Histones synthesized at different stages of myogenesis are differentially degraded in myotube cells

Multi-faceted quantitative proteomics analysis of histone H2B isoforms and their modifications

Background

Histone isoforms and their post-translational modifications (PTMs) play an important role in the control of many chromatin-related processes including transcription and DNA damage. Variants of histones H2A and H3 have been studied in depth and have been found to have distinct functions. Although 13 somatic histone H2B isoforms have been identified by various biochemical and mass spectrometric (MS) approaches, the distinct roles of these isoforms within human cells are as yet unknown. Here, we have developed quantitative MS techniques to characterize isoform-specific H2B expression across the cell cycle, in differentiated myogenic cells, and in different cancer cell lines to illuminate potential functional roles.

Results

Using the MS strategies that we developed, we identified differences in H2B isoform levels between different cancer cell types, suggesting cancer or tissue-specific H2B isoform regulation. In particular, we found large variations in the levels of isoforms H2B1B and H2B1M across the panel of cell lines. We also found that, while individual H2B isoforms do not differ in their acetylation levels, trends in the acetylation on all H2B isoforms correlated with acetylation on other histone family members in the cancer cell line panel. We also used the MS strategies to study H2B protein expression across the cell cycle and determined that H2B isoforms that are alternatively spliced to carry a polyadenylation signal rather than the standard histone downstream element are expressed independently of the cell cycle. However, the level of protein produced from the polyadenylated transcripts does not contribute significantly to the total pool of H2B isoforms translated across the cell cycle or in non-cycling myogenic cells.

Conclusions

Our results show that H2B isoforms are expressed at varying levels in different cells, suggesting isoform-specific, and possibly cell-type-specific, H2B gene regulation. The bottom-up mass spectrometry technique we developed for H2B quantification is compatible with the current standard histone H3 and H4 bottom-up ‘one-pot’ analysis platform so that H2B isoforms and their modifications can be studied in future experiments at the same time as histone H3 and H4 modifications. Therefore, we have expanded the histone landscape that can be interrogated in future experiments.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13072-015-0006-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Histone tyrosine phosphorylation comes of age

Histones were discovered over a century ago and have since been found to be the most extensively posttranslationally modified proteins, although tyrosine phosphorylation of histones had remained elusive until recently. The year 2009 proved to be a landmark year for histone tyrosine (Y) phosphorylation as five research groups independently discovered this modification. Three groups describe phosphorylation of Y142 in the variant histone H2A.X, where it may be involved in the cellular decision making process to either undergo DNA repair or apoptosis in response to DNA damage. Further, one group suggests that phosphorylation of histone H3 on Y99 is crucial for its regulated proteolysis in yeast, while another found that Y41 phosphorylation modulates chromatin architecture and oncogenesis in mammalian cells. These pioneering studies provide the initial conceptual framework for further analyses of the diverse roles of tyrosine phosphorylation on different histones, with far reaching implications for human health and disease.

Excess histone levels mediate cytotoxicity via multiple mechanisms

The accumulation of excess histone proteins in cells has deleterious consequences such as genomic instability in the form of excessive chromosome loss, enhanced sensitivity to DNA damaging agents and cytotoxicity. Hence, the synthesis of histone proteins is tightly regulated at multiple steps and transcriptional as well as posttranscriptional regulation of histone proteins is well established. Additionally, we have recently demonstrated that histone protein levels are regulated posttranslationally by the DNA damage checkpoint kinase Rad53 and ubiquitin-proteasome dependent proteolysis in the budding yeast. However, the underlying mechanism/s via which excess histones exert their deleterious effects in vivo are not clear. Here we have investigated the mechanistic basis for the deleterious effects of excess histones in budding yeast. We find that the presence of excess histones saturates certain histone modifying enzymes, potentially interfering with their activities. Additionally, excess histones appear to bind non-specifically to DNA as well as RNA, which can adversely affect their metabolism. Microarray analysis revealed that upon overexpression of histone gene pairs, about 240 genes were either up or downregulated by 2-fold or more. Overall, we present evidence that excess histones are likely to mediate their cytotoxic effects via multiple mechanisms that are primarily dependent on inappropriate electrostatic interactions between the positively charged histones and diverse negatively charged molecules in the cell. Our findings help explain the basis for the existence of multiple distinct mechanisms that contribute to the tight control of histone protein levels in cells and highlight their importance in maintaining genomic stability and cell viability.

Histone levels are regulated by phosphorylation and ubiquitylation-dependent proteolysis

Histone levels are tightly regulated to prevent harmful effects such as genomic instability and hypersensitivity to DNA damaging agents due to the accumulation of these highly basic proteins when DNA replication slows down or stops. Although chromosomal histones are stable, excess (non-chromatin bound) histones are rapidly degraded in a Rad53 kinase dependent manner in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Here we demonstrate that excess histones associate with Rad53 in vivo, appear to undergo modifications such as tyrosine phosphorylation and polyubiquitylation, before their proteolysis by the proteasome. We have identified the tyrosine 99 residue of histone H3 as being critical for the efficient ubiquitylation and degradation of this histone. We have also identified the E2 proteins Ubc4 and Ubc5, as well as the E3 ubiquitin ligase Tom1, as enzymes involved in the ubiquitylation of excess histones. Regulated histone proteolysis has major implications for the maintenance of epigenetic marks on chromatin, genomic stability and the packaging of sperm DNA.

The emergence of regulated histone proteolysis

Proliferating cells need to synthesize large amounts of histones to rapidly package nascent DNA into nucleosomes. This is a challenging task for cells because changes in rates of DNA synthesis lead to an accumulation of excess histones, which interfere with many aspects of DNA metabolism. In addition, cells need to ensure that histone variants are incorporated at the correct chromosomal location. Recent discoveries have highlighted the importance of regulated histone proteolysis in preventing both the accumulation of excess histones and the mis-incorporation of histone variants at inappropriate loci.

Normal transitions in synthesis of replacement histones H2A.Z and H3.3 during differentiation of dystrophic myotube cells. A brief note

We previously reported that differentiating G0 myotube cells cultured from normal chicken embryos exhibit a histone synthesis pattern that is highlighted by transitions in the expression of the minor replacement variants H3.3 and perhaps H2A.Z (Wunsch and Lough, Dev. Biol. 119 (1987) 94-99). Because these proteins may be synthesized to maintain chromatin structure during the differentiation and maturation of the skeletal muscle fiber, it was of interest to determine whether they are made at normal levels during the differentiation of dystrophic muscle. To this end, the synthesis of histone proteins in cultured myoblasts and myotubes from normal and dystrophic avian embryos has been characterized by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and fluorography. Proliferating myoblasts (day 1) as well as two stages of differentiating myotubes (days 3, 4) exhibited histone synthesis patterns that were indistinguishable when comparing normal and dystrophic cells. It is noteworthy that this study also revealed that, in both cell types, the change in H2A.Z synthesis during the myoblast/myotube transition was remarkable, increasing from approximately 20% of the non-ubiquitinated H2As in myoblasts to 80% in myotubes. Also, gel staining patterns and immunoblotting detected no differences in the degree of histone ubiquitination between normal and dystrophic cells. These findings indicate that, up to this point in dystrophic differentiation, neither the synthesis nor ubiquitination of histones are perturbed.

Affinity isolation of active murine erythroleukemia cell chromatin: uniform distribution of ubiquitinated histone H2A between active and inactive fractions

This laboratory recently reported the development of a biotin-cellulose/streptavidin affinity chromatography method based on the DNase I sensitivity of active chromatin to isolate a DNA fraction from murine erythroleukemia (MEL) cells that is more than 15-fold enriched in active genes (Dawson et al.: Journal of Biological Chemistry 264:12830-12837, 1989). We now report the extension of this technique to isolate and characterize chromatin that is enriched in active genes. In this approach, DNA in nuclei isolated from MEL cells was nicked with DNase I at a concentration that does not digest the active beta-globin gene, followed by repair of the nicks with a cleavable biotinylated nucleotide analog, 5-[(N-biotin-amido)hexanoamido-ethyl-1,3'-dithiopropionyl-3- aminoallyl]-2'- deoxyuridine 5'-triphosphate (Bio-19-SS-dUTP), during a nick-translation reaction. After shearing and sonication of the nuclei to solubilize chromatin, chromatin fragments containing biotin were separated from non-biotinylated fragments by sequential binding to streptavidin and biotin cellulose. The bound complex contained approximately 10% of the bulk DNA. Reduction of the disulfide bond in the biotinylated nucleotide eluted approximately one-half of the affinity isolated chromatin. Hybridization analysis of DNA revealed that whereas inactive albumin sequences were equally distributed among the chromatin fractions, virtually all of the active beta-globin sequences were associated with chromatin fragments which had bound to the affinity complex. Western blot assessment for ubiquitinate histones revealed that ubiquitinated histone H2A (uH2A) was uniformly distributed among active (bound) and inactive (unbound) chromatin fractions.

Histone variant patterns during vertebrate embryogenesis and limb development

Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis was used to examine the relative content of core histone variants during early chicken embryogenesis and at selected stages of hindlimb development. Nuclei from stage 19 limb buds displayed a pattern similar to whole embryos at stage 1, at which time all of the known avian histone variants, including the minor isoprotein H3.3, were detected. Variant ratios did not change during limb development, up to stage 29. However, the portion of H2A variants migrating as ubiquitinated conjugates increased more than twofold during limb development, advancing from 4.5% of the total H2A proteins at stage 19 to 12% at stage 29.