as fever, eosinophilia; d) delay between the initiation of treatment and onset of the disease; e) a shortened delay upon rechallenge; and f) occasional presence of autoantibodies in the serum of patients. Such signs have been found in cases of hepatitis triggered by drugs such as halothane, tienilic acid, dihydralazine and anticonvulsants. They will be taken as examples to demonstrate the recent progress made in determining the mechanisms responsible for the disease. The following mechanisms have been postulated: 1) the drug is first metabolized into a reactive metabolite which binds to the enzyme that generated it; 2) this produces a neoantigen which, once presented to the immune system, might trigger an immune response characterized by 3) the production of antibodies recognizing both the native and/or the modified protein; 4) rechallenge leads to increased neoantigen production, a situation in which the presence of antibodies may induce cytolysis. Toxicity is related to the nature and amount of neoantigen and also to other factors such as the individual immune system. An effort should be made to better understand the precise mechanisms underlying this kind of disease and thereby identify the drugs at risk; and also the neoantigen processes necessary for their introduction into the immune system. An animal model would be useful in this regard.

Recent developments in autoimmune liver diseases

Several diseases are regarded as autoimmune liver diseases. Apart from the cholestatic liver diseases, primary biliary cirrhosis, primary sclerosing cholangitis, these include autoimmune hepatitis, hepatitis as part of the autoimmune polyendocrine syndrome type 1 (APS-1) and particular overlap syndromes such as autoimmune cholangitis (also called antimitochondrial antibody negative primary biliary cirrhosis [PBC]), overlap syndrome chronic active hepatitis (CAH)/PBC and the overlap syndrome primary sclerosing hepatitis (PSC)/CAH. In addition, auto-antibodies may be observed during the course of chronic viral hepatitis, in particular chronic hepatitis C and D. Finally, a small number of drug-induced liver diseases is immune mediated. The following article will review our recent progress in the field of autoimmune hepatitis including APS-1 and autoimmunity in viral hepatitis and immune-mediated drug-induced liver disease.

Acute hepatitis caused by alverine associated with anti-lamin A and C autoantibodies

We report the case of a 67-year-old woman in whom onset and regression of acute hepatitis were closely related to the time of administration and withdrawal of the smooth muscle relaxant alverine. Antinuclear antibodies were positive, and their titer followed the course of hepatitis. They presented a smooth rim-like nuclear immunofluorescence staining pattern. Immunoblot assay showed that they were directed against lamin A and lamin C. This suggests that alverine should be added to the list of drugs known to produce acute hepatitis, and that drug-induced liver injury is a possible cause of antinuclear antibodies specific for lamin A and lamin C.

Molecular structure and hepatotoxicity: compared data about two closely related thiophene compounds

Two closely related compounds, a diuretic drug tienilic acid (TA) and its isomer TAI have been found to exert very different toxic effects. In human liver microsomes TA is oxidized mainly by CYP 2C9 with formation of a reactive metabolite which covalently binds to CYP 2C9 in a rather specific manner. On the contrary, CYP 2C9-dependent oxidation of TAI leads to reactive metabolite(s) causing an intense covalent binding to several microsomal proteins. Based on these very different behaviours and fates of TA and TAI metabolites, it is proposed that the direct hepatotoxic effects of TAI could be due to an intense, non-specific covalent binding of its reactive metabolite(s) to liver proteins, whereas the toxic effects of the immunoallergic type of TA could be due to the very specific covalent binding of its sulfoxide metabolite to CYP 2C9.

Immunotoxicology of the liver: adverse reactions to drugs

Liver is a frequent target for drug-induced hepatitis. They can be classified in two categories: the hepatitis in which the drug or a metabolite reach a vital target in the cell and the hepatitis in which the drug triggers an adverse immune response directed against the liver. We will discuss essentially this second kind of disease. They have key clinical features such as the low frequency, the dose independence, the delay between the beginning of drug intake and the triggering of the disease, the shortening of the delay upon rechallenge and very often the presence of autoantibodies in the serum of the patients. Such signs were found in hepatitis triggered by drugs such as halothane, tienilic acid, dihydralazine, anticonvulsants. They will be taken as examples to show the recent progress in the understanding of the mechanisms leading to the disease. It has been postulated that the drug is metabolised into a reactive metabolite binding to the enzyme which generated it; therefore the neoantigen might trigger an immune response characterised by the production of antibodies recognising the native and or the modified protein. Most of these steps were proven in the cases of halothane, tienilic acid and dihydralazine. Several points seem important in the development of the disease; the equilibrium between toxication and detoxication pathways, the nature and amount of neoantigen, the individual immune response. However, many points remain unclear: for instance, the reason for the very low frequency of this kind of disease; the precise mechanism of the adverse immune response; the risk factors for developing such adverse reactions. Efforts should be made to better understand the mechanisms of this kind of disease: for instance, an animal model, tests to identify drugs at risk for such reactions, the role of these drugs in the processing of P450s and the processing of the neoantigens for their presentation to the immune system.

Cytochromes P450 and UDP-glucuronosyl-transferases as hepatocellular autoantigens

Autoantibodies directed against cytochromes P450 or UDP-glucuronosyl-transferases (UGTs) are detected in hepatitis of different aetiology: drug-induced hepatitis autoimmune hepatitis type 2, hepatitis associated with the autoimmune polyglandular syndrome type 1 (APS1) and virus-induced autoimmunity. Autoantibodies directed against cytochrome P450 2C9 are induced by tienilic acid, and anti-P450 1A2 autoantibodies by dihydralazine. Potential mechanisms involved may be metabolic activation of the drugs by cytochromes P450, adduct formation and circumvention of T cell tolerance. In contrast, little is known about the aetiology of autoimmune hepatitis type 2. This disease is characterized by marked female predominance, hypergammaglobulinaemia, circulating autoantibodies and benefit from immunosuppression. Patients with HLA B8, DR3 or DR4 are over-represented. The major target of autoimmunity in this disease is cytochrome P450 2D6. The autoantibodies were shown to be directed against at four short linear epitopes. In addition, about 10% of the patient sera form an additional autoantibody that detects a conformational epitope on UGTs of family 1. The phenomenon of virus-associated autoimmunity is found in chronic infections with hepatitis C and D. In chronic hepatitis C the major target of the autoantibodies again is cytochrome P450 2D6. Some linear and a high proportion of conformational epitopes are recognized. The LKM3 autoantibody is found in 13% of patients with chronic hepatitis D. The target proteins are UGTs of family 1 and, in some sera also, low titres of anto-antibodies directed against UGTs of family 2 are found. The epitopes detected are conformational. In contrast to the patients suffering from autoimmune hepatitis, patients with hepatitis as part of the autoimmune polyglandular syndrome type 1 recognize cytochrome P450 1A2. Interestingly, in APS1 patients also, autoantibodies directed against cytochromes P450 c21, P450 scc and P450 c17a may be detected; these autoantibodies are associated with adrenal and ovarian failure.

Cytochrome P450 enzymes and UDP-glucuronosyltransferases as hepatocellular autoantigens

Cytochromes P450 and UDP-Glucuronosyltransferases (UGT) are targets of microsomal autoantibodies in liver and kidney (LKM). LKM autoantibodies are observed in autoimmune hepatitis, in some patients with viral hepatitis, drug-induced hepatitis and autoimmune hepatitis as disease component of the autoimmune polyglandular syndrome type 1 (APS-1). In autoimmune hepatitis LKM antibodies are markers of autoimmune hepatitis type 2. The major target of LKM-1 antibodies is cytochrome P450 2D6; a second less frequent target was the described UGTs of family 1. In autoimmune hepatitis LKM-1 autoantibodies are usually directed against small linear epitopes. LKM autoantibodies are also associated with infection with hepatitis viruses C and D. In hepatitis C about 1-2% of patients develop LKM-1 autoantibodies. About 60% of these autoantibodies are conformation dependent. The presence of LKM autoantibodies in hepatitis C may be associated with an increased risk in interferon treatment. LKM-3 autoantibodies are found in about 8% of patients with hepatitis D and are directed against conformational epitopes. Patients treated with certain drugs may develop drug induced hepatitis. In hepatitis induced by tienilic acid, tienilic acid is activated by and covalently bound to cytochrome P450 2C9. Activation of the immune system results in the formation of autoantibodies against cytochrome P450 2C9 (LKM-2) and infiltration of the liver with immune cells. A similar mechanism has been described for dihydralazine induced hepatitis, where autoantibodies are directed against P450 1A2 (LM). Autoantibodies directed against cytochrome P450 1A2 also are found in patients suffering from hepatitis as a disease component of APS-1.

Molecular mimicry in halothane hepatitis: biochemical and structural characterization of lipoylated autoantigens

Exposure of human individuals to halothane causes, in about 20% of all cases, a mild transient form of hepatotoxicity. A small subset of exposed individuals, however, develops a potentially severe and life-threatening form of hepatic damage, coined halothane hepatitis. Halothane hepatitis is thought to have an immunological basis. Sera of afflicted individuals contain a wide variety of autoantibodies against hepatic proteins, in both trifluoroacetylated form (CF3CO-proteins) and, at least in part, in native form. CF3CO-proteins are elicited in the course of oxidative biotransformation of halothane, and include the trifluoroacetylated forms of protein disulfide isomerase, microsomal carboxylesterase, calreticulin, ERp72, GRP 78, and ERp99. Current evidence suggests that CF3CO-proteins arise in all halothane-exposed individuals; however, the vast majority of individuals appear to immunochemically tolerate CF3CO-proteins. The lack of immunological responsiveness of these individuals towards CF3CO-proteins might be due to tolerance, induced through the occurrence of structures in the repertoire of self-determinants, which immunochemically and structurally mimic CF3CO-proteins very closely. In fact, lipoic acid, the prosthetic group of the constitutively expressed E2 subunits of the family of mammalian 2-oxoacid dehydrogenase complexes and of protein X, was shown by immunochemical and molecular modelling analysis to be a perfect structural mimic of N6-trifluoroacetyl-L-lysine (CF3 CO-Lys), the major haptenic group of CF3CO-proteins. As a consequence of molecular mimicry, autoantibodies in patients' sera not only recognize CF3CO-proteins, but also the E2 subunit proteins of the 2-oxoacid dehydrogenase complexes and protein X, as autoantigens associated with halothane hepatitis. Furthermore, a fraction of patients with halothane hepatitis exhibit irregularities in the hepatic expression levels of these native, not trifluoroacetylated autoantigens. Collectively, these data suggest that molecular mimicry of CF3CO-Lys by lipoic acid, or the impairment thereof, might play a role in the susceptibility of individuals for the development of halothane hepatitis.

Idiosyncratic liver toxicity of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs: molecular mechanisms and pathology

This review explores the clinical hepatic pathology associated with the use of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), possible cellular and molecular mechanisms of injury, and future challenges. NSAIDs comprise a group of widely used compounds that have been associated with rare adverse reactions in the liver, including fulminant hepatitis and cholestasis. These reactions are idiosyncratic, mostly independent of the dose administered, and host-dependent. The mechanisms responsible for the initiation and perpetuation of NSAID-induced hepatotoxicity remain poorly understood and have been largely inferred from clinical manifestation. A mounting body of evidence, however, indicates that many acidic NSAIDs are metabolized to reactive acyl glucuronides that can form covalent adducts with plasma proteins and hepatocellular proteins. In hepatocytes cocultured with lymphocytes, these NSAID-altered proteins can become antigenic. Thus, long-lived, drug-altered proteins may act as immunogens and produce cytotoxic T-cell-mediated or antibody-dependent, cell-mediated toxicity in susceptible patients. Alternatively, individual abnormalities in metabolism or disposition of some NSAIDs may lead to the formation or accumulation of toxic metabolites. Additional work with transgenic animal models is needed to permit better understanding of the general and specific risk factors involved in the pathogenesis of the idiosyncratic liver injuries related to NSAIDs and other drugs.

Identification of protein disulfide isomerase and calreticulin as autoimmune antigens in LEC strain of rats

Long Evans Cinnamon (LEC) rats, showing spontaneous hereditary hepatitis and hepatic carcinoma, were found to possess autoimmune antibodies to liver microsomal proteins, particularly to proteins with the molecular weight of 56kD and 55kD. The antibodies occurred in association with acute lethal hepatitis in the LEC rats in our previous study. Two-dimensional immunoblot analysis of the antigenic proteins revealed that the 56kDa and 55kDa proteins showed 4.2 and 4.0 pI values and were estimated to be protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) and calreticulin, respectively, from NH2-terminal amino acid sequence analysis. These proteins were further identified by immunoblot analyses using purified proteins and specific antibodies. PDI was a major autoimmune antigenic protein.

Immunotoxicology and expression of human cytochrome P450 in microorganisms

Drug-induced hepatitis can be caused by an abnormal immunological response. In the case of tienilic acid- and dihydralazine-induced hepatitis, we postulated a scheme in which a P450 produced a reactive metabolite (step 1); this reactive metabolite bound to the P450 producing it (step 2) leading to a neoantigen triggering the immune response (step 3); the autoantibodies produced during the immune response recognized the P450 producing the reactive metabolite (step 4). The use of microorganisms (yeast or bacteria) expressing cloned human P450 helped in proving some steps of this postulated scheme, particularly steps 1 and 4.

Diclofenac induced hepatitis. 3 cases with features of autoimmune chronic active hepatitis

Diclofenac is a frequently prescribed nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug (NSAID). Significant hepatotoxicity related to diclofenac may be more common than previously recognized, as three patients with diclofenac-associated hepatitis were seen by one clinician in a single year. All patients were ANA positive during the hepatitis and had histologic features of chronic active hepatitis. Two had been inappropriately treated with corticosteroids. The third patient presented more acutely with jaundice and symptoms of hepatitis. Two of the patients developed the same hepatic reaction when rechallenged with diclofenac. The third patient was changed to tiaprofenic acid, a NSAID of the same family, and redeveloped evidence of hepatotoxicity. All three were subsequently able to take naproxen without liver dysfunction. Diclofenac-induced liver disease may be misdiagnosed. Twenty-six cases of significant hepatic reactions to diclofenac have been previously reported in the literature and are reviewed. Such hepatic reactions to diclofenac and related NSAIDs may be commoner than realized. Introduction of a NSAID of another class appears to be safe.

Mechanisms of halothane toxicity: novel insights

Exposure of individuals to halothane causes, in 20% of patients, a mild form of hepatotoxicity. In contrast, a very small subset of individuals only develops halothane hepatitis, which is thought to have an immunological basis. Sera of halothane hepatitis patients contain antibodies directed against some discrete liver trifluoroacetyl (TFA)-protein adducts, which arise upon oxidative biotransformation of halothane and include protein disulfide isomerase, microsomal carboxylesterase, calreticulin, ERp72, GRP 78 and ERp99. No immune response occurs in the majority of human individuals, although evidence suggests that TFA-protein adducts arise in all halothane-exposed individuals. The lack of immunological responsiveness of individuals might be due to tolerance, induced by a presumed repertoire of self-peptides that molecularly mimic TFA-protein adducts. Thus, constitutively expressed proteins of 52 and 64 kDa have been identified that confer molecular mimicry of TFA-protein adducts. The 64 kDa protein corresponds to the E2 subunit of the mitochondrial pyruvate dehydrogenase complex. Lipoic acid, the prosthetic group of the E2 subunit, is involved in the molecular mimicry process. A fraction of halothane hepatitis patients exhibit irregularities in the expression levels of the 52 kDa protein and the E2 subunit protein. Molecular mimicry of TFA-protein adducts by the 52 kDa protein and the E2 subunit protein might play a role in the susceptibility of individuals to development of halothane hepatitis.

P450 enzymes. Inhibition mechanisms, genetic regulation and effects of liver disease

Multiple hepatic P450 enzymes play an important role in the oxidative biotransformation of a vast number of structurally diverse drugs. As such, these enzymes are a major determinant of the pharmacokinetic behaviour of most therapeutic agents. There are several factors that influence P450 activity, either directly or at the level of enzyme regulation. Drug elimination is decreased and the incidence of drug interactions is increased when there is competition between 2 or more drugs for oxidation by the same P450 enzyme. The available knowledge concerning the relationship between the presence of certain functional groups within the drug structure and inhibition of P450 activity is increasing. In many instances, it is possible to associate inhibition with certain drug classes, e.g. antimycotic imidazoles and macrolide antibiotics. Disease states, especially those with hepatic involvement, and the genetic makeup of the individual are conditions in which some P450s may be downregulated (that is, the enzyme concentrations in liver are decreased), with associated slower rates of drug elimination. In these individuals, dosages of drugs that are substrates for downregulated P450s should be decreased. Exposure to environmental pollutants as well as a large number of lipophilic drugs can result in induction (upregulation) of P450 enzyme activity. This raises the issue of previous approaches to the study of P450 induction in vivo. The use of human hepatocyte preparations in culture is a promising new direction that could assist the determination of modifications to drug therapy necessitated by exposure to inducing agents. Until such information is obtained, however, the use of drugs known to increase the microsomal expression of particular P450s, and increase associated drug oxidation capacity in humans, should be used with caution.

Presence of functionally active cytochrome P-450IIE1 in the plasma membrane of rat hepatocytes

Recent experiments have described the presence of cytochrome P-450 and certain P-450 isozymes in the plasma membrane of rat liver. Experiments were carried out to evaluate whether cytochrome P-450IIE1 was present in the plasma membrane fraction of livers from control rats and rats treated with 4-methylpyrazole, which induces this isozyme. Using immunofluorescence, fluorescence was detected at the surface of intact hepatocytes that were initially incubated with anti-P-450IIE1 IgG, but not preimmune IgG, followed by incubating with goat antirabbit IgG conjugated with either fluorescein or rhodamine. The fluorescence appeared to be uniformly distributed across the entire surface. Intense intracellular staining could be observed when the hepatocytes were permeabilized by acetone treatment. Similar results were obtained with control hepatocytes; however, the fluorescence intensity was considerably less than that shown by the induced hepatocytes. Hepatocytes isolated from the pericentral zone of the liver acinus displayed more intense fluorescence at the surface than did hepatocytes from the periportal zone. Purified plasma membranes oxidized dimethylnitrosamine to formaldehyde at rates that were 14% to 30% that of the microsomes, which exceeds the 3% contamination of the plasma membranes by microsomes as assessed by glucose-6-phosphatase activity. Immunoblots of the plasma membranes revealed the presence of a single band, whose intensity of staining was 14% to 26% that of the microsomes. Oxidation of dimethylnitrosamine and immunoblot intensity were about twofold greater with plasma membrane fractions from 4-methylpyrazole-treated rats than controls. These results suggest the presence of inducible, functionally active P-450IIE1 in the plasma membrane, which may be of toxicological significance in view of the preferential metabolism of a variety of hepatotoxins and carcinogens and the elevated production of reactive oxygen intermediates by this isozyme.

Occurrence of autoimmune antibodies to liver microsomal proteins in association with fulminant hepatitis in the LEC strain of rats

The Long Evans Cinnamon (LEC) rat, which has been established as a strain showing hereditary hepatitis and hepatic carcinoma, was found to possess autoimmune antibodies to liver microsomal proteins, particularly to a protein with the molecular weight of 56kD. The antibodies also recognized a protein(s) in liver microsomes from Long Evans Agouti and Sprague-Dawley rats. About 42 and 15 percent of respective female and male LEC rats died within a week after acute hepatitis; sera from all of the animals contained the antibodies. About 43 and 0 percent of the surviving female and male LEC rats possessed the antibodies, respectively. These results suggest that the autoantibodies occur in association with acute lethal hepatitis in the LEC rats.

Anti-liver endoplasmic reticulum autoantibodies are directed against human cytochrome P-450IA2. A specific marker of dihydralazine-induced hepatitis

Sera from patients with dihydralazine-induced hepatitis were shown to contain anti-liver microsomal autoantibodies (anti-LM) by indirect immunofluorescence. These anti-LM antibodies were different from anti-liver/kidney microsomes (anti-LKM) 1 or 2 autoantibodies which have been previously described. Sera recognized a single 53,000 = Mr polypeptide in human liver microsomes as judged by immunoblotting, and the target antigen was identified as cytochrome P-450IA2 (P-450IA2) by (a) comparison of immunoblotting patterns with anti-human P-450IA2 and anti-rat P-450IA2 and with five anti-LM sera, and (b) specific immunoinhibition of microsomal ethoxyresorufin and phenacetin O-deethylation activities (both P-450IA2 supported reactions) by anti-LM antibodies. Finally, purified human P-450IA2 was recognized by these anti-LM sera. The anti-LM antibodies are specific for the disease because none of the other antisera tested behaved in the same manner as anti-LM, even those from patients treated with dihydralazine and without hepatic disease. A possible role of P-450IA2 in the metabolism of dihydralazine was suggested by competitive inhibition of ethoxyresorufin-O-deethylase observed in microsomal incubations. Thus, a new example is presented in which a cytochrome P-450 may be a target for autoantibodies in drug-induced hepatitis.

Presence of functional cytochrome P-450 on isolated rat hepatocyte plasma membrane

Antibodies against cytochrome P-450 are found in some children with autoimmune hepatitis (antiliver/kidney microsome 1) and in patients with ticrynafen hepatitis (antiliver/kidney microsome 2). For an immune reaction against cytochrome P-450 to possibly destroy the hepatocytes, one must assume that cytochrome P-450 is present on the plasma membrane surface of hepatocytes. In a first series of experiments, plasma membranes were prepared with a technique based on the electrostatic attachment of isolated hepatocytes to polyethyleneimine-coated beads. After vortexing, beads were coated with a very pure plasma membrane fraction. Microsomal contamination, judged from the specific activities of glucose-6-phosphatase or NADH-cytochrome c reductase, was less than 1%. Nevertheless, the specific content (per milligram of protein) of CO-binding cytochrome P-450 was 20% of that in microsomes; the specific benzo(a)pyrene hydroxylase activity was 25%, and ethoxycoumarin deethylase 11%. Immunoblots showed the presence of cytochromes P-450 UT-A, UT-H, PB-B, ISF-G and PCN-E, the last three isoenzymes being inducible by, respectively, phenobarbital, 3-methylcholanthrene and dexamethasone. In a second series of experiments, nonpermeabilized isolated hepatocytes from untreated rats were incubated with anticytochrome P-450 antibodies. Immunofluorescence and immunoperoxidase staining confirmed the presence of cytochromes P-450 UT-A, PB-B and ISF-G on the membrane. In a last series of experiments, human antiliver-kidney microsomal 1 antibodies were found to react specifically with rat liver plasma membrane cytochrome P-450 UT-H (IID subfamily). We conclude that several cytochrome P-450 isoenzymes are present, active and inducible on the plasma membrane surface of hepatocytes. It is therefore conceivable that immunization against plasma membrane cytochrome P-450 might lead to the immunological destruction of hepatocytes in some patients.

Characteristics of clometacin-induced hepatitis with special reference to the presence of anti-actin cable antibodies

The clinical, biochemical, histopathological and immunological features of 30 cases of clometacin-induced hepatitis are described. The age range of the patients was 32-84 years with a notable female predominance of 29:1. The hepatitis was highly cytolytic with high values of transaminases but with little or no cholestasis. Gammaglobulins were higher than 18 g/l in 73% of the cases. 25 liver biopsies were performed and showed acute hepatitis with a predominant centrilobular necrosis in 17; chronic aggressive hepatitis was noted in 8 cases but 1 showed concomitant cirrhotic changes. Anti-tissue antibodies were looked for in all cases. Anti-smooth muscle antibodies of anti-actin cable type (titre 1/80 to 1/2, 560) were detected in 19 cases, anti-nucleus antibodies in 16 cases which were associated to the former in 14 cases. The above findings show that clometacin produces a hepatitis syndrome quite akin to autoimmune chronic active hepatitis (lupoid hepatitis) and to the hepatopathy induced by oxyphenisatin.