Characterization of T lymphocytes mediating in vivo protection against RSV-induced murine sarcomas

Immunological memory induced by genetically transduced tumor cells

BACKGROUND

Recent studies have demonstrated the usefulness of gene-modified tumor cells for immunotherapy. Using the tumorigenic murine fibrosarcoma, MCA 106, we investigated the effects of localized interferon-gamma (IFNg) secretion on tumorigenicity and on long-term memory.

METHODS

The murine IFNg (MuIFNg) gene was introduced into tumor cells. High and low IFNg-secreting clones were isolated. C57BL/6 mice were injected subcutaneously (s.c.) with either parental (P), high or low IFNg-secreting (H- or L-IFNg) cells, and tumor growth was assessed weekly. Spleens were harvested on different days postinjection (p.i.) to assess in vitro cytolytic activity. In parallel, tissues from injection sites were stained with macrophage-, CD4-, and CD8-detecting antibodies. Mice were injected s.c. with H-IFNg MCA106 tumor. After 150 days the animals were rechallenged s.c. with MCA106P in one leg and with irrelevant syngeneic tumor in the other.

RESULTS

Both P- and L-IFNg cells had similar growth, whereas the H-IFNg cells never grew. Only splenocytes from the H-IFNg animals showed in vitro CTL activity persisting until day 30 p.i. Histological data revealed a macrophage and CD4+ infiltrate much earlier in the H-IFNg group compared with the P group. Only the irrelevant, syngeneic tumor grew in animals previously injected with H-IFNg cells, whereas both P and irrelevant syngeneic tumors grew in controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Transduction of MCA106 cells with the MuIFNg gene diminished in vivo tumorigenicity in proportion to the amount of IFNg secreted. Immunization with H-IFNg cells elicited a host response characterized by macrophages and CD4+ cells. Long-term tumor-specific memory was seen after immunization with H-IFNg cells.

An extract of seeds from Aeginetia indica L., a parasitic plant, induces potent antigen-specific antitumor immunity in Meth A-bearing BALB/c mice

The antitumor activity of an extract of seeds from Aeginetia indica L., a parasitic plant, was investigated. BALB/c mice, inoculated i.p. 1 x 10(5) syngeneic Meth A tumor cells, were administered 2.5 mg/kg A. indica extract i.p. every 2 days from day 0. The untreated mice died of an ascitic form of tumor growth within 21 days, whereas all the treated mice completely recovered from tumor challenge without any side-effects. The extract did not exert direct cytotoxic activity against Meth A in vitro. Mice that survived after the first challenge as a result of A. indica treatment overcame the rechallenge with homologous Meth A without additional administration of the extract. On the other hand, those mice could not survive after rechallenge with Meth 1 tumor cells, which were also established in BALB/c mice but were different in antigenicity from Meth A, suggesting the development of antigen-specific concomitant immunity in the A. indica-cured mice. In the induction phase of antitumor resistance in this system, CD4+ T cells appeared to be the main contributors, since in vivo administration of anti-CD4 mAb completely abolished such resistance. In contrast, anti-CD8 mAb administration did not influence the effect of A. indica. The importance of CD4+ T cells in antitumor immunity was again clarified by Winn assay; that is, spleen and lymph node cells depleted of CD4+ T cells in vitro prior to assay abolished antitumor activity on co-grafted Meth A tumor cells in vivo.

Effector phenotypes and mechanisms of antitumor immune reactivity of tumor-immunized and tumor-bearing mice in two syngeneic tumors

By using two different syngeneic tumors, Meth A sarcoma and RL male 1 lymphoma of BALB/c origin, the present study was designed to investigate the subset(s) of T cells mediating in vivo antitumor immune responses and some of the effector mechanisms of in vivo protective immunity in BALB/c mice immunized against tumor or bearing tumor. Spleen cells from the mice immunized against Meth A tumor or bearing Meth A tumor inhibited the growth of Meth A tumor in the Winn assay. In the Meth A-immunized mice, L3T4+ (CD4+) cells played a major role in mediating the inhibitory activity against Meth A tumor growth, whereas in the Meth A-bearing mice, the antitumor protective immunity was mediated by both L3T4+ and Lyt-2+ (CD8+) cells. Spleen cells from the Meth A-immunized or Meth A-bearing mice were not able to generate cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) directed against Meth A tumor after the in vitro restimulation of spleen cells with mitomycin C (MMC)-treated Meth A cells, while fresh spleen cells from the Meth A-immunized or Meth A-bearing mice were able to induce the strong delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses to Meth A tumor. The DTH response to Meth A tumor was mediated by L3T4+ cells in the Meth A-immunized mice and by both L3T4+ and Lyt-2+ cells in the Meth A-bearing mice. In the similar experiments performed in the RL male 1 lymphoma, the antitumor activity in spleen cells from the RL male 1-immunized or RL male 1-bearing mice depended on Lyt-2+ but not L3T4+ cells in the Winn assay. When spleen cells from the RL male 1-immunized or RL male 1-bearing mice were cultured with MMC-treated RL male 1 cells for 5 days, an appreciable CTL response to RL male 1 tumor was induced. These results suggest that the nature of tumor and/or tumor antigens determines which T cell subset is required to exhibit the protective immunity against tumor and thus the different effector mechanisms could be induced in the different tumor models. Furthermore, these data support the conclusion that antitumor T cell responses are affected by the immune state of host to tumor.

Interferon gamma and tumor necrosis factor have a role in tumor regressions mediated by murine CD8+ tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes

We have investigated the mechanisms whereby adoptively transferred murine CD8+ lymphocytes mediate tumor regressions. Noncytolytic, CD8+ tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) eradicated established lung tumors in irradiated mice. Many cytolytic and noncytolytic CD8+ TIL cultures specifically secreted interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) and tumor necrosis factor when stimulated with tumor cells in vitro. The effectiveness of TIL when adoptively transferred to mice bearing micrometastases correlated better with their ability to specifically secrete lymphokines than with their cytotoxicity in vitro. In 14 of 15 tests, therapeutically effective TIL specifically secreted IFN-gamma in vitro, whereas only 1 of 11 ineffective TIL specifically secreted IFN-gamma. In contrast, only 8 of 15 therapeutically effective TIL were cytolytic. Antibodies to TNF inhibited the effectiveness of two adoptively transferred TIL cultures. In five experiments, antibodies to IFN-gamma abrogated the ability of four different CD8+ TIL cultures to mediate tumor regressions, indicating that secretion of IFN-gamma is an essential part of the mechanism of action of TIL.

Production of interferon-gamma by in vivo tumor-sensitized T cells: association with active antitumor immunity

The state of active immunity to Meth A fibrosarcoma in mice immunized with an admixture of Meth A cells and Propionibacterium acnes is associated with possession by the host of spleen cells capable of producing interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) upon in vitro restimulation with irradiated tumor cells. The ability of spleen cells from immunized mice to produce IFN-gamma in response to irradiated Meth A cells decays as active antitumor immunity is replaced by a state of immunological memory. The IFN-producing cells are L3T4+Ly2+, cyclophosphamide-sensitive and radiosensitive T cells, as determined by their sensitivity to corresponding monoclonal antibodies and complement. The induction of IFN-gamma production by in vivo tumor-sensitized T cells is tumor specific, in that spleen cells from mice immunized against Meth A fibrosarcoma can produce IFN in response to irradiated Meth A cells but not in response to another syngeneic tumor M109 lung carcinoma.

Delayed-type hypersensitivity to tumor antigens co-expressed with immunogenic determinants induced by xenogenization

Previous work has shown that murine lymphoma cells antigenically altered ("xenogenized") by drug treatment elicit strong in vivo resistance to the original cells. Moreover, splenocytes immune to a drug-treated variant (L5178Y/DTIC) of a murine lymphoma exert anti-parental tumor activity in an adoptive transfer system, an effect mediated by L3T4+ lymphocytes and associated with the detection of an anti-L5178Y delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response. We now report that the in vivo activity of the tumor-immune L3T4+ lymphocytes is a radio-sensitive (2,500 rad in vitro) phenomenon that requires collaboration with radio-resistant, silica-sensitive syngeneic cells in the host, and is inhibited by treatment of recipient mice with monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) to the L3T4 antigen or murine interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma). In vitro, the tumor-immune L3T4+ lymphocytes produce interleukin 2 (IL-2), lymphotoxin (LT) and IFN-gamma activities on incubation with L5178Y cells and spleen-adherent cells. These results suggest that the mechanisms of anti-parental tumor protection by xenogenized cells involve specific induction of a DTH response mediated by the "inflammatory" (THI) subset of L3T4+ T lymphocytes and IFN-gamma activated macrophages.

The Lyt phenotype of the T cells responsible for in vivo tumor rejection in syngeneic mice

Spleen cells of BALB/c mice hyperimmunized with a transplantable methylcholanthrene-induced sarcoma Meth A (Meth A-Im-SPL) inhibited the growth of Meth A tumor in vivo in a tumor neutralizing test. Meth A-Im-SPL did not neutralize another antigenically distinct sarcoma, Meth 1, indicating that the antitumor activity is tumor specific. Lyt-1+2- cells of Meth A-Im-SPL (Im-Lyt-1+2-) were the effectors since in vitro treatment of Meth A-Im-SPL with anti-Thy 1.2 or anti-Lyt 1.2 antibody plus complement completely abrogated their neutralizing activity, whereas treatment with anti-Lyt 2.2 plus complement did not. To further confirm the effector activity of Im-Lyt-1+2- cells, T cell subpopulations were separated from Meth A-Im-SPL by the panning method. The purified Im-Lyt-1+2-, but not Im-Lyt-1+2+ cells neutralized the tumor in athymic nu/nu mice as efficiently as in +/+ mice, suggesting that the donor Im-Lyt-1+2- cells but not recipient T cells were primarily responsible for neutralizing the tumor. The present study, however, did not exclude the possible contribution of recipient T cells to the tumor neutralization and this is open to further investigation.