Gene delivery to glioma cells in rat brain by grafting of a retrovirus packaging cell line

Electrospun Drug-Loaded and Gene-Loaded Nanofibres: The Holy Grail of Glioblastoma Therapy?

To date, GBM remains highly resistant to therapies that have shown promising effects in other cancers. Therefore, the goal is to take down the shield that these tumours are using to protect themselves and proliferate unchecked, regardless of the advent of diverse therapies. To overcome the limitations of conventional therapy, the use of electrospun nanofibres encapsulated with either a drug or gene has been extensively researched. The aim of this intelligent biomaterial is to achieve a timely release of encapsulated therapy to exert the maximal therapeutic effect simultaneously eliminating dose-limiting toxicities and activating the innate immune response to prevent tumour recurrence. This review article is focused on the developing field of electrospinning and aims to describe the different types of electrospinning techniques in biomedical applications. Each technique describes how not all drugs or genes can be electrospun with any method; their physico-chemical properties, site of action, polymer characteristics and the desired drug or gene release rate determine the strategy used. Finally, we discuss the challenges and future perspectives associated with GBM therapy.

The Potentials and Pitfalls of Using Adult Stem Cells in Cancer Treatment

Stem cells play a pivotal role in the developmental stages of an organism and in adulthood as well. Therefore, it is not surprising that stem cells constitute a focus of extensive research. Indeed, several decades of stem cell research have tremendously increased our knowledge on the mechanistic understandings of stem cell biology. Interestingly, revealing the fundamental principles of stem cell biology has also fostered its application for therapeutic purposes. Many of the attributes that the stem cells possess, some of which are unique, allow multifaceted exploitation of stem cells in the treatment of various diseases. Cancer, the leading cause of mortality worldwide, is one of the disease groups that has been benefited by the potentials of therapeutic applications of the stem cells. While the modi operandi of how stem cells contribute to cancer treatment are many-sided, two major principles can be conceived. One mode involves harnessing the regenerative power of the stem cells to promote the generation of blood-forming cells in cancer patients after cytotoxic regimens. A totally different kind of utility of stem cells has been exercised in another mode where the stem cells can potentially deliver a plethora of anti-cancer therapeutics in a tumor-specific manner. While both these approaches can improve the treatment of cancer patients, there exist several issues that warrant further research. This review summarizes the basic principles of the utility of the stem cells in cancer treatment along with the current trends and pinpoints the major obstacles to focus on in the future for further improvement.

Viral and other therapies for recurrent glioblastoma: is a 24-month durable response unusual?

A phase I trial of an engineered poliovirus for the treatment of recurrent glioblastoma (GBM) has attracted attention due to 8 survivors reaching the 24-month and 5 reaching the 36-month survival landmarks.1 Genetically engineered viruses (oncolytic viruses) have been in trials for GBM for almost two decades.2 These replication-competent (tumor-selective, oncolytic, replication-conditional) viruses or replication-defective viral vectors (gene therapy) deliver cytotoxic payloads to tumors, leading to immunogenic death and intratumoral inflammatory responses. This transforms the tumor microenvironment from immunologically naïve ("cold") to inflamed ("hot"), increasing immune cell recognition of tumor antigens and the durable responses observed in virotherapy.3,4 Several current and past virotherapy trials have reported a "tail" of apparent responders at the 24-month landmark. Other modalities have also reported a "tail" of seemingly long-term survivors. These trials seem to show that these responder "tails" characterize a defined subset of GBM patients.

Evaluation of hyaluronic acid-combined ternary complexes for serum-resistant and targeted gene delivery system

Branched polyethylenimine (bPEI) was well known as high transfection agent, which has many amine group. However, utilization of bPEI was limited due to high toxicity. To solve these problems, bPEI was introduced to low molecular weight water-soluble chitosan (LMWSC) with coupling agent. In addition, hyaluronic acid (HA), one of natural anion polymer, was introduced to binary complex of pDNA/bPEI-grafted LMWSC (LMPEI) to target the specific cancer cell and impart the serum resistant. Ternary complexes of pDNA/LMPEI/HA were prepared by electrostatic charge interaction and their binding affinity and DNase protection assay were conducted by gel retardation assay. Particle size of ternary complexes showed that had each 482 ± 245.4 (pDNA/LMPEI2%/HA, 1:16:1, w/w/w) and 410 ± 78.5 nm (pDNA/LMPEI4%/HA, 1:16:2, w/w/w). Moreover, to demonstrate serum-resistant effect of ternary complexes, particle size of them was measured according to incubated time (0-10 h) under serum condition. Transfection assay of ternary complexes showed that their transfection efficiency in CD44-receptor overexpressed HCT116 cell was higher than CD44-receptor negative CT26 cell. Additionally, intracellular uptake of ternary complexes with propidium iodide (PI)-labeled pDNA was observed to confirm targeting effect and cellular internalization by fluorescence microscopy. These results suggest that ternary complexes are superb gene carrier with excellent serum-resistant and high gene transfection.

Regulation of gap junction channels by infectious agents and inflammation in the CNS

Gap junctions (GJs) are conglomerates of intercellular channels that connect the cytoplasm of two or more cells, and facilitate the transfer of ions and small molecules, including second messengers, resulting in metabolic and electrical coordination. In general, loss of gap junctional communication (GJC) has been associated with cellular damage and inflammation resulting in compromise of physiological functions. Recently, it has become evident that GJ channels also play a critical role in the pathogenesis of infectious diseases and associated inflammation. Several pathogens use the transfer of intracellular signals through GJ channels to spread infection and toxic signals that amplify inflammation to neighboring cells. Thus, identification of the mechanisms by which several infectious agents alter GJC could result in new potential therapeutic approaches to reduce inflammation and their pathogenesis.

Strategies in gene therapy for glioblastoma

Glioblastoma (GBM) is the most aggressive form of brain cancer, with a dismal prognosis and extremely low percentage of survivors. Novel therapies are in dire need to improve the clinical management of these tumors and extend patient survival. Genetic therapies for GBM have been postulated and attempted for the past twenty years, with variable degrees of success in pre-clinical models and clinical trials. Here we review the most common approaches to treat GBM by gene therapy, including strategies to deliver tumor-suppressor genes, suicide genes, immunomodulatory cytokines to improve immune response, and conditionally-replicating oncolytic viruses. The review focuses on the strategies used for gene delivery, including the most common and widely used vehicles (i.e., replicating and non-replicating viruses) as well as novel therapeutic approaches such as stem cell-mediated therapy and nanotechnologies used for gene delivery. We present an overview of these strategies, their targets, different advantages, and challenges for success. Finally, we discuss the potential of gene therapy-based strategies to effectively attack such a complex genetic target as GBM, alone or in combination with conventional therapy.

Gene therapy and targeted toxins for glioma

The most common primary brain tumor in adults is glioblastoma. These tumors are highly invasive and aggressive with a mean survival time of 15-18 months from diagnosis to death. Current treatment modalities are unable to significantly prolong survival in patients diagnosed with glioblastoma. As such, glioma is an attractive target for developing novel therapeutic approaches utilizing gene therapy. This review will examine the available preclinical models for glioma including xenographs, syngeneic and genetic models. Several promising therapeutic targets are currently being pursued in pre-clinical investigations. These targets will be reviewed by mechanism of action, i.e., conditional cytotoxic, targeted toxins, oncolytic viruses, tumor suppressors/oncogenes, and immune stimulatory approaches. Preclinical gene therapy paradigms aim to determine which strategies will provide rapid tumor regression and long-term protection from recurrence. While a wide range of potential targets are being investigated preclinically, only the most efficacious are further transitioned into clinical trial paradigms. Clinical trials reported to date are summarized including results from conditionally cytotoxic, targeted toxins, oncolytic viruses and oncogene targeting approaches. Clinical trial results have not been as robust as preclinical models predicted; this could be due to the limitations of the GBM models employed. Once this is addressed, and we develop effective gene therapies in models that better replicate the clinical scenario, gene therapy will provide a powerful approach to treat and manage brain tumors.

Sitimagene ceradenovec: a gene-based drug for the treatment of operable high-grade glioma

The field of gene therapy for malignant glioma has made important advances since the first gene transfer studies were performed 20 years ago. Multiple Phase I/II trials and two Phase III trials have been performed and have demonstrated the feasibility and safety of intratumoral vector delivery in the brain. Sitimagene ceradenovec is an adenoviral vector encoding the herpes simplex thymidine kinase gene, developed by Ark Therapeutics Group plc (UK and Finland) for the treatment of patients with operable high-grade glioma. In preclinical and Phase I/II clinical studies, sitimagene ceradenovec exhibited a significant increase in survival. Although the preliminary results of a Phase III clinical study demonstrated a significant positive effect of sitimagene ceradenovec treatment on time to reintervention or death when compared with standard care treatment (hazard ratio: 1.43; 95% CI: 1.06-1.93; p < 0.05), the European Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use did not consider the data to provide sufficient evidence of clinical benefit. Further clinical evaluation, powered to demonstrate a benefit on a robust end point, is required. This article focuses on sitimagene ceradenovec and provides an overview of the developments in the field of gene therapy for malignant glioma.

Experimental approaches for the treatment of malignant gliomas

Malignant gliomas, which include glioblastomas and anaplastic astrocytomas, are the most common primary tumors of the brain. Over the past 30 years, the standard treatment for these tumors has evolved to include maximal safe surgical resection, radiation therapy and temozolomide chemotherapy. While the median survival of patients with glioblastomas has improved from 6 months to 14.6 months, these tumors continue to be lethal for the vast majority of patients. There has, however, been recent substantial progress in our mechanistic understanding of tumor development and growth. The translation of these genetic, epigenetic and biochemical findings into therapies that have been tested in clinical trials is the subject of this review.

Herpes simplex virus type 1/adeno-associated virus hybrid vectors

Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) amplicons can accommodate foreign DNA of any size up to 150 kbp and, therefore, allow extensive combinations of genetic elements. Genomic sequences as well as cDNA, large transcriptional regulatory sequences for cell type-specific expression, multiple transgenes, and genetic elements from other viruses to create hybrid vectors may be inserted in a modular fashion. Hybrid amplicons use genetic elements from HSV-1 that allow replication and packaging of the vector DNA into HSV-1 virions, and genetic elements from other viruses that either direct integration of transgene sequences into the host genome or allow episomal maintenance of the vector. Thus, the advantages of the HSV-1 amplicon system, including large transgene capacity, broad host range, strong nuclear localization, and availability of helper virus-free packaging systems are retained and combined with those of heterologous viral elements that confer genetic stability to the vector DNA. Adeno-associated virus (AAV) has the unique capability of integrating its genome into a specific site, designated AAVS1, on human chromosome 19. The AAV rep gene and the inverted terminal repeats (ITRs) that flank the AAV genome are sufficient for this process. HSV-1 amplicons have thus been designed that contain the rep gene and a transgene cassette flanked by AAV ITRs. These HSV/AAV hybrid vectors direct site-specific integration of transgene sequences into AAVS1 and support long-term transgene expression.

Gene therapy and targeted toxins for glioma

The most common primary brain tumor in adults is glioblastoma. These tumors are highly invasive and aggressive with a mean survival time of nine to twelve months from diagnosis to death. Current treatment modalities are unable to significantly prolong survival in patients diagnosed with glioblastoma. As such, glioma is an attractive target for developing novel therapeutic approaches utilizing gene therapy. This review will examine the available preclinical models for glioma including xenographs, syngeneic and genetic models. Several promising therapeutic targets are currently being pursued in pre-clinical investigations. These targets will be reviewed by mechanism of action, i.e., conditional cytotoxic, targeted toxins, oncolytic viruses, tumor suppressors/oncogenes, and immune stimulatory approaches. Preclinical gene therapy paradigms aim to determine which strategies will provide rapid tumor regression and long-term protection from recurrence. While a wide range of potential targets are being investigated preclinically, only the most efficacious are further transitioned into clinical trial paradigms. Clinical trials reported to date are summarized including results from conditionally cytotoxic, targeted toxins, oncolytic viruses and oncogene targeting approaches. Clinical trial results have not been as robust as preclinical models predicted, this could be due to the limitations of the GBM models employed. Once this is addressed, and we develop effective gene therapies in models that better replicate the clinical scenario, gene therapy will provide a powerful approach to treat and manage brain tumors.

Intravascular delivery of neural stem cell lines to target intracranial and extracranial tumors of neural and non-neural origin

The remarkable migratory and tumor-tropic capacities of neural stem cells (NSCs and/or neuroprogenitor cells) represent a potentially powerful approach to the treatment of invasive brain tumors, such as malignant gliomas. We have previously shown that whether implanted directly into or at distant sites from an experimental intracranial glioma, NSCs distributed efficiently throughout the main tumor mass and also tracked advancing tumor cells, while stably expressing a reporter transgene. As therapeutic proof-of-concept, NSCs genetically modified to produce the prodrug activating enzyme cytosine deaminase (CD), effected an 80% reduction in the resultant tumor mass, when tumor animals were treated with the systemic prodrug, 5-fluorocytosine. We now extend our findings of the tumor-tropic properties of NSCs (using a well-characterized, clonal NSC line C17.2), by investigating their capacity to target both intracranial and extracranial tumors, when administered into the peripheral vasculature. We furthermore demonstrate their capacity to target extracranial non-neural tumors such as prostate cancer and malignant melanoma. Well-characterized NSC lines (lacZ and/or CD-positive) were injected into the tail vein of adult nude mice with established experimental intracranial and/or subcutaneous flank tumors of neural and non-neural origin. The time course and distribution of NSCs within the tumor and internal organs was assessed in various models. Resulting data suggest that NSCs can localize to various tumor sites when injected via the peripheral vasculature, with little accumulation in normal tissues. Our findings suggest the novel use of intravascularly administered NSCs as an effective delivery vehicle to target and disseminate therapeutic agents to invasive tumors of neural and nonneural origin, both within and outside of the brain.

Clinical trials with retrovirus mediated gene therapy--what have we learned?

Retrovirus (RV) has been one of the earliest recombinant vectors to be investigated in the context of cancer gene therapy. Experiments in cell culture and in animal brain tumor models have demonstrated the feasibility of RV mediated gene transduction and killing of glioma cells by toxicity generating transgenes. Phase I and II clinical studies in patients with recurrent malignant glioma have shown a favorable safety profile and some efficacy of RV mediated gene therapy. On the other hand, a prospective randomized phase III clinical study of RV gene therapy in primary malignant glioma failed to demonstrate significant extension of the progression-free or overall survival times in RV treated patients. The failure of this RV gene therapy study may be due to the low tumor cell transduction rate observed in vivo. The biological effects of the treatment may also heavily depend on the choice of transgene/prodrug system and on the vector delivery methods. Retrovirus clinical trials in malignant glioma have nevertheless produced a substantial amount of data and have contributed toward the identification of serious shortcomings of the non-replicating virus vector gene therapy strategy. Novel types of therapeutic virus vector systems are currently being designed and new clinical protocols are being created based on the lessons learned from the RV gene therapy trials in patients with malignant brain tumors.

Expression of mutant non-cleavable Fas ligand on retrovirus packaging cells causes apoptosis of immunocompetent cells and improves prodrug activation gene therapy in a malignant glioma model

Recombinant retroviruses (RV) have been widely used as vectors for clinical gene therapy of malignant brain tumors. Because of the very limited stability of these vectors in vivo, RV producing cells (VPC) are routinely used for intratumoral RV release. The host immune system, however, recognizes the intratumorally grafted allogeneic or xenogeneic VPC, and mounts an immune response against them. Humoral and cellular immune responses eventually result in reduction of VPC numbers and in limited success of RV mediated gene therapy approaches. This study presents a non-pharmacological and spatially limited approach for protection of VPC grafted in the CNS against destruction by host immune responses. Murine fibroblast-derived VPC expressing herpes-simplex-virus type I thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) were genetically modified to co-express a human Fas ligand (CD95L) deletion mutant (DeltaFasL) resistant to enzymatic cleavage and shedding. Direct interactions between Fas (CD95) on lymphocytes and DeltaFasL on VPC upon cell-cell contact rapidly caused apoptosis in lymphocytes. In addition, cultured malignant brain tumor cells (U87, LN18, LN229) transduced with DeltaFasL-RV were rendered apoptotic by Fas/DeltaFasL interaction. DeltaFasL-expressing VPC grafted in a 9L rat brain tumor model survived in significantly higher numbers compared with control VPC, and did not cause an increase in neutrophil infiltration of tumors. Gene therapy of tumor bearing animals grafted with the modified DeltaFasL-VPC and given the prodrug Ganciclovir resulted in significantly increased survival rates compared to treatment with control VPC and Ganciclovir. In conclusion, prolonged intratumoral presence of DeltaFasL-VPC seems to be a direct consequence of the expression of the membrane-bound mutant FasL, and may result in increased total RV output and improved tumor transduction with RV.

Gene therapy for neurological disease

Significant advances have been made in the last 20 years in understanding the basic biology of the normal nervous system and in elucidating molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying neurological disease. This progress has generated, for the first time, a realistic possibility of treating what have historically been common and tragically untreatable diseases of the nervous system. In particular, therapeutic delivery of genes to the degenerating, injured or developmentally-deficient nervous system offers the potential to prevent cell death, induce new growth and restore function. Clinical trials of gene therapy are beginning to move forward in several neurological disorders. We have thereby begun the transition to molecular-based medicine which has the potential to alter the landscape and prognosis of neurological disease.

Potentiated gene delivery to tumors using herpes simplex virus/Epstein-Barr virus/RV tribrid amplicon vectors

The development and use of gene transfer techniques creates an opportunity to achieve better treatment modalities for numerous disease entities. Promising results for treatment in tumor cells in culture and in small animal models have been reported. Nevertheless, the lack of widespread vector distribution throughout tumor tissue is one of the current limitations for successful clinical application of gene therapy paradigms. The use of migratory tumor cells themselves as vector delivery vehicles may allow wider vector distribution in tumors. In addition, continuous release of retrovirus vectors on-site could generate a high local virion concentration over an extended time period with consequent increases in transduction efficiency. In this paper, we present in culture and in vivo data of a herpes simplex virus-Epstein-Barr virus hybrid amplicon vector containing retrovirus vector components (tribrid vector) that allows conversion of tumor cells into retroviral producer cells. With this method, we were able to achieve a local fourfold amplification of stable transgene expression in tumors. The application of this system, which can integrate a transgene cassette into tumors with therapeutic bystander effects, could increase the local amplification effect to a level of clinical relevance.

Encapsulation of packaging cell line results in successful retroviral-mediated transfer of a suicide gene in vivo in an experimental model of glioblastoma

AIMS

Retroviral-mediated gene therapy has been proposed as a primary or adjuvant treatment for advanced cancer, because retroviruses selectively infect dividing cells. Efficacy of retroviral-mediated gene transfer, however, is limited in vivo. Although packaging cell lines can produce viral vectors continuously, such allo- or xenogeneic cells are normally rejected when used in vivo. Encapsulation using microporous membranes can protect the packaging cells from rejection. In this study, we used an encapsulated murine packaging cell line to test the effects of in situ delivery of a retrovirus bearing the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase suicide gene in a rat model of orthotopic glioblastoma.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

To test gene transfer in vitro, encapsulated murine psi2-VIK packaging cells were co-cultured with baby hamster kidney (BHK) cells, and the percentage of transfected BHK cells was determined. For in vivo experiments, orthotopic C6 glioblastomas were established in Wistar rats. Capsules containing psi2-VIK cells were stereotaxically implanted into these tumours and the animals were treated with ganciclovir (GCV). Tumours were harvested 14 days after initiation of GCV therapy for morphometric analysis.

RESULTS

Encapsulation of psi2-VIK cells increased transfection rates of BHK target cells significantly in vitro compared to psi2-VIK conditioned medium (3 x 10(6) vs 2.3 x 10(4) cells; P<0.001). In vivo treatment with encapsulated packaging cells resulted in 3% to 5% of C6 tumour cells transduced and 45% of tumour volume replaced by necrosis after GCV (P<0.01 compared to controls).

CONCLUSION

In this experimental model of glioblastoma, encapsulation of a xenogeneic packaging cell line increased half-life and transduction efficacy of retrovirus-mediated gene transfer and caused significant tumour necrosis.

Gene therapy for human malignant brain tumors

PURPOSE

Brain tumors were the first human malignancy to be targeted by therapeutic transfer of nucleic acids into somatic cells, a process also known as gene therapy. Malignant brain tumor cells in the adult brain have some unique biologic features, such as high mitotic activity on an essentially postmitotic background and virtually no tumor spread outside of the central nervous system. Brain tumors seem therefore to offer major advantages in the design of tumor-selective gene therapy strategies, and the role of gene therapy in malignant glioma has been investigated since the late 1980s, initially in numerous laboratory studies and later on in clinical trials.

DESIGN

Retrovirus has been one of the earliest recombinant virus vectors used in brain tumors. Experiments in cell culture and in animal models have demonstrated the feasibility of retrovirus-mediated transduction and subsequent killing of glioma cells by toxic transgenes. Phase I and II clinical studies in patients with recurrent malignant glioma have shown a favorable safety profile and some efficacy of retrovirus-mediated gene therapy. However, the only prospective, randomized, phase III clinical study of retrovirus gene therapy in primary malignant glioma failed to demonstrate significant extension of progression-free or overall survival. Adenovirus- and herpes simplex virus type 1-based vectors have been actively investigated along with retrovirus, but their clinical use is still limited, mostly because of safety concerns. To increase efficacy, novel generations of therapeutic adenovirus and herpes simplex virus type 1 rely more on genetically engineered and tumor-selective lytic properties and less on the actual transfer of therapeutic genes.

CONCLUSIONS

The failure of most clinical gene therapy protocols to produce a significant and unequivocal benefitto brain tumor patients seems to be mainly due to the low tumor cell transduction rates observed in vivo, but it may also depend on the respective physical delivery strategy of the vector. Standard radiologic criteria for assessing the efficacy of clinical treatments may also not be fully applicable to the specific metabolic changes and blood-brain barrier permeability phenomena caused in brain tumors by virus-mediated gene therapy. Clinical trials in malignant glioma have nevertheless produced a substantial amount of data and have contributed to the continuous improvement of vector systems, delivery methods, and clinical protocols.

Retroviral vector-producer cell-mediated in vivo gene transfer of TIMP-3 restricts angiogenesis and neuroblastoma growth in mice

Destruction and remodeling of the extracellular matrix occurs during the formation of new blood vessels that are required for tumor growth. We sought to determine whether gene-therapy mediated in vivo delivery of tissue inhibitor of matrix metalloproteinase-3 (TIMP-3), using retroviral vector-producer cells, could suppress angiogenesis and subsequent tumor growth in a murine neuroblastoma model. Tumor volume 28 days after coinjection of tumor cells with producer cells generating TIMP-3-encoding retroviral vectors was 21% that of controls, as was the mean tumor vascular index, a measure of blood vessel maturity. When tumors were allowed to reach a mean volume of 0.05 cm(3) before treatment, their size 2 weeks later was 47% relative to controls; larger tumors were not significantly affected. When producer cells were injected at surgical sites following excision of subcutaneous tumors, local recurrence 14 days later was only 22% in TIMP-3 producer cell treated mice as compared to 71% in controls. Unsuccessful transduction of melanoma cells in situ, another tumor of neural crest origin, resulted in unimpaired tumor growth, despite the fact that these tumors are susceptible to TIMP-3 overexpression, demonstrating the importance of tumor cell transduction in this approach. Thus, retroviral vector-producer cell-mediated in vivo gene transfer of TIMP-3 to tumor cells can significantly restrict tumor-induced angiogenesis and tumor growth. This approach may be an effective adjuvant in the treatment of neuroblastoma and other solid tumors refractory to traditional therapy, although it appears to be most effective in smaller tumors or in the setting of minimal residual disease, and the tumor cells must be susceptible to retroviral vector-mediated transduction.

Tissue-specific transcriptional targeting of a replication-competent retroviral vector

The inability of replication-defective viral vectors to efficiently transduce tumor cells in vivo has prevented the successful application of such vectors in gene therapy of cancer. To address the need for more efficient gene delivery systems, we have developed replication-competent retroviral (RCR) vectors based on murine leukemia virus (MLV). We have previously shown that such vectors are capable of transducing solid tumors in vivo with very high efficiency. While the natural requirement of MLV infection for cell division imparts a certain degree of specificity for tumor cells, additional means for confining RCR vector replication to tumor cells are desirable. Here, we investigated the parameters critical for successful tissue-specific transcriptional control of RCR vector replication by replacing various lengths of the MLV enhancer/promoter with sequences derived either from the highly prostate-specific probasin (PB) promoter or from a more potent synthetic variant of the PB promoter. We assessed the transcriptional specificity of the resulting hybrid long terminal repeats (LTRs) and the cell type specificity and efficiency of replication of vectors containing these LTRs. Incorporation of PB promoter sequences effectively restricted transcription from the LTR to prostate-derived cells and imparted prostate-specific RCR vector replication but required the stronger synthetic promoter and retention of native MLV sequences in the vicinity of the TATA box for optimal replicative efficiency and specificity. Our results have thus identified promoter strength and positioning within the LTR as important determinants for achieving both high transduction efficiency and strict cell type specificity in transcriptionally targeted RCR vectors.

Viruses in the treatment of brain tumors

The grave outlook for malignant glioma patients in spite of improvements to current modalities has ushered in new approaches to therapy. Viruses have emerged on the scene and gained attention for their ability to play essentially two roles: first, as vectors for therapeutic gene delivery and second, as engineered infectious agents capable of selectively lysing tumor cells. To date, clinical brain tumor trials using viruses for gene delivery have employed retroviral or adenoviral vectors to introduce ganciclovir susceptibility to tumors in the form of the HSV1-TK gene. Clinical oncolytic studies, on the other hand, have evaluated a conditionally replicating HSV as an antineoplastic agent. Despite some promise afforded by these trials, further studies are warranted; the investigation of additional viruses to play these roles is inevitable and is now precedented.

Application of conditionally replicating herpes vector for gene therapy treatment of urologic neoplasms

Herpes vector has been widely used for experimental gene therapy. We herein review the strategies of such therapy for the treatment of urologic neoplasms. Most experimental studies of genetically altered viruses have employed replication-incompetent vectors. However, such viruses are unable to infect additional cells subsequent to the initial infection event. Therefore, this strategy has relied heavily on the bystander effect because a large number of noninfected tumor cells remain. Conditionally replicating herpes vector G207 has been developed in order to overcome potential problems of safety and tumor specificity for human use. It has been used to treat malignant brain tumors because of its neural tropism. In the last few years, applications of G207 for non-neural tumors have been reported. Because G207 may be useful for the treatment of urologic malignant tumors, we evaluated the antitumor effect against several types of tumor cells both in vitro and in vivo. Our data suggest that G207 may be applicable for the treatment of urologic malignant tumors.

Growth-factor gene therapy for neurodegenerative disorders

Preclinical neuroscience has advanced rapidly over the past two decades. New approaches for treating neurological disease, including gene-based therapies, nervous-system growth factors, stem cells, novel vaccines, and modulation of the immune system, offer the potential to prevent cell loss and degeneration in the brain, rather than attempting to compensate for loss after it has occurred. I will review one of these prospective therapies: growth-factor gene therapy for Alzheimer's disease, an approach that is currently the subject of a phase I clinical trial. Other disease targets for gene therapy will also be discussed, including Parkinson's disease, Huntington's disease, inborn errors of metabolism, and cancer. The progress of gene-therapy clinical trials is aiding the transition to molecular and gene-targeted therapeutic approaches which have the potential to improve dramatically the prognosis of neurological disease.

Generation of stable retrovirus packaging cell lines after transduction with herpes simplex virus hybrid amplicon vectors

BACKGROUND

A number of properties have relegated the use of Moloney murine leukemia virus (Mo-MLV)-based retrovirus vectors primarily to ex vivo protocols. Direct implantation of retrovirus producer cells can bypass some of the limitations, and in situ vector production may result in a large number of gene transfer events. However, the fibroblast nature of most retrovirus packaging cells does not provide for an effective distribution of vector producing foci in vivo, especially in the brain. Effective development of new retrovirus producer cells with enhanced biologic properties may require the testing of a large number of different cell types, and a quick and efficient method to generate them is needed.

METHODS

Moloney murine leukemia virus (Mo-MLV) gag-pol and env genes and retrovirus vector sequences carrying lacZ were cloned into different minimal HSV/AAV hybrid amplicons. Helper virus-free amplicon vectors were used to co-infect glioma cells in culture. Titers and stability of retrovirus vector production were assessed.

RESULTS

Simultaneous infection of two glioma lines, Gli-36 (human) and J3T (dog), with both types of amplicon vectors, generated stable packaging populations that produced retrovirus titers of 0.5-1.2 x 10(5) and 3.1-7.1 x 10(3) tu/ml, respectively. Alternatively, when cells were first infected with retrovirus vectors followed by infection with HyRMOVAmpho amplicon vector, stable retrovirus packaging populations were obtained from Gli-36 and J3T cells producing retrovirus titers comparable to those obtained with a traditional retrovirus packaging cell line, Psi CRIPlacZ.

CONCLUSIONS

This amplicon vector system should facilitate generation of new types of retrovirus producer cells. Conversion of cells with migratory or tumor/tissue homing properties could result in expansion of the spatial distribution or targeting capacity, respectively, of gene delivery by retrovirus vectors in vivo.

Critical issues in gene therapy for neurologic disease

Gene therapy for the nervous system is a newly emerging field with special issues related to modes of delivery, potential toxicity, and realistic expectations for treatment of this vital and highly complex tissue. This review focuses on the potential for gene delivery to the brain, as well as possible risks and benefits of these procedures. This includes discussion of appropriate vectors, such as adeno-associated virus, lentivirus, gutless adenovirus, and herpes simplex virus hybrid amplicons, and cell vehicles, such as neuroprogenitor cells. Routes of delivery for focal and global diseases are enumerated, including use of migratory cells, facilitation of vascular delivery across the blood-brain barrier, cerebrospinal fluid delivery, and convection injection. Attention is given to examples of diseases falling into different etiologic types: metabolic deficiency states, including Canavan disease and lysosomal storage disorders; and degenerative conditions, including Parkinson's disease and other neurodegenerative conditions.

Oncoretrovirus and lentivirus vectors pseudotyped with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus glycoprotein: generation, concentration, and broad host range

Lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) is a noncytopathic arenavirus shown to infect a broad range of different cell types. Here, we combined the beneficial characteristics of the LCMV glycoprotein (LCMV-GP) and those of retroviral vectors to generate a new, safe, and efficient gene transfer system. These LCMV-GP pseudotypes were systematically compared with vectors containing the widely used amphotropic murine leukemia virus envelope (A-MLVenv) or the vesicular stomatitis virus G protein (VSV-G). Production of LCMV-GP-pseudotyped oncoretroviral and lentiviral vectors by transient transfection resulted in vector titers similar to those with A-MLVenv or VSV-G. In contrast to A-MLVenv particles, LCMV-GP pseudotypes could be efficiently concentrated by ultracentrifugation without loss of vector titer. Unlike the cell-toxic VSV-G, a stable retroviral packaging cell line constitutively expressing LCMV-GP could be established. Vectors pseudotyped with LCMV-GP efficiently transduced many cell lines from different species and tissues relevant for gene therapy. Transduction of human glioma cells was studied in detail. These cells are a major target for cancer gene therapy and were transduced more efficiently with LCMV-GP-pseudotyped vectors than with the generally used A-MLVenv particles. The high stability, low toxicity, and broad host range make LCMV-GP-pseudotyped vectors attractive for gene transfer applications. The recombinant LCMV-GP-pseudotyped vectors will also allow functional characterization of naturally occurring and recombinant LCMV-GP variants.

Local inflammation and devascularization--in vivo mechanisms of the "bystander effect" in VPC-mediated HSV-Tk/GCV gene therapy for human malignant glioma

Somatic gene therapy with the herpes simplex virus type I thymidine kinase gene/ganciclovir (HSV-Tk/GCV) system and murine retroviral vector producer cells (VPCs) was introduced as a new adjuvant treatment modality to treat tumor bulk and to prevent tumor recurrence in patients harboring malignant glioma. The single-center experience after treatment of 27 patients undergoing tumor resection followed by intracerebral VPC injection for HSV-Tk suicide gene therapy will be presented focused on findings of systematic and close MRI follow-up and a few histological specimens. The data indicate that hemorrhagic necrosis due to endothelial cell transfection mediated vessel necrosis and that local inflammatory immune response occurs frequently after gene therapy. These phenomena seem to be specific because none of the patients of a control group showed any similar features. The prognosis (time to progression, survival) of the patients with "bystander effects" after gene therapy was better, but compared to those patients without bystander effects, they were also privileged by a favorable constellation of prognostic factors. Therefore, the appearance of these neuroradiologic features cannot serve as an indicator for treatment effectiveness and outcome.

Immunomodulation of glioma cells after gene therapy: induction of major histocompatibility complex class I but not class II antigen in vitro

OBJECTIVE

Acquired immunity has been demonstrated in Fischer rats bearing syngeneic 9L tumors after herpes simplex virus (HSV) thymidine kinase (TK) gene transfection and ganciclovir treatment. The nature of this immunity in rats and its relevance to the HSV TK/ganciclovir protocol for human subjects remain to be determined. In this study, levels of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) Class I and II antigen expression were measured before and after HSV TK transfection, in an effort to document immunomodulatory changes caused by gene therapy.

METHODS

Tumor cells from the 9L gliosarcoma cell line, three primary human glioma cultures, and the human glioma cell line U87 MG were transduced with HSV TK vector-containing supernatant from fibroblast-producing cells (titer of 5 x 10(6) colony-forming units/ml) and selected in G418 medium for neomycin resistance. Clones were pooled or individually selected for cell-killing assays with ganciclovir, to confirm TK expression (10(3) cells/well in a 96-well dish). Northern analyses using MHC Class I and Class II complementary deoxyribonucleic acid probes were performed on blots containing total ribonucleic acid from wild-type tumor cells and HSV TK transfectants. A beta-actin complementary deoxyribonucleic acid probe served as an internal control. Cell surface expression was confirmed with flow cytometry. The induction of MHC Class I was tested for cycloheximide and genistein sensitivity.

RESULTS

All cell cultures exhibited increases in MHC Class I but not MHC Class II expression, as determined by Northern analysis densitometry and flow cytometry. Cycloheximide treatment did not diminish the up-regulation of MHC Class I after retroviral transfection, implicating a signal transduction pathway that does not require ongoing protein synthesis. Genistein pretreatment of cell cultures did diminish the up-regulation of MHC Class I, implicating a tyrosine kinase in the signaling cascade.

CONCLUSION

Induction of MHC Class I in rat and human glioma cells after HSV TK retroviral gene therapy is a primary effect that is dependent on tyrosine kinase activity. Specific immune responses generated after transfection may represent an important general side effect of gene therapy protocols. Elucidation of the mechanism of immunomodulation after gene therapy will likely yield safer and more effective clinical protocols.

A uniquely stable replication-competent retrovirus vector achieves efficient gene delivery in vitro and in solid tumors

A major obstacle in cancer gene therapy is the limited efficiency of in vivo gene transfer by replication-defective retrovirus vectors in current use. One strategy for circumventing this difficulty would be to use vectors capable of replication within tumor tissues. We have developed a replication-competent retrovirus (RCR) vector derived from murine leukemia virus (MuLV). This vector utilizes a unique design strategy in which an internal ribosome entry site-transgene cassette is positioned between the env gene and the 3' long terminal repeat (LTR). The ability of this vector to replicate and transmit a transgene was examined in culture and in a solid tumor model in vivo. The RCR vector exhibited replication kinetics similar to those of wildtype MuLV and mediated efficient delivery of the transgene throughout an entire population of cells in culture after an initial inoculation with 1 plaque-forming unit (PFU) of vector per 2000 cells. After injection of 6 x 10(3) PFU of vector into established subcutaneous tumors, highly efficient spread of the transgene was observed over a period of 7 weeks, in some cases resulting in spread of the transgene throughout the entire tumor. MuLV-based RCR vectors show significant advantages over standard replication-defective vectors in efficiency of gene delivery both in culture and in vivo. This represents the first example of the use of an RCR vector in an adult mammalian host, and their first application to transduction of solid tumors.

Gene directed enzyme/prodrug therapy of cancer: historical appraisal and future prospectives

Gene therapy of cancer is a novel approach with the potential to selectively eradicate tumour cells, whilst sparing normal tissue from damage. In particular, gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (GDEPT) is based on the delivery of a gene that encodes an enzyme which is non-toxic per se, but is able to convert a prodrug into a potent cytotoxin. Several GDEPT systems have been investigated so far, demonstrating effectiveness in both tissue culture and animal models. Based on these encouraging results, phase I/II clinical trials have been performed and are still ongoing. The aim of this review is to summarise the progress made in the design and application of GDEPT strategies. The most widely used enzyme/prodrug combinations already in clinical trials (e.g., herpes simplex 1 virus thymidine kinase/ganciclovir and cytosine deaminase/5-fluorocytosine), as well as novel approaches (carboxypeptidase G2/CMDA, horseradish peroxidase/indole-3-acetic acid) are described, with a particular attention to translational research and early clinical results.

Mutation of Gln125 to Asn selectively abolishes the thymidylate kinase activity of herpes simplex virus type 1 thymidine kinase

The broad substrate specificity of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) thymidine kinase (TK) has provided the basis for selective antiherpetic therapy and, more recently, suicide gene therapy for the treatment of cancer. We have now constructed an HSV-1 TK mutant enzyme, in which an asparagine (N) residue is substituted for glutamine (Q) at position 125, and have evaluated the effect of this amino acid change on enzymatic activity. In marked contrast with wild-type HSV-1 TK, which displays both thymidine kinase and thymidylate kinase activities, the HSV-1 TK(Q125N) mutant was unable to phosphorylate pyrimidine nucleoside monophosphates but retained significant phosphorylation activity for thymidine and a series of antiherpetic pyrimidine and purine nucleoside analogs. The abrogation of HSV-1 TK-associated thymidylate kinase activity resulted in a 100-fold accumulation of the monophosphate form of (E)-5-(2-bromovinyl)-2'-deoxyuridine (BVDU) in osteosarcoma cells transfected with the HSV-1 TK(Q125N) gene compared with osteosarcoma cells expressing wild-type HSV-1 TK. BVDU monophosphate accumulation gave rise to a much greater inhibition of cellular thymidylate synthase in HSV-1 TK(Q125N) gene-transfected cells than wild-type HSV-1 TK gene-transfected osteosarcoma tumor cells without significantly changing the cytostatic potency of BVDU for the HSV-1 TK gene-transfected tumor cells. Accordingly, the presence of the Q125N mutation in HSV-1 TK gene-transfected tumor cells was found to result in a multilog decrease in the cytostatic activity of those pyrimidine nucleoside analogs that in their monophosphate form do not have marked affinity for thymidylate synthase [i.e., 1-beta-D-arabinofuranosylthymine and (E)-5-(2-bromovinyl)-1-beta-D-arabinofuranosyluracil].

Eradication of murine brain tumors by direct inoculation of concentrated high titer-recombinant retrovirus harboring the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase gene

Implantation of retrovirus-producing cells within a tumor has been demonstrated to eliminate malignant brain tumors effectively in animal models. In our previous study, the implantation of high-titer retrovirus-producing fibroblasts into tumors resulted in highly efficient transduction in vivo. The transduced glioma cells migrated far from the implantation site, potentiating the induction of the remarkable bystander effect. It is also possible, however, that the implantation of murine fibroblast-derived virus-producing cells may induce an immune response in patients. In this study, we prepared retroviruses carrying the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HTK) gene with titers of 1.4--2.5 x 10(11) colony-forming units (c.f.u.)/ml, and stereotactically inoculated only 3 microl of the HTK-bearing retroviruses into the brain tumors of mice. Following repetitive ganciclovir (GCV) intraperitoneal injection, effective killing of glioma cells in the mouse brain was observed. The transduction efficiency was nearly as high as that observed for the implantation of high-titer retrovirus-producing fibroblasts. Eighty percent of brain tumor-bearing mice were completely cured by our treatment protocol using concentrated HTK-harboring retroviruses. Our results suggest that repeated inoculations of high-titer retroviruses carrying the HTK gene followed by GCV treatment may be a promising strategy for the clinical treatment of malignant gliomas.

Retroviral vector-producer cell mediated angiogenesis inhibition restricts neuroblastoma growth in vivo

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to determine whether gene therapy-mediated delivery of an angiogenesis inhibitor, a truncated, soluble vascular endothelial growth factor receptor (Flk-1/KDR, VEGFR-2), could suppress tumor growth in a murine model of neuroblastoma.

METHODS

Murine fibroblasts producing a replication-defective retrovirus encoding this mutant form of flk-1 were made. These producer cells were mixed with neuroblastoma cells and injected subcutaneously into SCID mice. Subsequent tumor growth was then measured.

RESULTS

Murine neuroblastoma growth was decreased by 95% after 25 days. Similar tumor growth inhibitory effects were observed when the flk-1 producer cells were co-injected with cells from two different human neuroblastoma cell lines.

CONCLUSIONS

Neuroblastoma growth can be significantly restricted in vivo with a single injection of cells that produce a retroviral vector encoding the gene for an angiogenesis inhibitor. This suggests that gene therapy-mediated delivery can be an effective alternative to chronic administration of these cytostatic anticancer agents.

Cellular suicide therapy of malignant disease

Adoptive cellular therapy is developing as a supplement or alternative to chemotherapy and/or radiation for malignant disease. Our focus is two ongoing clinical studies with transgeneic (genetically altered) cellular therapy; one uses allogeneic (from another person) lymphocytes to treat leukemia, and the second uses xenogeneic (from another species) fibroblast cells genetically altered to contain a toxin-producing suicide gene to treat ovarian cancer. Allogeneic donor lymphocyte infusions (DLI) are known to induce remission of hematologic malignancies. However, the toxicity associated with DLI is related to graft-versus-host-disease, which is due to donor lymphocytes attacking normal tissue in the recipient. Therefore, we have taken the approach of infusing DLI that have been modified to contain a latent suicide gene to treat leukemia. To treat ovarian cancer, we used xenogeneic nonimmune fibroblast-derived cells to deliver a tumor-directed cytotoxic gene to carcinoma cells. These cells release HStk transgene retroviruses that in turn transduce replicating tumor cells but not quiescent epithelium, rendering the tumor selectively susceptible to ganciclovir-mediated killing. These initial trials summarize the early stage of allogeneic/xenogeneic adoptive cellular therapy for cancer, and although the data are limited, it is encouraging to see some patients with evidence of antitumor responses. Advances in our understanding of the basic science of these treatments, together with improvements in the technology of vector design, will be required to streamline these methodologies into broader application.

Genetic basis of intramedullary spinal cord tumors and therapeutic implications

The advent of molecular biology has provided tools to delineate genetic mutations that cause disease. Recently, several genetic mutations have been associated with intramedullary spinal cord tumors. Concurrently, advances in micro-neurosurgical techniques have significantly decreased the morbidity of surgical resection. In this review, we describe the current understanding of genetic mutations in sporadic and familial intramedullary spinal cord tumors. The future success of innovative gene therapy protocols may depend upon establishing a cause and effect relationship between these genetic mutations and disease progression. Successful gene therapy will also depend upon increasing the efficiency of gene therapy vector delivery.

Cellular suicide therapy of malignant disease

Adoptive cellular therapy is developing as a supplement or alternative to chemotherapy and/or radiation for malignant disease. Our focus is two ongoing clinical studies with transgeneic (genetically altered) cellular therapy; one uses allogeneic (from another person) lymphocytes to treat leukemia, and the second uses xenogeneic (from another species) fibroblast cells genetically altered to contain a toxin-producing suicide gene to treat ovarian cancer. Allogeneic donor lymphocyte infusions (DLI) are known to induce remission of hematologic malignancies. However, the toxicity associated with DLI is related to graft-versus-host-disease, which is due to donor lymphocytes attacking normal tissue in the recipient. Therefore, we have taken the approach of infusing DLI that have been modified to contain a latent suicide gene to treat leukemia. To treat ovarian cancer, we used xenogeneic nonimmune fibroblast-derived cells to deliver a tumor-directed cytotoxic gene to carcinoma cells. These cells release HStk transgene retroviruses that in turn transduce replicating tumor cells but not quiescent epithelium, rendering the tumor selectively susceptible to ganciclovir-mediated killing. These initial trials summarize the early stage of allogeneic/xenogeneic adoptive cellular therapy for cancer, and although the data are limited, it is encouraging to see some patients with evidence of antitumor responses. Advances in our understanding of the basic science of these treatments, together with improvements in the technology of vector design, will be required to stream-line these methodologies into broader application.

Neural precursor cells for delivery of replication-conditional HSV-1 vectors to intracerebral gliomas

Cellular delivery of a replication-conditional herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) vector provides a means for gene therapy of invasive tumor cells. LacZ-bearing neural precursor cells, which can migrate and differentiate in the brain, were infected with a ribonucleotide reductase-deficient HSV-1 mutant virus (rRp450) that replicates only in dividing cells. Replication of rRp450 in neural precursor cells was blocked prior to implantation into the tumor by growth arrest in late G1 phase through treatment with mimosine. Viral titers in the medium of mimosine-treated, rRp450-infected neural precursor cells were below detection levels 3 days after infection. In culture, after removal of mimosine and passaging, cells resumed growth and replication of rRp450 so that, 7 days later, virus was present in the medium and cell death was evident. Mimosine-treated neural precursor cells injected into established intracerebral CNS-1 gliomas in nude mice migrated extensively throughout the tumor and into the surrounding parenchyma beyond the tumor over 3 days. Mimosine-treated neural precursor cells, infected with rRp450 and injected into intracerebral CNS-1 tumors, also migrated within the tumor with the appearance of foci of HSV-thymidine kinase-positive (TK+) cells, presumably including tumor cells, distributed throughout the tumor and in the surrounding parenchyma over a similar period. This migratory cell delivery method has the potential to expand the range of delivery of HSV-1 vectors to tumor cells in the brain.

Oncolytic viruses as novel anticancer agents: turning one scourge against another

Although the use of viruses as oncolytic agents is an historic concept, the use of genetically modified viruses to selectively target tumour cells is relatively novel and recent. The ability of viruses to efficiently infect and lyse cells, combined with the potential augmentation of this effect by progeny viruses throughout the tumour provide justification for exploitation of these agents in cancer therapy. Before application to humans, though, issues related to tumour cell selectivity, lack of toxicity to normal tissues and the effect of the antiviral immune response, will have to be clarified. The more commonly used oncolytic viruses are based on mutant strains of herpes simplex virus, adenovirus and reovirus. The tumour selectivity of each of these strains is discussed, particularly the complementation of the viral defect by cellular pathways involved in tumourigenesis. The combination of oncolytic viruses with radiation, chemotherapy and gene therapy is also reviewed. Further study of the interaction of viral proteins with cellular pathways involved in cell cycle control will provide the rationale for viral mutants with increased selectivity for tumour cells.

Gene therapy in the CNS

Gene therapy for neurological disorder is currently an experimental concept. The goals for clinical utilization are the relief of symptoms, slowing of disease progression, and correction of genetic abnormalities. Experimental studies are realizing these goals in the development of gene therapies in animal models. Discoveries of the molecular basis of neurological disease and advances in gene transfer systems have allowed focal and global delivery of therapeutic genes for a wide variety of CNS disorders. Limitations are still apparent, such as stability and regulation of transgene expression, and safety of both vector and expressed transgene. In addition, the brain adds several challenges not seen in peripheral gene therapy paradigms, such as post-mitotic cells, heterogeneity of cell types and circuits, and limited access. Moreover, it is likely that several modes of gene delivery will be necessary for successful gene therapies of the CNS. Collaborative efforts between clinicians and basic researchers will likely yield effective gene therapy in the CNS.

Connexin 43-enhanced suicide gene therapy using herpesviral vectors

Tumor cell transduction with the herpes simplex virus (HSV) thymidine kinase (tk) gene and treatment with ganciclovir (GCV) is a widely studied cancer gene therapy. Connexin (Cx)-dependent gap junctions between cells facilitate the intercellular spread of TK-activated GCV, thereby creating a bystander effect that improves tumor cell killing. However, tumor cells often have reduced connexin expression, thus thwarting bystander killing and the effectiveness of TK/GCV gene therapy. To improve the effectiveness of this therapy, we compared an HSV vector (TOCX) expressing Cx43 in addition to TK with an isogenic tk vector (TOZ.1) for their abilities to induce bystander killing of Cx-positive U-87 MG human glioblastoma cells and Cx-negative L929 fibrosarcoma cells in vitro and in vivo. The results showed that low-multiplicity infection of U-87 MG cells with TOCX only minimally increased GCV-mediated cell death compared with infection by TOZ.1, consistent with the endogenous level of Cx in these cells. In contrast, bystander killing of L929 cells was markedly enhanced by vector-mediated expression of Cx. In vivo experiments in which U-87 MG cells were preinfected at low multiplicity and injected into the flanks of nude mice showed complete cures of all animals in the TOCX group following GCV treatment, whereas untreated animals uniformly formed fatal tumors. TOCX injection into U-87 MG intradermal and intracranial tumors resulted in prolonged survival of the host animals in a GCV-dependent manner. Together, these results suggest that the combination of TK and Cx may be beneficial for the treatment of human glioblastoma.

In situ use of suicide genes for therapy of brain tumours

Suicide gene therapy represents a new therapeutic approach to the treatment of patients with otherwise incurable malignant brain tumours. This strategy involves the introduction of a gene that renders the tumour cell susceptible to an otherwise nontoxic prodrug. The most often used genetic prodrug activation system is the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase/ganciclovir (HSV-tk/GCV) paradigm. An important aspect of this system is the 'bystander effect', the extension of cytotoxic effects to untransduced cells. For gene delivery, retroviral, adenoviral vectors and HSV-1 mutants have been used. Clinical studies have revealed that the HSV-tk/GCV approach is safe, but also that responses are observed only in very small brain tumours, indicating insufficient vector distribution and very low transduction efficiency with replication-deficient vector systems. To improve treatment efficacy, the use of replication-competent oncolytic vectors in combination with new or improved prodrug-suicide gene systems as a part of a multimodal approach is warranted. In the context of replication-competent vectors, suicide genes might also be used as fail-safe genes in the case of runaway infection.

Viral gene delivery

Experimental studies of viral gene delivery generally support the principle that virus-mediated gene transfer is indeed possible. However, the field of gene therapy has not yet been realised as a practicable clinical intervention. The delay in translation of laboratory work to clinical utility largely reflects the inability of gene delivery vectors to convey adequate genetic material to a desired location, with adequate durability and low enough toxicity to be effective. Current studies of viral gene therapy vehicles have focused on re-engineering viruses being tested as vectors at present, treating the host to facilitate viral gene transfer and the development of new vectors. Initial enthusiasm for oncoretroviral and adenoviral vectors has cooled, while adeno-associated virus and lentiviral vectors are attracting more interest. Experimental studies with modified SV40-based vectors have also been very promising. The future of gene therapy will probably entail using an array of gene delivery vehicles, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. The vector systems will probably be as diverse as the applications to which they will be put.

A phase 1-2 clinical trial of gene therapy for recurrent glioblastoma multiforme by tumor transduction with the herpes simplex thymidine kinase gene followed by ganciclovir. GLI328 European-Canadian Study Group

This study has investigated the effects of herpes simplex thymidine kinase gene (HSV-tk) transfer followed by ganciclovir treatment as adjuvant gene therapy to surgical resection in patients with recurrent glioblastoma multiforme (GBM). The study was open and single-arm, and aimed at assessing the feasibility and safety of the technique and indications of antitumor activity. In 48 patients a suspension of retroviral vector-producing cells (VPCs) was administered by intracerebral injection immediately after tumor resection. Intravenous ganciclovir was infused daily 14 to 27 days after surgery. Patients were monitored for adverse events and for life by regular biosafety assaying. Tumor changes were monitored by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Reflux during injection was a frequent occurrence but serious adverse events during the treatment period (days 1-27) were few and of a nature not unexpected in this population. One patient experienced transient neurological disorders associated with postganciclovir MRI enhancement. There was no evidence of replication-competent retrovirus in peripheral blood leukocytes or in tissue samples of reresection or autopsy. Vector DNA was shown in the leukocytes of some patients but not in autopsy gonadal samples. The median survival time was 8.6 months, and the 12-month survival rate was 13 of 48 (27%). On MRI studies, tumor recurrence was absent in seven patients for at least 6 months and for at least 12 months in two patients, one of whom remains recurrence free at more than 24 months. Treatment-characteristic images of injection tracks and intracavity hemoglobin were apparent. In conclusion, the gene therapy is feasible and appears to be satisfactorily safe as an adjuvant to the surgical resection of recurrent GBM, but any benefit appears to be marginal. Investigation of the precise effectiveness of this gene therapy requires prospective, controlled studies.

Retroviral transfection of the lacZ gene from Liz-9 packaging cells to glioma spheroids

Despite the development of numerous vectors for gene transfection to gliomas, patient survival length remains unaffected in clinical trials. For glioma gene therapy to be successful, the extent of gene transfer to the solid tumor tissue has to be high. In the present work we review some of the vector types and strategies so far utilized in experimental and clinical glioma gene therapy. Since gene transfer efficacy into solid glioma tissue is unknown for many vectors, we studied the gene transfer efficacy into multicellular spheroids derived from a human glioma cell line GaMg as well as into spheroids derived from human glioma biopsies (glioblastoma multiforme, GBM). A replication deficient retroviral vector from the Liz 9 packaging cell line was used for transfer of the bacterial beta-galactosidase lacZ gene into the target tissue. Gene transfer was obtained by adding medium containing virus from the producer cells to the target tissue. The experiments were also conducted with EGF (epidermal growth factor) added to the medium. The data show that the transfection rate ranged from 0-4.5% where the transfection efficacy was higher in spheroids after the addition of EGF. Most of the transfected cells were found at the surface, but transfected cells could also be observed in the center of the spheroids. We conclude that using this vector system, the transfection efficacy was low, even if the number of replicating cells was increased by adding EGF. The findings are consistent, and may partly explain, the lack of effect using this vector system during in vivo studies.