White Matter Hyperintensities Quantification in Healthy Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Decoding the best automated segmentation tools for vascular white matter hyperintensities in the aging brain: a clinician's guide to precision and purpose

White matter hyperintensities of vascular origin (WMH) are commonly found in individuals over 60 and increase in prevalence with age. The significance of WMH is well-documented, with strong associations with cognitive impairment, risk of stroke, mental health, and brain structure deterioration. Consequently, careful monitoring is crucial for the early identification and management of individuals at risk. Luckily, WMH are detectable and quantifiable on standard MRI through visual assessment scales, but it is time-consuming and has high rater variability. Addressing this issue, the main aim of our study is to decipher the utility of quantitative measures of WMH, assessed with automatic tools, in establishing risk profiles for cerebrovascular deterioration. For this purpose, first, we work to determine the most precise WMH segmentation open access tool compared to clinician manual segmentations (LST-LPA, LST-LGA, SAMSEG, and BIANCA), offering insights into methodology and usability to balance clinical precision with practical application. The results indicated that supervised algorithms (LST-LPA and BIANCA) were superior, particularly in detecting small WMH, and can improve their consistency when used in parallel with unsupervised tools (LST-LGA and SAMSEG). Additionally, to investigate the behavior and real clinical utility of these tools, we tested them in a real-world scenario (N = 300; age > 50 y.o. and MMSE > 26), proposing an imaging biomarker for moderate vascular damage. The results confirmed its capacity to effectively identify individuals at risk comparing the cognitive and brain structural profiles of cognitively healthy adults above and below the resulted threshold.

Decoding the Best Automated Segmentation Tools for Vascular White Matter Hyperintensities in the Aging Brain: A Clinician's Guide to Precision and Purpose

Cerebrovascular damage from small vessel disease (SVD) occurs in healthy and pathological aging. SVD markers, such as white matter hyperintensities (WMH), are commonly found in individuals over 60 and increase in prevalence with age. WMHs are detectable on standard MRI by adhering to the STRIVE criteria. Currently, visual assessment scales are used in clinical and research scenarios but is time-consuming and has rater variability, limiting its practicality. Addressing this issue, our study aimed to determine the most precise WMH segmentation software, offering insights into methodology and usability to balance clinical precision with practical application. This study employed a dataset comprising T1, FLAIR, and DWI images from 300 cognitively healthy older adults. WMHs in this cohort were evaluated using four automated neuroimaging tools: Lesion Prediction Algorithm (LPA) and Lesion Growth Algorithm (LGA) from Lesion Segmentation Tool (LST), Sequence Adaptive Multimodal Segmentation (SAMSEG), and Brain Intensity Abnormalities Classification Algorithm (BIANCA). Additionally, clinicians manually segmented WMHs in a subsample of 45 participants to establish a gold standard. The study assessed correlations with the Fazekas scale, algorithm performance, and the influence of WMH volume on reliability. Results indicated that supervised algorithms were superior, particularly in detecting small WMHs, and can improve their consistency when used in parallel with unsupervised tools. The research also proposed a biomarker for moderate vascular damage, derived from the top 95th percentile of WMH volume in healthy individuals aged 50 to 60. This biomarker effectively differentiated subgroups within the cohort, correlating with variations in brain structure and behavior.

Meta-Analysis of White Matter Hyperintensity Volume Differences Between APOE ε4 Carriers and Noncarriers

Several studies have suggested that white matter hyperintensity volume (WMHV) is increased among apolipoprotein E (APOE) ε4 carriers while others have reported contradictory findings. Although APOE ε4 carriage is associated with greater AD pathology, it remains unclear whether cerebrovascular damage is also associated with APOE ε4 carriage. The aim of this meta-analysis was to determine whether WMHV is associated with APOE ε4 carrier status. 12 studies that were included yielded a total sample size of 16,738 adult subjects (ε4 carrier n = 4,721; ε4 noncarrier n = 12,017). There were no significant differences in WMHV between ε4 carriers and noncarriers (Hedge's g = 0.07; 95% CI (-0.01 to 0.15), P = 0.09). Subgroup analysis of community-based studies (n = 8) indicated a small effect size where ε4 carriers had greater WMHV relative to noncarriers (Hedge's g = 0.09 95% CI (0.02 to 0.16), P = 0.008). Among clinic-based studies (n = 3) there was no significant difference in WMHV by APOE ε4 carrier status (Hedge's g = -0.09, 95% CI (-0.60 to 0.41), P = 0.70). Observed APOE ε4-associated WMHV differences may be context-dependent and may also be confounded by a lack of standardization for WMHV segmentation.

Causal relationship between multiparameter brain MRI phenotypes and age: evidence from Mendelian randomization

To explore the causal relationship between age and brain health (cortical atrophy, white matter integrity, white matter hyperintensities and cerebral microbleeds in various brain regions) related multiparameter imaging features using two-sample Mendelian randomization. Age was determined as chronological age of the subject. Cortical volume, white matter micro-integrity, white matter hyperintensity volume and cerebral microbleeds of each brain region were included as phenotypes for brain health. Age and imaging of brain health related genetic data were analysed to determine the causal relationship using inverse-variance weighted model, validated by heterogeneity and horizontal pleiotropy variables. Age is causally related to increased volumes of white matter hyperintensities (β = 0.151). For white matter micro-integrity, fibres of the inferior cerebellar peduncle (axial diffusivity β = -0.128, orientation dispersion index β = 0.173), cerebral peduncle (axial diffusivity β = -0.136), superior fronto-occipital fasciculus (isotropic volume fraction β = 0.163) and fibres within the limbic system were causally deteriorated. We also detected decreased cortical thickness of multiple frontal and temporal regions (P < 0.05). Microbleeds were not related with aging (P > 0.05). Aging is a threat of brain health, leading to cortical atrophy mainly in the frontal lobes, as well as the white matter degeneration especially abnormal hyperintensity and deteriorated white matter integrity around the hippocampus.

Bridging Reduced Grip Strength and Altered Executive Function: Specific Brain White Matter Structural Changes in Patients with Alzheimer's Disease

Objective

To investigate the correlation between specific fiber tracts and grip strength and cognitive function in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) by fixel-based analysis (FBA).

Methods

AD patients were divided into AD with low grip strength (AD-LGS, n=29) and AD without low grip strength (AD-nLGS, n=25), along with 31 normal controls (NC). General data, neuropsychological tests, grip strength and cranial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans were collected. FBA evaluated white matter (WM) fiber metrics, including fiber density (FD), fiber cross-sectional (FC), and fiber density and cross-sectional area (FDC). The mean fiber indicators of the fiber tracts of interest (TOI) were extracted in cerebral region of significant statistical differences in FBA to further compare the differences between groups and analyze the correlation between fiber properties and neuropsychological test scores.

Results

Compared to AD-nLGS group, AD-LGS group showed significant reductions in FDC in several cerebral regions. In AD patients, FDC values of bilateral uncinate fasciculus and left superior longitudinal fasciculus were positively correlated with Clock Drawing Test scores, while FDC of splenium of corpus callosum, bilateral anterior cingulate tracts, forceps major, and bilateral inferior longitudinal fasciculus were positively correlated with the Executive Factor Score of Memory and Executive Screening scale scores.

Conclusion

Reduced grip strength in AD patients is associated with extensive impairment of WM structural integrity. Changes in FDC of specific WM fiber tracts related to executive function play a significant mediating role in the reduction of grip strength in AD patients.

[Echo Train Length (ETL) of Fluid-attenuated Inversion Recovery (FLAIR) and Extraction Volume of White Matter Hyperintensity Volume in Automated White Matter Signal Analysis]

PURPOSE

To investigate whether the volume of white matter hyperintensity (WMH) extracted from FLAIR images changes when the imaging parameters of the original images are changed.

METHODS

Seven healthy volunteers were imaged by changing the imaging parameter ETL of FLAIR images, and WMHs were extracted and their volumes were calculated by the automatic extraction software. The results were statistically analyzed to examine the relationship (Experiment 1). Simulated images with different SNRs were created by adding white noise to four examples of healthy volunteer images. The SNR of the simulated images simulated the SNR of the measured images of different ETLs. The WMH was extracted from the simulated images and its volume was calculated using the automatic extraction software (Experiment 2).

RESULTS

Experiment 1 showed that there was no significant difference between FLAIR imaging parameters and WMH volume in automatic white matter signal analysis, except for some conditions. Experiment 2 showed that as the SNR of the original image decreased, the volume of high white matter signal extracted decreased.

CONCLUSION

In automatic white matter signal analysis, WMH was shown to be small when the ETL of the FLAIR sequence was larger than normal and/or the SNR of the image was low.

Spatial patterns of white matter hyperintensities: a systematic review

Background

White matter hyperintensities are an important marker of cerebral small vessel disease. This disease burden is commonly described as hyperintense areas in the cerebral white matter, as seen on T2-weighted fluid attenuated inversion recovery magnetic resonance imaging data. Studies have demonstrated associations with various cognitive impairments, neurological diseases, and neuropathologies, as well as clinical and risk factors, such as age, sex, and hypertension. Due to their heterogeneous appearance in location and size, studies have started to investigate spatial distributions and patterns, beyond summarizing this cerebrovascular disease burden in a single metric-its volume. Here, we review the evidence of association of white matter hyperintensity spatial patterns with its risk factors and clinical diagnoses.

Design/methods

We performed a systematic review in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) Statement. We used the standards for reporting vascular changes on neuroimaging criteria to construct a search string for literature search on PubMed. Studies written in English from the earliest records available until January 31st, 2023, were eligible for inclusion if they reported on spatial patterns of white matter hyperintensities of presumed vascular origin.

Results

A total of 380 studies were identified by the initial literature search, of which 41 studies satisfied the inclusion criteria. These studies included cohorts based on mild cognitive impairment (15/41), Alzheimer's disease (14/41), Dementia (5/41), Parkinson's disease (3/41), and subjective cognitive decline (2/41). Additionally, 6 of 41 studies investigated cognitively normal, older cohorts, two of which were population-based, or other clinical findings such as acute ischemic stroke or reduced cardiac output. Cohorts ranged from 32 to 882 patients/participants [median cohort size 191.5 and 51.6% female (range: 17.9-81.3%)]. The studies included in this review have identified spatial heterogeneity of WMHs with various impairments, diseases, and pathologies as well as with sex and (cerebro)vascular risk factors.

Conclusion

The results show that studying white matter hyperintensities on a more granular level might give a deeper understanding of the underlying neuropathology and their effects. This motivates further studies examining the spatial patterns of white matter hyperintensities.

Value of white matter hyperintensity volume and total white matter volume for evaluating cognitive impairment in patients with cerebral small-vessel disease

Background

White matter hyperintensities (WMH) are a key imaging feature of cerebral small-vessel disease (CSVD). However, there is a lack of standardized methods for determining WMH volume, and the value of total white matter (WM) volume in the assessment of cognitive impairment in patients with CSVD remains unknown.

Objective

We aimed to explore the correlations of WMH volume and WM volume with cognitive dysfunction and its components in patients with CSVD. We also aimed to compare the value of the Fazekas score, WMH volume, and ratio of WMH volume to total WM volume in the assessment of cognitive dysfunction.

Methods

The study included 99 patients with CSVD. Patients were categorized into following groups based on MoCA scores: patients with mild cognitive impairment and those without. Brain magnetic resonance images were processed to investigate differences in WMH and WM volumes between the groups. Logistic regression analysis was used to determine whether these two factors were independent risk factors for cognitive dysfunction. Correlation analysis was used to examine the relationships of WMH and WM volume with different types of cognitive impairment. Receiver operating characteristic curves were used to compare the effectiveness of the WMH score, WMH volume, and WMH to WM ratio for evaluating cognitive dysfunction.

Results

There were significant differences in age, education level, WMH volume, and WM volume between the groups (P &lt; 0.05). After adjusting for age and education, the multivariate logistic analysis indicated that both WMH volume and WM volume were independent risk factors for cognitive dysfunction. Correlation analysis indicated that WMH volume was mainly related to cognition involving the visual space and delayed recall. WM volume was not strongly associated with different types of cognitive dysfunction. The WMH to WM ratio was the strongest predictor, with an area under the curve value of 0.800 and a 95% confidence interval of 0.710–0.891.

Conclusion

Increases in WMH volume may aggravate cognitive dysfunction in patients with CSVD, and a higher WM volume may reduce the effect of WMH volume on cognitive function to a certain extent. The ratio of WMH to total WM volume may reduce the impact of brain atrophy, allowing for more accurate evaluation of cognitive dysfunction in older adults with CSVD.

The effects of white matter hyperintensities on MEG power spectra in population with mild cognitive impairment

Cerebrovascular disease is responsible for up to 20% of cases of dementia worldwide, but also it is a major comorbid contributor to the progression of other neurodegenerative diseases, like Alzheimer's disease. White matter hyperintensities (WMH) are the most prevalent imaging marker in cerebrovascular disease. The presence and progression of WMH in the brain have been associated with general cognitive impairment and the risk to develop all types of dementia. The aim of this piece of work is the assessment of brain functional differences in an MCI population based on the WMH volume. One-hundred and twenty-nine individuals with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) underwent a neuropsychological evaluation, MRI assessment (T1 and Flair), and MEG recordings (5 min of eyes closed resting state). Those participants were further classified into vascular MCI (vMCI; n = 61, mean age 75 ± 4 years, 35 females) or non-vascular MCI (nvMCI; n = 56, mean age 72 ± 5 years, 36 females) according to their WMH total volume, assessed with an automatic detection toolbox, LST (SPM12). We used a completely data-driven approach to evaluate the differences in the power spectra between the groups. Interestingly, three clusters emerged: One cluster with widespread larger theta power and two clusters located in both temporal regions with smaller beta power for vMCI compared to nvMCI. Those power signatures were also associated with cognitive performance and hippocampal volume. Early identification and classification of dementia pathogenesis is a crucially important goal for the search for more effective management approaches. These findings could help to understand and try to palliate the contribution of WMH to particular symptoms in mixed dementia progress.

The non-linear correlation between the volume of cerebral white matter lesions and incidence of bipolar disorder: A secondary analysis of data from a cross-sectional study

Cerebral white matter lesions (WML) are major risk factors for bipolar disorder (BD). However, studies on the association between cerebral WML volume and BD risk are limited. This study aimed to investigate the relationship between cerebral WML volume and BD incidence. This is a secondary retrospective analysis of patients (N = 146, 72 males, 74 females, mean age = 41.77 years) who have previously undergone magnetic resonance imaging examinations. Information was obtained from the Dryad database. Univariate analysis, piecewise linear regression model, and multivariable logistic regression model were used for statistical analysis. A non-linear relationship was recognized between the cerebral WML volume and BD incidence, in which the inflection point of the WML volume was 6,200 mm³. The effect sizes and confidence intervals on the left and right sides of the emphasis point were 1.0009 (1.0003, 1.0015) and 0.9988 (0.9974, 1.0003), respectively. Subgroup analysis (WML volume < 6,200 mm³) showed that the cerebral WML volume (for 0.1 mm³ increase) was positively related to the BD incidence (OR = 1.11, 95% confidence interval [CI] (1.03, 1.21)). Here we show that the cerebral WML volume is positively and non-linearly correlated to the BD risk. Volumetric analysis of WML provide a better understanding of the association between WML and the BD risk, and thereby the pathophysiological mechanisms of BD.

Graphical abstract

A non-linear relationship between the volume of cerebral white matter lesions (WML) and bipolar disorder (BD) incidence is shown. The cerebral WML volume is positively and non-linearly correlated to the BD risk. The correlation is stronger when the cerebral WML volume was <6,200 mm³.Graphical AbstractA non-linear relationship between the volume of cerebral white matter lesions and bipolar disorder incidence is shown after adjusting for age; sex; lithium, atypical antipsychotic, antiepileptic, and antidepressant drug use; BMI; migraine; smoking; hypertension; diabetes mellitus; substance and alcohol dependency; and anxiety disorder.

Lobar Cerebral Microbleeds Are Associated With Cognitive Decline in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus

Purpose

Combined the number, volume, and location of cerebral microbleeds (CMBs), this study aimed to explore the different features of CMBs and their correlation with cognitive ability in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM).

Methods

This study recruited 95 patients with T2DM and 80 healthy control (HC) individuals. AccuBrain^®, an automated tool, was used to obtain the number and volume of CMBs. The scores on global cognition and five cognitive domains were derived from a battery of cognitive tests. The logistic regression and multivariate linear regression were conducted to determine the relationship between the CMBs (number, volume, and location) and cognitive ability in patients with T2DM.

Results

After adjusting for several variables, the total volume of CMBs (OR = 0.332, 95%CI: 0.133–0.825, and p = 0.018) was independent risk factor for cognitive impairment, whereas the total number of CMBs was not (OR = 0933, 95%CI: 0.794–1.097, and p = 0.400). Furthermore, the volume of CMBs in lobar regions was independently associated with working memory (β = −0.239, 95%CI: −0.565 to −0.035, and p = 0.027). However, no significant correlation between the number of CMBs (both lobar and deep/infratentorium) and any cognitive domains was observed.

Conclusions

Lobar CMBs was related with cognitive impairment in patients with T2DM and might be a potential early warning signal. Compared with the counting analysis, the quantitative method offered a more sensitive and objective measurement for studying imaging features of CMBs.

Adults with tetralogy of Fallot show specific features of cerebral small vessel disease: the BACH San Donato study

Life expectancy in adults with congenital heart disease (ACHD) has increased. As these patients grow older, they experience aging-related diseases more than their healthy peers. To better characterize this field, we launched the multi-disciplinary BACH (Brain Aging in Congenital Heart disease) San Donato study, that aimed at investigating signs of brain injury in ACHD. Twenty-three adults with repaired tetralogy of Fallot and 23 age- and sex-matched healthy controls were prospectively recruited and underwent brain magnetic resonance imaging. White matter hyperintensities (WMHs) were segmented using a machine-learning approach and automatically split into periventricular and deep. Cerebral microbleeds were manually counted. A subset of 14 patients were also assessed with an extensive neuropsychological battery. Age was 41.78 ± 10.33 years (mean ± standard deviation) for patients and 41.48 ± 10.28 years for controls (p = 0.921). Albeit not significantly, total brain (p = 0.282) and brain tissue volumes (p = 0.539 for cerebrospinal fluid, p = 0.661 for grey matter, p = 0.793 for white matter) were lower in ACHD, while total volume (p = 0.283) and sub-classes of WMHs (p = 0.386 for periventricular WMHs and p = 0.138 for deep WMHs) were higher in ACHD than in controls. Deep WMHs were associated with poorer performance at the frontal assessment battery (r = -0.650, p = 0.012). Also, patients had a much larger number of microbleeds than controls (median and interquartile range 5 [3–11] and 0 [0–0] respectively; p < 0.001). In this study, adults with tetralogy of Fallot showed specific signs of brain injury, with some clinical implications. Eventually, accurate characterization of brain health using neuroimaging and neuropsychological data would aid in the identification of ACHD patients at risk of cognitive deterioration.

Five years of exercise intervention at different intensities and development of white matter hyperintensities in community dwelling older adults, a Generation 100 sub-study

We investigated if a five-year supervised exercise intervention with moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT) or high-intensity interval training (HIIT) versus control; physical activity according to national guidelines, attenuated the growth of white matter hyperintensities (WMH). We hypothesized that supervised exercise, in particular HIIT, reduced WMH growth. Older adults from the general population participating in the RCT Generation 100 Study were scanned at 3T MRI at baseline (age 70–77), and after 1-, 3- and 5-years. At each follow-up, cardiorespiratory fitness was measured with ergospirometry, and physical activity plus clinical data collected. Manually delineated total WMH, periventricular (PWMH), deep (DWMH), and automated total white matter hypointensity volumes were obtained. No group by time interactions were present in linear mixed model analyses with the different WMH measurements as outcomes. In the combined exercise (MICT&HIIT) group, a significant group by time interaction was uncovered for PWMH volume, with a larger increase in the MICT&HIIT group. Cardiorespiratory fitness at the follow-ups or change in cardiorespiratory fitness over time were not associated with any WMH measure. Contrary to our hypothesis, taking part in MICT or HIIT over a five-year period did not attenuate WMH growth compared to being in a control group following national physical activity guidelines.

Effects of cerebral hypoperfusion on the cerebral white matter: a meta‑analysis

Decreased cerebral blood flow (CBF) in aging is known to induce aging‑related cerebral deteriorations, such as neuronal degeneration, white matter (WM) alterations, and vascular deformations. However, the effects of cerebral hypoperfusion on WM alterations remain unclear. This study investigates the relationship between cerebral hypoperfusion and WM total volume changes by assessing the trends in CBF and WM changes by meta‑analysis. In this meta‑analysis, the differences in CBF were compared according to cerebral hypoperfusion type and the effect of cerebral hypoperfusion on the total volume of WM changes in rodents. Using subgroup analysis, 13 studies were evaluated for comparing CBF according to the type of cerebral hypoperfusion; 12 studies were evaluated for comparing the effects of cerebral hypoperfusion on the total volume of WM changes. Our meta‑analysis shows that the total volume of WM decreases with a decrease in CBF. However, the reduction in\r\nthe total volume of WM was greater in normal aging mice than in the cerebral hypoperfusion model mice. These results suggest that the reduction of cerebral WM volume during the aging process is affected by other factors in addition to a decrease in CBF.