Utilization of alternative species for toxicity testing: an overview

The Predictive Potential of a Battery of Ecotoxicological Tests for Human Acute Toxicity, as Evaluated with the First 50 MEIC Chemicals

The acute toxicities of the first 50 chemicals (dextropropoxyphene hydrochloride excluded) of the multicentre evaluation of in vitro cytotoxicity (MEIC) programme were determined on four aquatic invertebrates and a bacterial strain (Photobacterium phosphoreum for the Microtox™ test) commonly used in ecotoxicology testing. Three of the aquatic invertebrate tests consisted of cyst-based toxicity tests (Artoxkit M with Artemia salina, Streptoxkit F with Streptocephalus proboscideus, and Rotoxkit F with Brachionus calyciflorus), and the Daphnia magna test. Results of simple linear regression analyses indicated that the rodent tests (rat and/or mouse) were better than the ecotoxicological tests for predicting acute oral lethal doses in man. However, it appears that the batteries of ecotoxicological tests resulting from the partial least squares method appear to be better than the rodent tests for predicting human oral lethal doses.

Cyst-Based Toxicity Tests. IV. The Potential of Ecotoxicological Tests for the Prediction of Acute Toxicity in Man as Evaluated on the First Ten Chemicals of the MEIC Programme

In the framework of the multicentre evaluation of in vitro cytotoxicity (MEIC) programme, the first ten chemicals of the prescribed list were tested for acute toxicity in four standardised cyst-based aquatic invertebrate tests, consisting of two rotifer species (the estuarine Brachionus plicatilis and the freshwater Brachionus calyciflorus) and two crustacean species (the halophilic anostracan Artemia salina and the freshwater anostracan Streptocephalus proboscideus). Mortality was the test criterion and toxic effects, expressed as 24-hour LC50 values, were correlated with rodent and human acute oral toxicity data. Generally, a good correlation was obtained between any of the invertebrate tests and the rodent data. Likewise, the predictive screening potential of the aquatic invertebrate tests for acute oral toxicity in man was slightly better than the rat test for eight (excluding diazepam and digoxin) and nine (including diazepam, excluding digoxin) of the ten substances. The aquatic test systems, however, appear to be more suitable for compounds soluble in water.

The use of freshwater planarians in environmental toxicology studies: Advantages and potential

Regarding the humane use of animals in scientific research, invertebrates are often recommended in toxicological studies. "Freshwater planarians" refers to numerous free-living freshwater members of the Class "Turbellaria" of the phylum Platyhelminthes. This group of invertebrates has received extensive attention from biologists for many years because of their unique biological characteristics, such as the primitive form of the central nervous system and notable capability to regenerate tissues. Using freshwater planarians as test animals in chemical toxicity studies has grown in popularity since the 1960s. Results from various toxicological experiments have collectively suggested that freshwater planarians can serve as not only alternative models for chemical toxicity screenings in laboratories but also as potential bioindicators for the quality of freshwater environments. However, thus far, no standardized battery of tests for conducting toxicological studies that includes freshwater planarians has been proposed. This paper comprehensively reviews the toxicological information obtained from chemically exposed planarians and proposes practical factors for consideration in toxicity experiments with freshwater planarians as test organisms.

Environmental chemical mediated male reproductive toxicity: Drosophila melanogaster as an alternate animal model

Industrialization and indiscriminate use of agrochemicals have increased the human health risk. Recent epidemiological studies raised a concern for male reproduction given their observations of reduced sperm counts and altered semen quality. Interestingly, environmental factors that include various metals, pesticides and their metabolites have been causally linked to such adversities by their presence in the semen at levels that correlate to infertility. The epidemiological observations were further supported by studies in animal models involving various chemicals. Therefore, in this review, we focused on male reproductive toxicity and the adverse effects of different environmental chemicals on male reproduction. However, it is beyond the scope of this review to provide a detailed appraisal of all of the environmental chemicals that have been associated with reproductive toxicity in animals. Here, we provided the evidence for reproductive adversities of some commonly encountered chemicals (pesticides/metals) in the environment. In view of the recent thrust for an alternate to animal models in research, we subsequently discussed the contributions of Drosophila melanogaster as an alternate animal model for quick screening of toxicants for their reproductive toxicity potential. Finally, we emphasized the genetic and molecular tools offered by Drosophila for understanding the mechanisms underlying the male reproductive toxicity.

Toxicity of selected pesticides to freshwater shrimp, Paratya australiensis (Decapoda: Atyidae): use of time series acute toxicity data to predict chronic lethality

Toxicity of six pesticides (carbaryl, chlorpyrifos, cypermethrin, dimethoate, diuron and fenarimol) to the freshwater shrimp, Paratya australiensis was assessed after 96 h exposures. Of the six pesticides tested, alpha cypermethrin was the most toxic to the shrimp followed by chlorpyrifos, carbaryl, dimethoate, fenarimol and diuron. Regression methods for predicting chronic toxicity (lethality) from acute lethality data with shrimp were developed and compared, and it was found that the log-log model gives the most reliable predictions of the probability of death as a function of extended exposure times. Based on this model, chronic toxicity (21 days) to P. australiensis was estimated as 0.0058 microg/L for alpha cypermethrin, 4.9 microg/L for carbaryl, 0.004 microg/L for chlorpyrifos, 89 microg/L for dimethoate, 240 microg/L for diuron and 1500 microg/L for fenarimol. Acute LC(10) values were also useful predictors of the chronic lethality. The log-log model was used to derive extrapolated chronic values that were compared to measured experimental chronic values for two fish species. The predictions of chronic toxicity based on acute toxicity data were found to give credible results for both fish species. These predictions of chronic toxicity can therefore be used in ecological risk assessments to fill in gaps with reasonable confidence where no measured estimates of chronic toxicity are available.

Methylation of dietary flavones increases their metabolic stability and chemopreventive effects

Dietary flavones have promising chemoprotective properties, in particular with regard to cancer, but problems with low oral bioavailability and sometimes unacceptable toxicity have made their use as protective additives to normal diets questionable. However, methylation of free phenolic hydroxyl groups leads to derivatives not susceptible to glucuronic acid or sulfate conjugation, resulting in increased metabolic stability. Methylation also leads to greatly improved transport through biological membranes, such as in intestinal absorption, and much increased oral bioavailability. Recent studies also indicate that methylation results in derivatives with increasing potency to kill cancer cells. They also show high potency towards inhibition of hormone-regulating enzymes, e.g., aromatase, important in the causation of breast cancer. Methylation of the flavones may also result in derivatives with diminished toxic side-effects and improved aqueous solubility. In conclusion, it appears that methylation of dietary flavones as well as of other food products may produce derivatives with much improved health effects.

Cytotoxic effects of the dietary flavones chrysin and apigenin in a normal trout liver cell line

Many flavonoids have been shown to possess prooxidant properties, capable of causing oxidative stress, especially at larger doses. Here, we examined the potential cell toxicity caused by exposure to the hydroxylated flavones chrysin, apigenin, luteolin and quercetin in comparison to the methylated flavones 5,7-dimethoxyflavone and 3',4'-dimethoxyflavone in normal Rainbow trout hepatocytes. The hydroxylated flavones, especially chrysin, demonstrated cell toxicity and inhibition of DNA synthesis at very low (2 microM) concentrations. The cytotoxicity of chrysin may partially be due to its metabolism by myeloperoxidase, which was shown to be present in these normal trout liver cells (164pmol/(min mg protein)). In contrast, methylated flavones showed no significant metabolism by myeloperoxidase and no signs of toxicity, even at much higher concentrations. These results may be useful for further investigations of cytotoxicity of dietary flavonoids.

Overview of molecular, cellular, and genetic neurotoxicology

It has become increasingly evident that the field of neurotoxicology is not only rapidly growing but also rapidly evolving, especially over the last 20 years. As the number of drugs and environmental and bacterial/viral agents with potential neurotoxic properties has grown, the need for additional testing has increased. Only recently has the technology advanced to a level that neurotoxicologic studies can be performed without operating in a "black box." Examination of the effects of agents that are suspected of being toxic can occur on the molecular (protein-protein), cellular (biomarkers, neuronal function), and genetic (polymorphisms) level. Together, these areas help to elucidate the potential toxic profiles of unknown (and in some cases, known) agents. The area of proteomics is one of the fastest growing areas in science and particularly applicable to neurotoxicology. Lubec et al, provide a review of the potential and limitations of proteomics. Proteomics focuses on a more comprehensive view of cellular proteins and provides considerably more information about the effects of toxins on the CNS. Proteomics can be classified into three different focuses: post-translational modification, protein-expression profiling, and protein-network mapping. Together, these methods represent a more complete and powerful image of protein modifications following potential toxin exposure. Cellular neurotoxicology involves many cellular processes including alterations in cellular energy homeostasis, ion homeostasis, intracellular signaling function, and neurotransmitter release, uptake, and storage. The greatest hurdle in cellular neurotoxicology has been the discovery of appropriate biomarkers that are reliable, reproducible, and easy to obtain. There are biomarkers of exposure effect, and susceptibility. Finding the appropriate biomarker for a particular toxin is a daunting task. The appropriate biomarker for a particular toxin is a daunting task. The advantage to biomarker/toxin combinations is they can be detected and measured shortly following exposure and before overt neuroanatomic damage or lesions. Intervention at this point, shortly following exposure, may prevent or at least attenuate further damage to the individual. The use of peripheral biomarkers to assess toxin damage in the CNS has numerous advantages: time-course analysis may be performed, ethical concerns with the use of human subjects can partially be avoided, procedures to acquire samples are less invasive, and in general, peripheral studies are easier to perform. Genetic neurotoxicology comprises two focuses--toxin-induced alterations in genetic expression and genetic alterations that affect toxin metabolism, distribution, and clearance. These differences can be beneficial or toxic. Polymorphisms have been shown to result in altered metabolism of certain toxins (paraoxonase and paraoxon). Conversely, it is possible that some polymorphisms may be beneficial and help prevent the formation of a toxic by-product of an exogenous agent (resistance to ozone-induced lung inflammation). It has also become clear that interactions of potential toxins are not straightforward as interactions with DNA, causing mutations. There are numerous agents that cause epigenetic responses (cellular alterations that are not mutagenic or cytotoxic). This finding suggests that many agents that may originally have been thought of as nontoxic should be re-examined for potential "indirect" toxicity. With the advancement of the human genome project and the development of a human genome map, the effects of potential toxins on single or multiple genes can be identified. Although collectively, the field of neurotoxicology has recently come a long way, it still has a long way to go reach its full potential. As technology and methodology advances continue and cooperation with other disciplines such as neuroscience, biochemistry, neurophysiology, and molecular biology is improved, the mechanisms of toxin action will be further elucidated. With this increased understanding will come improved clinical interventions to prevent neuronal damage following exposure to a toxin.

Defining the molecular and cellular basis of toxicity using comparative models

A critical element of any experimental design is the selection of the model that will be used to test the hypothesis. As Claude Bernard proposed over 100 years ago "the solution of a physiological or pathological problem often depends solely on the appropriate choice of the animal for the experiment so as to make the result clear and searching." Likewise, the Danish physiologist August Krogh in 1929 wrote that "For a large number of problems there will be some animal of choice, or a few such animals, on which it can be most conveniently studied." This scientific principle has been validated repeatedly in the intervening years as investigators have described unique models that exploit natural differences in chemical and molecular structure, biochemical function, or physiological response between different cells, tissues, and organisms to address specific hypotheses. Despite the power of this comparative approach, investigators have generally been reluctant to utilize nonmammalian or nonclassical experimental models to address questions of human biology. The perception has been that studies in relatively simple or evolutionarily ancient organisms would provide little insight into "complex" human biology. This perception, although always somewhat misguided, is now even less tenable given the results of the genome sequencing projects, which demonstrate that the human genome is remarkably similar to that of evolutionarily ancient organisms. Thus, the various life forms on Earth share much more in common then anyone had previously envisioned. This realization provides additional rationale for the use of nonclassical experimental models and provides perhaps the strongest validation of Bernard's and Krogh's assertions. This overview emphasizes some of the special attributes of alternative animal models that may be exploited to define the molecular and cellular basis of toxicity. For each attribute, selected examples of animal models and experimental approaches are presented. It focuses on the areas of neurotoxicology, reproductive and developmental toxicology, organ systems toxicology, carcinogenesis, and functional genomics/toxicogenomics and highlights the use of fish, avian, Drosophila, Caenorhabditis elegans, and yeast models in such studies.

Fixation and staining of planaria for histological study

Fixation and staining of planaria can affect the interpretation of histopathological changes following their exposure to various agents. We assessed several fixation protocols with various stains in planaria to determine an optimal combination. Planaria were fixed in each of the following: 10% neutral buffered formalin, 2.5%, glutaraldehyde, Bouin's, Zenker's, 70% ethanol, and relaxant. In addition, planaria were fixed in relaxant and postfixed in each of the fixatives above. Paraffin embedded sections from each fixation protocol were stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H & E), toluidine blue, periodic acid-Schiff (PAS), or phosphotungstic acid-hematoxylin (PTAH). Relaxant fixed planaria were also stained with Steiner's, Holmes, trichrome, Giemsa, Grocott's methenamine silver (GMS) and antibodies for intermediate filaments (cytokeratin, vimentin and desmin). Relaxant and Zenker's gave the best fixation with minimal artifacts. Formalin, glutaraldehyde, and ethanol were unacceptable because they caused contortions of the body, crenation, and a darkly pigmented epidermis. Gastroderm could be differentiated from stroma best when stained with H & E, toluidine blue and PTAH. Other organ systems differentially stained included the epidermis, marginal adhesion gland, nervous tissue, and muscle. PAS, Steiner's, Holmes, trichrome and the intermediate filament stains were not useful for planaria staining. The most morphological information was obtained with relaxant fixative and a combination of sections stained with H & E and PTAH.

Modelling of human acute toxicity from physicochemical properties and non-vertebrate acute toxicity of the 38 organic chemicals of the MEIC priority list by PLS regression and neural network

Linear and non-linear modelling of human acute toxicity (as human lethal concentrations; HLCs) of the 38 organic chemicals from the 50 priority compounds of the Multicentre Evaluation of In Vitro Cytotoxicity (MEIC) programme was investigated. The models obtained were derived either from a set of 23 physicochemical properties of the compounds or from their acute toxicities to five aquatic non-vertebrates together with the physicochemical properties. For the linear type, modelling was performed using a partial least square projection to latent structures (PLS) regression method; for the non-linear models, both PLS regression and neural network were utilized. A neural network using a combination of backpropagation and cascade-correlation algorithms was applied in this study. The results generally reveal a slightly better predictive performance of the models obtained from PLS regression than those obtained from neural networks. However, the model composed of physicochemical properties (PC-model) from the trained neural network using a back propagation algorithm with pruning technique proved superior to that trained with a combination of backpropagation and cascade-correlation algorithms after leave-one-out cross-validation. The predictive power of the PC-models, whether linear or non-linear, was comparable with that of the corresponding models consisting of both structural descriptors and the ecotoxicological tests (ECOPC-models), except for the battery (ECOPC-model) from the neural network. The composition of the 'best' PLS and neural network models points to the importance of the combination of physicochemical properties reflecting lipophilicity, size, volume, intermolecular binding forces and electronic properties of the molecule. All the aquatic non-vertebrate tests are shown to be essential in explaining human acute toxicity. However, the degree of contribution differed, with the crustacean (Artemia salina) and the bacterial (Microtox) bioassays being more important to the linear and non-linear PLS models, whereas the crustacean (Artemia salina and Streptocephalus proboscideus) tests, and the rotifer (Brachionus calyciflorus) assay were important to the neural network models. The organochlorine (lindane) and bipyridinium (paraquat) pesticides were common outliers in all the models. Moreover, the latter two compounds and the organophosphate (malathion) pesticide were also common outliers in all ECOPC-models. Other types of pesticides, however, fit the models. The predicted HLCs of a number of non-pesticides, including some chlorinated compounds, also deviated from the observed HLCs by more than one order of magnitude.

Human acute toxicity prediction of the first 50 MEIC chemicals by a battery of ecotoxicological tests and physicochemical properties

Five acute bioassays consisting of three cyst-based tests (with Artemia salina, Streptocephalus proboscideus and Brachionus calyciflorus), the Daphnia magna test and the bacterial luminescence inhibition test (Photobacterium phosphoreum) are used to determine the acute toxicity of the 50 priority chemicals of the Multicentre Evaluation of In Vitro Cytotoxicity (MEIC) programme. These tests and five physiocochemical properties (n-octanol-water partition coefficient, molecular weight, melting point, boiling point and density) are evaluated either singly or in combination to predict human acute toxicity. Acute toxicity in human is expressed both as oral lethal doses (HLD) and as lethal concentrations (HLC) derived from clinical cases. A comparison has also been made between the individual tests and the conventional rodent tests, as well as between rodent tests and the batteries resulting from partial least squares (PLS), with regard to their predictive power for acute toxicity in humans. Results from univariate regression show that the predictive potential of bioassays (both ecotoxicological and rodent tests) is generally superior to that of individual physicochemical properties for HLD. For HLC prediction, however, no consistent trend could be discerned that indicated whether bioassays are better estimators than physicochemical parameters. Generally, the batteries resulting from PLS regression seem to be more predictive than rodent tests or any of the individual tests. Prediction of HLD appears to be dependent on the phylogeny of the test species: cructaceans, for example, appear to be more important components in the test battery than rotifers and bacteria. For HLC prediction, one anostracan and one cladoceran crustacean are considered to be important. When considering both ecotoxicological tests and physicochemical properties, the battery based on the molecular weight and the cladoceran crustacean predicts HLC substantially better than any other combination.

A promising indicator of neurobehavioral toxicity using the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans and computer tracking

A promising screening test for neurotoxicity has been developed using a computer tracking system and a species of nematode, Caenorhabditis elegans. The animals are viewed in dark-field illumination by a video camera interfaced directly to a microcomputer. Several hundred nematodes are tracked simultaneously and rates of locomotion and frequency of change of direction are reported in real time. This system can rapidly obtain reliable data on a variety of behavioral parameters relating to locomotion and response to sensory stimulation. Initial testing has examined the effects of six chemicals on locomotion. Four metals (copper, beryllium, mercury, and lead) and two organophosphate pesticides (malathion and vapona) have been studied. Copper and beryllium were chosen as chemicals that have not been shown to be neurotoxins and the other four chemicals were chosen as substances known to be neurotoxins. Our findings indicate that the rate of movement of exposed nematodes compared to the rate of movement of vehicle controls may prove to be useful as an indicator of neurotoxicity.

Developmental toxicity screen: results of rat studies with diethylhexyl phthalate and ethylene glycol monomethyl ether

The purpose of these investigations was to develop a protocol for an in vivo developmental toxicity screen (DETS) that would provide sufficient data to determine whether to 1) do a full developmental toxicity evaluation without additional range-finding studies, or, depending on the results, to 2) do no further testing of a chemical. In order to evaluate this screen, we compared results obtained by using the DETS protocol with results of previously conducted developmental toxicity evaluations of diethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP) and ethylene glycol monomethylether (EGME). Five groups (n greater than or equal to 17) of F344 rats were treated on days 6-15 of gestation by dosed feed (DEHP levels = 0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0%) or gavage (EGME doses = 0, 12.5, 25, 50, 100 mg/kg/day). One half of the rats in these studies were killed on day 16 of gestation, and the remaining animals were allowed to deliver litters which were killed on day 4. EGME caused only a small decrease in maternal weight gain during treatment (100 mg/kg group) that was accompanied by a decrease in gravid uterine weight. The percentage of resorptions was increased in the 50 and 100 mg/kg groups. The number of live pups was decreased in the 25, 50, and 100 mg/kg groups, and litter weight and postnatal survival were decreased in the 100 mg/kg group. These results are consistent with those reported in developmental toxicity studies on EGME conducted by the inhalation and dermal routes. With DEHP, there were treatment-related reductions in maternal body weight and weight gain. There was also a nonstatistical increase in percentage of resorptions per litter that was also observed, but at relatively high levels, in a definitive study in which F344 dams were treated on days 0-20 of gestation. The results of studies on these two chemicals compare well with published results and would have led to the selection of proper dose levels for subsequent FDA segment 2 studies.

Distribution of neurotoxic esterase activity in the brain of control and diisopropyl phosphorofluoridate-treated hens: in vivo and in vitro exposure

Neurotoxic esterase (NTE) is a protein which is hypothesized to be the site where certain organophosphorus compounds act to produce delayed-onset neurotoxicity. Adult white Leghorn hens (Gallus domesticus) were injected subcutaneously (0.5 mg/kg and 2.0 mg/kg) with diisopropyl phosphorofluoridate (DFP). Control and DFP-treated hens were killed 24 h after treatment and their brains sectioned into telencephalic, cerebellar, diencephalic, mesencephalic, metencephalic tegmentum, and myelencephalic portions. NTE activity was highest in the telencephalon and cerebellum, and brainstem activity progressively decreased moving caudally with the myelencephalon approaching reported spinal cord levels. Percent inhibition of NTE by DFP (0.5 mg/kg and 2.0 mg/kg) did not differ among brain regions or whole brain. The IC50's for DFP were not significantly different either among brain regions or whole brain. The results suggest that nervous system regions with higher NTE levels are protected from delayed neuropathy by virtue of overabundant NTE activity.