Human T cell responses to HPV 16 E2 generated with monocyte-derived dendritic cells

New Approaches to Immunotherapy for HPV Associated Cancers

Cervical cancer is the second most common cancer of women worldwide and is the first cancer shown to be entirely induced by a virus, the human papillomavirus (HPV, major oncogenic genotypes HPV-16 and -18). Two recently developed prophylactic cervical cancer vaccines, using virus-like particles (VLP) technology, have the potential to prevent a large proportion of cervical cancer associated with HPV infection and to ensure long-term protection. However, prophylactic HPV vaccines do not have therapeutic effects against pre-existing HPV infections and do not prevent their progression to HPV-associated malignancy. In animal models, therapeutic vaccines for persisting HPV infection can eliminate transplantable tumors expressing HPV antigens, but are of limited efficacy in inducing rejection of skin grafts expressing the same antigens. In humans, clinical trials have reported successful immunotherapy of HPV lesions, providing hope and further interest. This review discusses possible new approaches to immunotherapy for HPV associated cancer, based on recent advances in our knowledge of the immunobiology of HPV infection, of epithelial immunology and of immunoregulation, with a brief overview on previous and current HPV vaccine clinical trials.

Dendritic cells treated with HPV16mE7 in a three-dimensional model promote the secretion of IL-12p70 and IFN-γ

Although the human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA therapeutic vaccine represents a promising approach to the prevention and treatment of cervical cancer, the mechanism of the HPV DNA vaccine is poorly understood. Moreover, current strategies have met with only limited success in preclinical and dendritic cell-based (DC-based) clinical research. In addition, two-dimensional (2-D) DC monolayers poorly mimic the physiology function in vivo. We used a three-dimensional (3-D) DC culture model in vitro to explore the immune mechanism of the HPV DNA vaccine. DCs were generated from peripheral blood monocytes with interleukin-4 (IL-4) and granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF). The cells, growing in 3-D collagen gel, were treated with pcDNA3.1-HPV16mE7 in vitro for 48 h. Compared to DCs treated with E7 in a 2-D culture model, the expression of co-stimulatory molecules CD80 and CD40 were significantly increased in the 3-D model (p<0.05), and a remarkable increase of IL-12 p70 was observed. However, we did not detect any obvious change in IL-10 in 3-D culture. In addition, we found that IFN-γ expression increased when HPV16mE7-DC cells were co-cultured with T-cells for 96 h in the 3-D model, and HPV16mE7-DCs stimulated the proliferation of T lymphocytes more efficiently in the 3-D model than in the 2-D model (p<0.05). These results suggest that DCs in 3-D culture model have a notable effect on the enhancement of the HPV16 DNA vaccine's immune reaction and indicate that the DC-based 3-D model is a novel approach to study the HPV vaccine.

Immune concept of human papillomaviruses and related antigens in local cancer milieu of human cervical neoplasia

It is presently the right time for clarifying human papillomavirus (HPV)-associated cellular immunity and clinical implications before global HPV vaccination programs begin. Infection with oncogenic HPV associates with the progression of cervical neoplasia. Both cellular and humoral immune responses are essential for the clearance of HPV-associated cervical lesions. There is increasing evidence that the immune system plays a pivotal role in determining the outcome of HPV infection. Viruses and associated neoplastic cells are proposed to have evolved mechanisms to avoid immune attack. T-cell-mediated immune responses against oncogenic HPV are believed to play a central role in cervical carcinogenesis. The presence of HPV-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in a majority of human cervical cancer patients provides an approach for further study of their functional role in modulating this malignancy. Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) develop as manifestations of the recognition and defense against malignant cells by the host immune system. Cancer cells may overcome immune surveillance, either by downregulating the proliferation of HPV-specific CTL, or altering the effector compositions of immune cells against HPV infections. TIL in the tumor microenvironment can be functionally inhibited and lose the ability of clonal proliferation as a result of depressed expression of IL-2Ralpha. The upregulation of inhibitory signaling relates to the modulation of the virus- and/or tumor-specific immune responses. Alteration of host genetic susceptibility may also lead to abnormal immune response as a general genomic instability resulting from virus persistence. Induction of HPV-specific immune responses is anticipated as an intimate point for the treatment of cervical neoplasia.

A quasi-spontaneous amyloid route in a DNA binding gene regulatory domain: The papillomavirus HPV16 E2 protein

The DNA binding domain of papillomavirus E2 proteins is at the center of the regulation of gene transcription and replication of the virus. Its unique fold consists of a beta-barrel domain that combines an eight-stranded dimeric beta-barrel core interface with two symmetrical DNA binding alpha-helices and other two helices, packed against the central barrel. Treatment with low amounts of trifluoroethanol readily leads to a mostly beta-sheet oligomeric species, with a loss of near-UV circular dichroism signal and increase in its ANS binding capacity, indicating that buried hydrophobic surfaces become accessible to the solvent. This species subsequently undergoes a slow transition into amyloid aggregates as determined by light scattering and Congo red and thioflavin T binding. Electron microscopy shows short amyloid fibers with a curly aspect as the end product. The amyloid route is completely prevented by addition of stoichiometrical amounts of specific DNA, strongly suggesting that unfolding of the DNA binding alpha-helix is required for the formation of the intermediate. The slow nature of this expanded beta-oligomeric species and the availability of several different conformational probes make it an excellent model for investigating amyloid mechanisms. The mild perturbation required for entering an amyloid route is indicative of a preexisting equilibrium. Oligomerization processes are required for the assembly of transcription initiation and DNA replication machineries, where proteins from different viruses must come together with host cell proteins. The E2 protein is a virus-encoded multifunctional master regulator that may exert one of its multiple functions through its ability to oligomerize.

Resolution of cervical dysplasia is associated with T-cell proliferative responses to human papillomavirus type 16 E2

The 'high-risk' human papillomaviruses (HPVs) cause persistent infections of the anogenital region that may resolve spontaneously following activation of a protective immune response. The aim of this study was to determine whether cell-mediated immunity (CMI) to the early protein E2 was associated with disease regression and to establish whether E2 CMI and antibodies to L1 virus-like particles (VLPs) were associated markers of immunity to HPV. Lymphoproliferative responses to histidine-tagged E2 and antibody responses to VLPs were measured in patients with persistent cervical dysplasia, those whose disease had recently resolved and normal controls. Resolvers had significantly higher E2-specific lymphoproliferative responses when compared with normal controls or persisters, whereas there was no significant difference between the persisters and the normal controls. The T cells stimulated by E2 secreted high levels of gamma interferon (IFN-gamma), consistent with a type 1 helper (Th1) phenotype. VLP IgG responses were associated with current or previous HPV infection, but not with disease regression or a lymphoproliferative response to E2. Major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted T cells secreted IFN-gamma following stimulation with E1, and E2 peptides were detected more frequently in the persister group. The data showed that lymphoproliferative responses to E2 with a cytokine profile indicative of Th1 are associated with disease resolution, supporting the development of a therapeutic vaccine that activates this type of response for the treatment of individuals with pre-existing disease.

Development of a topical protein therapeutic for human papillomavirus and associated cancers

Human papillomaviruses (HPVs) are the causative agents of several disease states, including genital warts and cervical cancer. There are around 500 million cases of genital warts per annum worldwide and around 450,000 cases of cervical cancer. Although HPV vaccines should eventually reduce the incidence of these diseases, new and effective treatments are still urgently required. The E2 (early) proteins from some HPV types induce growth arrest and apoptosis, and these proteins could be used as therapeutics for HPV-induced disease. A major obstacle to this approach concerns the delivery of the protein to HPV-transformed cells and/or HPV-infected cells in vivo. One possible solution is to use recombinant viruses to deliver E2. Another possible solution is to use purified E2 proteins or E2 fusion proteins. The herpes simplex virus VP22 protein is one of a small number of proteins that have been shown to cross the cell membrane with high efficiency. VP22-E2 fusion proteins produced in bacterial cells are able to enter mammalian cells and induce apoptosis. This suggests that VP22-E2 fusion proteins could be topically applied as a treatment for HPV-induced diseases, most probably post-surgery. In this review, we discuss this and other approaches to the topical delivery of selective therapeutic agents against HPV-associated conditions.

Diffusible VP22–E2 Protein Kills Bystander Cells and Offers a Route for Cervical Cancer Gene Therapy

Human papillomaviruses (HPVs) are a causative agent of cervical cancer and are implicated in several other types of malignant disease including cancer of the vulva, oral cancer, and skin cancer. In HPV-transformed cells, expression of the viral E6 and E7 oncogenes increases cell proliferation and inhibits apoptosis. Expression of the viral E2 protein in HPV-transformed cells represses transcription of E6 and E7 and induces apoptosis and/or growth arrest. We have shown previously that herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) VP22-HPV E2 fusion proteins can traffic between cells and induce apoptosis. Here we show that replication-defective adenoviruses can be used to deliver VP22-E2 fusion proteins to target cells. We show that the use of adenoviral vectors to deliver VP22-E2 proteins leads to high levels of apoptosis. Interestingly, VP22-E2 proteins produced in adenovirus-infected cells are able to enter uninfected cells and induce apoptosis. Trafficking between cells and the induction of apoptosis in bystander cells are detectable in a three-dimensional tumor model. These results suggest that adenoviral vectors expressing VP22-E2 fusion proteins could be used to treat cervical cancer and other HPV-associated diseases.

T-cell responses to human papillomavirus type 16 among women with different grades of cervical neoplasia

Infection with high-risk genital human papillomavirus (HPV) types is a major risk factor for the development of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and invasive cervical carcinoma. The design of effective immunotherapies requires a greater understanding of how HPV-specific T-cell responses are involved in disease clearance and/or progression. Here, we have investigated T-cell responses to five HPV16 proteins (E6, E7, E4, L1 and L2) in women with CIN or cervical carcinoma directly ex vivo. T-cell responses were observed in the majority (78%) of samples. The frequency of CD4+ responders was far lower among those with progressive disease, indicating that the CD4+ T-cell response might be important in HPV clearance. CD8+ reactivity to E6 peptides was dominant across all disease grades, inferring that E6-specific CD8+ T cells are not vitally involved in disease clearance. T-cell responses were demonstrated in the majority (80%) of cervical cancer patients, but are obviously ineffective. Our study reveals significant differences in HPV16 immunity during progressive CIN. We conclude that the HPV-specific CD4+ T-cell response should be an important consideration in immunotherapy design, which should aim to target preinvasive disease.

Flow cytometric quantitation of the protective efficacy of dendritic cell based vaccines in a human papillomavirus type 16 murine challenge model

A murine model for the assessment of protective immunity to human papillomavirus (HPV) type 16, a virus that does not naturally infect mice, is described. In this system, protection was tested following intranasal challenge of mice with a recombinant vaccinia virus expressing both the selected HPV antigen and a beta-galactosidase (beta-gal) reporter. The extent of viral infectivity was determined by measuring beta-gal positive lung cells using flow cytometry. The efficacy of this model to measure protective immunity was evaluated by priming mice with the beta-gal vaccinia virus then challenging the mice with the same virus. Vaccinia primed mice had negligible numbers of beta-gal positive cells in the lung 5 days following viral challenge indicating protection, whereas around 50% of cells were infected in immunologically naive, challenged mice. The protective efficacy of two dendritic cell vaccines for HPV16 was measured in this model. Both vaccines provided some protection to subsequent viral challenge, compared with their controls. Although this protection model was applied to HPV in this study, it may also have broad application to other viruses that do not infect mice naturally.

Human papillomavirus type 16 E2- and L1-specific serological and T-cell responses in women with vulval intraepithelial neoplasia

Human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV-16)-associated vulval intraepithelial neoplasia (VIN) is frequently a chronic, multifocal high-grade condition with an appreciable risk of progression to vulval cancer. The requirement to treat women with VIN has recently stimulated the use of immunotherapy with E6/E7 oncogene vaccines. Animal models have shown that E2 may also be a useful vaccine target for HPV-associated disease; however, little is known about E2 immunity in humans. This study investigated the prevalence of HPV-16 E2-specific serological and T-cell responses in 18 women with HPV-16-associated VIN and 17 healthy volunteers. E2 responses were determined by full-length E2-GST ELISA with ELISPOT and proliferation assays using E2 C-terminal protein. As positive controls, HPV-16 L1 responses were measured using virus-like particles (VLPs) and L1-GST ELISA with ELISPOT and proliferation using VLPs as antigen. The VIN patients all showed a strong serological response to L1 compared with the healthy volunteers by VLP (15/18 vs 1/17, P<0.001) and L1-GST ELISA (18/18 vs 1/17, P<0.001). In contrast, L1-specific cellular immune responses were detected in a significant proportion of controls but were more prevalent in the VIN patients by proliferation assay (9/17 vs 17/18, P<0.02) and interferon-gamma ELISPOT (9/17 vs 13/18, P=not significant). Similar and low numbers of patients and controls were seropositive for E2-specific Ig (2/18 vs 1/17). In spite of previous studies showing the immunogenicity of E2 in eliciting primary T-cell responses in vitro, there was a low prevalence of E2 responses in the VIN patients and controls (2/18 vs 0/17).