A quantitative analysis of the aging of human glial cells in culture

Is Evidence Supporting the Subtelomere-Telomere Theory of Aging?

The telomere theory tries to explain cellular mechanisms of aging as mainly caused by telomere shortening at each duplication. The subtelomere-telomere theory overcomes various shortcomings of telomere theory by highlighting the essential role of subtelomeric DNA in aging mechanisms. The present work illustrates and deepens the correspondence between assumptions and implications of subtelomere-telomere theory and experimental results. In particular, it is investigated the evidence regarding the relationships between aging and (i) epigenetic modifications; (ii) oxidation and inflammation; (iii) telomere protection; (iv) telomeric heterochromatin hood; (v) gradual cell senescence; (vi) cell senescence; and (vii) organism decline with telomere shortening. The evidence appears broadly in accordance or at least compatible with the description and implications of the subtelomere-telomere theory. In short, phenomena of cellular aging, by which the senescence of the whole organism is determined in various ways, appear substantially dependent on epigenetic modifications regulated by the subtelomere-telomere-telomeric hood-telomerase system. These phenomena appear to be not random, inevitable, and irreversible but rather induced and regulated by genetically determined mechanisms, and modifiable and reversible by appropriate methods. All this supports the thesis that aging is a genetically programmed and regulated phenoptotic phenomenon and is against the opposite thesis of aging as caused by random and inevitable degenerative factors.

Simple Detection Methods for Senescent Cells: Opportunities and Challenges

Cellular senescence, the irreversible growth arrest of cells from conditional renewal populations combined with a radical shift in their phenotype, is a hallmark of ageing in some mammalian species. In the light of this, interest in the detection of senescent cells in different tissues and different species is increasing. However much of the prior work in this area is heavily slanted towards studies conducted in humans and rodents; and in these species most studies concern primary fibroblasts or cancer cell lines rendered senescent through exposure to a variety of stressors. Complex techniques are now available for the detailed analysis of senescence in these systems. But, rather than focussing on these methods this review instead examines techniques for the simple and reproducible detection of senescent cells. Intended primary for the non-specialist who wishes to quickly detect senescent cells in tissues or species which may lack a significant evidence base on the phenomenon it emphasises the power of the original techniques used to demonstrate the senescence of cells, their interrelationship with other markers and their potential to inform on the senescent state in new species and archival specimens.

Cellular aging beyond cellular senescence: Markers of senescence prior to cell cycle arrest in vitro and in vivo

The field of research on cellular senescence experienced a rapid expansion from being primarily focused on in vitro aspects of aging to the vast territories of animal and clinical research. Cellular senescence is defined by a set of markers, many of which are present and accumulate in a gradual manner prior to senescence induction or are found outside of the context of cellular senescence. These markers are now used to measure the impact of cellular senescence on aging and disease as well as outcomes of anti-senescence interventions, many of which are at the stage of clinical trials. It is thus of primary importance to discuss their specificity as well as their role in the establishment of senescence. Here, the presence and role of senescence markers are described in cells prior to cell cycle arrest, especially in the context of replicative aging and in vivo conditions. Specifically, this review article seeks to describe the process of "cellular aging": the progression of internal changes occurring in primary cells leading to the induction of cellular senescence and culminating in cell death. Phenotypic changes associated with aging prior to senescence induction will be characterized, as well as their effect on the induction of cell senescence and the final fate of cells reviewed. Using published datasets on assessments of senescence markers in vivo, it will be described how disparities between quantifications can be explained by the concept of cellular aging. Finally, throughout the article the applicational value of broadening cellular senescence paradigm will be discussed.

Importance and Meaning of TERRA Sequences for Aging Mechanisms

Any theory suggesting an adaptive meaning for aging implicitly postulates the existence of specific mechanisms, genetically determined and modulated, causing progressive decline of an organism. According to the subtelomere-telomere theory, each telomere is covered by a hood formed in the first cell of an organism having a size preserved at each subsequent duplication. Telomere shortening, which is quantitatively different for each cell type according to the telomerase regulation, causes the hood to slide on the subtelomere repressing it by the telomeric position effect. At this point, the theory postulates existence of subtelomeric regulatory sequences, whose progressive transcriptional repression by the hood should cause cellular alterations that would be the likely determinant of aging manifestations. However, sequences with characteristics of these hypothetical sequences have already been described and documented. They are the [sub]TElomeric Repeat-containing RNA (TERRA) sequences. The repression of TERRA sequences causes progressively: (i) down- or up-regulation of many other regulatory sequences; (ii) increase in the probability of activation of cell senescence program (blockage of the ability to replicate and very significant alterations of the cellular functions). When cell senescence program has not been triggered and the repression is partial, there is a partial alteration of the cellular functions that is easily reversible by telomerase activation. Location of the extremely important sequences in chromosomal parts that are most vulnerable to repression by the telomeric hood is evolutionarily unjustifiable if aging is not considered adaptive: this location must be necessarily adaptive with the specific function of determining aging of the cell and consequently of the whole organism.

Late Passage Cultivation Induces Aged Astrocyte Phenotypes in Rat Primary Cultured Cells

Astrocytes play various important roles such as maintaining brain homeostasis, supporting neurons, and secreting inflammatory mediators to protect the brain cells. In aged subjects, astrocytes show diversely changed phenotypes and dysfunctions. But, the study of aged astrocytes or astrocytes from aged subjects is not yet sufficient to provide a comprehensive understanding of their important processes in the regulation of brain function. In this study, we induced an in vitro aged astrocyte model through late passage cultivation of rat primary cultured astrocytes. Astrocytes were cultured until passage 7 (P7) as late passage astrocytes and compared with passage 1 (P1) astrocytes as early passage astrocytes to confirm the differences in phenotypes and the effects of serial passage. In this study, we confirmed the morphological, molecular, and functional changes of late passage astrocytes showing aging phenotypes through SA-β-gal staining and measurement of nuclear size. We also observed a reduced expression of inflammatory mediators including IL-1β, IL-6, TNFα, iNOS, and COX2, as well as dysregulation of wound-healing, phagocytosis, and mitochondrial functions such as mitochondrial membrane potential and mitochondrial oxygen consumption rate. Culture-conditioned media obtained from P1 astrocytes promoted neurite outgrowth in immature primary cultures of rat cortices, which is significantly reduced when we treated the immature neurons with the culture media obtained from P7 astrocytes. These results suggest that late passage astrocytes show senescent astrocyte phenotypes with functional defects, which makes it a suitable model for the study of the role of astrocyte senescence on the modulation of normal and pathological brain aging.

Astrocyte senescence: Evidence and significance

Astrocytes participate in numerous aspects of central nervous system (CNS) physiology ranging from ion balance to metabolism, and disruption of their physiological roles can therefore be a contributor to CNS dysfunction and pathology. Cellular senescence, one of the mechanisms of aging, has been proposed as a central component of the age dependency of neurodegenerative disorders. Cumulative evidence supports an integral role of astrocytes in the initiation and progression of neurodegenerative disease and cognitive decline with aging. The loss of astrocyte function or the gain of neuroinflammatory function as a result of cellular senescence could have profound implications for the aging brain and neurodegenerative disorders, and we propose the term “astrosenescence” to describe this phenotype. This review summarizes the current evidence pertaining to astrocyte senescence from early evidence, in vitro characterization and relationship to age‐related neurodegenerative disease. We discuss the significance of targeting senescent astrocytes as a novel approach toward therapies for age‐associated neurodegenerative disease.

Cell cycle arrest in replicative senescence is not an immediate consequence of telomere dysfunction

In replicative senescence, cells with critically-short telomeres activate a DNA-damage response leading to cell-cycle arrest, while those without telomere dysfunction would be expected to cycle normally. However, population growth declines more gradually than such a simple binary switch between cycling and non-cycling states would predict. We show here that late-passage cultures of human fibroblasts are not a simple mixture of cycling and non-cycling cells. Rather, although some cells had short cycle times comparable to those of younger cells, others continued to divide but with greatly extended cycle times, indicating a more-gradual approach to permanent arrest. Remarkably, in late passage cells, the majority showed prominent DNA-damage foci positive for 53BP1, yet many continued to divide. Evidently, the DNA-damage-response elicited by critically-short telomeres is not initially strong enough for complete cell-cycle arrest. A similar continuation of the cell cycle in the face of an active DNA-damage response was also seen in cells treated with a low dose of doxorubicin sufficient to produce multiple 53BP1 foci in all nuclei. Cell cycle checkpoint engagement in response to DNA damage is thus weaker than generally supposed, explaining why an accumulation of dysfunctional telomeres is needed before marked cell cycle elongation or permanent arrest is achieved.

Senescent cells: an emerging target for diseases of ageing

Chronological age represents the single greatest risk factor for human disease. One plausible explanation for this correlation is that mechanisms that drive ageing might also promote age-related diseases. Cellular senescence, which is a permanent state of cell cycle arrest induced by cellular stress, has recently emerged as a fundamental ageing mechanism that also contributes to diseases of late life, including cancer, atherosclerosis and osteoarthritis. Therapeutic strategies that safely interfere with the detrimental effects of cellular senescence, such as the selective elimination of senescent cells (SNCs) or the disruption of the SNC secretome, are gaining significant attention, with several programmes now nearing human clinical studies.

Senescence in the aging process

The accumulation of 'senescent' cells has long been proposed to act as an ageing mechanism. These cells display a radically altered transcriptome and degenerative phenotype compared with their growing counterparts. Tremendous progress has been made in recent years both in understanding the molecular mechanisms controlling entry into the senescent state and in the direct demonstration that senescent cells act as causal agents of mammalian ageing. The challenges now are to gain a better understanding of how the senescent cell phenotype varies between different individuals and tissues, discover how senescence predisposes to organismal frailty, and develop mechanisms by which the deleterious effects of senescent cells can be ameliorated.

From old organisms to new molecules: integrative biology and therapeutic targets in accelerated human ageing

Understanding the basic biology of human ageing is a key milestone in attempting to ameliorate the deleterious consequences of old age. This is an urgent research priority given the global demographic shift towards an ageing population. Although some molecular pathways that have been proposed to contribute to ageing have been discovered using classical biochemistry and genetics, the complex, polygenic and stochastic nature of ageing is such that the process as a whole is not immediately amenable to biochemical analysis. Thus, attempts have been made to elucidate the causes of monogenic progeroid disorders that recapitulate some, if not all, features of normal ageing in the hope that this may contribute to our understanding of normal human ageing. Two canonical progeroid disorders are Werner's syndrome and Hutchinson-Gilford progeroid syndrome (also known as progeria). Because such disorders are essentially phenocopies of ageing, rather than ageing itself, advances made in understanding their pathogenesis must always be contextualised within theories proposed to help explain how the normal process operates. One such possible ageing mechanism is described by the cell senescence hypothesis of ageing. Here, we discuss this hypothesis and demonstrate that it provides a plausible explanation for many of the ageing phenotypes seen in Werner's syndrome and Hutchinson-Gilford progeriod syndrome. The recent exciting advances made in potential therapies for these two syndromes are also reviewed.

Heterogeneity of dimer excision in young and senescent human dermal fibroblasts

We have examined the relationship between nucleotide excision of the main UV-induced photoproduct, the cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer and in vitro cellular senescence. An in situ semiquantitative immunocytochemical assay has demonstrated that, following a UV-C dose of 15 J m-2, young human dermal fibroblasts maintained in a high level of serum are more efficient than senescent fibroblasts in the removal of dimers. However, in G0-arrested cultures (serum-starved), young fibroblasts are compromised in their ability to remove dimers and are significantly less efficient than senescent cells in this process. Supplementation of the culture medium with 0.1 mm deoxyribonucleosides enhances the removal of dimers in both young and senescent fibroblasts in proliferating or serum-starved cells. These data indicate that overall there is a modest but significant reduction in nucleotide excision of dimer photoproducts in cells as they age in vitro. In addition, G0-arrested young cells exhibit reduced removal of dimers, although this can be complemented by deoxyribonucleoside addition. In addition, this in situ assay has revealed heterogeneity in both susceptibility to UV-C-induced damage and excision. Overall, we provide evidence of reduced UV-induced damage excision in senescent compared with young fibroblasts, and demonstrate modulation of these processes in young and senescent cells under specific growth conditions.

Contribution of p16INK4a to replicative senescence of human fibroblasts

In standard conditions of tissue culture, human fibroblasts undergo a limited number of population doublings before entering a state of irreversible growth arrest termed replicative senescence or M1. The arrest is triggered by a combination of telomere dysfunction and the stresses inflicted by culture conditions and is implemented, at least in part, by the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors p21(CIP1) and p16(INK4a). To investigate the role of p16(INK4a), we have studied fibroblasts from members of melanoma prone kindreds with mutations in one or both copies of the CDKN2A locus. The mutations affect the function of p16(INK4a) but not of the alternative product, p14(ARF). The p16(INK4a)-defective fibroblasts have an above average life span, compared to the heterozygous and normal age-matched controls, but they arrest with characteristics typical of senescence. Using agents that are known to bypass M1, such as DNA tumor virus oncoproteins or the Bmi1 transcriptional repressor, we provide evidence that p16(INK4a) defective cells arrest at a stage that is operationally between M1 and M2 (crisis). As well as indicating that p16(INK4a) contributes to but is not essential for replicative senescence of human fibroblasts, our data reveal considerable heterogeneity in the levels and accumulation of p16(INK4a) in different strains.

Telomeres and Telomerase: A Modern Fountain of Youth?

Since ageing is a universal human feature, it is not surprising that, from the Babylonian epic of Gilgamesh to Ponce de Leon seeking the "Fountain of Youth," countless people have dreamed of finding a way to avoid ageing, to no avail. Yet the search continues. In this review, we present one of the latest candidates: the enzyme telomerase, capable of elongating the tips of chromosomes, the telomeres. Research into the causes of cellular ageing established the telomeres as the molecular clock that counts the number of times cells divide and triggers cellular senescence. Herein, we review arguments both in favor and against the use of telomerase as an anti-ageing therapy. The importance of the telomeres in cellular ageing, the low or non-existent levels of telomerase activity in human tissues, and the ability of telomerase to immortalize human cells suggest that telomerase can be used as an anti-ageing therapy. On the other hand, recent experiments in mice have raised doubts whether telomerase affects organismal ageing. Results from human cells expressing telomerase have also suggested telomerase may promote tumorigenesis. We conclude that, though telomerase may be used in regenerative medicine and to treat specific diseases, it is unlikely to become a source of anti-ageing therapies.

An in silico investigation into the causes of telomere length heterogeneity and its implications for the Hayflick limit

In telomerase-negative cell populations the mean telomere length (TL) decreases with increasing population doubling number (PD). A critically small TL is believed to stop cell proliferation at a cell-, age- and species-specific PD thus defining the Hayflick limit. However, positively skewed TL distributions are broad compared to differences between initial and final mean TL and strongly overlap at middle and late PD, which is inconsistent with a limiting role of TL. We used computer-assisted modelling to define what set of premises may account for the above. Our model incorporates the following concepts. DNA end replication problem: telomeres loose 1 shortening unit (SU) upon each cell division. Free radical-caused TL decrease: telomeres experience random events resulting in the loss of a random SU number within a remaining TL. Stochasticity of gene expression and cell differentiation: cells experience random events inducing mitoses or committing cells to proliferation arrest, the latter option requiring a specified number of mitoses to be passed. Cells whose TL reaches 1SU cannot divide. The proliferation kinetics of such virtual cells conforms to the transition probability model of cell cycle. When no committing events occur and at realistic SU estimates of the initial TL, maximal PD values far exceed the Hayflick limit observed in normal cells and are consistent with the crisis stage entered by transformed cells that have surpassed the Hayflick limit. At intermediate PD, symmetrical TL distributions are yielded. Upon introduction of committing events making the ratio of the rates of proliferating and committing events (P/C) range from 1.10 to 1.25, TL distributions at intermediate PD become positively skewed, and virtual cell clones show bimodal size distributions. At P/C as high as 1.25 the majority of virtual cells at maximal PD contain telomeres with TL>1SU. A 10% increase in P/C within the 1.10-1.25 range produces a two-fold increase in the maximal PD, which can reach values of up to 25 observed in rodent and some human cells. Increasing the number of committed mitoses from 0 to 10 can increases PD to about 50 observed in human fibroblasts. Introduction of the random TL breakage makes the shapes of TL distributions quite dissimilar from those observed in real cells.

CONCLUSIONS

Telomere length decrease is a correlate of cell proliferation that cannot alone account for the Hayflick limit, which primarily depends on parameters of cell population kinetics. Free radical damage influences the Hayflick limit not through TL but rather by affecting the ratio of the rates of events that commit cells to mitoses or to proliferation arrest.

The disparity between human cell senescence in vitro and lifelong replication in vivo

Cultured human fibroblasts undergo senescence (a loss of replicative capacity) after a uniform, fixed number of approximately 50 population doublings, commonly termed the Hayflick limit. It has been long known from clonal and other quantitative studies, however, that cells decline in replicative capacity from the time of explantation and do so in a stochastic manner, with a half-life of only approximately 8 doublings. The apparent 50-cell doubling limit reflects the expansive propagation of the last surviving clone. The relevance of either figure to survival of cells in the body is questionable, given that stem cells in some renewing tissues undergo >1,000 divisions in a lifetime with no morphological sign of senescence. Oddly enough, these observations have had little if any effect on general acceptance of the Hayflick limit in its original form. The absence of telomerase in cultured human cells and the shortening of telomeres at each population doubling have suggested that telomere length acts as a mitotic clock that accounts for their limited lifespan. This concept assumed an iconic character with the report that ectopic expression of telomerase by a vector greatly extended the lifespan of human cells. That something similar might occur in vivo seemed consistent with initial reports that most human somatic tissues lack telomerase activity. More careful study, however, has revealed telomerase activity in stem cells and some dividing transit cells of many renewing tissues and even in dividing myocytes of repairing cardiac muscle. It now seems likely that telomerase is active in vivo where and when it is needed to maintain tissue integrity. Caution is recommended in applying telomerase inhibition to kill telomerase-expressing cancer cells, because it would probably damage stem cells in essential organs and even increase the likelihood of secondary cancers. The risk may be especially high in sun-exposed skin, where there are usually thousands of p53-mutant clones of keratinocytes predisposed to cancer.

A model for the phenotypic presentation of Werner's syndrome

Werner's syndrome (WS) is a valuable model of accelerated ageing and results from mutations in a recQ helicase (wrn). WS fibroblasts show a mutator phenotype, replication fork stalling, increased rates of mean telomeric loss and accelerated cellular senescence. Senescence has been proposed as a candidate mechanism for the ageing of mitotic tissue. However, some mitotic tissues (such as the immune system) seem unaffected in WS. Is this evidence against a role for cell senescence in ageing? Two experiments resolve this paradox (i) the demonstration that the abbreviated replicative lifespan of WS fibroblasts can be corrected by the ectopic expression of telomerase and (ii) the demonstration that T cells derived from WS patients have the mutator phenotype characteristic of the disease but show no reduction in replicative potential. Since T cells can upregulate telomerase naturally these findings are consistent with a model in which the only wrn-mediated deletions that have a significant effect on replicative lifespan are those at or near the telomere. These data are thus supportive of a role for senescence in the ageing of the immune system. Emerging data on divisional counting mechanisms have the potential to produce many other apparent WS "paradoxes". Accordingly, we propose a general model for the phenotypic presentation of WS, which includes a modification of the Olovnikov model of telomere erosion. Somewhat unexpectedly, this predicts that accelerated senescence should not be observed in all telomerase-negative WS cell types.

Differential response of mature TrkA/p75(NTR) expressing human and pig oligodendrocytes: aging, does it matter?

A differential morphological response of mature oligodendrocytes (OL) isolated from human and pig brains to the phorbol ester 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA) and to the nerve growth factor (NGF) was observed. In both cases, OL regenerate their processes; however, the rate and the extension of the process formation of human OL were behind that of pig OL. Presumably, the advanced age of the human tissue in these experiments might have contributed to this decrease in process formation, an effect that was already observed for rat OL [Yong et al. (1991) J Neurosci Res 29:87-99]. The less effectivity of NGF via TrkA, which was immunocytochemically shown in human OL, and of TPA via the protein kinase C (PKC) pathway, may have its common focus on the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) cascade. In this context, it was noted that only a few studies on aging of mature OL are available. It is conceivable that age-related changes in the properties of OL could be an important factor for their cellular responsiveness during longer lasting demyelinating diseases such as multiple sclerosis. Hence, this review would like to provide a basis for future investigations on the aging of mature OL. The data presently available suggest a preliminary classification of mature OL into three categories.

A cell kinetic analysis of human umbilical vein endothelial cells

Cultures of normal human cells 'age' and become senescent in vitro due to a continuously declining mitotic fraction. Although endothelial cells represent a tissue of major relevance in the development of age-related vascular disease, the rate at which these cells senesce has never been systematically measured in culture. Accordingly the population kinetics of human vascular endothelial cells (HUVECs) serially passaged in vitro has been studied in order to determine (i) the rate of decline in the growth fraction; (ii) the rate of increase of the senescent fraction and (iii) the relationship between changes in these parameters and the baseline rate of apoptosis. Immunocytochemical visualisation of the growth fraction using antisera to the proliferation marker pKi67 showed a rate of decline in the growth fraction of 4.43+/-0.31% per population doubling. This was not accompanied by any change in cell cycle time as assessed using time lapse video microscopy. The number of senescent cells within the population increased at a rate of 6.47+/-0.3% as assessed by senescence associated beta-galactosidase activity. The baseline rate of apoptosis as measured by TUNEL remained essentially unchanged (0.31+/-0.07%) during this process. These data show (i) that senescence and apoptosis are unrelated processes in HUVEC and (ii) that senescent cells rapidly and progressively accumulate in dividing populations of endothelial cells. The physiological relevance of these observations is discussed.

Human neural stem cells: isolation, expansion and transplantation

Neural stem cells, with the capacity to self renew and produce the major cell types of the brain, exist in the developing and adult rodent central nervous system (CNS). Their exact function and distribution is currently being assessed, but they represent an interesting cell population, which may be used to study factors important for the differentiation of neurons, astrocytes and oligodendrocytes. Recent evidence suggests that neural stem cells may also exist in both the developing and adult human CNS. These cells can be grown in vitro for long periods of time while retaining the potential to differentiate into nervous tissue. Significantly, many neurons can be produced from a limited number of starting cells, raising the possibility of cell replacement therapy for a wide range of neurological disorders. This review summarises this fascinating and growing field of neurobiology, with a particular focus on human tissues.

The limited reproductive life span of normal human cells in culture

It has been suggested that the limited reproductive life span of normal (diploid) cells in culture may be explained by an inevitable shortening of one or more telomeres. The hypothesis is that one of the shortened telomeres will either generate a specific signal or will invoke a DNA damage checkpoint, in either case causing that cell to leave the cell cycle irreversibly. To assess this hypothesis, I review what constitutes the limited life span of cells in culture. Careful inspection of the kinetics of the life span of diploid cells in culture has shown that the limited life span arises because a fraction of newborn cells irreversibly leave the cell cycle at each division; and this fraction of reproductively sterile cells increases steadily throughout the life span of the culture. Cell fusion experiments suggest that only a small number of genes are involved in preventing continued cell growth, but that at least two independent mutation events are required to immortalize human cells, although only one event is sufficient in some rodent species. Human genetic diseases such as Werner's syndrome indicate that the duration of the life span is also genetically regulated, and is independent of the cessation of cell proliferation.

Different kinetics of senescence in human fibroblasts and peritoneal mesothelial cells

Senescence has been reported for a wide variety of human cell types. In cultures of human fibroblasts the process is due to a percentage of the cells becoming senescent at each passage rather than all the cells entering senescence simultaneously at the end of the life span. By measuring the percentage of fibroblasts which are still cycling at each passage, a rate of decline in the growth fraction, which mirrors the rate of senescence, can be obtained. However, such an analysis has never been undertaken in multiple cell types using the same method to identify cycling cells. It is thus unknown if the rate of senescence is the same or different in cultures of different human cell types. To answer this question the rates of decline in the cycling fractions were simultaneously measured in two cultures of human cells (AGO7086A, peritoneal mesothelial cells; and 2DD, human dermal fibroblasts) which have practically identical in vitro life spans. 2DD fibroblasts showed a rate of decline of 0.89% cycling cells per population doubling when the data obtained were fitted to a simple linear equation. However, AGO7086A gave a decline of approximately 2.2% per population doubling. Thus mesothelial cells enter senescence significantly faster than fibroblasts (P < 0.001). This decline in the growth fraction was accompanied by an increasing fraction of mesothelial cells which retained detectable endogenous beta-galactosidase activity at pH 6. Such activity has previously been shown to be associated with senescent human fibroblasts. These findings suggest that the process of senescence has common features in different cell lineages but that the rate of the process can differ markedly between them.

Progeroid syndromes: probing the molecular basis of aging?

A valid method of studying age related degenerative pathologies is to study human genetic diseases that appear to accelerate many, though not necessarily all, features of the aging process. Such diseases are described as progeroid syndromes because of their possible relevance to many aspects of aging and age related disease. This article describes the recent progress made at the cellular and molecular levels in understanding the pathogenesis of one of the best characterised of these disorders, Werner's syndrome. These observations are related to some of the less well characterised progeroid syndromes within the context of the cell senescence hypothesis of aging, a theory formulated to explain the aging of regenerative tissue in normal individuals.

Cell aging in vivo and in vitro

It has become a staple assumption of biology that there is an intrinsic fixed limit to the number of divisions that normal vertebrate cells can undergo before they senesce, and this limit is in some way related to aging of the organism. The notion of such a limited replicative lifespan arose from the often repeated observation that diploid fibroblasts cannot proliferate indefinitely in monolayer culture, and that the number of divisions before senescence is directly related to the in vivo lifespan of different species. The in vitro evidence is countered by estimates that the number of cell divisions in some organs of rodents and man are one or more orders of magnitude higher than the in vitro limit, with no indication of the degenerative changes seen in culture. Serial transplantation experiments in animals also exhibit many more cell divisions than the in vitro studies, with some indicating an indefinite replicative lifespan. I present evidence that vertebrate cells are severely stressed by enzymatic dispersion and sustain cumulative damage during serial subcultivations. The evidence includes large increases in cell size and its heterogeneity, reductions in replicative efficiency at low seeding densities, appearance of abnormal structures in the cytoplasm, changes in metabolism to a common cell culture type, continuous loss of methyl groups and reiterated sequences from DNA, and a constant rate of decline of growth rate with passage. This evidence is complemented by the reduction induced in the replicative life span of diploid cells by a large array of treatments which have different primary targets in the cells. The most consistent and general observation of cell behavior in aging animals, with only a few exceptions, is a reduction in the rate of cell proliferation. This reduction is perpetuated when the cells are grown in culture, indicating it is an enduring and intrinsic property of the cells rather than a systemic effect of the aging organism. A similar heritable reduction in growth rate can be induced in established cell lines by prolonged incubation at quiescence. The reduction can be exaggerated by subculturing the quiescent cells under suboptimal conditions, just as the effects of age are exaggerated under stress. The constant decline of growth rate that occurs during serial passage of diploid cells may represent a similar decay of cell function. I propose that the limit on replicative lifespan is an artifact that reflects the failure of diploid cells to adapt to the trauma of dissociation and the radically foreign environment of cell culture. It is, however, a useful artifact that has given us much information about cell behavior under stressful conditions. The overall evidence indicates cell in vivo accumulate damage over a lifetime that results in gradual loss of differentiated function and growth rate accompanied by an increased probability for the development of cancer. Such changes are normally held to a minimum by the organized state of the tissues and homeostatic regulation of the organism. The rejection of an intrinsic limit on the number of cell divisions eliminates the need for a cellular clock, such as telomere length, that counts mitoses. I offer a heuristic explanation for the gradual reduction of cell function and growth capacity with age based on a cumulative discoordination of interacting pathways within and between cells and tissues. I also make a case for the use of established cell lines as model systems for studying heritable damage to cell populations that simulates the effects of aging in vivo, and represents a relatively unexplored area of cell biology.

DNA damage and the proliferation and aging of cells in culture: a mathematical model with time lag

This paper is an extension of an earlier one by the same author in which a mathematical model was presented to describe the proliferation and aging of cells in culture. The model consists of a group of ordinary differential equations with a time lag. In the previous paper, the time lag was omitted for simplicity and the resulting differential equations were resolved analytically. It was shown that the model explains the behavior of a cell culture reasonably well. In this paper, the analytical solution of the original differential equations is presented without omitting the time lag. An analytical description of the variations in doubling capability between sister cells that was only simulated numerically in the earlier paper is given.

The expression of proliferation-dependent antigens during the lifespan of normal and progeroid human fibroblasts in culture

Normal human fibroblasts display a limited lifespan in culture, which is due to a steadily decreasing fraction of cells that are able to proliferate. Using antibodies that react with antigens present in proliferating cells only, in an indirect immunofluorescence assay, we have estimated the fraction of proliferating cells in cultures of normal human fibroblasts. Furthermore, we have estimated the rate of decline in the fraction of proliferating cells during the process of cellular ageing by application of the assay to normal human fibroblasts throughout their lifespan in culture. Werner's Syndrome is an autosomal recessive disease in which individuals display symptoms of ageing prematurely. Werner's Syndrome fibroblasts display a reduced lifespan in culture compared with normal human fibroblasts. Like normal human fibroblasts, the growth of Werner's Syndrome fibroblasts is characterised by a decreasing fraction of cells reacting with the proliferation-associated antibodies throughout their lifespan in culture. However, the rate of loss of proliferating cells in Werner's Syndrome fibroblasts during the process of cellular ageing is accelerated 5- to 6-fold compared with the rate determined for normal human fibroblasts.

The gene responsible for Werner syndrome may be a cell division "counting" gene

Werner syndrome is a rare, autosomal, recessive condition that is frequently studied as a model of some aspects of human aging, although the behavioral changes that are usually associated with old age are only seen very infrequently. A most striking aspect of the phenotype of Werner syndrome, presumably arising from the same gene defect, is a dramatic shortening of the replicative life-span of dermal fibroblasts in vitro. The finite replicative life-span of human cells in vitro is due to the stochastic loss of replicative ability in a continuously increasing fraction of newborn cells at every generation. Normal human fibroblasts achieve approximately 60 population doublings in culture, while Werner syndrome cells usually only achieve approximately 20 population doublings. We describe an analysis of the replicative ability of fibroblasts from Werner syndrome patients and demonstrate that the cells in these cultures usually exit, apparently irreversibly, from the cell cycle at a faster rate than do normal cells, although they mostly start off with a good replicative ability. We propose that the Werner syndrome gene is a "counting" gene controlling the number of times that human cells are able to divide before terminal differentiation.

The influence of cell co-operation, nutrients and surface area on cell division

Two opposite views have been proposed to explain the decline of the growth potential in cell populations with a limited life span: 1 variations in the probability of cycling and in cycling times or 2 a progressive increase in the nondividing cell fraction. Human brain-derived cells were studied with respect to their proliferative potential under the influence of different growth conditions, using haptotactic palladium islands on agarose. The results emphasize the need for cell co-operation, surface area and nutrients for cell division. These parameters also influence the final cell density. The results illustrate the multiple factors that can vary the probability of initiating the division cycle and stress the uncertainty of defining the irreversible non-dividing state.

A mathematical model of proliferation and aging of cells in culture

A mathematical model is presented which describes the proliferative senescence of cells in culture. The model is based on the DNA damage hypothesis of cellular aging and is able to account for both the limited and unlimited in vitro proliferative potential of normal and transformed cells. It is predicted that the destiny of a cell population is determined by two counteracting factors: the proliferation rate of the dividable cells and the gene damage accumulation rate. The formation of an immortal cell line requires high rate of proliferation and/or low rate of gene damage accumulation. The related computer simulations on a number of proliferative properties of cell culture produces results in agreement, in the general properties, with experimental observations.

Spontaneous immortalization of mouse embryo cells: strain differences and changes in gene expression with particular reference to retroviral gag-pol genes

We have studied the kinetics with which cultures of primary mouse embryo cells pass through the crisis period, escape their terminal differentiation (cellular senescence), and give rise to an immortal cell line. The process is strain-dependent, with cells from the outbred Swiss CD-1 mouse being considerably more adept at forming an immortal 3T3 line than cells from the inbred SWR line; Balb/c cells appeared intermediate in their behavior. The continued presence of the tumor promoter 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate or the poly(ADPribose)polymerase inhibitor 3-aminobenzamide affected the kinetics but did not seem to alter the outcome. Changes in expression of various genes, including those encoding mitogen-regulated protein (proliferin), endogenous gag-pol retrovirus sequences, insulin-like growth factor II, and a variety of protooncogenes, were monitored during the process of immortalization, and although certain changes were reproducibly characteristic of cells from a given mouse strain passed according to a specific regimen, none of the observed changes were reproducibly characteristic under all conditions of immortalization. In particular, our data indicate the absence of a strict correlation between cellular immortalization and the activation of endogenous gag-pol expression. We conclude from our observations that the establishment of permanent lines from primary mouse embryo cells in serum-containing medium reflects the selection of a variant subpopulation of cells that did not preexist but rather arose in response to the specific culture conditions by a process resembling differentiation. Multiple and complex changes in gene expression occur that are affected by the culture conditions and the strain (genotype) of the mouse.

Differences in growth factor sensitivity between individual 3T3 cells arise at high frequency: possible relevance to cell senescence

At low serum concentrations (3% or less), individual Swiss 3T3 cells display marked heterogeneity in proliferative capacity. Here we show that this heterogeneity arises at extremely high frequency within a clone, often with sister cells showing considerable differences in capacity for further proliferation. The heterogeneity is unlikely to be due to genetic instability or mutation. Instead, it appears to reflect physiological differences between cells in their requirement for serum growth factors. It is suggested that these differences arise because cells are unable to sustain production, at low growth factor concentrations, of some rare component which is itself required for growth factor action. We believe that the generation of heterogeneity in 3T3 cells has much in common with the phenomenon of senescence in diploid cells.

Cellular senescence revisited: a review

The field of cellular senescence (cytogerontology) is reviewed. The historical precedence for investigation in this field is summarized, and placed in the context of more recent studies of the regulation of cellular proliferation and differentiation. The now-classical embryonic lung fibroblast model is compared to models utilizing other cell types as well as cells from donors of different ages and phenotypes. Modulation of cellular senescence by growth factors, hormones, and genetic manipulation is contrasted, but newer studies in oncogene involvement are omitted. A current consensus would include the view that the life span of normal diploid cells in culture is limited, is under genetic control, and is capable of being modified. Finally, embryonic cells aging in vitro share certain characteristics with early passage cells derived from donors of increasing age.

Free radical scavenging systems and the effect of peroxide damage in aged human skin fibroblasts

One prominent theory of aging postulates an accumulation of cell damage resulting from nonenzymatic chemical reactions between important cellular components and free radicals. Fibroblast lines derived from skin biopsies of psychiatric patients ranging in age from 22 to 70 were evaluated soon after adaptation to culture. No significant correlation was found between donor age and the detoxification enzyme activities of superoxide dismutase (SOD) or aryl hydrocarbon hydroxylase (AHH) or susceptibility to damage by oxygen metabolites as measured by cell viability or lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) leakage.

Apparent heterogeneity in the response of quiescent swiss 3T3 cells to serum growth factors: implications for the transition probability model and parallels with "cellular senescence" and "competence"

When subconfluent, Swiss 3T3 cells made quiescent by serum deprivation are stimulated with low concentrations of serum (ca. 1%), only a proportion of them (roughly 50%) enter S phase despite daily replacement with fresh, low-serum medium. The cells that fail to enter S phase are not incapable of doing so, since most of them initiate DNA synthesis after transfer to 10% serum. It would appear that individual cells vary in their growth factor requirements. Using time-lapse cinemicroscopy a few of the cells that respond to low serum were seen to give rise to several generations of progeny, while the majority of cells failed to divide at all, or divided once at most. Despite this, differences between cells in growth factor requirements do not seem to be heritable in the long term, since attempts to enrich for responding cells by prolonged culture in 1% serum have been unsuccessful. Rather, it would appear that the capacity to respond to low serum is an unstable property lost after a few generations in low serum. The loss of responsiveness shows parallels with "cellular senescence" and could conceivably result from decay of the platelet-derived growth factor-induced state of "competence." But regardless of why some cells respond to low serum while others do not, it is clear that the kinetics of entry into S phase after serum stimulation of quiescent 3T3 cells are not strictly first-order, since the labelling index plateaus after roughly 3 days at values substantially below 100%. As such, the kinetics, though not contradicting the transition probability model, cannot be taken to support it as was previously thought.